I finally managed to force myself to do a low honor playthrough, was tough being so rude. I didn't even know this version of the song existed until I heard it then and there for the first time as Arthur was riding to his last mission. Gave me chills and I've been playing and replaying this game since it came out.
I 100% the game about a month ago, and now I recently started a low honor playthrough. I already felt terrible killing the train guards that were in Cornwalls private boxcar at the end of the train robbery. Yep, low honor isn't going to happen for me. I should probably take break from this game for a while, the 100% completion has drained me. I 100% rdr1 and undead nightmare too.
As a logo on one of my 'T' shirts says, "If your path leads you to hell, walk around as though you own the place" which I think Arthur would accomplish easily.😀
Yea, it definitely fits the vibe, I like how they didn't use many, if any, high pitched instruments in this. It's just really low, dark sounding drones and synths which fits the dark and low down nature of a low honor play through.
2:36 this for me is the biggest difference in the songs. Typically my fav part of the harmonica comes in. Instead here it’s that sinister sounding noise. Very well made game
I can’t bring myself to ever complete a low honor play through, but this is by far my favorite version. It’s crazy how they could make essentially the same song convey completely different feelings
@@FormerlyEpicjcatDon't worry, lol. I just did a low honor playthrough for the first time recently. When I hit chapter 6 I worked on raising my honor as much as possible so that Arthur could "redeem" himself
Imagine you got the low honor version of that‘s the way its is, but Arthur redeems himself by helping John so he gets high honor Unshaken. That‘s the canon ending for me (even though Mr Morgan was always a good man)
To me this song gives two themes. One that, while the high honor version is in a sense rewarding you for your selfless actions and letting you reflect on them with a sense of pride This song makes you look at yourself and see that you made mistakes, Horrible mistakes and now it was time to pay. But it wasn’t too late. There was still one last chance to make things right with the melody played at the end. As if it were imploring you to dig yourself out of the Hell you made for yourself. And two, that no matter how good some of us may think we are. There is a dark side. And we have to struggle and fight to avoid succumbing to that darkness and becoming better people. IMO. That’s the way it is.
This was the only version I knew when I completed the game 4 years ago on low honour. Wow so emotional, this game could be a Netflix series. No game has ever given me the nostalgia and emotional feeling this game did.
This was the last ride/ending I got first time and I have no regrets. I was a cold killer and stayed true to going after the money, this theme was perfect to sum that up.
This song makes me think on all the bad choices and mistakes I've made. I'm with you Arthur, I've lived a bad life too. I'm sorry Ryder and Zack. I could have been a better friend, I should have. I could have supported you when you needed someone, now you're gone and I can't even tell you sorry. I'm trying to be better person, but I have a long way to go.
If a RDR2 movie comes out This better be the trailer music because holy shit this just evoked all the emotions back into me that playing this beautiful magnificent game Brought me the first time.
i physically cannot bring myself to doing the low honor ending no matter what Edit: I got the low honor ending and got shot by micah, balling my eyes out rn 😭😭😭😭
Basically what I did to get this song, was be just a bit under mid honour. I then selected help John which gave me more honour after this song and got the good ending. It works really well if you want the music and it's just a sad feeling this low honour version.
