What Artist Is Insanely Overrated (Pt. 2) | ANTHONY FANTANO
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ส.ค. 2024
- What Artist Is Insanely Overrated (Pt. 2) | ANTHONY FANTANO #shorts #music #reaction
===================================
Subscribe: bit.ly/3EHhMms
Patreon: / theneedledrop
Official site: theneedledrop.com
Twitter: / theneedledrop
Instagram: / afantano
TikTok: / theneedletok
TND Twitch: / theneedledrop
===================================
![เบิ้ล ปทุมราช - สาวสอง ( มีมี่ของอ้าย ) ft. ตาต้า,ต้องเต [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mqlMjnP08XI/mqdefault.jpg)
We are at the point where melon is defending J cole. True character development
Finally
Lmaooooo
He's seems to be defending J.Cole the person and brand what he represents he's saying he likes what he represents but not necessarily the music the music is not horrible and he does seem to genuinely be passionate about the music even if Fantano doesn't personally love it the effort is deserving of praise not attacking you just saying what I think Melon meant
He's not really defending him, he's just kinda making sense of why people might like him
Only because JID sounds goofy
the fact that Drake is one of the most successful artists ever still baffles me to this day. And dude's not stopping anytime soon
EDIT: Drake is falling off lmao
Saying Drake is the most overrated Artist is the most NPC Fantano fan type take, Drake has 3 great Projects (Take Care, NWTS, IYRT) but has some duds, his influence is massive and Take Care was Genre AND Era Defining. It feels like "Drake bad" or "Drake Overrated" is just the safe option in these Fantano threads, Drake has made Trash, but his Classic Material was game changing, and he has a memorable place in Hip Hop
Drake will forever have the Midas touch and people just get mad at that. He is by far the greatest artist of our generation and will remain a staple in pop/hip-hop
@@no-vk2qe drake is just boring
@@salt7861wow what a well thought out and explained take, what if i just say Kendrick is boring? Jay Z is Boring? beatles are boring? Without explaining and ignoring their obvious qualities and impacts on music
@@no-vk2qeHe doesn't write his own music and he steals other peoples music and if you speak up you will end up like xxxtentacion
Taylor swift is severely over-rated
I agree. She is Falling in Reverse but for tween girls. What do I mean by this? Well, both take perfectly fine genres, remove all likable aspects of them, and replace them with something much worse. I still can’t understand why they are so popular…
she's been in the field for 18 years!! It feels like people only know her now just because of the Eras tour and her recent music and all the buzz, so all her previous era defining work is just forgotten. Its hilarious because she's a staple in the industry. You don't get to put down an OG, come on now! There's an obvious reason for all her fame and HUGE fanbase. You can say you don't like her music or not a fan, but it's pure jealousy/hatred if you don't respect her for where she is today.
If being in the music industry for a long time is your only metric for what is properly rated you need new metrics. Or let’s just say that all of the artists who have been making music for longer than Taylor are underrated
@@herbertmorrison730to deny her talent is just wrong, clearly she is talented and succesful, she is just very popular but that doesn’t mean she sucks
Taylor Swift is talented I will admit. I just don’t like her music that much. Nothing against her, she’s a great singer, I just don’t like the songs that much. I only believe she is a tad bit overrated is because people idolize her, and not in the like fan way. Like WORSHIP her. That’s the only reason I think she’s a bit overrated
Why does this come up when i search MF DOOM? 😡
Because it is not true, the algorithm plays with your own criteria
I got this for King Crimson, so yeah
TH-cam is fucking with us
I got it when searched up John Frusciante lol
because he is. jk
i looked up earl sweatshirt haha
Melon really referred to Nirvana as a "he." Some real "Thom Yorke and the Radioheads" energy.
kurt was the biggest poser, everyone in that band had more talent than him, he's just the face of it, also the commenter was right, when i heard dude say "rawest performances best songwritting of the 90's dude clearly never checked out alice in chains and has no clue what 90's grunge means outside nirvana
@@sp4c3y A poser in his views, he was, always claiming he hated fame yet overshadowed every outstanding grunge musician due to insanely good marketing and promotions, you cannot make it to fame if you do not trully desire it, correct me if i'm wrong but many people in the scene did say kurt wished to be mainstream and it was his dream, to me that comes off as hypocrisy, if you hate fame so much let other people shine that trully wished to be in your place.
