Honestly, I have NEVER heard Shirley sound this good live, ever! Don’t take that wrong, I’m a huge, long time die hard fan, only a couple years younger than Shirley. Maybe it’s the acoustics of the room, or maybe because she’s sitting and not running around on stage... but I had NO IDEA she could sound this good live. W O W‼️
@@mikesniadecki1205 auto tune was alive for way long before 1999.. and its called Live tuning, i dont think she used it in this video but it's possible
I have seen them live several times and never heard any artifacts from Shirley using autotune, so I am quite convinced she does not use it . In fact once in Copenhagen she gave everyone - herself included - a good laugh when she didn't hit the note. Can't remember the song, but I clearly remember the venue because they refused to remove to stoned and abusive women from the front rows.
Woah! This is sweet! These songs feel so much more intimate played like this, stripped down to their essentials, especially The Trick is to Keep Breathing. I'd love to hear more unplugged shows from these guys! Absolutely beautiful!
The best vocals from Garbage. Keep in mind they did it on French T.V. Many know the French are ethno-centric. Been there four times. To get the applause and adulation from a French crowd is something Special for foreigners.
When one does a song that inspires HOPE when things are bad , it's beyond special. It's something bigger, better, and everlasting... and the angelic way Manson sings it... is just, just, um.... makes me wanna keep breathing!
I think Shirley is prettier than these tarts of today and she can sing very well using her own voice! She doesn't try to copy the trendy vocal sound. And this band is very good!
What an amazing jewel... Garbage unplugged!! I love this! It is the epitome of an expression of true talent... live and unplugged! Her voice is amazing AND the drummer is one of the tightest I have ever heard.
I love this band since I was a kid and I´ve had always a crush on Shirley but this is the first time I hear this acoustic versions. Thanks a lot, more garbage for my head
Saw her and Garbage open for Alanis Morrisette in Portkad, OR, the same year. Went to see and hear Shirley and Garbsge mainly. Great set. All the hits from the first two albums done spot on to the studio versions. As people came into the open floor level just before their last song, Shirley said. "To everybody who just came in and missed our set ' F***You!" The bandthen Immediately launched into the set ender. Alamis' band was excellent too. One of the best rock concerts I've ever been to. It was in the Rose Garden basketball arena. Full on PA and economics. Noth bands just soared.
![Garbage - I Think I'm Paranoid + Push It [Nulle part ailleurs 1998]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/r4RPKqo18J4/mqdefault.jpg)
![Garbage - I Think I'm Paranoid + Push It [Nulle part ailleurs 1998]](/img/tr.png)
![Garbage - Köln Palladium [April 3rd, 2005] FULL CONCERT](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/rYJ1jNnGUu0/mqdefault.jpg)
![ถามตรงๆ กับ อาจตุพร ทำไม ประเทศไทย ใครเป็นนายก ก็โดนด่า พอออกเเล้วคนคิดถึง!!?? l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3YFLMXxBGAs/mqdefault.jpg)
Shirley is simply a brilliant vocalist. No smoke and mirrors.
вокалістка плюс шикарна дама і має шарм
She really is amazing
"The Trick Is To Keep Breathing" is my favourite Garbage song.
I think this rendition of the song is the best version
for me too
Para mi tambien es mi favorita
People who were calling her ugly at school were just jealous, she's a really beautiful woman.
I saw her in Portland, Oregon. She is drop dead beautiful. Any guy who say elsewise has a little bitty dick.
What？She was called ugly? I don't understand.....
she literally looks like a model
She is really breathtaking... and an amazingly beautiful voice to go with
let's be honest, she is not model look, she isn't so beauty. BUT she has huge charm, charisma, her simplicity is endearing
She's definitely special.
Many years later, I remember being in the audience this very evening at Nulle Part Ailleurs as one of the most touching and lucky moments of my life.
I can only imagine
Shirley is so sensual in her vocal style here that I get goose bumps....