Both high honor and low honor have their own way to be deep as you play the game focusing on one of them from the start to the end. This low honor reflects how Arthur is corrupted by his bad and evil actions before, the game feels like Arthur knows that his time is over, the memories when he did bad things to people come in, and he has to finish his last job once and for all with all he had. He accepts his fate and tries to face it with the same way he faced people and their problems. Now high honor Arthur feels he can die in peace, with no regrets or bad feelings because of how many good things he did for the others. High honor theme reflects peace, harmony and mission complete, like a good ending. Arthur knows that he'll die, and he decides to give all he got to save the last people that needs him and try to fix the trouble between the gang to make things clear. High honor Arthur: I'll die in an hour, but there's still someone who needs me, besides, I have to talk to Dutch. Low honor Arthur: I'll die in an hour, but I must have a big chat with Dutch about the time he turned on me and also tell him about Micah and deal with this two, once and for all. We can see how Arthur thinks about Dutch just after getting back to Van Horn. In Guarma, he saw that Dutch was acting crazier than before and he starts to suspect him, but after Guarma he becomes angry with Dutch, even more after he turned his back when he most needed him. Arthur's intention was to kill Micah so badly and kill Dutch after Micah, not likely just get after Dutch and kill him, but firstly have a conversation with him to see if he still is going to say the same things he usually does, since Arthur was doubting that when he was trying to involve with the natives, always saying the same thing that even John perceived that too before. This could seem to Arthur that Dutch were still crazy and he would not try to change himself, I believe since we are talking about low honor Arthur, he would probably duel or take other severe actions against Dutch.
playing rdr2 with low honor is not hard, but playing low honor the "true way" is what really made me change my perspective on this game, the game goes from you being a nice and caring guy who will go out of their way to help; to a person whos out for one thing... to survive, but the things you do on the way is scary
Thanks for this. I much prefer the sound of the low honor song. The only problem is that it is shorter than the high honor version and you cannot seem to purchase it. I have the soundtrack from iTunes which includes the high honor song but you cannot find the low honor version which is an oversight in my opinion. I am loving the outro here as it extends the song nicely.
I really have no clue what to do about my drug addiction. Nothing in life comes close to the high of drugs. But I still wanna quit. That's why I listen to this song. Like Arthur, I keep doing bad things even though I know what the right thing to do is. Idk ik this seems corny and shit and it might seem like I'm grabbing attention but I need help. I have no clue what to do and I'm going down a really fucked up path.
Guys, i just realized something....(Spoilers Ahead! You have been warned!) The song is called that's the way it is right? So it might mean that it's telling that Arthur died and them trying to save him That they can't save Arthur from dying! (Yall already figured it out)
It’s like a man who got treated horribly and had a hard life just gave up being good and didn’t care about anything anymore so he has no morals or compassion for anyone or anything so he lost himself forever and is heading for the underworld instead of heaven
The first time i played rdr2 honestly i didn't care too much about the story and the only think i wanted was k1ll and rob (i tought that it was the same like gta) and wthout taking care to the honor bar, at the end of the prologue i got the bad ending but i helped john to escape i didn't even care about arthur until he died, now i always i start a new game i always try to get the good ending but this song always makes me remember the first time.
Us before this: Highest Quality pls Us after this: ULTRASONIC HIGH QUALITY PLEASE!!! (Not saying it’s bad just want a better one, it’s not THAT bad it’s just not loud enough)
this version feels like the sad realistic situation arthur really is in and the game really is coming to an end, i love the original but man, this one has much more emotion
this version played on my first playthrough and i redeemed myself by helping john and got the high honor ending where you die on the hill facing the sun.
Do you know what the name of the song that plays when low honour Arthur gets his diagnosis with TB, and if possible would you be able to upload it, if you haven't already. Thanks.
So all I could find is the backing track (and a riser?) for both versions (which I can upload if you want) . But I found both versions, someone else uploaded them. Low Honor: th-cam.com/video/eRSWI7nSFEU/w-d-xo.html High Honor: th-cam.com/video/I7GpZZhuxH0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=IiPDlIJqku3Y88JK
Though many would prefer the high honor version so that Arthur can have a good ending, in truth he lived a very evil life. For those who’re religious, they know where Arthur went after his death especially when he never proclaimed faith in God. So this, is really his song.
@proffesorsyntax401 well now.... Not only am I still playing this brilliant art of a game years later, but STILL learning new things. Thanks for the quick response mate!!!
