@@elizabethgately3976 we'll for one... Minorities have spent decades trying to be seen as just another citizen. "I look to a day when people will not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character"- Martin Luther King, Jr. Now progressives claim people are defined by their skin color, gender and so on. Literally judging people by their skin color. It's absolutely racist and sexist. I don't need progressives telling me I'm "X" because of my skin color any more than I need racist bigots telling me I'm "X" because of my skin color.
@@Coldrin6 That's... Not how any of this works. Modern progressives aren't judging people based on any of these factors, they simply draw attention to them because the difficulties those people face are more subtle than they used to be. Segregation is, legally speaking, not allowed, as an example, but limited financial mobility and other factors have led to population density maps remaining effectively unchanged even in some major cities.
"I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character." When did we forgot this?
"I have a dream that my four little gender fluid children will one day live in a nation where they *will be* judged by the color of their skin, their gender, and by their sexual preferences, not by the content of their character."
Mmmm, not so sure about that. MLK Jr. was the closest thing we had to a unifying leader in our history. His movement correctly identified the problem with this country, and that is the problem of poverty. He welcomed all types of people into his movement, intersectionality wasn't a thing, it was about the haves and have-nots. That's the true root of the problem, remove poverty and suddenly all of the other problems vanish. How to address poverty is a completely different and complex question with as many potential answers as to how to skin a cat.
Should we feel bad for her? Either she is very charismatic and can pretend to sound gentle and nice. Or she is gentle and nice? Or am I stupid? I'm just pointing out that this girl probably got tricked into believing in SJW propoganda and thought with the best of intentions that intersectionality was a good thing.
Do you think the SJWs tricked her, like they do most people? This woman sound like she is a nice person but the issue is she thinks traits out of human control define who you are, something progressives tell people are more important than who they are.
I agree somewhat. If you are using intersectionality as a means to not be prejudiced or biased against another group of people then i think everyone can agree on that point. Unfortunately, it has been used as a vessel for people to influence the laws and morals of a society based on group affiliation. This ideology goes hand in hand with subjectivism and moral relativism in that our value and meaning are only as good as the group that we belong to and the groups we place others in or worse, whatever the majority decides. This will inevitably lead to bloodshed. The core of any civilization and particularly in the west is that our meaning and value transcends the lenses and the views of the people around us. Meaning that I nor any other human being has the right to determine the worth of someone based on their group identity regardless of how well meaning we are or how much we want equity. Why is it wrong to kill people, why is it wrong to steal from others, why is it wrong to hurt one another? Because we have to believe in the value of human life, decency, ingenuity, and prosperity. Otherwise whenever we decide the values and rights of groups overrule the individuals in them, it becomes rather easy to sacrifice 10, 100, 1000, or 1,000,000 just to achieve an ideal. You don't have to take my word for it just look at recent history aka China, Russia, Venezuela, Cambodia, Germany circa 1939, Italy, and yes even the United States.
To progressives you are only as important as the victim groups you belong to...and how many there are. Victimization becomes social and political currency.
This is ignorant, what happened to be an individual. Now everybody wants a label! "Pay attention TO ME I'm special!" SHE DID IT FOR THE LULZ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
The smallest minority is the individual. Protecting the individuals rights is the only way to guarantee justice, tell unique and compelling stories and not spout endlessly politically divisive nonsense.
@@blzahz7633 Intersectionality promotes interconnectedness and to unite people of differences together. Don't you think they are trying to fight for individual rights and freedoms since many kinds of race and genders are not subjected to equal individual rights?
@@junkim5853 _"Intersectionality promotes interconnectedness and to unite people of differences together."_ Apparently not. _"Don't you think they are trying to fight for individual rights and freedoms since many kinds of race and genders are not subjected to equal individual rights?"_ No, I don't think they are trying to fight for individual rights and freedoms - the results speak for themselves. I don't care what they "say" they are doing, I'm only interested what they are *actually doing* - which hurting everyone, including themselves. I don't trust words, I trust actions. Also: _"Many kinds of race and genders are not subjected to equal individual rights"_ Think about that sentence for a bit - if that is the premise they operate from, you should know they can't do anything else but fail.
@@AVAL2775 So you're happy to remain the aforementioned child? It's rare that people admit their faults and ironically I can respect that, in a way lol.
@@AVAL2775 There is a difference between courtesy and respect. While I would agree that everyone deserves a baseline of courtesy, very FEW people are deserving of respect. Courtesy: The showing of politeness in one's attitude and behavior toward others. Respect: A feeling of deep admiration for someone or something elicited by their abilities, qualities, or achievements. The problem is that people seem to think they are entitled to admiration regardless of their abilities, qualities or achievements...
@@russiane.lection-hacker2057 How is this not a "political statement?" [in reference to you earlier comment to @Illusionist Kyouko: "That's an interesting statement. Where do you believe I mentioned politics?"]
when you are oppressed because of your identity by literally our own government but it's marginalized by people who don't actually know what it's like.
I'm just going to say one thing: to be intersectional means you are NOT defined by one word. You are part of many groups. To the people who are saying this is a division: this is not a division. In fact, having many facets of your identity is true for everyone, and they are all important. Saying that one group defines you is not a true statement for a lot of people.
Lethe, I also appreciate your response. Intersectionality is about the multifaceted nature of being human. As such, it applies to virtually all people when we discover what lies beneath the surface of the persona images (social faces) that people generally allow others to see. Even privileged white, heterosexual males.
@@AVAL2775 Her arguments are so ludicrous, and have been addressed multiple times in other comments on this page, and all we get is NPC responses with no coherent logic, so why bother?
