Best lesson for this song I've seen. The pacing is just right -- focused on the hard bits without going on too much about the easy bits and making the video too long -- and the fact you broke down the structure logically rather than going through 7 pages of sheet music for no good reason, is much appreciated. You're a great teacher
Toni, I am sure you have thousands of fans out here in internet land, but I wanted you to know I am one of them! God Bless You. Thank you for sharing your talent with all of us!
There are many guitar lessons on YT with excellent tutors. Toni is so humble and at the same time a 100 times clearer. Toni's quiet, easy, concise style of tuition mirrors her playing whatever the genre. I just wish I had a guitar. Thanks Toni. Guitar or not I'm subscribed and going to follow your lessons - but not on my ukulele!
You can use your ukulele. It’s just a guitar minus the two lowest strings with a capo at the 5th fret. You can use the exact same chord shapes she uses, you’ll just be in a different key.
I've wanted to learn this but had never figured out the tuning. I just got the tab and I'm setting my mind to learning it. Thank you, really enjoy your guitar playing.
I worked out a simpler version in a D tuning but when I heard your rendition it sounded so much better I knew I had to start over. Thanks for the very effective lesson, and PLEASE continue to put out solo tracks. I love what you do with Reina, Josh and Carson, but you are a wonderful vocalist (in addition to being a guitar virtuoso) and I sure would like much more of it. BTW, I really, really loved the instrumental coda you added to your video performance of this song on Reina's channel.
Toni, you know you're amazing...performing with Reina has always been a delight and going solo every now and then is definitely inspiring whilst doing a tutorial is monumental...!!!
Thank you Toni. I was playing this in open D, just bouncing between the two D strings throughout. Your insight on dropping the fifth string back to G was spot-on. (Toni does it in Open E, so she drops the fifth to A) It sounds so much better with this when the tune shifts to A, and I always thought that I needed a bass player to get the right sound there. Thanks again!
Hearing your cover was the first time hearing this song and I loved it. I've spent the entire day trying to play it and hoping you'd release a lesson on it. What a legend, can't wait to master this piece!
So good. Both your playing and the lesson. Heard you sing this yesterday in the van and so glad you put this lesson out there. One of my favorite songs. This gives me the courage to try to chop out a version.
So smooth. So gentle. I love your playing, and I've been listening to music for a long time. Your tutoring presentation is top shelf. Thanks for the entertainment.
This cover is so good, could listen to you do entire Dylan cover album … great songs but sound even better when you perform them ! There is a beauty in the simplicity of a sweet voice and fantastic sounding acoustic guitar …
Toni! Didn’t know you had you’re own channel. I think you’re an amazing musician as both a guitar player and singer. And wow, you also teach us ? Amazing! Thank you!
Thank you, Toni. I love your approach, you do not talk too much, just show it at tempo and then a little slower. This is deep water for beginners but a great relief for somewhat more advanced guitarists who do not need "which finger goes where" type of instructions :) Zs
I believe you could teach most any subject. You strip away the superfluous and present the basics in such a way the difficult seems attainable. Thank you...
Great lesson. Thank you so much for taking the time to inset tab, playing below and at tempo and spending time on the tricky sections. Look forward to more lessons like this. Excellent
Excellent lesson. The 2 best versions of this song out there are your fingerpicking version and Sully Tuttle's flatpicking version. As for a lesson, I would love to see you take one of your Reina del Cid covers and then do a lesson on your arrangement. What you select for the backing to the vocals, and then how you arrange your solo over that for the break. TH-cam has no-one doing that kind of a lesson (and I know it quadruples the work), and any of the Sunday Morning covers could be great fodder for such a lesson. It would be a song us bangers might play with friends, and would give use a roadmap to playing something way more interesting than all strumming the same thing.