The only think i will have to say is listen with a good sound system or with head phones. I try to hear it on my phone and you dont hear the very low bassy tunes. Sound way to much distortion
This playlist has all the songs with lyrics in the game in highest quaility. Same version as the one from Spotify. th-cam.com/play/OLAK5uy_kj3Ql4kDDvzBzNYqEiiUU3Aked6gwDIy8.html&si=7yLooCbRHEwvLQRX
This song literally displays a message from God that your time of terror is over and that you shall pay for all the sins you've committed throughout your life
![Piss Towel OST - International Secrets [REMAKE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/PlJlQEDrbt0/mqdefault.jpg)
"Sad thing is, good people do bad things." -Hosea
That outro… no sadder feeling than knowing the consequences of your actions being tenfold worse when it’s given back to you
Fr the outro always gets me. Especially since the fun little harmonica is my fav part in other version and it’s missing
As in real life, there's no payoff to being evil. That's the way it is.
You can still get high honor ending
this version gives me chills but still sad at the same time
I never went for a low honor playthrough, i have told myself I will, but when I do the npcs feel to real for me to be a bad guy. It feels dirty.
@@proffesorsyntax401 Exactly, this game has that kind of impact of it being realistic
I finally managed to force myself to do a low honor playthrough, was tough being so rude. I didn't even know this version of the song existed until I heard it then and there for the first time as Arthur was riding to his last mission. Gave me chills and I've been playing and replaying this game since it came out.
I 100% the game about a month ago, and now I recently started a low honor playthrough. I already felt terrible killing the train guards that were in Cornwalls private boxcar at the end of the train robbery. Yep, low honor isn't going to happen for me. I should probably take break from this game for a while, the 100% completion has drained me. I 100% rdr1 and undead nightmare too.
I must not be human🤪
when ur final exam is the next day but you didnt study:
completely plagiarising the top comment of another video including this song
@@gordonfreeman6511is anything on TH-cam original these days?
@@ben-sm1xo hell I've yet to see a original comment,and at this point video as well, it's all just becoming full copy cats of each other now
lol i listened to this when i was studying for said exam and got a A
Me fr
This feels like Arthur realising he really is going to die, with him in the low honour save john ending doing one final attempt to redeem himself
this version has the "welcome to hell" feeling
As a logo on one of my 'T' shirts says, "If your path leads you to hell, walk around as though you own the place" which I think Arthur would accomplish easily.😀
Playing this in my car when I drive to the last day of school as a senior
upload a video pls!
I didn’t even know it sounded different in the low honor , I actually really like the low honor one sounds cool
Yea, it definitely fits the vibe, I like how they didn't use many, if any, high pitched instruments in this. It's just really low, dark sounding drones and synths which fits the dark and low down nature of a low honor play through.
@@proffesorsyntax401nailed it💯 I said the same
@@proffesorsyntax401 yeah it does, sounds awesome!
Going for all endings. already got 3. 2 high honor for helping john escape and go for money and low honor run helping john
2:36 this for me is the biggest difference in the songs. Typically my fav part of the harmonica comes in. Instead here it’s that sinister sounding noise. Very well made game
If you get the low honor ending in RDR2, basically it means you've failed the main quest of the game: the redemption part of Red Dead Redemption...
As shown by the hopelessness in this version.
If you get high honor you fail the red dead part which is first and thus most important
@@tobyflederstech5305 you're supposed to go through the first part in the early stages of the game until Guarma
I can’t bring myself to ever complete a low honor play through, but this is by far my favorite version. It’s crazy how they could make essentially the same song convey completely different feelings
I cant let Micah Do that then again if you go for the money you can do something Pretty crazy on low honour
@@FormerlyEpicjcatYou get to slash his eye with high honor if you go for the money too. He doesn't kill Arthur as long as you have high honor
@@Trilasent oh sorry
@@FormerlyEpicjcatDon't worry, lol. I just did a low honor playthrough for the first time recently. When I hit chapter 6 I worked on raising my honor as much as possible so that Arthur could "redeem" himself
Yeah in the other one it’s like “that’s the way it is, let’s do the best we can”
This one is like “that’s the way it is, I didn’t have a choice”
Dutch- we are not criminals we are outlaws
*I get sick with cough*
Automatically I:
Your comedy is funny
@B.I.T.G- bot 💀
Does this imply you're on low honor irl rn
Imagine you got the low honor version of that‘s the way its is, but Arthur redeems himself by helping John so he gets high honor Unshaken. That‘s the canon ending for me (even though Mr Morgan was always a good man)
This is why this part 3:02 for me, feels like there's still hope, for me at least
This is my headcanon, as well. It just feels right.
