The Shawshank Redemption | DVD vs Blu-Ray vs 4K Ultra HD | Graphics Comparison | 2021
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ย. 2024
- The Shawshank Redemption | DVD vs Blu-Ray vs 4K Ultra HD | Graphics Comparison | 2021
Subscribe and Hit the Notification Bell to Keep up to Date with When I Upload!
Playlists:
Gameplay Comparison: • Playlist
Face and Voices Models in Games: • Characters and Voice A...
All Scenes With... : • Playlist
Films: • Films
Collection: • All Collectables
Best Videos:
The Lord of The Rings Trilogy 4K Ultra HD vs Original | Graphics Comparison | 2020: • The Lord of The Rings ...
Diablo II: Resurrected | Remake vs Original | Early Graphics Comparison: • Video
Ratchet & Clank Rift Apart | Rivet - All Scenes | 4K 60FPS: • Video
Demon's Souls Remake vs Original | 4K All Bosses Gameplay Graphics Comparison | PS5 vs PS3: • Video
Bayonetta 3 vs Bayonetta 2 vs Bayonetta 1 | 2022 vs 2014 vs 2009 | Gameplay & Graphics Comparison: • Video
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Shredder’s Revenge 2021 vs Games (1989-1992) | Gameplay Comparison: • Video
Assassin's Creed Odyssey - All Legendary Armor Sets for Alexios Showcase - (ALL DLC): • Assassin's Creed Odyss...
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Shredder’s Revenge 2021 vs Games (1989-1992) | Gameplay Comparison: • Video
#TheShawshankRedemption #Films #GraphicsComparison
The jump from DVD to bluray is insane
DVD is made to view on CRT so its not really a big jump.
@@BKDDYit’s a huge jump. Are you out your noodle?
@@Drogas3653 Dude has a point, If you watch DVD on CRT it will be just as good as blueray on LED,LCD. It just different purpose
Always was. 480p on dvd vs 1080p anyone who says its not is blind or not looking at details especially in faces and backgrounds.
@@rittis013 While it does look better on a crt the details really aren't there. You have less pixels and thus less details
The problem with such comparisons is that there are multiple versions of the movie on DVD and BD. Here in Germany alone, we have three versions: one from 2009, which suffers from the same red tinge as the DVD and BD versions here, one from 2019 which has the same colour grading as the 2009 version but vastly inferior audio (owing to the transfer of rights from a German distributor, which put only English and German on the disc, to Warner Bros., which filled their disc with a multitude of dubs), and one from 2021, which has the Roger Deakins-approved colour grading as demonstrated by the 4K disc here. The low colour temperature of the BD version here has nothing to do with HDR.
but the differnce between hdr and non hdr is a fact! So here on youtube shadows can apear underexposed and the highlights overexposed.
Bluray looks brighter than 4k ultra, to me some 4k films look greenish
the "greenish" look is because the 4k looks more life like and thus with a warmer tone. the other versions look unnaturally blue.
Blu-ray retains the original film coloring as opposed to digital like how 4K makes it. I personally enjoy the natural colors caught by the analog film vs digital.
The 4K was supervised by the cinematographer of the film. That's how it's supposed to look and how it would have been seen in cinemas. There's also HDR which you won't be seeing in a youtube video but would see on a 4K tv.
@@2HackFrauds This is true. Roger Deakins specifically intended the film to have cooler colours. Also worth noting that there are multiple BD versions with different color grading - three here in Germany alone.
Blu-ray colors are wrong. That's not how it's supposed to look like. 4K color grading is correct. Approved by oscar winning cinematographer Roger Deakins.
@@2HackFrauds4k looks fake
@@stevemuzak85264k looks overly polish and movies looks artificial when they use dnr
4k is the original aspect ratio intended. The HDR makes the 4k far more superior than the blu-ray. It looks filmic with realistic colors.