You are not alone ;)
Shirley, a perfect package in every way.
Year 2022 and I fell in love again with Garbage. If only there is a full acoustic version of 2.0
There is nothing acoustic about this concert ;)
Honestly, I have NEVER heard Shirley sound this good live, ever!
Don’t take that wrong, I’m a huge, long time die hard fan, only a couple years younger than Shirley.
Maybe it’s the acoustics of the room, or maybe because she’s sitting and not running around on stage...
but I had NO IDEA she could sound this good live.
W O W‼️
That Voice ! !
That Girl ! !
That Band ! !
Absolutely perfect!!! That voice of hers just melts me into a blubbering pool, great to hear it acoustic
I’ve listened to this 100 times. Never gets old ❤
I have no words to explain what this really makes me feel.
Wow she sounds fantastic, better than the record!!!!!😎😍
This acoustic performance is very calm & serene. I love it
how is it possible they could be so good. Shirley is awesome
Beautiful vocals and that bass...oh, my, that bass!
th-cam.com/video/SDElJ-Nz4Ec/w-d-xo.html the bass on this one is lovely too
What an awesome baseline/drum combination with gorgeous vocals overtop of it.
Amazing performance!!! I have been coming back to this over and over for many months now. Love Garbage & Shirley!
Marina Verdi same here!
Such a power feeling voice, excellent band.
I'd die to be watching this when it was aired... Became a fan much later... She is so unique! Love love love 💖
This is her most perfectly in tune live performance i've ever heard - Sitting down must help massively?!
Auto tune lol
Nope no auto-tune back then and she sang for real
@@mikesniadecki1205 auto tune was alive for way long before 1999.. and its called Live tuning, i dont think she used it in this video but it's possible
I have seen them live several times and never heard any artifacts from Shirley using autotune, so I am quite convinced she does not use it . In fact once in Copenhagen she gave everyone - herself included - a good laugh when she didn't hit the note. Can't remember the song, but I clearly remember the venue because they refused to remove to stoned and abusive women from the front rows.
There is def a backing track
Always return to this... to enjoy... to remember... to cry.
Beautiful Voice
You can't take your eyes off Shirley...her eyes are a godsend...her voice makes you freeze in your tracks. holy smokes...
awesome voice :) she is so kiut
Agreed
what a beautiful version, simply overwhelming
She has the IT factor.. Wow she really is special.. Talk of the town...
Woah! This is sweet! These songs feel so much more intimate played like this, stripped down to their essentials, especially The Trick is to Keep Breathing. I'd love to hear more unplugged shows from these guys! Absolutely beautiful!
what a voice!!!
Simply amazing
Everyone raves about Shirley, and rightly so, but Garbage was a helluva an ensemble!
Excellent performance! The audience gave quite the applause 👏 Well deserved.
The best vocals from Garbage. Keep in mind they did it on French T.V. Many know the French are ethno-centric. Been there four times. To get the applause and adulation from a French crowd is something Special for foreigners.
ugh
What a prejudiced stereotype.
Ah, the usual dose of French bashing! Well at least, contrary to the BBC, French TV did not erase tapes!
c'était le temps ou C+ était une vrai chaine de TV!!temps hélas révolu....!
Really nice version of Special. Shirley's vocals are top notch here :)
Great Bass Lines
Especially the second song. Just great, supports the song perfectly.
@@coffeeandsynonyms absolutely!!! I am amazed by it, too... both by the modest "supporting"... and the mind-blowing song :)
When one does a song that inspires HOPE when things are bad , it's beyond special. It's something bigger, better, and everlasting... and the angelic way Manson sings it... is just, just, um.... makes me wanna keep breathing!
Magnifique interprétation... Shirley particulièrement divine...
never even heard this song before. now its on my top favorites list.
I think Shirley is prettier than these tarts of today and she can sing very well using her own voice! She doesn't try to copy the trendy vocal sound. And this band is very good!
She has such a beautiful voice.
