Julian Nagelsmann criticizes handball law after Germany’s loss to Spain | ESPN FC
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ส.ค. 2024
- The ESPN FC crew reacts to Julian Nagelsmann’s comments saying a penalty was missed on Spain for a handball in Germany’s 2-1 loss in the UEFA EURO 2024 quarterfinals.
✔ Subscribe to ESPN+: espnplus.com/so...
✔ Subscribe to ESPN FC on TH-cam: bit.ly/SUBSCRIB...
![[Watch Party] RoV Pro League 2024 Winter | with Moowan ( Bacon Time Vs Talon )](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CCEDhu6dPN8/mqdefault.jpg)
referee was english, commentators would be crying if it was england
WHO CARES !!!! Our refs got the Krauts out of the way and stuffed the Spaniards with cards - WELL DONE AT LAST !!!
Who’s salty?! 😂😢😢😢😢
long live Anthony Taylor ( formerly known as the Klopp hater )
@@Alex-bl1es even if the crowds desert England, Anthony Taylor is our 12th man
@@mamumonkan At least the Brits are not going to win a flower pot again :D Competing with the French on who plays the greater BS
If that wasn´t a penalty then nothing is.
The penalty if it was , came after 5 extra minutes. In 15 minutes 5 more minutes? Is that fair?
Is it fair inyuring Pedri in the first 10 min and not receiving any car??
@@Miguel-lf4ujthis has nothing to do with the penalty lol
bro the pass before the hand was offside end of the conversation AHAH
@@Miguel-lf4ujThe Situation where cucurella blocked the shot with his hand was in Minuten 106 + kroos played the Ball. Injuries happen.
@@miguelnavarrodonadios6067 Show evidence it was offside. Everybody calling "offside" does not back it up. So, no, not "end of conversation". If you say it was offside, then you're responsible to back it up.
Funny how a panel made of 2 English men a Scot and a French man are roasting the German coach. So petty! Especially Le Boeuf confirming the ball was not on target 😂 Mediocre pundits
Yeah, saying the shot was not even on target is mind blowing.
cry louder loser
The 0% Ball knowledge in this whole conversation is beyond crazy
The only people with less ball knowledge are the morons thinking this was somehow a penalty
The only person who lacks knowledge is you, the person who calls it ‘ball knowledge’ 😂
💯 agree with you@@environm3ntalist549
So explain to us great knowledgeable one . Dont just object, show you have knowledge. Go
@@roberto5red5rocky85 explain what?
In today's game it's definitely a penalty the way Burley acts uff he's a pure Germany hater
No it's not because Fulkrug was offside
I agree. Craig Burley hates Germany. Just watch any video out there when Craig Burley comments on a Germany game or even comments on German players. Maybe it's because of his envy of German football because he was such a talentless player.
@@Prasko131 nobody has said he was offside
@@WEstHamUTD777 he has big mouth and I agree he was talentless but acts so arrogantly
@@Prasko131 no he was not and it does not become true if you people say it again and again
I feel like even Cucurella stopped expecting it to be called a penalty
look at the spanish players everybody knew it was a penalty
And he was so relieved after, smiling, when the penalty wasn’t given. Definitely already expected it
Yeah, he thought it was a penalty, he didn't know about the previous offside, as well as most spanish players
@@HyCris it wasnt offside
100%
Just imagine Denmark fans, their handball was given but this not ? lmao
I can't believe what they're talking about. It's a clear handball and the shot was going towards the goal CLEARLY what a prejudice from you guys just because it was germany. What a shame
@@locke333333333333333 it’s definitely not a handball
It was a clear penalty.
@@highland7426 it wasn’t
@@highland7426 it wasn’t
In the same play, Füllkrug is offside, then he touches the ball with his arm, and when Musiala shoots, there is another German player offside... furthermore, UEFA recommended that this type of handball should not be a penalty... that was before the start of the championship... in the Copa America final, a similar handball was not called a penalty... crying Germans... it was not a penalty, and if it had been, there would have been three previous fouls by German players: offside, arm, and offside!
Calling bad looser after this is such a bad taste, this is a clear cut penalty no matter what side you are on.
it's not, read the rules, you sore loser
dats not a penalty
@@keletsosebolai414 yes it was. especially after watching kolo muani get his head slammed into the ground opn purpose by nacho, it's clearly rigged for spain. i will be putting my money on them!
