Was his phone sitting still in his truck when he picked up Maggie's and Paul's? This is chilling. He's caught lying = guilty. He wanted Maggie's estate + life insurance. Probably had life insurance on Paul too(?). Buster said "I do not support my father." I don't even know how AM's family can sit so close to him in the courtroom. I wouldn't put it past AM to put a hit out on Buster or his own siblings from his jail cell, this man is so greedy.
@@shannonmathiscowen8682 they claim there wasn't life insurance on Paul and Maggie. I think this is a lie too. I think there was life insurance in Busters name but not in Alex name. Alex has a ten million dollar life insurance policy on himself and Buster is the beneficiary. That why Alex tried to stage his own murder with his cousin. So Buster could get his life insurance money.
if I sat my phone on the seat of the car, walked over and picked your up your phone walked to the car while trying to unlock it and read the drop down screen then set it down in the car, and picked mine up, walked a bit outside the car and called or messaged your phone, sat mine down, then picked yours up to see if the message sent then set it down again, then drove off, then threw your phone out the window while the screen was off this would account for the difference.
He knows he's screwed as even if he walks for killing his wife and son, he faces close to 100 federal financial crimes that will keep him behind bars for the rest of his life. He's in his 50's now, correct?
Paul didn't deserve that violent death but he was a mean spirited kid according to TH-cam info. He "spit and hit" his girlfriend on the boat while drunk. Imagine what kind of man he'd be. Punk.
Playing Devil's Advocate: Just after the video he could have driven up to the house (a minute drive), went to his room, popped in some ear buds and went to sleep? I think he did it, but the defense can be full of such excuses.
@@22ergie yes but when your son and wife are slaughtered on your property and you are completely innocent, you would not lie to police about being there or not!!!!
Vinnie is The Greatest current host of any show on TV, and it’s because of his COMMON SENSE. He asks the most logical questions that the audience and-or a jury would be asking themselves. So smart.
As a Momma to two sister dachshunds who eat, sleep, and breathe in my house: (kitchen, bedroom, bed, bathtub, living room, couch, guest room etc.) they are spoiled rotten, and have full reign of the inside, and the run of the large fenced in yard for outdoor play. I cannot imagine it any other way! WHY HAVE DOGS TO LOCK THEM IN CAGES?! The people who do that should be LOCKED IN CAGES! It should be against the law.
@@22ergie You think a greed-driven psychopath who kills their own son and wife care about dogs? Those dogs are likely in foster care now. The way they were in the cage and he was HOLDING the dog by the tail to control it. smh
To those of you speaking about the dogs. It wasn’t their dog in video. It was Paul’s friends dog. He did look perfectly healthy and in fact beautiful. I believe these are hunting dogs who actually get to run outside a lot. It was just later in the day. His coat and weight seems great & they were concerned about him enough to video back and forth about his tail
It's so eerie how this is moments before they're blown apart by the person who should've protected them from all harm. How insane is this world we live in.
He was quick to tell investigators the night of the murders that Paul’s cell phone “fell” out of his pocket. Then he laid it on the back of his leg. This was a detail he didn’t have to offer. I believe he was attempting to get into his phone to delete videos and resent phone calls to Paul’s friend about his dog
You are never safe married to a psychopath, and your children and pets aren't safe, either. She wanted that money and power, though, so she married it.
I don't believe Alex knew about his voice on that video. That was a major screw up.eventually ppl get caught for theft and murder. How long did he think his luck would hold out. He's been a criminal for years.
Hakeem Pinkney's family, Mallory Beech's family, Gloria Satterfield's family, Stephen Smith's family...I know there's more, but I can't remember their names right now.
He didn’t know there were TWO videos. One with Paul by the trees, wearing pants and blue shirt around 7PM, then the second one at the kennels of the dog later
Psychopaths are driven almost entirely by extreme greed...plus their need to alleviate their extreme, pervasive boredom...and their extreme sexual deviance. They incapable of caring for or loving anyone.
Don't you all think it's (ironic) a major miracle that Paul is the very witness against his own father who happens to be the one that murdered him. His two videos are a witness that beats all. In the snapchat video, Alex is in different clothing; most likely the bloody ones. The timeline says Paul was murdered right as that video finished. 8:49:01 is the time Paul's phone went dead and 8:49:39 is when Maggie's phone goes dead. 8:50 is the time they say he died. Remember, Alex picked up Paul's phone- Most likely he knew the videos were there.
@@jamie.777 As a matter of fact, as I have seen on many crime/court related documentaries, and even here on Court TV, much of "cell phone pings" as "evidence" in regard to "location" are not admissible in court as proof of anything due to it's unreliability in "pinpointing exact location." This is even being mentioned in the Bryan Kohberger/Idaho murder case. PS) Also time stamps can certainly be manipulated. Just saying.
To me sometimes it feels the prosecuters aren't really trying hard, they are not good at pointing out important stuff to the jury IMO, not asking certain things when they could/should etc.
Also, there was a video sent to one of Paul's friends that shows Paul and Alex riding around in a buggy and laughing as they check out trees that had fallen on the property. It was taken and sent a 7 pm and shows Alex in a long-sleeved shirt and long pants. What happened to those clothes he was wearing an hour and forty-five mins before the murders? And, as far as the clothes he was wearing, couldn't he have prepared a set of clothes, brought them to the scene, changed into these extra clothes at the scene, and then disposed of them when he went to his mother's?
Those clothes have disappeared. And he would have needed a shower to remove traces of blood and guts as well as gunshot residue. Hard to get all that in, in the time allowed. I think the clothes missing ALONE indicts him. If he innocently changed clothes from earlier in the evening, they should be in his room in the laundry bin, all clean with no blood. It amazes me that in the days afterwards when techs came over to 'search the house' the family (mostly lawyers) were all there and the house wasn't made part of the crime scene and off limits. SLED there is incompetent.
Exactly those clothes are no where to be found. The investigation should ask where those clothes are. If Alex did not kill his family those clothes should be clean and presented as evidence to clear Alex. But those clothes are missing which indicates Alex is hiding them. Guilty.
@@signalfire6691 that bothered me too not dusting for prints in certain places, not checking the drains, w/d, really checking under cabinets, drawers, and behind doors. I think the crime scene lady might have been intimidated by the partner lawyer and brother lawyer was following her around. They have obviously gotten the special treatment gentle house search. I hope he doesn't get away with it, nor anyone who might have helped him .. 🧐
@@lil_PowPow The good news is, the financial crimes alone will put him away for years. But if he's not convicted of the murders, there's potentially some pretty vicious killers out there that the community has to be afraid of, and/or we'll have to listen to discussions of this for the next 100 years like the Lizzie Borden case. Either way, Buster should dye his hair dark brown, change his name and move to another country. His life anywhere near that area is over.