@@AVAL2775 She doesn't have any arguements, she has PC soundbites, hackneyed and discredited stereotypes, and victim narratives, having nothing to do with reality.
I'm a gay Mexican and I find the idea that there HAS to be a gay Mexican for the sake of diversity a bad thing. A movie like Love Simon made me wish the movie came out when I was in high school so it could help with my sexuality. I did not care that the main character wasn't Mexican because I wasn't relating to that, I was relating to what I felt in high school. This is just plain stupid and redundant.
Respect is earned not given. It’s not a fiat currency that is just given to everyone because they simply exist. If you just randomly respect everyone, it loses its value and is worthless. The only thing you are entitled to is common decency, that’s it.
@@aurenkleige True, but its still at least offered until one shows them self to be a "MORON, FUCKING MORON" (not calling *you* a moron, just in case it seems that way). The first is given and lost, the other is earned and hard to lose (typically). At least that's now I see it.
Yeah, I'd be careful with that statement. There are quite a few lesbians that still had children, either by "biting the bullet" and fucking with a man or by just having a sperm donor and getting an IV fertilization.
I am *HUMAN*. Basic stuff you guys seem to have forgotten, I (and I bet other people too) don't really give a shit about what, where or who you are. Live, I'll live and don't force your way of living on me, the end.
The one word to complete the sentence "I am ..." is, simply, "me". I am me. YOU, are a caricature of a human being, a non-player character composed of certain attributes.
thank you. I am doing a social work assignment at uni involving intersectionality, and your video is the clearest one I found that explains it in a way I understand.
I feel kinda bad for her, i dont think she has the capacity to understand how wrong she is. They brain washed her for years probably in a bubble on a campus and she never considered that it could be lies. Lies to serve someone elses agenda. You know thats true because common sense and logic wont lead you to such ridiculous ideas. Must be weird
Shouldn't you have referred to females as womxn in this video given that some factions of intersectional feminism now claim this is how they should be addressed? Is it that you are excluding womxn or that intersectional feminism can't agree on definition of female.... er sorry...femxle.?
You know, I am a white man, I am not really poor so I won't have problems getting in the upper middle class, so I guess I'm privileged, but what is about my privilege for being pretty? Where's my intelligence privilege? I have serious concerns that this intersectionality thing just leads us (or better, you) down the wrong way. And by the way, I don't have to respect you. You can loose my respect for you entirely based on what you say to me or what I hear you saing to others. So if you wanna be respected, you gotta respect everyone else too (even those who don't buy into your interesectionality. Because no one wants to get instructed by someome who has got successfull with their minority passport)
Jole Schütz Agreed. Funny how the "goal" of this is to bring people together yet they can't that they're in fact creating more barriers between people. I don't care what you are so long as we don't actively try to harm one another I think we'll be ok. By harm I mean with physical and potentially lethal violence. Being "triggered" isn't the same as suffering from violence
@@000Dragon50000 Vinyl defended intersectionality by saying it's "honoring the experiences". Did they not? Intersectionality assumes someones experience based on innate characteristics. You might not agree with my opinion, but claiming it's "got nothing to do with..." is false.
At this point the fact this girl is Chinese cancels out the fact that she's a lesbian. Chinese are a privileged group where I live. Not being privileged in her case is still more privileged than the other marginalized groups she's talking about... She should stop talking and apologize right now...
The problem with intersectionality is that it assumes victimhood. It does not take into account the positive factors that those same people may possess. For example beauty, talent, the status of family and friends, wealth, education, profession, etc. Beyonce' is a black woman. According to intersectional rules, she is a victim. But she is a beautiful, talented, rich, celebrity. Does anyone think that her life suffers from negative intersectional bias? In fact, I would say that as of 2020 no beautiful, rich, or talented woman does.
Population of Black Women in USA = +21.7 Million. No. of Beyonce(s) = 1 See, the idea of victimhood is misleading. Intersectionality is more about being mindful of other people and their identities and not discriminating them for them. People are not claiming free health insurance because they are intersectional. They are expecting an open, safe, and accepting world. I don't see a problem with that Bill. Peace!
@@MegaAadhar And I see no problem whatsoever with your consept of intersectionality. But as with many other things today "intersectionality" is being used to drive a Marxist aganda nationwide. It is being used to seperate us into tribes. It is being used in a classic devide and conquer fashon. Marxists always devide. In Europe they focused on class warefare. Here they have focused on race primarily and included pretty much everything else. E pluribus unum means out of the many, one. But intersectionality is being used as a tool to seperate the one into many manageable sections. Be well Mega. Peace and love!
I'm sure glad your, intersectional lesbian immigrant "oppression" made it to TH-cam. You are awesome for intersectionalizing. I'm sorry, but Asian immigrant homosexual is not inclusive enough, it's totally 2017'ish.
I kinda thought Asians were getting lumped in with whites in this iteration of the race wars? Maybe I'm not caught up? Or is it only those Asians who aren't cishet? I swear, I can't keep up with who I'm supposed to be oppressing these days. If anyone could forward the memo that covers this, that'd be great. 😥😂
@John G Didn't you know just by posting here you are oppressing her? I don't know how but if she could respond I am sure that is what she would say to us! lol
Yes it's basically asking oneself--how many ways am I a victim, and then expecting everybody else to give you all kinds of special treatment so that you don't have to ever face challenges in life and learn how to overcome them. Instead of teaching people ways to identify in which way they are victims of so-called "privileged" people, why not teach people about things like COMPASSION, EMPATHY, SHARING, KINDNESS.
Nothing helps defeating imaginary oppressive forces like dividing minorities into even smaller groups. I TOTALLY see that helping minority communities handling ACTUAL oppression.
