Secrets of India’s Smartest Hotel Company | Business Games #3
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ธ.ค. 2021
- Learn how india’s most profitable hotel business is creating a virtual hotel
Monopoly through its super profitable & unique business model
➡️Open your Demat Account - forms.gle/1Hah4kvH5TJtCxSm7
Subscribe to Finology One - www.finology.in/one
.............................................................................
Academy of Value Investing - quest.finology.in/racetracks#...
.....................................................................................
Courses on Industry Analysis - quest.finology.in/racetracks#...
......................................................................................
Get Stock Recommendations - recipe.finology.in/app/recomm...
................................................................................
File your taxes - taxy.finology.in
..................................................................................
Read our blog on Club Mahindra - blog.finology.in/success-stor...
......................................................................................
Your Equity Research Assistant (Ticker)- ticker.finology.in/
.....................................................................................
Find the Best Stockbroker: select.finology.in/
................................................................................
Pranjal's Favourite books - zurl.co/ZgEI
Mint your Money by Pranjal Kamra - www.amazon.in/dp/8194879035/r...
Investonomy by Pranjal Kamra- amzn.to/36kKrdj
...............................................................................................
Get in Touch-
Twitter Tips - / myfinology
Facebook connect - / myfinology
Instagram updates - @myfinology
Telegram - @myfinology
Email - Pranjal@finology.in
Website - www.finology.in/
![[HIGHLIGHT] หมีLIVEปะ? | EP.171 เห็นแต่ในจอ วันนี้มาต้องขอคารวะ](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/gPWLxa0e_Z8/mqdefault.jpg)
Club Mahindra me sirf staying free hai. Food cost bahut high hai aur unke resorts me outside food allowed nahi hai. Travel costs alag. Plus less flexibility in holidays. Upfront cost and annual subscription cost ko kisi mutual fund me daal de to holidays bhi mana lenge aur extra returns bhi...
So IMHO Club Mahindra only exists because people aren't financially aware - which is ironic as you're on a mission to make them financially aware Pranjal sir. So as long as you & other people spread financial awareness, you'll be hurting Club Mahindra's business😅
Club Mahindra Timeshare membership is a good choice for Ultra Rich individuals.They hv pioneered in Holidaying .💕
yes as long as people are ignorant, club mahindra will stay in business.
Satya Vachan
THIS IS A FLOP BUSINESS MODEL FOR FINANCIALLY INTELLIGENT PEOPLE.
We have to pay upfront cost of minimum 5lakh + 20000 per year as Annual maintenance charges.
This is NOT AT ALL a FINANCIALLY CLEVER DECISION.
If you put 5lakh even in bank FD @6% Interest you can earn 30000 per year. This 30000 + 20000Rs Annual maintenance fee = 50000Rs.
By this 50000Rs you can easily avail holidays every year....
@@dr.dilipkagat yes exactly I think common people will always get lootedif they don't start using their brain
Nice video. If you just invest in FD, for 8 lakhs we get roughly around INR 40000 and we can save a maintenance fee of INR 20000. So with INR 60000 you can easily buy a holiday for 7 days in any 4 or 5-star hotels
point hai boss
I was about to write same thing.
💯
What about inflation? Do you consider that the price you pay for 6-7 days will remain constant? No bro. It does not work like that.
@@rsanjoy4u then why not mutual fund. FD he took the worse case or guaranteed return
30 years back I was offered this membership for around 1 lakh on installments, it was looking very lucrative. I was going to agree but my wife saved me from this trap, i now realise how intelligent she was at such a young age
You are lucky to have such a level headed wife. My wife pushed me into this even though I was not very keen. I signed up just for her sake. Now I'm regretting it.
Just last month Club Mahindra has been caught violating many norms. The members are being scammed.
I am a Club Mahindra member honesty i am saying Pranjal sir members are not even 1% happy with the CM services
Exactly
You are absolutely right
I am a very happy Ex club Mahindra member.
