Bernstein produced a much more insightful and detailed musical exegesis on Eroica entitled "How a Great Symphony was Written (lecture)" which can be found his 1964 Beethoven: Symphony No. 3 performance with the NPO. The CD is amazing and that single track is worth the purchase alone.
FYI, these Bernstein lectures are available on Spotify, at least in part: open.spotify.com/playlist/37i9dQZF1DXbuvjwsGcSq1?si=feBphOt3Rb6PBqvJbKfwxA They are eye-opening!
Bernstein said about beethoven that he proved his greatness by writing the exact right note after right note. beethoven also demonstrated that he could build a magnificent piece of music using meager material. he demonstrated that with the second movement of his seventh symphony. Bernstein said not even Mozart could do this as well as Beethoven. not a very involved melody that begins that movement but he turned it into an astounding, involved piece of music. so much so that audiences demanded encores of that movement going into the 20th century.
Truer words have never been spoken! I mean, look at the 1st Movement of his Violin Concerto. Sure, there is one pretty tune, but the rest of it is just scales, arpeggios, some octaves… This is easy stuff, the kind of material children use when they are studying the instrument! It also happens to be, in my opinion, the most exquisitely beautiful concerto ever written for the instrument. Beethoven wasn’t just a composer. He was a magician🤩
How elegant: The subject, the presentation, the necessary virtuosity to play such a piano reduction, and the total mastery of the subject matter. There is so much pedagogical Bernstein out here, and aren't we fortunate? (Addendum, one year later) Allow me to presume to modify Lenny's final statement by inserting the only other name in the cultural history of Western Civilization about whom it could be made: "The answer to the Shakespeare phenomenon is not really expressible, except in terms of the mysterious genius of a man who is capable of uniting all contradictions into one single, perfect entity.”
Sir Leonard... I love your statements about Beethoven. They simply speak to me and reach me like pure heaven. You say exactly what I feel when listening to his legacy. His sounds will never grow old nor unimportant, quite the opposite. It will plant a seed in you that grows and grows and matures. ;o)...
After the first two Symphonies which were Mozart like IMO, Beethoven starts the romantic period with a crash. If you look at Picasso’s early drawings, he could draw everything as a classical artist before he went in his own direction. To me it’s that stark.
One of my favorite scripture passages is found in Ecclesiastes 7:3 “Sorrow is better than laughter: for by the sadness of the countenance the heart is made better.” Beethoven’s heart is certainly the musical epitome of Plato’s tempered heart “wax” which is smooth, abundant, deep, and worked to the proper consistency. His monuments are a testament to the fire of life’s experiences that produces gifts of inestimable quality and enduring. Would to GOD people might consider how priceless a jewel is the life that sustains such crushing heat and blows to emerge as heroic and prophetic in proclaiming, by faultless example, that The Lord Jesus gives eternal grace and beauty to all who love his appearing and glory in their own hearts and souls. PWG
I fell in love with Leonard Bernstein when I was nine years old and he explained Beethoven's sixth symphony on our newly purchased first B&W television set. Or…. Was it Beethoven I fell in love with? Doesn’t matter, the love remains though both are long gone. Long may you run…. Spirits of Beauty and Joy.
Katsaris plays a stunning performance of Liszt’s piano transcription of the Eroica. It is on TH-cam. Bernstein is admirable in that he never shows off how much he knows; he was a perfect teacher!
Even though I was shamed in never studying a music career, I remember these videos by Leonard Bernstein that opened the world of classical music to my "uneducated" brain.
I liked the late Harnoncourt’s comment in his last interview on BBC radio - ‘if Beethoven was alive today he would be making bridges’ i.e. forging necessary cosmic connections in new ways and not inhabiting mined-out modalities.
The A dim 9th chords in decrescendo ( 1:07 ) is from one of the most dramatic passages in the first movement. But the whole first movement is full of drama and tension with brief respites in between. Hard to pick one passage.
"the mysterious genius of a man who is capable of uniting all contradictions into one single, perfect entity" -- Lenny, I thought this was supposed to be a talk about Beethoven, not an autobiography!
