POPPY in Metal? Vocal analysis of Suffocate by Knocked loose
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ส.ค. 2024
- WTF is happening in this song though (Spoiler its dope as hell)
▼▼ Cool stuff below! ▼▼
Ready to start your metal vocal journey? Get screaming with my online course! Learn more at www.kardavoxac...
Want one-on-one private lessons? go to www.kardavoxac... to find out more!
Show your love of Harsh vocals with OFFICIAL Kardavox Academy merch! kardavoxacadem...
If you love these videos, head to PATREON - / kardavoxacademy to join our exclusive Discord server, get the inside track on upcoming content, exclusive access to hangouts, Kardavox Karaoke, and much more !!!!
Video Referenced: • Knocked Loose "Suffoca...
Want to hear my vocal work? Check out the links below!
We released a new song via Metal Blade Records!: • Kardashev - Compost Gr...
Kardashev on Spotify: open.spotify.c...
Kardashev: / kardashevband
Viraemia - Glioblastoma: • Viraemia - Glioblastom...
Neverbreath Album: • Neverbreath - To Defil... - บันเทิง
Start Screaming TODAY! www.kardavoxacademy.com - I've been a vocalist for nearly 15 years and can help you in one on one lessons or with our online course, "False Cord Fundamentals"! Listen to this sample of my students and hear for yourself! th-cam.com/play/PLUWlpPRyCEaZiPCurr6_lxxI1Y3qjB1-4.html
I don't often write comments directly to channels but you mentioned something about Poppy and black metal and just now I again came across this video of her with her favourite albums:
th-cam.com/video/zOzsteNBYNU/w-d-xo.html
Craft is a band mentioned so she just might accept if you reach out to her. She does love her collabs and trying new genres.
We can't expect them to add her as a permanent member but I think it's totally in line for us to ask for a " Popped Loose " EP with both of them going hard as fuck. Their synergy is just too fucking good .
I NEED Popped Loose!
That would SLAP!
I can only agree, they give off such pissed off little sister and big brother vibes, that ending with them together slaps so damn hard
It's unlikely we will get an EP with them as far as Bryan said in the interview with Nik, but this hopefully won't be their only feature together
I agree completely but Popped Loose has me dying 😂
this! a 15-20 min ep with her is all i want. especially because she also does weird stuff and production so that could maybe be also a part of it, not just singing. i would be absolutely down for it.
According to Brian this was Poppy’s idea. She asked them for the collaboration after Knocked Loose had finished the album.
where did you see that
@@kevenracanelli3091The interview he did with Nik Nocturnal.
She approached them, they were big fans of hers so bing bang boom
@@kevenracanelli3091the coolest part was they wrote this song the next day and recorded it to be a late addition to the album it wasn’t planned at all
не всем дано разбираться в сортах фекалий
The confused switch from "I'M GONNA POUND THIS PIT" to the "Dang that's kinda groovy" shoulder shimmy killed me
She sounds like Byrans little sister. Fits perfectly with the band.
THAT Poppy scream is legitimately one of the top 5 best I've ever heard in 20 years of listening to heavy music. Shit gave me chills the first time I heard it.
High praise!
Poppy and Bryan's voice compliments each other so well
I have chills everytime in that last part of them screaming together
I've seen a handful of reactions to this song and everyone's reaction to Poppy's scream after the reggaeton breakdown is gold. It's such a good scream.
It really is, I've listened to this song hundreds of times and it just came out... and I still get shivers at that scream.
I saw reggaeton and was like, WTF? Then I got to the breakdown, and instantly recognized the beat. 😂😂😂
Forget the bleghs and brees, that "AHHHHHH" is one of the best callouts I've heard in a LONG time
She has come so far with her screams, it's so impressive. She used to not be able to do them live, but every time I see her, I can HEAR all her growth 🖤
Brian said in an interview with Nik Nocturnal that they’ve been joking about doing a reggaeton breakdown for a while and they decided this song was the time to drop it.
"Poppy in metal" i mean she's been doing it since 2018. she's pretty metal if you ask me.
can't wait for the video
Her cover is Spit goes hard
That's not metal
Pop fans talk all the time about artists they feel are “pushing the boundaries” but I think none of them truly experiment and go beyond their comfort zones like poppy. And it sounds good. She literally always sounds good.
Myrkur is the only other kinda similar story.
