Karachi's forgotten Jewish community
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ก.ค. 2015
- (9 Jun 2011)
AP Television
Karachi, April 11, 2011
1. Mid caretakers of the Jewish graveyard walking past graves
2. Close up of grave stone
3. Pull focus of grave stones
4. Mid of graves
5. SOUNDBITE (Urdu) Mehrunnisa Bibi, Caretaker, Gulshan Graveyard:
"The last they came was six months ago, put flowers on graves and left; they do live here in the neighbourhood of Gulshan, but they don't make themselves apparent. They told me not to tell anyone who they are, they go by the surname of Koreshi, they stay very quiet about their identity."
6. Various graves
7. Chand Arif cleaning dust off tomb stone
8. Various of tombstone
9. SOUNDBITE (Urdu) Chand Arif, Caretaker, Gulshan Graveyard:
"I remember seeing three or four funerals here, they used to bring the dead on a horse driven carriage, they used to place the bodies on a platform inside the graveyard and perform the last rites. They were tall people, well built and used to wear small caps on their heads, they were very nice people, they used to give us money to look after the place, and never gave us any grief. Normally around 400-500 people would visit each funeral."
10. Various of the graveyard
AP Television
Karachi, 12th April
11. SOUNDBITE (Urdu) Mumtaz Ali, Hashoo, Curator, Karachi Museum :
"They weren't that rich or influential, what or how they were thinking about the future of the Jewish community wasn't really known, unlike the Christians, who were very well organised at that point, their commission, and their churches, the Christians had a direct link with Italy (Vatican). By comparison, very little was known about Jewish people here, people close to them did think that they were from the desert of Sinai."
12. Various of Madi Hashoo shopping mall which now stands on the site of the Magain Shalome Synagogue
13. Various of people shopping
14. Various of shopping mall
15. Wide exterior of living quarters of Jewish people who lived in Karachi
16. Various of interiors
17. Tilt up from traffic to clock tower
18. Mid of traffic
19. Close tilt up of the star of David on the tower
20. Mid of tower
21. Close up of name plate inside the tower
22. Wide of tower
23. Close up tower
24. Pan of architectural drawings of a mosque drawn by Jewish architect
25. Tight of the front facade on the drawing
26. SOUNDBITE (English) Yasmin Lari, Architectural Historian:
"Moses Somake has a very definite style that he pursued, all his buildings are very robust in nature, they all use the beautiful Gizri stone of Karachi and a lot of times they are nicely treated - the stones are not just put in there - they are properly treated."
27. Tilt up of mosque drawings
28. SOUNDBITE (English) Yasmin Lari, Architectural Historian:
"It was a very tolerant city, that Muslims of the area were quite willing and happy to commission an architect who was Jewish. That means a lot of trust and faith in the architect, they obviously held him in great esteem, maybe he belonged to that community, maybe he lived there, we don't know where he actually lived, we do know where he worked because we found his (business) letterheads."
34. Tight pan of Moses Somake's official letterhead
35. Wide of the same
LEAD IN:
Karachi, Pakistan's largest city and financial hub, was once home to a thriving Jewish community.
Most left the city after an increase in anti-semitism in Pakistan following the 1967 Six Day War.
But the community left their cultural mark on the city - and some say a handful still live here in secret - watching over their architecture and graveyards.
STORYLINE:
Find out more about AP Archive: www.aparchive.com/HowWeWork
Twitter: / ap_archive
Facebook: / aparchives
Instagram: / apnews
You can license this story through AP Archive: www.aparchive.com/metadata/you...
My early brought up was in Sadar Karachi back in 60's when we had Jewish families living in our neighbourhood. My best friend in those days was Parsi/Jewish called David and his father was Robin.
Those were good days.
Synagogue shown in clip was in our close vicinity. I have great respect for this community
Where is he now sir?
Not known, unfortunately
Its good to hear from you mate . Plus happy to see your doing good. Jewish community was around Gulshan area of Karachi.
goood comment bhaijaan luve from matli city zilla badin sindh Pakistan 20/11/22 💞💞💞🌷♥️♥️
@@shoukatalisoomro7056 love just sindh and karachi it feels like home India the diversity the tolerance i hope all extrimist from both nations know people need to coexist with love and peace
EVERY PAKISTANI HAVE A RIGHT TO LIVE FREELY ACCORDINGLY HIS RELIGION
ZAIN JUTT
Agar ye sach ha
To aapka dil se shukrgujar hu
ZAIN JUTT! Mulla dont care and become GOD
Only words after 70 years of genocide of jews, hindus, sikhs, jains, buddhists...
