ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ก.ย. 2024
- This movie belongs to Fox Searchlight Pictures. I own nothing!
-Fair use.
-Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended.
-All the Rights in This Content Belong to Their Respective Owner/s.
Putting the glass of juice on the table was powerful, but turning the straw towards him absolutely shattered me the first time I saw this scene. It adds a human touch to the powerful symbolism of this scene that makes it feel so real and true.
Him sitting down and breathing heavily like tat speaks volumes about PTSD as well...Especially since he's now been sorta forced into this situation with the very person who'd did this to him...Man this part made the movie for me.
just shows that Welby is a very forgiving dude. What Dixon did to him was just downright terrible, but at the same time Dixon really redeemed himself the second half of the movie and Welby pouring the glass of orange juice for him shows that he forgives him and truly thinks that he was sorry and regretted what he did, good stuff
Nah bro he was just giving him a glass of juice
When he hands the juice, faith in humanity restores once again.
I believe everybody thinks Welby is gonna hurt Dixon but the twist was just heart warming. This is a scene where I believe Sam earned a number one slot in everyone's ballot.
Despite the fact that Dixon did something so horrid to him, Wilby did something good by him (even though it was small), and got him some orange juice.
A guy who was nearly killed gives his assailant orange juice. I don't see how it can restore anyone's faith in humanity. Maybe I'm just not Christian enough.
@@SCharlesDennicon The idea that the assailant seeing his victim show him mercy helped nudge him along making that character turn he was making towards the better, or even just validating it if he had his mind set anyway? I think that's what they're angling towards. It's a sweet moment even if you're gonna reject how believable it is. But you can't pretend not to get it anymore. I don't like when cynics do that
@@SCharlesDennicon cause he saw true remorse on him. he saw a badly burned man, who cried and ask for forgivenes on the harm he did. insane or not, many victims that seek restitution get a great deal of relief knowing that the guilt is eating alive the person who harmed them, knowing that is not just fucking up their own lifes, but theirs as well. and it was red choice to be kind and get that closure on it, instead of holding onto hate.
One of my favourite scenes. Love how McDonagh fakes you out into thinking this will be some 'darkly ironic' comic scene and turns it into such a beautifully humane moment.
And it stays so in character too. Welby couldn't punch, humilliate, or even insult a guy covered in bandages, even if it's Dixon. It's not in him, he is just too decent to do that. Dixon starts his atonment through this, someone forgives him for no reason other than avoiding to hold a grudge. Forgiveness is one powerful and cleansing gesture.
I also love how McDonagh made you think Dixon burnt down the signs, only to find out he didn't
I broke down during this beautiful scene. Welby could have done some major damage, but he just couldn't beat a man who is down even though what Dixon did was unforgivable. This is when Dixon atoned for his past behavior and sought forgiveness as well as trying to the right thing by the eyes of the law.
This probably is the most unlikely scenes to have made me cry. I simply couldn't contain my tears during this moment, it was so humane, so agonising and so beautiful
I didn't cry, I sit silently looking at the screen, I couldn't move or talk. It was shocking in a very special way. Welby was too kind to mistreat a burnt man, it's not into him, and he couldn't help to feel sorry for him. Welby turned the other cheek in such a genuine way, he also indirectly forgave him, I guess it isn't into him to keep a grudge either. So much decency and fragility in the same couple of scenes.
Because Dickxon sorry first. Simple
What a scene.... laughed my ass off during the first half, and almost brought to tears in the second half. Not many directors can pull that off
This director (Martin McDonagh) has a very unique style, he's only directed a few movies but they're all good.
It’s all about knowing your plot and where it’s supposed to go. Also about knowing when the comedy needs to end in the seriousness needs to begin. The comedy is covering what we wish we could do in real life. The drama is covering what we need to do in real life. And I think that’s kind of the overall message of the movie. Anger and violence only beats more angry, angry, and violence. That’s why it’s best reserved to fantasy.
Sam added some really funny scenes into this film. To play such an asshole and still make laugh, he's a great actor. He played in a movie about civil rights in a small town and was just as good in that film.
