This Pilot Made an Emergency Landing in a Shallow River
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.พ. 2018
- It's January 16, 2002 and Garuda Indonesia Flight 421 is struggling with a loss of power. The captain decides to perform a maneuver few other pilots have ever attempted: to land his Boeing 737 in water.
Watch the Full Episode with your FREE trial for Smithsonian Channel Plus by signing up today at watch.smithsonianchannel.com/
From the Series: Air Disasters: River Runway bit.ly/2BMSdRm - บันเทิง
He also saved his crew in Palu Tsunami 2018. Respect capt
He and his crews were scheduled to fly there, and was trapped on a hotel when the quake came
?
@@georgiusdamar8042 itu capt. Lion air yg terbang saat gempa. Yg dimaksud capt. Abd rozak turut menyelamatkan korban waktu beliau di hotel
i live there its scary and many parents lost their sons/ Daughter cuz everyone is panicked and unfortunely my bestie died on the earth quake
😂😂
The co pilot is my uncle, hariyadi gunawan, he passed away in 2017 in jakarta, RS polri kramat jati. A very humble person, rides his old rusty yamaha force 1 to mosque everyday, visits family and friends everyday, to find out if theres anyone in need for food or need money to go to doctor or if their children needs money for school..., when he passed away, we found many photographs of my late father (his elder brother) under his shirt in his cupboard, who passed away in 1994...he always missed him, now they both gone,i lost 2 good men of my life...
sorry just read it, he will definitely get a place worthy of God's side, he is very instrumental, such a heroic. we remember him as a hero. jannah for him
@@nabilas4243 aamiin...
Turut sedih denger berita ini 😭😭
Btw is abdul rozaq still alive
Innalillahi wainnailaihi rojiun
Sully is marked a hero for landing on a wide straight canal wirh tons of room meanwhile thid guy lands in between 2 bridge on narrow river with lots of turns and twists and you never hear about him
He is popular in Indonesia. The president give him a medal of honour
its bcuz the plane could of crashed into new york city, recreating Americas worst nightmare. also it's spelled Hudson
Arte em biscuit lol you copy and pasted and still have the it’s spelled Hudson part.. lazy idiot...
Captain abdul rozaq
You do, just not in america, just like people who dont speak english probably dont hear much about sully
Every pilot that saves their passengers lives are a hero, but this guy deserves recognition and a medal
Absolutely!
yep
He has earned digong’s shining brown+red medal for bravery
Unfortunate one of the Crew (Attendant) died in the Accident
@@kazazaky2397yeah, her body got sucked out
the pilot / captain is my father, he still flying until now, me and my brother become a pilots too in the same company, unfortunately the first officer just passed away on 2017
edit : thank you for your many responses, i appreciate the opinions and appreciations from all of you
fyi : on last june 2020 my father retired from flying and the first officer / co-pilot died because of sickness not from this accident, thank you
Deep condolences to FO..
Selaku orang kecil saya berharap dan mendoakan anda,, jadilah seperti ayah anda.. Capt Abdul Rozaq sungguh telah menjadi idola dan inspirasi bagi banyak orang.. beliau rendah hati, ramah, dan bertaqwa kpd Tuhan.. semoga Allah memberkati beliau beserta seluruh keluarganya.. Amiin
Is there any attempt on making your dad a national hero? He deserved that!
Your dad is a hero :)
Your Dad is a hero .... 👍👍👍👍
Proud of your Dad and condolences to FO.......Greetings from India
You forget to included TWO important things:
1. Actually, the pilot planned to land it on some sort of field but abort the plan since there were some village kids played soccer on the field at that time.
2. The pilot land the plane opposite the flows. Means, the plane actually had a time to turn so it opposite the flows of the river. By landing opposite the flow, it will help to stop the plane.
I can confirm no 1, as i heard the story from my uncle (capt hariyadi gunawan, the co pilot) himself..., he and my father (his elder brother), used to play soccer on a rice field when they were kids.
@@kuliborgeopilot5439 Your uncle is hero, May Allah gives jannah for Him. greeting from semarang
Later in an interview capt. Rozaq said before the plane hit the water he was praying. He had already thought that it was time to go, but he tried to land it till the end. Then he had a vision of a long line on the water, telling it was where he should land the plane. He also said that the river's depth varied from deep & shallow and he was very lucky that he landed on the shallow point. Truly an amazing story.