Now all minorities of pakistan hare eliminated, and so pakistan is talking of tolerance of minorities to india and others. So clever huh?
@nuvvnak nacha Ye aap ke maan baap ki tarbiat hai jo zuban istimaal kar rahe ho wo bhee koi waja ke beghair.
@nuvvnak nacha Taleem hasil ker taleem. Mein ne aap ko na koi gali dee or na hi bura. Dehshat gard to aap ho jo zubaan se dehshat garrdi ker rahe ho.Pata nahi kitne muslamano to India me aap ne tashadud ka nishana banaya hoga.
ALL minorities and their sacred placed MUST be respected in Pakistan. We will - not let - evil tarnish our loving image.
Not as long as islam is the state religion
Nasser MJ - Indeed we are all pakistanis and we should all 💘 one another and help each other 😊
Shivani so is hinduism.Forget about cow lynching and riots due to hindu fundamentalism. I'm not targeting any religion but extremism of any religion is harmful.
rational Dude well then what is cow lynching, RSS who said that minorities of india should revert back to hinduism or they can't live. Once india was a secular country but now it won't.
If you want others to be secular, be secular yourself first, which means leave islam as islam is ANTI SECULAR.
All other faiths today have reformed and are compatible with secular as they have left the path of fear threats coercion and violence and accept free speech that critics religion their fake gods and rituals etc. Only islam is left, and islam is most horrid of all religions right now as it has resisted all attempts to reform it from within. Killer religion.
We love them. Please don't hide your identity. This is your country too
Bisma Baloch this is my country and I don't like Jewish
Baloch
why u don't like them. jewophobic.
Balushi Khake this is not your country according to biology and history you are converted..and they are genuine
King Caligula am baloch and u know my history very well what we are
As pr quaid e azam promise every Pakistani have equal right regardless of their religion
yea well he's dead and mullahs have the power now keep voting for muslim league..
Jinnah said so. But look at the present constitution. Look at the school text books.
Every thing becomes transperant.
But brother,this promise of barister jinnah was mercilessly broken by one man.gen zia ul haq.
@@veeraaa6344 well im pakistani but im glad zia ul haq died in plane crash I hope he suffered
@@veeraaa6344 agreed
I know this vdo about Pakistan but why these indiANTS from bhaRAT spewing venom for over here!!!??,respect for Pakistan from great Nepal.
Respect from Pakistan💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚
Love u brother. We are peace loving friendly people
love you bro. Nepalese are very friendly people as we have many in our company in Riyadh
@@AliAhmed-tm1jf from the religion of peace?
Ali Ahmed, you seen to know all shit, it seems.
Why would people hide their identity? They are all under tremendous pressure to hide themselves or it is for just fun? Do you tolerate other religion? Do you allow them to flourish? What is the growth rate of all minorities in Karachi? In pakistan? In India? In Nepal? In Iraq?, or in say even Myanmar? Hello peaceful man, look at the world you are in and talk. Bharti or Bharati is itself a big world, which has taken other ideas and cultures peacefully. Did not cause wars, distastes,etc.
You make yourself hateful. Stop, see, listen to others and also please tolerate others point of view and other religions too.
I'm so happy to see so many Pakistani Muslims saying that Pakistani Jews are Pakistani too and should not hide their identity and that the people causing problems are not real Muslims.
My family on my mother's side was from Lahore and from Luxor/Egypt - and Jewish.
I love Pakistan, I love Egypt, and I love my Native American background from my father's side.
Unfortunately I have experienced so much hatred and violence from several Pakistanis that I cannot even describe in words what I have been put through. The abuse I suffered was so extreme that nobody even believes me because nobody believes that a human being could do such things to another living being - especially a vulnerable girl that is alone in the world.
On top of that, they denied me my identity as being part Pakistani. They defamed me and stole my identity by making it out that I was "white" and "Western", and "of loose morals". I am neither Caucasian nor Western. I merely live in the UK - as do many other Pakistanis, Egyptians and Americans. I have very strict moral standards, so much so that I have stayed single all my life because I refuse to run around with men. What they did was character assassination. Character assassination is equal to murder in Judaism - because it destroys the standing of a person in society, it destroys a person's honor.