When investors are more interested in buying club Mahindra shares instead of club Mahindra memberships. Investors' mindset 🤣🤣
The length of this video has nothing to do with the content quality you're delivering. Thanks for sharing such valuable knowledge 😊
Exactly
I get free stay in CM every year for 7 days in all seasons from my corporate, but I have used it only once in last 7 yrs.. Resort was good, but it's so big that just to reach reception or restaurant or activity area within CM premises, you have to walk a lot.. they have vehicle but only for senior citizens and waiting time is 20-25 minutes.. so no use.. Food is super expensive.. it's in remote area.. very far from EVERYTHING.. you must have own car.. otherwise renting cab everyday will add-up cost and limitations as well.. I had rented cab for 5 days with airport pick-up & drop and spent 20k on that.. Because I had cab full time available, I could go out to nearby marketplace for breakfast lunch dinner .. still for experience ate couple of times at CM restaurants also.. Food was good, but very expensive.. Traveling time increase to sight seeing places because this is too far from EVERYTHING as I mentioned earlier.. So just imagine, even after having total free stay without paying for membership & anual fees, I still don't prefer to go to CM resorts because of these issues... I can understand the pain of paid members..
Same lol
Yeah same here,....overall cost ends up being more than justified. This model won't sustain.
same here
@@mikethornet7842 it is sustainig so far just like coroprate hospitals as people dont know before they got caught
This comment should be pinned
Superb analysis Pranjal...the same analysis I gave to my family n friends almost 10 yrs before...tab jakar their eyes opened...😋...btw I stayed thr in their goa wala resort for free as part of their promotional offer and they tried their best to sell me but I am also a sakht launda 😊😊
They are scamsters.... Investigation is on... They will be arrested soon... The chairman has already resigned to avoid arrest.
Same experience I had with country Club.. And now after wasting money I am now regreting becoming part of it
@Pranjal My relative is a member for a long time...whenever he takes vacation he never gets to stay in his preferred location...plus he has to choose his stay as per vacancy available...since 2017 he has never spent his vacation where he really wanted to instead he had to pick amongst choices provided to him
Well said.
Living this series. All 3 cases are near to our daily life and eye opener. Few years ago I got into CM trap but realized next day and did cancel the deal.
There is no one on the internet who explained this as clearly as you have..
Thanks 👍🏾
I am the member of club mahindra since last few years at first i feel i was trapped in some scam after paying such huge amount but after staying in resorts of Club Mahindra I am very much satisfied.After seeing your video the little much of doubt that was on my mind is completely cleared.
Thankyou so much Pranjal Sir..😊😊
Hey, I wish to know more about your experience
Rather I will invest that 5 lacs in stocks and will earn 60,000 per year that is enough to enjoy holiday. Only irrational people will buy such memberships
@@ganeshnandore correct 💯
@@ganeshnandore good example
@@ganeshnandore x
Business Games is the most informative & mind blowing series. Thanks PRANJAL SIR for Sharing such knowledge!!!!
Sir, can your next business games video please be on Zomato? I m quite curious to know why its financials are bad and has an overall bad performance even though its market has gone up significantly in quarantine and is doing visibly good.
Loving this series sir!
I really appreciate your way of exposing companies like these. You smartly said everything about company. Keep it up the good work.
It is better to invest in liquid mutual fund and when needed you can withdraw and use that fund for travel expenses.
Check do exit load
100%
@@artoflifesurya4206 after 7 days its nil
STCG?
@@MsRkshukla liquid funds cant grow exponentially in few months. They only provide 5-7%return(better than fd) and yes stcg is charged as per ur tax slab.
Loving this series as always
Excellent, in-depth analysis!! This series is simply brilliant!!!
My respect for @ Pranjal is multi foldes with each video , below 3 qualities or motive I find when u share ur videos .....
1.Am I teaching something incredible for my viewers. 2. Am I making something which my audience can utilize.
3. Am I making every minute worth while for my viewers watching on other side......
And it's not a paid promotion I genuinely feel this for your video and they are really helping to understand business & sometimes these case studies help a lot in my studies
Best quality presentation in depth, hat's off, needless to mention that your one year back Mutual Fund related VIDEOS discussion helps me to growing my fund values to >40%.👍👍👍
Yes...I am also following his suggestion...