@@vintagesonofabOh 100% agree with this. Nirvana buried everyone into obscurity around them on accident by becoming ultra famous. I didn’t grow up in the 90’s (I was born ‘98) but when I used to think of grunge it was always Nirvana. When I got deeper into the scene when I was a teenager I realized Nirvana is good but they’re literally the most skin deep, at least since they’re so overplayed compared to their counterparts.
lol true
@@sp4c3ynirvana was kurt's vision & soul at the end of the day. dave & krist are talented people, but they both have come out and said that most of the nirvana work was kurt's ideas with them two just following his lead (and being happy to do so). many bands are like that. alice in chains, for example, is basically jerry cantrell's vision with the others following his lead (even though layne got most of the attention lol). not to underestimate the importance of the others' instrumentation at all- both sean kinney & dave grohl are two of my favorite drummers of all time- but the person who carries the band on their back absolutely deserves the most credit lol.
You can think coles overrated but INSANELY overrated? Yea def not
Yea…right
Idk man I listened to Forest Hills Drive and didn't really think it was anything special. My brother really likes him and when I asked him what he thought was so good about it all he said was "its just a vibe bro" which is extremely vauge at best. I think im pretty firmly in the overrated category
@@user-ge5qz2rv7hbro if he made Forest Hills Drive 5 times I’d still be a fan lol but respect to Cole
@@bakhtiyarguseinov9402based pfp rip DOOM
@ifthesewallscouldtalktheyp7692 his cause of death was just released yesterday, it was from an a rare reaction to blood pressure medication after being admitted for kidney issues. RIP
Over rated just means you didn’t like as much as other people.
Yeah tbh that’s why I don’t really like to use that term
Bingo. By the definition, if you are a big star you are going to be overrated anyway, as there are many great artists who didn't make it for other reasons, regardless of their talents.
Yeah tbh, I find underrated artists something more interesting to talk about, Although I guess it is still somewhat subjective. I primarily use it for influential artists who don't get as much recognition as (I feel) they deserve for their influence, though.
I don't think it's just that
@@diegogamer2661 It's just that
Boygenius being overrated is crazy
I mean they kind of are when their fanbase praises everything they release as a masterpiece/modern classic.
@@Cheddar_WizardYou’re not sad enough. It’s ok. I have enough depression to share ❤️
They don't even have 5 million monthly listeners 😭😭
I didn't see anything special in their music.
@@tangerinesarebetterthanora7060 woah
J Cole once said don’t listen to the critics who ain’t ever fucking made it
Did it *
that case you should be a certified cook to tell whether the food in a restaurant is good or not?
@@fluerchil6494yeah exactly. I assume Cole meant critics who don’t know how it’s like to live his life but it’s still a dumb thing to say honestly
@@retsell459 Cole meant if you have never made music, how can you judge someone’s properly when you don’t even understand the process or know the common hardships that come with making music.
@@multimediaswamp5169"if you've never worked in a restaurant, how could you properly judge food at all?"
Taylor Swift, at every city she goes to on her eras tour she sells out all the hotels and boosts the cities activity and makes restaurants and hotels more money than an entire other week
I was chilling in a parking garage outside of her stupid Minnesota concert and I got drove out by drunk white girls without tickets 😭😭😭
Insanely overrated. Her albums are so generic
Taylor is overrated and underrated and the same time
@elektra8535 What r u smoking Taylor is the most overrated artist of all time not only r her albums generic, but they all sound the same she does the same thing over n over again
@@elektra8535it’s really weird, she starts to put out great music the moment she is overrated and gets hate, then when she is called underrated she starts to put out utter garbage
Bad Bunny is insanely overrated.
agreed.
“AYUHYUHYUUUHHH” 😩🎶
He is but he has some good ass songs too
Tired of his voice
Any dry and saturated pop artist like Drake or Taylor Swift
I thought for sure Melon was going to say "the thing about J Cole is he went platinum with no features"
he always seems to leave that part out when talking about cole. and people say he isnt a hater😂
Drake for sure. But that is an easy pick lol
He’s not overrated if he’s literally one of the most heavily scrutinized and hated on artists of this generation… imo overrated refers to artists who get unanimous praise while not actually being all that
@@benelbourne3050Drake is the second highest-selling rapper of all time. He may get flack from people because his music is lazy af, but he has outsold almost everyone.
Drake is largely overrated by the average music listener imo, the type that only listens to the hits from playlists and stuff casually. Sometimes though I think people downplay his better projects from like 2011-2015 because they are genuinely quite good. Plus I enjoyed Her Loss overall. He's definitely talented and has the ability to make quality it's just that he doesn't try very hard and pumps out too much music imo. I feel like this is probably a cold take tho
@@benelbourne3050so Taylor Swift isn’t overrated? Lol just stop talking
Wtf yall want him to do😂😂
the most overrated artist it's obviously Carti, it's actually out of mind for me to think that anything carti ever made is even close to decent😭
You probably listen to phonk and shit 💀
@@mehrav___ nah nah, i love hip hop, hes mid af
@@mehrav___Carti is more overrated I rather listen to japanese girl puking on eachother mouth
@@mehrav___the only thing I like about carti is his aesthetic and album art but hes overall overrated and not generally a good person
@@mehrav___carti is ass 😂
Saying J.Cole is average is the wildest thing I think I’ve ever heard
Ikr it's wild
Says cole is overrated and then he goes on to use kendrick to amp his argument.