Despite this, my love for Pakistan has never ceased.
Thank you to all the wonderful Pakistani people who encourage Jewish Pakistanis to live freely - you are truly people of real faith, you are wonderful representatives of Pakistan!
Sad to know that! You were, are and will be a Pakistani. Those who didn't accept you as a Pakistani are illiterate brats as history can't be changed. I wish one day, you visit Pakistan and see its beauty. Kindly, do let me know whenever you come so that I can host you in your own country, Pakistan. 🤲🇵🇰
@Witty Witty You have a fundamental misunderstanding of what physical relations are for. They are a celebration of love within a marriage. They are NOT to satisfy your own needs - if you do that, you are using the other person and that is the most selfish and abusive act imaginable, in fact this is r@pe by deception!
Dear little kitty.its your greatness that you are still in love of pakistan.indeed religion is personal afair and pakistani respect minorities religion nation fellows.
You will be most welcome in pakiatan
@@zaryabazad5634 Thank you! I really hope one day I'll be able to see Pakistan again. I've been to Lahore and Mian Channu (near Khanewal) in 2013 and absolutely loved it. There were some negative experiences associated with that trip but just because some people choose to be bad, doesn't make the whole nation bad.
@@LittleKitty22 good to hear
You will always be welcomed
Back in 2013 Pakistan's situation was quite bad because of terrorism
But now believe me Lahore is totally changed
And now is safe too
Don't hide your identity you are as patriot as we are
right bro
It's so shameful that minority don't feel safe here. Our ancestors didn't set this example.. I feel sad 😥
👍
yes they did.
Same as India
wow amazing i never heard about it that in Pakistan we have jewish
+Niaz Afridi There are hundreds of grave yards in Afghanistan of JEWISH people too with Hebrew writing. ONE SYNYGOGE still in Kabul with on Jewish rabi still living there. Others will come if it become peaceful. 20,000 jews lives in Kyrghistan.
Oliver C I know in Afghanistan there is a Jewish I watched his interview
All the Jews were forced to flee Pakistan in 1948.
Niaz Afridi amazing naa
@@semsemeini7905 They did good and flew, as Islamist are mostly run by passions and dictated by radicals. F*K
I love sindh and karachi it feels like home like our India the diversity the tolerance inclusion of all i hope all extrimist from both nations should know people need to coexist with love respect and peace ❤️🇮🇳
Live freely, Practice your religion freely, plz don’t hide your real identity, we respect the rights of every minorities, Love Pakistan, it’s our country, it’s your country too,the most tolerant country in the World, Proud to be a Pakistani.
Han wo tou nazar arha hai kitni respect krtay ho..koi apni identity aisay he nhe chupaya. Keep living in fools paradise.
These peoples are also patriot like us. Pakistan is your country. We love you.
Hello Mr r u mad
I would love to visit that place.
Maria Farooq do inform me b4 going
I know these places.
Ranchorline, Hoti Market, NJV school and surrounding.
Chipak gya kisi yahodi ka Jin tu na bolna bataya nhi tha
chalay
teri ma k andr chipka tha yahudi ka jin@@khan-xz2zy
You guys are Pakistani too, don’t hide your identity, it’s your land too not only ours.
Dont hide your identities you want them to be massacred
MC Gamer - Same advice from me I mean I feel really bad for them.
MOVIES PLANET - Question why eactly would they be massacred ? I mean their human beings just like us regardless of religion.
@@theguyver4934
Maybe you dont know what Pakistanis are upto they hate non Muslims and certainly jews there is hardly a single where clerik doesn't preach hate and spit venom against jews ..
Its a universal fact that Pakistani's are intolorent towards non Muslims btw im a Pakistani
@@moviesplanet9482 I agree, deep inside we are intolerant of them. Christians in punjab have been treated unfairly many times, same with hazara community in quetta. Hindus in sindh were safe until now, recently many hindu girls were forcefully converted into muslim.
There was once a flourishing Jewish community in Karachi ( I have family buried in this graveyard) - paths to reconciliation exist if there is only the will to seek them out...
I would love to see pakistan recognize israel. It would be my greatest wish right now.
