I recently got into knife making, and it really made me understand the value of the small pocket fixed blade. A well designed small fixed blade is a joy to use, isn’t much bigger than a folder, and it’s impervious to the grit and dirt I encounter at my job. Plus, since I’m making them myself, I can treat them like disposable tools - I’m talking prying, opening caustic chemicals, screwdriver duty, all that good stuff.
Since you’re a knife maker I’ll run this by you. I also favor fixed blades but don’t like using any knife I can’t get a full four finger grip on. I think the pinkie is important for maximum control and guiding a knife for finesse cuts. What are your thoughts on a knife with a 3.5-4” handle and a 1.75-2.25” blade. The proportions would be similar to the classic Stanley razor knife but would be much stronger and sharpenable.
@@donalddicorcia2433 The proportions you’re describing are pretty similar to the very popular Civivi Baby Banter (if you count the finger choil area as part of the handle). I actually made a Baby Banter inspired fixed blade awhile ago just to see what the fuss was about, and I do like it. It’s great for anything you’d typically use a utility razor for, PLUS a few things like wood carving that require a stouter blade. The downside of course is that having such a short blade does limit you a bit. If you’re going to go this route, learn from my mistake and keep the edge fairly straight like a utility razor (very little or no belly) so that you have the aggressive tip and so that the blade doesn’t fall away from the cut quite so quickly.
Good point. (no pun intended) A sheepsfoot might fit the bill. Checked out the baby banter and yes, the proportions are about right, but it would be a fixed blade, of course. The other option would be a “reverse folder” where the blade and most of the handle would be one piece and if you needed a bit more handle for extra control or leverage, an extra piece would fold out of the handle and provide a place for your pinkie.
@@donalddicorcia2433 An extendable handle does sound interesting. For a simpler option, you could instead attach a substantial lanyard as the optional fourth finger grip. It’s not rigid so it doesn’t transfer delicate twisting forces, but it does provide better grip and control.
@@donalddicorcia2433 check out Very Good Knife Company. They're usa made 80crv2 blade steel with micarta handles and very affordable. they have one that fits your description called the splicer it 75$
I blame him for everything: new surfboards, new motorcycles, new knives, new pistols! It’s all DCA’s fault! Plus drinking too much beer! Plus smoking cigars. He is a very very bad influence.
@@surfingonmars8979 I will do the same especially the cigars going to the cigar bar Tuesday Tobacco Haus in New Braunfels go and I'll really get the wives mad
@@FrankCastle-he8fl Ah, I miss the European sensibilities of leisurely and sane use of tobacco - not chain smoking disgusting cigarettes, but slowly enjoying an occasional cigar…….
I found this channel about 20 episodes of this back and watched all of them now. As far as I’m concerned this guy and Thomas are the face of the company. Y’all better give them a raise! Great presentations and great humor.
Didn't know there were so many. I've had an Esee Candiru for a few years now. Similar to the other 5th pocket knives you list, it's tiny, sturdy, and easy to carry. The 1095 blade is coated, which is needed, but my only objection is the coating has too much texture.
YES!!!! I LOOOOVE fixed blades, I'm so happy youre talking about them today! Im looking to get me a Mini Gunny from bark river, but so many handle options!!!
I have a mini Gunny in MagnaCut with antique white linen Micarta scales and toxic green liners, such a beauty. made the sheath into a pocket carry. perfect edc size knife, you won't regret picking one up.
The thing about both frame locks and liner locks is that they are simple locks that give you a nice strong detent for not that much effort. They are not my favorite either but I certainly appreciate a good liner or frame lock.
I’ve taken a seam ripper (a standard sewing tool), opened up the bottom seam of the watch pocket, and let my sheath poke thru the bottom. Also a good idea to use a little seam tape and a hot iron on the open seam to prevent fraying. Allows for a slightly large knife.
The magnetic sheath is key. I carry a Dan Wesson Valkyrie Commander in a JM4 Tactical holster of the same design. The magnet is versatile for carrying adjustment as well as options to stick on any ferrous surface.
I watch all the beatiful blade shapes, materials, designs, locks...and always end up buying a Cold Steel knife. This time that great Bird and Game for EDC, lightweight workhorse and a somewhat tactical fixed blade. Thumbs up! great video!
Surprised I didn’t see the Esee Candiru on the 5th pocket list: Small blade that shouldn’t have any problem fitting in a small pocket, comes with a pocket clip that can attach to the sheath, and has micarta or G10 handles that can be purchased to add extra grip. I think it’s smaller than the Canary, too
I really enjoy and appreciate your videos. They are comprehensive with logical, sensible, and solid information. All of that is very hard to come by these days especially on TH-cam; I thank you. The only other TH-cam presenter of your stature (I was going to say “caliber”) is Chris Baker of Lucky Gunner.
Can you do a whole video on edc self defense fixed blade knives that have at least one ring in them? I searched through your list of popular videos and I don’t see anything like that. In self defense I think the ring part is invaluable to keep a good hold on the knife. Please do this video. Something that can be comfortable in the pocket or on the belt and concealable obviously. Thanks!
I bought my 1st fixed blade about a year ago(?). I almost stopped carrying it completely. Decided to try a custom leather sheath and try again. Fixed my issues with it completely. It's now pocketable and the edges of the sheath don't get caught on everything like the original included kydex sheath. I carry it pretty much every day either in my rear pocket or even the front pocket, now.
I EDC a fixed blade - the Hogue Extrak. The M4 steel is sharp and tough. The size is just right for a pocket, and the kydex sheath keeps it small and light. Thanks for talking about fixed blades. If you revisit the topic, please include the Extrak.