How ironic. Hes definitely a fantano type fanboy
@@loganlund6801he is 😂. KOD tries to hard to be deep and lyrical. His last record wasn’t good and the one before that was decent. He overall has maybe two or theee decent records the rest are snooze test
@@Usabby1776you're really just describing J Cole here. Nice projection lil bro. Cole is the pinnacle of what a "fake deep" rapper is. That "Foldin Clothes" song where he tries to be introspective, but he just comes off as someone that's not self aware. No adult gets points for folding clothes, the same you don't get points for making your bed in the morning. Then you have the truisms and platitudes "Doing the right thing is so much better than doing the wrong thing" yeah okay? Lmao
@@Usabby1776 that's way too much hate. KOD is his worst album but it ain't that bad. Off season was rlly good. And 4 your eyez only is insane.
Drake
I feel like he used to be but now so many people clown on him 😂
He gets so much hate now that he’s probably underrated now
@@derekcisneros3918you’re insane if you think that
No.
Hes perfectly rated. Hes gets clowned and ragged on. But then drops a song and in a week everybody knows all the words. Drops an album and everybody is listening, every critic is reviewing it.
its low hanging fruit but carti. his producers and engineer's are miracle workers carti is just an image (check replies for outrageous takes)
Not at all, L take
L
W
Carti is not talented he can't rhyme or speak English@@Evr0man
@@Darkstar_Dayne u don’t even listen to his music stfu 😂
Guns n Roses. I mean not that they aren't good but it's how over the top their fans are about them. Like yeah buddy it's a cool riff but we're on minute 5 of hearing it.
And their singer sounds like a baby on crack
Beyonce is WAY OVERRATED
Bro u told not one lie. She’s a great artist though.
It always depends on what you define as "overrated" in your own terms
Experience has to do with it. If you listen to a GOAT from the start, everyone else sounds like a rubber chicken.
Most useless comment ever. 70 likes? Overrated
Right. Every major artist is considered overrated by someone.
Agreed. You can argue most here as overrated
@@SolracCAPSadly, important artists are put on a pedestal, there you have Radiohead
Taylor Swift. heard one song heard them all.
Many of her songs are passable, but songs like 'The Best Day', 'All Too Well', 'The Last Great American Dynasty', and 'Marjorie' are what makes her great in my eyes
A drunken monkey would make a decent song... but he doesn't have the required looks
Nobody cares @@kimi9572
I'm not a huge swift fan but objectively this isn't true. She pivoted from Country to Pop. Criticize her for other stuff, but she definitely has variety.
Well no
Nirvana would be irrelevant today if Kurt didn't take one for the team
completely untrue lmao
@bob-5c I'm as big a fan as anybody, but their music just doesn't hold up today
No one said Taylor Swift? She’s so overrated
The dude with the cole take said some of the most fantano core shit eva
Fr
"no fantano has never said any thing bad about cole. he loves cole. he is just giving criticism" average fantano glazer
ive never had any major issues with cole, but when his fans say that he's top 5 of all time or that he compares to some of the greats it's really off-putting. like, let's be real...
Seen mfs call him better than Wayne, which is just insane
@@vaudevilleE54 some ppl say he top 3 oat
Nah he's top 5. And many in the industry have said that. I swear y'all Fantano clones think these opinions come from thin air😂
@akaInfamous he is not even top 30 and the reason you only see industry people say it most of the time is because it's people who work with him (for the most part). That metric don't mean anything, I've seen carti be called top 5 by a few members of the industry, doesn't mean he is (not that he bad though). Most people in general do not rank cole top 5, it's just weird cole stans doing it. You can't say the same about actual top 5s like Andre 3k and Wayne
@@akaInfamous explain how he is top5? He has no amazing albums, he dont have any depth and is rlly bland. Shit if jid continues to drop 1-2 great albums he is already better than cole. I mean he is already a better rapper skillwise
China, officially the People's Republic of China (PRC),is a country in East Asia. With a population exceeding 1.4 billion, it is the world's second-most populous country after India, representing 17.4% of the world population. China spans the equivalent of five time zones and borders fourteen countries by land. With an area of nearly 9.6 million square kilometers (3,700,000 sq mi), it is the third-largest country by total land area. The country is divided into 33 province-level divisions: 22 provinces, five autonomous regions, four municipalities, and two semi-autonomous special administrative regions. Beijing is the country's capital, while Shanghai is its most populous city by urban area and largest financial center.