I look really white but by birth I am linked to the First Nations of the town I was born in. My great , great, great grandfather was the leader of the First Nations and the town I was raised in is actually named after him. My adopted Father was Korean and his name by birth is my middle name, Hanju. When he came to Canada in the 1950s, immigration officials misheard his name and recorded it as Han Choo. He never corrected them… in the 1990s he had made contact with family in North Korea, and we’d get letters addressed to Hanju Lee, and Mum asked why, and Dad shared the story that it was his birth name, and the government of Canada recorded it wrong. My middle name was actually Robert Han, and I had it changed to just Hanju, to correct the mistake and so his name would live on through me. I also identify as non-binary / genderqueer. My pronouns are they / them / their. I came out demipansexual in 2020. Pansexual fit who I am perfectly as a terminology, and I recognize it as being under the bisexual umbrella. In grades 7-10 I was bullied horribly, and in grades 11-12, didn’t really have any close friends as to get the bullying to stop, they threatened to sue the school and the district. The school put out an edict that anyone bullying me would be expelled from the district. So the bullying stopped but in some ways I ended up preferring the negative attention to no attention. It’s been something that’s hindered me my whole life, I still have trust issues and difficulties making friends today.
Just because you're gay or you Asian doesn't make you special what makes you special is what you do in life good or bad doesn't make you better than anyone else if you're gay the only makes you look like you're playing the victim when people can't get out and you don't like the opinions stop playing the victim
I understand why this video has so many dislikes while she obviously did a great job at explaining all these serious issues on a light note. It is because most people prefer to be ignorant when they are privileged in their respective societies. It is important to understand that intersections here represent the myriad of oppression, and discrimination one can face by just belonging to any labeled 'artficial' category. At the same time, it is rather offensive to not see humans as humans. Her example of Moonlight clearly represents how underrepresented the black community is within Hollywood. If they don't want to put an effort into a character, make them black, or gay, or both, because the minority becomes the center of the joke to entertain privileged people who spend money for cheap laughs. I am glad I am settled in the east. As an Indian we still suffer from the same standards imposed by outsiders who firmly believed that our culture and religion needs to be 'fixed'. Each intersection comes with a predefined stereotype widely accepted by the majority and they will boldly judge and oppress because privilege is a fragile thing, today is, tomorrow not.
I get it that one would want to put up a defense if one feels marginalized, but if the defense is to marginalize other groups, what's the point? As soon as you say you've been discriminated against by another group, you're betraying a prejudice against that group that will marginalize individual humans who just happen to be members of that group. If you defend yourself by saying ALL members of that group behave that way, you're doing exactly what you claim they do.
You are promoting a harmful ideology; not all Chinese people are the same, not all Chinese lesbians are the same, not all Chinese lesbian immigrants are the same. People don't have common experiences because they share a race, sexuality, nationality, and so on. How about we treat each other as individuals with a modicum of decency, instead of NPCs that must march to some prescripted behaviors...
You have just been Undoomed! Muahahahha. And, I'm not going to get into a whole debate over everything. But with your "Respect" thing. Either you earn my respect or don't. It's not granted. And I'm not under any obligation to want to or have to learn about any of this. It's all nonsense. You are an individual and these are just your traits. You don't need to make it more complicated than that. Stop trying to shove everyone into a category. That's part of the issue! Let people be seen as just there individual selves and nothing more.
Not sure what you mean by 'respect'. I think by 'respect' she just means treating people with tolerance/politeness/decency/kindness. That's how I define 'respect'. And I assume that's what she meant too. Like a "I may not understand why an Asian lesbian immigrant is doing this video but I respect your right to do it." Just like you may say something like, "I may not understand your choice to have an open relationship, but I respect your right to do it." Or like we may say "Don't be an asshole. Treat people with some respect. Have some respect." That sort of thing. Also, I don't think intersectionality is about diminishing the importance of individuality. It's just about seeing that people struggle with different things. For example you may meet a person who's really really good looking, and you feel jealous and you feel they have a lot of privilege. But then you find out they're really really poor. So now they're not as privileged as you thought they were.
So basically, we need stories about characters representing these groups. More and more and more. Forget about character complexity, philosophy, principles, and values. As long as they check the boxes of marginalized groups, then that's all that matters. Worked so well for the comic industry.
Why is it necessary for there to be more intersectional movies like Moonlight? You make it sound as though the quality of the story is secondary to a movie being representative of certain demographics.
As a non American this concept of intersectionality is so flawed. why can't be as a society just encourage kindness, and respecting people and leaving them be. Instead we have this system of labelling victim cards and stacking them together for moral points. You realise this is just scoring people objectively for social credit. Not much different from the authoritative Chinese government policies. Not trying to spew hate but hear me out. Maybe pursue an actual crime for being a crime. Also, can't we just accept that we as humans do judge the unfamiliar, and socially are more accepting of people similar to ourselves? No I think the way to solve this is just to encourage respect for one another. Not some arbitrary law or social construct to make us feel morally superior. Shit happens to people. Guess what, for the majority of humankind people have always been fighting for dominance, socially, through wars, etc. Just be more accepting. Stop focusing so much on victimhood, start trying to live a better life
Honestly, Americans have been doing that for centuries. Ignoring the victims and cancelling out cultures. Our history books don't tell the history of Black people as they attributed to our society, we built a white supremacist nation, we created "conversion therapy" to "fix" our gays. We tried our damnest to snuff out the "weird" and make "white and straight" normal, so much so that even the LGBTQ+ community was convinced they were "weird". The fact that we even HAVE this term is a step forward. Representation matters, especially when a nation has so many oppressed and systematically marginalized people, specifically BIPOC (Black, Indigenous, People of Color).