Go back and watch the first time they played the tape in court room. AMs sister is sitting directly behind him and the look on her face when she hears Alex voice on dog video Says it ALL!
If you recall, in the car, he said that "Paul's cell phone had popped out of his pocket and I started to do something with it, but then I put it back down really quickly." HOWEVER ...According to the report, a cell phone in Paul Murdaugh’s back pocket had been removed and a blood stain was found inside the pocket. Kinsey said he believes the phone was taken out of Paul’s pocket by someone else after he was killed and the blood stain was produced during its retrieval. (as per Chief Deputy Kenneth Kinsey) Sooo.. there is another lie. He was going to check for that video and just didn't have time?
He probably didn't know Paul's password to unlock his phone to see all of Paul's text messages at the time of his murder. It's telling that both Maggie and Paul failed to respond to anymore text messages after 8:49pm. Why would Alex lie about taking a nap and not at the kennel with Maggie and Paul? Because that's when and where the murders happened. Alex is either hired someone/s or he did it himself.
@@matthill2957 yes maybe he couldn’t find it. But then again there would be evidence of someone being on the phone. Maybe Alex was going to delete the video then realized there would be evidence of that.
P.S. Alex took them to the dog kennel so the main house didn’t get blood & guts everywhere, hired hitmen don’t care about the living room furniture Vinny
No hired hitman, Alex was the sole murderer. Alex did not bring them there. They met per Alexa request. Then he very quickly ambushed them, Paul first then maggie. There are no cameras there, outside or inside. Camera are way out in the woods for hunting. Alex thought this was the perfect spot to kill them.
Oh I think he knew that there was something on Paul’s phone but couldn’t open it. And that’s why Alex called Rogan, to check and see if he had heard or seen anything because Alex said himself that he called Ro-Ro that night. That’s why he made a point of telling them that Paul’s cell phone popped out and he picked it up “to do something with it, I don’t know what”. I think he was covering for the fact that his fingerprints would be on Paul’s phone.
I think Buster is cut from the same cloth as daddy-o. He’s kissing dads ass because he is useless. He needs daddy to pull strings for him and buy people off. Those boys were evil in training from their devil dad.
@@kahledblackman318 Alex never intended to be killed. That was just another failed attempt to mislead or redirect suspicion to some unknown character out there as coming after his family. Alex is a coward and a liar. He never intended to kill himself for anybody out there. Once he was caught in his own infantile and stupid acting, he had to come up with another fake stupid sob reason aka doing it for Buster...hahahah since when can Alex consider another soul before his own?? Never!
@@rayray8687 Hearing from others that have been in big trials, these guys usually come into the courtroom very briefly to observe and do most of the reporting at different locations throughout the day.
@@rayray8687 What you see after 7:00 EST, like this clip, is filmed across from the courthouse at a local bar or 'pub'. Folks here don't care for rain, and it's been raining off and on all week.
It is truly remarkable how so much is available out that to track what we do! Maybe one day those who commit crimes will realize not to because they will get caught!!! I know, wishful thinking 😂 I know people hate the fact that their lives can be tracked but I say bring it, especially if it means my protection. Besides, If you are not committing wrong doings, then why worry if you are being “tracked”?!
Do you realize that the closure rate for murder in the U.S is 63.4%?? (Source - F.B.I Crime closure rate statistics) When you account for the people who just flat admit it from the beginning that means they odds of it being solved are barely better than flipping a coin You believe that’s good🤦🏻
Because Big Brother knows everything about you, as does "Google"... EVERYTHING about you! So you say "bring it"? No, thanks; I don't own a cp, nor use "Google", we are "tracked" enough in so many other ways as it is to have to add to it= making it easier for them. Have a look at what TRAITOR Edward Snowden says on this topic-it's just as interesting as it is frightening! He speaks for several hours about all the ways you are being monitored.
I think his motive was to spare himself due to the personal failure and humiliation and the inevitable downfall so close to closing in. He knew how much their status and reputation meant to his wife. I personally think he killed them to spare himself and to spare his family. Family annihilations happen everyday for that exact reason. Because this family was so hyper focused and only cared for material things and status, he knew they would have zero life after he was exposed.
I must live in a very small world because I do not think family annihilation happens but rarely especially by very wealthy people. I cannot come up with any reason he wanted them both dead.
I think the reason he picks up Paul’s mobile, he wanted to check and delete it 🤔 because how would pick up a phone and try to open it before checking on his wife 🤔
Men who kill their wives ALWAYS CALL THEIR PHONE AND ACT CONCERNED AFTER. They think it makes them have a better alibi and seem concerned. Meanwhile if he called his wife before the murders and she didn’t answer there is no way in hell he would keep calling her.
Why is nobody talking about how you can hear AM address Paul by name and it sounds like Paul responded by either saying "it's alright dad" or etc????!!!
I don't place high dependency on the phones counting/not counting steps. My phone doesn't count my steps when I'm walking around in a store or when I'm mowing large yards. I wish it would because in both there is a lot of walking and I'd love to know how far I travelled. It only counts my steps when I walk to a destination. Was he holding a phone and not swinging his arm while the other was in hand of a swinging arm? That could possibly account for them not being in sync. My two cents.
Maggies cell phone was found purposely. If another person killed Maggie and took her phone, they would have destroyed it. Alex just wanted to create doubt
Hi. Due to work & family can't watch all aspects of the trial. My question is are Maggie's family present during procedure's? Also, is it me or does Buster not looked bothered that his dad is on trial? Where was Buster when the murders happened? These questions have probably been answered. Being busy in life & in United Kingdom difficult for me personally to keep upto date
Buster was about an hour south at his girlfriends house. He’s probably over the whole lie of a life his dad has been living . Buster is manipulated and used by Alex He’s lied to and lying for Alex Hiding money Moving money Lying about everything I think Buster believes either his dad did the killings or had someone do the murders for him. I think Buster is probably overwhelmed w fear and grieving but he’s not able to express his feelings. Buster is made to show up and be supportive of the only family he had left Or walk away and be a self made orphan. I think Buster knew his dad was upto some sketchy finances and lying But I doubt Buster would initially believe his dad was capable of this. I’m sure the more Buster learns the angrier he is at Alex But can’t say it because he’s the only living heir to all the money and properties and doesn’t want to be cut from Alex will
Maggie's parents live about 20 minutes away from Mosel. Her older sister and her husband live in Charleston, SC. Her family has not made any comment to the press, and they have not attended the court proceedings in person. I expect they are home watching on TV like most of the world.