A lot of people tend to label popular artists overrated. This is a never ending discussion in part because whether artists are underrated or overrated is highly subjective.
I would say who I think is insanely overrated but I don’t want a bunch of Swifties trying to kill me, we all know what they’re like
😂
taylor swift. i am not scared of them
Many of her songs are passable, but songs like 'The Best Day', 'All Too Well', 'The Last Great American Dynasty', and 'Marjorie' are what makes her great in my eyes
@@kimi9572Nice, thanks for the recs, genuinely. Have never listened to a Swift song, but with recommendations from an appreciator, I'll have some confidence that I'm giving her a fair shot. 👍
Is she? I mean, I’m not a big fan, but the girl became famous writing and performing her own music as a teenager. That alone is impressive. Then she stayed at the top of the charts for two decades. You may not dig her music, but saying that she is overrated is a stretch.
J.cole is my favourite rapper. Whenever i tell people that they start arguing with me like I didnt say he was "the best" just my favourite. There is a difference
You are one of the only J Cole fans that makes that distinction
@@YoungSigmaGrindsetthat’s true lol
Exactly. I always say Kanye is my favorite and Eminem is my number 1 OR Nas. Definitely a difference.
Exactly. I always say Kanye is my favorite and Eminem is my number 1 OR Nas. Definitely a difference.
I am a j.cole fan too, He is a goat but he is not the best of the goats
That guy got a lot of nerve to say Nirvana is overrated
What Nirvana did for music was unprecedented. I guess compared to other bands like Alice In Chains they could seem overrated because i personally like layne more
I thought Nirvana were overrated… Until I started listening to them. One of my favourite bands now.
Exactly. Falling down the rabbit hole of them really made me appreciate them more. Especially some of the stuff that didn't make it to In Utero, like Gallons of Rubbing Alcohol Flow Through The Strip and Oh The Guilt
@@The_Real_ShrimpI will give them a chance too
Nirvana is great, the fans absolutely fucking suck
There really good but still overrated
@@The_Real_Shrimp😮
90% of modern day rappers
Every single Mumble Rapper.
@@shspurs1342what do you consider mumble rappers
Nah
@@parke6704 Don’t you know that there. Is a genre called Mumble Rap.
fantano js doesn’t like J. Cole💀
Ive never liked Kanye. I can acknowledge that he definitely shows creativity in his compostions though.
How can Adele be overrated now? Maybe back with hello when that’s all people knew but she’s proven herself to be the top mainstream female vocalist lol
she was annoying from the beginning
In a world where Adele and Yola don’t have the same notoriety, yes she is
@@JulioLeonFandinho?
Yes. Her music is stale and boring
At what point was "Hello" all people knew from her??? 21 was legit like one of the biggest albums 4 whole years before "Hello" came out. Heck, Even her debut got a fair bit of notoriety 2 years before that. Don't get me wrong, "Hello" is for sure one of her most popular songs, But to act like she wasn't already quite famous when it came out is honestly preposterous.
Saying J Cole is overrated is criminal
It's not, I like Cole but people saying he top 10 are crazy. I think the fact hes still compared to Kendrick is already crazy. Hes good but not as good as his fans make it out to be, pen game is great but musically lacking in his discog.
Bro said ballin like juwanna man in 2019. I’d say he’s trash just for that alone.
He is
@@BoboKoyohow tf is he lacking? he’s got multiple classic albums under his belt
@@BoboKoyohe is top 10, and The Off Season was better than MMATBS
J. Cole is the journey. Kendrick is the destination.
Nirvana are absolutely overrated. That doesn't mean they're bad. I also understand their cultural importance. But they're overrated in the way people are over glorifying their music. It's alright but it's far from amazing.
I think the only like "objective" thing you can say to argue that they are not over rated is that before them the focus of pop rock was glam rock and hair metal and he/they brought something so poppy while being still so punk in ethos that the world kinda just listened and loved them with dropped jaws and then radio and mainstream music totally shifted to grunge and alternative.... (which meant at the time... all kinds of shit like beck, bjork, tori amos, REM and Tool all on the same radio airplay... it was fucking awesome despite that it made no sense haha) ... was it entirely Nirvana that was responsible for that? or Seatle bands in general and the grunge movement? probably not... The origins came from college radio and the popularity of bands like pixies, pavement, my bloody valentine.....but the world of rock had become bloated and egotistical and vapid (whereas Nirvana and most grunge bands were pretty liberal/left/focused less on material things and sex and partying for its own sake) and I think it was just time for a cultural shift.... and so I guess Nirvana gets the focus for all that because it was seriously a world phenomenon, the world before and after Nirvana. But of course its all taste I get there's many who arent moved by them and dont see it that way etc...