Who cares about 4k bluray 1080p bluray has ps3
Here's the kicker though... the HDR isn't reflected in this video. This TH-cam video is purely SDR, so even on an HDR display you'll just get the SDR colour gamut translated to HDR. I usually use Firefox, which sadly isn't HDR capable, which means I have to fire up Edge from time to time just to get HDR support for a specific video. Also, "4K" isn't an aspect ratio. It's a resolution, and it's just as much 1.78:1 as 1080p (1920x1080) (footnote: these images aren't actually 1.78:1 - Shawshank Redemption is in 1.85:1, hence the very thin blank bars top and bottom).
The various 480p resolutions of DVDs are a little more complicated but, by and large, a well-mastered DVD will compensate for the slightly-off aspect ratios through the transfer, usually with very mild cropping.
It's only the DVD version here that distorts the aspect ratio, as is most apparent on Morgan Freeman's head there. Beyond that, it's not the HDR in the 4K version that provides the more "realistic" colours (a bizarre illusion in its own right - the use of "unrealistic" colour grading requires sheer incompetence or deliberate artistic intent). It's simply better workmanship in the authoring of the 4K disc, and I suspect that a new BD release has since been released with the improved colour grading based on the same master as the new 4K version.
And there's a certain amount of preference involved in the colour grading between the BD and 4K versions.
Edit: And I've just checked - here in Germany at least, there are three different prints of the movie on BD: one from 2009, which suffers from the same red tinge as the BD version here, one from 2019 which has the same colour grading as the 2009 version but vastly inferior audio (owing to the transfer of rights from a German distributor, which put only English and German on the disc, to Warner Bros., which filled the disc with a multitude of dubs), and one from 2021, which has the Roger Deakins-approved colour grading as demonstrated by the 4K disc here.
No I will not upgrade my TV to 4K I'm staying with 1080p
4k garbage dvd is better i dont care what anybody says 4k is trash dvd is better it part of the 1990s-2000s
4K trash. Blu ray still better
Thanks very much for this illustration , I think the blue ray looks much better, very helpful 😊 p.s just watched top gun 2 in blue ray, it was epic, gonna watch again......
Best color: DVD (most movie accurate)
Best aspect ratio: Blu-ray
Best resolution: 4K UHD Blu-ray
Best light: Blu-ray
Best highlight detail: 4K UHD Blu-ray
Best in general: Blu-ray
Worst in general: DVD
Least movie accurate: 4K Blu-ray
So best color: DVD is just wrong. 4K is closer to how it was intended by the makers.
This is a total misrepresentation. On a monitor screen the size of a laptop or a computer does not portray the picture quality when projected on equipment designed for 4K. We have a 77" LG OLED, and, believe me, there is a definite difference between DVD, Blu-ray and 4K when viewed on equipment that cannot be duplicated in a demonstration like this. The larger the screen, particularly anything 65" and above, and the quality difference is noticed immediately. On screens smaller than 65"s and the quality difference is not noted nearly as much. It depends entirely on the size of the screen and whether the equipment is designed to carry the full benefit of 4K technology, which this demonstration is not equipped to handle. There is no need to go to 4K for smaller screens, but once you go larger than a 65" screen, the more information on the 4K disc translates beautifully to a brighter, clearer, more dynamic image and better sound, depending on the quality of the sound system. The problem with this demonstration is that there is no way it can provide an accurate representation of of the 4K visual image, because it isn't designed to achieve it. It is nothing, but misleading.
Also worth mentioning that this YT video is SDR only, which negates and misrepresents the colour grading of the 4K version, not to mention that YT's compression crushes a lot of the colour nuances of both the BD and 4K versions.
Beyond that, I'm seeing clear differences on my 32" 1440p monitor between the BD and 4K versions here, so I wouldn't say that resolution is being unfairly represented.
Wonderful work. One of the best comparison I found on the web.
Thank you!)
The Blu-Ray looks more brighter and colorful, 4K has a dark color pallet added to it, makes me wonder if it’s really worth the upgrade, plus 4K Ultra HD movies are extremely expensive at this point. The jump from VHS to DVD was clear, the jump from DVD to Blu-Ray was clear as well.