I absolutely love my Extrak! So thin and light that it disappears in a pocket, scout carry, crossdraw, or as a neck knife. Or in the waistband of basketball style shorts and won't weight them down.
I've had a fixed blade in my pocket almost since 2008-09. Never in the 5th pocket though. That one is reserved for my Victorinox Pioneer. The TOPS CUT 4.0 has been my edc fixed blade for 5+ years (also answers the second question a bit without sticking to 50$ 'constraint). 5+ years of EDC in India - I'm an outdoorsman by nature and tend to sweat a lot. The knife has never had an issue of any sort with respect to corrosion even with extended iWB carry. Takes a wicked edge and helps me with emergency food prep, gardening and wood processing and general package opening too, wherever needed. Highly recommended. I've already stashed up 2 more in case I lose the current one. It is near indestructible however.
First video i have ever seen from this channel, people keep talking about their "fifth pocket" and what they are putting in there, asking for recommendation what can fit in there. Love it! Have my like 😂
Small fixed blades… praise the lord. Thank you! Addendum: would love to see best fixed blades under 12 cm blade length for concealed scout carry, again with consideration for ease of mounting them to your belt and discreet concealment. I find that length, handle shape, sheath design, or clip design can all create logistical problems for these carry desires. Prefer to carry up front above the appendix. Under 100 bucks would be nice, but sometimes we can’t have everything… 😋
you might also want to look into the lionsteel h2, real steel furrier, tops c.u.t. and kizer cabox. they're all above the $50 mark, but absolutely worth considering!
Love the fixed blade specials. For the 5th pocket... the Mini Elementum fixed blade, Spyderco ARK, SOG Instinct and some of the CRKT Minimalist blade shapes should work as well. My most serious question of the day - What knife should DCA be carrying on set to parry Thomas' verbal lunges? 🤺
Spyderco Street Beat (VG-10), with cool-smooth, substantial micarta handle: (discontinued) Front-pocket carry; Thumb press pops sheath that stays in pocket; Totally concealed with hand in pocket, sheath popped, blade loosened, edge still covered, handle gripped... all while hidden in pocket. No knife draw is faster or quieter. Autos make noise, slower, needs button-push. Best knives don't have moving parts.
The frame lock has more security from folding in on you than a liner lock; I have the, Kershaw Filter and I love it, very well made for a great price. Great EDC. Thank you for your review. 😎👍
Framelocks are still great for making nicely slim knives! I bought the CRKT M16-03BS because it has a framelock for example! Sweet robust, slim and easy to maintain construction! 🥰
Hi David and Thomas long time watcher first time commenter! I have reached the mid century of my life and have amassed a very large collection. I’m wondering are there any recommendations you could make for parting with items from my collection other than eBay? I have a vast array from customs to production many makes and models. Any suggestions are greatly appreciated keep up the great work!
2 other options for the 5th pocket fixed blade question are the Camillus Heater II, and the Boker Magnum Lil Friend, they don´t have micarta handles, but fit very well in there
Hey DCA. I hear lots of people from the knife community complain about Itailian heat treat and their overall bad reputation. Is this something you've personally experienced? Or is it just like you mentioned about internet and reality TV. What would you consider to be the best and most consistent Italian knife makers, in regards to the heat treat? Much❤️from🇨🇦
I could carry my BPS Knives Mini Kiridashi in the 5th pocket with ease, but it's made of 1066 high-carbon steel and a pocket is NOT an optimal space for it. I had its counterpart, the Pry-C, also made of 1066, cover in a layer of rust just after 90 minutes in my pocket... Then it rusted when it was carried as a keychain on a humid day... As for a fixie with a ring - albeit a "ricasso ring" - the Kubey Hippocamp is an awesome option. D2, kiridashi/sheepsfoot/cleaver (depends how you look at it) style blade, impressive sharpness and uncanny looks. Very useful. My go-to fixed knife.
Old Curmudgeon here..Mora #1 Classic. I put it back in the sheath the same way every time, so I know where the business edge is. It tucks into pants pocket just fine. Cheers
If you are in Europe, have a look at Wolfgangs (Odenwolf now), they have a couple of neck knives, the Veriti and the Acus. They are more budget friendly and their handles are a little bit longer, with it something positive at the moment of actually using the knife. I carry one exactly in the way the question’s poster was asking for.
@Asher Parker - the ultimate pocket knife rig with a finger ring has got to be the Lionsteel H1 or H2 (got both and prefer the blade shape of the H1), with the newly-released kydex sheath. A bit more than your $50 budget, but something to aspire to maybe?!
Spartan blades enyo, tops sneaky Pete mini, white river M1 backpacker are my 3 favourite “edc” fixed blades. For camp, around town and in the bush on a hunt. With respect given to benchmade hidden canyon
Hey DCA and Thomas. I recently purchased the Viper Vale with the bocote handles. I hesitated to put some pivot lube on it due to the wood handles. My question is whether it’s safe to use and is there a consensus on dealing with wood grips and lubricants.
DCA, you disappoint me, I can’t believe you left out an obvious choice for the pocket karambit/ring pull style knife - the Kabar TDI Pocket Strike is a perfect answer to the query and is more affordable than most of your suggestions. It comes with an integrated pocket clip and sits lower in the pocket than most other options. Maybe I should guest host? 🤣
Each and every knife I use I carry on my pocket, all of them fixed blades (including the bird and game) and I circumvented all the sheath adaptation or clips by using a paracord static line to my belt. The knife that mostly can be found in my pocket is an SRK Compact, great, great stuff. Although I would like Cold Steel to go an extra level with an SRK Micro.