How about the Central and South Asian people who don't have 'small eyes'? Just because they don't have small eyes, shall we consider creating a new continent or "Big Eye Asians"? :P
Just to note outside myself and I see a few others. Undoomed just tore down this video. Which means by this time tomorrow you are gonna be flooded with messages attacking your nonsense. R.I.P video! You deserve it though.
Intersectionality fails because it violates the fundamental bedrock of enlightenment values: Prioritizing the individual. It is not WHAT you are, it is WHO you are; and whatisms should play no significant role in determining WHO you are as an individual. Whereas intersectionality puts ALL the emphasis on these things, and as such, is not only counter-enlightenment, but is by definition, illiberal.
Who else is here thanks to Undoomed?
Red 6 standing by.
Charlie in the rear waiting to launch!
Opinionated Asshole With A Giant Penis And A Big Tiddy Goth Gf online and awaiting orders!
Yeah but i dont watch him
SCV reporting for duty
As a member of a minority I think this philosophy is poison.
why? Curious
@@elizabethgately3976 we'll for one... Minorities have spent decades trying to be seen as just another citizen. "I look to a day when people will not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character"- Martin Luther King, Jr.
Now progressives claim people are defined by their skin color, gender and so on. Literally judging people by their skin color.
It's absolutely racist and sexist.
I don't need progressives telling me I'm "X" because of my skin color any more than I need racist bigots telling me I'm "X" because of my skin color.
Intersectionality happens when it is more important to hate the victimizers than love the victims.
@@Coldrin6 That's... Not how any of this works.
Modern progressives aren't judging people based on any of these factors, they simply draw attention to them because the difficulties those people face are more subtle than they used to be. Segregation is, legally speaking, not allowed, as an example, but limited financial mobility and other factors have led to population density maps remaining effectively unchanged even in some major cities.
@Guss Ruffee communism = progressive
How do we get rid of this cancer?
"I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character."
When did we forgot this?
"I have a dream that my four little gender fluid children will one day live in a nation where they *will be* judged by the color of their skin, their gender, and by their sexual preferences, not by the content of their character."
About 5 seconds after he said it.
Mmmm, not so sure about that. MLK Jr. was the closest thing we had to a unifying leader in our history. His movement correctly identified the problem with this country, and that is the problem of poverty. He welcomed all types of people into his movement, intersectionality wasn't a thing, it was about the haves and have-nots. That's the true root of the problem, remove poverty and suddenly all of the other problems vanish. How to address poverty is a completely different and complex question with as many potential answers as to how to skin a cat.
@Phillip Scott And your point is that since poverty is relative it shouldn't be addressed at all?
The point of this video is lost on the OP
I notice she is basically saying she cant empathize with anyone who isn't exactly like herself.
Dez Wong yep, pretty progressive, innit?
Dez Wong if she live in China then wold have 1,5 billion people to empathize with but in China she with this ideas would be killed.
Should we feel bad for her? Either she is very charismatic and can pretend to sound gentle and nice. Or she is gentle and nice? Or am I stupid? I'm just pointing out that this girl probably got tricked into believing in SJW propoganda and thought with the best of intentions that intersectionality was a good thing.
What is she saying? I thought this was a petition to make more gay/lesbian movies.
Expressing no empathy is one of the symptoms of psychopath.
You define yourself according to immutable characteristics rather than what makes you an unique person. I feel tremendous pity for you.
Do you think the SJWs tricked her, like they do most people? This woman sound like she is a nice person but the issue is she thinks traits out of human control define who you are, something progressives tell people are more important than who they are.
We define ourselves by the way that other people perceive us and treat us, unfortunately.
They're commies. They hate the individual.
This video is extremely offensive.
AdamEater clearly, then, your white cishet privileged offense doesn't matter
@@bchin4005 You're a dumbass.
@megapowers I don't see how he is a dumbass he was simply making a joke.
@@Megapowers-xy6xv r/woooooosh
@@Megapowers-xy6xv r/quityourbullshit
I think this is nonsense. We need to look at people as individuals and not this group or that group.
I agree somewhat. If you are using intersectionality as a means to not be prejudiced or biased against another group of people then i think everyone can agree on that point. Unfortunately, it has been used as a vessel for people to influence the laws and morals of a society based on group affiliation. This ideology goes hand in hand with subjectivism and moral relativism in that our value and meaning are only as good as the group that we belong to and the groups we place others in or worse, whatever the majority decides. This will inevitably lead to bloodshed. The core of any civilization and particularly in the west is that our meaning and value transcends the lenses and the views of the people around us. Meaning that I nor any other human being has the right to determine the worth of someone based on their group identity regardless of how well meaning we are or how much we want equity. Why is it wrong to kill people, why is it wrong to steal from others, why is it wrong to hurt one another? Because we have to believe in the value of human life, decency, ingenuity, and prosperity. Otherwise whenever we decide the values and rights of groups overrule the individuals in them, it becomes rather easy to sacrifice 10, 100, 1000, or 1,000,000 just to achieve an ideal. You don't have to take my word for it just look at recent history aka China, Russia, Venezuela, Cambodia, Germany circa 1939, Italy, and yes even the United States.
Unfortunately this isn't the world we live in. If it was there wouldn't be thousands of videos educating us.
you mean indoctrinating not educating
To progressives you are only as important as the victim groups you belong to...and how many there are. Victimization becomes social and political currency.
Hold up! I'm a progressives. I don't play this dumb victim BS like in this video. These are not progressives, these are extremist!
