Such a profound statement, as so many have the same sentiment for losing such an amazing artist and human being ~ The Legend that is Chris Cornell, still years later, our wounds open and raw. #LoudLove
Excellent observation Nolan. Actually you couldn't be farther from the truth, you need to let life take its course and embrace the experience .... enough said....
I couldn't agree more,not leaving out anyone,while people jump at the fact.Ed,hopefully you live a long-beautiful life. LIKE your baritone,beautiful voice you deserve Chris still in your presence. So obvious,he was sincerely your brother.Always missed,depression kills! Amazing song,you made even more remarkable w/ this performance!
It breaks my heart knowing that Eddie Vedder has to wake up everyday without Chris Cornell. This is the most beautiful version of Black I have ever heard. Eddie can feel every word. You can tell. He cries. We all cry. Chris, we miss you so much.
Eddie has been had to wake up to the loss of all the men of seattle. Kurt..layne..scott..chris..and he is the last man standing. Imagine that loneliness now.. having lost all your buddies.
This man is carrying so much pain in this video.... poor Eddie... he’s the only survivor of all that voices of a whole generation... the last generation of musical integrity and true rock stars.... #GodblessEdVed
When he starts singing "come back", I just lost it. God damn that was so beautiful and fitting. I’ve been at that point of suicide, after the murder of my three year old daughter. I don’t ever wish someone to feel like that. I never said this before, but when Cornell was there, so was I. This song saved me, Eddie. Thank you, for my surviving daughter’s sake, thank you.
2024 here, we still have Eddie Vedder ❤️ so grateful for him looking after himself, giving us all of this, his pain to share. We've been through so much together, all of us! Love you Chris 😭❤️
God, I remember when the news about Chris broke I was on my way to work, I just pulled over to the side of the road and bawled. I got to work and looked it up. He was such a big part of my life. I miss him everyday. I can’t even imagine how these guys feel. They lost a brother. Someone they went through all the deaths with, Kurt, Layne, and Scott. My heart goes out to him and the rest of the guys from the grunge era.
I feel really lucky to have attended that concert. Everyone in the crowd cried alongside Eddie at the end of the song. After that, while he was singing Imagine, a shooting star fell right behind the stage. I like to think that that star was Chris and John saying hi to us. That night has been pure magic.
When Kurt died it hurt Eddie. He talked about tearing up his hotel room then paid tribute multiple times, when Layne died that hurt Eddie even more. He locked himself in a room and did an entire song by himself dedicated to his friend. When Chris died, well this performance alone shows that it almost destroyed Eddie and it hurt him way worse than the other 2..
@@joshtonkin7684 no the song is called 42002 that’s the date that Eddie found out about Layne’s death it’s the last track on the Lost Dogs álbum it’s a hidden track but the song is clearly about Layne Staley and Eddie Vedder calls out several bands (not by name) who were copying the style of Alice In Chains
@@adriana4489 I see how it can be interpreted that way but it’s actually about an old childhood relationship that had split with a girl and moreover the pains of realising he’d have to let life take its course and for her to be with whoever else she was destined to be with, be it not him. The struggles of not letting his emotion take control of his maturity in such a situation. Think it works just as well in context with his brother or Chris too tho hence why this performance is so emotional and meaningful :)
@@xTwistCinema Agreed. That is the magic of them, Eddie Vedder and Chris Cornell.. They express different feelings performing the same song and connect with our own emotions in several levels. They put their souls out there.
Lost my dad, unexpectedly, about 6 months ago. He was arguably one of the biggest Pearl Jam / Eddie Vedder fans of all time. He had dozens of their live albums on CD (that I now have) and we always jammed to them on road trips from the time I was 10 years old (probably even younger) up to this past year when I was 29. I have his iPod now and some Pearl Jam songs are probably on there 30+ times because he wanted each and every different version of songs like ‘Alive’ and ‘Even Flow’ he could find. The night after he passed, we went to his favorite local bar to drink our sorrows away. About 5 minutes after we get there, a live musician shows up with a guitar to play some tunes. The first song he plays is an Eddie Vedder cover. Next song was Daughters by John Mayer, which he and my sister always jammed to. Next song was Phil Collins - In The Air Tonight. Makes me think pops was with us that night, sipping on some bourbon right there next to us. Miss that man every day. Cheers, pops. Come back.
That was a sad but also sweet little story about you & your father. I hate to admit it but I got a little teary eyed. I just wanted to say sorry for loss.I truly believe your dad was definitely with you that night. And you know he is always their in spirit watching over you. Keep your spirits high & don't ever stop jamming out to the good stuff. Eddie Vedder was truly one of a kind. Take care, Kristie
Holy fuck, I forgot how unbearable the ending is in this version. When he broke down saying "come back" it felt like somebody reached in, grabbed my soul, beat the living shit out of it and left it for dead. I haven't felt such pain in a very long time. There are way too few people that can do this via singing. Long live Eddie!
First time I have seen this version of Black. You expressed every thought spinning around in my heart & head right now. “Come back…” ripped my heart into a million pieces. I know that kind of heartbreak. To put it all out there is a brave and beautiful thing. God Bless Eddie Vedder. I don’t know how he made it through the song to be honest. From the first note, the heartache of loss was palpable.