Nope there one of the most important and influential bands of all time
@@dillionplm4024 not in the slightest
@@Nichwar19 jajaja great joke
@@dillionplm4024 seriously
Taylor Swift, when your concerts are causing earthquakes you better be curing cancer
Or at least be worth it. Only person to ever reach that scale and have it be totally reasonable was Michael Jackson. Hell even the people who fed into the propaganda against him after he couldn't defend himself still like his music.
Taylor Swift is the most baffling person to ever exist to me. I think she's great, I grew up listening to her music and I think she's an amazing songwriter, but for how popular she is currently I just don't get it. I think there are many many other much better artists that should be more popular than her and make much better music. Is it because she's relatable? I just don't get it. I've never listened to a Taylor Swift album and felt like crying, or thinking it's a legendary album in any way, and I've listened to all of them.
@@jaguwa4816doesn’t she have like a few break up songs or albums or sum? That’s the only thing I can think of in-terms of relatability, but even then they aren’t that REMOTELY good at all to be shaking stadiums or breaking records. Most of her music to me has no replay value whatsoever nor contains anything memorable.
Like you said there are way better artists who deserve to be in her spot.
I think it just comes down to her obnoxious cult of a fanbase who worship her for every small thing she does but she’s nothing special
Taylor Swift is the most underrated artist because a lot of people who love her haven't listened to enough other music to realize that she actually is the best even after listening to thousands of different artists.
@@yxrackman2397 I've figured it out, relatability is a factor but it's a mix of other things. It's because she's like the poster child for a current very feminine pop musician, more relatable than most other artists, more talented (musically) than most other artists in the same genre, and she's a white female. There's nobody else around that could take that position, it's like the Powerpuff girls somebody put the exact right simple ingredients for a superstar for white girls and white gay guys.
She is a pretty good artist talent-wise, maybe 8/10, but the rest of what she is, is what truly makes her as big as she is right now.
The cult/obsessed aspect just comes from people being terminally online and following a hype, with a little bit of the impact her music has had on them mixed in there.
About an 80/20 mix.
I am no longer baffled by Taylor Swift :)
The people saying nirvana is overrated have probably only listened to the radio hits, with bands like nirvana you have to dig into their discography to find the really good shit, don't get me wrong, the more popular tracks are still bangers, but the rarer songs and b-sides are really where you want to look, especially with punk, grunge, and other forms of alternative music, even kurt got tired of hearing smells like teen spirit though
Yeah consistent quality when they were around. I think that has to do with Kurt's passing. Like Tupac and Biggie, thier best work was released before death so we never saw the decline, we have some of their best shit. Shame Kurt started to dislike SLTS, that was a banger.
@acorn9134 fair enough.
All of Bleach is so underrated
I've listened to their entire discography and I still agree with the people saying they're overrated
Nirvana was my favorite band by far when I was 16 and 17, I had all their records, knew plenty of their b sides and was obsessed with it. I would say the same you are saying now, I think Smells like teen spirit is not even in their top 15. I am twice that age and I think they are overrated.
who tf said boygenius is over rated?
Only the person who tweeted it. Nobody else. Boygenius deserves more recognition.
@@RianFender1958real 🙏
@@RianFender1958 AMEN
Right? They're so talented
Me they suck
Adele doesn’t need to be this stellar songwriter for her music to resonate with people though, she just writes and sings
When I was growing up and getting into soundgarden Alice in chains stone temple pilots etc I thought Nirvana was OK but mostly boring and overrated. Wasn't til my late 20s I really appreciated what a genius Cobain was, and grew to like how nasty and abrasive he could be instead of having the "this is just simple punk chords" mentality. Moral ots: sometimes you have to get over yourself.
by any means i still don't see the genius of nirvana, everything they did AIC did better, nirvana does sound more raw but is it trully a good thing? to me it just sounds more unpolished, the lyrics sound more tryhard and pretentious. At 20 and 40 i can still clearly understand and aknowledge the lyrics of any AIC song given how geniune they feel, nirvana sounds like teenage angst these days.
@@vintagesonofab AiC lyrics are more tangible and straightforward by comparison, Kurt could get really cryptic and symbolic which I think is harder to appreciate at first but I think it's aged brilliantly. I can't deny it comes off pretentious and I can understand how thatd be offputting but I think it's earned pretense. He backed it up.
@@vintagesonofab I think both bands are pretty different to say they were trying to do the same thing.
@@jayr.3720 The thing is, sometimes Kurt would say some of his lyrics didn't really make sense. They sound hella cool, which is OK, nothing wrong with putting words that sound cool together. At the end, people is going to find so meaning to it.