As for 4K Ultra HD, the most I have seen are Demo movies in the local stores, showing nature documentaries that are filmed in true 4K quality, although I do see the difference between Blu-Ray to 4K Ultra HD, I don’t think 4K is the norm yet, let’s see what the future holds.
I know it’s a late reply but You can’t truly see 4k movies on mobile or most portable devices as youtube doesn’t support HDR10 instead supports a weaker version of HDR. 4K is also more noticeable and better with the correct setup from your tv and input device. Watching 4k movies with a correct setup is special and makes it feel like a home theater. But the movies are pretty expensive
I couldn't agree more! as a graphic designer and a video editor for over 10 years I grew to love and appreciate the less filters/color grading and showing what's closer to real life
back in the 90s we had a great movies that capture the natural range and shades of colors and it was iconic but starting with early 2000s almost all movies follow the same rules
with putting the same color grading/filters which makes it boring and loses it's appeal really quick. When I go back to watch 80s and 90s movies I love how it capture the true colors
and all the shades and range of colors as close to the real color as possible and it works as a window to see that era and the colors in it today like shop signs and furniture etc.
4k looks artificial
It's a shame that the raw contrast in the standard blu-ray is making people think that it's superior. The lighting is so much more realistic in the 4k, there's no question. Also the 4k has more detail, _especially_ that first shot, wow! Just as I was thinking the 4k couldn't improve on the blu-ray, here it comes and the depth of the character's face is a revelation!
Blu-ray for sure looks the best.
I have this movie in 4k and a atmos sound system. The New 4k blows it out of the water. The old Blu ray was Fuzzy, With heavy noise reduction in scenes. The 4k Is actually brighter in the scenes outside the prison but in the prison it feels more earie and creepy on 4K with its duller color palette. But outside and as they go off to the beach. Its crystal clear.
I think the 4K colour grading is fine for the most part, but by God, that shot of Andy in the rain looks dreadful in the 4K version.
Because we ain't watching this on a 4k HDR screen.
@@birdsteak9267 hi, i have a 4k HDR10+ TV, and 4K ULTRA HD discs do just have bad colour grading lol
I did not see this in film in theaters so I don’t know what the film print looks like but the 4K is the best. That Andy in the rain is probably only scene that looks better on Blu-ray but I’m not sure if that was the look originally intended by Darabont and Deakins
Did you use the same DVD player for all resolutions. I have a Sony UBP700, I find Blu Rays are brighter than 4Ks.
Probably the best 4k blu ray I own. Even more satisfying to watch than Dark Knight and LOTR
DVD and normal blu ray produce the most accurate colors
Thanks, I said 4k looks artificial
The 4k one seems a lot darker and the colors aren't as vibrant. Luckily my new LG 4k HD Blueray player also plays Blue Rays so I think my movie collection will be a mix of both formats as some movies look better on Regular Blue Ray and other movies look better on 4k Blue Ray. As with everything in life "It's complicated" 😅
I may be old, (30) but I love the bluray version. It feels like a movie. The 4k is just too crisp and detailed lol
You need to upload this video in HDR to get a more realistic comparison to the 4K disc. Blu Ray usually looks brighter in SDR. HDR, HDR10, HDR10+, and Dolby Vision are what make 4K stand out most.
Blu-ray is the best!
Trust me!
dvd is the best! trust me!
@@Mariofans-gn1lu VHS forever!
@@jamyskis (dvd)
I have nothing against VHS. I like VHS too. I just think other formats are better. I own multiple VHS copies of VHS Horror stories. I love horror movies and VHS horror movies have their own aesthetic. I think you're simply a VHS purist.
very helpful, thank you and great movie to use as your medium
The difference in quality between SD DVD vs HD Blu-ray is very noticeable. The jump to 4K Blu-ray isn't as significant. But I am watching this on a 1080p display, so perhaps it's a bigger deal on 4K displays.
On a 4k display with the movie on 4k disc it is a nice improvement
@@yarferreira6722 I've seen 1080P and 4K with the same videos on my friend's 4K TV and it seems to have some sort of AI upscaler, so even 480P videos look decent. So 4K isn't worth it even on 4K TVs.