The most heartbreaking line ever..."I know some day you'll have a beautiful life, I know you'll be a star...in some body else's sky. But why, why can't it be mine"
There are people who sing with their voices. Others sing with their hearts and at the top of their lungs. But Eddie ... Eddie sings with the heart, the lungs, the liver, the spleen and the whole soul
Absolutely right Eddie is a great man who has suffered so much loss, the whole grunge movement and all the bands involved were never arrogant they helped each other, encouraged each other, supported each other, they truly wanted to see each other succeed, and that is what sets them apart from the rest of the bands in this world
These men, who were all friends and mostly came from the same Seattle music "scene" in the late 80s, were my Camelot. Layne, Andy, Chris, Mike, Chester, Scott, Shannon, Kurt.... my God so many of them are gone.... and all those I haven't even mentioned.... we were so lucky to have them all..... I'd sell my soul to turn the clock back to when I was 22 in 1989.... they are ALL greatly missed by this fan.... and will continue to be.....
@Brittany Satterwhite we post things like that so the assholes like yourself make their presence known..... CONGRATULATIONS...... you get the ASSHOLE AWARD for the day! Go tell Mommy and Daddy what an overachiever you are now!
@Brittany Taylor yeah never say that. Your soul is the most precious part about this human body and Satan doesnt deserve it. Christ suffered for all mankind so that the soul can live on forever if you accept him.
Brittany Taylor Bc they don’t know the value and how easily the world pulls those scales over their eyes and causes their great pain, but lost to the connection and what it truly means. That’s why Chris touched so many bc he was from the light side and his inspiration and convictions are obvious in his music. He didn’t worship celebs or man, nor materialism. His music was genuine and soulful and don’t make the mistakes of the world and blindly follow. These demigods, false prophets they’re replacing the original real deal like CC, etc with sell outs that taking ppl down with created chaos and virtue signaling.
Words just can't describe this human being. His reason for being here is profoundly defined. We Love you Eddie and many of us understand how you feel. Know we are with you brother 🤙 Shaka
I like to think of this version as the aged one. The one that carries Eddie's whole life. He might not be feeling all those things while writing and performing this song in his days. Now it carries a completely different meaning for him and to us. Can't imagine the things that goes on his head while singing this song to this day. This song was a gift, a blessing, a reminder of how we've all been through the black. I thank Sir Eddie Veddar for everything he's given to us. A lifetime of memories fit into one perfect song.
And here I am, four years later, crying my eyes out listening to this song. Chris Cornell, Chester Bennington, Eddie Vedder will forever be my idols. They represent everything that is good to me. It's sometimes unbelievable how you can feel so much from people you never met (or will never meet), but they have talked to each one of us directly, and said some much more meaningful things that whoever is around us. I feel it, I was almost at that point, but I am still here, to remember them. Thank you.
I love how Vedder down plays his voice so he can take in his fans voices singing in harmony over the loss of one of the most precious souls that ever existed in the music industry ❤ R.I.P Cornell.
This was the song playing at my best friends' funeral as her casket was leaving the room, as Pearl Jam was her favourite band. She was only 25. I think of her every day
I know, right. At that time I had no phone and I asked the man next to me to shoot that video. He sent it to me right away and I am so happy to have that memory kept. ( :
as l get older and have been on this planet long enough now. l realize some people's beautiful/pure, kind hearts don't belong in this evil/hateful, putrid world, that's why they move on to a much kinder, peaceful place where they can and are understood. much love to you all🙏🏻
There is not one song in the world that translates feeling to me as strongly as this one, for as depressed i've been and as many fucking devastating songs i've heard before, this one is the constant. It breaks me, it makes me weep without fail, it touches my soul. This is what art is, a transmission of feelings, feelings so deep and so pure that only through a medium such as music can they truly be translated. I see so many covers of this song where everyone has a fantastic voice, yet they all fail because they don't feel it, they don't go to this place. You need to understand that feeling is all black is about, so if you don't feel it, you can have the worlds most angelical voice and you would still fail.
Totally agree. It’s the first song that ever brought me to tears and I didn’t even know what was happening! Brings me back to laying on my bed at 16 years old and that same emotion that I had then. It’s an emotional masterpiece!
Beautifully expressed. If a song doesn’t make me FEEL something across the scale of emotions - joy, heartbreak, uplifting, makes me want to dance, get fired up, turned on, or the longing ache of loneliness ‘wanting to know what love is’ , it ends up sounding like the adults of Charlie Browns world, wah wah wah. Very few current artists with the exception of Adele, Pink and even at times Miley - she sings Nothing Else Matters with Metallica that blows me away. I’m a classic rock/ 80’s to early 90’s person for the most part. Eddie is one of the few voices that fall into the ‘timeless’ category for me. Just Breathe is an all time fave. If you haven’t seen his duet with Yusuf Cat Stevens of Father & Son from Global Citizen, check it out. It should be required listening! You seem so in tune with the soul of music. Do you ever get messages thru music? When I am sad, depressed, kicking myself about something I can’t go back and fix or despondent (just a sample of a few), a certain song will come on. Whatever ‘lesson’ I need to hear at that particular time, seems to scream the lyrics into my heart. It’s hard to describe. I guess my most relatable example is being in a very dark emotional place, abusing pain medication, in love with someone who didn’t love me back and all I could see was the path of sadness and self destruction ahead of me. I started driving hoping something would happen to end my pain. Stairway to Heaven came on the radio. I was on autopilot, unable to snap out of the hopelessness, it was as if time stood still and MADE me listen to the following lyrics - yes there are two paths you can go by, but in the long run, there’s still time to change the road you’re on’ It changed my life. The other comes from the amazing Freddie Murcury in BoHo Rhapsody - I don’t want to die. I sometimes wish I’d never been born at all, followed by Brian Mays guitar sound like it’s crying. Another song I had heard a billion times suddenly screaming what I needed to hear. I couldn’t live without music. It’s saved my life on so many levels. The silly 70’s pop I grew up with, kept my spirits up during lockdown. I’m rambling. I just relate to your thoughts about the song/music. #lifelessons #musicheals
Umbrace Titan are you crazy? Chris had by far the best voice, he was the most versatile and technical. All 4 are amazing singers but Chris was on a whole other level.