This is ignorant, what happened to be an individual. Now everybody wants a label! "Pay attention TO ME I'm special!" SHE DID IT FOR THE LULZ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I think you missed the point entirely
The smallest minority is the individual. Protecting the individuals rights is the only way to guarantee justice, tell unique and compelling stories and not spout endlessly politically divisive nonsense.
Well said.
@@blzahz7633 Intersectionality promotes interconnectedness and to unite people of differences together. Don't you think they are trying to fight for individual rights and freedoms since many kinds of race and genders are not subjected to equal individual rights?
@@junkim5853
_"Intersectionality promotes interconnectedness and to unite people of differences together."_
Apparently not.
_"Don't you think they are trying to fight for individual rights and freedoms since many kinds of race and genders are not subjected to equal individual rights?"_
No, I don't think they are trying to fight for individual rights and freedoms - the results speak for themselves. I don't care what they "say" they are doing, I'm only interested what they are *actually doing* - which hurting everyone, including themselves. I don't trust words, I trust actions.
Also: _"Many kinds of race and genders are not subjected to equal individual rights"_ Think about that sentence for a bit - if that is the premise they operate from, you should know they can't do anything else but fail.
here we go, another individual
The perfect video for entitled women to get whatever they want for free? Earn your respect or continue to be treated like a child, your choice.
everyone deserves alittle respect as humans
@@AVAL2775 So you're happy to remain the aforementioned child? It's rare that people admit their faults and ironically I can respect that, in a way lol.
@@AVAL2775 no. No they do not.
UndertaleSkeleBros Respect is earned, not given on a silver platter. Those who demand respect are the least deserving of it.
@@AVAL2775 There is a difference between courtesy and respect. While I would agree that everyone deserves a baseline of courtesy, very FEW people are deserving of respect.
Courtesy: The showing of politeness in one's attitude and behavior toward others.
Respect: A feeling of deep admiration for someone or something elicited by their abilities, qualities, or achievements.
The problem is that people seem to think they are entitled to admiration regardless of their abilities, qualities or achievements...
This is so poorly thought out
Rational thought played no role in this.
I think you're giving too much credit by implying any thought went into it at all.
@@russiane.lection-hacker2057 How is this not a "political statement?"
[in reference to you earlier comment to @Illusionist Kyouko: "That's an interesting statement. Where do you believe I mentioned politics?"]
When you want to be oppressed so badly.
when you are oppressed because of your identity by literally our own government but it's marginalized by people who don't actually know what it's like.
Camille know what what’s like?
@@lethe9705 no government in western culture is oppressing non-white people.
@@shaquilleharvey6063 i do, actually :)
@@zeenuf00 I didn't say we shouldn't have a government. I said that the government is oppressive.
I'm just going to say one thing: to be intersectional means you are NOT defined by one word. You are part of many groups. To the people who are saying this is a division: this is not a division. In fact, having many facets of your identity is true for everyone, and they are all important. Saying that one group defines you is not a true statement for a lot of people.
THANK YOU. this comment section is exhausting
Lethe, I also appreciate your response. Intersectionality is about the multifaceted nature of being human. As such, it applies to virtually all people when we discover what lies beneath the surface of the persona images (social faces) that people generally allow others to see. Even privileged white, heterosexual males.
Intersectionality leads to people who C.an't U.nderstand N.ormal T.hought.
chris don she’s definitely a “C U Next Tuesday” sort of idiot.
She C ould U se N eurological T reatment perhaps?
how about actually adressing her arguements?
@@AVAL2775 Her arguments are so ludicrous, and have been addressed multiple times in other comments on this page, and all we get is NPC responses with no coherent logic, so why bother?
@@AVAL2775 She doesn't have any arguements, she has PC soundbites, hackneyed and discredited stereotypes, and victim narratives, having nothing to do with reality.
Remember to rotate you phaser settings when she adapts.
Set phasers to shake and bake!
That is one of the best lines I have heard Thanks
Black, seriously, that was so fuckin hilarious my brain shut off 🤣 it took half a second to sink in. Brilliant
I'm a gay Mexican and I find the idea that there HAS to be a gay Mexican for the sake of diversity a bad thing. A movie like Love Simon made me wish the movie came out when I was in high school so it could help with my sexuality. I did not care that the main character wasn't Mexican because I wasn't relating to that, I was relating to what I felt in high school. This is just plain stupid and redundant.
i agree, the idea of forced diversity is silly
character first, then traits
@@AVAL2775 that is impossible. Only forced diversity matter. Story? What's that?
Researching intersectionalty is like researching flat earth
That's if research means watching TH-cam videos.
it turns out the earth is round but the universe is flat.
Respect is earned not given. It’s not a fiat currency that is just given to everyone because they simply exist. If you just randomly respect everyone, it loses its value and is worthless. The only thing you are entitled to is common decency, that’s it.
Cass Larsen subtleties and nuance are lost on the ideologues
Meh, I'd say common decency is an entitlement easily lost. At least from what I have observed.
@@aurenkleige True, but its still at least offered until one shows them self to be a "MORON, FUCKING MORON" (not calling *you* a moron, just in case it seems that way). The first is given and lost, the other is earned and hard to lose (typically). At least that's now I see it.
People who proclaim victimhood aren't seeking respect, they seeking to abuse other people's compassion.
Cass Larsen Respect is not earned! It is lost.
Idk, when your teacher said "I Am_____" maybe they were referring to personality traits?
She's an SJW. She has to whine about something.
Or you can fill in the blank with “human being”
I'm honestly grateful that she took herself out of the gene pool.
Yeah, I'd be careful with that statement. There are quite a few lesbians that still had children, either by "biting the bullet" and fucking with a man or by just having a sperm donor and getting an IV fertilization.