@@ToniLindgren I keep putting plus on the thumbs up. I come back to the page along a thread and my thumbs up shows not to have recorded. Che cosa? (Italian)
@@jhh113 Luca Zerrilli. I think she actually went to Italy w/o a guitar and picked it up on the beginning of a tour. She talks about it here. th-cam.com/video/WiUpvhU2kXU/w-d-xo.html
I saw John Renbourne play this from about 6ft away in a little pub in Sheffield. I've always loved it, but never thought to try and play it. Now I will - thanks to your fantastic break down 👏
Dear Toni, I love, love , love your version of this song. I think I have watched your video at least 50 times, just listened to it now actually. I hope you see my note here, just want to tell you I am a great fan of you and Elle, have seen you play live in Amsterdam couple of years ago. I hope you come to our small country again soon. 😘👏👏👏👏👏
I love your channel although I play guitars for many years, but I never understood the theory as much and you’re a great teacher. I’m glad I found you. Thank you very much.
Hi Toni I've been trying to understand how to play the verse for months and with your simple teachng explanation I've got it. Cheers for this your a star.
Wow... this sound so cool and is exactly my style. Never heard this song before, I think. Thanks a lot for the tutorial and all the best from Germany 👍🙂
Fabulous lesson Toni. Thanks so much for sharing. I have to adapt my version due to a left hand injury, but would never have got there without your tutorial.
The start is very informative and useful. A well-organised and useful lesson. I look forward ot playing this! In the back of a van in the woods, preferably.
I can't play, or carry a tune in a bucket. I love listening, I liked, subscribed to give support. Toni is so cool, love to hear her play. Keep up the great work!
Thanks Toni for your accurate guitar lessons, fifty years ago it was very difficult to pickup genuine guitar notes most were bum notes that made no sense so I was forced to learn songs by ear which I don't regret.
Thanks so much for this. I've just recently started to get the hang of fingerstyle playing and this is a great lesson. That descending line is quite the thing to make the fingers do rapidly. Gotta train up the muscle memory a bit more, I guess!
It would be so great if I had any idea what you were talking about lol. Gotta say I loved the video non the less. I have been listening to this song 50 times a year for 42 years and now understand it more. Thank you so much for that.in 5 years I retire and will learn to play it.
Thanks Toni this is awesome and the best version out there! Thanks for giving the lesson you truly are amazing love your singing and playing very much such an inspiration.
Thanks Toni, I had asked about the tuning on Rena's channel. I figured it had to be open E or D and I have been knocking around with it all day on my resonator that is tuned in open D. This lesson finished off the details.
Loved how gentle you played your guitar, and the melody coming from it was so sweet and soothing. Thank you for showing us how it's done. Not many guitarists bother to experiment with the tuning and harmonics anymore. I grew up listening to Bob Dylan, Joni Mitchell, Joan Baez, Simon and Garfunkel, Peter, Paul, and Mary, Sweet Baby James Taylor, Carole King, The Carpenters, and many others back in the 1960 's and 1970 's. Today there is too much musical talent wasted on garbage lyrics. The language of love is not expressed in the same way it was back then.
Best lesson for this song I've seen. The pacing is just right -- focused on the hard bits without going on too much about the easy bits and making the video too long -- and the fact you broke down the structure logically rather than going through 7 pages of sheet music for no good reason, is much appreciated. You're a great teacher
Your teaching style is fantastic. Buckets of class.
Toni, I am sure you have thousands of fans out here in internet land, but I wanted you to know I am one of them! God Bless You. Thank you for sharing your talent with all of us!
There are many guitar lessons on YT with excellent tutors. Toni is so humble and at the same time a 100 times clearer.
Toni's quiet, easy, concise style of tuition mirrors her playing whatever the genre. I just wish I had a guitar. Thanks Toni. Guitar or not I'm subscribed and going to follow your lessons - but not on my ukulele!
You can use your ukulele. It’s just a guitar minus the two lowest strings with a capo at the 5th fret. You can use the exact same chord shapes she uses, you’ll just be in a different key.