The only one who died was a flight attendant, namely Santi Anggraeni.
Fyi the flight number 421 is still in service today but it has a different route; it flies between Ngurah Rai airport Denpasar & Soekarno-Hatta airport Cengkareng whereas previously flew from Mataram to Jogjakarta.
The survivors hold a reunion with capt. Rozaq every year and there's an article about the 2013 reunion. Not everyone involved was present at that time but the crash strongly connects the people who barely knew each other before the flight. They still keep in touch to this day.
Rizal Batheki Why did she die?
DestinyFucker9000 when plane landing and tail crash rock in river, it made hole. Stewardress sit in back, she through out from plane
all power to allah
God bless you too for letting those aren't a wear of ,
wow.. truly amazing. thank you for sharing this
this captain deserves a medal or something. I watched this on the tv few days ago and i am still so impressed by the captain's level-headedness. as i remember he even did a circle around the spot to perfectly align the plane and the altitude for a river landing... he saved all those people 's lives by his amazing knowledge and reaction. mad respect to him. Hope he is doing well.
Weeeell..good landing, but if he was level-headed he would have started the apu first, and he would have followed the checklist when it comes to the intervals between each engine windmill restart🤨
@@speedbird9313 You must remember that Garuda is a commercial airplane, means the fuel usage are watching closely. He already divert the course once, so I'm sure both of the pilots already calculated how much fuel they already spent. It sucks, but that's how commercial airplane works. The pressure to save fuels are even more greater on low budget airplane.
@@snowyconfession Garuda is a commercial airline😉The 737 is the airplane, an airplane which the apu uses very little fuel. So that should not be the reason.
@@speedbird9313 well the APU failed to start after trying many times in that 737.
@@thunderboltfireplane Hard to start the apu without battery power..
RIP to the 1 who didn't survive, also bravo to the pilot for saving nearly everyone from death
Why he didnt make it?
Drowning?
Nearly everyone
She was sucked out from the plane by air pressure when the back part of the plane broke.
“One who didn’t survive”
“Saving *everyone”* ... Words 100.
+That.One.Unfeatured.Person what should he say instead of everyone?
“Indonesian Sully”
No, more like “American Abdul Rosaq”
The Indonesian was in 2002 Then sulpy was in 2009
Long live Indonesia.
Crash landing on water has been performed several times, the earliest recorded being in 1952, so fuck you all playing racism card. All of these pilots are heroes there is no such thing as Indonesian Sully or American Abdul Rozaq. Captain Sully is captain Sully and captain Rozaq is captain Rozaq, stop belittling any of them.
(:
Its a same mean
This Indonesian River Landing = 2002
Sully River Landing = 2009
Woah
Except, on GA421, one flight attendant got killed. Plus, there are several injuries unlike US1549.
They are professionals doing their job. Just be glad we go flying in good hands.
Dont talk about who is the best but at least they saved people its not that easy to land a plane like that you know and its not that easy to safe people like that.
@@aurelioyoyo9222 bruh i'm just telling the difference. Not telling which one is the best
@@v12ts.gaming Yea i know i just telling too
And he just survived from collapsed Hotel building where he stayed with his flight crews, when the multiple earthquake & tsunami hit Palu City
Aviation FUR memes 😱😱😱😱
100% Real Story...
It's true
What karma?
@Joen Delfiero learn what karma means first then commenting later...