@@Schnittertm1 That is true. So, she's 75% out of the gene pool.
the only fertilization she's gonna get is with a turkey baster
technically two women can have a child
@@AVAL2775 he clearly meant biological by normal means
The strange obsession of sticking a bunch of labels on people and then dividing them in groups is something I will never understand.
I remember one party that used to do it. Theu used to go by the nickname "nazi".
How does this type of thinking further human progress?
Staffotex this video is why aliens leave us alone. 😁
@@AC-gb7do That's fucking brilliant.
I am *HUMAN*. Basic stuff you guys seem to have forgotten, I (and I bet other people too) don't really give a shit about what, where or who you are. Live, I'll live and don't force your way of living on me, the end.
The one word to complete the sentence "I am ..." is, simply, "me".
I am me. YOU, are a caricature of a human being, a non-player character composed of certain attributes.
She used to be a person. Then she took that arrow to the knee.
Either this video or Earth was a mistake...
I'd say both
Back at you.
@@Foche_T._Schitt who ever told this poor woman that intersectionality is important was a mistake.
I find you offensive. What do I win? Does that mean you have to go away now? Because I'm offended. That's all it takes, right?
TheStig ZeroZeroZero your inherent privilege negates your offense taken
thank you. I am doing a social work assignment at uni involving intersectionality, and your video is the clearest one I found that explains it in a way I understand.
We are all different and those differences are diversity. Are you against diversity?
Undoomed brought me here....
Same
I know thousands people said this but who came here from Undoomed and dislikes it just for him
Actually, I found out about this video via Deterlucum.
I AM - An idiot.
that's two words, genius.
@@KaiserBlaze Stop wordsplaining me.
*An idiot sandwich
Don't make assumptions, except when you assume that your race or gender is more important than your values. Got it.
Respect is earned.. Not freely given.
You said you wanted women to have equal rights to men. Does that mean you want to take away rights from women or give men more rights?
I feel kinda bad for her, i dont think she has the capacity to understand how wrong she is. They brain washed her for years probably in a bubble on a campus and she never considered that it could be lies. Lies to serve someone elses agenda. You know thats true because common sense and logic wont lead you to such ridiculous ideas. Must be weird
I SOOOO needed this video! So many other videos made this concept sound like a truly difficult thing, and you've summed it up so beautifully
Let me help out with that last word: I am *cancer.*
You're welcome.
Shouldn't you have referred to females as womxn in this video given that some factions of intersectional feminism now claim this is how they should be addressed? Is it that you are excluding womxn or that intersectional feminism can't agree on definition of female.... er sorry...femxle.?
Intersectionality sounds like a bunch of nonsense to me!
You know, I am a white man, I am not really poor so I won't have problems getting in the upper middle class, so I guess I'm privileged, but what is about my privilege for being pretty? Where's my intelligence privilege? I have serious concerns that this intersectionality thing just leads us (or better, you) down the wrong way.
And by the way, I don't have to respect you. You can loose my respect for you entirely based on what you say to me or what I hear you saing to others. So if you wanna be respected, you gotta respect everyone else too (even those who don't buy into your interesectionality. Because no one wants to get instructed by someome who has got successfull with their minority passport)
Jole Schütz Agreed. Funny how the "goal" of this is to bring people together yet they can't that they're in fact creating more barriers between people.
I don't care what you are so long as we don't actively try to harm one another I think we'll be ok. By harm I mean with physical and potentially lethal violence. Being "triggered" isn't the same as suffering from violence
Honoring the experiences of our differences is not dividing us. It's called respect.
@@vinylfetishclub341 Assuming something about a person based on their innate characteristics is racist, sexist and so on...period.
@@Coldrin6 That's... pretty explicitly got nothing to do with what Vinyl said.
@@000Dragon50000 Vinyl defended intersectionality by saying it's "honoring the experiences". Did they not? Intersectionality assumes someones experience based on innate characteristics.
You might not agree with my opinion, but claiming it's "got nothing to do with..." is false.
Is it being divisive assuming all members of marginalized group feel oppressed?
Asahel Smith nope, we are borg
At this point the fact this girl is Chinese cancels out the fact that she's a lesbian. Chinese are a privileged group where I live. Not being privileged in her case is still more privileged than the other marginalized groups she's talking about... She should stop talking and apologize right now...
I love the way you put subtitles in this video! Super helpful. Also, the narrator was so engaging and fun to watch. Thanks for making this video!
When will you set aside your privilege and stop stereotyping all people like myself?
The problem with intersectionality is that it assumes victimhood. It does not take into account the positive factors that those same people may possess. For example beauty, talent, the status of family and friends, wealth, education, profession, etc. Beyonce' is a black woman. According to intersectional rules, she is a victim. But she is a beautiful, talented, rich, celebrity. Does anyone think that her life suffers from negative intersectional bias? In fact, I would say that as of 2020 no beautiful, rich, or talented woman does.
Population of Black Women in USA = +21.7 Million.
No. of Beyonce(s) = 1
See, the idea of victimhood is misleading. Intersectionality is more about being mindful of other people and their identities and not discriminating them for them. People are not claiming free health insurance because they are intersectional. They are expecting an open, safe, and accepting world. I don't see a problem with that Bill. Peace!
@@MegaAadhar And I see no problem whatsoever with your consept of intersectionality. But as with many other things today "intersectionality" is being used to drive a Marxist aganda nationwide. It is being used to seperate us into tribes. It is being used in a classic devide and conquer fashon. Marxists always devide. In Europe they focused on class warefare. Here they have focused on race primarily and included pretty much everything else. E pluribus unum means out of the many, one. But intersectionality is being used as a tool to seperate the one into many manageable sections. Be well Mega. Peace and love!