@@elby6980 eh my opinion your opinion. Layne I thought always had the "grungiest" voice that felt so alive but was also able to somehow mix that violent voice with emotion and make songs like down in a hole. I love Chris and back with stp he was amazing and right with eddie and layne. I just thought audioslave he was always a little mediocre. Its hard to compare legends bro
Umbrace Titan Layne is my favourite singer, but if we are talking about the ‘best SINGER’ out of the 4, Chris wins every time followed by Layne, then Eddie, then Kurt
Así es, cómo no iba a recordar a su gran hermano, pensar que de un momento a otro se fue y no tuvo la posibilidad de despedirse, Eddie siempre se ha caracterizado por expresar sus emociones y no podía aguantar más...
My dad passed away in August of last year, and this was his favorite Pearl Jam song, and Pearl Jam was his favorite band. I remember sometime earlier last year he sat me down and we watched this version of Black and while he cried, I didnt. I hope he knows I am now.
This song and hearing Eddie's broken and painfully beautiful voice already makes me cry.... seeing him cry at the end of this and knowing why quite literally made me cry a river 😭
2023 and it still makes me cry. I saw Chris in one of his last concerts. I went alone for the first time ever. I was very depressed and self medicating at the time. It will stay with me forever ❤️ he may be gone but still impacts people to this day. That’s the epitome of a legend. Millions miss you Chris
Can’t get over Chris being gone. Can’t wait to see Pearl Jam for the first time at Wrigley, my top two favorite artists of all time, Eddie is the only one left standing, may you live to be 100
I dedicate this to my bestie of 50 years, Pete, who passed away suddenly a few months ago. This was his favorite Pearl Jam song. RIP to him and Chris.. 😭😔
I still can’t watch this without bawling. I was a teenager in the 90’s and these guys were the soundtrack to my life at the time. It’s not fair so many are gone. Time to wrap Eddie in a bubble.
Lost my Dad yesterday morning new years eve 2021 at six am about 24 hours ago. I cried. I love you Dad. Will see you again one day. When freedom has overwhelmed us both and death has been swallowed up in Victory. Then I will see you again.
This is one of the very very few occasion where I am happy that someone filmed on his phone. Good quality and sound... And now I need to wipe those fucking tears off my face. I tried not to break, I felt them coming up on the "we belong together", then the break down on the last "come back" opened the gate. Music cannot get more real than this.
It’s absolutely incredible how emotional this song made me. I would never think a youtube clip could jerk as many tears as this one did. Eddie, you’re such a joy. This world is lucky to have you, we’re lucky to have you. Thank you ❤️
I'm totally freaking out! I just discovered 'Black' last month! The vibrato in Eddie's voice is the BEST I've heard in DECADES! I feel blessed to have found this song in 2024.Betteer late than never! Thank you, Eddie!❤❤❤
My girlfriend and I saw Pearl Jam in Ottawa recently. I am a changed man now. The best band ever. Moving, emotional, thoughtful music. I feel blessed to have been able to witness Pearl Jam Live.
Eddie is such an amazing man. The stuff he does with Steve Gleason and the A.L.S. community makes him a saint. This song is the only way I feel that can actually come close to the pain I feel from losing my husband and childrens father.
Chris is still living in Eddie's voice and music. A part of every dear who has died still keeps on living in us who loved him/her. In our movenents, in our actions, in our tasks. We belong together... Our task does not end with death. Thanks Eddie for this song, it catches straight my heart and memories....
this song is truly beautiful, Eddie's music has been such a gift to so many people... Recently my dog died of cancer, and i listened to this song everyday of his last week with us, it really helped me process the pain, i'm now going to be releasing a cover of this song in memory of AJ and as homage to the great Eddie Vedder!
COME BACK-- COME BACK ...You can feel the emotion ,hurt,loneliness in the words....hats off to eddie im not sure how he kept it together much as he did.thanks eddie.rest easy Chris, layne,kurt, you guys are never forgotten.sad that the time was so short.play it loud for the heavens!!!
Eu chorei no "come Back" senti a dor dele , a dor de perder um amigo. Incrível como o Eddie tem o poder de transmitir o que ele está sentindo com tamanha excelência , meu cantor favorito de sempre. ❤️ #RipChris
This song is life... not only about love it is about everything what matters for a person and what you never can have, even it is for good or for bad doesnt matter. You cant get it...and it destroy you in some way everyday of your life.
Eddie your Heart retching performance of Black for Chris said it all. You loved him as we all did . He is truly missed by you more than other love and peace
I take a walk outside, some kids play outside, i cant feel their laughter, so y do i see them, twisted thoughts spin round my head,..................i know someday youll have a beautiful life, youll be wrapped in somebodys else arms, y cant it be mine. ....love lost turns ur world to black... I love this song so much. After my ddughter passed away, my world turned black.
Llevo mas de 20 años llorando la misma canción... su manera de interpretar su obra maestra del álbum "ten" me pone los pelos de punta y ese sentimiento tan fresco del dolor en la pérdida. Excelente Eddie Vedder, cuidate harto, Porque no queremos seguir perdiendo a nuestros héroes de juventud.
@@soniadutto9143 pasarán décadas y esta como muchas otras joyas del grunge seguirán sonando en nuestros corazones como himnos de la vida... la banda Sonora de todas nuestras vivencias.
I'm so glad I grew up, with the honer of these men as my role models, open my eyes an gave me resolve. Thank you, best years ever spent on music.. RIP CHRIS..