@@keletsosebolai414 ..it's one of the clearest^^
@@keletsosebolai414 why not. ther is hand.. and he move his body into ball.. and block a shot on goal.. explain me. why no penaltiy? hand was clearly
If it was against England I'd like to watch you comment on it xD
precisely because it was not involving england their opinion is more obective
@@magnusVarblomst hahaha sure sure.
yeah but fortunately Anthony Taylor can't whistle England games :)
It was offside and a handball by fullkrug, stop crying germans jajajaj
@@juanperezpaniagua3601 I don’t think there are any germans in this convo lol
People dont get it. It is about consistency in refereeing in adherence to the rules when borderline calls are made. If the referee sometimes doesn't give a handball in that same position and other times does. Then that gives the referee the chance to actually pick and choose when to make the call. Then affect the outcome of the game or even get paid to cheat for a side.
The referee should of just stuck to the same refereeing style at the beginning of the tournament where any sort of hand ball away from the body was a penalty. But to suddenly change the their mind shows no consistency even if the rules can be interpreted support it.
EXACTLY EVEN FRANCE GOT A PEN ON THE FINAL WC 2018 AGAINST CROITIA BASED ON THIS SAME RULE SHOULD WE NOW ANNUL THE RESULTS
@@2DarkHorizon it’s not a handball so ofc no penalty
Nagelsman's reaction is justified and should be seriously clarified. On German television, referees discussed whether it would now be legal for other players, like Cucurella, to simply pull their arm towards their body to avoid a penalty.
Nagelsmann was actually too kind.
There cant be a more clear penalty especially if u consider other penalty calls during the same tournanent. Its a disgrace and decided the game
@@DennyCraneReloaded it’s not a handball no matter how you losers can’t accept it
Nagelemann is making a good point.
If this happened to England y'all would make two hour content about why it should have been a penalty. If this is not a penalty then I want a clear explanation about when it is one?
You get 3 Brits and a Frenchman finding no issue with Germany being robbed and eliminated. I’m shocked 🫢
True
They shouldn't have started a World War of they wanted to be treated fair
it was offside. There was no robbery. in any case kros should have 2 red cards for how he played
Yea keep ignoring the blatantly obvious red Card Kroos should have gotten that would have turned the game in Spains favor. An eye for an eye
nah
Füllkrug was not offside. Offside is automatically checked and since it was followed by a throw-in for Germany, it was checked, otherwise there would have been a free kick for Spain
He was though
Plus handball before from Füllkrug
@@rodrigofuentes5486 Show me the video.
Again, show me the video.
@@tobiasbrandt6840 it was offside and he probably handballed
The solution to this case is obvious. It was clearly a mistake by the referee, who was, however, under massive pressure. Days earlier, in the Germany-Denmark match, the referee decided to give a penalty after letting the VAR decide. However, this VAR was reprimanded by referee boss Rosetti after the game against Denmark, saying that he should not decide on penalties because of such trifles.
And in the match between Germany and Spain, the SAME VAR was used again, this time not wanting to do anything wrong. The English referee also knew this, which is why he didn't give a penalty.
A clearly wrong decision! - It was clearly a most likely successful shot on goal, which was prevented by the hand of the Spanish player.
The UEFA assignment of referees to certain games is just incredibly stupid. To use the same VAR again with an English referee, knowing that he will be deducted points if he interferes and has already uncovered a wrong decision by Michael Oliver (England) in a previous game, which was then criticized, is stupid.
@@OhLoonJohnson It's not just incredibly stupid, it's simply irresponsible. You don't have to be a football expert with limited English skills like me to realize this.
@@Indah-tjs Yap totally agree. Just UEFA things.
@@Indah-tjs it was clearly not a handball so the ref actually made the right call
In the same play, Füllkrug is offside, then he touches the ball with his arm, and when Musiala shoots, there is another German player offside... furthermore, UEFA recommended that this type of handball should not be a penalty... that was before the start of the championship... in the Copa America final, a similar handball was not called a penalty... crying Germans... it was not a penalty, and if it had been, there would have been three previous fouls by German players: offside, arm, and offside!