@@marycahill546 oh thanks I thought that looked like Maggie’s sister a few people to the right of Buster . It maybe is Alex sister? I don’t blame them for staying away from the gruesome evidence. Bless their hearts 💕
@@uright2661 Alex is actually the lucky one. He still has a chance to repent and receive Jesus Christ as his Lord and Savior. If Maggie & Paul were not saved, they no longer have an opportunity to do so. The irony of it all....
The fact that the dog "Bubba" had an animal in his mouth meant that someone must have been hunting at that moment. Alex could have been that person. He could have also worn a tarp (which was allegedly seen carried by Alex towards his mother's home) to cover himself from any evidence. All together, Alex made himself less suspicious why he would be carrying a gun and to not surprise Maggie and Paul. This could mean that he has a gun (or guns) with him during that time. Just my two cents...
@@theoryofpersonality1420 For me it doesn't. Law is made by politicians chosen by people so people are obliged to follow the laws made by people they chose.
Any time you find a family that has generational power like that, you're looking at a family of psychopaths. Psychopathy is genetic, and narcissists who are addicted to social status and wealth marry into these families. Both are empathy deficient and morally bankrupt (and sexually deviant). It would CURL YOUR HAIR if you knew what these people do behind closed doors.
@Court TV What do you know about the phone call that was made to 911 at the same time Alex was calling 911, by a couple who were on the road that goes to AM's and they said that there was a man by the side of the road, covered in blood, he had what looked to be white or white/blond hair, waving his arms at them to stop, he had his trunk or hatch open, it was a black SUV. They said he looked frantic, covered in blood. The couple said it looked like a set up so they kept going. This was on the same road as AM's property, the same time that Alex was calling 911 too.
You are referring to the events of September 4 when Alex faked having a flat tire and had called his cousin to come and help him, then produced a rifle which they struggled over. The life insurance phony suicide event. lex has not faced trial yet on that fraud indictment.
Alex not only has no alibi, cell phone evidence proves he was at the kennel with Maggie and Paul when they were murdered. Did Alex hire someone/s to do the dirty deeds$ for him or did he do it himself? Why did Alex change from long pants and long sleeve shirt that day to wearing a t shirt and shorts that night? and did he change his clothes after the murders which would explain no blood on his clothes despite his claim that he touched the blood covered bodies. He didn't even have blood on his hands and if he did touch the bodies as he claims, he would et least have blood on his hands. I think he showered and changed his clothes 'after' the murders.
@@combatepistemologist8382 He had already changed from his work clothes to the blue shirt and khaki's in the 7:44 om video. Sitting in the police car in the white T shirt he was wearing was FRESH, still had the fold creases in it.
i dont believe dude didnt hear the gunshots. i can hear my neighbors guns going off miles away. im catching up on this case so i dont know what gun was used. but even if it was a 9mm, i dont believe he didnt hear it within that convenient ten minute nap.
He used a hose near the kennels to wash off. There wear puddles when the police arrived. I' don't know where he got clean clothes or if they ever found the guns. Haven't heard about that
I don't know about cash being heaven sent.....but EXTRA cash ...now that I always thank heaven for!! (HA HA I am just teasing you, I know what you really meant!)
How did Alex know they had been “shot badly” ? What if someone swung an axe onto Paul ? Did Alex ever ask if there were any other type of weapon(s) involved?
Alex killed his son and wife, that's how he knew they had been shot so badly. Paul 3 in body and 2 times in head, then Maggie 5 times in body then 2 times in the back of the head with a high power rifle. It appears he hated maggie, he shot her so many times with high power. He definitely wanted them both dead . with no reason why
Do you all know that AM bought the Moselle property for $5.00 from the widow of his good friend and business partner, and that he also took the man’s life insurance? I think AM was born bad…that whole family is bad! I’d also like to know what Harpootlian’s voters and supporters think of him seeking the limelight/spotlight to represent a family annihilator…!
The cellphone evidence is damning but it is the compilation of several important facts when you look at the bigger picture that really nails Alex as the murderer!
@Deborah Hershey but there is cell phone evidence and it shows how many errors he made. No blood on him at all after touching the bodies is suspicious plus his bizarre alibi...plus the Boat lawsuit plus the business massive lawsuit. Plus all of the other people's cellphone evidence...too much evidence plus a real motive too much to ignore. The police would keep looking and find no other person but AM. He is guilty af.
Agreed, it's the confluence of so many factors together that make this airtight. Now, if the ignorant, narcissistic jurors from this community will convict him, that will be a miracle.
He suspected a video, he tells police he picked up Paul's phone and was going to do something with it but changed his mind. He really fumbles his words at that point. Maybe he just wasnt able to access it? I think he was worried about the video.
Ok so with his phone not recording any steps while hers is moving, I heard people keep bringing up that his data wasn’t on at that time, is that true and would that matter?
Also, didn’t they say that because his phone wasn’t extracted until August that many things were overwritten? Steps data could have been overwritten since then.
My iphone stay is driving mode once I'm out of the car, and it goes INTO driving mode if I hold it out and spin around in a circle. It's not always accurate.
I think Alec knew Paul was filming a video, that's why he touched Paul's phone after he shot him. I think he wanted to delete the video, but maybe the phone was locked or Alec realized he would get dna or blood on the phone.
@@cerebrumexcrement If he was recording AS he was shot......would a video continue to record or do you have to hold a button and release when done filming ???(sorry, I don't own a smartphone or do snaptchat)
There was testimony that his phone didn’t have any activity at all within a certain time frame. Prosecutors need to tighten that up and show a map with times as to where the phones were. Demonstratives with re to the cellphones are highly needed for this case. Not sure if the jury has them and the public doesn’t.
How is the defense going to get out of this??? That voice is clearly his. This alone is enough to make the jurors convict him. It certainly has caused me to make up my mind that he did it.
Why does the prosecution need to have their ideas approved by the judge ? I mean even in the Cayce Anthony trial they let the prosecution commit a horror on the grandfather by claiming he was the one responsible for Caylee’s death. Which was completely desperate and crazy.