@@trackie1957 Thank you. I'm trying it and hope to succeed
Thanks!
I've wanted to learn this but had never figured out the tuning. I just got the tab and I'm setting my mind to learning it. Thank you, really enjoy your guitar playing.
Not only are you natural as an artist but also as an instructor. Bravo!!
I'm not a musician. I have no idea what you are talking about but, I love listening to you explain these great songs. Thanks.
THIS is how a geeetar lesson is done. Beautiful job Toni
I worked out a simpler version in a D tuning but when I heard your rendition it sounded so much better I knew I had to start over. Thanks for the very effective lesson, and PLEASE continue to put out solo tracks. I love what you do with Reina, Josh and Carson, but you are a wonderful vocalist (in addition to being a guitar virtuoso) and I sure would like much more of it. BTW, I really, really loved the instrumental coda you added to your video performance of this song on Reina's channel.
ditto
Toni, you know you're amazing...performing with Reina has always been a delight and going solo every now and then is definitely inspiring whilst doing a tutorial is monumental...!!!
Thank you Toni. I was playing this in open D, just bouncing between the two D strings throughout. Your insight on dropping the fifth string back to G was spot-on. (Toni does it in Open E, so she drops the fifth to A) It sounds so much better with this when the tune shifts to A, and I always thought that I needed a bass player to get the right sound there. Thanks again!
Hearing your cover was the first time hearing this song and I loved it. I've spent the entire day trying to play it and hoping you'd release a lesson on it. What a legend, can't wait to master this piece!
There are many wonderful things in life and listening to Toni picking guitar is definitely one of them.
So good. Both your playing and the lesson. Heard you sing this yesterday in the van and so glad you put this lesson out there. One of my favorite songs. This gives me the courage to try to chop out a version.
So smooth. So gentle. I love your playing, and I've been listening to music for a long time. Your tutoring presentation is top shelf. Thanks for the entertainment.
Thank you Toni , this is a wonderful gift! Also I simply love your rendition of this song in the original video
This cover is so good, could listen to you do entire Dylan cover album … great songs but sound even better when you perform them ! There is a beauty in the simplicity of a sweet voice and fantastic sounding acoustic guitar …
Such a lovely tune! Not in a million years could I make my fingers do any of that but I love hearing you play.
Toni I second the request to post how you did the ending the little instrumental outro was fantastic and icing on the cake to your sweet song here
Dang! I freakin love how you shred and this lesson shred just as good :) Thanks Toni!
Being a Dylan fan for years I really do appreciate your lesson. Thanks a lot!
Toni! Didn’t know you had you’re own channel. I think you’re an amazing musician as both a guitar player and singer. And wow, you also teach us ? Amazing! Thank you!
Really well done lesson - perfect pace and attention to detail. Thanks for sharing it!
You are such an inspiration, Toni. And thank you for this in depth lesson.
Best tutorial I've ever seen! I love your playing. What a beautiful guitar as well!❤❤❤
Thanks
A very welcome treat. Thank you.
Total masterclass. Thanks - I've wanted to play this for years.
So glad I found you and Reina. Great selection of songs and the presentation is spot on. Thanks for your generosity.
Thank you! So helpful. Great lesson 👍😎and your version in the van is fantastic
Thank you, Toni. I love your approach, you do not talk too much, just show it at tempo and then a little slower. This is deep water for beginners but a great relief for somewhat more advanced guitarists who do not need "which finger goes where" type of instructions :)
Zs
Excellent tutorial! Thanks so much, Toni! Loved your Alaska van performance! Very cool! I’m a huge fan!
the way you explain the tuning part is already awesome! thanks a lot!
I believe you could teach most any subject. You strip away the superfluous and present the basics in such a way the difficult seems attainable. Thank you...