I saw a signboard of BOMBAY LIGHT HOUSE at 3.39 at a traffic junction...shows Karachi connection with bombay (mumbai)
Yeah there are many restaurants like delhi kabab etc
Sir sab kuch ak jesa hai kabi Ao to sab dekhain gaye apko....Ak hi tara ki galiyan or roads hain Karachi Or Mumbai Ak jese hi hian takribn...
There are many shops in Karachi which have name of Indian cities.
Nadira, the old actress was Jewish. Karachi is vivid man. I hope that partition never would have happened.
agreed, There should have been a constituional amendment about Muslim seats in national assembly and hindu muslim problem solved.. No partition. If we were one nation, by now we'd be huge super power like competing US and Russia
Very good information thanks
How sad our Jewish community has left us alone. I hope the same does not happen to Jewish community of Iran.
As a Pakistani PAKISTAN sy wafadar jo hy wo Pakistani hy that's it
😂😂😂
Beware of Jews they could be Spy for Israel. and you must distinguish between them if they are true then why they are living as hidden identity? Why not openly coming up as proud Pakistan Jew's.
wow did anyone notice paranomal activity @1:57 that thing came out of nowhere !!
good documentary, could have been little more lengthier and detailed...
where is the of actual location of Gulshan Graveyard?
We are not anti-Jew, we're anti-Zionism. I understand their fear though because there are so many uneducated people who resort to violence, they don't know the difference between a Jew and an Israeli.
Pakistan is the Islamic Republic but it's not Islam only. Pakistan is for all who love and live in it.
We need to educate our family and friends. Please do so. Let's not let our brothers and sisters from other religions suffer. Let's be an example of religious freedom so that the world can see what Islam really is.
Some quotes from the Qur'an and Haddith.
“Beware! Whoever is cruel and hard on a non-Muslim minority, or curtails their rights, or burdens them with more than they can bear, or takes anything from them against their free will; I (Prophet Muhammad) will complain against the person on the Day of Judgment.” (Abu Dawud)
“To the Jews who follow us belong help and equity. He shall not be harmed nor his enemies be aided.”
“Whoever kills a person who has a truce with the Muslims will never smell the fragrance of Paradise.”
“This is a message from Muhammad ibn Abdullah, as a covenant to those who adopt Christianity, near and far, we are with them. Verily I, the servants, the helpers, and my followers defend them, because Christians are my citizens; and by God! I hold out against anything that displeases them. No compulsion is to be on them. Neither are their judges to be removed from their jobs nor their monks from their monasteries. No one is to destroy a house of their religion, to damage it, or to carry anything from it to the Muslims’ houses. Should anyone take any of these, he would spoil God’s covenant and disobey His Prophet. Verily, they are my allies and have my secure charter against all that they hate. No one is to force them to travel or to oblige them to fight. The Muslims are to fight for them. If a female Christian is married to a Muslim, it is not to take place without her approval. She is not to be prevented from visiting her church to pray. Their churches are declared to be protected. They are neither to be prevented from repairing them nor the sacredness of their covenants. No one of the nation (Muslims) is to disobey the covenant till the Last Day (end of the world).”
“…There is no compulsion in religion…”
Shehran Baloch most positive comment on this video.........😊😊😊 you wrote the facts and I know people read it and still they are commenting bad about islam and Pakistan. Showing their minds that they are not different from any ordinary keyboard warrior.... Huhhh.......!!!
Fuck off you Shehran Baloch
I second that shehran! 😊
@Amb Dar You don't know what that is. Also, taqqiya is used to save lives. Albanians used taqqiya to protect Jews from other Europeans. Muslims are permitted to deny their faith if their life is in danger, that is what taqqiya means.
You're clearly uneducated. But please, try again
We are not even against the commoner Israelis, just their govt.
As a Pakistani and Muslim also I hang my head in shame and disgust that any minority Christian Hindu Jew or anyone not Muslim living in Pakistan in fear of their lives just because they are not Muslims they had to live under different name or hide their believe in order to survive in Pakistan if only ignorant Muslim know what Quran orders and what prophet Muhammad ( pbuh ) said about the rights of non Muslims and how many rights non Muslim have living in Muslim lands we should all be ashamed of ourselves may Allah forgive our sins ameen . you can tell a lot about a country the way they treat their citizens specially minority's.