“Come back... come back...” I’m not sure I’ve ever heard two words carry so much weight.
James Cromer Me either 🖤❤️
😔😔😔
James Cromer yea I actually teared up when I heard that
Such a profound statement, as so many have the same sentiment for losing such an amazing artist and human being ~ The Legend that is Chris Cornell, still years later, our wounds open and raw. #LoudLove
Wow. Same. Felt that in my soul.
Kurt, Layne, Scott, Chris. This man has watched them all go.
Chester...
Poser
After Kurt and Chris, we need to bubble wrap this guy.
Excellent observation Nolan.
Actually you couldn't be farther from the truth, you need to let life take its course and embrace the experience ....
enough said....
@@FSEVENMAN I know I just don't want my favorite grunge singer dead.
@@nolanr7679 Yeah that's a great point, I hear you dude too many have died already
Cant believe you forgot layne
Nolan R 😂IKR!!!
Cornell, Staley, Weiland, all gone already.
May Vedder live forever.
You forgot Cobain
Don't forget Andrew Wood from Mother Love Bone
They will all live forever through their music.
So sad, inspired forever☺
I couldn't agree more,not leaving out anyone,while people jump at the fact.Ed,hopefully you live a long-beautiful life. LIKE your baritone,beautiful voice you deserve Chris still in your presence. So obvious,he was sincerely your brother.Always missed,depression kills! Amazing song,you made even more remarkable w/ this performance!
It breaks my heart knowing that Eddie Vedder has to wake up everyday without Chris Cornell. This is the most beautiful version of Black I have ever heard. Eddie can feel every word. You can tell. He cries. We all cry. Chris, we miss you so much.
I so agree
Eddie has been had to wake up to the loss of all the men of seattle. Kurt..layne..scott..chris..and he is the last man standing. Imagine that loneliness now.. having lost all your buddies.
@@vijaynair4881 don't forget Andrew Wood in the list of those who passed on from his era Mark Arm is still alive i think also
Very nicely said Makayla : )
Yeah damn onions are rough today😭💔
This man is carrying so much pain in this video.... poor Eddie... he’s the only survivor of all that voices of a whole generation... the last generation of musical integrity and true rock stars.... #GodblessEdVed
Gavin Rosdale
#GODBLESSEDVEDD
Man shut the fuck up
@@giovanniq7283 why?
musical integrity...exactly !
When he starts singing "come back", I just lost it. God damn that was so beautiful and fitting. I’ve been at that point of suicide, after the murder of my three year old daughter. I don’t ever wish someone to feel like that. I never said this before, but when Cornell was there, so was I. This song saved me, Eddie. Thank you, for my surviving daughter’s sake, thank you.
Dylan Harvey As I father of a 3 year girl, I send my condolences to you.
My love to you.
My condolences to you.
Sorry for your loss. Be strong.
my sincere condolences
2024 here, we still have Eddie Vedder ❤️ so grateful for him looking after himself, giving us all of this, his pain to share.
We've been through so much together, all of us!
Love you Chris 😭❤️
My son passed in 2015, this song makes me cry so hard, but sometimes it's a good thing....he loved Eddie, as do I.
RIP my JohnJohn, Chris, Chester 💔
My condolences.
I'm so sorry....... love and light to you ♥️
I'm so sorry for you. ❤
My heart is with you Robyn Wright... I wish you healing, strength and peace...♥️
Love from Brazil ❤️
Every once in a while the internet is worthwhile.
That says it all
so right
Yup. You just gotta pick those fleeting spots.
Long live memories brother!
God, I remember when the news about Chris broke I was on my way to work, I just pulled over to the side of the road and bawled. I got to work and looked it up. He was such a big part of my life. I miss him everyday. I can’t even imagine how these guys feel. They lost a brother. Someone they went through all the deaths with, Kurt, Layne, and Scott. My heart goes out to him and the rest of the guys from the grunge era.
It was my birthday . . . I woke up to that news on my birthday . . .
Me too. x 2
Sandy T. Heroin is a helluva drug. 👎🏻👎🏻
Don't forget Shannon Hoon.
Sandy T don’t forget the original.....Andrew Wood of Mother Love Bone...you know...Pearl Jam.
I feel really lucky to have attended that concert. Everyone in the crowd cried alongside Eddie at the end of the song. After that, while he was singing Imagine, a shooting star fell right behind the stage. I like to think that that star was Chris and John saying hi to us. That night has been pure magic.
😢🌠❤
Wow
“I know you’ll be a star in somebody else’s sky” but that night, he was the star in all of yours.
As were Layne and Kurt
Holy. Shit.
If you didn't shed a tear when hearing Eddie shakily crying out "Come Back" you ain't human ♥️☝🏾
You could literally feel the pain when he was singing "come back" and it hurts so much...
When Kurt died it hurt Eddie. He talked about tearing up his hotel room then paid tribute multiple times, when Layne died that hurt Eddie even more. He locked himself in a room and did an entire song by himself dedicated to his friend. When Chris died, well this performance alone shows that it almost destroyed Eddie and it hurt him way worse than the other 2..
@@josecano9210 what song did he write about Layne?