To me this song gives two themes. One that, while the high honor version is in a sense rewarding you for your selfless actions and letting you reflect on them with a sense of pride This song makes you look at yourself and see that you made mistakes, Horrible mistakes and now it was time to pay. But it wasn’t too late. There was still one last chance to make things right with the melody played at the end. As if it were imploring you to dig yourself out of the Hell you made for yourself. And two, that no matter how good some of us may think we are. There is a dark side. And we have to struggle and fight to avoid succumbing to that darkness and becoming better people. IMO. That’s the way it is.
This was the only version I knew when I completed the game 4 years ago on low honour. Wow so emotional, this game could be a Netflix series. No game has ever given me the nostalgia and emotional feeling this game did.
don't compare this masterpiece to a Netflix series boah
this version is somehow so much more devastating
"We are not Criminals, We Are OUTLAW" 🤠💀
outlaws for life, fellas
There’s a differences?
@@Dyabcito”Of course there is a GODDAMN difference!”
This is my theme song (I’m currently stuck in a phase where I want to let my anger run wild in a public setting)
This was the last ride/ending I got first time and I have no regrets.
I was a cold killer and stayed true to going after the money, this theme was perfect to sum that up.
Me walking to dean’s office:
You don't get to live a bad life and expect good things to happen to you
Arthur Morgan 1899
That's the exactly quote that i remind when i hear this version of the song
The long drive home right after having my dog put down…
HEAVENLY OUTRO
This song makes me think on all the bad choices and mistakes I've made. I'm with you Arthur, I've lived a bad life too.
I'm sorry Ryder and Zack. I could have been a better friend, I should have. I could have supported you when you needed someone, now you're gone and I can't even tell you sorry. I'm trying to be better person, but I have a long way to go.
You can forgive yourself. You've done bad things, but you can grow. I don't know who you are, or what you've done, but I forgive you.
You can't be worse than low honor Arthur
theres still time. grow better
If a RDR2 movie comes out
This better be the trailer music because holy shit this just evoked all the emotions back into me that playing this beautiful magnificent game
Brought me the first time.
This game feels like time traveling
i physically cannot bring myself to doing the low honor ending no matter what Edit: I got the low honor ending and got shot by micah, balling my eyes out rn 😭😭😭😭
Is about you, basically you are a kind person, im medium honor bc sometimes the good things what i do is bad things, sorry for my bad english
me neither pal High Honor every time both Arthur and John
Basically what I did to get this song, was be just a bit under mid honour. I then selected help John which gave me more honour after this song and got the good ending. It works really well if you want the music and it's just a sad feeling this low honour version.
True there is a way to get this song but still have the good ending
Getting shot by Micah doesn’t really make you sad it pisses you off the most
I didnt know they change based on honour still cool
Bro had enough of his tomfoolery
At least Arhur tried to help until final mission
It all went downhill once I got dynamite
Both high honor and low honor have their own way to be deep as you play the game focusing on one of them from the start to the end. This low honor reflects how Arthur is corrupted by his bad and evil actions before, the game feels like Arthur knows that his time is over, the memories when he did bad things to people come in, and he has to finish his last job once and for all with all he had. He accepts his fate and tries to face it with the same way he faced people and their problems. Now high honor Arthur feels he can die in peace, with no regrets or bad feelings because of how many good things he did for the others. High honor theme reflects peace, harmony and mission complete, like a good ending. Arthur knows that he'll die, and he decides to give all he got to save the last people that needs him and try to fix the trouble between the gang to make things clear.