Bro, that was 1000000% a penalty. I'm so shocked the ref didn't even want to see the replay from different angles. That ref was either bought from Spain or is clearly oblivious and needs medical attention
In the same play, Füllkrug is offside, then he touches the ball with his arm, and when Musiala shoots, there is another German player offside... furthermore, UEFA recommended that this type of handball should not be a penalty... that was before the start of the championship... in the Copa America final, a similar handball was not called a penalty... crying Germans... it was not a penalty, and if it had been, there would have been three previous fouls by German players: offside, arm, and offside!
Argentina against Germany ref didn’t see 1986. Spain against Germany ref didn’t see 👀 shocking and no truth in football for me. Germany F.A. Wake up u
Even italy vs germany 2006, when the score was 0-0 there was a clear handball but no penalty awrded
In any European league play over the last 5+ years this would have been a penalty 10 times out of 10. Crazy he didn't even bother with VAR. GG to the Spanish team, but this moment was a stain.
Wrong, there was offside before the handball so everything after doesn't count when VAR looks at it
it was offisde and handball from a german before. what is awesome is that people who didnn't watch the match comment these things
@@nosirve9458 I heard the offside was borderline, so it still up for grabs if the offside was given or not. Not a clear case
@@2DarkHorizon IT IS a clear offside, go watch the match again
@@nosirve9458 i heard someone say it there was a throwin so no offside
I expected that from the game. When Germany or a German team plays internationally, the referee always decides against Germany. That is normal and has become very noticeable in the last two years.
ja ja,and Kroos' fouls..... 7 yellow cards that were not shown to him...and Tah's penalty on Morata? In the same play, Füllkrug is offside, then he touches the ball with his arm, and when Musiala shoots, there is another German player offside... furthermore, UEFA recommended that this type of handball should not be a penalty... that was before the start of the championship... in the Copa America final, a similar handball was not called a penalty... crying Germans... it was not a penalty, and if it had been, there would have been three previous fouls by German players: offside, arm, and offside!
If that had happened to England you would see these pundits with whole different answer and energy ofc that was a clear penalty your hands shouldn’t be in that position it should be at your sides just my opinion tho
I’m pretty sure the guy sat on the far right wouldn’t have a different answer.
It was offside and a handball by fullkrug, stop crying like a baby and watch game
I expected that from the game. When Germany or a German team plays internationally, the referee always decides against Germany. That is normal and has become very noticeable in the last two years.
@@juanperezpaniagua3601Not offside at all clown! Stop spreading false information
Neither an england fan, spain nor germany fan...but from the handball.rules, that is not a penalty. Read the rules
If it's england playing these peoples would say penalty 😅😅😅
people are saying pen anyway lol why mention england
Karma-2010 World Cup frank lampards goal crossing the line. Goal not given
@@charliegates3556 big difference thou, in 2010 video check was not allowed now it is so the excuse is pretty weak. 2010 was a normal human mistake and 2024 it was deliberate.
@@reinerhoch1357 no it’s a vendetta everyone wants England to lose. It will only increase their ego though, the hate is baggage, form of admiration and bitterness
It was a clear penalty. Dammm
Fullkrug was offside anyways. VAR noticed and moved on.
Offside before that happened
@@cactaceousvar literally didn’t even check for any of it, plus the lines man didn’t race his flag ever so they wouldn’t have check for the offside
@@cactaceous There is no footage that proves that it was an offside therefore the statement is a lie.
@@Triple_X_X There is no footage that proves that it was an offside therefore the statement is a lie.
ESPN should be ashamed of themselves. The anti-German sentiment on display here is embarassing. Let's be honest - if UEFA gave Germany a penalty for the handball from Denmark, then this Spanish hanball wouls be 1 million % a penalty!
kross red after 5 minute would also be fair. then germany would have no chance against spain with 10 man... so be happy you even had 11 palyers for 120minutes
@@cm-gw9yb that was not a red card period. At most a yellow. So no your argument does not work.
@@TheIInWin its 100% red card. also it was off side....
@@cm-gw9ybthe offside was questionable at best and your argument is weakened by the fact that VAR never checked for offside. As well you using "100%" shows how strong your argument is. If this was a court case your client would be suing you for malpractice.