That reggaeton breakdown hitting like a dominican house party
Can’t wait to hear that live on Tuesday 😂
*perrea in metal*
Possibly controversial opinion: Poppy is the most metal act in pop
Poppy feat Spiritbox would be a collision course waiting to happen.
@@DjDarkDI would die to have a collab with Spiritbox and Poppy, that legitimately sounds too good to be real
@@DjDarkD Yeah, she ws also great with Bad Omens, so Spiritbox would be amazing
Poppy covered Spit which is a song by Kittie.
@@EatABrickBigot Yeah, her album before her last one also had a lot of metal influenced screams. Spit was awesome.
You’re the only person I’ve seen/heard comment on the break in her big scream. It caught my ear too!
For me it’s the cherry on top. Probably my favorite part of any song I’ve heard this year. So good
@@evdboy2 It added such a unique and creepy layer to the end of that scream.
She does it very often and consistently in her own songs as well! And she even manages to do it amazingly live!
I caught it instantly. I've been listening to Poppy since she first hit the scene. I love that little aspiration is a little staple of hers I love.
@@deceiver8646 I found out she was in Atlanta one night a couple years ago. I found out at 5:00 PM that day and drove two hours to see her. I bought the ticket on the drive. So worth it.
As a fellow old, this band has me so fucking excited for the younger generation. This is the band that kids are going to emulate 10 years from now and I am here for it.
The way they incorporate the “Cumbia” rhythm is so good. The build up the the breakdown previews the groove. Then the breakdown hits fully. The post breakdown keeps the rhythm but instead of multiple notes, it’s a single chuggier version. And then they transition to the end of the song back to a more hardcore style rhythm.
This is why knocked loose are so great - they’re heavy and they’re angry, AND they’re great songwriters!
How is that even cumbia? If there was a delay in the snare then yeah, but there not delay so it’s not
Poppys been making metal for quite a while now.
LOL I thought the same thing. I actually found Poppy because of her more metal songs then went from there. Love all the mix of sounds and genres :)
@@TabbyWithMittens Basically same.
Her song with Bad Omens was pretty sick! She's based off a character a sketchy dude made up and already had a girl portraying the character then got into stuff with her then Poppy took the character over so that kind of made her not as appealing but she's a cool chick!
Not really. She's fake AF and made her fame by ruining Mars Argo's career
That's not metal
What's hilarious is that on his episode of hardlore, Isaac said that he can't stand reggaeton specifically bc they use that beat in every single song, and then they drop this the very next album cycle
Bryan also talks about this in the Nick Nocturnal interview
I'm Puerto Rican and can't stand it. But I'll take it in a metal song for a minute. 🤘
Your anime protagonist voice is scary good lol
You should really listen to some of Poppys other metal. It's amazing (and often very weird).
She did a great cover of "Spit" by Kittie, and her songs like "Flux", "Her" and "Say Cheese" I really like.
Some of her older metal she doesn't scream (that much) and it's way weirder.
"Fill The Crown" is kinda like black? I guess. And "Anything Like Me" is quite industrial.
bro did you just recommend flux and her? lmao wtf!!
@@TheBrandonn
It seems like it, doesn't it?
I do like Flux but I wouldn't say it's metal lol
@@chuksk8592 Fair, but her scream in it is quite metal-ish :P
I was a doubter years ago 😅 just couldn't get into Brian's vocals. A tear in the fabric of life changed that, now I'm a huge fan, even the stuff I didn't care for before. I'm just a big fan now.
I still cant stand his vocals but the music is getting to the point where its worth suffering through them to listen. Especially this song
Same here! A tear in the fabric of life settled the deal for me
They went reggaeton!! Even Bryan tweeted he had a laugh making it😂
Popped Loose
Underrated comment
Its awesome to see Poppy continuing her dominance, and seeing how many people are finally taking her seriously. She's a beast.
The fact she still has haters from metal elitists drives me wild, she’s proved herself 10 times over.
She steals her content. What did she do too Mars Argo? Poppy is a fraud
@@tiamodhow? Her voice is all auto tuned and she's just trying to copy Bryan here. There's nothing impressive here.
@@zachsumner1635 Saying she stole from Mars Argo makes no sense. Argo worked with Titanic. Then Poppy worked with him when Argo left. Like duh of course there’s gonna be similarities. That’s like saying someone joined a band and stole that band sound, duh, it’s the same band. Of course it’s gonna be similar. And whatever persona Argo had going was different from Poppy’s. Or different enough at least. Because Poppy did it way better. I don’t even have anything against Argo, but it’s true.