Dear Friend with respect to your views let me tell you this is the main reason why we Indians will never give Jammu and Kashmir to you, so that you dont turn it in to Islamic/Pakistani Muslim only Kashmir....even if for that we loose million of rupees and huge number of lives we will keep J/Kashmir secular as it is now
yes, with muslim majority population, muslim rights will be definitely secured and other minorities can live well within a secular state ,were they to be given into the hands of a "so called" islamic government like pakistan i wouldn't like that for myself.just look at the cases of aasia bibi and mashal khan and now don't tell me that it was just because of some fundamentalist. They'd literally kill you for offending them.
I agreed with you my friend .
Damn the innocence on people's face tho 🥺🥺🥺
Everyone is equal God bless jews this country is not only for muslims
j b Only Musilms made this country for their religion
Like Israel only made for jews
Bhai ye qabristan Karachi k kis area me ha?
Why no subtitles?
Stunning.....
What happens at 1:56 on the right hand side of the grave behind the guy.... Or am i seeing things!!!
lol was it a bird?
Zulfiqar Raffad 👼👼👼👼👼fallen angel?
Yeah there is something 😳😳
It seems like a bird...
it was a polythene
The building madiha square which we have seen in this video was used to be a cynagogue local persons called (Israeli masjid).its located near ranchor lane , (2:50)
Where is this cemetery.
Still there are few in Peshawar, Lahore and Karachi but very few in number and under cover.
how we meet?
so are you still interested in meeting a Jewish person or Jewish Family in Pakistan?
@@InnerLifePhotography I am
We..!! ask me whatever you want to..your all kind of questions are welcome..
@@InnerLifePhotography are you Jew?
What's the location of this graveyard in Karachi?
Mewa Shah lyari
Location?
ye kaha hai karachi mein?
Please watch the video. Exactly on 2 minute mark we see something mysterious. Please reply on this. Could it be a ghost caught on camera ???
Bhai tension na lay, koi billi waghera thi raat kay andheray mein.
Kabootar tha . Saf nzr aya.
Whom they are talking about?
If thy are loyal Pakistani we don’t have any problem from there religion for us thy like brothers and sisters is your country live with full freedom without hiding your identity or religion
Maasha Allah... i wish if could visit them and have few friend forever..
We love them. Please don't hide your identity. This is your country too......yes we all r pakistani love n respect
Han wo tou nazar arha hai kitna love krtay ho..koi apni identity aisay he nhe chupaya. Keep living in fools paradise.
Salam, 🙏🏻 in islam we are also strictly told by our prophet Muhammad s.a.w.s about the preservence of any Grave, by what ever religion 🙏🏻 But, Specially Abraham's Religions 🙏🏻 God Bless Us All, Amen 🌹 Sohail Karachi Pakistan ❤️👍🏻
As a Muslim we must protect all minorities
Nice
Wish it had subtitles....
My father told me that one Jewish family lived in his neighborhood in the 1970s in Karachi. They lighted their Menorah every week and had Mezuhah nailed to their front door.
Which bateau 🤨
Area *^
@@mariyumgee7515 Nazimabad
@@zarinakhan592 thanks
hain ya zinda kesy hain?
Pakistan welcomes every religion and allows them to practice freely. This is the best about Pakistan.
Tabidaking 1 pakistan has s cruelly barbaric culturevin remote villages, stoning and killingbofvapostates
i don't know where you saw that pakistan
Which Pakistan are you talking about?
Oh yeah sure. Ask the Ismailis and the Christians and the Jews who had to flee in 1948. And the Hindus.
Syed M Tabish
I think
You are wrong
In 1947 there was 21% hindus
And right now percentage of hindu is 1. 5%
I respect them as a Muslim Pakistani
O I still remember when I had a friend long time ago. He told me he is qureshi, but once he was telling me about the countries his father visited and Israel was among then, and I asked him how can it be possible when Pakistani passport does not allow but there was not a satisfactory reply since then my mind is intriguing about his background. But I'm damn sure he was a practicing Muslim, perhaps second or third generation Muslim.
ab apka wo dost kidr hai rabtya mai hai ya ni
Kya woh ab bhi apkay rabtay main hay ya nahi?
U r Pakistani also . Don't hide yourself .