@@joshtonkin7684 42002, Eddie wrote the song the night he found out about Layne
@@josecano9210 what black? Cause that came out in the early 90s and Layne died in 2002
@@joshtonkin7684 no the song is called 42002 that’s the date that Eddie found out about Layne’s death it’s the last track on the Lost Dogs álbum it’s a hidden track but the song is clearly about Layne Staley and Eddie Vedder calls out several bands (not by name) who were copying the style of Alice In Chains
one of the saddest songs of all time
and everyone is singing along
epic
Everyone has experienced loss of a loved one. Why it's such a classic
Love this song, love Eddie Vedder. Audience singing along-not so much
I feel so bad for Eddie, Chris was his best friend and a brother to him. He is probably still grieving about his death to this day :(
He lost his brother before Chris died. Maybe this song was about his brother "we belong togheter"
@@adriana4489 I see how it can be interpreted that way but it’s actually about an old childhood relationship that had split with a girl and moreover the pains of realising he’d have to let life take its course and for her to be with whoever else she was destined to be with, be it not him. The struggles of not letting his emotion take control of his maturity in such a situation.
Think it works just as well in context with his brother or Chris too tho hence why this performance is so emotional and meaningful :)
@@xTwistCinema Agreed. That is the magic of them, Eddie Vedder and Chris Cornell.. They express different feelings performing the same song and connect with our own emotions in several levels. They put their souls out there.
Just as Chris grieved over Andy for his entire life. It is almost as though the career of Chris Cornell was dedicated to the memory of Andrew wood
grief never goes away .. you just learn to manage it a bit better.
Thank you Eddie for giving voice to our pain.
Still loving Eddie Vedder, and missing Chris Cornell!! We in Music Land still feel the void Chris!!! 🎶🙏💔
Eddie's voice still sounds as he was in 1992
baba yaga maybe better
His voice has gotten a little deeper but yeah his talent hasn't declined at all.
Sounds nothing like he did in 92 but still sounds good
@@ChrisS-nj3ye he still has the same tone it's just deeper.
@Kevin Ross He has a unique voice that very few have even come close to matching. There will never be an Eddie Vedder again.
Andrew, Kurt, Chris, Chester, Layne, Shannon, Scott, many more. Some the greatest music ever recorded came out the 90’s. Please stay Eddie!!
David from Drowning pool too. So sad
Doug Hopkins
Mark Lanegan
Lost my dad, unexpectedly, about 6 months ago. He was arguably one of the biggest Pearl Jam / Eddie Vedder fans of all time. He had dozens of their live albums on CD (that I now have) and we always jammed to them on road trips from the time I was 10 years old (probably even younger) up to this past year when I was 29. I have his iPod now and some Pearl Jam songs are probably on there 30+ times because he wanted each and every different version of songs like ‘Alive’ and ‘Even Flow’ he could find. The night after he passed, we went to his favorite local bar to drink our sorrows away. About 5 minutes after we get there, a live musician shows up with a guitar to play some tunes. The first song he plays is an Eddie Vedder cover. Next song was Daughters by John Mayer, which he and my sister always jammed to. Next song was Phil Collins - In The Air Tonight. Makes me think pops was with us that night, sipping on some bourbon right there next to us. Miss that man every day. Cheers, pops. Come back.
Aw man I'm so sorry about your loss. I'm sure he's in a better place now. And after all, he is a star in your sky.
He was.
😢
That was a sad but also sweet little story about you & your father. I hate to admit it but I got a little teary eyed. I just wanted to say sorry for loss.I truly believe your dad was definitely with you that night. And you know he is always their in spirit watching over you. Keep your spirits high & don't ever stop jamming out to the good stuff. Eddie Vedder was truly one of a kind. Take care, Kristie
I can tell you, you are a good Man Adam ! I play his tunes often too.. Best wishes from India - A fellow Eddie admirer
Holy fuck, I forgot how unbearable the ending is in this version. When he broke down saying "come back" it felt like somebody reached in, grabbed my soul, beat the living shit out of it and left it for dead. I haven't felt such pain in a very long time. There are way too few people that can do this via singing. Long live Eddie!
First time I have seen this version of Black. You expressed every thought spinning around in my heart & head right now. “Come back…” ripped my heart into a million pieces. I know that kind of heartbreak. To put it all out there is a brave and beautiful thing. God Bless Eddie Vedder. I don’t know how he made it through the song to be honest. From the first note, the heartache of loss was palpable.
The most heartbreaking line ever..."I know some day you'll have a beautiful life, I know you'll be a star...in some body else's sky. But why, why can't it be mine"
There are people who sing with their voices. Others sing with their hearts and at the top of their lungs. But Eddie ... Eddie sings with the heart, the lungs, the liver, the spleen and the whole soul
Absolutely right Eddie is a great man who has suffered so much loss, the whole grunge movement and all the bands involved were never arrogant they helped each other, encouraged each other, supported each other, they truly wanted to see each other succeed, and that is what sets them apart from the rest of the bands in this world
I can't imagine how hard it was for him to perform this. Chris Cornell was an amazing talent
And Also and amazing Soul and Human Being
Gosh that crowd was extraordinary
These men, who were all friends and mostly came from the same Seattle music "scene" in the late 80s, were my Camelot. Layne, Andy, Chris, Mike, Chester, Scott, Shannon, Kurt.... my God so many of them are gone.... and all those I haven't even mentioned.... we were so lucky to have them all..... I'd sell my soul to turn the clock back to when I was 22 in 1989.... they are ALL greatly missed by this fan.... and will continue to be.....
@Brittany Satterwhite we post things like that so the assholes like yourself make their presence known..... CONGRATULATIONS...... you get the ASSHOLE AWARD for the day! Go tell Mommy and Daddy what an overachiever you are now!
@Brittany Satterwhite and also trending are dumbass remarks by ignorant little girls looking for affirmation from other "like" simple minds.
@Brittany Taylor yeah never say that. Your soul is the most precious part about this human body and Satan doesnt deserve it. Christ suffered for all mankind so that the soul can live on forever if you accept him.
