I think the high honor ending is the real ending to the story. From the beginning Arthur wanted to change his nature but knew he couldn't, so he helped John change his.
@@wrne7121 There isn't anything saying what's canon lol, at the end of the day it doesn't need to show what's canon, it can be left up to interpretation because at the end of the day, the only thing that we have to know is canon is the events of rdr2, and rdr1, not the ending to rdr2, or Arthur's actions
he couldnt because of micah getting in dutch's ear. i believe milton whole heartily when he said micahs the rat. but before ik any of that i didnt like him from the moment you meet him and he killed a man that was in the same boat as he was. not very honorable. micah was a true thief cause there no honor among thieves and shooting a guy rival or not while escaping is not honorable then lay waist to 90% of the town including inocent people that wernt involved at all
My grandfather passed away yesterday morning. I dedicate this music to you. You died like arthur, peacefully. Sorry for everyone reading this comment to ruin your day. I miss you so much grandpa, you liked this game along with your favourite clint eastwood western movies. I hope you are doing better in paradise...
@Arthur Callaghan thanks for your kind words. My grandfather had lung cancer wich he defeated but the therapy did a side effect on the lungs cavity that suffocated him. He didn't suffer tough thanks to morphine and died at his house peacefully. He loved western and loved red dead redemption 2. He was 73 and the entire city of my country knew him and loved him...
I’ve played and finished this game 6 times, and every time I tried to finish it with low honor but it took one mission or conversation/ choice and I just couldn’t. I’d maybe kill or antagonize to low honor, but then I do a story mission and I realize that I just couldn’t be bad, and Arthur just SHOULDN’T. I’m basically giving up on the low honor ending since I prefer the high honor ending. RIP Arthur Morgan, #1 Gaming Protagonist
I love the differences between the high honor and low honor version of this song. In the high honor version, it has the peaceful harmonica lead in the intro, and the background music is beautiful. In the low honor version, there's no harmonica, and the background music has a much darker, ominous tone. This game's soundtrack is amazing.
I've only heard the high honor version and it's so moving that I'm afraid to listen to the other version 😆 this story can't have a dark ending, I can't handle it.
I actually teared up at this part. I was thinking about my dad the whole time, he just passed away on the 7th of January and goddamn did this hit me like a slap in the face.
i’m sorry to hear about that man, My nan passed away very recently and a lot of this game reminds me of her, arthur’s arc and his final ride remind me of how much my nan always believed in second chances which is basically what this game is about
Closely, if you listen to both versions of this song ( high honour and low ) you can hear the fear in the low honour, it has a different tone and vibe, but in this version, it has more of an acceptance tone, meaning Arthur knows he’s gonna die, maybe he’s ready to die
I feel the exact same way. Hearing this version of the song on my first playthrough, a feeling of duty overwhelmed me. I knew I was going to die, but felt I HAD to do this whatever it takes. That's what great storywriting does, it takes you to places and feelings you didn't know exist.
I know this comment is a bit old, but I'll say this anyway: The key difference in the low honor version is the lack of a harmonica in the intro. It only has the depressing, foreboding tone in the background. The difference isn't huge, but it's enough to make a beautiful, peaceful song sound evil and sad. I absolutely love it.
@@umbreongaming9921I find the low honor theme fits Arthur perfectly. Due to to his unfortunate upbringing, tragic experiences, and unflinching outlaw lifestyle.Yet I guess there is still hope for some people. Despite their guilt and corrupt nature we can all at least try to be good.
“Why, you’re a good man. I just wish you’d done it before he worked hisself into the grave.” Mrs. Londonderry - “I'm really sorry for you, son, it's a hell of a thing.” Dr. Barnes - “Our time... has pretty much passed.” Arthur Morgan - “And all you can do now is decide the man you wanna be, for all the time you have left.” Edith Downes - “There's a good man within you... but he is wrestling with a giant.” Mary Linton - “We already owe more than it’s worth.” Thomas Downes - “I just don't want any more folks to die, Dutch.” Hosea Matthews - “Thank you, feller. You know, there ain't enough kindness in this world, that's for sure.” John J. Weathers - “You saved my life... You're a good man...” Jimmy Brooks - “Be grateful that for the first time, you see your life clearly.” Sister Calderón - “Save who you can and let the rest rot, and look after yourself.” Orville Swanson - “Maybe it's a sign, Arthur... try... try to do the good thing.” Mary-Beth Gaskill
My Mother has passed away a few weeks back and i'd like to dedicate this music to her. You are a great mom and i am very proud of be your son. Rest in Peace, Mom Always Love You.