The guy who plays Welby is a great actor. In Get Out, seeing him get brutally killed was so satisfying but in this movie, you can't help but have sympathy for him.
at this rate, seeing all the comments under different videos, seems like every actor ever should play the Joker
Ayven Moon - This "X would make a great Joker" should be a meme by now. It's everywhere and it's so cringey.
I thought that was Alfie Allen for some reason
@@acequorthon7351 also the Michael B Jordan as literally anything meme. Dude's great but that meme needs to die
Thanks for spoiling the movie, asshole!
Dixon didn’t deserve Welby’s kindness, but he got it anyway. Welby has a heart of gold.
I think main part that made this film so unbelivably good was the writing. It plays you, the characters acts just the opposite you're expecting to do in such an spontaneous way you discover new things of them every single scene. When Welby finds out Dixon's the guy, instead of cursing him or blaming him (wich would have been a HUGE cliché) he says "Shut up or your wound are gonna get worse". He's concern about him! I wasn't expecting that. That brief moment, that sentence that shows mercy, it's what makes the film so special. The characters don't act the way we expect them to act, they're impulsive, irrational and in every sentence they're slowly showing their true colours. They're human.
PalmurcioWorld its a southern thing. Everyone looks out for one another generally speaking.
Very well said!
Dixon's epiphany moment. He's finding out the path of love is better to live by than hate. Welby just proved to him that love and forgiveness are hard to do but it's must be done to heal the mental injuries. This is a small town. These people see each other multiple times a week and grew up together so deep down they most likely want to see one another succeed.
I think his moment might have even come before that, when he saved the case file from the fire
Phil Lee it's possible. You're right Phil. That's what I love about art. They're so many different interpretations to it that it could be a combination or culmination of scenes throughout the movie. Dixon saving the Angela Hayes file in the fire was most likely in my opinion a start of his transformation with it apexing in the hospital. Just my two cents. Thanks for your interpretation.
Ryan Harbison Beautifully said 💕
I also saw some commentary that said Dixon may have been a closeted gay man and that’s why he was so cruel to Welby. Thoughts?
And fire is hot.
Some gay nerds making straight characters gay in the internet doesn't actually make him gay.
Gay people do that a lot for some reason.
This film was robbed at the Oscars this Sunday.
oh yes it was. Such a beautiful and mature film that actually respects the viewers' intelligence, instead of just being the most predictable, cliche and boring social justice rant of the year (yes I am looking at you Shape of Water)
Shape of water more like the "Fish Fucking Movie".
Yes it was!!!!!
They only gave it to shape of water because this was suposed to be a "mexican year" on the academy agenda. Political echoes. I bet you that if shape was a mid year release by a canadian guy... no oscars at all. (PD: Im Mexican )
Um yeeeeaaah. Oscar Maidana. SOW won because it had a cheesy Hollywood storyline that's been played out till kingdom come like La La Land last year. Three Billboards and Get Out should've dominated the Oscars. Lord of the Rings the first one dominated back in the day at the Oscsrs.
Congrats on the Oscar Sam. You definitely earned it.
Absolutely!!!!
Oh hi Evan
Rockwell before this film he was doing many good works, even very similar like this role in Three Billboard.
If Sam rockwell doesn't win Sunday then I just don't know what to say but this scene nearly brought me to tears when I first watched it red giving him the orange juice at the end just tugged at my heartstrings it was in this moment when Dixon began his path for redemption
I agree.
good news!
I agree and Sam DID WIN!!!!! I LOVE HIM, AMAZING ACTOR!!!!!
Master Epps k
Dixon: I'm sorry
Red: For what??
Dixon: Throwing you out the window.
*the audience laughed at that part legitimately*
Nico Marquez15 guessing you live in America?
Well, is a darkly amusing line. That's McDonagh's thing.
Not gonna lie, I laughed out loud during this scene, funniest scene in the movie. Like the other guy said, that how McDonagh is. Seven Psychopaths!
@@HarryMoho what a ignorant comment. Imagine lumping a whole land mass of people into groups. How embarrassing
@@HarryMoho it's supposed to be funny to break up the tension. Guessing you don't understand dark humor?