Quality content, loving this series. Brilliant!
Dear Pranjal ji, you are really honest judge and analyst, keep it up exposing the malpractices... Bhagwan Rama Bless you!
Great! Very informative video. In my early days of job, once I had nearly escaped from the trap of Mahindra Holidays package. I could sense that, I am getting trapped in their marketing pitch..
Super video.... Took me thru ups and downs .... I would see the numbers and look at it as a value investor.....thank you Pranjal for excellent effort.... Pls make video about Pesticide companies
Brilliant video Sir, clear understanding of the Buyer, User and the Business point of view.
Hi Pranjal, thank you for making such insightful videos. I find your videos and knowledge so valuable that I just can't help but share them among my friends and also feel empowered.
Length doesn't matter for video , you videos help a lot in business studies. These series " Understand Busniess" is awsommme...😇🥰😍
That's why we are with you ❤
Superb knowledge Sir 🙏🙏
Hey Pranjal, thanks for candid views.. Your analysis is truly awesome
This Series is excellent Initiative by FINOLOGY team! Keep Awaring us with such Insightful videos!
As a Club Mahindra member since 12 years now, I agree to everything you said, except just a piece of information: there is not extra person cost, in terms of money, if the member is itself present... They'll just deduct "days" from the member's account for each extra room... Also, unused days from 3 years are available to be used at any time :) Based on the colour of your membership and room types, number of days deducted is calculated... Suppose, I have a membership of red colour and room type 1BR, and I get 1 room booked which is studio, number of days deducted will not be whole 1 day, it will be in points.... Similarly if I choose during a lower colour type, it will be a lesser number.. And vice versa...
Sir, if I have paid for the previous year's ASF but the unused days are carried forward. I can't enjoy those lapsed days unless I pay ASF for the current year, right! When I have already paid that year's ASF 😢😢😢
They are scamsters.... Investigation is on... They will be arrested soon... The chairman has already resigned to avoid arrest.
We came accross one similar company. Vivanta. They say it's joint venture of Taj by Tata. They even come down from Rs. 5 lakh to Rs. 1200 per month as EMI option to desperately sell the membership.
Perfect Observation. I have gone through all these points you have mentioned. As a Buyer member, it is ok. But very good for investors. Thanks.
Pichle 2 mahine se me aap ke video dekhta aa raha hun apki har ek video dekh li hai ,bahut kuch Janne ko mila, me ye nahi keh Raha ke me expert ban gaya hun, bas itna kehna chahta hun ke meri age group ke kai logo se to me kai guna jyada stock market ko samaj chuka hun.
Pranjalji apka bahut bahut dhanyawad sab kuch itni asan lenguage ne samjane ke liye , bahut sukriya
You increasing the bar of brilliance and benchmark with every video. Well Done Pranjal 😊
Sir nice video , I have done some calculations basis details given by you
As per you club Mahindra has 3,00,000 members and rooms available in all the resorts are 4000
So club Mahindra can give stay to total 4000 members i a day and in 356 days total stay to members are =4000*365 =14,60,000 stays considering all the rooms are booked for 365 days however they have 3,00,000 members and they need to give 7 nights to each member that’s come out to =3,00,000 * 7 =21,00,000 stays that is short by 6,40,000 nights that means 640000/7=91428 members will no be able to book room
If club Mahindra don’t have sufficient rooms they why are they adding members correct me if have done some error in calculation data picked according to said by you
Thank you for such a wonderful video and analysing businesses in such a simple manner that a layman can understand. Can you make a video on Real Estate industry. Their business model, what an investor, buyer should look for etc. Thank you
Superb Pranjal...few days back only, this was the topic of discussion n voila u have made vdo with such detailing n taking all aspects...Keep doing hard work
The analysis of the idea would have been more interesting if you would have thrown more facts to support the actual revenue model of Club Mahindra. Considering Club Mahindra is way old than Netflix and other subscription model their no of customers growth is way less. Next, I know many customers of Club Mahindra who are dissatisfied with their poor service and lack of room availability.