I posted a new video explaining how Beethoven's loss of hearing made created a massive increase in his capacity to process variables between Symphony #2 and Symphony #3, making him the world's greatest composer
Origins of music unevidenced. Except it is gift to humanity from God the Creator. Music continues in heaven. Discontinues in hell. Jesus Christ died and resurrected for remissions of everybody's pre-existing sins to save from eternal hell. Penalty of sin already paid by Jesus Christ on The Cross. Accept HIM. Be saved from eternal hell. Enter heaven. Enjoy heavenly music. For free.
Someone who truly understood Beethoven, a really great musician himself: Leonard Bernstein, a twentieth century legend in his own right.
Bernstein produced a much more insightful and detailed musical exegesis on Eroica entitled "How a Great Symphony was Written (lecture)" which can be found his 1964 Beethoven: Symphony No. 3 performance with the NPO. The CD is amazing and that single track is worth the purchase alone.
RaisingAbel the first time I heard his voice. I've been in awe ever sincde
FYI, these Bernstein lectures are available on Spotify, at least in part: open.spotify.com/playlist/37i9dQZF1DXbuvjwsGcSq1?si=feBphOt3Rb6PBqvJbKfwxA They are eye-opening!
@@alexed100 OMG, thanks for that tip/link! I just logged into Spotify; Lenny does 35 mins. on Eroica!! I can't wait to listen.
@@annedwyer797 I just tried to open that file on Spotify, and was informed that they do not recognize the link shown above.
Bernstein is teaching perfection, personified.
Excellent point.
He talks like he is reading from a great author's book. What a mind.
Bernstein said about beethoven that he proved his greatness by writing the exact right note after right note. beethoven also demonstrated that he could build a magnificent piece of music using meager material. he demonstrated that with the second movement of his seventh symphony. Bernstein said not even Mozart could do this as well as Beethoven. not a very involved melody that begins that movement but he turned it into an astounding, involved piece of music. so much so that audiences demanded encores of that movement going into the 20th century.
Truer words have never been spoken! I mean, look at the 1st Movement of his Violin Concerto. Sure, there is one pretty tune, but the rest of it is just scales, arpeggios, some octaves… This is easy stuff, the kind of material children use when they are studying the instrument! It also happens to be, in my opinion, the most exquisitely beautiful concerto ever written for the instrument. Beethoven wasn’t just a composer. He was a magician🤩
my favorite beethoven symphony and no one could explain it better than lenny. i miss his mug.
How elegant:
The subject, the presentation, the necessary virtuosity to play such a piano reduction, and the total mastery of the subject matter.
There is so much pedagogical Bernstein out here, and aren't we fortunate?
(Addendum, one year later)
Allow me to presume to modify Lenny's final statement by inserting the only other name in the cultural history of Western Civilization about whom it could be made:
"The answer to the Shakespeare phenomenon is not really expressible, except in terms of the mysterious genius of a man who is capable of uniting all contradictions into one single, perfect entity.”
And such humility while describing the complete genius of LvB. From a genius of a conductor. What a jewel of a video we've lucked out to see.
Disgustingly emphatic
Beg pardon?
tuxguys: beautifully said!
lmao
Just one word: fantastic! thanks Lenny for your this great introduction to the Beethoven "Eroica". A page everyone shouldn't miss!
LBs conclusion is brilliant and admirable Thank you for posting, this
There is some recoil off that piano
lmao
Sir Leonard... I love your statements about Beethoven. They simply speak to me and reach me like pure heaven. You say exactly what I feel when listening to his legacy. His sounds will never grow old nor unimportant, quite the opposite. It will plant a seed in you that grows and grows and matures. ;o)...
Thanks for putting up all these Bernstein intros - much easier than flipping thru my Bernstein discs :)
I love listening to Bernstein talk as much as I love hearing him conduct. Titan? Hmm, Bernstein's the Gentle Giant.
Fantastic!
Beethoven and Bernstein...the Energizer Bunnies of the music world!
Enjoyed! Especially what he says of the 'cosmic spirit' a/o 2:30
eloquent and brilliant
After the first two Symphonies which were Mozart like IMO, Beethoven starts the romantic period with a crash. If you look at Picasso’s early drawings, he could draw everything as a classical artist before he went in his own direction. To me it’s that stark.