High honor Arthur: I'll die in an hour, but there's still someone who needs me, besides, I have to talk to Dutch.
Low honor Arthur: I'll die in an hour, but I must have a big chat with Dutch about the time he turned on me and also tell him about Micah and deal with this two, once and for all.
We can see how Arthur thinks about Dutch just after getting back to Van Horn. In Guarma, he saw that Dutch was acting crazier than before and he starts to suspect him, but after Guarma he becomes angry with Dutch, even more after he turned his back when he most needed him. Arthur's intention was to kill Micah so badly and kill Dutch after Micah, not likely just get after Dutch and kill him, but firstly have a conversation with him to see if he still is going to say the same things he usually does, since Arthur was doubting that when he was trying to involve with the natives, always saying the same thing that even John perceived that too before. This could seem to Arthur that Dutch were still crazy and he would not try to change himself, I believe since we are talking about low honor Arthur, he would probably duel or take other severe actions against Dutch.
If I could have a high honor playthrough but have this play it would be awesome
😢
playing rdr2 with low honor is not hard, but playing low honor the "true way" is what really made me change my perspective on this game, the game goes from you being a nice and caring guy who will go out of their way to help; to a person whos out for one thing... to survive, but the things you do on the way is scary
This is my life's theme(I'm not actually low honor, I'm just an utter failure and defeated and this music airs that feeling)
Same here bro
Thanks for this. I much prefer the sound of the low honor song. The only problem is that it is shorter than the high honor version and you cannot seem to purchase it. I have the soundtrack from iTunes which includes the high honor song but you cannot find the low honor version which is an oversight in my opinion.
I am loving the outro here as it extends the song nicely.
No problem m8
If you listen carefully, you'll notice that the album version is actually both versions mashed together, the low honor version being more faint.
“We’re not criminals, we’re outlaws”
Me when I cough up spit and think it’s blood
There's a big picture here arthur trust me
That's the way it is.
I finally listen to this full version
Me riding my bike to bros house after the group chat was leaked:
I really have no clue what to do about my drug addiction. Nothing in life comes close to the high of drugs. But I still wanna quit. That's why I listen to this song. Like Arthur, I keep doing bad things even though I know what the right thing to do is. Idk ik this seems corny and shit and it might seem like I'm grabbing attention but I need help. I have no clue what to do and I'm going down a really fucked up path.
what is drugs are u addicted?
God will help you
@@NobleDorito8698don’t say that
This song is SICK I mean it's so epic though.
😢😢
You have a exam tomorrow and you didn't study:
Guys, i just realized something....(Spoilers Ahead! You have been warned!)
The song is called that's the way it is right?
So it might mean that it's telling that Arthur died and them trying to save him
That they can't save Arthur from dying!
(Yall already figured it out)
It's literally "it is what it is" in song form
It’s like a man who got treated horribly and had a hard life just gave up being good and didn’t care about anything anymore so he has no morals or compassion for anyone or anything so he lost himself forever and is heading for the underworld instead of heaven
DAMN US BOTH
TENNIS BOAT!
You eat babies
The first time i played rdr2 honestly i didn't care too much about the story and the only think i wanted was k1ll and rob (i tought that it was the same like gta) and wthout taking care to the honor bar, at the end of the prologue i got the bad ending but i helped john to escape i didn't even care about arthur until he died, now i always i start a new game i always try to get the good ending but this song always makes me remember the first time.
Us before this: Highest Quality pls
Us after this: ULTRASONIC HIGH QUALITY PLEASE!!!