The 4k Ultra HD, most pictures captured from scenes looked like if the movie was made from a decade ago or today
4k merely looks different to blu ray, it looks no better at all, in fact it sometimes seems worse, merely darkening the image or tweaking the colour. I mostly prefer the blu ray look, way more like cinema than 4k
Blu ray wins on this transfer, im sorry.....way too dark for my liking. I am for 4k, i own a OLED tv and have an amazing 4k player so you cant say its my hook up. some movies look better then blu ray, a smaller amount look "night and day" better then the blu ray.
Guaranteed if you put the 4k version on your OLED display with HDR (or Dolby Vision) it will look a million times better than the screenshots in this video.
I'm actually noticing teal in the transfer. The Blu ray is bright. Now I know Blu rays tended to be brighter due to some titles being oversaturated a bit but this seems like the opposite. WB dimmed the picture and added teal. Fucking hate when they do this! It's a classic for a reason, just remaster it properly, throw it on the disc and leave it alone, does not need to be modernised.
That the issue I have with 4k, they start tweaking it with digital software and it makes it looks fake
To many people saying blueray better or dvd good. Remember this film is old shot in the 90s and 4k blue ray ultra is 100% better in format to bluray like to dvd to bluray but old films from 35mm film will not transfer to 4k to like a new digital film in true 4k spec. Theres alot of remastered blurays with to much film grain from 35 mm film masters and not removed but less grain in dvd. At this time bluray is best value for money for films all round.
The 4k makes it look like it came out last week
DVD's are good enough for me.
I can understand you if you said Blu-Rays but DVDs 🤔🤔 I don't think that DVDs deserve to buy, especially with the cheap price of the Blu Ray Discs, and the spread of modern screens and smart TVs that Dvds looks so bad on it, DVD discs may appear acceptable only on old TVs with small sizes, Not large TVs are like now.
Every time I see comparisons, it just seems to me that 4k is way too dark, dull, digital and blue. I usually go with the blu ray
Because they don’t calibrate it and the hdr darkens it
@@DannyCosmos4k looks looks like someone put sunglasses on the screen
4K is darker than Blu Ray.
I prefer Blu Ray version.
But 4k is more clear but yes Blu-ray more better quality and motion picture better
everyone complaining about 4K looking dark and blue - that’s how it’s supposed to look, and how it looked in the cinema in 1995
4K very dark. You cannot see the background and details in dark scenes. Blu-ray 1080 wins.
This video can’t show the actual difference with 4K because of the lack of HDR. On an HDR capable display, the difference is night and day and the 4K easily wins out.
I don't know how anyone can watch DVDs anymore
So true, went to a local Walmart this week and they only carried DVD, even for new releases. I understand the general population probably could care less, just interesting.
dude there people who stell use crtv and dvd portable player
There are people who can't afford the HD stuff so they settle for DVD. Sometimes it's just life.
They're cheap, cheerful, and for TV sizes of 42" and under, there are few real benefits from DVD to BD at standard home cinema viewing distance, let alone from BD to 4K. That's why they're still selling so well. There's also no perceptible difference in audio quality for people listening through the integrated speakers of a TV.
That said, the price differential between DVD and BD nowadays is so negligible that it's really time to start phasing out DVD.
@@Mariofans-gn1lu I use a CRT for all my old video game consoles but for movies and TV it's 4K all the way
4k is Cropped.
Blu-Ray still looks amazing.
seriously, 4k is often a slight downgrade of blu ray, it simply looks worse
I prefer BD version.
Honestly blue ray to 4k looks the same
Blu-ray is better
4K looks awful. Same clarity as 1080p, because I'm watching in video cardB but the colors are bland and washed out. It would help if you corrected the aspect ratio for DVD.
Brightness and color looks way better and natural on bluray the 4k just look washed out and dark
The colouring and lighting looks all wrong on the 4K version. Too dark and too much colour muting
It’s because this video doesn’t show the difference HDR makes. If you put this film on a 4K HDR capable display, it will look so much better than the blu ray.