I was the opposite, my favorite band was Nirvana but then I started appreciated other grunge bands, right now I prefer AiC.
@@vintagesonofab not Alice but everything Nirvana did to make them relevant, Pixies had already done (Alice was more metal so I don’t compare them to the other grunge acts aside from Soundgarden, myself).
His influence on the band even came from Pixie songs to where up until after Nevermind, you could find a Pixie vibe on everything they did
DJ Khaled😂 I already know I’m gonna get this for this one
His expectation is to have the best music as in his slogan but if we’re being honest, does he really have the best music😂
@@Bones-hates_you.
Nah. He does not have the best music. And when he does have a good instrumental, he ruins it by speaking nonsense over it. Stfu Khaled.
Nah you aint getting no hate bro dj khaled is epitome of bs
Guns N Roses for me. Welcome To The Jungle and Paradise City are songs that get old and have not stood the test of time, IMO. Rose's voice is something that wears on you every time you listen and gets worse with age. They have 3 good songs - Sweet Child of Mine, November Rain and Live and Let Die, which of course is a Paul McCartney song.
Damn, you just made do some serious reflecting.. But technically Live and Let Die is a “Wings” song
Yeah maybe. Didnt help their own cause either. Turned into a trainwreck.
I live in a world where people say "J cole is overrated" or "TPAB is overrated", and in the same breath say "Playboi Carti is one of the best artists of our generation"
Absolutely Mind Fucking
Carti is the greatest artist of our generation
taylor swift is the obvious answer
Saying she's overrated then is acceptable, but saying she's overrated now isn't really true. A lot of her latest albums just doesn't reach as many views/stream as her previous work. Of course, excluding her shows and all, I'm just talking about streaming and views only
@@oksure5963numbers don’t mean jack when swifties double by the day and put her on a pedestal like she’s the God of Autotune
Just because someone is really popular, that doesn't mean they're overrated.
@@WoahLookAtThatFreak it does when they get way too much attention for their mediocre music
@@WoahLookAtThatFreak that is a true fact that i am already aware of. my answer still stands
every nirvana song slaps. end of story.
edit: i think kurt is one of the greatest lyricists of all time and nirvana was one of the most influential and unique bands in rock. are they the best instrumentalists? no. is kurt the best vocalist technically speaking? no. music does not have to be perfect to be amazing.
edit of an edit: this is my opinion.
Not really. They were good, though. But still insanely overrated, seeing as Kurt Cobain is frequently ranked as one of the greatest vocalists *and* guitarists of all time (he was neither).
@@ericforsythHe definitely had one of the greatest voices in rock, but as a guitarist he was nothing too great I will admit
@@ericforsythaverage note salad enjoyer. Just because he didn’t squeeze 200 notes into each measure doesn’t mean he was a bad guitarist. The riffs he wrote were extremely simple and catchy as hell but they had a layer of nuance to them. Kurt had an excellent ear.
@@1steeeezyeah but greatest? Nah
@@1steeeez: Note salad enjoyer? Lmao, my favourite guitarist is Peter Green. Kurt is an overrated guitarist. Writing a few catchy (and mostly unoriginal or straight up ripped off) riffs doesn't change that.
How could someone put Nirvana that just blows my mind like a literal shotgun to my mouth in my loft above the garage
I’m sorry everyone always says it’s incorrect and I am wrong. But the first person that comes to my mind is always Beyoncé. She’s really good. But she is no where near the top female vocalist now or of all time. She just isn’t. Nina Simone has that crown
I think people say J Cole is overrated because most of his fans defend his music by just saying “he’s too deep for you, you just don’t understand it” and it rubs people the wrong way. Strictly from a rapping and song writing perspective, he is objectively top three of this generation, if not tied for first with Kendrick. Plus I think most people who say that are young and only listened to KOD and maybe a few songs from Forest Hills
Most people who say that only like hype rap tracks. They probably only like Kendrick because he made Alright and HUMBLE, which in hindsight are hype songs
tied with kendrick 💀💀💀💀
@@Ethan-ez2tiinsane
Too deep? Wet dreamz is straight up a song about a highschooler having sex in detail.
@@joshfrey6315have you listen to 4yeo then, it's deep asf ? Or are you one of the hater like everyone else that don't know sheyt bout an artist then start bashing them
I think j cole is a bit overrated his albums aren’t the most mind blowing pieces of work but the things that really help his case as a great artist are his features,production, and work with Dreamville and ROTD he’s done a bunch of great features including some that could be talked about as the best in the past decade and he does a lot with production on tracks and ROTD. Is he the goat as people say no. But is he a very good artist that could elevate if he builds off the “The Off-season” with upcoming projects, I believe so.
The fact that you are indirectly saying The off season is his best work, shows you don't know anything.