To me, this is the best scene of any movie all year. Up til this point, you've seen so much damage to property, to spirit, and to the human body. You have an idea of how this scene will go, that it'll be all about Red getting revenge on Dixon. You think he'll hit him or throw the orange juice in his face. But you see the kindness through the pain and the struggle from Red. You see the sincere change in Dixon just through his eyes. It also shows how one act of kindness can change everything for someone. McDonagh really knows how to play with your preconceived notions and throw a curveball at you. I really loved In Bruges and Seven Psychopaths, but this is a masterpiece of a film. It's a shame it didn't win Best Picture, but that doesn't take away just how powerful this scene is. I was shaking in my seat from how intense it was. Hats off to McDonagh, the cast, and the editor. Favorite scene of the year.
Don't forget the scene in the end in the car. "I gotta tell you something..."
I really do agree, this movie is a master piece.
I laughed so hard at the beginning of this scene and then came the touching moment. Sam Rockwell was outstanding in his role, great character development.
This breaks my every time. So humane, touching, beautiful and simple moment...
Welby was so precious omg I just wanted to hug him.
If he didn’t throw him out the window I’m sure he would’ve filled the glass more
😹😹😹
Welby chose to heal and forgive. Rather than burn and destroy.
Sam did that, very well.
Guess Welby should have "GOTTEN OUT".
Get it? Haha because the actors in....ah fuck it
leonthesleepy Speaking of Get Out,
GET OUT of this comment section after that comment.
Jk lol
This was the saddest thing I’ve ever seen
Welby is the true MVP, though.
Ladybird.......Nope. Shape of Water........Nope. This single moment is why Three Billboards is going to win best picture and top all the rest. This, the deer scene, the fire scene, beating up Welby scene Woody Harrison’s death scene, and the ending will be iconic scenes in the future and prove my point of this being not only the best movie of the year but up there as one of the best of all time.
Justin O'Neill It was robbed. Sadly robbed.
Justin O'Neill Those were all great scenes but Iconic is pushing it
It was robbed BIG TIME!😠
Seems like u were wrong .
Poor kid is actually a kind hearted soul
Amazing scene. God I love this movie.
Me too!!!!
This is my favorite scene in the movie
It restored my faith in humanity, bless Dixon and Welby!😪🙏❤
I was actually crying during this scene. Insanely powerful!
The guy playing Welby is a really good actor. His delivery of the line "I don't care!! Stop fucking crying, goddammit!" is absolutely superb.
Imagine being in the same hospital room with the guy who threw you out a window
Is there any man in REAL LIFE who could do the same thing like Welby does in this scene?
.
.
.
I don't think so.
Well, we'd all like to hope so, at least.
I have seen a video of a mother who forgave her son's killer and embraced him in open court. So you never know what humans are capable of my friend. Stay optimistic!
@@thekub32 Oh yeah, I think I have seen that too. Was it in a court where the killer was going out with handcuffs and the mother came up too him and embraced him?
@@framegenius9205 Yes that's the one.
@@thekub32 Awsome! I thought of that when I saw this scene :)
Sam Rockwell deserved this Oscar!!!!! Amazing!!!!!!!
Absolutely!
When Welby flicks the straw then carefully points in back towards Dixon...such a small gesture with so much meaning.
I fucking love this movie so much
One of the best scenes of 2017
If Welby wasn’t so hurt I’d hug his little sweet self.❤️
There are so many great "show don't tell" moments in this film, and I think this is one of the best.
I was properly afraid for Dixon when Welby found out it was him, I thought it was going to turn into like a huge fight or something and then…..a beautiful moment of humanity
Cohen brothers have given the seal of quality to this film!
Rodrigo RJ it’s not by them
What a scene, I was getting ready to gloat about Dickson and what he did to poor Red, but Red shows class and true human act, this is one of the best scenes ever, such a great movie.
men, I need more movie like this, give me some
Sam Rockwell and Caleb Landry Jones are hell of some actors
The Amazing scene that made me ship them. ♥♥
The complexity of these characters and their relationship is incredible.