Very experienced pilots they were... God bless them
I reported your comment as "offensive towards other religions"
tuber I reported this comment as well, it's very offensive toward others
Yup alhamdulilallh . Muslims have a prayer they say when they travel by airplane or any transportation.The Book of Etiquette of Traveling : Ibn 'Umar (May Allah be pleased with them) reported: Whenever the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) mounted his camel for setting out on a journey, he would recite: "Allahu Akbar (Allah is Greatest)," thrice. Then he (ﷺ) would supplicate: "Subhanal-ladhi sakh-khara lana hadha, wa ma kunna lahu muqrinin, wa inna ila Rabbina lamunqalibun. Allahumma inna nas'aluka fi safarina hadh al-birra wat-taqwa, wa minal-'amali ma tarda. Allahumma hawwin 'alaina safarana hadha, watwi 'anna bu'dahu. Allahumma Antas-Sahibu fissafari, wal-Khalifatu fil- ahli. Allahumma inni a'udhu bika min wa'ta'is-safari, wa kaabatil- manzari, wa su'il-munqalabi fil-mali wal-ahli wal-waladi (Far removed from imperfection is the One Who has made this subservient to us, for we have no power to subjugate it, and certainly to our Rubb shall we return. O Allah, we ask You during this journey of ours for righteousness, piety and such deeds as are pleasing to You. O Allah, make easy for us this journey of ours and make the distance short for us. O Allah, You are our Companion during the journey and the Guardian of the family and the property in our absence. O Allah, I seek refuge in You from the hardships of travelling, unhappiness connected with ghastly scenes and evil turns in property and family)." When he returned, he recited this supplication making addition of these words: "Ayibuna, ta'ibuna, 'abiduna, li-Rabbina hamidun (We are those who return; those who repent; those who worship and those who praise our Rubb)."
[Muslim].
Yeah
i'm with you
Landing between the 2 bridges that too on that narrow stretch.....this has got to be the best crash landing in the aviation history. I pay my respect to captain sullivan, but captain abdul rozaq did a much more commendable job and needs much more recognition. All hail to the hero.☺✌🙌
The way they were so cooperative with each other makes me proud.
I don't know if the captain, first officer, family of them, or acquaintances will see this...but, you two men are certified badasses. I'd fly with either of you anytime.
The copilot has passed away in 2017. Only the captain is left.
I always feel such relief in these videos when there is an eye witness account because then I know that not everyone died
so fucking true
the only casualty was a flight attendant afaik
It always a relieve to see the pilot telling the story of his experience than just the ATC person
As soon as I saw the pilot being interviewed I felt so relieved
Captain Abdul Rosaq makes Sully look like a novice. Wow what an ace!👍
I wouldn't call it novice, but ok....
@@kevin-7091 much better than calling Sully an "Amateur"
@@kevin-7091 The miracle for sully is that his apu still works. Capt. Rozaq flew an old airplane without any electrical power, the apu was not working. And had to land the plane in a narrow and shallow river. At a much higher speed. He even turned the plane 360 degrees with no computer assistance at all to land against the river current as a braking aid.
Fantastic pilot, he should be just as famous as Sullenberger.
Finally, somebody that doesn’t speak out their butthole
He is😀, in Indonesia
That's a much harder landing than sullys landing on the Hudson. Landing between two bridges, on a narrow river which was bendy at higher speed. That's more miraculous than anyone survived at all, never mind the fact only one person died.
sully lost both engines at a lower altitude than any jet in history and the 155 people survived he had a seconds to act and take a decision, but this landing was good nonetheless
I didn't say sully had it easy, I said this Indonesian pilots job was a hell of alot harder.
it wasn't, did you red my full comment?
Yes, I read it. He had a large area to land, a wide area of water, wasn't hampered by bridges so close together, and landed 40kph slower. This pilot had 1 tiny spot to touch down, going far too fast, between two bridges close together, on a river that's not straight...
No Sully landed in the Hudson, which that area had multiple bridges, Manhattan, Brooklyn, Williamsburg, etc...
I liked how co pilot close to captain,
"Yes sir,"
"250 sir"
"170 sir"
He's a legend. I was a youngling back then, I had nightmares of the plane crash just from watching the news. RIP to the one soul lost.
This was more impressive than the Hudson river landing
both are impressive
@@javierf6162 just for the record, ditching on the Bengawan Solo river is much harder because it's narrow, twisting, and not to mention there are 2 bridges you need to take care. Whilst the Hudson river in comparison, is wide and straight, and it's in a middle of a populated city.
@@v12ts.gaming people were on scene right away
No because sully didn’t kill anyone
I went to Indonesia on july 2013 and I just want to say, Indonesia is an amazing country!
Thanks!
Infinite Flight Solo im from Indonesia and we hope u visit us again
Infinite Flight Solo love u cuz u like Indonesia
Infinite Flight Solo where are you from ? I've always wanted to visit but didn't know if I should because I'm white af
Hey , thank you for visiting my country and i'm glad that you enjoyed it here ! Welcome back to Indonesia
Nobody ever publicise this water landing.