@@LaurenRuby The defense side can come with any odd theory but the prosecution has to hope a judge will allow info that seems obviously pertinent ? It’s strange that it would have to be an uphill battle, since they’d need to back up what they claim anyway ? It seems too that the prosecution didn’t go about this very well since if they’d connected all the dots (for permission or whatever) before the trial started this wouldn’t be going on now.
Maybe he was wearing his AirPods, told Siri to call his wife’s phone while his phone was inside the car. This way the phone will not have any record of him walking
MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/trending/alex-murdaugh-family-murders/?
Was his phone sitting still in his truck when he picked up Maggie's and Paul's?
This is chilling. He's caught lying = guilty. He wanted Maggie's estate + life insurance. Probably had life insurance on Paul too(?). Buster said "I do not support my father." I don't even know how AM's family can sit so close to him in the courtroom.
I wouldn't put it past AM to put a hit out on Buster or his own siblings from his jail cell, this man is so greedy.
@@shannonmathiscowen8682 they claim there wasn't life insurance on Paul and Maggie. I think this is a lie too. I think there was life insurance in Busters name but not in Alex name.
Alex has a ten million dollar life insurance policy on himself and Buster is the beneficiary. That why Alex tried to stage his own murder with his cousin. So Buster could get his life insurance money.
if I sat my phone on the seat of the car, walked over and picked your up your phone walked to the car while trying to unlock it and read the drop down screen then set it down in the car, and picked mine up, walked a bit outside the car and called or messaged your phone, sat mine down, then picked yours up to see if the message sent then set it down again, then drove off, then threw your phone out the window while the screen was off this would account for the difference.
At 6:00 Alex says "whats the matter Paul?" And Paul replies "It's ok DAD"
Did no one else hear this??????
It doesn't say it's not bad he said it's ok dad.
The tears he shed in court are all about him being held accountable for his heinous crimes.
Such an odd ball too
His high weird voice
He seems absolutely insane
Exactly Spoiled Brat
He was remembering what he saw that day. And if he's guilty, reliving their final messy moments.
He knows he's screwed as even if he walks for killing his wife and son, he faces close to 100 federal financial crimes that will keep him behind bars for the rest of his life. He's in his 50's now, correct?
@@lovepet4565 He totally resembles an inbred hamster.
Paul solved his own murder and his Mom's!
Yep!!
YES!
He is a hero!!
Paul didn't deserve that violent death but he was a mean spirited kid according to TH-cam info. He "spit and hit" his girlfriend on the boat while drunk. Imagine what kind of man he'd be. Punk.
Yeah. Nailed him to the wall.
@@amandawalden6319 according to Mallory Beach he is not
Paul had no idea that his Snapchat video wld help solve his own murder....how sad smh. That last name is forever tainted. Murda is in their name 🤦
murda ugh
It was eerie.
Alex lies about his name too. His name is Richard Alexander Murdaugh. So basically his name is Dick murda.
and a dog named Cash...
Well said! Along with that Murda house!
Thank God the "Cash" the dog video exists or we wouldn't have the timeline that puts Alex at the murder scene AT THE TIME OF THE MURDERS.
Hell ya!! That puppy is a hero!
God works in mysterious ways... Amen
Playing Devil's Advocate: Just after the video he could have driven up to the house (a minute drive), went to his room, popped in some ear buds and went to sleep? I think he did it, but the defense can be full of such excuses.
People in this community are so ignorant and narcissistic, the jury might not convict him.
@@22ergie yes but when your son and wife are slaughtered on your property and you are completely innocent, you would not lie to police about being there or not!!!!
Vinnie is The Greatest current host of any show on TV, and it’s because of his COMMON SENSE. He asks the most logical questions that the audience and-or a jury would be asking themselves. So smart.
Vinnie , ur voice, ur presence makes my day thank you and chandlee
They really are a draw. Daytime crew as well.
Chanley. And she’s nice but sounds like a chipmunk with marbles in its mouth.
Wow, I expected it to be a very faint voice, but you can really hear him.
I hope someone rescued those poor dogs from such a miserable, lonely life.
Definitely
As a Momma to two sister dachshunds who eat, sleep, and breathe in my house: (kitchen, bedroom, bed, bathtub, living room, couch, guest room etc.) they are spoiled rotten, and have full reign of the inside, and the run of the large fenced in yard for outdoor play. I cannot imagine it any other way! WHY HAVE DOGS TO LOCK THEM IN CAGES?! The people who do that should be LOCKED IN CAGES! It should be against the law.
@@22ergie You think a greed-driven psychopath who kills their own son and wife care about dogs? Those dogs are likely in foster care now. The way they were in the cage and he was HOLDING the dog by the tail to control it. smh
@@le_th_ Paul was making the video to show his friend (the owner of choc lab dog Cash) because he thought the dogs tail was injured
To those of you speaking about the dogs. It wasn’t their dog in video. It was Paul’s friends dog. He did look perfectly healthy and in fact beautiful. I believe these are hunting dogs who actually get to run outside a lot. It was just later in the day. His coat and weight seems great & they were concerned about him enough to video back and forth about his tail
It's so eerie how this is moments before they're blown apart by the person who should've protected them from all harm. How insane is this world we live in.
My mind cannot fathom that..
Right this is beyond me
Yeah laughing and cutting up with them one second and the next he puts that dead chicken on the crate, grabs the gun and shoots them both dead.
Can't believe court tv was ever taken off! Been so happy your back sense day one! 💯♥️⚖️
Imagine the fear in their eyes when they saw the person they trusted the most point a gun at them. :(
😢😢
I believe that Video at the Kennels was all the jury needed! Thank God for Paul Taking that Video 🙏
He was quick to tell investigators the night of the murders that Paul’s cell phone “fell” out of his pocket. Then he laid it on the back of his leg. This was a detail he didn’t have to offer. I believe he was attempting to get into his phone to delete videos and resent phone calls to Paul’s friend about his dog
That IS Alex’s voice, no doubt. And Maggie and Paul sound so happy to be with the dogs! Poor Maggie, WHY her? RIP 🙏. ☮️🌻💜
It really is a horror. Maggie knew something was up. I don’t think Paul had any clue his dad could do that.
@@darcymoon2109 Maggie probably felt safe with Paul there.
@@JimiBegbaaji Oh, wow. This just breaks my broken heart into even smaller pieces. Jesus.
You are never safe married to a psychopath, and your children and pets aren't safe, either. She wanted that money and power, though, so she married it.
She and her son, didn't seem all they great either.
Thank God for Snapchat & Apple phone Tech. Voices from the graves!😮
I like this setup it makes feel more comfortable and on edge at the same time.
Guilty!!!