I have no words to properly describe the greatness of this scene, performances and dialogues. 👏🔝
LOVE THIS MOVIE. 👏❤
LOVE THIS SCENE. 👏❤
LOVE REDXON. 👏👏💔💔❤❤🔥🔥
Didn't know what much to make of this movie, but that scene where he beat this kid was truly horrifying and this brought to tears to my eyes...
That scene was raw! You can tell Welby could not put up a fight, he was completely out-matched and vulnerable. This scene on the other hand... there so much into it, Welby's kindness is natural, is not into him to mistreat a wounded man and Dixon sure feels humiliated: he beat up a kid to near death for nonsensical reasons and Welby was too decent to act like he would if roles were inverted.
This scene is supposed to be comical at first, but then it gets emotional in the mid time
this became one of my movies. So beautiful, so graceful. Thank God I've watched it.
He turned the straw, man.
This was a really great movie. I got lost though - was Dixon gay? Willoughby’s letter said something about homophobia but I didn’t get whether that was implied towards Dixon or not.
No, he was a bigoted moron who FINALLY saw the light.
I on the other hand thought it was implied that Dixon was a latent homosexual, a frustrated man who hated himself and turned it into violence. Idk. That's just what I thought.
I haven’t heard any confirmation but i do think he is gay.Apart from Willoughby letters about homophobic things,Dixon’s verbal-abusive mother said in one scene “You’re going out with a girl?” In the intention of mockery,Dixon’s also replied coldly but accepting that statement.Which means probably Dixon is gay and his mother is being hard to him,but in the other hand he is just some bigoted moron lol.
Nah he says “arrest them for homophobia, wont they be surprised” meaning he’s a bigot who most likely hates gays. Hence the people being surprised he would take offense to homophobic behavior
He also invaded Red's space pretty much everytime he saw him. There was never any need to get as close as he did and I don't remember him doing that to anyone else, at least not to that extent. Also called Red gay while just moments before he was pressing up against him. Thought it was kind of implied but I wasn't sure.
Orange juice
Right about 2:10, that subtle head turn away was something that only the greats can pull off. Its seems like nothing to most, but it actually pulls on the emotional strings a bit harder with the sad but well timed music
When Sam Rockwell won the Oscar, he of course made the usual pitch asking viewers to see their film and that the film was all about compassion. As soon as he said, it was all about compassion My mind went to this scene. This poor kid who he had beaten the crap out of and pretty much almost killed him by throwing himout a window. By All rights he should’ve been arrested, but wasn’t. And yet this kid who still recovering from his injuries and has no reason to empathize with him. He is helping him drink orange juice. And it wasn’t until that scene that Sam Rockwell’s character realized how he’d been wasting his life with that my way or the highway BS. I think that’s the first time he started sympathizing with Mildred.
SPOILER ALERT
Could you please upload the scene in which Dixon reads the letter at the police station? And when he calls Mildred to tell her that the man was not her daughter's rapist but he knows where he lives?
The police station scene is very difficult to upload because it's heavily filled with copyright material. I have tried to edit it and everything but as long as the opera song is in there, it's hard. I can upload the other scene though. Thanks for the suggestions!
Master Epps Yeah
To think this kid gave Anton Chigurh his shirt after he got hit by a car kinda speaks to his character.
I was so scared that this might turn creepy because you're just waiting for him to take his revenge instead you get this. "stop fucking crying god damn it. The salt will just fuck up your wounds" why did that melt my heart?
Why the hell would they be put in the same hospital room?
This movie is just fucked up audience feelings,i can’t stop being surprised,excited,or extremely sad throughtout the films.This movie just fucking masterpiece
In any other movie - this scene would be the one where the "bad guy becomes the good guy" - bout time for Sam Fuckin' Rockwell
This movie astonished me, just finished 2nd watch - this is after binging on Pulp Fiction and GlenGarry Glenn Ross for a week with my friends and loved ones. 12mil budget, yeeesh......what can you say about Frances McDormand? She's the Sissy Spacek of my generation. Holds a special place in my heart as I spent six years in STL and Columbia and have been to dozens of places like Ebbing.