World only knows the sully's hutson River landing.
Here, this Indonesian pilot displayed a magnificent airmanship by landing in between bridges plus on twisting river.
Great salute to you n your first officer.
Just because Hutson River landing was American it got fame.
Bloody politics.
America only want to speak something bad about another world if they dont have they will make it up
@@Va-dy8pd "even for a crow, itz child is precious"..... LOL...
Indonesia also have B.J. Habibie who he is aeroplane internasional engineer
Listen I live in this area, the Solo river is just very narrow and full of bushes, far from the city center. in contrast to the wide American hudson river and people will soon find out.
Wow sir, I thought this story are known well in aviation history of the world. Never know that still much ppl out there didn't knew this story.
I'm Indonesian btw
That guy is a true and talented hero. Epic reaction and quick thinking!
Wow. What an amazing feeling to find this episode on youtube and to see that it reached over 2 million views. Thank you everyone for watching, we hope you enjoyed the episode. It was definitely a fun experience to film this show and my respect goes out to the pilots and crew that help saved the many lives on board.
SEE RANK
Redd Ochoa
it really nice!
These pilots are hero´s. Many pilots who have tried to ditch unfortunately have´t made it. But these did, and they saved many lives.
Lol you always know it’s a good sign when the pilot is talking about the experience
RIP that 1 who died, those pilots are still considered heroes for saving many people.
The one that died jumped out of the plane
@@removed5035 nope, the pilot confirmed that the cabin crew (who died) got "sucked out" from the plane while landing. and her position was on that hole. so it threw her out and her whole security equipments took off.
This one was very emotional. The Pilots did something unconventional to save lives. They really are heros. God bless them.
Sometime you get to see how pathetic people can be comparing one flight emergency to another. I'm sure neither the crew nor the passengers want to be reminded of that situation or ever relieve it ever again.
Asian (Indonesian) First. Sully (American) Second. More difficult than Sully’s situation.
Min H. OO
Agree..
I disagree. Captain Sullenberger lost both engines at 2800 feet over the most densely populated city in America.
@@KempeIzGud yes but it was a straight river the bengawa isn't straight
@@KempeIzGud
exact same case, Garuda pilot says in another video he was lost both engine and generator also died, so he land without any communication to the tower.
the woods & bridges also "dense" too in that speed, only 1500 meters distance between them. when plane was finally stopped, water depth only 1 - 3 feet range.
at the time 9/11 was a nightmare for the americans, if sully made that turn it would be the worst thing to happen yet
America: I have capt.sully
Indonesia: i have capt.rozak
This was the older real "miracle" American media ignored
I can’t believe a movie hasn’t been made on behalf of these pilots.
The river is called THE Bengawan Solo, i often pass that river and this story was so famous at that time
Izzuddin Azzam i think so wait wait
Are you from indonesia?
yeah. now im in this river side
there was my brother on that flight GA421 with his wife and 3 year old daughter... survivors ..very very lucky
For a moment I thought of that Confectionery cake shop in Singapore
Bengawan artinya sungai bapak, nama sungainya Sungai Solo
Respect for Capt Rozaq, perhaps Sully read about Solo river landing years before. They are extraordinary Pilot.🇲🇨🇺🇸
Ini bendera indo yang bener 🇮🇩
@@javeddd7167 itu kan emg bener dia naruh bendera amrik karena pernah ada tragedi sama setelah kejadian ini di amrik dikenal sebagai Sully/Miracle on the hudson
@@ForwardSpace146 dia pake bendera Monako. Bendera Monako pendek dikit dan merahnya agak ketuaan.
I've never heard of this before, I'm glad i have now. This is an amazing reenactment very intense!
that sucks for that one person who died, tragic
Hahah
yudiweb best anime dying scene
yudiweb her fucking dumbass
Yusif Kimeisua umm yudiweb wasn't wrong lol
yudiweb are u serious? Wow
Indonesian Sully
+Torres So Tru lol
Problem is, there's one casualty
A casualty is an injury, not a death
Wow that means they were better than sully! Only one injury! Sully had about 50 injuries I think.