4k king❤❤❤😊
No I will not upgrade my Blu-rays to 4K I'm staying with my 1080p TV and using my PS4 as a Blu-ray player there's no need for me to upgrade to 4K
Waste of time upgrading to 4k bluray because 4k bluray films is dead they don't make movies for 4k bluray anymore. All the 4k content is on online streaming like Netflix and Amazon prime.
@@thestreaker4635 do you know what is DVD portable is
@@samuelarriaza1283 what u mean
@@thestreaker4635 you don't even know what DVD portable is
@@samuelarriaza1283 yes
The 4k makes everything blue for some reason
Blu-ray looks the best
I have to say that DVD quality does look more better have the original season of charmed season 8 seen the Blu rays and boy are the colors bad!!!!!! The original film of charmed is alot better I do have some Blu rays and half the time they look like a camcorder and so bad I do have alotta DVDs and when I play them on PS4 they do have a better look for some reason, if you want quality put the DVDs in a Blu ray player it actually ups the original quality and my point is no need for Blu rays half the time they are pretty bad and 4k looks even worse just pop a DVD in a Blu ray it will give you great quality and resolution!!!!! I've done it many times.....Blu rays are just not that inspiring!!!!!!!!
Blu ray looks way better then 4K
Mostly because 4K is lacking the hdr which TH-cam disables
dvd is better then hd bluray and 4k bluray
Blu ray the best,4k bad
Blu ray wins
why is dvd stell around if 1080p bluray and 4k bluray is much superior
4k is the superior format, the people in the comments are delusional
HDR doesn't even have a standard, making investing in Ultra 4K pointless.
I think 4K is better
4k Blu-Ray? Yeah 4k Blu-ray is better than DVD.
You know what, screw everything. Laserdisc is better than everything.
Laserdisc wins.
The 4K version is cropped. I've always disliked that no matter which version but the visual quality looks much sharper.
why is dvd stell around if 1080p bluray and 4k bluray is much superior
@@Mariofans-gn1lu probably because it's a lot less expensive to produce and obtain. You have a point because there are those who also use blu ray discs as data storage.
@@BleedForTheWorld dvds are only good for crtv or dvd portable player
4k garbage dvd is better i dont care what anybody says 4k is trash dvd is better it part of the 1990s-2000s
You are probably the guy who watches TH-cam videos in 144p, huh?
This comparison should be redone, eliminate the DVD example it's useless and the 4K needs to be HDR which TH-cam can do because it's completely useless also without it.
This film looks bad on 4k. The lighting is so dark.
Whoever did 5his didn’t calibrate it . If you calibrate it right and left hdr and no hdr it looks nothing like this … if you have a goood expensive hdr tv it does look good
4k actually looks the worse of the 3 🥴
It's actually the best of the 3. We aren't able to see its differences clearly because YT doesn't support HDR which 4K has but it's superior in quality. I plan on just getting blu rays though
@@casie6609 TH-cam supports HDR, this video doesn't have it but still we can see the difference, and the problems of the 4K restoration.
@@TheStOne1 Oh ok but what problem does 4k have?
@@casie6609 i really think that dvds are made for a dvd portable player
@@Mariofans-gn1lu I'm not sure what that is but Blu Ray and DVD players can play DVDs. Probably even other things :-)
4k looks trash they ruined the image with the filter
4k bluray films already dead they don't sell it anymore cause the online streaming killed the 4k bluray. They only sell dvds and bluray. 4k bluray fail big time 🤣 they know they wouldn't stand a chance against dvd and bluray in the market. Now people just stream 4k movies on Netflix other streams site
Utter crap you've just wrote. Most people don't even have a set up good enough to get 4K let alone good 4k.. more percentage of the population are still on 1080p displays/players than 4k.
At least try and do some research before crying online about a topic you clearly aren't educated in.
Streaming is nowhere near the quality of a 4kUHD Disk.
👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