@Brittany Taylor by the way it's too not to. Instead of being ugly and negative to others go back and learn something in school
Brittany Taylor Bc they don’t know the value and how easily the world pulls those scales over their eyes and causes their great pain, but lost to the connection and what it truly means. That’s why Chris touched so many bc he was from the light side and his inspiration and convictions are obvious in his music. He didn’t worship celebs or man, nor materialism. His music was genuine and soulful and don’t make the mistakes of the world and blindly follow. These demigods, false prophets they’re replacing the original real deal like CC, etc with sell outs that taking ppl down with created chaos and virtue signaling.
He's barely keeping together at the end. Powerful performance - lots of love for his lost friend
All those moans... Even his voice was crying for Chris.
Words just can't describe this human being. His reason for being here is profoundly defined. We Love you Eddie and many of us understand how you feel. Know we are with you brother 🤙 Shaka
You’re right. An Old Soul, doing his Calling :-)
Cornell was a healer/shaman in all his lifetimes and always will be in future
What a great way to be a great holy man nowadays- be a rockstar 🤘😎🎸
Perfectly said ♥️
Eddie Vedder is one in a million...
it doesnt get eddie vedder than that
@@ericspring2033😂true❤
7 years now wow, i remember this the day it happened, my heart still hurts
May the Legends rock on forever in eternity 🤘🏻🎸
I like to think of this version as the aged one. The one that carries Eddie's whole life. He might not be feeling all those things while writing and performing this song in his days. Now it carries a completely different meaning for him and to us. Can't imagine the things that goes on his head while singing this song to this day. This song was a gift, a blessing, a reminder of how we've all been through the black. I thank Sir Eddie Veddar for everything he's given to us. A lifetime of memories fit into one perfect song.
Amen.
That is a brilliant and probably very true assessment. Well said my friend .
Kurt, Layne, Chris & Eddie.... Nothing could ever compare to these legends! EVER!!!! SEATTLE SOUND FOREVER 😔
Thanks for your love and support I really appreciate
@@Moviebox424 great performance!
Can we chat private
@@Moviebox424 what ya wanna talk about
And here I am, four years later, crying my eyes out listening to this song. Chris Cornell, Chester Bennington, Eddie Vedder will forever be my idols. They represent everything that is good to me. It's sometimes unbelievable how you can feel so much from people you never met (or will never meet), but they have talked to each one of us directly, and said some much more meaningful things that whoever is around us. I feel it, I was almost at that point, but I am still here, to remember them. Thank you.
Lovely
I love how Vedder down plays his voice so he can take in his fans voices singing in harmony over the loss of one of the most precious souls that ever existed in the music industry ❤ R.I.P Cornell.
This was the song playing at my best friends' funeral as her casket was leaving the room, as Pearl Jam was her favourite band. She was only 25. I think of her every day
I miss Chris Cornell every day
“The fire that burns twice as bright, burns twice as fast” R.I.P to all the musical legends that have gotten us to where we are today
The audience is beautiful.
Everytime I listen to this song it moves me beyond any other...it's truly indescribable.
I know, right. At that time I had no phone and I asked the man next to me to shoot that video. He sent it to me right away and I am so happy to have that memory kept. ( :
It's true
as l get older and have been on this planet long enough now. l realize some people's beautiful/pure, kind hearts don't belong in this evil/hateful, putrid world, that's why they move on to a much kinder, peaceful place where they can and are understood. much love to you all🙏🏻
There is not one song in the world that translates feeling to me as strongly as this one, for as depressed i've been and as many fucking devastating songs i've heard before, this one is the constant. It breaks me, it makes me weep without fail, it touches my soul.
This is what art is, a transmission of feelings, feelings so deep and so pure that only through a medium such as music can they truly be translated.
I see so many covers of this song where everyone has a fantastic voice, yet they all fail because they don't feel it, they don't go to this place. You need to understand that feeling is all black is about, so if you don't feel it, you can have the worlds most angelical voice and you would still fail.
You have to go to the place while singing it, read your opinion, I agree.
Greetings.
Totally agree. It’s the first song that ever brought me to tears and I didn’t even know what was happening!
Brings me back to laying on my bed at 16 years old and that same emotion that I had then.
It’s an emotional masterpiece!
Beautifully expressed. If a song doesn’t make me FEEL something across the scale of emotions - joy, heartbreak, uplifting, makes me want to dance, get fired up, turned on, or the longing ache of loneliness ‘wanting to know what love is’ , it ends up sounding like the adults of Charlie Browns world, wah wah wah. Very few current artists with the exception of Adele, Pink and even at times Miley - she sings Nothing Else Matters with Metallica that blows me away. I’m a classic rock/ 80’s to early 90’s person for the most part. Eddie is one of the few voices that fall into the ‘timeless’ category for me. Just Breathe is an all time fave. If you haven’t seen his duet with Yusuf Cat Stevens of Father & Son from Global Citizen, check it out. It should be required listening!
You seem so in tune with the soul of music. Do you ever get messages thru music? When I am sad, depressed, kicking myself about something I can’t go back and fix or despondent (just a sample of a few), a certain song will come on. Whatever ‘lesson’ I need to hear at that particular time, seems to scream the lyrics into my heart. It’s hard to describe. I guess my most relatable example is being in a very dark emotional place, abusing pain medication, in love with someone who didn’t love me back and all I could see was the path of sadness and self destruction ahead of me. I started driving hoping something would happen to end my pain. Stairway to Heaven came on the radio. I was on autopilot, unable to snap out of the hopelessness, it was as if time stood still and MADE me listen to the following lyrics - yes there are two paths you can go by, but in the long run, there’s still time to change the road you’re on’ It changed my life. The other comes from the amazing Freddie Murcury in BoHo Rhapsody - I don’t want to die. I sometimes wish I’d never been born at all, followed by Brian Mays guitar sound like it’s crying. Another song I had heard a billion times suddenly screaming what I needed to hear.