Hi DCA, for a "ringed" pocket fixed blade, the KA-BAR 1119 Forged Wrench Knife meets IMHO all the criteria. Under 50$, with a good and easy to "Ulticliped" sheath, for me this is the one.
So I ordered a Gerber Dibs to try out a fixed blade knife. I liked it and carried it in my fifth pocket without issue. Had to adjust when sitting while driving, but was perfect while standing. Honestly the biggest problem was the trash sheath, and I can’t find a kydex sheath online. Considered ordering kydex sheath making kit, but I’ll just wait till someone makes one and order a ulticlip with it. Until then, CRKT Pilar goes in the fifth pocket.
No mention of the CRKT Minimalist? Right size, micarta, ergos, etc. Readily available and can be found under $20 in a variety of blade shapes and colors. Maybe a bit on the cheap side for daily steel but a surprisingly great knife for the price.
On the Boker Gnome a lanyard with an inline bead will give you more finger purchase. A SHORT static line from the sheath to the belt/belt loop will prevent knife orphaning.
... can't recall if they've done a 5th pocket *FOLDER* edition of this outside of maybe a Knife Center DCA FAQ session. That said, would love that linked here and def hope that the following (in no particular order) would be in consideration: - Civivi Baby Banter - Spyderco Dragonfly 2 - Vosteed Mini Nightshade - Kizer Mini Sheepdog (Thumbhole only) - Finch Model 1929
Thin grabbable fixed blade skeletonised / ring like. I just bought a real steel alieneck. It fits really well in my jeans or in my work boots. Can recommend highly, I did do a para wrap for comfort and discretion.
David, I’m old, you’re young. It’s a Watch Pocket. “5th pocket” is a new term used by youngsters unfamiliar with pocket watches. A small sturdy fixed blade can be handy. My neck knife is an Ed Caffrey EBK-1.
Tried carrying a Guardian 3, didn't work. I love the knife, love the look, love the feel, sharp. Just was hard to get out the sheathe since only a small part of the handle sticks out, so you have to inch it out a little at a time, you could wrap some paracord into a tie at the base but to me that kind of defeats the point of a pocket knife and increases the profile. I tried 3 different sheathes. It was just longer and wider... Wasn't a good fit for me, especially where in the summer I'm wearing gym shorts a lot. Still have the Guardian 3, but don't carry it anymore,
The cure for the snake charmer sheath is to put a lanyard on the hole and loops around your belt, or a belt loop, when you pull the knife out the lanyard will remove the sheath for you.
The snake charmer sheath will work in pocket if you want to paracord lash it to a belt loop and don't mind it being deeper in pocket like a sak. I've become quite fond of this method of carrying a pocket fixed blade on my off-hand side.
Hi D.C.A. So me and my 5-year-old daughter watch your show every week since she was borne, She has been asking for her own knife so she can watch the show whilst holding hers. I want to be a responsible father and wondered what would you recommend for her first folding knife,, the only thing she requests is its small and cute. Preferably with a pink handle.. Look forward to hearing your suggestions.. Keep up the great work.. Supporting from 🇬🇧
My first knife I got when I was around 6 or 7 was a tiny Gerber folding knife that was red, still have it over 20 years later. Spyderco has a lot of small ones in lots of colors.
Spydero Dragonfly (steel handles) or Case Texas Toothpick (medium!) as my last resort completely in the fifth pocket since oh so many years. Spyderco with its fat blade and solid back lock good last defense stabber, Toothpick with its long and thin blade excellent slicer. So one or the other, every time, all the time.
I've learned a bunch from this series, thanks bro. Where can I find info about the financials of the knife industry, something like an overvall market analysis maybe? Gross annual revenue for large and small makers, total employees and salaries, supply and marketing budgets etc. Also financials for major retailers like yours and a breakdown of what type of products sell at what markups, volumes and what speed. What specific financial info are the decision makers looking at when they decide to manufacture a new model or stock a batch of new models? I know this is not a typical question answered here but maybe you can point me in the right direction very briefly while explaining something more relevent to your wider audience like how many pm2s you sell a month or how much a designer gets paid to put his name on a mass produced version of his custom. Thanks again DCA, tell Seth I said thanks too but please do not thank thomas until he can correctly identify a reverse tanto hahaha.
You can use a piece of paracord and make a static line. Cheaper then the ulti clip. Use your thumb to push the sheath off, oo for rapid deployment just grab the handle a rapidly pull the whole thing out of your pocket. No ring needed (unless you want the ring). So you would tie a piece of paracord to a hole in the sheath, loop the other end around your belt or belt loop. Stick the knife (with Sheath) in your pocket or tuck in your waistband or belt. Always check local laws
Hey guys! Question for a future video: can you show off different types of sheaths and clips, and methods of carry for different knives? For example, I own a Ka-Bar TDI Investigator, and I can't figure out how to carry this thing effectively on a belt. The stock clip just does not seem to lend itself to a good belt position for me. I'd love to see options that are out there and how to get different knives to sit where you want them.
Love the bird and game. The bird and fish is a little smaller,laced into my boots and was my favorite fo years till I lost it on a really hot fishing day. Now that I see it I gotta go buy another one
What about the little Mora neck knife, the Eldris? Fits in my pockets just fine. I have carried it on my belt with the belt loop attachment, as a neck knife with that attachment, and in my pocket with the plain sheath. It is small enough, but not too small, and affordable and tough!