@@TheIInWin You forgot the "offside" Denmark was given against Germany? Denmark were clearly stronger than Germany up to then, would have been interesting to see how the match went were that "offside" not given and game not interrupted for the rain...So that they made it to the Spain match is already a great result. Kroos committed 5 fouls in the Spain match (3 more than any other offender)!!!! and all yellow standard fouls. He should have been booked for the butcher-like foul on Pedri, long before he was eventually yellow carded halfway through the second half for halting Dani Olmo's run on goal. Had the referee given the two yellows Kroos absolutely deserved, how would Germany have played without Kroos in ten for more than 100 minutes??? Also, the 3 min extra time turned magically into six, nobody mentions that either...So Germany wasn't robbed. Spain was the slightly stronger side. And the referee made mistakes on both sides. We have to be objective instead of focusing only on that penalty (which in any case would not have been a 100% guarantee of a goal...)
who are these guys and how can they come to the conclusion that this was not a pen?
They are paid actors
those guys are pure idiots
Easy. It wasn't deliberate. Defender has a right to be there, the arm itself didn't do anything unnatural.
Fulkrug was in offside so the handball after that doesn't count
@@stnbch3025lol because it wasnt deliberate? So then whats the point in defenders keeping their arms behind their back, if you can just casually leave your arms on the side of your body 😅 I think the referee wanted the game to go to penalties. because germany injured Pedri at the start of the match and since the match was 1:1 already, he felt like ignoring that penalty In fact, this whole match had more fouls than counter attacks.
I just unsubscribe smh am not even a German supporter but a fan of musiala , if it was England you guys would say clear penalty lol smh 🤦♂️ 😅😅 clearrrrrr hand ball his hand is way outttttttt
@@russian6fullycode931 it’s clearly not a handball so ofc no penalty
cry more loser
keep whining
@@russian6fullycode931 cry more loser
In the same play, Füllkrug is offside, then he touches the ball with his arm, and when Musiala shoots, there is another German player offside... furthermore, UEFA recommended that this type of handball should not be a penalty... that was before the start of the championship... in the Copa America final, a similar handball was not called a penalty... crying Germans... it was not a penalty, and if it had been, there would have been three previous fouls by German players: offside, arm, and offside!
Wow, it starts with a pretty inaccurate and incomplete translation of Nagelsmann‘s statement and gets progressively worse from there. ❤❤❤ five stars out of five for incompetence
In the same play, Füllkrug is offside, then he touches the ball with his arm, and when Musiala shoots, there is another German player offside... furthermore, UEFA recommended that this type of handball should not be a penalty... that was before the start of the championship... in the Copa America final, a similar handball was not called a penalty... crying Germans... it was not a penalty, and if it had been, there would have been three previous fouls by German players: offside, arm, and offside!
@@josemiguelmaiza2279 I was talking about the translation and the panel.
when it's about Germany, German club, or Cristiano Ronaldo I can't hear what they say, they are disgusting
It was penalty English Referee had robbed Germany.
Fullkrug was offside
Shut up dumb American
@@spartansamin1631 no he wasnt
@@Maggi0561yes he was and either way this was obviously not a penalty
@@Thekidjeremy789 I don't know your definition of "obvious," but for me, it would only be the case if other referees would always make the same decision based on the rules. However, that's not the case here; the rules leave room for interpretation. The decision of whether it's a natural or unnatural hand movement or whether it's close to the body or not is very subjective. Deciding this with certainty without relying on video footage is a joke. And its not offside, otherwise they would have shown us the footage and Spain would have gotten free kick.
These guys who say it wasn’t a penalty are delirious. His hand was not beside his body like his teammate beside him. 100% a penalty shocking poor refereeing and total garbage what these commentators are saying.
and it was 100% on target. going towards goal. player offside may not of even interfered with it. had cucurellas hand not stopped it 100%
You can tell most of the people who watch this channel are either from the USA or other non footballing nations. They don’t even know the rules 😂!
actually, you can tell nobody knows the rules at all, because it is clearly explained there :D, it was not a penalty.
@@asdfomfglolit's hilarious isn't it? Everybody keeps talking about how it should be a penalty because of intent or how the ball would have gone right at the goal but none of that has to do with the rules. Yet everybody, even former footballers like Michael Ballack keep saying this is a textbook penalty. Without actually knowing what's in the textbook lmao.