Mine too. (Condolences). Also ur dedication was classy and direct. Not bloated w self pity/selfishness. I truly hope time heals u best as can. Best wishes and any comfort at all
“We are not Criminals…we are outlaws..” “I’m sorry for you son its a hell of a thing” “And all you can do now is decide the type of man you want to be for the time you have left”
My girl died, and so did my old boss.. Matty was the closest thing I had to a father. I wanted to get married to CC but my life changed, i moved to a new town, and re established myself some what, and this is the only piece of music holding my ass up. I think about them both every single day, and give myself a reason not to do it. Tell you why i dont, i am an assistant manager of a local liquor store and i do it for the customer. There are so many good people, innocent people who make me laugh an smile. If you love them, dont wait tell em today man. Much love to everyone who played Arthur’s story and if you’re ever in Delaware, drop into Greenwood, there’s only one liquor store and come bullshit with me on the register❤
I think the way I played really impacted me. When Arthur got TB, I saw and heard the low honor hallucinations, and by the time I got here I was max honor. Idk it really sold the idea to me that Arthur being faced with his own mortality forced him to start changing. He had always wanted to change but realizing he was going to die soon, he and I really started putting in a lot more effort
As much as I appreciate both versions, this is really the true way to listen to this song. The beautiful instrumental is completely missed /minimized in the low honour :(
At this part, it hit me real hard. I spoiled the game on purpose to get mentally ready for his death...but this song just hit me hard, i was crying until the end
I spoiled it for myself cuz I didn’t think I’d play it for a long while. Played it a year later and it still hit like a freight train because while yes I knew it was coming, that was MY Arthur. MY horse I had since the beginning. That old 15 dollar horse I bought with Hosea that I originally planned on ditching once I got the money and instead kept it until the end and now use in almost every playthru going forward.
I'm Only On Chapter 4 on Red dead Redemption 2 And I Listen To this Song to Keep me Calm, I Sometimes Exactly copy Arthur Morgans Horse Riding Stance. Edit After nearly 2 Yrs: Thank you So much For the Likes, I know it's not much but I appreciate it, have a Good day Or week :) Double Edit: I'm Going Through Things in My life That Breaks me Constantly. My Family members From My Dad's Side of his Family (10 People) passing away Due To Cancer. I hope Their Resting and Enjoying Heaven With their friends, family and Mates, Enjoying Pints in Peace.
@@katiet2987 yes, I've got to chapter 6 and Refusing Myself to Play anymore of campaign to carry on but to adventure as Arthur I did the Veteran Side Missions And the Vet Died and Gave me his rare Dutch-Warm blood Horse Buell, I know what happens to Arthur in the Mission *"Red Dead Redemption"* . I've got Arthur to Maximum High Honour, helping folk, saving folk, doing the "Noblest Of men and Women" (Got their Guns) found the Meteorite crash-site, meteor house etc RDR2 Is such an Amazing Game
This version of this represents my brother he is always trying to crack a smile on our friends faces even mind but I am always frowning (I rarly smile) but he is always trying to make me smile even when in our hardest of times cause the both of us had been through hard times in the past and it made me more serious and always quiet not talking to anyone So bassicly My brother: has high honour Me: has low honour
@@greycatofnobodys2007 well, "Don't be afraid. Be grateful that for the first time, you see your life clearly." "Take a gamble that love exists and do a loving act." Sister Calderón.
My first time playing this, when this theme started, I knew he was about to die. I knew how it ended but didn’t expect it to be so emotional. Had me bawling on the inside
high honors like arthurs satisfied with his decisions and he just accepts that he doesnt get anything in return. thats the way it is. in low honor, arthur regrets what hes done, and he knows that there will be consequences. thats the way it is.