I'm the kind of guy who cries watching Rocky no matter how many times I've seen it - but this goes beyond sentimental, what a sensational way to bring about a character arc. And by that I mean not this scene by itself, but the movie as a whole. There are no "good" and "evil" characters (except for the creep rapist)
That Dixon was a character hiding inside of a rough exterior - I mean who listens to "Chuiquitita" or whatever? how torn up he was about WIllloughby, that he was transformed as a result of Willoughby's inherent sincerity and generosity, etc. etc.
God dammit this deserved best picture
YES 😭
I think this is a great scene but come on, how do these two people end up in a room together? The hospital obviously knows both their names. Are you telling me no one happened to watch the news and find out the name of the person who beat up Red? How to you put an abusee and their abuser in the same room together? How do you overlook that?
Anyone else think that there was something symbolic of the glass of orange juice being "half full", would be quite interesting to interject some the philosophy behind that at this point of the movie..
This scene made me laugh and cry at the same time, no seriously, I laughed and cried, not other movie could ever do that to me before.
Não me recordo de outro filme desta década ter um desenvolvimento de personagem, um arco dramático tão bem desenvolvido como este filme.
Overwhelming
He doesnt even have to tell anything. The glass was it. Wow.
That's forgiveness. I don't know that I'd have that in me in that situation.
Not enough oscars for this film
Absolutely 🎬🔝👏
I still get cold chills watching this in November of 2023,
"Three Billboards" ist einer meiner absoluten Lieblingsfilme und ich nutze diese Szene gerade für eine Predigt. Das wollte ich schon immer mal machen.
Did Welby forgive him?
My jaw was dropped throughout the film , especially in this scene.
The soundtrack it's wonderful.
The level of English used in the comments deserve an Oscar too
By far one of my favorite movies of all time
You can definitely tell this is Carter Burwell music. So much Coen Brothers inspiration.
I'm sorry Welby, that these windows look so poorly CGI'd
He's just sorry because in this moment, Welby can do whatever he wants. And there's nothing he can do to stop him.
Sam is The best i love this man
That's a wonderful scene!!!!
That scene OMGGGG
So beautiful
He's not a doctor, but his name sake played one on TV.
I think academy should add a category as best synced cast in a movie too
I know people can change but I'm just not buying his remorse for throwing him out a two story window.
yeas but it's a movie
Man did this scene make me tear up
:)
this was so powerful 😊
The power of forgiveness can never be forgotten
Because forgiving abusers works out great………They only understand one thing, payback.
Mr Wolf In Hospital
When you first see welby your like oh God he gonna do something horrible but no he was already forgiven....x x x x💛💙💜💚💔💕💓❤x x x x
I don't care, stop fucking crying goddamit!!!! And then he gives him juice, nobody does that.... Amazingly human moment, we need more people like him, really brave
Google: stop crying! The salt [in the tears] will mess up your wounds.
Me: I thought salt was supposed to be good for the wounds.
Google: what am I, a f***in’ doctor??
*all jokes aside, this was a sweet and touching scene
The behaviour the character uses with Sam reminded me to The republic of Platon, which he says "does an injustice to someone who made you a harm, it becomes the same person that someone is" or even it reminds me to Meditations of Marco Aurelio, where there is a thought which more o less says "the best vengeance against an enemy is to not be the same thing".
We all learned that violence begets violence from the smartest character in the movie who is cleverly made out to be a bimbo.
Not only dose violence begets violence…………mercy begets further mercy too.
Window kid forgave Dixon, and he I turn forgive the main character, the mother….
Sorry her name is escaping me now
A man, now you made me cry again.... Love this movie so much!
How can I watch the full movie?
Buy it
To all victims (especially by homophobic crimes) Sam Rockwell's warm eyesight melts their hurtful minds. I was the victim. So, thank you.
The Power of Forgiveness is always more powerful than that of violence ❤
See everybody people can change. Have a little faith.
Welby also plays the brother from get out and banshee from x men
I just watched this scene out of context and now really want to see this movie.
Why isn’t this movie on Netflix in Japan...