I couldn’t live without music. It’s saved my life on so many levels. The silly 70’s pop I grew up with, kept my spirits up during lockdown.
I’m rambling. I just relate to your thoughts about the song/music. #lifelessons #musicheals
It makes me weep.
Two of the best of our generation Eddie & Chris(RIP)
Noel Gilroy You think so? I’d say it’s Layne then Chris. Can’t stand Vedder.
@@christar9527 eddie then layne for me. Chris is good but voice wise nothing compared to them
Umbrace Titan are you crazy? Chris had by far the best voice, he was the most versatile and technical. All 4 are amazing singers but Chris was on a whole other level.
@@elby6980 eh my opinion your opinion. Layne I thought always had the "grungiest" voice that felt so alive but was also able to somehow mix that violent voice with emotion and make songs like down in a hole. I love Chris and back with stp he was amazing and right with eddie and layne. I just thought audioslave he was always a little mediocre. Its hard to compare legends bro
Umbrace Titan Layne is my favourite singer, but if we are talking about the ‘best SINGER’ out of the 4, Chris wins every time followed by Layne, then Eddie, then Kurt
Anyone who doesn't get emotional with this song and this interpretation, is already dead inside 💔
Ese "come back" es desgarrador, para los que conocemos a Eddie sabemos lo doloroso que es para el. Casi lloro.
tomas vargas Me sucedió exactamente lo mismo, se eriza la piel.
Ignacio Bahamondes si... es el poder de la musica de Eddie, y la banda completa, pero en especial la voz de Eddie es increible
Así es, cómo no iba a recordar a su gran hermano, pensar que de un momento a otro se fue y no tuvo la posibilidad de despedirse, Eddie siempre se ha caracterizado por expresar sus emociones y no podía aguantar más...
Mal amigo tengo un nudo en la garganta..
I'm not crying, you're crying...
You're goddamn right I am 😭😭😭
No I’m not, someone splashed my face with a cup of water... ok, I’m crying.
Yes you are.
It's the onions.
This has to be one of the most beautiful performances I’ve ever seen...
My dad passed away in August of last year, and this was his favorite Pearl Jam song, and Pearl Jam was his favorite band. I remember sometime earlier last year he sat me down and we watched this version of Black and while he cried, I didnt. I hope he knows I am now.
I’m so sorry for your loss! He knows, he sees!
😢
He knows... Sry for your loss.
This comment made me cry. Sorry for your loss
Stay strong.
I've never seen Eddies voice break in the middle of a song.... but now i found the only thing that can...
This song and hearing Eddie's broken and painfully beautiful voice already makes me cry.... seeing him cry at the end of this and knowing why quite literally made me cry a river 😭
2023 and it still makes me cry. I saw Chris in one of his last concerts. I went alone for the first time ever. I was very depressed and self medicating at the time. It will stay with me forever ❤️ he may be gone but still impacts people to this day. That’s the epitome of a legend. Millions miss you Chris
When he sings come back it just gets me
Can’t get over Chris being gone. Can’t wait to see Pearl Jam for the first time at Wrigley, my top two favorite artists of all time, Eddie is the only one left standing, may you live to be 100
ll6hlian Kessler Qw
this song makes me cry every time. We all belong together. Flesh is an illusion.
Its all a joke, I say.
I dedicate this to my bestie of 50 years, Pete, who passed away suddenly a few months ago. This was his favorite Pearl Jam song.
RIP to him and Chris.. 😭😔
Chris is the only celebrity that I ever shed a tear for. Some of the best years of my life included listening to Soundgarden.
wow he sounds a million times better live
Idk about that, he sounds good both ways!
...and it was only Eddie and his guitar, awesome!!!
@@edgalexmtz Eddie, his guitar, and his fans
@@Faks.09 You are absolutely right!
Very grateful we still have Eddie in this world. One of the greatest singers from the 90's.
Eddie Vedder has some big shoulders... Carrying on so many legacies. R.I.P Chris Cornell, Layne Stanley, Kurt Cobain, Andrew Wood
I still can’t watch this without bawling. I was a teenager in the 90’s and these guys were the soundtrack to my life at the time. It’s not fair so many are gone. Time to wrap Eddie in a bubble.
Lost my Dad yesterday morning new years eve 2021 at six am about 24 hours ago. I cried. I love you Dad. Will see you again one day. When freedom has overwhelmed us both and death has been swallowed up in Victory. Then I will see you again.
This is one of the very very few occasion where I am happy that someone filmed on his phone. Good quality and sound...
And now I need to wipe those fucking tears off my face.
I tried not to break, I felt them coming up on the "we belong together", then the break down on the last "come back" opened the gate.
Music cannot get more real than this.
It’s absolutely incredible how emotional this song made me. I would never think a youtube clip could jerk as many tears as this one did. Eddie, you’re such a joy. This world is lucky to have you, we’re lucky to have you. Thank you ❤️
2024 and we still miss and love you Chris.
2022 and thought I’d give this another listen. Hairs standing on end all over my body and a tear in my eye whilst sitting at my desk. Beautiful.
I can only imagine what this man feels having lost Andy, Kurt and Chris. This man needs to heal.
Huhuhuhu i thought that im the only one who missing chris huhu
I don’t think Eddie ever even met andy, and he wasn’t close with Kurt at all.
It's heart wrenching to hear him sing with so much passion "come back". If only the greats knew how much they were missed and adored they were.
Hello, how are you doing today? Nice meeting you here.