That's the way it is Так тому и быть The many miles we walked Много миль, что мы прошли, The many things we learned Много вещей, которым мы обучились, The building of a shrine Строительство святыни только для того, Only just to burn Чтобы сгореть. May the wind be at your back Пусть ветер дует тебе в спину, Good fortune touch your hand А удача прикоснется к твоей руке, May the cards lay out a straight Пусть в твоем рукаве окажется козырь, All from your command Благодаря тебе самому. That's the way it is Так тому и быть. That’s the way it is Так тому и быть. That's the way it is Так тому и быть. That's the way it is Так тому и быть. Blue heron leaves the northern sky Голубая цапля покидает северное небо, Trusts the journey to new heights Доверяет свое путешествие новым высотам. What’s the meaning of the scar В чём смысл шрама, если мы If we don't know how to heal Не знаем, как исцелить себя? Реклама Should we ever be apart Должны ли мы разделяться? Then how does it feel Каково это? That's the way it is Так тому и быть. That's the way it is Так тому и быть. That's the way it is Так тому и быть. That's the way it is Так тому и быть. Shine light into darkness Будь светом во мраке. Shine light into darkness Будь светом во мраке. That's the way it is Так тому и быть. That's the way it is (So many miles to walk) Так тому и быть. (Так много миль еще можно пройти) That’s the way it is (So many things we’ve got to learn) Так тому и быть. (Так много вещей, которым осталось научиться) That's the way it is (Oh, that’s the way it is) Так тому и быть. (Ох, так тому и быть) That's the way it is (Oh) Так тому и быть. (Ох) That's the way it is Так тому и быть.
![Red Dead Redemption 2 Soundtrack - You're my brother FULL DEFINITIVE Version [HQ]](/img/n.gif)
I think the high honor ending is the real ending to the story. From the beginning Arthur wanted to change his nature but knew he couldn't, so he helped John change his.
It is cannon fortunately, before tuber he was low honor and after the dr he became high honor
@@wrne7121 There isn't anything saying what's canon lol, at the end of the day it doesn't need to show what's canon, it can be left up to interpretation because at the end of the day, the only thing that we have to know is canon is the events of rdr2, and rdr1, not the ending to rdr2, or Arthur's actions
@@thexylophone the events of red dead redemption 2 and the ending to the game change based on honor though so what u said made no real sense there
he couldnt because of micah getting in dutch's ear. i believe milton whole heartily when he said micahs the rat. but before ik any of that i didnt like him from the moment you meet him and he killed a man that was in the same boat as he was. not very honorable. micah was a true thief cause there no honor among thieves and shooting a guy rival or not while escaping is not honorable then lay waist to 90% of the town including inocent people that wernt involved at all
Imagine going for the money, when your sick and about to die. What kind of an idiot would? Idk.
"People never change, they just become more of who they really are."
"We can't change whats done, only move on."
That's why you need a savior, because you're a sinner
@@TheTenthLepergo preach somewhere else
@@TheTenthLeper A Man makes his own way. NON SERVIAM!
@@source6893this is the perfect place to preach tbh, like rdr2 teaches you to be a better person, so does Jesus
"maybe its a sign, Arthur try, try to do the good thing"
😭💔
I miss him so much☹️💔💔
only read your comments all game come instantly in my mind and I want cry again, and again...
"there Is a Good Man inside You Arthur, and He is Wrestling With a Giant"
That’s the quote that bridged the gap from tearing up to crying for me lol
"You know there aint enough kindness in this world thats for sure"
My grandfather passed away yesterday morning. I dedicate this music to you. You died like arthur, peacefully. Sorry for everyone reading this comment to ruin your day. I miss you so much grandpa, you liked this game along with your favourite clint eastwood western movies. I hope you are doing better in paradise...
F
@Arthur Callaghan thanks for your kind words. My grandfather had lung cancer wich he defeated but the therapy did a side effect on the lungs cavity that suffocated him. He didn't suffer tough thanks to morphine and died at his house peacefully. He loved western and loved red dead redemption 2. He was 73 and the entire city of my country knew him and loved him...
sorry for your loss. He is living happily in Heaven
@@FranklinDeTortuga thank you... i still miss him
@@karakizan he did play and watched rdr 2 but didn't see the ending
If you heard this version of the song on your first playthrough playing during this scene
I appreciate your kindness and high honor☺️
I’ve played and finished this game 6 times, and every time I tried to finish it with low honor but it took one mission or conversation/ choice and I just couldn’t. I’d maybe kill or antagonize to low honor, but then I do a story mission and I realize that I just couldn’t be bad, and Arthur just SHOULDN’T. I’m basically giving up on the low honor ending since I prefer the high honor ending. RIP Arthur Morgan, #1 Gaming Protagonist
I did and I am proud to have done that
I couldn't bring myself to do low honor actions :(
@@nathanaelward6868 same
@@memedaddy5817 no sane man/ women could ever do it at this stage - red dead REDEMPTION for a reason
Beginning: We are outlaws
End: That’s The Way It Is.