Great lesson. Thank you so much for taking the time to inset tab, playing below and at tempo and spending time on the tricky sections. Look forward to more lessons like this. Excellent
Excellent lesson. The 2 best versions of this song out there are your fingerpicking version and Sully Tuttle's flatpicking version. As for a lesson, I would love to see you take one of your Reina del Cid covers and then do a lesson on your arrangement. What you select for the backing to the vocals, and then how you arrange your solo over that for the break. TH-cam has no-one doing that kind of a lesson (and I know it quadruples the work), and any of the Sunday Morning covers could be great fodder for such a lesson. It would be a song us bangers might play with friends, and would give use a roadmap to playing something way more interesting than all strumming the same thing.
Oh man, thanks for the thoughtful comment and suggestion - this is great and definitely something I'm planning on doing!
@@ToniLindgren I keep putting plus on the thumbs up. I come back to the page along a thread and my thumbs up shows not to have recorded. Che cosa? (Italian)
Wonder what guitar she is playing......anyone know?
@@jhh113 Luca Zerrilli. I think she actually went to Italy w/o a guitar and picked it up on the beginning of a tour.
She talks about it here. th-cam.com/video/WiUpvhU2kXU/w-d-xo.html
Love Sully Tuttle's flatpicking!
Thanks so much. Your instructional videos with the tab are very helpful.
Real teaching skills here, not to mention the musicianship. Thank you.
I saw John Renbourne play this from about 6ft away in a little pub in Sheffield. I've always loved it, but never thought to try and play it. Now I will - thanks to your fantastic break down 👏
Dear Toni, I love, love , love your version of this song. I think I have watched your video at least 50 times, just listened to it now actually. I hope you see my note here, just want to tell you I am a great fan of you and Elle, have seen you play live in Amsterdam couple of years ago. I hope you come to our small country again soon. 😘👏👏👏👏👏
I love your channel although I play guitars for many years, but I never understood the theory as much and you’re a great teacher. I’m glad I found you. Thank you very much.
Excellent lesson Toni!
Wonderful tutorial! And what a great Dylan tune with superb finger picking, thanks!
Hi Toni
I've been trying to understand how to play the verse for months and with your simple teachng explanation I've got it. Cheers for this your a star.
Wow... this sound so cool and is exactly my style. Never heard this song before, I think. Thanks a lot for the tutorial and all the best from Germany 👍🙂
Thank you, trying it now 👍👍👍 (its one of the greatest love songs ever written!)
I saw Bob Dylan live in Edmonton, Alberta, in 1990. This is a great tutorial on an awesome song. Cheers! ✌️
Yessss! I was looking forward to more lessons from you! You have an excellent way of explaining song arrangements. Thank you!
Fabulous lesson Toni. Thanks so much for sharing. I have to adapt my version due to a left hand injury, but would never have got there without your tutorial.
what a wonderful arrangement, what a wonderful lesson!! thank you so much!!
Thanks, Toni, that was great. A clear and structured explanation of how to play this song. I know lots of work went into this video. Much appreciated.
Underrated classic. So glad you did a lesson for this, thank you Toni! Time to pick up my guitar and get to work ♪
well arnt you awesome , i cant stop watching your version , listen to it about once a day
fantastic having that fingering and tuning set out like that. thanks!
Thank you, Toni, as I am proudly taking slowly as possible to new levels.
Beautiful! Thankyou for the great breakdown and the tuning explanation. Keep the videos coming!
great explanation of the tunings, string tension, song layout ... and then your playing is fabulous as always!
Bedankt
Exceptional tuition , really easy to follow and understand .Greatjob, thanks.
The start is very informative and useful. A well-organised and useful lesson. I look forward ot playing this! In the back of a van in the woods, preferably.
Wonderful lesson, so lucid and clear. Been trying to nail this great song for ages now thanks to you I’m on track. Thank you so much
Your performance of this song in the back of the van was magical Toni.Cheers from Tasmania.
Sounded great,it’s a pleasure to listen to you
Absolutely love this lesson. Toni doing Dylan ! Make this a thing - sooo good.