They are scamsters.... Investigation is on... They will be arrested soon... The chairman has already resigned to avoid arrest.
Yaa.... I have read this Company Article on finology.।। Interesting Article that have you delivered
I am a premium member of Club Mahindra since 17 years....I found it very useful if you use it wisely....
Great research brother... eagerly waiting for these types of more videos 👍👍
Business games....very informative and mind blowing series
Strong recommendation : Never buy these plans ... remember OPPORTUNITY COST and LOCK IN
22 minute long video shows your dedication for viewers
One of the best parts of this case study is that it is in Hindi!! Brilliant Video thanks Pranjal.
You made my day Pranjal..I was looking out for this, not becoz I want to be a member but I WANT TO BE IT'S BIGGEST COMPETITOR.. thanks a ton..
This is one of the best series in TH-cam ♥️
Purely trapping, eye opener video, Good job !!
Great information...eye opener video... great job done Pranjal bhai keep it up
The only thing I like about u sir is your honesty towards yours audience❤️
Superb h ye video,,great work
Wonderful✨😍 vedio thank❤🙏 you very much good research really I love it. That too from you it's a God blessing.
Loving this series ❤️
Content was so much amazing didn't noticed that 22 minutes got over
Best Plan would be to Invest in Mutual Fund or Liquid Fund
Your Principal Amount would be intact + Together with Annual Fees (20000) & Interest/return on that Investment which would be approx 20000 per year, Enjoy with any resorts in India with any season and get variety of Travel & Hotels
Bad Option to go for this Membership
Invest and Enjoy travel Worldwide 🔥
Love this series 👍
I love this #BusinessGames Series...❤️
Very informative video Pranjal. As someone who has been hoodwinked into purchasing a timeshare from Country Club Resorts, can vouch that this is exactly what happens to customers.
This Club Mahindra membership seems like a total nonsense and a clear scam. Thanks for providing your valuable analysis.
I had never seen a mature and true person like you❤❤
Pranjal bhai bhuth research lagi ha iss video me. Thank you big brother
Amazing series, thank you.
pls bring more
One thing 🤔let's say person is paying one time payment of 5,00,000 and annual maintenance fee 20,000 for 25 years...so in total it cost 5,00,000 + 20000*25 = 10,00,000
Am I thinking in a right way? Or am I missing something 🧐
Yeah it sounds really weird and not a bit attractive.
Plus 20000 is not fixed it will increase
1. High transport cost, when you go out for sight seeing, shopping.
2. High food bills.
3. Lapsed holiday days, if you couldn't use it for any reason.
4. Time wasted in traveling.
5. When you want to go out, family will think twice - Market is so far away, रहने दो इतनी दूर कौन जाए।
It should be 25 times, whenever you want, instead of 7 days in a year. If insted of two persons 4 persons join as a group deduct two trips from the total number of times. For senior citizens who are capable of paying that fat amount of ₹5 lakhs at a time 25 years period is not required at all.
Later life they can not move as many times yearly.
It should be like this.
2 members 25 times no limit per year.
4 members 12.5 times.
5 members 10 times.
That kind of free occupancy will allow people to choose such plans. Flexibility is more important to people rather rigid rules, to spoil their holiday moods.
Country club member here
Organised scam these are , just ignore these,stay happy
CCIL is a scam for sure 😊
Yesss... loving the series ❤️
Superb analysis and equally superb explaination. Thanks
Thank You Very Much.
Superb Sirji👍
I respect your honesty to tell everything. Great explanation.
You are adding a value in my life you are like myself ..
Hi Pranjal, thank you for sharing this. Your business games series is insightful.
Broadly speaking we can say that the membership count is going to increase because of the boost in per capita income and digital accessibility in the years to come. I have one question - in spite of this profitable business model, share price of the business hasn't moved much in the last 12 years. Have they recently adopted this business model?