I love the differences between the high honor and low honor version of this song. In the high honor version, it has the peaceful harmonica lead in the intro, and the background music is beautiful. In the low honor version, there's no harmonica, and the background music has a much darker, ominous tone. This game's soundtrack is amazing.
I've only heard the high honor version and it's so moving that I'm afraid to listen to the other version 😆 this story can't have a dark ending, I can't handle it.
No matter how many times I replay this game, the ending, and the last ride with this music will always make me tear up.
Whenever I hear this I think of that last scene where Arthur say one last thank you to his horse before leaving. Nothing lasts forever.
I actually teared up at this part. I was thinking about my dad the whole time, he just passed away on the 7th of January and goddamn did this hit me like a slap in the face.
i’m sorry to hear about that man, My nan passed away very recently and a lot of this game reminds me of her, arthur’s arc and his final ride remind me of how much my nan always believed in second chances which is basically what this game is about
Bro my eyes becane a damn waterfall, such a damn good game
sorry to hear that, bro
Really sorry bro hope you are doing okay
Closely, if you listen to both versions of this song ( high honour and low ) you can hear the fear in the low honour, it has a different tone and vibe, but in this version, it has more of an acceptance tone, meaning Arthur knows he’s gonna die, maybe he’s ready to die
I feel the exact same way. Hearing this version of the song on my first playthrough, a feeling of duty overwhelmed me. I knew I was going to die, but felt I HAD to do this whatever it takes. That's what great storywriting does, it takes you to places and feelings you didn't know exist.
I know this comment is a bit old, but I'll say this anyway: The key difference in the low honor version is the lack of a harmonica in the intro. It only has the depressing, foreboding tone in the background. The difference isn't huge, but it's enough to make a beautiful, peaceful song sound evil and sad. I absolutely love it.
@@umbreongaming9921I find the low honor theme fits Arthur perfectly. Due to to his unfortunate upbringing, tragic experiences, and unflinching outlaw lifestyle.Yet I guess there is still hope for some people. Despite their guilt and corrupt nature we can all at least try to be good.
Oh Dutch... he gave u all he had... he did
“Why, you’re a good man. I just wish you’d done it before he worked hisself into the grave.” Mrs. Londonderry
-
“I'm really sorry for you, son, it's a hell of a thing.” Dr. Barnes
-
“Our time... has pretty much passed.” Arthur Morgan
-
“And all you can do now is decide the man you wanna be, for all the time you have left.” Edith Downes
-
“There's a good man within you... but he is wrestling with a giant.” Mary Linton
-
“We already owe more than it’s worth.” Thomas Downes
-
“I just don't want any more folks to die, Dutch.” Hosea Matthews
-
“Thank you, feller. You know, there ain't enough kindness in this world, that's for sure.” John J. Weathers
-
“You saved my life... You're a good man...” Jimmy Brooks
-
“Be grateful that for the first time, you see your life clearly.” Sister Calderón
-
“Save who you can and let the rest rot, and look after yourself.” Orville Swanson
-
“Maybe it's a sign, Arthur... try... try to do the good thing.” Mary-Beth Gaskill
My Mother has passed away a few weeks back and i'd like to dedicate this music to her. You are a great mom and i am very proud of be your son. Rest in Peace, Mom Always Love You.
My condolence
Mine too. (Condolences).
Also ur dedication was classy and direct. Not bloated w self pity/selfishness. I truly hope time heals u best as can.
Best wishes and any comfort at all
“We are not Criminals…we are outlaws..”
“I’m sorry for you son its a hell of a thing”
“And all you can do now is decide the type of man you want to be for the time you have left”
The 1st one ain't from high honor memories
"Thank you, feller. You know there ain't enough kindness in this world, that's for sure..."
I never knew there were two versions and for me this version (High Honor) is the real ending.