Hey DCA, Thomas, and Seth! I appreciate you guys very much for all you do to keep the knife community informed! I recently picked up a Victorinox Venture and just love the knife, it does so much right… that sheath though? It has a bit much in the wiggle and play categories for my liking, and the retention is a wee bit soft. Can you recommend some aftermarket sheath options that would work? I got the red one, so maybe some black options? Thanks much!
Although it has G10 handles, I can't believe that you guys didn't even mention the CRKT Minimalist family. I used the Wharncliffe variant for 2 years and it is imho one of the most practical knives in this price range: Easy to sharpen, somewhat decent edge retention and it sure does not break the bank.
Same here, Not a fan of frame or liner lock knives. Very early on thats what i had, now i pretty much never carry one. For a folder i prefer a knife with, as David calls it, a "finger safe lock", and easily one hand open and closed.
Looking for a fixed blade for use around the yard, opening bags, cutting string, rope, etc. Very general purpose, and easy to clean. $50 maybe? Bright handle would be a plus, so you can find it back in the grass. Suggestions?
I've been carrying a lon humphrey "whitetail" in my front pocket since 2018. It was the last run he made of them that I know of, I'm lucky to have got it.
Snake Charmer is even more useable as a neck knife with that plastic sheath. i wore and used it daily more than 3 years in a row working in my little sharpening and knife selling business. will get another one.
DCA, I know you don’t talk about this topic much but what do you think the best overall combat self defense carry there in terms of blade shape, size, lock/fixed, and material around 4 inches? I think my Protech Godfather Operator fits this category well but want to hear y’all’s thoughts.
Apropos of nothing in particular, I have read that the wisdom of the pudding metaphor is, "The proof of the pudding is in the eating." Not being what most people would consider perfect however, I could be wrong... I do enjoy your channel though, and I am not wrong about that!
I might have a possible answer to the frame lock question. People who buy high end knives don't buy them because they're frame locks, but because they're high end. It's not that the high end buyer loves frame locks, it's that frame locks are all there is for high end buyers. The companies have no incentive to change.
If you want a bit larger of a finger ringed fixed blade with a more useful shape try the Tops C.U.T. 4.0. About $150, but is worth it. I carry mine scout or on a dangler, depending on what I'm doing/wearing.
What's going on with the shadeless lamp? Could we see the store vacuum cleaner or broom next week? Or maybe the coat rack/hat stand? Yep, the hat stand would be nice.👌🏻 Edit: Indeed I was wondering.
DCA! What is the 7-inch (4" handle/3" inch blade) drop point, lefty, liner lock knife for general outdoor use? A liner lock Zancodo would be great. The Rat II is out because the large space between the blade and handle makes it close to a 3 finger knife. I've settled on my old Kershaw RJII 1980 which is a tanto, but a modified tanto with curves. Also, the pocket clip is right only. I typically drop it in a pocket when climbing in the Mojave, but also want a pocket clip for a lefty. Thanks!!
You are missing an awesome knife. The CRKT Minimalist. It’s an excellent knife and it cost less than $30.00. I like mine so much that I purchased 4 more to keep in storage in case something ever happens to mine.
I don't know why that one person question about frame locks of why companies still make them? Because its still a convenient locking mechanism. It's also stronger than a liner lock. So that's one of the reasons why people still buy them but also preference as well.
Can you guys do an updated video for pocket fixed blades? I don't know how many more have come out since your last video on it, but it'd be nice to have one that keeps the list updated.
I recently got into knife making, and it really made me understand the value of the small pocket fixed blade. A well designed small fixed blade is a joy to use, isn’t much bigger than a folder, and it’s impervious to the grit and dirt I encounter at my job. Plus, since I’m making them myself, I can treat them like disposable tools - I’m talking prying, opening caustic chemicals, screwdriver duty, all that good stuff.
Since you’re a knife maker I’ll run this by you. I also favor fixed blades but don’t like using any knife I can’t get a full four finger grip on. I think the pinkie is important for maximum control and guiding a knife for finesse cuts. What are your thoughts on a knife with a 3.5-4” handle and a 1.75-2.25” blade. The proportions would be similar to the classic Stanley razor knife but would be much stronger and sharpenable.
@@donalddicorcia2433 The proportions you’re describing are pretty similar to the very popular Civivi Baby Banter (if you count the finger choil area as part of the handle).
I actually made a Baby Banter inspired fixed blade awhile ago just to see what the fuss was about, and I do like it. It’s great for anything you’d typically use a utility razor for, PLUS a few things like wood carving that require a stouter blade.
The downside of course is that having such a short blade does limit you a bit. If you’re going to go this route, learn from my mistake and keep the edge fairly straight like a utility razor (very little or no belly) so that you have the aggressive tip and so that the blade doesn’t fall away from the cut quite so quickly.
Good point. (no pun intended) A sheepsfoot might fit the bill. Checked out the baby banter and yes, the proportions are about right, but it would be a fixed blade, of course. The other option would be a “reverse folder” where the blade and most of the handle would be one piece and if you needed a bit more handle for extra control or leverage, an extra piece would fold out of the handle and provide a place for your pinkie.
@@donalddicorcia2433 An extendable handle does sound interesting. For a simpler option, you could instead attach a substantial lanyard as the optional fourth finger grip. It’s not rigid so it doesn’t transfer delicate twisting forces, but it does provide better grip and control.
@@donalddicorcia2433 check out Very Good Knife Company. They're usa made 80crv2 blade steel with micarta handles and very affordable. they have one that fits your description called the splicer it 75$
Your a bad influence i went on the knife center web site and bought 3 knives so when my wife finds out I'm blaming you 😅
One of my favorite things I've seen on r/knife_swap is when sellers say, Can include a note saying: Congrats on your free knife. Hahah.
