Your question is valid, and I’m sure Engineer bhai will definitely reply to your logical question. He loves rationalism and constructive criticism unlike other scholars who just malign him on personal level
The Sunnah is the living tradition. The Prophet[saw] lived with the Muslims for 23 years. Umar ibn Khattab, Uthaman , Ali , Ayesha [the senior companioins] all lived with Muslim community for decades after the Prophet[saw]. How salat, fasting, umrah, Hajj, the night prayer, the two eids all things we would associate with the Sunnah have been perfectly preserved by the Muslim community. That's why the salafi methodolgy of claiming everthing in Sahih Muslim and Sahih Bukhari [books of ahadith] is true is flawed.
I would never disown imam Bukhari. Some of the daef hadith in his Sahih are clearly not due to him, but later scholars. We have no original manuscript from Imam Bukhari.
@@sparephone8228 Exactly, but after Allah's Quran Imam Malik's Muwatta is the most sound book according to me. Sahih Bukhari, Muslim, tirmidi, ibn Maja, sunan abu Wadood and Musdad e imam hanbal are no different to me. We need to stop giving this divinly status to Bukhari Sharif because even Imam Bukhari didn't give such a high status to it
@@mohammedumarfarhan9900 Imam Malik’s book may contain lots of sahih ahadith, describing the Prophet’s [saw] actions and words, but it’s not the only ahadith book. Don’t forget, a significant number of companions lived outside Madina, e.g. Mecca, Iraq, Yemen, Palestine, Egypt etc. So the city of Madina cannot be the only source of authentic ahadith.
@@sparephone8228 maybe am a bit Maliki and emphasizes much on traditon of madina. But yeah what you say is also correct but for us the Medina tradition supercedes everything
Masses have different levels of understanding and we need diverse ulema teaching them in a variety of manners. Everyone is useful 😊. Traditionally we had knowledgeable divided in groups known as Ahl e Hadith and Ahl e Rae…… Let’s keep learning folks and live by the principle of love and let’s live! 😅
any of the following 1.) you may msg me on instagram 2.) book an 1:1 (hourly) consultation on Patreon/MALM (Tier 2) 3.) sign up for my ebook on my site: www.MuftiAbuLayth.com and you'll be emailed you can respond. Allah bless you 🙌🏻🥰
Why we cant stay within 114 Chapters, then Apply our intellectual faculty & history with historicity. Why trust Zoroastrian Conspirators. Wolves in Sheep's skin. your own Bukhari Gate is a vivid example.
That 114 chapters are preserved as other ahadees were preserved...if we neglect those ahadees based on the way of their collection then following these 114 chapters doesn't mean any sense ..as base is same for all these..
Zubair Ahmed, you are absolutely right. The 114 Chapters are the starting point. And Allah has repeatedly called upon us to use our intellectual faculty in the Quran. The Quran is the furqan. That is the only gold standard. All else are secondary.
@Vihaan4u ignorance?. How. Do you have 100% certainty the collections almost 200 yrs after the prophet. How did they ascertain memory,integrity,reliability.?
@@cameo777There are different types of hadith. The hadith of Ghadeer e Kumm was directly heard by more of the sahaba than even any ayah of the Qur'an except for one ayah which itself was said for the context of the hadith. The hadith was heard by tens of thousands of sahaba. What do you say about that?
@@mdbahrozbaburali where are the hadith of ghadeer e kumm?. Do you know where I can find them?. How relevant are they in today's islam and islamic education. Who talks about them?. Who knows about them?.
Mufti I feel you are not fully utilising your education and wisdom. You need to start having live debates/dialogues with others like the Salafis who claim they are unmatched
No point. Mufti's education and wisdom is only good for thought for people with at least an ounce of rationality. Debating or dialoguing with arrogant idiots is like banging your head against a brick wall.
Ahadith were generated and infact favorable ones kept for misuse by Abbasid rulers Sunnah is some thing genuine practice of Muslims of Medinah from Muhammad s a w till today
Tbf they’re still 1 step closer than most other Muslims out their. They still Follow more ‘sahih’ Hadiths but as mufti said he digs deep but not deep enough to ask the questions regarding if those ‘sahih’ graded Hadiths are really sahih. All we can say is may Allah guide him, his heart seems pure
@@sohailislam3416 that's exactly my point! He follows the sahih ahadith of 6 hadith books which makes him an ahl e hadith. He is wrong when he says he dosent belong to any sect ! He follows the ahl e hadith school.