I'm sure glad your, intersectional lesbian immigrant "oppression" made it to TH-cam. You are awesome for intersectionalizing.
I'm sorry, but Asian immigrant homosexual is not inclusive enough, it's totally 2017'ish.
@@DonCapiche and change her sex after joining Islam.
I kinda thought Asians were getting lumped in with whites in this iteration of the race wars? Maybe I'm not caught up? Or is it only those Asians who aren't cishet? I swear, I can't keep up with who I'm supposed to be oppressing these days. If anyone could forward the memo that covers this, that'd be great. 😥😂
@John G Didn't you know just by posting here you are oppressing her? I don't know how but if she could respond I am sure that is what she would say to us! lol
Intersectionality is basically a game to see who can be victimized more
Yes it's basically asking oneself--how many ways am I a victim, and then expecting everybody else to give you all kinds of special treatment so that you don't have to ever face challenges in life and learn how to overcome them. Instead of teaching people ways to identify in which way they are victims of so-called "privileged" people, why not teach people about things like COMPASSION, EMPATHY, SHARING, KINDNESS.
I'm surprised the comments haven't been disabled.
I should care about all these victim points? In the words of the 'former' journalist Cahty Newman, what's in it for the men?
Tolerance is owed. Respect is earned. You dont get to demand respect you have not earned.
but asking people about their culture is considered micro-aggressions
Nothing helps defeating imaginary oppressive forces like dividing minorities into even smaller groups. I TOTALLY see that helping minority communities handling ACTUAL oppression.
Remarkably well said. Ridiculous micromanaging
They call it "intersectionality" because that's where crashes often occur.
undoomed says hi
*undoomed was here.
>Google dosent judge.
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA.
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA yeah thats a good one got my sides hurting real bad HAHAHAHAHA
respect is earned.
I believe everyone should be listened to, male, female, or otherwise, straight, queer, trans, cis, POC, white, disabled, etc.
Nuh uh.
Is Intersectionality the Pentathlon of the Oppression Olympics ?
What you are? You are Human like me. And all humans should have equal rights no matter what human it is.
when bigots hide behind their feelings you get intersectionalism
"I am" IS a complete sentence, it's the shortest complete sentence in the English language.
No.
@@boisejohnsonjr.5702 A complete sentence must have a subject & predicate.
inb4 comments are disabled
AveraGamer most appropriate inb4 comment evah
Why does intersectional have to refer to 'marginalised'. It could've been a useful word
Where can I get a PhD in Victim-hood?
I look really white but by birth I am linked to the First Nations of the town I was born in. My great , great, great grandfather was the leader of the First Nations and the town I was raised in is actually named after him. My adopted Father was Korean and his name by birth is my middle name, Hanju. When he came to Canada in the 1950s, immigration officials misheard his name and recorded it as Han Choo. He never corrected them… in the 1990s he had made contact with family in North Korea, and we’d get letters addressed to Hanju Lee, and Mum asked why, and Dad shared the story that it was his birth name, and the government of Canada recorded it wrong. My middle name was actually Robert Han, and I had it changed to just Hanju, to correct the mistake and so his name would live on through me.
I also identify as non-binary / genderqueer. My pronouns are they / them / their. I came out demipansexual in 2020. Pansexual fit who I am perfectly as a terminology, and I recognize it as being under the bisexual umbrella.
In grades 7-10 I was bullied horribly, and in grades 11-12, didn’t really have any close friends as to get the bullying to stop, they threatened to sue the school and the district. The school put out an edict that anyone bullying me would be expelled from the district. So the bullying stopped but in some ways I ended up preferring the negative attention to no attention. It’s been something that’s hindered me my whole life, I still have trust issues and difficulties making friends today.
I think the like/dislike ratio is comment enough, your sh#t ain't selling.
Just because you're gay or you Asian doesn't make you special what makes you special is what you do in life good or bad doesn't make you better than anyone else if you're gay the only makes you look like you're playing the victim when people can't get out and you don't like the opinions stop playing the victim
Intersectionailty or whatever you call it = narcissism which is actually a word.
Victimhood is not a virtue.
Especially when it's weaponized.
Love this video and the presenter! Thank you
Ooooh the oppression bingo. Go get your prize.
mauro rivera the only prize is sadness and dispair
@@bchin4005 I thought it was a big mac
I understand why this video has so many dislikes while she obviously did a great job at explaining all these serious issues on a light note. It is because most people prefer to be ignorant when they are privileged in their respective societies. It is important to understand that intersections here represent the myriad of oppression, and discrimination one can face by just belonging to any labeled 'artficial' category. At the same time, it is rather offensive to not see humans as humans. Her example of Moonlight clearly represents how underrepresented the black community is within Hollywood. If they don't want to put an effort into a character, make them black, or gay, or both, because the minority becomes the center of the joke to entertain privileged people who spend money for cheap laughs. I am glad I am settled in the east. As an Indian we still suffer from the same standards imposed by outsiders who firmly believed that our culture and religion needs to be 'fixed'. Each intersection comes with a predefined stereotype widely accepted by the majority and they will boldly judge and oppress because privilege is a fragile thing, today is, tomorrow not.
I get it that one would want to put up a defense if one feels marginalized, but if the defense is to marginalize other groups, what's the point? As soon as you say you've been discriminated against by another group, you're betraying a prejudice against that group that will marginalize individual humans who just happen to be members of that group. If you defend yourself by saying ALL members of that group behave that way, you're doing exactly what you claim they do.