My girl died, and so did my old boss.. Matty was the closest thing I had to a father. I wanted to get married to CC but my life changed, i moved to a new town, and re established myself some what, and this is the only piece of music holding my ass up. I think about them both every single day, and give myself a reason not to do it. Tell you why i dont, i am an assistant manager of a local liquor store and i do it for the customer. There are so many good people, innocent people who make me laugh an smile. If you love them, dont wait tell em today man. Much love to everyone who played Arthur’s story and if you’re ever in Delaware, drop into Greenwood, there’s only one liquor store and come bullshit with me on the register❤
Stay strong friend.
I think the way I played really impacted me. When Arthur got TB, I saw and heard the low honor hallucinations, and by the time I got here I was max honor. Idk it really sold the idea to me that Arthur being faced with his own mortality forced him to start changing. He had always wanted to change but realizing he was going to die soon, he and I really started putting in a lot more effort
"you saved my life... your a good man"
Beginning of the game: we just need money and Tahiti Arthur
Ending: screw Arthur we are going back to the mountains yay perfect plan
Begging of the game they want to go to a farm in the west
I thought I was a pretty bad person in RDR2 but my honor was always high. Dunno, I picked every choice just like I would do irl
As much as I appreciate both versions, this is really the true way to listen to this song. The beautiful instrumental is completely missed /minimized in the low honour :(
At this part, it hit me real hard. I spoiled the game on purpose to get mentally ready for his death...but this song just hit me hard, i was crying until the end
we all cried man.. man, woman, old, young.. this is a masterpiece game.
I spoiled it for myself cuz I didn’t think I’d play it for a long while. Played it a year later and it still hit like a freight train because while yes I knew it was coming, that was MY Arthur. MY horse I had since the beginning. That old 15 dollar horse I bought with Hosea that I originally planned on ditching once I got the money and instead kept it until the end and now use in almost every playthru going forward.
you saved my live...you'r a good man
Jimmy Brocks.
*YOU'RE
BROOKS.
'Theres a good man within you.'
“It’s A Sign, Arthur.”
"Try, try to do the good thing"
I'm Only On Chapter 4 on Red dead Redemption 2 And I Listen To this Song to Keep me Calm, I Sometimes Exactly copy Arthur Morgans Horse Riding Stance.
Edit After nearly 2 Yrs: Thank you So much For the Likes, I know it's not much but I appreciate it, have a Good day Or week :)
Double Edit: I'm Going Through Things in My life That Breaks me Constantly. My Family members From My Dad's Side of his Family (10 People) passing away Due To Cancer. I hope Their Resting and Enjoying Heaven With their friends, family and Mates, Enjoying Pints in Peace.
Oh you poor soul...
Do you know what's coming?
@@katiet2987 shhhhh🤫
You still alive?
@@katiet2987 yes, I've got to chapter 6 and Refusing Myself to Play anymore of campaign to carry on but to adventure as Arthur I did the Veteran Side Missions And the Vet Died and Gave me his rare Dutch-Warm blood Horse Buell, I know what happens to Arthur in the Mission *"Red Dead Redemption"* .
I've got Arthur to Maximum High Honour, helping folk, saving folk, doing the "Noblest Of men and Women" (Got their Guns) found the Meteorite crash-site, meteor house etc RDR2 Is such an Amazing Game
“Were thieves in a world that don’t want us no more.”
I want this played at my funeral
Dang bro same
Arther may have killed but he was always a good man
This version of this represents my brother he is always trying to crack a smile on our friends faces even mind but I am always frowning (I rarly smile) but he is always trying to make me smile even when in our hardest of times cause the both of us had been through hard times in the past and it made me more serious and always quiet not talking to anyone
So bassicly
My brother: has high honour
Me: has low honour
Well, learn from him and achieve Redemption.
@Blue Xbox Gamer wish I could but I'm beyond achieving reception I'm afraid unless I can redeem myself
@@greycatofnobodys2007 well, "Don't be afraid. Be grateful that for the first time, you see your life clearly." "Take a gamble that love exists and do a loving act." Sister Calderón.
@Blue Xbox Gamer I do not think qouts will do anything I have to try redeeming myself if I can even try
@@greycatofnobodys2007 Well, maybe "Try. Try to do the good thing."