@@rayanhassan3795 you don't even know the definition of ahl e hadith , anyone who considers khabar e wahid as hujjat ! Is called ahl e hadith, 95% of sahih hadith is khabar e wahid. Only a minority ( ahl e hadith ) considers khabar e wahid a hujjat, majority of ummah does not agree with it.
Well there are still red lines in the deen however much we might not want to acknowledge; trespassing such borders of deen renders one heretical or in disbelief kufr, or some sort of evil biddah; one must abstain from such foreign practices/ideas to stay safe in deen and be part of the ummah.
@@musawer5 if speaking and understanding Arabic is the deciding factor, then there are thousands of deobandi and barelvis mufti’s who are just spreading misinformation and dogma. Engineer is 100x better than them, even if he doesn’t understand arabic. The damage has been done.
So Mufti, you're great and i love you but i hate to say this but on this issue you have straw maned Eng. Mirza Sahab. He actually firstly does believe what you believe that there is a difference between Hadith and Sunnah and quite brillantly explains how do they fit with each other: th-cam.com/video/fqiv5VeLayw/w-d-xo.html Secondly he doesn't say to the Hanafis, Malikis or anyone that they don't have a right to exist or that they are out of the fold of islam and all these extreme fanatical positions of some extremists in Islam. He literally has a video titled "Don't curse/say bad words to the Ulema, only do a knowledge based disaggrement"[Iktilaf based on Ilm]: th-cam.com/video/USarRapCxq8/w-d-xo.html Also another video explaning that he doesn't do excommunication (Takfir) of any mainstream branches of Islam titled "Why i don't do Takfir": th-cam.com/video/j3zws-4VQOM/w-d-xo.html So Mufti as much as i love hearing you, on this matter you have been misinformed. But thats okay we all are humans.
This engineer is not a "shaykh" he doesn't know Arabic he reads Urdu translation and commentaries and you can tell he heavily relies on these as he cannot quote from earlier salaf , and I wonder why maybe it's because nobody has translated their work into urdu
He criticises every school of Jurisprudence, says the Muqallid are now follow Islam they are following thier Babas, He doesn't respect difference of opinion, criticises them,and claim that only his Fatwa or opinions is correct and is a.q to Quran & Sunnah, He makes fun of the miracles of Auliya/Saints. He always mocks other and challenges other, but never accepts the Debate. Is created new conflicts, another flights has been started between his followers and followers of other schools. And they claims they are true Muslim, truly following Quran & Sunnah, without any sect(a logical fallacy) rest are wrong.
you are not even clear in your own argument . cmon man if you cant explain what you wana tell us how can you do such a video. pehlay sooch lo bolna kia hay phir video banaya karo mian !
@@Huzaifakhosa. in that case khomeni has way more followers than mirza ..... having a large number of followers have nothing to do with truth and reality
Brother you're good I like your lectures But want I think is that is not right to give lectures in Islam when you're not using the right sauces to give to the peoples that men's you're lieying to them
NO OFFENSE BUT BRO... Hey You're Disrespecting the Blessing Of ALLAH. Come on Buckle up.. Start your Marathon on TH-cam Again get up and Get going... Spread the Knowledge you've been blessed with.
@@GAMING24HOURS693 میرے معصوم بھائی آپکو اہلحدیث کے معنی اور تعریف ہی نہیں معلوم ، ہر وہ شخص اہلحدیث ہوتا ہے جو کتب ستہ کی ستہصحیح سند والی خبر واحد کو حجت مانتا ہو۔ باقی مرزا علی صاحب کے اپنے چند تفردات ہیں اور تفرد کی وجہ سے کوئی شخص فرقے سے باہر نہیں ہو جاتا مرزا انجنیئر بھائی سو فیصد اہلحدیث ہیں ۔
@@GAMING24HOURS693 see you yourself are propagating the ahl e hadith narrative because of your superficial knowledge, 90% of sahih hadith is khabar e wahid ! And khabar e wahid is not a hujjat on ummah.Only a minority (ahl e hadith) considers khabar e wahid as hujjat.The majority of ummah has always been ahl e ijtihad and took deen from living tradition.
SubhanAllah, A true scholar and a wise man Mufti Abu Layth, a very technical point my brother
Islam needs more of Mufti Abu layth as well
Love you Mufti reasoning is very important; in every step in life and religion is no exception.