2014 Forest hill drive is still his best work till date
@@user-qx9zs1zr6i if anything it’s the opposite way around you trying to say I don’t know anything about j cole because I enjoy an album more than another. Music is subjective and people have different opinions that’s what makes it beautiful plus guys like fantano and NFR argue that the off-season is his best. Also I think 4YEO is his best album not the off-season
so your a fantano clone. that is exactly what fantano says. " the off season is his best"
"you're just not sad enough" is so true
The fact that ppl think J.Cole is worse than Tyler the creator is a wild take
If you’re saying Kurt Cobain is one of the greatest singer songwriters of his generation you have lost your mind bro. Layne Staley, Eddie V, Chris Cornell, and Shannon Hoon just to name a few were far better than him
Yes Chris and Kurt are the only names people readily recognize
Drake is overrated rubish, I literally fell asleep to Search & Rescue
We went from the "DAMN BOI HE’S SICK… BOIIIII" from a man defending good artists. What a glow up ma dude, you earned it
I gotta be honest kendrick is becoming severely overrated
Ed Sheeran is the correct answer
Who is overrating Ed Sheeran other than 40 year old moms
He's a decent songwriter.
@@axelbruv he certainly has a broad appeal im glad you like him
@@blaghgames5050 you’d be surprised
critica hate his work so i guess partly overrated? also his latest project doesnt do well lol
Drake, it's just Drake
Get your lab made i saw on twitter people dindt like it so i dont like it looking ass clb was good and hn was good too
@@jenske2881aight bro u js trippin horrendously, clb and hnvm are not great in any form
@@jaycyclondoi deadass enjoy honestly nevermind bro, liability is my favorite song across all genres currently, and I listed to ALOT of genres and music, that song activates some dif emotions bro u gotta listen
@jenske2881 Honestly, nevermind is the definition of mid for me
not even mid just not good
@@officialdvsthomas
Being a good performer doesnt make u good or bad just makes your performance good or bad
This kind of questions requires categories. Cause who general public vs critics overrate is very different.
Overrated by general public: Maroon 5, they have one good song in a decade-plus of making music.
By music critics: Beyonce. Good artist with some catchy hits, but the only truly elite talent she has is as a performer. Throw on a Beyonce record and I can guaranteed names better vocalists, songwriters, producers, etc.
By Music fans (/RYM): Radiohead. Great band, like a legitimately elite band. Do they have three of the top-15 albums of all-time? No. I’d argue none of their big three is even top-50 albums of all-time.
Knowing that Doug’s mom is a real doctor I’d imagine seeing her reaction to this
Who is Doug
@@Griimmyyy wait wtf why was this posted on this video. I posted this comment on DougDoug’s channel but it was posted here lmao
@@katchereyethis is way funnier than it should be
I somehow KNEW you were talking about dougdoug!
Taylor Swift, nobody even comes close to her in terms of being overrated.
Ariana Grande IMO is neck and neck with Swift.
@@MidnaTTP no way, at least Ariana's face is not punchable af.
I know I'm late, but I maintain that AC/DC is the most OKAY band ever. Maybe they made genre definining hits at the time, but the more time passes, the more I realize they just scratched rhe surface of rock, and the video comparing 1950's olympic gymnastics vs. this years performance is super similar. We've come so far, and the Eagles and Led Zepellin are still timeless.
Juice is the most overrated, the tiktok kids call him the goat, when he was just fine
Did you hear the Just Lose It freestyle? That was crazy
ever seen his freestyles?
As a juice fan i gotta tell you these kids on titkok tryna get clout off of his death is annnoying, same goes for x. But honestly Juice isn't that bad as a rapper i mean some of the released songs are bad, but the unreleased ones.. theyre the good ones you can pretty much find all od them on YT theres like about a thousand of them
Bad Bunny
Criminally overrated
No…
Definitely. Idk how it is in the US but in my country his music was omnipresent during the past two or three years. Not that much during the last months fortunately. He has some decent even enjoyable songs but most of them are annoying as hell.
Bad Bunny fills a niche for club music for sad boys, that's why he's popular even in English-speaking countries
He ruins every music he is in
Drake is soooo overrated
The guy is a basic artist and has been making the same album since 2017
Ppl tend to think that streams=good music
That's just wrong, "same album since 2017". I'm not even a big drake fan but they have each been wildly different. I mean cmon his last two releases was literally a trash house record and an ok dark trap 21 savage collab. They were way different from eachother
@@vaudevilleE54both of which were extremely mediocre. Honestly nevermind being outright bad
@@mr.dirtydan3338 doesn't change what dey said
couldnt have said it better
@@Sourcing590 really? You couldn't have? 😂
I googled Neutral Milk Hotel and this came up. I am extremely disappointed you are not telling me NMH is completely overrated, because they were and are.