My first time playing this, when this theme started, I knew he was about to die. I knew how it ended but didn’t expect it to be so emotional. Had me bawling on the inside
Widow: *words*
"Why you are good man" because i always played arthur with high honor
not even my music genre and I like it
Same I've always hated country music but I absolutely love this
Gonna play this on my drive home from work the day I’m either fired or if I quit.
Same but I'd be playing American venom if I quit and I hated the job
Good call.
@maxm2317 if you ever get a career in construction or house building, be sure to blast the house building theme 24/7
Will do.
“we all live bad lives, Mr Morgan, we all sin.”
I’ve gotten this one while playing, it fits Arthur well
I gave you all I had
I got the other version of the song with high honor luckily I wasn't too danm evil.
I miss arthur morgan😔💔
Me too
😭💔.
We all do
Red Dead Redemption 2 is the only game that made me cry
I didn’t realize that the dark lord of the Sith would cry at something like this.
He didn't do it he can't anymore
@@CynicalJonas it’s a running theme that the sith lords are emotional messes
Brilliant music and stunning visuals!
The goosbumbs
My old man said if you look at the stars long enough you can see the whole world go by 😔
just gotta learn thats the way it is
This video needs more likes and views
RIP Arthur Morgan.
I was really close to having low honor the first time but then I figured it out
the alternate version is haunting nightmare.
This is the good ending tbh the bad ending is low honor which is much more sad
I did low honor my first play through
My pa said if you stare into the fire long enough, you can see the whole world pass by...
My last thing on my bucket list is riding a horse to this song
high honors like arthurs satisfied with his decisions and he just accepts that he doesnt get anything in return. thats the way it is. in low honor, arthur regrets what hes done, and he knows that there will be consequences. thats the way it is.
3x this song and game broke me now :(
No matter how many times I play RDR2 I will never do a low honor gameplay ever 🙏
“Be loyal to what matters”
Fuck me this tune has me gearing up another playthru at 4 or 5 am, x amount of years later
Let's go🐎
Great job
“You’re my brother!”
“I know…. I know”
You'll do whats right
That's the way it is
Так тому и быть
The many miles we walked
Много миль, что мы прошли,
The many things we learned
Много вещей, которым мы обучились,
The building of a shrine
Строительство святыни только для того,
Only just to burn
Чтобы сгореть.
May the wind be at your back
Пусть ветер дует тебе в спину,
Good fortune touch your hand
А удача прикоснется к твоей руке,
May the cards lay out a straight
Пусть в твоем рукаве окажется козырь,
All from your command
Благодаря тебе самому.
That's the way it is
Так тому и быть.
That’s the way it is
Так тому и быть.
That's the way it is
Так тому и быть.
That's the way it is
Так тому и быть.
Blue heron leaves the northern sky
Голубая цапля покидает северное небо,
Trusts the journey to new heights
Доверяет свое путешествие новым высотам.
What’s the meaning of the scar
В чём смысл шрама, если мы
If we don't know how to heal
Не знаем, как исцелить себя?
Реклама
Should we ever be apart
Должны ли мы разделяться?
Then how does it feel
Каково это?
That's the way it is
Так тому и быть.
That's the way it is
Так тому и быть.
That's the way it is
Так тому и быть.
That's the way it is
Так тому и быть.
Shine light into darkness
Будь светом во мраке.
Shine light into darkness
Будь светом во мраке.
That's the way it is
Так тому и быть.
That's the way it is (So many miles to walk)
Так тому и быть. (Так много миль еще можно пройти)
That’s the way it is (So many things we’ve got to learn)
Так тому и быть. (Так много вещей, которым осталось научиться)
That's the way it is (Oh, that’s the way it is)
Так тому и быть. (Ох, так тому и быть)
That's the way it is (Oh)
Так тому и быть. (Ох)
That's the way it is
Так тому и быть.
How did you get these 2 versions of the songs?
Have high or low honor
I only said hi to everyone
how did you got the extended one from the end?
They ripped the audio from the game files
Gran tema para recordar a mi amigo Arthur morgan con su ultima galopada😢😢😢
we are more ghosts than people
Can't believe that Arthur Morgan is going to be missed after Riding his Horse. 🥺😢😢😢😢😭💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔
Song makes me think of matpat lol
Great
yes, Arthur Morgan is a good men.
What genre is this?
Final ride
Nice song 🔥🌈🌕