@@HeyIntegrity Okay? Most people can’t even scream like that, she can and she pulled it off. Ive seen her scream improve and get better over the years. It’s been a journey and she’s clearly improved. I’d like to see you do better? Maybe not impressive to you, but judging by the mostly positive reception, most people realize she’s come a long way, and those who don’t know her are digging it.
But yes, please impress me with your superior screams
Poppy fit so well into this song. Like she's been with them the whole time
Yoooo that reggaeton breakdown just bridged the gap between my wife and my music finally after 16 years
I can feel the rage and anguish of Poppy's scream in my spine.
Big brother little sister energy here. Love it
Its definitely reggeton. Bryan has spoke about it. It was the goal.
The song is dope. Favorite KL song so far.
Oh, if she legit joined the band. It would be epic.
Poppy did a song with HEALTH that has some more atmospheric screaming in it. It's mostly soft, haunting clean vocals, but the bridge has her doing screams that are longer and more sorrowful than what she's doing here and it's pushed a bit further back in the mix. I think it's great and could really go for a lot more of it.
I'd really like to hear Knocked Loose collab with some more female hardcore/metalcore vocalists because the two occasions they've done it (this and A Serpent's Touch w/ Emma from Dying Wish) have been stellar. There's just a slight difference in male and female vocals, even when doing the same style, that makes for great contrast.
Health introduce me to Poppy and Im a big fan of her since than. Dead Flowers always my most favourite song featuring Poppy, the scream man, thats is so damn good.
Poppy and Knocked Loose needs to become a regular thing. They are incredible together.
Poppy's scream right after the reggaeton breakdown is the most chill-inducing thing I've heard this year, it's so good....
That 10+ seconds of The Thinker pose at the end of the song was just Mark softly whispering into his head, "that was. so. fucking. hard bro...."
100%
I've been waiting for this notification
I gotchu boo!
Poppy is such a bizarre but intriguing person. She does do a fair amount of screaming in her solo stuff which might be a fun wormhole to go down…try X or Spit.
Incidentally, that was my exact experience with Knocked Loose lol. Obsessed now
I'm really digging what Poppy is doing these days
I love that you hear the bunta beat (reggaetón) earlier in the song for a bit when Byran and Poppy are singing together but then it becomes more prominent in the breakdown.
Me: holy shit! This is the guy in Kardashev? Instant subscribe. Dude, I do a vocal cover of "Compost Grave-Song" frequently on my drive to work. Huge fan.
Yo thank you so much for the love! Would love to hear that cover!
@@KardavoxAcademy Might have to join the academy first!
I LOVED this song! Their voices complement each other so well! I've been a fan of Poppy for years, and she's been doing more metal and screaming for some time now. I highly recommend you listen or react to more of her stuff, to start I would recommend the song "Say Cheese", from her 2021 EP "EAT", it's one of her heaviest. Greetings from Brazil!
Your reaction to the reggae breakdown was quality! Also love your deep dive into the vocal techniques very interesting to learn about:)
The fact that it was so off the wall yet worked so well was fuggin amazing
ok so I am a first time viewer, and you drop the ABSOLUTE BOMB on me that you're the vocalist for Kardashev?! Liminal Rite is one of the most underrated albums of the 2020's in general for me. I am so glad you are enjoying Knocked Loose, Suffocate is leading to be my favorite song of the year!
Ayo, that's me! THanks so much for the love and kind words about Liminal Rite! Next album is almost done!
Hopefully this will get more people to listen to her I Disagree album. Some really heavy shit in there. Girl can rock the fuck out
Omg 11:29 is EXACTLY what I did that just got me thank you for that
listen to Poppy's "Spit" by Kittie cover
Lmao I love how you went from headbanging to indian shoulder dance in a split second when the breakdown kicked in
I'm no musician, but as a music nerd I found this delightful. Your talk about mastery of technique and jaw tension reminds me of masterful drummers explaining how relaxed the most intense players tend to be
This has become a new favorite. Poppy's voice works so well with Bryan's. She'd fit right in.
I keep coming back to your reaction on this because I enjoy it sooo much. Poppy is killing it! Since you totally get her (her old stuff), I think you'll dig her doing Kittie's Spit too. In my opinion, it's better than the original. Enjoy & have a great week!