I blame him for everything: new surfboards, new motorcycles, new knives, new pistols! It’s all DCA’s fault! Plus drinking too much beer! Plus smoking cigars. He is a very very bad influence.
@@surfingonmars8979 I will do the same especially the cigars going to the cigar bar Tuesday Tobacco Haus in New Braunfels go and I'll really get the wives mad
@@FrankCastle-he8fl Ah, I miss the European sensibilities of leisurely and sane use of tobacco - not chain smoking disgusting cigarettes, but slowly enjoying an occasional cigar…….
You can blame yourself for marrying in the first place.
I found this channel about 20 episodes of this back and watched all of them now. As far as I’m concerned this guy and Thomas are the face of the company. Y’all better give them a raise! Great presentations and great humor.
Same here I love their videos! Actively looking forward to knife advertisement!
Thanks to them I bought one of the knives off this list today lol
I second the raise 💵
Didn't know there were so many. I've had an Esee Candiru for a few years now. Similar to the other 5th pocket knives you list, it's tiny, sturdy, and easy to carry. The 1095 blade is coated, which is needed, but my only objection is the coating has too much texture.
Civivi Midwatch is my choice for a pocketable fixed blade with a finger ring. Slicy and corrosion-resistant, perfect for camping and food prep
YES!!!! I LOOOOVE fixed blades, I'm so happy youre talking about them today! Im looking to get me a Mini Gunny from bark river, but so many handle options!!!
I have a mini Gunny in MagnaCut with antique white linen Micarta scales and toxic green liners, such a beauty. made the sheath into a pocket carry. perfect edc size knife, you won't regret picking one up.
@@johngoodwin2734 exactly! I think I will do a kydex sheath for neck carry... after that I'm getting the Kitsuné looks awesome as well!
The thing about both frame locks and liner locks is that they are simple locks that give you a nice strong detent for not that much effort. They are not my favorite either but I certainly appreciate a good liner or frame lock.
I’ve taken a seam ripper (a standard sewing tool), opened up the bottom seam of the watch pocket, and let my sheath poke thru the bottom. Also a good idea to use a little seam tape and a hot iron on the open seam to prevent fraying. Allows for a slightly large knife.
Used to do that myself! Works great.
Ooh sold on the Gnome. Thanks DCA!
The whole episode, I was wondering about the missing light shade 🤣
The magnetic sheath is key. I carry a Dan Wesson Valkyrie Commander in a JM4 Tactical holster of the same design. The magnet is versatile for carrying adjustment as well as options to stick on any ferrous surface.
I watch all the beatiful blade shapes, materials, designs, locks...and always end up buying a Cold Steel knife. This time that great Bird and Game for EDC, lightweight workhorse and a somewhat tactical fixed blade. Thumbs up! great video!
Surprised I didn’t see the Esee Candiru on the 5th pocket list:
Small blade that shouldn’t have any problem fitting in a small pocket, comes with a pocket clip that can attach to the sheath, and has micarta or G10 handles that can be purchased to add extra grip. I think it’s smaller than the Canary, too
The "Candiru" always cracks up my inner 12-year-old. A little fish that fits in a tiny pocket.
I bought one on a whim at a local shop while shopping for another knife, turned out to be more useful then I ever thought.
I really enjoy and appreciate your videos. They are comprehensive with logical, sensible, and solid information. All of that is very hard to come by these days especially on TH-cam; I thank you. The only other TH-cam presenter of your stature (I was going to say “caliber”) is Chris Baker of Lucky Gunner.
Can you do a whole video on edc self defense fixed blade knives that have at least one ring in them? I searched through your list of popular videos and I don’t see anything like that. In self defense I think the ring part is invaluable to keep a good hold on the knife. Please do this video.
Something that can be comfortable in the pocket or on the belt and concealable obviously. Thanks!
I bought my 1st fixed blade about a year ago(?). I almost stopped carrying it completely. Decided to try a custom leather sheath and try again. Fixed my issues with it completely. It's now pocketable and the edges of the sheath don't get caught on everything like the original included kydex sheath. I carry it pretty much every day either in my rear pocket or even the front pocket, now.
I EDC a fixed blade - the Hogue Extrak. The M4 steel is sharp and tough. The size is just right for a pocket, and the kydex sheath keeps it small and light. Thanks for talking about fixed blades. If you revisit the topic, please include the Extrak.
I absolutely love my Extrak! So thin and light that it disappears in a pocket, scout carry, crossdraw, or as a neck knife. Or in the waistband of basketball style shorts and won't weight them down.
I've had a fixed blade in my pocket almost since 2008-09. Never in the 5th pocket though. That one is reserved for my Victorinox Pioneer.
The TOPS CUT 4.0 has been my edc fixed blade for 5+ years (also answers the second question a bit without sticking to 50$ 'constraint). 5+ years of EDC in India - I'm an outdoorsman by nature and tend to sweat a lot. The knife has never had an issue of any sort with respect to corrosion even with extended iWB carry. Takes a wicked edge and helps me with emergency food prep, gardening and wood processing and general package opening too, wherever needed. Highly recommended.
I've already stashed up 2 more in case I lose the current one. It is near indestructible however.
First video i have ever seen from this channel, people keep talking about their "fifth pocket" and what they are putting in there, asking for recommendation what can fit in there.
Love it!