Your question is valid, and I’m sure Engineer bhai will definitely reply to your logical question. He loves rationalism and constructive criticism unlike other scholars who just malign him on personal level
ان كنت لا تدري فتلك مصيبة
و ان كنت تدري فمصيبة اعظم
As poet “naughty” said:Ignorance is bliss
This is so awesome to hear.
Like wow.
But why the video is so short mufti? Any full video where you go in full detail please link it to me ♥️
The Sunnah is the living tradition. The Prophet[saw] lived with the Muslims for 23 years. Umar ibn Khattab, Uthaman , Ali , Ayesha [the senior companioins] all lived with Muslim community for decades after the Prophet[saw]. How salat, fasting, umrah, Hajj, the night prayer, the two eids all things we would associate with the Sunnah have been perfectly preserved by the Muslim community. That's why the salafi methodolgy of claiming everthing in Sahih Muslim and Sahih Bukhari [books of ahadith] is true is flawed.
Even Bukhari and Muslim never liked each other. And people disowned Bukhari in his latter days
I would never disown imam Bukhari. Some of the daef hadith in his Sahih are clearly not due to him, but later scholars. We have no original manuscript from Imam Bukhari.
@@sparephone8228 Exactly, but after Allah's Quran Imam Malik's Muwatta is the most sound book according to me. Sahih Bukhari, Muslim, tirmidi, ibn Maja, sunan abu Wadood and Musdad e imam hanbal are no different to me. We need to stop giving this divinly status to Bukhari Sharif because even Imam Bukhari didn't give such a high status to it
@@mohammedumarfarhan9900 Imam Malik’s book may contain lots of sahih ahadith, describing the Prophet’s [saw] actions and words, but it’s not the only ahadith book. Don’t forget, a significant number of companions lived outside Madina, e.g. Mecca, Iraq, Yemen, Palestine, Egypt etc. So the city of Madina cannot be the only source of authentic ahadith.
@@sparephone8228 maybe am a bit Maliki and emphasizes much on traditon of madina. But yeah what you say is also correct but for us the Medina tradition supercedes everything
Engineer Muhammad Ali bhai is ❤
Finally mufti abu laith noticed Muhammad Ali Mirza.
He already did in the Past. ۔he had already made a vdo on him when he was attacked
@@saeerseik7577 attach the link, i wanna see that clip.
Masses have different levels of understanding and we need diverse ulema teaching them in a variety of manners. Everyone is useful 😊.
Traditionally we had knowledgeable divided in groups known as Ahl e Hadith and Ahl e Rae……
Let’s keep learning folks and live by the principle of love and let’s live! 😅
That's true analysis about Engr. sb....
Jazaka'Allah bro!
We need malm Sunday nights pleas please please
Mufti sb how can I get in touch with you please tell me
any of the following
1.) you may msg me on instagram
2.) book an 1:1 (hourly) consultation on Patreon/MALM (Tier 2)
3.) sign up for my ebook on my site: www.MuftiAbuLayth.com and you'll be emailed you can respond.
Allah bless you 🙌🏻🥰
Why we cant stay within 114 Chapters, then Apply our intellectual faculty & history with historicity. Why trust Zoroastrian Conspirators. Wolves in Sheep's skin. your own Bukhari Gate is a vivid example.
That 114 chapters are preserved as other ahadees were preserved...if we neglect those ahadees based on the way of their collection then following these 114 chapters doesn't mean any sense ..as base is same for all these..
How on earth one will understand those 114 chapters without Ahadees. Ahadees are the tashreeh / explanation of those 114 chapters.
Zubair Ahmed, you are absolutely right. The 114 Chapters are the starting point. And Allah has repeatedly called upon us to use our intellectual faculty in the Quran. The Quran is the furqan. That is the only gold standard. All else are secondary.
@@muhammadobaidullahhashmi4334
QURAN doesn't need anything or anyone to authenticate it. QURAN itself is sufficient for it's authenticity. Stop lying
@@muhammadobaidullahhashmi4334 QURAN is self-sufficient for it's authenticity.
Exactly what i have been thinking since years
Allah bless you my brother, you are amazing subhanalah, زادك الله علما وشرفا. You are a true scholar mufthi, I love listening to your wisdom.
very kind words, Allah bless you 🙌🏻❤
Balanced view although it is necessary to point out the opinions of scholars hold no weight in front of the sayings and actions of the prophet
The point is we dont hv 100% assurity of what the prophet did except the Quran
@@TwinofIcarus Ignorance
@Vihaan4u ignorance?. How. Do you have 100% certainty the collections almost 200 yrs after the prophet. How did they ascertain memory,integrity,reliability.?