“come back” i’m crying so hard right now :(
I'm totally freaking out! I just discovered 'Black' last month! The vibrato in Eddie's voice is the BEST I've heard in DECADES! I feel blessed to have found this song in 2024.Betteer late than never! Thank you, Eddie!❤❤❤
After Chris Cornell's passing this song has a whole new meaning to me.
This is a heart breaking version of this song . Epic but so sad!!
My girlfriend and I saw Pearl Jam in Ottawa recently. I am a changed man now. The best band ever. Moving, emotional, thoughtful music. I feel blessed to have been able to witness Pearl Jam Live.
Eddie is such an amazing man. The stuff he does with Steve Gleason and the A.L.S. community makes him a saint. This song is the only way I feel that can actually come close to the pain I feel from losing my husband and childrens father.
Omg!!!! The raw emotion behind this performance. 😭😭😭😭
Hello, how are you doing today? Nice meeting you here.
Thanks for your love and support I really appreciate
RIP Chris Cornell 😭
RIP Chester Benington 😭
Yes, may Chester RIP. But let him away of Chris Cornell, he was out of Chirs league,
Chris is still living in Eddie's voice and music. A part of every dear who has died still keeps on living in us who loved him/her. In our movenents, in our actions, in our tasks. We belong together... Our task does not end with death. Thanks Eddie for this song, it catches straight my heart and memories....
Hello, how are you doing today? Nice meeting you here.
this song is truly beautiful, Eddie's music has been such a gift to so many people... Recently my dog died of cancer, and i listened to this song everyday of his last week with us, it really helped me process the pain, i'm now going to be releasing a cover of this song in memory of AJ and as homage to the great Eddie Vedder!
"Black " music written by Stone Gossard!!!
Oh I'm so sorry....... You will always be together....♥️ 🐾🐾
This version is a million times sadder and more hitting than the studio version
Eddie you know he loved you. We can always still feel both of yall together..
COME BACK-- COME BACK ...You can feel the emotion ,hurt,loneliness in the words....hats off to eddie im not sure how he kept it together much as he did.thanks eddie.rest easy Chris, layne,kurt, you guys are never forgotten.sad that the time was so short.play it loud for the heavens!!!
Eu chorei no "come Back" senti a dor dele , a dor de perder um amigo. Incrível como o Eddie tem o poder de transmitir o que ele está sentindo com tamanha excelência , meu cantor favorito de sempre. ❤️ #RipChris
Eddie Vedder canta com uma paixão e uma dor, deu vontade até de chorar na hora em que ele encosta a testa no microfone e suspira fundo ♥️
Essa música tocou fundo :'(
Essa doeu 3 lendas que se foram da minha geração chorão chester e Chris.....
Kurt, Scott, Layne, Chris many voices of a great generations gone, let’s cherish Ed while we can!
This is so beautiful, no song has ever touched me like this. I miss you chris, may eddie keep your spirit and soul alive.
This song is life... not only about love it is about everything what matters for a person and what you never can have, even it is for good or for bad doesnt matter. You cant get it...and it destroy you in some way everyday of your life.
Come back.
Class act Eddie.
Righteous love for Chris.
it was never dedicated to chris. Don't be fooled for clicks.
@@thafirestarter this one was dumbass lmao
We need to keep this guy away from everything. Last piece of 90s dreams... Lets Protect him my fellow Eddie lovers.😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
This song has always torn me to pieces but that ending.....
Ive been a PJ fan since the 90s. This has ALWAYS been my favorite song! He performs it just a good as he did back then. TY for sharing footage✌
tears in my eyes. So beautiful, so soul-touching, unbelievable. Thanks
Foi um dos melhores momento da minha vida insignificante.triste,saudade
Fucking Got me crying Eddie, come back Chris !
Eddie your Heart retching performance of Black for Chris said it all. You loved him as we all did . He is truly missed by you more than other love and peace
I started crying already when he started singing this for Chris....goddamn it!!! Why does life have to be this way????
life is hard
but we all knew that when we decided to be born
instead of another miscarriage, or stillborn
this song celebrates life in all its glory
it was never dedicated to chris.
I take a walk outside, some kids play outside, i cant feel their laughter, so y do i see them, twisted thoughts spin round my head,..................i know someday youll have a beautiful life, youll be wrapped in somebodys else arms, y cant it be mine. ....love lost turns ur world to black...
I love this song so much. After my ddughter passed away, my world turned black.
Hope he stays w us , sad but to sing blues like Chris and Curt you have to have the pain...so sad but they shined hard and fast.
Llevo mas de 20 años llorando la misma canción... su manera de interpretar su obra maestra del álbum "ten" me pone los pelos de punta y ese sentimiento tan fresco del dolor en la pérdida. Excelente Eddie Vedder, cuidate harto, Porque no queremos seguir perdiendo a nuestros héroes de juventud.
Sub Zero sin duda. Inmortales
Al fin alguien en español!!!
Si ...a grandes como Kurt cobain, Cris, el de avissi
@@soniadutto9143 pasarán décadas y esta como muchas otras joyas del grunge seguirán sonando en nuestros corazones como himnos de la vida... la banda Sonora de todas nuestras vivencias.
Whoever was recording this new that they were capturing something special.
I'm so glad I grew up, with the honer of these men as my role models, open my eyes an gave me resolve. Thank you, best years ever spent on music..
RIP CHRIS..
I could just die listening to this song. So intense ... plus it's dedicated to Chris. This is pure blues reinvented by grunge.
His pain is palpable 🙏
My adopted son took me to lunch. Said the same thing bringing it to me. Thank you.
Just hearing him break as he ushers comeback is enough to break any grown man, it pulled my heart strings for sure