Un concierto para mi absolutamente desconocido. No creo haberlo oído nunca antes. Pero el 1 y el 2 son tan avasallantes que han ocultado este, que sin duda es menor
Only that it is an arrangement of sketches left unfinished at the time of Mendelssohn's death to create this concerto, listed as No 3, Op. Posthumous. I don't know if the composer was actually working on it when he died or simply lost interest in it along the way; I suspect the latter, because the work, though it has some fine moments, seems pedestrian compared to the established Mendelssohn canon. To me, the slow movement is more convincing whereas the opening movement has little of the dash, exhilaration, and momentum I expect from a Mendelssohn first movement in quick tempo.
Bufalini's arrangement works quite well. If I didn't know this was constructed from sketches I'll bet even the experts might be fooled into believed this was the genuine article. Unfortunately, Doležel slows the tempo of the 1st movement down to the point it drags. I don't like breakneck speeds like Serkin's but neither do I like Mendelssohn played at a snail's pace. Prosseda gets just the right tempo and he's the one that premiered the concerto. This should rank right up their with the No's 1 and 2 in terms of quality and I hope it finds its way into the repertoire although I knows purists will scream, "Foul!"
Dear JJ Townley, this is not my arrangement, which is the one you have heard in the Prosseda-Chailly Decca recording, and was commissioned to me by Mr. Prosseda himself; I think this one should be by Larry Todd.
Prosseda narrates episodes in the Lezioni di Musica podcast series on RAI Italian radio, and has been busy during Covid doing live pedagogy from his home on Instagram. Very sharp guy.
Who would have thunk there was another Mendelssohn Piano Concerto out there? Amazing! In all honesty it should be listed Felix Mendelssohn-Bartholdy/Bufalini- Piano Concerto No. 3. Whoops! It is only one movement which gives a feeling of incompleteness. All-in-all, it is not successful because while what is written is interesting, it doesn't measure up to a true piano concerto nor a complete Mendelssohn creation. It seems to meander and unlike Mendelssohn wont, it just seems to drift away. How about giving it another name. It is just not a true piano concerto. How about "Concertino"?
Nonsense. Practically all concert pianists play from memory. I played the Mendelssohn Concerto No. 1 with the Columbus Symphony when I was still in high school and did it all from memory.
@@OrchestrMUNI The so-called "Mendelssohn's Piano Concerto No. 3"... FAKE! "Liszt's Piano Concerto No. 3" is also a fake... FAKE! "Rachmaninov's Piano Concerto No. 5" is a fake, too... FAKE! etc.
In this orchestra,
all is full of far superior splendor amazing,
especially
the wonderfulness of his piano playing is off the charts
Never the less it's his romantic style. Love it!
Pieter Domburg 第二楽章は無言歌ぽくて佳いですね❣️
Un concierto para mi absolutamente desconocido. No creo haberlo oído nunca antes. Pero el 1 y el 2 son tan avasallantes que han ocultado este, que sin duda es menor
So was this concerto never official? I never got it on my cd's as a kid.....
There's a gorgeous 2nd movement I can't find of Mendelssohn, I have concerto's one and two, but w/e
It maybe just only exist in my head space who knows.
Someone can tell me something about this piece?
Only that it is an arrangement of sketches left unfinished at the time of Mendelssohn's death to create this concerto, listed as No 3, Op. Posthumous. I don't know if the composer was actually working on it when he died or simply lost interest in it along the way; I suspect the latter, because the work, though it has some fine moments, seems pedestrian compared to the established Mendelssohn canon. To me, the slow movement is more convincing whereas the opening movement has little of the dash, exhilaration, and momentum I expect from a Mendelssohn first movement in quick tempo.
MENDELSHON'S CONCERTO n* 3..ONE OF THE BEST MUSICIan.at 2o years old..conduct t bach's sant matthew oratorio...
nice!
Bufalini's arrangement works quite well. If I didn't know this was constructed from sketches I'll bet even the experts might be fooled into believed this was the genuine article. Unfortunately, Doležel slows the tempo of the 1st movement down to the point it drags. I don't like breakneck speeds like Serkin's but neither do I like Mendelssohn played at a snail's pace. Prosseda gets just the right tempo and he's the one that premiered the concerto. This should rank right up their with the No's 1 and 2 in terms of quality and I hope it finds its way into the repertoire although I knows purists will scream, "Foul!"
Dear JJ Townley, this is not my arrangement, which is the one you have heard in
the Prosseda-Chailly Decca recording, and was commissioned to me by Mr. Prosseda himself; I think this one should be by Larry Todd.
Prosseda narrates episodes in the Lezioni di Musica podcast series on RAI Italian radio, and has been busy during Covid doing live pedagogy from his home on Instagram. Very sharp guy.
아,,,갓델스존
Who would have thunk there was another Mendelssohn Piano Concerto out there? Amazing!
In all honesty it should be listed Felix Mendelssohn-Bartholdy/Bufalini- Piano Concerto No. 3.
Whoops! It is only one movement which gives a feeling of incompleteness.
All-in-all, it is not successful because while what is written is interesting, it doesn't measure up to a true piano concerto nor a complete Mendelssohn creation.
It seems to meander and unlike Mendelssohn wont, it just seems to drift away.
How about giving it another name. It is just not a true piano concerto. How about "Concertino"?
メンデルスゾーン ピアノ 協奏曲1ばん
They are a little tight there...
Sleeping
人に聴かせる時は暗譜で演奏しましょう‼️ まさか練習風景ではないですよね⁉️ えっ、公開リハーサルでしたか❗️
指は機械のようによく動くけど、暗譜出来ない演奏者が多いですよね。平気で楽譜とにらめっこする演奏者に音楽学校の教官はどう指導してきたのでしょうか？？？
あんた、リヒテルって知ってるか・・・？
tomoyuki sugano
痴呆症で記憶が飛んでしまうようになった演奏者でしたね(^_-)
中村紘子も怒ってましたwww
I was going to say exactly the same.
lol, ya, I really want to see the typewrite/keyboard, I do!!!!
Nonsense. Practically all concert pianists play from memory. I played the Mendelssohn Concerto No. 1 with the Columbus Symphony when I was still in high school and did it all from memory.
FAKE!
What is fake?
@@OrchestrMUNI The so-called "Mendelssohn's Piano Concerto No. 3"... FAKE! "Liszt's Piano Concerto No. 3" is also a fake... FAKE! "Rachmaninov's Piano Concerto No. 5" is a fake, too... FAKE! etc.
@horiaganescu3948 its based off sketches by mendelssohn tho so its not completely fake
@@Max-qd3rb I know...