Choudhary Ali - What i said we're all pakistanis and we should all help one another and respect each other and this will make a better and more emerging pakistan (amen) 😊
@@theguyver4934 ..hi 03477744525
Feeling so Proud after watching this video that also jews are living in pakistan 😍
Pakistan’s agenda
No minorities no discrimination
Israel was actually the title of prophet Yacob peace be upon him ..
Politics has created a mess if Jews are present here in Pakistan they are Pakistanis we love all our minorities ..
Me bhe yahoodi hon meray id card par mera muslim.likha huwa hi
@@aligawadari2347 Do you hate islam and muslims?Whats your opinion about indian hindus?
@@aligawadari2347 are you serious
@@aligawadari2347 kio likhwaya hy Muslim apne ap Jewish ho to Jewish he likhao mere bhai ap bhi Hamare Pakistani ho ap yaha Azad ho azadi se raho hum apke dushamn nahi hame acha lagyga k ap bhi Pakistan me Hindus or Christian ki tarhan apni pehchan bana k raho aplog kio apni pehchan chupaty ho ? Easi kya waja hy?
@@ihatemylife1179 he has to otherwise he will face consequence of it whole life
Christian Muslims and Jews each of them connected the roots with prophet Hazrat Ibrahim Alahsalam. Allahsubhanatallah bless us saratemustaquam.
Ameensumameen.
Paksitan respect each minority not only Hindu voters
can't say that about Christians in punjab or hazara community in quetta, sorry to say
Han wo tou nazar arha hai kitni respect krta hai...koi apni identity aisay he nhe chupaya. Keep living in fools paradise.
This is Pakistan
And your free 💖
The city looks like our Bombay
No but its our karachi
Becoz it was part of Bombay
mine craft the Sindh and Gujarat are very similar
We should protect our minorities ❤
where's this graveyard ?
Mewa sha lyari
Respected, Jews lived in every vicinity, PECHS, Saddar, Lawrence Road, Nazim Abad, Pak Colony,
I visited in that cemetery before 2 years.
where is it? location
@@rakhshikhan381 Mewashah Cemetery Karachi
@Free Fire Jo apne dekha hai wohi sab hai
@Free Fire Waha bas muslims rehte hain aap pas
I remember there used to be a jewish community near Hoti market in Karachi - But later all the jewish left. Their worshiping place was converted into a shoppping plaza.
Sindh Govt. protect Jewish graveyard.This is a old history of pakistan. I respect all religion.
see the video 1:54 to1:58 behind the men right side the door what is that
manwender singh BIRD
Mystery specialist ?
manwender singh I think that was a pigeon flew down
Jew ki aatma
Shoper
we again capture our lost land again
We love our Pakistani Jews. Love and support
Dont hide ur identity live freely .
Are muslims Christians and jews not cousins of eachother??? As Hazrat Yaqoob and Hazrat Ismail a.s were
It saddens me that there is so much hate. To those talking about all your hate of Jews, have you ever even met a Jewish person? They are good enough when they invent something that will benefit you. Just sad. I am sure that Allah would bow his head in shame over all the hate.
Pakistanis & Muslims only hate jews bcoz Israeli jews killing palastinian muslims and occupying their houses thats the reason of hate. While Pakistani shouldn't hate Pakistani jews who loyal to Pakistan
Every one has Rights to live in pakistan.yahoodi hindu christian sikh jo bhi sub ko haq hai.❤️
I respect all minorities👍
We love you all. Please do not hide your Identity.This country is for all Pakistanis regardless of cast, creed or religions. In Pakistani Law we are all equal. We are all equal under the constitution of Pakistan. We have equal rights in Pakistan.
Pakistan Zindabad.
There are many jews still lives in India currently around 10k-15k especially in Mumbai and konkan region of Maharashtra few pockets in south india and few in north India few in kolkata and so on but they had significant population before later many moved to Isreal as aliyah's to move there's 70k around jews in Isreal of Indian origins which makes upto 1% population of Isreal
Protect them why they hide themselves??? they r citizen of Pakistan , can live peacefully n freely they have rights , Islam is a peaceful religion n give rights for all minorities if any one hurts them he is not a Muslim
mujhe AJ pata laga yahan Jewish community b ha
It is sad and shame for us. That we didn't know, because they have insecurities so that they don't show their identity
We get messages from them that they are fearing for their lives
where u from???
@@dastanale47 Israel
@@user-rx6dv4wh1z u used whtsap?