You hear Alex clear as day, calling for one of the dogs! It gives me chills!!!!!!!
He was right there!!!!
That was his dog Buddy.
You also here him around 6 minutes in saying "what's the matter son?"
I don't believe Alex knew about his voice on that video. That was a major screw up.eventually ppl get caught for theft and murder. How long did he think his luck would hold out. He's been a criminal for years.
Justice for the Victims!! 🙏🙏🙏
Except not for the girl on the boat
Hakeem Pinkney's family, Mallory Beech's family, Gloria Satterfield's family, Stephen Smith's family...I know there's more, but I can't remember their names right now.
He didn’t know there were TWO videos. One with Paul by the trees, wearing pants and blue shirt around 7PM, then the second one at the kennels of the dog later
He had no idea that Paul was taking a video!!!! He was too busy calling Bubba. The dogs are hero’s.
That's not Paul in the video wearing the blue shirt, that's Alec.
@@shannonodom8977 yes, I’m sorry I hadn’t made that clear. Paul was on his 20s, and took the Snapchat video.
@@LB-lt3pz 0u
Also in Alex's interview he said he grabbed Paul's phone and was going to do something with it but then he decided not too.
He couldn't unlock it. It needed face recognition and his dad left him with his brain outside his head making recognition useless
Great condensed breakdown !
Yea he’s done
Great coverage. Thank you as always!
He seems more interested in creating an alibi than finding the murderers of his wife & son.
He's cold-blooded.
Psychopaths are driven almost entirely by extreme greed...plus their need to alleviate their extreme, pervasive boredom...and their extreme sexual deviance. They incapable of caring for or loving anyone.
Right, that's what I'd think. All that power and clout yet not worried for his wife and son. That speaks volumes.
He's cold blooded because he is the guilty one
Don't you all think it's (ironic) a major miracle that Paul is the very witness against his own father who happens to be the one that murdered him. His two videos are a witness that beats all. In the snapchat video, Alex is in different clothing; most likely the bloody ones. The timeline says Paul was murdered right as that video finished. 8:49:01 is the time Paul's phone went dead and 8:49:39 is when Maggie's phone goes dead. 8:50 is the time they say he died. Remember, Alex picked up Paul's phone- Most likely he knew the videos were there.
Yes, and I bet when Paul was shot, Alex picked it up to try to erase the videos but couldn't
No he didn't or he would of had to get rid of it somehow. This is the best incriminating evidence and 1 st against him.
If he knew it was there he's a lawyer he wouldn't have made that alibi. He couldn't have known.
I hear Paul saying “it’s alright Dad” in that Snapchat video! 100% it’s Alex’s voice.
Why would he say that. I haven't heard that video yet.
Good job, Paul. You caught your murderer!
He didn't mean to, he had no idea he was about to be murdered by his father
Thanks to Waters for playing that video over and over. Letting the jury find for themselves that WAS ALEX VOICE!
Thank you for adding the subtitles because I couldn’t tell who is who 😅
Same here. I thought Paul was Alex, even then I wasn’t sure what was going on.
Same
If he’s not held accountable we all know it’s because of status and money
@@jamie.777 As a matter of fact, as I have seen on many crime/court related documentaries, and even here on Court TV, much of "cell phone pings" as "evidence" in regard to "location" are not admissible in court as proof of anything due to it's unreliability in "pinpointing exact location." This is even being mentioned in the Bryan Kohberger/Idaho murder case. PS) Also time stamps can certainly be manipulated. Just saying.
The narcissists will ALWAYS support money and social hierarchy. It's all that matters to them.
His defense lawyer the sitting senator has connections to the judge, I wouldn’t be surprised
To me sometimes it feels the prosecuters aren't really trying hard, they are not good at pointing out important stuff to the jury IMO, not asking certain things when they could/should etc.
100 years of people owing that family “favors” anything is possible
Paul’s body was found just outside the kennel door where he took the video of the dog.
Paul and Maggie may as well be speaking from beyond to make sure justice is done!
I sure hope so when such a close family member that is supposed to love but does this, justice needs to be served.
Also, there was a video sent to one of Paul's friends that shows Paul and Alex riding around in a buggy and laughing as they check out trees that had fallen on the property. It was taken and sent a 7 pm and shows Alex in a long-sleeved shirt and long pants. What happened to those clothes he was wearing an hour and forty-five mins before the murders? And, as far as the clothes he was wearing, couldn't he have prepared a set of clothes, brought them to the scene, changed into these extra clothes at the scene, and then disposed of them when he went to his mother's?
Those clothes have disappeared. And he would have needed a shower to remove traces of blood and guts as well as gunshot residue. Hard to get all that in, in the time allowed. I think the clothes missing ALONE indicts him. If he innocently changed clothes from earlier in the evening, they should be in his room in the laundry bin, all clean with no blood. It amazes me that in the days afterwards when techs came over to 'search the house' the family (mostly lawyers) were all there and the house wasn't made part of the crime scene and off limits. SLED there is incompetent.
Exactly those clothes are no where to be found. The investigation should ask where those clothes are. If Alex did not kill his family those clothes should be clean and presented as evidence to clear Alex. But those clothes are missing which indicates Alex is hiding them. Guilty.
@@signalfire6691 that bothered me too not dusting for prints in certain places, not checking the drains, w/d, really checking under cabinets, drawers, and behind doors. I think the crime scene lady might have been intimidated by the partner lawyer and brother lawyer was following her around. They have obviously gotten the special treatment gentle house search. I hope he doesn't get away with it, nor anyone who might have helped him .. 🧐
@@lil_PowPow The good news is, the financial crimes alone will put him away for years. But if he's not convicted of the murders, there's potentially some pretty vicious killers out there that the community has to be afraid of, and/or we'll have to listen to discussions of this for the next 100 years like the Lizzie Borden case. Either way, Buster should dye his hair dark brown, change his name and move to another country. His life anywhere near that area is over.
@@signalfire6691 I never trusted red heads
I've thought the prosecution was weak up until that audio was played..
Great coverage Vinnie its great you explain!
What a damn shame keeping dogs in cages. Now in will be Alex turn
I was thinking the same. Dud you notice the lock on the gate? I just hope the dogs were taken care of....
Don't ever take your dog to a vet then if they have to stay over night. Because guess what, the dog will stay in a cage.
Vinnie. Truly the best top true crime journalist/lawyer
Thank You
Go back and watch the first time they played the tape in court room. AMs sister is sitting directly behind him and the look on her face when she hears Alex voice on dog video Says it ALL!