Sorry this commentator does not know what is talking about. Subjectivity? Really? How is that applied? And explain? How does that Germany work with that getting kicked out because of subjectivity? Really? Come on. These guys are a joke. It is either a penalty or it isn’t and it was a clear penalty. Period!!!!
In the same play, Füllkrug is offside, then he touches the ball with his arm, and when Musiala shoots, there is another German player offside... furthermore, UEFA recommended that this type of handball should not be a penalty... that was before the start of the championship... in the Copa America final, a similar handball was not called a penalty... crying Germans... it was not a penalty, and if it had been, there would have been three previous fouls by German players: offside, arm, and offside!
Yes, it was a clear penalty.
Yes it was blatantly clear
@@outdooradventuresja Let them enjoy winning like this.
*clearly not a penalty
@@outdooradventuresjaagreed, blatantly clear that it was not a penalty by any stretch of the imagination
@@Thekidjeremy789 Lol
No consistency, thats the problem
The rules should be made clear
They are clear. There was offside before the handball. Even goals are disallowed for offsides, you want them to count the penalties?
@@Prasko131exactly
@@Prasko131everyone missing this key part of that whole situation
@@Prasko131show me only 1 proof that it was offside otherwise not true
The rule was clear. First it was offside. Second the handball rule was stated before the tournament began with their new rulebook. Guess the pundits never read the rule changes
This is really sad to watch, at least argue that it was offside first, or something else. saying that it was never going to be goal is crazy.
Yeah saying the shot of Musiala wasnt going for the goal is ridiculous, how did he manage to come to that conclusion from the angle of his chair ?
In football you can't play with hands . someone must change the rule when there is a hand ball inside the box or outside it should be a hand ball no excuses no accident player must avoid accident
robbed in the swiss game, robbed in the danish game, robbed in the spanish game
Funnily enough, in the danish game the germans were benefitted from the same thing :D
@@asdfomfglol The danish penalty was no penalty, the spanish was one a penalty and its exactly what nagelnsman said
@@asdfomfglol yeah but we also had a goal taken by a bs foul call on our first corner kick 😅
The true personality of English people exposed
Why in the French F is that not a handball? Part of the defensive skill is not giving a handball. Players everywhere else in the world would get crucified for that handball.
because arms where down..... its clear no handball if you know the football rules...
@@cm-gw9yb arm was down and out, not against the body. What rules are you citing?
Now I don't know what is a Penalty 😮
I'm so pissed, still. Not just that the call was not given, but because the pundits here to say this was clearly not hand ball, claiming that Germany is a bad loser, and also for laughing about Nagelsmann, who actually made good points. Three days after the game, and Taylor and VAR still have not given an explanation. Do those pundits watch Copa America? I've just watched 3 penalties given for hand ball for similar situations. Are they getting it wrong? F!
Only in Handball this is not a penalty! I would love to see your opinions on this if it would have been England getting robbed. Disgusting!
Who hired these guys ????? Omg !!!!! This is ridiculous
He was lucky that his hand was out wide, and by tucking it in behind his back, he had an opportunity to block the ball.
I wonder if these Brits would be reacting the same way if this would have happened to Bellingham their golden boy 😂😂
In what world is that not even reviewed by VAR? Oh that's right.. a world where Anthony Taylor is the ref.
Clear penalty
*clearly not a penalty
Only if you don't know football rules. Fulkrug was offside before the handball so it's not a penalty
@@Prasko131 if he was offside, it would be a free kick for spain, idiot
@@Prasko131 Don't spread fake facts, please. There has been no analysis on this for good reasons.
@@Prasko131 If fullkrug was offside uefa would have already told us just to protect the ref, the fact that they didn't kinda confirms there was no offside. In the the Top 5 European leagues this pen would be given 10 out of 10. another fact. Btw. if you would know the rules, if it was offside the ref has to whistle and give a free kick.
The ref was calling everything a yellow card and I mean everything. But somehow, an obvious handball penalty doesn't even get a VAR review. Highly suspicious and disappointing.
I mean not really. Kroos should have had 3 obvious yellow cards in that game and only got one. His first on Pedri could easily have been a straight red.