HAHA im from Puerto Rico 🇵🇷 and when i heard that breakdown i went craazy had ur same reaction just started to “perriar” with confusion and a face like it smelled like my work boots it was hard tho worked so welll🔥🔥 and then they downed the tempo to the same beat but reversed 🤢🤢🫠🫠🫠🫠🫠🫠🫠🫠🫠🫠 loved it and loved seeing u dancing! HAHA❤
Haha!
WELCOME ONBOARD MY GUY!!
Dawg you gotta listen to some more Poppy if nothing else just in your free time. She's been doing metal for like 5 years now, granted not all with screaming. But yeah she's awesome:)
So damn good. Their voices compliment each other so well.
Man love this video. The way u bring such joy in something thats really difficult for many people to approach is unique. Hope one day i’ll be able to get as many lessons it’s take with u.
Thanks for the kind words, I hope to see you in my classroom one day!
The fact you haven’t heard Poppy’s music is a crime. You would have a great time.
Well, sounds like I'll have to get to it!
They sound so fcking good together. Im obsessed
I'll show this video to anyone who says poppy's technique isnt good/is hurting her.
man, poppy is killing it lately. im starting to like her more and more
I gotta start with a “thank you” to Poppy, who has 3M subs on TH-cam music compared to knocked loose with barely 30K. She may have just put KL on the radar of a bunch of people who’s didn’t know the band existed.
Great song, I like the steady fast paced stuff better, but really good. Most anticipated album after Benighted.
Its true i didnt even know who knocked loose were and thought they were some nobodies and apparently everyone is expecting their album impatiently
Idk how many hardcore Poppy fans would actually like knocked loose though. I'd say the ones who do, already liked KL before the feature with her.
@setoburu Lol "a bunch of nobodies" I can guarantee you most Knocked Loose fans feel the same way about Poppy. I've never heard of her before this song. You act like she's some huge figure. Her screams are trash too. So many more talented female metal vocalists out there than whatever that garbage was.
@Brandon-bc5um Poppy is way overhyped on this track lol. Props to her for doing it, but it's really not that good.
@@TheBrandonn Poppy is why I checked out Knocked Loose. Now I love Knocked Loose! I'm willing to bet we are many
Lmfao couldn't stop laughing at your confused dancing on the breakdown. Great laugh to start the morning thanks.
Also 100% agreed with you on Hereditary. One of the best horror films ever made, the acting in it is phenomenal.
i love knocked loose!! and poppy is my favorite!! she’s generally post-genre so perhaps that would explain the breakdown 😝
First vid of yours I’ve watched but that bad anime protagonist vo was so fucking spot on 🤣🤣🤣
IF you want to hear her metal listen to her I DISAGREE album, her EAT EP and last but not least her SPIT cover. She can do nice pop music too surprisingly! but her metal is where its at!
This song is so brutal!! Good for both of them knocking this out of the park !!
I would love for more Knocked Loose and Poppy - Her vocals mesh so well with Brain's!
Great reaction vid BTW 👌
Thanks for watching!
Hahaha the head bang into confusion during the breakdown was comedy
Haha, thanks for watching!
You're the only one I've seen pick up that small whine at the end of Poppy's longer sustained scream. I heard it on the first listen and was like, "ffffffffffuh....😮". You got a new subscriber my dude. 👍👍
Hell yeah, I'm glad you noticed it too!
Check out her Eat EP for more Poppy screams! Its one of her best projects.
your reaction is great haha I guess the reggae didnt catch me off guard because im so used to poppy doing weird ass things in her music. (been a fan since 2016)
Honestly never got the hate for Bryan's voice, he sounds like with roots above Mike Hranica of TDWP
Its god awful. It sounds like spongebob squarepants
I didn't like it at first. It's very abrasive. I really like his screams now, but I understand how someone might not enjoy it.
Aw, the shout out to the Elotes man. Glad you experienced some latin flavor in both music and food in your life. That was definitely a reggaeton beat. 🙌
She delivered perfectly for this song. I was astounded by her voice here
I can imagine the crowd going wild during their live performances🔥 Btw I can't wait to see your genuine reaction to Nick Thurl Mavromatis' new song 🤘
i love your comments about Poppy. people keep saying she lip syncs at live shows but clearly she is a great singer. she has a signature scream now. at the very end she does a whine or something like that i love it.