I adore him
One of my favorite scripture passages is found in Ecclesiastes 7:3 “Sorrow is better than laughter: for by the sadness of the countenance the heart is made better.” Beethoven’s heart is certainly the musical epitome of Plato’s tempered heart “wax” which is smooth, abundant, deep, and worked to the proper consistency. His monuments are a testament to the fire of life’s experiences that produces gifts of inestimable quality and enduring. Would to GOD people might consider how priceless a jewel is the life that sustains such crushing heat and blows to emerge as heroic and prophetic in proclaiming, by faultless example, that The Lord Jesus gives eternal grace and beauty to all who love his appearing and glory in their own hearts and souls. PWG
Beethoven was a composer like no other. His biographer (which I have been reading) tells of his human complexity.
well said, Sir. Well said.
I fell in love with Leonard Bernstein when I was nine years old and he explained Beethoven's sixth symphony on our newly purchased first B&W television set. Or…. Was it Beethoven I fell in love with? Doesn’t matter, the love remains though both are long gone. Long may you run…. Spirits of Beauty and Joy.
Yes!
Katsaris plays a stunning performance of Liszt’s piano transcription of the Eroica. It is on TH-cam. Bernstein is admirable in that he never shows off how much he knows; he was a perfect teacher!
Even though I was shamed in never studying a music career, I remember these videos by Leonard Bernstein that opened the world of classical music to my "uneducated" brain.
I liked the late Harnoncourt’s comment in his last interview on BBC radio - ‘if Beethoven was alive today he would be making bridges’ i.e. forging necessary cosmic connections in new ways and not inhabiting mined-out modalities.
I wish to have hair like this when I'm old
The A dim 9th chords in decrescendo ( 1:07 ) is from one of the most dramatic passages in the first movement. But the whole first movement is full of drama and tension with brief respites in between. Hard to pick one passage.
Amo muito essa sinfonia!
super good.
"the mysterious genius of a man who is capable of uniting all contradictions into one single, perfect entity" -- Lenny, I thought this was supposed to be a talk about Beethoven, not an autobiography!
willcwhite, beautifully put!
willcwhite he IS talking about Beethoven.
@@onecircle1 I think willcwhite meant it as a joke!
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
2:15, Bernstein discusses the melodious section of the 3rd Symphony.
in which movement can one find that melody?
@@ashutoshjangle7926 you can find that in the final movement.
@@McIntyreBible thanks
Wow he looks either hammered or like he just woke up lol
No body can do Bernstein's music like Bernstein. But Bernstein can do anybody's music, sometimes even better..
I posted a new video explaining how Beethoven's loss of hearing made created a massive increase in his capacity to process variables between Symphony #2 and Symphony #3, making him the world's greatest composer
Why would anyone give this a Thumbs down? 🤔 Clearly Sociopaths..
hes got big balls
1:40
4th wall slipped for a minute there 😅
@@dmsalomon Those restless (lip flick, nose brush, eye rub, hair flatten) mannerisms are in lieu of a cigarette, I believe.
@@mlconlanmeister I think that is exactly it!!!.
お願いします、字幕を！
Inexpressible is right.
Giant meets Auteur..
0:23 Did Mr. Bernstein just make a Reference to a Marvel Superhero?
Den Zuhörern müssen damals die Ohren weggeflogen sein.
Origins of music unevidenced. Except it is gift to humanity from God the Creator. Music continues in heaven. Discontinues in hell.
Jesus Christ died and resurrected for remissions of everybody's pre-existing sins to save from eternal hell. Penalty of sin already paid by Jesus Christ on The Cross. Accept HIM. Be saved from eternal hell. Enter heaven. Enjoy heavenly music. For free.
I have never seen a worse waste of 3 minutes. Tragic that he didn't touch on ANY of the things that make Beethoven brilliant
Awful, Beethoven music is just so bad, bad melody, poor orchestration, silly tunes and awkward chord combinations, this is a prodigy of bad taste.
You are in a very small minority among those who enjoy classical music.
Moron.
You absolute 🤡
You haven't the spirit or intellect to comprehend true greatness.
Oh boy, what a complete musical idiot...