Did you watch the game? Did Kroos get a card for the fouls in the first few minutes? Specially the ones on Pedri, that got him not only out of the game, but out for the rest of the tournament.
lol kross should get red after 5 min. he did not even got 1 yellow looool
I'm Spanish and happy Spain won but I think that was a penalty. I agree to Nagelsmann.
Thank u thats fairplay. Good Luck in Final.
In the same play, Füllkrug is offside, then he touches the ball with his arm, and when Musiala shoots, there is another German player offside... furthermore, UEFA recommended that this type of handball should not be a penalty... that was before the start of the championship... in the Copa America final, a similar handball was not called a penalty... crying Germans... it was not a penalty, and if it had been, there would have been three previous fouls by German players: offside, arm, and offside!
Frank saying in his time it wouldn't have been a penalty - I'd refer him back to the France vs Portugal semi final of Euro 2000
Yeah, I don't know what Frank's mental state was in this interview. He also said the ball was not on target.
exactly... they gave pks if the ball barely touch a finger. look at WC98. baggio v chile. baggio is just outside of box, kicks ball purposely into defenders hand in the box. instant pk given.
@@andrezcabara2774 its called gaslighting. its what any and all media does.
If it was going outside then how did France get a penalty in the final of the world cup against Argentina ? These pundits are so funny. It’s a clear penalty
clear penalty. Anthony Taylor did it again 😅
A clear penalty This cheating only happens for Spain and Real Madrid against Germany.
😂😂😂😂😂😂 BUT FRANCE GOT THE SAME PEN KICK AGAINST CROITIA IN FINAL 2018 SO SHOULD WE REPEAT THAT GAME, THE RULE IS CLEAR BUT THEY KEEP THE BS
Your suppose to block the ball with your legs or chest when a shot is going towards target, not with your hands. That is why this is a clear penalty. If cucerella handled the ball anywhere else in the area where he is challenging for the ball with a German player than it would definitely not be a penalty. The fact is cucerella was at least 7 yards away from any German player when he blocked a goal bound shot with his outstretched hand so this to me based on the rule book is an automatic penalty. And for those that might think that I must be bias, I can tell you guys I have always been an italian fan since I was a kid and I never objected that frattesi handball against croatia as unfortunate it was a clear cut penalty and the ref had to make that call in an important match. I hated that it was a penalty of course but after watching the replay myself it was the right call. This spain hand ball I feel was even more of a penalty than the italian one as his entire hand and arm was outstretched. There is a big difference between hating a call from a fans point of view and the right call being made no matter which team you support.
Cucurella didn't know were the shot was aimed at. So penalty it is.
Beyond ridiculous
I'm only looking at reality, at what is actually decided as penalty and what is not, day in, day out. And to say that this is not a penalty is disregarding reality.
This is twilight zone stuff
In what planet was that not a penalty? It was a clear handball. His arm was out and away from his body, it was a 1000% clear penalty
In the planet in which UEFA specified the handball rules for the tournament and this exact scenario is not a penalty. UEFA's confirmed it.
@@metalmouse2953 dude this was a clear penalty, it’s ver simple dude had his arm out and he blocked the ball, the shot was going in the goal. It’s very simple
@@vjluarasi1847 dude, I just gave you UEFA's statement and confirmation that it's not a penalty. It's very simple, they gave an image showing the yes/no for handball, this one fell exactly in the no handball one. It's very simple, the ref applies the rules. The rule given by UEFA is no penalty. Ask UEFA but it's the rule, it's not up to you.
@@metalmouse2953 then no handball should ever be a penalty because a handball doesn’t come as clear as that one was. But anyway that’s over with man it is what it is.
@@vjluarasi1847 it's the rule. Ask FIFA
Imagine hiring these 4 guys here. 3 english and 1 french. but their teams play the most boring football 😂 France and England don't deserve to be in the semi finals
Bro if this was Croatia vs France this would’ve been 2 penalties
This pundits are crazy
That a penalty
WAAH WAAAH WAAAAH 🥺😢😂
If instead of giving your opinion just seeing a clip maybe you would realize that prior to that the guy is offside. Also if you had seen the game you would see that the referee did not favor Spain, in fact, he should have sent off Kroos in the first half and another German in the second, it was a shame as Germany's goal comes from a play in the that the referee also fails, the referee whistled in favor of Germany.