By one casuality means one death
Us airways 1549: we have the actual and accurate water emergency landing!
GA 421: *hold my bandrek*
**9999% accurate**
🤣✌️
Bandrek anying 🤣🤣🤣🤣👍👍👍
Everyone comparing Capt Rozak with Capt Sully. But I think they're both great pilot. They saved people from disaster,
Nobody talk about him as much as Sully😢
Sully landed the plane calm without any fatalities and all survive no serious injured, sully saved 155 souls meanwhile your hero 59souls.
Water ditching is incredibly rare. From Wikipedia, there have been 21 passenger aircraft water ditchings in history, 9 in the past 20 years. 7 of them resulted in 0 fatalities. The ones ditching in rivers had much more success in terms of fatalities than those that ditched in the ocean. Interesting stuff.
Um the flight attendant died so there is 1 fattalatie
Respect to these pilots. They did the impossible.
Sully landed on a river at much lower speed, this guy at almost 200mph. How did this pilot not get recognized for this?
Actually he circled around first looking for a good landing spot without any computer assistance at all and even his apu didn't work because the battery was dead. He first chose a field but was forced to abandon his intention because there were children playing soccer nearby, then he chose the river and circled again to fight the river current as a braking aid.
He did it before sully
Beta Sully I guess..
Then Sully is American Rozaq
@@v12ts.gaming thats true, also there is only one death in the accident. and it wasnt his fault either, the crew jumped off before it landed thats why she died. so this man did better than Sully.
@@itzAbbasCH no the crew got sucked out because of a rock there were 2 who got sucked out the other one survived
I saw this episode and the failure modes are incorrect. I was the equipment manager for 737 engine air turbine starters at the time and have designed APUs for both the 737 and 757.
ALL commercial jet engines (except the 787) are started with air turbine starters, not electric motors. The source of compressed air comes from the Auxiliary Power Unit mounted in the tail and only useful below 20,000 feet, the opposite running engine, a ground cart, or in flight, by ram air spinning the low pressure fan (also below 20,000 feet). This is an FAA requirement and I've seen it done on test flights.
APUs have an electric starter, powered by a totally separate NiCad battery in the heated, pressurized aft cargo compartment, so repeated ram-air starts of the main engines would have zero effect on the APU battery.
What I think happened is that that pilots failed to turn on the engine ignitors (spark plugs) before entering foul weather, to ensure the fire doesn't go out. They also didn't give the engines enough time to start--it could take minutes, not 30 seconds to get a fire going and reach 50% minimum sustainable N1 idle speed. And engines are started one at a time, not simultaneously, since 737s can fly (and take off) easily with only one engine.
The APU didn't start because its battery was defective and was cold-soaked after an hour in -40F temps (the battery is in a heated enclosure). That had absolutely NO effect on restarting the main engines.
I suspect the NTSB report got things right. Too bad the TV show misled so many.
Greatdome99 has
Pilot made an excellent decision saving the life of hundreds ...good job
Very difficult landing between 2 bridges in narrow river... Super save and so well thought in timing and executed
Appreciation to Capt Abdul Rozaq, one of Indonesia's best pilots
Incredible... bows to the pilots!
I love watching the videos where all passengers & crew get out alive. Xx makes me feel nice 🥰 x
All but one. One flight attendant, named Santi Anggraeni, died when the rear of plane hit hard upon contact with the river.
The original Sullys. This might of been harder. These guys are absolute badssses. I think they only lost few, unfortunately though. Amazing feat of flying. So clutch.
Good job at Piloting your aircraft Captain.
MEGA SKILLED PILOTS!!!!
This is actually no less compare to captain sully heroic landing, but lost of media spotlight since it was not happened in USA. The river there was snaky and far narrower than hudson river, and there was also two bridges ahead the river blocking the way, plus the dead engine. It's incredible that almost all of passengers still alive
things to clarify:
1. "plus the dead engine" Both G421 and US1549 had its engines flameout, so it's not just the former.
2. "almost all of passengers still alive" All of the passengers are alive, some having injuries. The person who died is a cabin crew, named Santi Anggraeni, so she doesn't count as a "passenger".
It’s popular in Indonesia, in sure people from there don’t recognize the sully incident either
The Captain and First officers are a legend!