@@dastanale47 yes
@Panjet slayer ???
I had no idea there were any such thing in Pakistan
Why not
Pakistan main yuhudi bhi Hain ??
Yes alots of jews
@@wajeehabatool2585 A lot of Jews? I don't think there are more than 300-500 Jews in Pakistan.
3.15... This building in Ranchore line was constructed after removing the yahoodi masjid own by Mr Rachel Joseph.
Everyone is free to live regardless and the issue is not being Jewish but what Israel has done to the world had nothing to do with decent Jewish living anywhere.
In English please!
Most of the polish and Jews migrated from Poland .
If qadyiani can live in Pakistan then why can't Jews?
They came in karachi during rule of talpur kings if sindh stayed for long than left
Why that hide their identity .. they're also pakistanis.. we live with hindus christians parsis and sikhs like brothers here in pakistan, jews are also our brothers and pakistanis
Dont hide your identities so that you can kill massacre them? Huuhhh
We are seeing how you are living with hindus sikhs and christians they have been completely squeezed by you guys..
Maryam Sherazi tu phir Kya karay
"Hindus" are not a religion. It's a persian word for any local cult, spirituality that was not Muslim.
@@moviesplanet9482 brain washed idiot how many hindus have been wiped out in pak....in Rani kot 92 %hindus living in interior sindh and so on chrintians and parsies living in khi as compare to india how many mosques gurdawaras and churches have been burnt in pak ....if u have dare just go in india and slaughter a cow after that u will no longer to spread hatred......
i am hindu
But i also love israil ad jewish
Jewih are good loving and honset people
Bro they also killing innocent children women and men in palestine.... Accorrding to amenesty 2800 chilldren killed by israeli forces
@@awesome_0357 OK, so if the caste system is practiced in India by a few people, then all the people are responsible and need to be educated not to treat their fellow humans as lower and upper caste.
@@maklangry5742 I don't think u read what I said I nd yes if there are black sheep's everywhere nd u can't blame entire community for it that's what I said above
@@awesome_0357 OK, thanks,... ISIS is a Zionist creation to attack Muslims only, ISIS has never attacked Israel. US or Nato.
Tou iska matlab hai mera abbo theek kehta tha k ranchor lane main iseali masjid thee jo ab apko raksha k opar building nazar arahe hai
Pakistan is for every Pakistani religious does"t matter after watching the video i feel really bad that u need to hide u identity for your life i am ashamed and sorry for that
it is sad thing. the western and Indian RAW supported seperated Groups from Afghanistan like P.T.M and B.L.A .including the extremist relgious group like T.L.P is dangerous for not even muslims in Pakistan but also every human kind
Why not say bani-israel?
That would mean children of israel instead of jew or israeli.
Its ur country as well dont hide ur identities
پاکستانی یہودیوں کو پاکستان میں مکمل مذھبی آزادی کے ساتھ رھنے کا حق ھے مگر اس وڈیو میں سب سے پہلی بوڑھی خاتون نے بتایا کہ وہ اب انہیں قریشی کہا جاتا ھے..یہ بات غلط ھے
Abdul Khaliq yeh wo dar k boltay hain k unko koi maar na dai. aur qureshi sab muslims nhe thay bhai. Abu jehel muslim tha kya?
Well if we try compare with the Jewish community left in India ....Personally i don't think Pakistan Army would have had one of them among their Top Brass ( eg Lt Gen JFR Jacob ) or the Pakistan Army an admiral such as Ben Samson or even a martyred pilot ( Ft Lt M Sassoon shot over Sargodha in1971 ) ...actors Like David, Nadira or writers such Esther David or Nissim Ezekiel ??? just dropping a few names!!! ....Points to Ponder ???
@@xtylishb4377
This is how u think about minorities in Pakistan. Shame on u.
I think we should resecpt and give rights to jews in pakistan just like all other minorities
Hum pakistani musalmano ne aj tak in pe kisi kisam ka zulm Nahi kya ye log q itne zalim log hain
A Few
Bad Seeds's
rite maria
Mullah JB s takat m aie hn inhone bardast dosre mazahib k li bardast khatam krdi ar upr s jihalat
Those saying to reveal their identity and live free...if today even 1 jew unveiled their identity, they would be lynched by some of our muslim fanatics.. m even worried about the graveyard...what if they destroued it too..