@@cameo777There are different types of hadith. The hadith of Ghadeer e Kumm was directly heard by more of the sahaba than even any ayah of the Qur'an except for one ayah which itself was said for the context of the hadith. The hadith was heard by tens of thousands of sahaba. What do you say about that?
@@mdbahrozbaburali where are the hadith of ghadeer e kumm?. Do you know where I can find them?. How relevant are they in today's islam and islamic education. Who talks about them?. Who knows about them?.
Mufti I feel you are not fully utilising your education and wisdom. You need to start having live debates/dialogues with others like the Salafis who claim they are unmatched
I totally agree.
Debates are a waste of time
Mufti has already done that years ago.
No point. Mufti's education and wisdom is only good for thought for people with at least an ounce of rationality.
Debating or dialoguing with arrogant idiots is like banging your head against a brick wall.
@@syedrashidraza5630 Never give up on people.
Aoa
Sir this is Hassan Raza from Pakistan...
Plz do a talk with Hassan Allahayari he is becoming an ICON for comparative study aalim
Ahadith were generated and infact favorable ones kept for misuse by Abbasid rulers
Sunnah is some thing genuine practice of Muslims of Medinah from Muhammad s a w till today
Great insight
Iss ko maturity kehte hain👍
Sadly mirza & his followers fail to comprehend these points because of being ahl e hadith themselves.
Tbf they’re still 1 step closer than most other Muslims out their. They still
Follow more ‘sahih’ Hadiths but as mufti said he digs deep but not deep enough to ask the questions regarding if those ‘sahih’ graded Hadiths are really sahih. All we can say is may Allah guide him, his heart seems pure
@@sohailislam3416 that's exactly my point! He follows the sahih ahadith of 6 hadith books which makes him an ahl e hadith. He is wrong when he says he dosent belong to any sect ! He follows the ahl e hadith school.
@@musawer5 well he really speaks on Bukhari 2812 and Muslim 240..
Following hadith don’t make anyone alhe hadith. 2812 is a living example.
@@rayanhassan3795 you don't even know the definition of ahl e hadith , anyone who considers khabar e wahid as hujjat ! Is called ahl e hadith, 95% of sahih hadith is khabar e wahid. Only a minority ( ahl e hadith ) considers khabar e wahid a hujjat, majority of ummah does not agree with it.
WOW such a great lecture and I can't believe he didn't laugh 100 times it's refreshing and relaxed to listen to him now
Age brings wisdom brother, I think mufthi is maturing gracefully, I really like this scholar as a maliki myself
@@fasalalbana4913 he is soothing but i do not follow Hadith at all. Quran only.
Beautiful ♥️
Mufti Sahib please invite Shaykh Wajahat Hussain al-Hanafi in your programme.
Current time engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza best islamic SCHLOR specially for indo-pak-banglades ❤️
I want to say one thing babey te Shay hi koi nhi 🤣🤣🤣🇮🇳
qayamat ko dekh lenge
@@gladiator8192 tumhre babo par jab kam padega
@@Mirzaa97 i wonder tum apna deen kaha se lete ho, because at the end everything relies on those "Babas"
@@gladiator8192 Qur'an aur hadesh tumhra ala hazrat ya thanvi se 😂
@@Mirzaa97 stop your arrogance & for once defend your claim if you are truthful
I do agree to disagree, because i state respectfully i am yet to see where and how Engineer has tuned a blind eye rather that hypothetical scenarios
Well there are still red lines in the deen however much we might not want to acknowledge; trespassing such borders of deen renders one heretical or in disbelief kufr, or some sort of evil biddah; one must abstain from such foreign practices/ideas to stay safe in deen and be part of the ummah.
❤
I love engineer saheb and mufti abu layth! Both are absolute genius of our time. 👍
Why do you love him?
But mufti abu layth can speak arabic and engineer cannot.
@@musawer5 if speaking and understanding Arabic is the deciding factor, then there are thousands of deobandi and barelvis mufti’s who are just spreading misinformation and dogma. Engineer is 100x better than them, even if he doesn’t understand arabic.
The damage has been done.
@@rayanhassan3795 Firqoon ki dukaan band
He's a Mufti and Ali Mirza is a engineer..