Have my like 😂
Small fixed blades… praise the lord. Thank you! Addendum: would love to see best fixed blades under 12 cm blade length for concealed scout carry, again with consideration for ease of mounting them to your belt and discreet concealment. I find that length, handle shape, sheath design, or clip design can all create logistical problems for these carry desires. Prefer to carry up front above the appendix. Under 100 bucks would be nice, but sometimes we can’t have everything… 😋
Thank you for covering my question my friends! I appreciate y’all! Have a great week.
you might also want to look into the lionsteel h2, real steel furrier, tops c.u.t. and kizer cabox. they're all above the $50 mark, but absolutely worth considering!
Love the fixed blade specials. For the 5th pocket... the Mini Elementum fixed blade, Spyderco ARK, SOG Instinct and some of the CRKT Minimalist blade shapes should work as well. My most serious question of the day - What knife should DCA be carrying on set to parry Thomas' verbal lunges? 🤺
Not a thomas fan. The camera man should always remain silent.
I like their banter... @@stevenstroupe3805
Any knife with a reverse tanto blade.
The Bradford Guardian 3 in Magnacut get some pocket time
@@stevenstroupe3805sorry. I can't picture that.
Spyderco Street Beat (VG-10), with cool-smooth, substantial micarta handle: (discontinued)
Front-pocket carry;
Thumb press pops sheath that stays in pocket;
Totally concealed with hand in pocket, sheath popped, blade loosened, edge still covered, handle gripped... all while hidden in pocket.
No knife draw is faster or quieter. Autos make noise, slower, needs button-push.
Best knives don't have moving parts.
If you were stranded on a deserted island would you rather have the knife of your dreams or a sat phone?
The frame lock has more security from folding in on you than a liner lock; I have the, Kershaw Filter and I love it, very well made for a great price. Great EDC. Thank you for your review. 😎👍
Framelocks are still great for making nicely slim knives!
I bought the CRKT M16-03BS because it has a framelock for example! Sweet robust, slim and easy to maintain construction! 🥰
Hi David and Thomas long time watcher first time commenter! I have reached the mid century of my life and have amassed a very large collection. I’m wondering are there any recommendations you could make for parting with items from my collection other than eBay? I have a vast array from customs to production many makes and models. Any suggestions are greatly appreciated keep up the great work!
2 other options for the 5th pocket fixed blade question are the Camillus Heater II, and the Boker Magnum Lil Friend, they don´t have micarta handles, but fit very well in there
Hey DCA. I hear lots of people from the knife community complain about Itailian heat treat and their overall bad reputation. Is this something you've personally experienced? Or is it just like you mentioned about internet and reality TV. What would you consider to be the best and most consistent Italian knife makers, in regards to the heat treat? Much❤️from🇨🇦
I'm glad you shed some light on all this 😂 love your vids
Intro on these videos of whats happening in your mind cracks me up. Love it.
I could carry my BPS Knives Mini Kiridashi in the 5th pocket with ease, but it's made of 1066 high-carbon steel and a pocket is NOT an optimal space for it. I had its counterpart, the Pry-C, also made of 1066, cover in a layer of rust just after 90 minutes in my pocket... Then it rusted when it was carried as a keychain on a humid day...
As for a fixie with a ring - albeit a "ricasso ring" - the Kubey Hippocamp is an awesome option. D2, kiridashi/sheepsfoot/cleaver (depends how you look at it) style blade, impressive sharpness and uncanny looks. Very useful. My go-to fixed knife.
The Gerber Gator is one of the best knives ever made! I've got one I bought around 1992. That things stays razor sharp and takes a beating!
I picked up a CRKT minimalist drop point neck knife for Christmas '22. Awesome knife and very handy to have. WIll check out what you have here.
I am a big fan of the UltiClip solutions as well. Highly recommend. I often pocket carry a ESEE Xancudo using an UltiClip.
Old Curmudgeon here..Mora #1 Classic. I put it back in the sheath the same way every time, so I know where the business edge is. It tucks into pants pocket just fine. Cheers
If you are in Europe, have a look at Wolfgangs (Odenwolf now), they have a couple of neck knives, the Veriti and the Acus. They are more budget friendly and their handles are a little bit longer, with it something positive at the moment of actually using the knife. I carry one exactly in the way the question’s poster was asking for.
Crkt’s minimalist would be a great option for anyone looking for this style of knife and it is very affordable.
Lets go!! I'm a every day fixed blade carry guy. Absolutely love fixed blade dedicated videos
@Asher Parker - the ultimate pocket knife rig with a finger ring has got to be the Lionsteel H1 or H2 (got both and prefer the blade shape of the H1), with the newly-released kydex sheath. A bit more than your $50 budget, but something to aspire to maybe?!
Thank you my friend!
@@asherparker4631 No problem - great question by the way!
About time we talk fixed blade again 😂.. Thanks for your time and the video as always man 😎🔪👍
Spartan blades enyo, tops sneaky Pete mini, white river M1 backpacker are my 3 favourite “edc” fixed blades. For camp, around town and in the bush on a hunt. With respect given to benchmade hidden canyon
"Safety third" caption and a cartoon of a jolly fella installing a lightbulb with two knives would be an ace t-shirt!
Another small pocket fixie would be the CRKT Minimalist. You may want to get an ulti-clip for it but they are small and versatile.
Hey DCA and Thomas. I recently purchased the Viper Vale with the bocote handles. I hesitated to put some pivot lube on it due to the wood handles. My question is whether it’s safe to use and is there a consensus on dealing with wood grips and lubricants.