I agree with growing per capita since liberalisation, but many people critically argue that these hotels have expensive food menu also these hotels are far away from cities hence the travel expenses increases, also many people don't go for vacation as jobs in informal sectors doesn't give much holidays apart from that this service is only for selective people as many of them find loss as they don't go for vacation every year. Just my personal biased criticism, you guys can highly disagree too
Suppose , instead of paying them 5 lakh , we invest these 5 lakhs and stay invested for minimal 1 yrs in good stock .. i assume we will get minimum 10% as return on those 5 lakhs .. we will make 50,000 ( minimum) ... plus we also save 20,000 of annual maintenance charges .. that makes 50,000 + 20,000 per year ... plus our 5 lakh is also with us .. so, all I want to say instead of giving them 5 lac for their membership fee ,we can easily make a very good holiday without giving them any penny with those 70,000 that we have earned and saved thru investing ...
@@golujain4125 right ,in those 70k ,anyone can stay in 5 star for 14 days instead of 7 days offered by them which is near to the sight seeing place
True improvement in share price is not so impressive
It is not a good business model if it exploits any stakeholders especially the customer, one should not be involved in anyway with such an exploitative enterprise.
Super bhaiya.. the way you speak it's simply magical...
Thanks for sharing such hidden secrets of these Businesses Pranka ji...
SUPER EXPLAINED SIR
From outside the Idea of Club mahindra looks good, but nowadays Indians are more cautious about the world, and now everyon knows ki C Mahindra's Hotel will be 40-50 km away where the cost of taxi will increase, because of remote location the prineness of property fades away, so most probably in near future The exixting members of club mahindra will start complining and their sales will go down drastically. Moreover it is not absolutely free, they charge you for food too and I guess they charge GST from the consumer so all in all this Club mahindra thing will not be able to survive in long run.
👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻Awesome thank you for making this type of videos
Anything that limits me in repeatedly doing same activity, even if it is about fun, enjoy and entertainment
I will never ever get into this.
One more disadvantage is that if I go with my cousin or friends, I will insist them for Mahindra and they will resist to go on a cheaper hotel/resort and it will lead to disagreement and mess 😑
mind opening video,never watched such a wonderful analysis before
this was a fantastic analysis ..thank you very much
you are a great sir 🙂
Please do analysis over starbucks business model..
Why it has unbeatable streak of success and fame.
Appreciating your efforts and content quality, hatsoff to you sir.
Sir you are best youtuber i seen till now🙂
Your explanations are brilliant🔥
Excellent in-depth analysis.. With correct adv n dis adv . Of club mahindra membership
Sar I am personally a member club Mahindra each and every single thing that you have said is absolutely correct whether it is an upgrade whether it is food cost whether it is extra person charged absolutely scam these people are running
It's not scam it's business model stupid 😂
STOCK MARKET HERO
And
FINANCIAL EXPERT
One and only PRANJAL sir
👌👌Ek Number analysis hats off
Brilliant Content sir I loved it ❤️💯
Please Make Video on Flats Vs Plot.... By the Way Never Miss Your Video....❤️🙏
Being a hotelier i have attended their seminar and it was clear that their sales services are poor. Their agents hides all these and many others Terms and Conditions, normal public can be easily traped.
It's eye 👀 opener video. 👍 Thanks 😊 a lot.
Amazing Video & learning experience. Thank You
Club Mahindra se pehle country club and RCI both tried this model, with influx of airbnb it crashed
Why in the world I would pay lacs of Rupees in advance & AMC every year & still have to pay extra for my traveling, food cost? No financially wise would ever purchase their membership. I would much rather have the flexibility of planning my vacations on my own terms & save myself all that money.
Very nicely explained.. Kudos.
In my opinion, one should first start investing , earn and spend . Spending is necessary to boost indian economy.
I am Retail investor since 2010 and took club Membership in 2015 .
Let’s explore India first to boost Indian economy.
Jai Hind .
Well done 👏. Analyzed CM business in a very simple language 👍
Invest 5 lakhs in bonds (8.5%)
40K ~ in this amount you can easily book a 4 star hotel for a week