Offside, you know that?
@@Torosentao Rewatched it, no Offside.
@@wokeaf1337you're sentimental,not only was it an offside it was also a hand ball for Germany player before the shot was taken
A clear penalty clear. Go and look at the World Cup finals between France and Croatia and see the first goal. It was similar and year that was the World Cup final
To ask English guys if an English ref made a mistake …. Made my day 😂😂😂🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
The game is played by humans and the decisions are being taken by robots.
You are sitting there laughing, but a first class team is being robbed of their chance to win the championship.
In the same play, Füllkrug is offside, then he touches the ball with his arm, and when Musiala shoots, there is another German player offside... furthermore, UEFA recommended that this type of handball should not be a penalty... that was before the start of the championship... in the Copa America final, a similar handball was not called a penalty... crying Germans... it was not a penalty, and if it had been, there would have been three previous fouls by German players: offside, arm, and offside!
it was a clear penalty!
Well if you consider the rules of the game, not a penalty by any stretch of the imagination
No penalty, Fulkrug was offside
Disgusting that u guys are called experts. Your show is turning more into some former senile c-class players gathering talking some bs. We need some hosts who understands the modern football game on a show like this!
There was no offside, and no handball feom Fulkrug, otherwise they would have shown it and they never did... blatant cheating and we all know soccer does not have the best record in that regard. Just like the "offside" between Madrid and Bayern...
A huh 😂, it’s all conspiracy against Germans in favour of Spanish. Spain was clutch Germany wasn’t, stop crying. It’s unbecoming of Germans football history and pedigree
@malvarez8484 guess the ignored penalty didn't happened or the "offside " call didn't happen as well during Madrid vs Bayern... all "mistakes" that favored Spain or a Spanish team.
@@lagranarob-3881 😭
Spain r the cheating champs of Europe. Doping extraordinary talent!
it was offside and handball, in my tv they showed the replace
I've been calling him Cucaracha ever since.
What I don't understand is that even though the players are offside, they let the game continue to say that it doesn't count.
Uefa confirmed Fullkrug was offside, discussion ended.
Reported for spreading of misinformation.
Lol what a clown
Oh I can see they don't like Germany. ESPN.
So much opinion and so little competence...tf is this show even
what a huge surprise that the english "pundits" talk against germany
These ESPN pundits have no shame. Offside? Ball going out?
The only reason people would see it as offsides is because of the handball lmao, this ref fucked up and made germany lose
how ridiculous can you be
Literally in the 3rd minute of the game, Kroos breaks Pedri's knee and leaves him out of the Euro Cup and he doesn't even see a yellow card, and not only that, at 20 minutes he does another one and he doesn't see a yellow card either, it would make me ashamed to be German and complain about yesterday's refereeing.
It makes it all the more horrific. I agree that Kroos should have been booked earlier. And who knows, that might have impacted the game. But I cannot recall a more clear penalty being denied in a long time.
It was just overall garbage officiating. And that is not worthy of a Euro quarter final.
So yes. As a German I have no problem whatsoever complaining about horrific refereeing.
It's always the same people crying and whining about Kroos. Guys it's not that hard to understand unless you have an IQ under 85: If Kroos got a yellow card in the beginning of the game he obviously wouldn't have made the later harsh foul where he got the yellow card. So yea Kroos deserved yellow card in minute 3 but nothing would have happened.
I hate this whataboutism by Germany haters. This is a clear penalty.
Yess it's clearly red card when he attack to pedri
@@stephanaszyiemlieh5811 a clear red card when the Spanish players fake foul after foul and punch Musiala in the face when they feared Germany.
@@david53444Kroos on a yellow, means he would’ve played more safe (like the challenge on Olmo when he was clear on goal) or he would’ve been substituted early, which also would’ve worked in Spain’s advantage. So how can you say nothing would’ve happened so certainly?
If that had been a goal line clearance hitting his hand like that it's a straight pen . This whole bs about subjective handballs is just annoying because later on we'll see another incident like this and it's gonna be given as a pen . The level of inconsistency in officiating is actually ruining the games . We saw it in the prem , laliga , serie a , champions league . At this point I'd rather the letter of the law than nature of the law , because atleast it'll be consistent.
Cant be offside cuz germany got throw in. If offise Spain had a freekick.