They had several witnesses confirm that it was alexs voice.
If you recall, in the car, he said that "Paul's cell phone had popped out of his pocket and I started to do something with it, but then I put it back down really quickly." HOWEVER ...According to the report, a cell phone in Paul Murdaugh’s back pocket had been removed and a blood stain was found inside the pocket. Kinsey said he believes the phone was taken out of Paul’s pocket by someone else after he was killed and the blood stain was produced during its retrieval. (as per Chief Deputy Kenneth Kinsey) Sooo.. there is another lie. He was going to check for that video and just didn't have time?
OR didn't know how to use snapchat...
He probably didn't know Paul's password to unlock his phone to see all of Paul's text messages at the time of his murder. It's telling that both Maggie and Paul failed to respond to anymore text messages after 8:49pm. Why would Alex lie about taking a nap and not at the kennel with Maggie and Paul? Because that's when and where the murders happened. Alex is either hired someone/s or he did it himself.
He probably checked his videos and didnt know anything about snapchat
@@matthill2957 yes maybe he couldn’t find it. But then again there would be evidence of someone being on the phone. Maybe Alex was going to delete the video then realized there would be evidence of that.
👍
You hear paul say" its alright dad"
My 4 and 5 year old does better acting when they don't get what they want 🤣
True. Yet consider they are acting for something they actually WANT......Alex only "wants" to find the real killer(s)!! 😆
P.S. Alex took them to the dog kennel so the main house didn’t get blood & guts everywhere, hired hitmen don’t care about the living room furniture Vinny
Exactly
Correct. The kennel was the perfect place to clean up. Cold and calculated.
I think you said it best. I Wonder if the police ever thought the same thing that you said. ❤️
No hired hitman, Alex was the sole murderer. Alex did not bring them there. They met per Alexa request. Then he very quickly ambushed them, Paul first then maggie. There are no cameras there, outside or inside. Camera are way out in the woods for hunting. Alex thought this was the perfect spot to kill them.
Oh I think he knew that there was something on Paul’s phone but couldn’t open it. And that’s why Alex called Rogan, to check and see if he had heard or seen anything because Alex said himself that he called Ro-Ro that night. That’s why he made a point of telling them that Paul’s cell phone popped out and he picked it up “to do something with it, I don’t know what”. I think he was covering for the fact that his fingerprints would be on Paul’s phone.
He's a horrible actor. Guilty Guilty Guilty!
I wonder what Buster is thinking at this point 😢
I think Buster is cut from the same cloth as daddy-o. He’s kissing dads ass because he is useless. He needs daddy to pull strings for him and buy people off. Those boys were evil in training from their devil dad.
I keep waiting to see him stand up and go over to sit with the prosecution side...
@@kahledblackman318 Alex never intended to be killed. That was just another failed attempt to mislead or redirect suspicion to some unknown character out there as coming after his family. Alex is a coward and a liar. He never intended to kill himself for anybody out there. Once he was caught in his own infantile and stupid acting, he had to come up with another fake stupid sob reason aka doing it for Buster...hahahah since when can Alex consider another soul before his own?? Never!
@@laikaevelyn4478 yes!! Nailed it!!!
@@laikaevelyn4478 🎯🎯🎯🎯🎯
Love seeing Vinnie on location!!!
On location? He’s in a bloody pub, lol.
@@rayray8687 Southern Justice - the bar or pub is across the street from the courthouse.
@@lizpound2278: Ok, so they do this podcast while court is in recess? I mean aren’t they usually in the courtroom covering the trial?
@@rayray8687 Hearing from others that have been in big trials, these guys usually come into the courtroom very briefly to observe and do most of the reporting at different locations throughout the day.
@@rayray8687 What you see after 7:00 EST, like this clip, is filmed across from the courthouse at a local bar or 'pub'. Folks here don't care for rain, and it's been raining off and on all week.
It is truly remarkable how so much is available out that to track what we do! Maybe one day those who commit crimes will realize not to because they will get caught!!! I know, wishful thinking 😂 I know people hate the fact that their lives can be tracked but I say bring it, especially if it means my protection. Besides, If you are not committing wrong doings, then why worry if you are being “tracked”?!
Do you realize that the closure rate for murder in the U.S is 63.4%?? (Source - F.B.I Crime closure rate statistics)
When you account for the people who just flat admit it from the beginning that means they odds of it being solved are barely better than flipping a coin
You believe that’s good🤦🏻
Yikes
Because Big Brother knows everything about you, as does "Google"... EVERYTHING about you! So you say "bring it"? No, thanks; I don't own a cp, nor use "Google", we are "tracked" enough in so many other ways as it is to have to add to it= making it easier for them. Have a look at what TRAITOR Edward Snowden says on this topic-it's just as interesting as it is frightening! He speaks for several hours about all the ways you are being monitored.
Are you for real? I don't do anything wrong, I still like my privacy.
I'm sure President Xi Jinping agrees with you. You are assuming those doing the tracking are benevolent.
I think his motive was to spare himself due to the personal failure and humiliation and the inevitable downfall so close to closing in.
He knew how much their status and reputation meant to his wife.
I personally think he killed them to spare himself and to spare his family.
Family annihilations happen everyday for that exact reason.
Because this family was so hyper focused and only cared for material things and status, he knew they would have zero life after he was exposed.
Disgusting take.
They needed to turn back to God.
I must live in a very small world because I do not think family annihilation happens but rarely especially by very wealthy people. I cannot come up with any reason he wanted them both dead.
Alex had no idea that Paul had did that Snapchat
How money,power and greed has shattered this country to pieces and people still haven’t learn that this only has destroyed us as a whole💔🤮☠️
I think the reason he picks up Paul’s mobile, he wanted to check and delete it 🤔 because how would pick up a phone and try to open it before checking on his wife 🤔
I bet Alex calling the phone that many times was trying to trigger it so that he could answer it in the phone would be unlocked
Who know's what the criminal mind is thinking?
Men who kill their wives ALWAYS CALL THEIR PHONE AND ACT CONCERNED AFTER. They think it makes them have a better alibi and seem concerned. Meanwhile if he called his wife before the murders and she didn’t answer there is no way in hell he would keep calling her.
Why? He gave the police her codes.
@@Thebeautiful11 he had to at that point. He was hoping the phone would die and they wouldn’t find it and he would go back later and dispose of it.
@@Thebeautiful11 because he had too. Other people must have known he had the code, like his brothers.