I can tell you're an awesome person in many ways just by watching this video. Very well done, thank you
I can't play, or carry a tune in a bucket.
I love listening, I liked, subscribed to give support.
Toni is so cool, love to hear her play.
Keep up the great work!
Thank you, Toni. Loved your version. And that video in the back of the van is perfect!
Thanks Toni! This is just what I was looking for after listening to your version yesterday
A brilliant guitarist, and a brilliant teacher. Thank you, Toni. You are amazing!
Haven't played in decades. This has me wanting to learn this song.
You are so so talented!! You sure know how to make whatever I strument you play sing so sweet!!
Thanks so much for doing this! I love your rendition of the song - such a nice surprise to get a lesson as well.
Thanks Toni for your accurate guitar lessons, fifty years ago it was very difficult to pickup genuine guitar notes most were bum notes that made no sense so I was forced to learn songs by ear which I don't regret.
Think your the best teacher out there using tab as well for a guy like me I need to see it on paper, cheers from Devon UK
Thanks so much for this. I've just recently started to get the hang of fingerstyle playing and this is a great lesson. That descending line is quite the thing to make the fingers do rapidly. Gotta train up the muscle memory a bit more, I guess!
Love the pace of this lesson, and the lesson itself even though i'm only half way in when writing this. Thanks!
Thank you so much for your lessons!! Looking forward to learning this tune :)
I love the pacing of your lessons and adore your voice. Very clear to follow-Thank You. New Subscriber 👍
Phenomenal lesson! Thank you, I teach six days a week and gig and don't always have time to transcribe! Much appreciated!
It would be so great if I had any idea what you were talking about lol. Gotta say I loved the video non the less. I have been listening to this song 50 times a year for 42 years and now understand it more. Thank you so much for that.in 5 years I retire and will learn to play it.
Thanks for the information and tips on the strings and tension and structural damage and capo trick!!
Loved this! Pitched at the level for me so thank you!
Very nice! I was told he played in open D. E sounds right. You make it look so easy!
Thank you Toni, great lesson, big hug from Argentina
Thanks Toni this is awesome and the best version out there! Thanks for giving the lesson you truly are amazing love your singing and playing very much such an inspiration.
OH wow.. just found this.. I love this and have been working it for a few years. Thank you thank you.
Excellent and well taught lesson! Thanks Toni!
I love the way you play guitar generally
Thank you so much for sharing this. Would never have tried dropping the A string back to A to get the A root 🥰
Yea me either but it makes a great bass pedal....big difference for vocal aomompaniment
this is wildly helpful! answered every question i had before i knew i needed to ask them lol. cheers!
Thanks for the great lesson! I like that little variation with the A-string. Now I only have to figure out that lovely ending in your cover.
That is really beautiful, and very well done. Thank you very much.
Thanks Toni.... you're one of the best guitarist I have seen...... thanks again for your valuable video 🙏
Toni is so brilliant! Amazing.
Thanks Toni, I had asked about the tuning on Rena's channel. I figured it had to be open E or D and I have been knocking around with it all day on my resonator that is tuned in open D. This lesson finished off the details.
Thank you Toni! 💖💖💖 Greats and Love from Cologne /Germany!
Loved how gentle you played your guitar, and the melody coming from it was so sweet and soothing. Thank you for showing us how it's done. Not many guitarists bother to experiment with the tuning and harmonics anymore. I grew up listening to Bob Dylan, Joni Mitchell, Joan Baez, Simon and Garfunkel, Peter, Paul, and Mary, Sweet Baby James Taylor, Carole King, The Carpenters, and many others back in the 1960 's and 1970 's. Today there is too much musical talent wasted on garbage lyrics. The language of love is not expressed in the same way it was back then.
Love this song and this is the best "lesson" I've seen on it. : )
Amazing work. My fingers cramped up just watching you