Young Shirley did NOT need to tell us that there was something technical going on. We just thought it was perfect! Love her!
What an amazing jewel... Garbage unplugged!! I love this! It is the epitome of an expression of true talent... live and unplugged! Her voice is amazing AND the drummer is one of the tightest I have ever heard.
my two favorite songs!
amazing taste
I love her voice!! So soothing.
Garbage is excellent. always expresses necessary awesomeness
I love this band since I was a kid and I´ve had always a crush on Shirley but this is the first time I hear this acoustic versions. Thanks a lot, more garbage for my head
Perfect. Perfect. Perfect is the word.
Super
Her voice is so smooth
Sooo elegant!
Garbage's best live ever!!!! I really love this performance!! Fucking genious!!
Absolutely beautiful.
omg, look how CUTE Shirley is here
+Rose McGee that hairstyle sucks though
+05PtVxUI thank god there's make-up
@@75claymont No.. Always better when a girls takes her hair up.. Much better view of her lovely expressions ;)
The best ever band ...awesome!!!!
Beautiful Tone with excellent music... very special indeed! Lovely!
Absolutly brillant.
This video has great sound quality as well as a great performance..
Shirley....eine zeitlose Stimme für Träumer und Seelenwanderer
I’m so glad I found this video. Their performance is fantastic.
dos temazos de esta genial banda..en vivo y en acustico y se escucha genial
shirley manson es fantastica una diosa.
saludos
Love Love Love it. Great quality - and that acoustic set really suits 'Special'. Thanks for posting!
Saw her and Garbage open for Alanis Morrisette in Portkad, OR, the same year. Went to see and hear Shirley and Garbsge mainly. Great set. All the hits from the first two albums done spot on to the studio versions. As people came into the open floor level just before their last song, Shirley said. "To everybody who just came in and missed our set ' F***You!" The bandthen Immediately launched into the set ender. Alamis' band was excellent too. One of the best rock concerts I've ever been to. It was in the Rose Garden basketball arena. Full on PA and economics. Noth bands just soared.
Shirley looks absolutely adorable w/that beautiful red hair of hers all pulled back...my hearts melting.. Shirley Manson = Total Hottie
Best vocals!!! ❤️🇧🇷
Bass line is just perfect.
Just...AMAZING *-------------*
Это лучшее что меня связывает с молодостью, MTV спасибо вам !
Талант, нечего сказать.Сегодня так уже ей не спеть, к сожалению.
My two favorite Garbage songs. So glad they picked these two to do!
She is awesome .
Very Nice Shirley
That bass player ----> rocks!
I could look at her all day. It doesn't hurt cause she's just the type of girl I like; adorable, talented and bad ass. These guys always sound great.
Qué recuerdos de la adolescencia tan bonitos me traen estos temazos
great voice,great band,great tunes..
Very good special Garbage ❤👍🎶
Shirley always unbelievable "thanks from Cologne Palladium"
Some times We forget how beautiful our tongue is and our hearts and people are
Love this version everytime I hear it!!! Flawless
I enjoyed them when I was young, now I return to this marvellous group and singer, they were soooo good!
I Think This Is The Best Version Of These 2 Songs By This Great Band Thank You
I love it...as usual. so beautiful.
Voice as clear as a bell!
Still loving this in 2021
Best Garbage's live! So powerful and closer!
Shirley's eyes look so stunning here...
Always loved the song but never heard this version A whole new dimension to the song Fn wonderful
the chorus effect on the vocals, nailed it.
I could listen to Shirley all day all night and she is so beautiful
I cannot be in ecstasy listening to this jewel of presentation
Incredible
This is insanely great
Really wish they'd put out an acoustic album with all these songs... they sound fantastic unplugged
Great performance by Shirley here. She's my favourite female singer for sure :)
In the trick is to keep breathing she was about to cry ... love her
I Love you Garbage
underrated band!
So proud of garbage being announced in French.