Miracle on the Solo
Amazing pilots. Credit as much as posibel.
Awesome Job... Highly skilled and reliable Pilots
The best Cockpit crew of all time, big respect cap
Kesini gara" kejadian Sriwijaya air .. semoga korban diampuni dosa" nya.. Turut berduka cita atas Sriwijaya air tgl 9/01/2021
Amin
Wow that’s talent right there those pilots could have not handled it any better
I don’t know why but its too addictive to watch videos of airplane crashing and worst landing 😂😂
That first officer cooperated so well
Well done for such an awesome emergency landing.
2:58 that woman's acting beside the woman wearing light blue hijab is hilliarous
Well done to those hero pilots for their dedicated skill and wisdom they nailed it
Captain Abdul Rozaq the real HERO from Indonesia. Respect Capt
Allah bless him.very experience pilot
Thanks for the kind compliment.
God bless everyone that was on board that flight
IRISH AVATATION 777896 but one person died
respect for both the pilots but also rip for one perso who died may he rest in peace and his family move on and live a happy life
God I must say, when I get in any airplanes from now on, I hope I get experienced pilots Everytime they save tons of lives and do their job flawlessly
Capt. Abdul Rozak use a flashlight...and tunder flash....to read the instrument after they failed to turn on the APU and electricity were totally down. Thank's God they still have..and only have a hydrolic system
Pilot and co-pilot are brave
0:09 Young Abdul Rosaq
0:15 Old Abdul Rosaq
This pilot is a legend.
At the start of the video: flying is a 737
Everone: Is It A mAx
Wait wait wait... there was an incident similar to hudson case ? Wow never knew - why is this not so popular while this was at least as miraculous as sulleys landing...
Are Western people more preferred or what ?
And before you start arguing: this river was much shallower and had obstacles while the hudson was bride and clear!
Because "America"
It happened long time ago. 2002 I was 15 years old at that time. It was a pretty big news here in Indonesia.
Hayrullah Ceylan no ...America usually doesn't do international news unfortunately....unless it's HUGE! Like a terrorist attack or something . Pretty sad. They don't really want us knowing what's going on outside of where we live.
Hayrullah Ceylan it’s cuz Americans like attention and think that they are the only people in the world that are in a wealthy countey
Because sullys landing was in hudson US not in Indonesia.
Hooray someone did a good work on the plane !Someone survived!
Leon Alaimaleata all survived except one
Respect to this pilot
Salute to the Captain and the co pilot
🙆
Garuda Indonesia Best flight forever
props to the camera guy he went outside and recorded the plane
Incredible...
Really the flight requires these types of pilots in these circumstances...
well done well done pilot...👍👍👍👍
Yes, Indonesia, pray for SJ182😭
Thanks for making it subtitles
👏👏👏 hats off to the pilot
2:38 Me on roadtrips.
Lol
btw, Sully happened in 2009, this was 2002 and in a 737 AND in bad weather, it ALSO stayed in-tacked like the Sully's airbus and this is an older 737-3 i might add
lmao, how bouh dah airbuster, how about dah
heres a comment someone posted fr you to explain why the sully landing is more popular than this:
*what makes sully's landing more incredible is that he lost both engines at a lower altitude than any jet in history, and he had way more people and he had seconds to take a decision, and muhammad said sully had radio contact, its because he turned on the APU "auxiliary power unit" theres a check list that you need to follow when you loose bouth engines, those pilots didnt do that (im taking off of this video I havent reed the report) but sully tried but they had almost no speed or altitude left, plus he was over NYC a really big city so one wrong thing and he could have killed hundreds, so sully was still better becuase les altitude, less speed, more people, and in a verry crowded area, plus it was in the winter they could have died from hypothermia because of the water.*
-iRx Destiny
@@artemsamico this Garuda Indonesia lost both engines too
@@x-planelandings5308 Yes, but it also had thousands more feet and thousands fewer bystanders at risk. Its still an incredible job, its just not necessarily a fair comparison for either.
INDONESIA PROUD TO YOU CAPT!
Salute to brave pilots!
Miracle on solo
This was before 'Miracle on the Hudson.'
Still a tragedy for that one unlucky person who didn’t make it
Awesome job capt.👍🏿