Why is nobody talking about how you can hear AM address Paul by name and it sounds like Paul responded by either saying "it's alright dad" or etc????!!!
I don't place high dependency on the phones counting/not counting steps. My phone doesn't count my steps when I'm walking around in a store or when I'm mowing large yards. I wish it would because in both there is a lot of walking and I'd love to know how far I travelled. It only counts my steps when I walk to a destination. Was he holding a phone and not swinging his arm while the other was in hand of a swinging arm? That could possibly account for them not being in sync. My two cents.
He didn't say he was at the kennels either doh
AleX stated in his second interview he was NOT at the kennels that night.
Have they said anything about Alex’s cell phone data? When he called and texted Maggie, where did the GPS show he was at the time?
Maggies cell phone was found purposely. If another person killed Maggie and took her phone, they would have destroyed it. Alex just wanted to create doubt
Or the killer took it. I feel like he hired someone.
if another person killed maggie, they wouldnt take the phone in the first place.
Hi. Due to work & family can't watch all aspects of the trial. My question is are Maggie's family present during procedure's?
Also, is it me or does Buster not looked bothered that his dad is on trial? Where was Buster when the murders happened? These questions have probably been answered. Being busy in life & in United Kingdom difficult for me personally to keep upto date
Buster was about an hour south at his girlfriends house.
He’s probably over the whole lie of a life his dad has been living .
Buster is manipulated and used by Alex
He’s lied to and lying for Alex
Hiding money
Moving money
Lying about everything
I think Buster believes either his dad did the killings or had someone do the murders for him.
I think Buster is probably overwhelmed w fear and grieving but he’s not able to express his feelings.
Buster is made to show up and be supportive of the only family he had left
Or walk away and be a self made orphan.
I think Buster knew his dad was upto some sketchy finances and lying
But I doubt Buster would initially believe his dad was capable of this.
I’m sure the more Buster learns the angrier he is at Alex
But can’t say it because he’s the only living heir to all the money and properties and doesn’t want to be cut from Alex will
Maggie's parents live about 20 minutes away from Mosel. Her older sister and her husband live in Charleston, SC. Her family has not made any comment to the press, and they have not attended the court proceedings in person. I expect they are home watching on TV like most of the world.
@@marycahill546 oh thanks
I thought that looked like Maggie’s sister a few people to the right of Buster .
It maybe is Alex sister?
I don’t blame them for staying away from the gruesome evidence.
Bless their hearts 💕
Houdini prosaccusers did a good power of suggestion on this one. Judges see through that crafty technique.
All that privelege and none of it can save him,now.. He better call on The Lord
Would not want to be him on judgement day
@@uright2661 Alex is actually the lucky one. He still has a chance to repent and receive Jesus Christ as his Lord and Savior. If Maggie & Paul were not saved, they no longer have an opportunity to do so. The irony of it all....
@@ldebrobander pretty hard to think Alex will ever feel bad about killing them except feel bad he was caught.
@@ldebrobander: What if they were Jewish and were saved by Mashiach…or maybe Saoshyant, or Maitreya? Would that be just as good?
Better call Saul because he left the Lord a long time ago.
The fact that the dog "Bubba" had an animal in his mouth meant that someone must have been hunting at that moment. Alex could have been that person. He could have also worn a tarp (which was allegedly seen carried by Alex towards his mother's home) to cover himself from any evidence. All together, Alex made himself less suspicious why he would be carrying a gun and to not surprise Maggie and Paul. This could mean that he has a gun (or guns) with him during that time. Just my two cents...
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Maggie would go down to the kennels and put the dogs away. Bubba had a chronic bird in mouth issue.
He lured them both there then ambushed them what a great dad and husband.
Technology is GREAT! We are followed everywhere but if you are not a criminal you don't care. Saves lives and solves crimes! Good job, dear poor Paul.
Depends on who makes the laws.
@@theoryofpersonality1420 For me it doesn't. Law is made by politicians chosen by people so people are obliged to follow the laws made by people they chose.
@@izabela1961 oh so simple minded. Bet you’re boosted x5 too
It really makes me sad that it is looking like AM murdered his family - it's still saddening when we find yet another evil, callous person.
Any time you find a family that has generational power like that, you're looking at a family of psychopaths. Psychopathy is genetic, and narcissists who are addicted to social status and wealth marry into these families. Both are empathy deficient and morally bankrupt (and sexually deviant). It would CURL YOUR HAIR if you knew what these people do behind closed doors.
I’ve heard people speculate that Paul says “It’s all right dad.” But this makes sense.
He died immediately so how could he say that to his dad?
@@rhondafredericksen2302 This was right after Alex was yelling at Bubba about the chicken, I believe. “Oh, Bubba!” “It’s all right dad.”
You always deliver !!!
Vinnie is a pro, the background noise and the peeps would have had me so distracted lol
@Court TV What do you know about the phone call that was made to 911 at the same time Alex was calling 911, by a couple who were on the road that goes to AM's and they said that there was a man by the side of the road, covered in blood, he had what looked to be white or white/blond hair, waving his arms at them to stop, he had his trunk or hatch open, it was a black SUV. They said he looked frantic, covered in blood. The couple said it looked like a set up so they kept going. This was on the same road as AM's property, the same time that Alex was calling 911 too.
You are referring to the events of September 4 when Alex faked having a flat tire and had called his cousin to come and help him, then produced a rifle which they struggled over. The life insurance phony suicide event. lex has not faced trial yet on that fraud indictment.
That was the planned suicide in Sept.
Alex not only has no alibi, cell phone evidence proves he was at the kennel with Maggie and Paul when they were murdered. Did Alex hire someone/s to do the dirty deeds$ for him or did he do it himself? Why did Alex change from long pants and long sleeve shirt that day to wearing a t shirt and shorts that night? and did he change his clothes after the murders which would explain no blood on his clothes despite his claim that he touched the blood covered bodies. He didn't even have blood on his hands and if he did touch the bodies as he claims, he would et least have blood on his hands. I think he showered and changed his clothes 'after' the murders.
Realistically, it's not unusual for people to don casual clothes in the evening.
@@combatepistemologist8382 He had already changed from his work clothes to the blue shirt and khaki's in the 7:44 om video. Sitting in the police car in the white T shirt he was wearing was FRESH, still had the fold creases in it.
i dont believe dude didnt hear the gunshots. i can hear my neighbors guns going off miles away. im catching up on this case so i dont know what gun was used. but even if it was a 9mm, i dont believe he didnt hear it within that convenient ten minute nap.