My Asian-Canadian wife that lives in America and married an Australian thinks this is a horrible message.
the most important thing is being a individual which she can not say
Thank you Dr. Peterson
You are promoting a harmful ideology; not all Chinese people are the same, not all Chinese lesbians are the same, not all Chinese lesbian immigrants are the same. People don't have common experiences because they share a race, sexuality, nationality, and so on. How about we treat each other as individuals with a modicum of decency, instead of NPCs that must march to some prescripted behaviors...
I wonder how she would be treated in her home country? Would she feel like being open about her sexuality in a place like china?
no which makes her a marginalized group.
You have just been Undoomed! Muahahahha. And, I'm not going to get into a whole debate over everything. But with your "Respect" thing. Either you earn my respect or don't. It's not granted. And I'm not under any obligation to want to or have to learn about any of this. It's all nonsense. You are an individual and these are just your traits. You don't need to make it more complicated than that. Stop trying to shove everyone into a category. That's part of the issue! Let people be seen as just there individual selves and nothing more.
Not sure what you mean by 'respect'. I think by 'respect' she just means treating people with tolerance/politeness/decency/kindness. That's how I define 'respect'. And I assume that's what she meant too. Like a "I may not understand why an Asian lesbian immigrant is doing this video but I respect your right to do it." Just like you may say something like, "I may not understand your choice to have an open relationship, but I respect your right to do it." Or like we may say "Don't be an asshole. Treat people with some respect. Have some respect." That sort of thing.
Also, I don't think intersectionality is about diminishing the importance of individuality. It's just about seeing that people struggle with different things. For example you may meet a person who's really really good looking, and you feel jealous and you feel they have a lot of privilege. But then you find out they're really really poor. So now they're not as privileged as you thought they were.
So... your opinion only matters depending on your gender, race or sexual preference?
So basically, we need stories about characters representing these groups. More and more and more. Forget about character complexity, philosophy, principles, and values. As long as they check the boxes of marginalized groups, then that's all that matters.
Worked so well for the comic industry.
Thus is why contemporary movies are so bad. Story, dialogue and direction are all secondary to "diversity "
There was a political party in germany - the nacional socialists - that operated in the same way.
Why is it necessary for there to be more intersectional movies like Moonlight?
You make it sound as though the quality of the story is secondary to a movie being representative of certain demographics.
Ernie Velveeta but but but, muh representashun!
Tf is this, how would any of that effect anything, especially body size which you can work to improve.
Doodem Last name
You seem to have misunderstood her point
@@__kou__5653 Her point being What? That she's a complete and utter moron?
This is a great way to not only divide marginalized communities, but make everyone else hate us, too!
As a non American this concept of intersectionality is so flawed. why can't be as a society just encourage kindness, and respecting people and leaving them be.
Instead we have this system of labelling victim cards and stacking them together for moral points. You realise this is just scoring people objectively for social credit. Not much different from the authoritative Chinese government policies.
Not trying to spew hate but hear me out. Maybe pursue an actual crime for being a crime. Also, can't we just accept that we as humans do judge the unfamiliar, and socially are more accepting of people similar to ourselves? No I think the way to solve this is just to encourage respect for one another.
Not some arbitrary law or social construct to make us feel morally superior. Shit happens to people. Guess what, for the majority of humankind people have always been fighting for dominance, socially, through wars, etc.
Just be more accepting. Stop focusing so much on victimhood, start trying to live a better life
Honestly, Americans have been doing that for centuries. Ignoring the victims and cancelling out cultures. Our history books don't tell the history of Black people as they attributed to our society, we built a white supremacist nation, we created "conversion therapy" to "fix" our gays. We tried our damnest to snuff out the "weird" and make "white and straight" normal, so much so that even the LGBTQ+ community was convinced they were "weird". The fact that we even HAVE this term is a step forward. Representation matters, especially when a nation has so many oppressed and systematically marginalized people, specifically BIPOC (Black, Indigenous, People of Color).
what is an intersectional person, please reply as fast as u can
Thank you for the wonderful video explaining intersectionality. And please please don't listen to all these unkind comments.
Identity politics of any stripe builds walls, not bridges.
There's only one tribe, the human race, we rise or fall together, all of us.
It's chinese people like this that makes me think that Unit 731 did nothing wrong.
ohhh damn
okay why is this person, oppressing people who don't use the same ideology
How about the Central and South Asian people who don't have 'small eyes'?
Just because they don't have small eyes, shall we consider creating a new continent or "Big Eye Asians"? :P
So intersectionality is being a victim.
Only if you victimize people. Have you thought about working to prevent victimization?
This is so terribly steeped in bad ideology.... I'm sorry this happened to you
Intersectionality is the Olympic sport of victimhood.
Just to note outside myself and I see a few others. Undoomed just tore down this video. Which means by this time tomorrow you are gonna be flooded with messages attacking your nonsense. R.I.P video! You deserve it though.
John231984 Tomorrow?
@@bchin4005 I was giving time for people to catch the video
Anyone else just become aware of this.... yesterday?
Intersectionality fails because it violates the fundamental bedrock of enlightenment values: Prioritizing the individual. It is not WHAT you are, it is WHO you are; and whatisms should play no significant role in determining WHO you are as an individual.
Whereas intersectionality puts ALL the emphasis on these things, and as such, is not only counter-enlightenment, but is by definition, illiberal.
Who in this planet can think that Blacks, Women or Gays are a "collective" with the same identities?
Does anyone else feel this video is quite good but is not appreciated so?
and these people are still scratching their heads trying to figure out how Trump won.
it's ppl like this that are guaranteeing trump's re-election in 2020
Wow.. Just call yourself a lesbian and call it a day
Oppression Olympic gold FTW!