What? Füllkrug was offsides on a cross so that can clearly be offside
@@Elian571 Arms can't be offside. Stoptalking about the beautiful game. The refs also didn't rule offside, neither has VAR: Taylor simply ruled that there was no handball...
@@Elian571 nope. nothing with it can be offside. its offside or not offside. If it was offside Spain had a free kick. Offside Rule is simple and clear.
I think that was always a penalty, 20, 30, 40, or 50 years ago. :) I can not recall a situation where this was not a penalty. Except the referee did not see the situation.
If a defender jumps into a shot to block it, his arms need to touch his body. Otherwise its a penalty. The defender next to Chucharella does exactly that. So of course its a penalty, he blocks the shot with his hand that is widely away from his body. And of course the shot was on target. It is so simple. Who is this Scot talking about football? Is he hockey player or what?
whatttt no penalty ????? you totally nuts all
These dudes are talking like VAR doesnt exsist… tf
I also thought it was a handball until I read the official FIFA rules “For the purposes of determining handball offences, the upper boundary of the arm is in line with the bottom of the armpit. Not every touch of a player's hand/arm with the ball is an offence. It is an offence if a player: deliberately touches the ball with their hand/arm, for example moving the hand/arm towards the ball.” So it was not a handball.
Yea then why wasn’t the play whistled dead ? Play continued like it hit his foot.
A statement for the record: I very much dislike the way the Germans and the English approach football. Having said that, I consider ridiculous the way the Germans were eliminated the day before yesterday. I am not a referee, but I would have given the penalty. Taylor (and the VAR assistants) must have had his (their) own reasons for letting the match continue. It may also be that they had to take "intention" into account (which may be difficult to judge), as well as the shortness of the distance (between the shooter and the defender). I find all these EXTREMELY confusing and I would suggest that the FIFA lot have another close look at this issue. The veil of mystery, concerning when a penalty should be given and when not, must be removed. I would go for the obvious: handball by any defender inside the penalty area = penalty, no matter where the arm is, regardless of intention, regardless of closeness. If this does not come to pass, people will go on discussing for decades whether an arm was in touch with the body in a particular situation or not, whether an arm was in its "natural" position, whether an arm was supporting a falling defender, whether a defender was looking away and had no intention to touch the ball, and the like. At the end of the day, I feel that the rules must become simpler and more straightforward. In any other case, everything will continue to rest upon the momentary judgement of the referee (and of the VAR assistants).
Every single handball was a penalty in the tournament, but this one was denied.
We have technology to analyze these situations. I can't understand why they didn't use it to check if it was offside. And if that's not the point then it definitely was handball cause the ball was going inside and Cucurella probably unconsciously knew it and preferred a penalty instead.
I'm spanish but sports rules should be applied as a science and not as an art, just for sake of fairness
Well ... the cf was clearly offside before the handball ....
If it was offside, how come Spain didnt get a free kick and Germany got a throw in instead? Even if it was offside, the red didnt realize. Taylor did a disgustingly bad job in this match.
To all the "purists" of the game: During good old days without the VAR, this would have clearly been a penalty
Whose here after Spain won the Euros😂
100% penalty. They gave penalty for wayyyy less that that. Football os Rigged. VAR is controlled and convenient for some teams that’s a fact !!!
100% facts. There is no other sensible explanation
Exactly, Lukaku's goal was disallowed because of Openda's slight unintentional touch with his fingertips, whereas Cucarella, although involuntarily, was playing volleyball in his team's penalty area.... Talk about consistency... You either call them or not
Cone on, it s a clear penalty
Almost everybody take the scene only from the 2 seconds Cucarella touches the Ball with his wrist and argue that there was no intension to do so by the player... hmmm, please watch the scene in complete, from the pass to Füllkrug.. and you will come to 2 decisions;
1. Fülle was not offside in the moment the ball is passed to him
2. But Cucarella moves immediately two steps over to the left, seen from the direction and point where Musialla got the ball. So his intension is to block his shot, and this means his pure intension is to avoid a goalshot by Musialla, and he is at 5 Meters distance, so this is a perfect handgame, whether he tried to get his arm on the back or not, basta.. Funny by the way that his right arm is where it belongs when a defender blocks a shot in this area.