I love how you quoted the first lines of psychosocial to demonstrate pitched screams lol
Haha, a classic!
You aren't wrong that is definitely reggaeton beat and i fucking love that they managed to do that
Hell yeah, me too!
11:27 i lost it when he just felt it in his body LOL
I have "Holy Roller" Vibes on that with a diffrent Theme and crushed in U´r face from Twins shouting out about experience with false PPL.
As Drummer I wonder why nobody get the change from the Snare after Poppy`s "Suffocate" into "Metalic" sound........
I love that so hard!
Poppy is so cool. Her enthusiasm with metal is so real, and this cannot be said about all pop/rap artists that have been influenced by metal.
This is the first video I see from you, so Idk how any of this works, but I'd love to hear your thoughts about Banshee. She's an independent alternative artist and her musical roots are in metal. Lamb of God and Arch Enemy are her biggest inspirations, she used Melissa Cross's videos to learn how to scream and her music, which she describes as "fairy metal" is a combination of black metal, trap, witch house and hyperpop. I think she's gonna be the inspiration for many female metal vocalists in the future and that she has had and continues to have a true impact on the underground metal scene.
For context, I just turned 32 and have been a metalhead since I was 11. I live in Finland.
Sounds like a cool recommendation, I'll have to check her out!
KL have been so surprisingly consistent. They will be remembered. And I knew Poppy was down with heavier stuff...but KL?? And she went all in. So good.
I'm sure since this is over a month old now you probably won't see this, but you should check out 156/Silence if you haven't. I think if you dig hardcore stuff like this you'd love them. I listen to mostly deathcore/death metal, but they're a hardcore band that I'll listen to for days at a time sometimes. Super underrated and amazing all around.
This video was an absolute delight! And yes, that was reggaeton :)
Best cameo in a song ever. Pearler of a track. That scream from Poppy at the end. 😮 Visceral.
The Regi breakdown is fire
Its so good
The best part of this video is Brian dancing to that Reggae tone beat
We’re going POPPED LOOSE MADEFAKA!!🔥🔥🔥
First video ive seen of yours and love the way you break down the vocals, you should check out chatpile, theyre an incredible sludge metal band that have some unhinged vocals
100% would back Poppy as a permanent member of Knocked Loose. Probably more likely to, at most, just be a repeat collaborator though -- in that scenario maybe they even lean into the meme and release stuff/tour as Popped Loose lol
Oh my Gosh... That Poppy's scream sounds like a witch in the middle of the Forest chasing you. 11:37
Her scream gives to you the necessary power to lift heavy weight in bench press.
I got to finally see these guys last night in Seattle. they were insane.
that technique you mentioned around 16:30 where she drops the grittiness off at the end of a scream is really neat, and the singer for Silent Planet does it a LOT.
Yeah Garrett is an absolute master of blending in the whimper of his voice with his frys, his ability to add and remove distortion at will is masterful. Brian from Currents does it a lot too but with a false chord/hybrid technique.
You’re from Kardashev?
Bruh I just got done listening to the Progression EP in my car one of my favorite collections
Yes I am, yo thanks for listening and supporting!
i think it would be very worth it to check out more poppy, for example her song "spit" is also on the heavier side
Yesss!! I was hoping for this song!
I love this song. I've liked Knocked Loose since GARYYYYYYYYYYY. He's one of the only true male high tenors who is screaming successfully and healthily in my opinion. The only criticism I can say is that from what I have seen, Poppy isn't really killing her vocals live yet and I think there is quite a bit of editing and effects on her recorded vocals. A lot of other people say she usually brings it live so I'm not sure what the deal is at the moment. I second that Poppy and them should join up more permanently or semi-permanently side project type thing. 100%
Best song of the year so far 🔥🔥🔥
Just saw them on Saturday at sick new world and THEY BROUGHT POPPY OUT! It was so dope 🤘🤘😝😝😝
OH, that would have been sick!
I think im the only person who isn’t a fan of poppy..I saw this and thought eyeroll...but I was super surprised. I like how she compliments Bryan. She really showed out and killed it. Im freaking beyond excited for their new album.
i like people noticing the latin beat breakdown, but another thing that's really cool is the dance beat on drums beforehand. it's the same sort of thing on The Wretchedness Inside by Trivium.
So Converge... And i love it!
Poppy's scream at the end of the breakdown gives me goosebumps
Never been happier