(Not saying it’s bad just want a better one, it’s not THAT bad it’s just not loud enough)
Forever tennis boat!
“Cough*, cough*”- Arthur Morgan
this version feels like the sad realistic situation arthur really is in and the game really is coming to an end, i love the original but man, this one has much more emotion
Man it feels more dark and sad
My horse have my moms name you will ever know how sad I was …
Your not better than me Morgan
Whatever you say you fool
Damn you!
Tennis boat!!!
this version played on my first playthrough and i redeemed myself by helping john and got the high honor ending where you die on the hill facing the sun.
Do you know what the name of the song that plays when low honour Arthur gets his diagnosis with TB, and if possible would you be able to upload it, if you haven't already. Thanks.
I don't, but I will try to find and upload both versions of it.
@@proffesorsyntax401 You're a lifesaver, thanks!
So all I could find is the backing track (and a riser?) for both versions (which I can upload if you want) . But I found both versions, someone else uploaded them. Low Honor: th-cam.com/video/eRSWI7nSFEU/w-d-xo.html High Honor: th-cam.com/video/I7GpZZhuxH0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=IiPDlIJqku3Y88JK
@@proffesorsyntax401 my thanks, just exactly what I was looking for.
Shine lightttt into darkknesssss
I thought for some reason it would be the Celine Dion song, sung by Authur Morgan
lol, that would be funny though
2:37
0:25
Best western
👍👍
Though many would prefer the high honor version so that Arthur can have a good ending, in truth he lived a very evil life.
For those who’re religious, they know where Arthur went after his death especially when he never proclaimed faith in God.
So this, is really his song.
I’m pretty sad because one of my old teachers passed away and I love rdr2 so this song hits different right now
Sorry for your loss man.
@@proffesorsyntax401 thanks
Me listening to this for the FIRST TIME after doing HORRIBLE THINGS to the NPCS
So there's different versions based on honor????
Yep, there's a low honor and high honor version.
@proffesorsyntax401 well now.... Not only am I still playing this brilliant art of a game years later, but STILL learning new things. Thanks for the quick response mate!!!
@thebeardedYETI no problem man!
High honor one feels too fulfilling and bright for the situation.
It's meant to be redeeming and satisfactory. A final bit of peace before the end of the gang.
Me on my way to work because I made the choice to have bills and rent
You speak as if killing was something I cared about- Arthur Morgan
when ur girfriends finds someone else and your there to see it 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬
Damn homie
Can you make a high honor version of highest quality?
high honor version of the highest quality is available on streaming platforms dear mister. have fun
@@amnessiac Can't find it on TH-cam. They don't have Stereo sound only Mono. Could you send me a link to these other "Streaming Platforms"?
@AMM_KILLAKATZ th-cam.com/play/OLAK5uy_kj3Ql4kDDvzBzNYqEiiUU3Aked6gwDIy8.html&si=7yLooCbRHEwvLQRX
Original score as well th-cam.com/play/PLY4At6--82Dk_xScJ2irgf-qcFBrqHc4Z.html&si=mlrsuXaeDSCu8Mj8
The only think i will have to say is listen with a good sound system or with head phones. I try to hear it on my phone and you dont hear the very low bassy tunes. Sound way to much distortion
do u have the high honor version?
This playlist has all the songs with lyrics in the game in highest quaility. Same version as the one from Spotify. th-cam.com/play/OLAK5uy_kj3Ql4kDDvzBzNYqEiiUU3Aked6gwDIy8.html&si=7yLooCbRHEwvLQRX
Arthur Morgan, the dishonorable one, he is a bad person
It hurts like hell to think that.
@tartakovski9457 I know l know
This song literally displays a message from God that your time of terror is over and that you shall pay for all the sins you've committed throughout your life
I hate this because I got this my first playthrough. The music is barely there
It’s out of tune
I had a disease like Arthur bit different been sick 20 days some of my friends had diseases but one of them died so I listen to this
2:55