He used a hose near the kennels to wash off. There wear puddles when the police arrived. I' don't know where he got clean clothes or if they ever found the guns. Haven't heard about that
Cash is truly heaven sent !! Thank God Paul suspected something wrong with the tail & wanted to let his buddy know … that’s the nail in the coffin!
Yep those dogs are heroes. Also Bubba who made Alex call out!!!!
Nothing happens by accident.
I don't know about cash being heaven sent.....but EXTRA cash ...now that I always thank heaven for!! (HA HA I am just teasing you, I know what you really meant!)
That laptop sitting there with all the movement, no hands holding it in place. It is giving me so much anxiety. 😐
How did Alex know they had been “shot badly” ?
What if someone swung an axe onto Paul ?
Did Alex ever ask if there were any other type of weapon(s) involved?
Alex killed his son and wife, that's how he knew they had been shot so badly. Paul 3 in body and 2 times in head, then Maggie 5 times in body then 2 times in the back of the head with a high power rifle. It appears he hated maggie, he shot her so many times with high power. He definitely wanted them both dead . with no reason why
It is hard to hear you guys in the restaurant. 😊
20:30 time stamp: interaction with Siri could be Maggie saying “Siri call 911”
no. this happens when u press the side button and siri does that little beeping sound to let u know u woke her up.
the emergency call is done by holding both buttons. it doesnt require siri.
That 3rd voice in the video is 💯 percent Alex Murdaugh .
Alex tried to throw off he just did it with the 2 weapons etc he did it on purpose to cause doubt!
Things seemed so normal in that moment, all the while Alex knew he was about to shoot and kill his wife and son😢
Yep it’s unimaginable for a normal person but I guess not for a psychopath
I know, I'm stumped as to what motivated him to do this.
Yep, j new sneaky of him
Normal people can't fathum a father killing his son. A narcissistic, entitled, coward with the world closing in on him sees it very differently.
Love watching Vinnie! ⚖️
Do you all know that AM bought the Moselle property for $5.00 from the widow of his good friend and business partner, and that he also took the man’s life insurance? I think AM was born bad…that whole family is bad! I’d also like to know what Harpootlian’s voters and supporters think of him seeking the limelight/spotlight to represent a family annihilator…!
It totally makes sense that a father would murder his own son if he couldn’t afford his defense fees for the boat trial.
By a family that’s not used to being humble or poor.
Nor could he afford a divorce! Case closed!!!
But he's still paying.
Well he's still responsible and he's still paying.
@@rhondafredericksen2302 Paying for what? Certainly not Paul’s trial. Mallory’s family is suing, but they’re not likely to get much.
I wonder if Alex's father prematurely died after learning of Maggie and Paul's murders. He died two days later.
No, he was not there
@@rhondafredericksen2302 ????
He left his phone at the house to make it appear he was at the house and then lied abt being at the kennels, Premeditated.
The cellphone evidence is damning but it is the compilation of several important facts when you look at the bigger picture that really nails Alex as the murderer!
That is how every successful trial is resolved
Many sloppy errors by AM.
@@davidhughes5788 I think w/o the cell phone evidence, he would walk.
@Deborah Hershey but there is cell phone evidence and it shows how many errors he made. No blood on him at all after touching the bodies is suspicious plus his bizarre alibi...plus the Boat lawsuit plus the business massive lawsuit. Plus all of the other people's cellphone evidence...too much evidence plus a real motive too much to ignore. The police would keep looking and find no other person but AM. He is guilty af.
Agreed, it's the confluence of so many factors together that make this airtight. Now, if the ignorant, narcissistic jurors from this community will convict him, that will be a miracle.
He suspected a video, he tells police he picked up Paul's phone and was going to do something with it but changed his mind. He really fumbles his words at that point. Maybe he just wasnt able to access it? I think he was worried about the video.
Ok so with his phone not recording any steps while hers is moving, I heard people keep bringing up that his data wasn’t on at that time, is that true and would that matter?
Also, didn’t they say that because his phone wasn’t extracted until August that many things were overwritten? Steps data could have been overwritten since then.
My iphone stay is driving mode once I'm out of the car, and it goes INTO driving mode if I hold it out and spin around in a circle. It's not always accurate.
@ 5.59, I hear Alex say "What's the matter, Paul?" and Paul answers "It's nothing, dad" in the video clip!
good catch
Why would Vince have this video with so much noise in the background.!!!
I think Alec knew Paul was filming a video, that's why he touched Paul's phone after he shot him. I think he wanted to delete the video, but maybe the phone was locked or Alec realized he would get dna or blood on the phone.
looks like paul was shot while he was in the middle of chatting with his gf and his friend. i dont think he knew his son recorded a video.
@@cerebrumexcrement If he was recording AS he was shot......would a video continue to record or do you have to hold a button and release when done filming ???(sorry, I don't own a smartphone or do snaptchat)
Needed face recognition to open it. His dad blew his brain out of his head so recognition would not recognize his face, same with maggie
There was testimony that his phone didn’t have any activity at all within a certain time frame. Prosecutors need to tighten that up and show a map with times as to where the phones were. Demonstratives with re to the cellphones are highly needed for this case. Not sure if the jury has them and the public doesn’t.
Rogan also texted Maggie asking her to have Paul call him. It went unread.
What is the time stamp of the video with dog… it could have been taken at a completely different time. Is there a digital time stamp on that?
How is the defense going to get out of this??? That voice is clearly his. This alone is enough to make the jurors convict him. It certainly has caused me to make up my mind that he did it.
It is the first bit of evidence that makes Alex guilty.
Why does the prosecution need to have their ideas approved by the judge ? I mean even in the Cayce Anthony trial they let the prosecution commit a horror on the grandfather by claiming he was the one responsible for Caylee’s death. Which was completely desperate and crazy.
That was the defense
@@LaurenRuby The defense side can come with any odd theory but the prosecution has to hope a judge will allow info that seems obviously pertinent ? It’s strange that it would have to be an uphill battle, since they’d need to back up what they claim anyway ? It seems too that the prosecution didn’t go about this very well since if they’d connected all the dots (for permission or whatever) before the trial started this wouldn’t be going on now.
Maybe he was wearing his AirPods, told Siri to call his wife’s phone while his phone was inside the car. This way the phone will not have any record of him walking
It does make sense. Alex is a family annihilator.
It's Vinnie!!!! Hi Vinnie!!!
Where's the beef?
Why the hell is Buster and the rest of the family still standing by Alex I’d like to know!?
To impress the jury, that's all
That's his only family member left