I’d like to know the lubricant do’s and dont’s
DCA, you disappoint me, I can’t believe you left out an obvious choice for the pocket karambit/ring pull style knife - the Kabar TDI Pocket Strike is a perfect answer to the query and is more affordable than most of your suggestions. It comes with an integrated pocket clip and sits lower in the pocket than most other options. Maybe I should guest host? 🤣
I can get behind this suggestion. Also, I need a break, host away :D -DCA
Each and every knife I use I carry on my pocket, all of them fixed blades (including the bird and game) and I circumvented all the sheath adaptation or clips by using a paracord static line to my belt. The knife that mostly can be found in my pocket is an SRK Compact, great, great stuff. Although I would like Cold Steel to go an extra level with an SRK Micro.
Hi DCA, for a "ringed" pocket fixed blade, the KA-BAR 1119 Forged Wrench Knife meets IMHO all the criteria. Under 50$, with a good and easy to "Ulticliped" sheath, for me this is the one.
So I ordered a Gerber Dibs to try out a fixed blade knife. I liked it and carried it in my fifth pocket without issue. Had to adjust when sitting while driving, but was perfect while standing. Honestly the biggest problem was the trash sheath, and I can’t find a kydex sheath online. Considered ordering kydex sheath making kit, but I’ll just wait till someone makes one and order a ulticlip with it. Until then, CRKT Pilar goes in the fifth pocket.
No mention of the CRKT Minimalist? Right size, micarta, ergos, etc.
Readily available and can be found under $20 in a variety of blade shapes and colors.
Maybe a bit on the cheap side for daily steel but a surprisingly great knife for the price.
On the Boker Gnome a lanyard with an inline bead will give you more finger purchase. A SHORT static line from the sheath to the belt/belt loop will prevent knife orphaning.
... can't recall if they've done a 5th pocket *FOLDER* edition of this outside of maybe a Knife Center DCA FAQ session. That said, would love that linked here and def hope that the following (in no particular order) would be in consideration:
- Civivi Baby Banter
- Spyderco Dragonfly 2
- Vosteed Mini Nightshade
- Kizer Mini Sheepdog (Thumbhole only)
- Finch Model 1929
Right here mate: th-cam.com/video/5JXBoex_Q9A/w-d-xo.html
Good job. I enjoyed this table talk.
The high end frame locks sell because people love everything ELSE about the knives and they aren't offered with other locks.
Thin grabbable fixed blade skeletonised / ring like.
I just bought a real steel alieneck. It fits really well in my jeans or in my work boots. Can recommend highly, I did do a para wrap for comfort and discretion.
David, I’m old, you’re young. It’s a Watch Pocket. “5th pocket” is a new term used by youngsters unfamiliar with pocket watches. A small sturdy fixed blade can be handy. My neck knife is an Ed Caffrey EBK-1.
Tried carrying a Guardian 3, didn't work. I love the knife, love the look, love the feel, sharp. Just was hard to get out the sheathe since only a small part of the handle sticks out, so you have to inch it out a little at a time, you could wrap some paracord into a tie at the base but to me that kind of defeats the point of a pocket knife and increases the profile. I tried 3 different sheathes. It was just longer and wider... Wasn't a good fit for me, especially where in the summer I'm wearing gym shorts a lot. Still have the Guardian 3, but don't carry it anymore,
I Cannot believe you took the wrench knife off your pocket knife list! I know it is probably out of the price range but the pocket strike is awesome.
I've been strictly a folder carry type, but now I think I need a fixed blad.. knife center does it again!
The cure for the snake charmer sheath is to put a lanyard on the hole and loops around your belt, or a belt loop, when you pull the knife out the lanyard will remove the sheath for you.
I believe that is commonly called a tether, works well!
The Spyderco ARK is the best 5th pocket knife.
The snake charmer sheath will work in pocket if you want to paracord lash it to a belt loop and don't mind it being deeper in pocket like a sak. I've become quite fond of this method of carrying a pocket fixed blade on my off-hand side.
My favorite knife category!!!!! Thank you, thank you!!!!
Hi D.C.A.
So me and my 5-year-old daughter watch your show every week since she was borne,
She has been asking for her own knife so she can watch the show whilst holding hers.
I want to be a responsible father and wondered what would you recommend for her first folding knife,, the only thing she requests is its small and cute. Preferably with a pink handle..
Look forward to hearing your suggestions..
Keep up the great work..
Supporting from 🇬🇧
My first knife I got when I was around 6 or 7 was a tiny Gerber folding knife that was red, still have it over 20 years later. Spyderco has a lot of small ones in lots of colors.
Spydero Dragonfly (steel handles) or Case Texas Toothpick (medium!) as my last resort completely in the fifth pocket since oh so many years. Spyderco with its fat blade and solid back lock good last defense stabber, Toothpick with its long and thin blade excellent slicer. So one or the other, every time, all the time.
I've learned a bunch from this series, thanks bro. Where can I find info about the financials of the knife industry, something like an overvall market analysis maybe? Gross annual revenue for large and small makers, total employees and salaries, supply and marketing budgets etc. Also financials for major retailers like yours and a breakdown of what type of products sell at what markups, volumes and what speed. What specific financial info are the decision makers looking at when they decide to manufacture a new model or stock a batch of new models? I know this is not a typical question answered here but maybe you can point me in the right direction very briefly while explaining something more relevent to your wider audience like how many pm2s you sell a month or how much a designer gets paid to put his name on a mass produced version of his custom. Thanks again DCA, tell Seth I said thanks too but please do not thank thomas until he can correctly identify a reverse tanto hahaha.
You can use a piece of paracord and make a static line. Cheaper then the ulti clip. Use your thumb to push the sheath off, oo for rapid deployment just grab the handle a rapidly pull the whole thing out of your pocket. No ring needed (unless you want the ring).