سر ہفتہ وار ایک وڈیو اردو میں بھی اپلوڈ کیا کریں
engineer mirza is a great man in pakistan!!! ❤❤❤
Lets have debate between Abu Layth and Engineer
Like if you are agree 👍
mufti sahab u didn't laugh this tym.
lol missed it
ngl engineer is really good
He is just dissing Muawiya RadiAllahu all the time which is absolutely ridiculous. He is inviting a great catastrophy on himself and his followers
So Mufti, you're great and i love you but i hate to say this but on this issue you have straw maned Eng. Mirza Sahab. He actually firstly does believe what you believe that there is a difference between Hadith and Sunnah and quite brillantly explains how do they fit with each other: th-cam.com/video/fqiv5VeLayw/w-d-xo.html
Secondly he doesn't say to the Hanafis, Malikis or anyone that they don't have a right to exist or that they are out of the fold of islam and all these extreme fanatical positions of some extremists in Islam. He literally has a video titled "Don't curse/say bad words to the Ulema, only do a knowledge based disaggrement"[Iktilaf based on Ilm]: th-cam.com/video/USarRapCxq8/w-d-xo.html
Also another video explaning that he doesn't do excommunication (Takfir) of any mainstream branches of Islam titled "Why i don't do Takfir": th-cam.com/video/j3zws-4VQOM/w-d-xo.html
So Mufti as much as i love hearing you, on this matter you have been misinformed. But thats okay we all are humans.
This engineer is not a "shaykh" he doesn't know Arabic he reads Urdu translation and commentaries and you can tell he heavily relies on these as he cannot quote from earlier salaf , and I wonder why maybe it's because nobody has translated their work into urdu
lol he knows arabic too but he doesn't have any islamic degree
He criticises every school of Jurisprudence, says the Muqallid are now follow Islam they are following thier Babas, He doesn't respect difference of opinion, criticises them,and claim that only his Fatwa or opinions is correct and is a.q to Quran & Sunnah, He makes fun of the miracles of Auliya/Saints. He always mocks other and challenges other, but never accepts the Debate.
Is created new conflicts, another flights has been started between his followers and followers of other schools. And they claims they are true Muslim, truly following Quran & Sunnah, without any sect(a logical fallacy) rest are wrong.
You have not done justice
you are not even clear in your own argument . cmon man if you cant explain what you wana tell us how can you do such a video. pehlay sooch lo bolna kia hay phir video banaya karo mian !
Everyone rejected him and makes fun of him
He is a layman tbh
@@Huzaifakhosa. in that case khomeni has way more followers than mirza ..... having a large number of followers have nothing to do with truth and reality
Brother you're good I like your lectures
But want I think is that is not right to give lectures in Islam when you're not using the right sauces to give to the peoples that men's you're lieying to them
Using the right sauce is very important. I use a mix of cholula original and Hellmanns mayonnaise.
@@haroon420 how they taste like
I always give the right sauce when I'm lying on men..... 😅
NO OFFENSE BUT BRO...
Hey You're Disrespecting the Blessing Of ALLAH.
Come on Buckle up..
Start your Marathon on TH-cam Again get up and Get going...
Spread the Knowledge you've been blessed with.
Bro my salafi friend don't like this man at all 🤣🤣🤣 but i like him m not salafi
Mirza himself is a salafi ( ahl e hadith)
@@musawer5 no brother
@@GAMING24HOURS693 میرے معصوم بھائی آپکو اہلحدیث کے معنی اور تعریف ہی نہیں معلوم ، ہر وہ شخص اہلحدیث ہوتا ہے جو کتب ستہ کی ستہصحیح سند والی خبر واحد کو حجت مانتا ہو۔ باقی مرزا علی صاحب کے اپنے چند تفردات ہیں اور تفرد کی وجہ سے کوئی شخص فرقے سے باہر نہیں ہو جاتا مرزا انجنیئر بھائی سو فیصد اہلحدیث ہیں ۔
@@musawer5 righht. But dont divide this ummah in sects. Follow Quran and authentic hadees and the scholars whom you trust
@@GAMING24HOURS693 see you yourself are propagating the ahl e hadith narrative because of your superficial knowledge, 90% of sahih hadith is khabar e wahid ! And khabar e wahid is not a hujjat on ummah.Only a minority (ahl e hadith) considers khabar e wahid as hujjat.The majority of ummah has always been ahl e ijtihad and took deen from living tradition.
❤❤❤