So you would tie a piece of paracord to a hole in the sheath, loop the other end around your belt or belt loop. Stick the knife (with Sheath) in your pocket or tuck in your waistband or belt. Always check local laws
Hey guys! Question for a future video: can you show off different types of sheaths and clips, and methods of carry for different knives? For example, I own a Ka-Bar TDI Investigator, and I can't figure out how to carry this thing effectively on a belt. The stock clip just does not seem to lend itself to a good belt position for me. I'd love to see options that are out there and how to get different knives to sit where you want them.
Love the bird and game. The bird and fish is a little smaller,laced into my boots and was my favorite fo years till I lost it on a really hot fishing day. Now that I see it I gotta go buy another one
What about the little Mora neck knife, the Eldris? Fits in my pockets just fine. I have carried it on my belt with the belt loop attachment, as a neck knife with that attachment, and in my pocket with the plain sheath. It is small enough, but not too small, and affordable and tough!
Hey DCA, Thomas, and Seth! I appreciate you guys very much for all you do to keep the knife community informed! I recently picked up a Victorinox Venture and just love the knife, it does so much right… that sheath though? It has a bit much in the wiggle and play categories for my liking, and the retention is a wee bit soft. Can you recommend some aftermarket sheath options that would work? I got the red one, so maybe some black options? Thanks much!
Although it has G10 handles, I can't believe that you guys didn't even mention the CRKT Minimalist family. I used the Wharncliffe variant for 2 years and it is imho one of the most practical knives in this price range: Easy to sharpen, somewhat decent edge retention and it sure does not break the bank.
Same here, Not a fan of frame or liner lock knives. Very early on thats what i had, now i pretty much never carry one. For a folder i prefer a knife with, as David calls it, a "finger safe lock", and easily one hand open and closed.
Looking for a fixed blade for use around the yard, opening bags, cutting string, rope, etc. Very general purpose, and easy to clean. $50 maybe? Bright handle would be a plus, so you can find it back in the grass. Suggestions?
I want that Karbon @ 20:46 but dang, they gotta get rid of that huge TIAWAN on the blade
I still have my Gerber gator. Great knife. I used it through all my military time.
I've been carrying a lon humphrey "whitetail" in my front pocket since 2018. It was the last run he made of them that I know of, I'm lucky to have got it.
I’ve carried a cold steel hidden edge as a edc for years now 👍🏻
Regarding the 5th pocket, I know the OP said fixed blade, but the Boker Subcom has always been my go-to for that pocket.
Love that little qsp canary
Snake Charmer is even more useable as a neck knife with that plastic sheath. i wore and used it daily more than 3 years in a row working in my little sharpening and knife selling business. will get another one.
THAT’s what’s that damn lamp was there for! I definitely didn’t guess correctly. Nice pick on the Gators. Awesome.
I have never seen a fifth pocket that would accept any one of these knives! Thumbnail says it all! 😂😂😂 Love the knives though.ATB👍👍👍
DCA, I know you don’t talk about this topic much but what do you think the best overall combat self defense carry there in terms of blade shape, size, lock/fixed, and material around 4 inches? I think my Protech Godfather Operator fits this category well but want to hear y’all’s thoughts.
Apropos of nothing in particular, I have read that the wisdom of the pudding metaphor is, "The proof of the pudding is in the eating." Not being what most people would consider perfect however, I could be wrong... I do enjoy your channel though, and I am not wrong about that!
I might have a possible answer to the frame lock question. People who buy high end knives don't buy them because they're frame locks, but because they're high end. It's not that the high end buyer loves frame locks, it's that frame locks are all there is for high end buyers. The companies have no incentive to change.
For the fixed blade with a ring, I carry the KABAR wrench knife with an Ulti-clip in my pocket at work. USA made and gets the jobe done.
I call shenanigans on using the Ulticlip with the QSP canary. The screws are too wide to fit through the holes.
If you want a bit larger of a finger ringed fixed blade with a more useful shape try the Tops C.U.T. 4.0. About $150, but is worth it. I carry mine scout or on a dangler, depending on what I'm doing/wearing.
Found a Gerber Gator in the woods once, on an old logging trail in Virginia! Good knife!
What's going on with the shadeless lamp?
Could we see the store vacuum cleaner or broom next week?
Or maybe the coat rack/hat stand?
Yep, the hat stand would be nice.👌🏻
Edit:
Indeed I was wondering.
DCAs eyes sparkle with joy when there’s a table full of fixed blades 😂
The Toor Viper Outlaw would be a sound choice
5th pocket carry jams anything sticking above it into your hip bone when you sit. Something a knife salesman won’t tell you. 😉
DCA show us how to change out our bearings and put washers in our knives😊
DCA! What is the 7-inch (4" handle/3" inch blade) drop point, lefty, liner lock knife for general outdoor use? A liner lock Zancodo would be great. The Rat II is out because the large space between the blade and handle makes it close to a 3 finger knife. I've settled on my old Kershaw RJII 1980 which is a tanto, but a modified tanto with curves. Also, the pocket clip is right only. I typically drop it in a pocket when climbing in the Mojave, but also want a pocket clip for a lefty. Thanks!!
You are missing an awesome knife. The CRKT Minimalist. It’s an excellent knife and it cost less than $30.00. I like mine so much that I purchased 4 more to keep in storage in case something ever happens to mine.
I don't know why that one person question about frame locks of why companies still make them? Because its still a convenient locking mechanism. It's also stronger than a liner lock. So that's one of the reasons why people still buy them but also preference as well.
You really gotta bring a pair of jeans out there to show how they sit in the pocket.
Can you guys do an updated video for pocket fixed blades? I don't know how many more have come out since your last video on it, but it'd be nice to have one that keeps the list updated.