Ngl i still think nirvana is overrated, that’s not saying they’re bad but i think when comparing them to other grunge bands like soundgarden or Alice In Chains I think those bands come out on top. Both Layne and Chris have absurd chops, not to mention Alice In Chains’ intensity can’t really be beat for grunge. Especially on songs like Them Bones, God Smack and Man in the Box. I like nirvana especially for their chemistry, Dave grohl’s drumming and the fact they’re more approachable than the other grunge bands, but I still think soundgarden and AIC are the better bands
Honestly, I don't dislike Alice in Chains, But I do feel like "Man In The Box" is really overrated. The vocals and chorus are quite good, But it has genuinely one of the most annoying guitar riffs I've heard. I'd probably take any Nirvana song I know over that one.
Nirvana is up there with the Beatles where, if you like them or not, their influence was massive and has shaped music even today
Nirvana in no way shape or form has shaped music of today, neither did the Beatles.They weren't first in their genras nor the best in them.
@@6DarthSion9not the first in their genres, so what? Both of them were the first in their genres to create a cultural explosion in music and the shape of music to come afterwards. Without the Beatles, the rock scene in the 60s would have never reached the heights that it did. Without nirvana, grunge would have remained an underground heavy genre and wouldn’t have made the insane impact that it did on music afterwards.
Kurt Cobain was a terrible musician. He was an absolutely brilliant song writer. Just because Nirvana's songs weren't technical doesn't mean they were overrated. Also, their influence on an entire generation is immeasurable. Curt Cobain and Nirvana had a huge hand in killing the Sunset Strip hair metal scene.
Lil Uzi Squirt
Holy cold take
MOST overrated?
He’s not overrated he’s like top 5 in his sub genre
For this Chop suey "cover" he should be persecuted for committing this atrocity
not overrated, he has some duds but is not overrated
I do think J. Cole is overrated. But I respect him. You can tell people like Kendrick, Big, and Nas has the "gift". Something raw and magnetic that couldn't be replicated. Cole is a hard work and master of the craft. He figure out the codes and became equipped. I wasn't always a fan, but I appreciate his work ethic.
kendrick doesnt have the gift but sure
J cole is one of the greatest of all time in my opinion
Its not that Nirvana is over rated but now the name is Iconic to the point where people who are not even actual fans of not just the band but the genre of music it wear shirts with Nirvana stuff.
I love the bleach album, probably my favorite album
Nirvana is way to played out.
Like Blond Redhead " for the damaged coda"
Rick and morty played that song out to the point i dont even enjoy listening to it anymore
What’s with the Cole hate?
no hate. he just overrated
His fans aren't the brightest
@@Python-xs2iv you mean Coles or Anthonys? But i agree on both lol
@@tupla1122 Coles
*someone makes a completely fair & constructive argument on why an artist is overrated*
“What’s up with the [artist] hate?”
White woman rage is such a strong music genre
Black on black crime is booming genre right now 😮
@@nodruj8681and so is white on white crime
@@nodruj8681 it's funny how y'all love to keep us in y'all mouths but haven't done shit for any community let along yourself get well soon God 😂
@@Kiah_.0so the benefits y’all get from your government isn’t worth anything?
@@mika-yy7gkIf you hate that so much, start running for congress bud.
J.cole is definitely one of the greatest of all time. FACTS
Taylor swift is not overrated
She’s a goddamn cult leader
Boy I sure do love Mr Nirvana
Bro Fantano we aren’t saying that those artists are bad, we just don’t think they are up to the hype given to them.
Ed Sheeran. Why won't people shut up about him?
Adele isn't overrated, but she's out of touch. She needs to stop thinking that her job is as hard as a McDonald's cashier or a parent of four. She's got her bag. Quit if you're overworked.
Drake. I really tried to give his music a chance, I wanted to like it because he has so much music I was excited to get into it, but I just can’t get over his delivery, it’s so cringey and it ruins his songs. Nothing special from the production either, it’s not the worst music I’ve ever heard, it’s just mid and I wish I liked it more because he consistent puts out music unlike many other artists I like. I don’t understand why he’s ever in the goat conversation, and I’m not just saying that because I don’t personally like his music, it just makes no sense even if you are a huge drake fan you can’t deny that he has misses and utterly horrible songs, even entire projects that are unlistenable. He can’t possibly even be in the conversation just based off of that, and me personally wouldn’t even have him in the top 100 let alone in the goat conversation
Yeah, I never try to dislike an artist's work and I feel as though there are a lot of listeners (especially Fantano fans) out there who actively try to hate Drake in particular, but personally I've tried to listen to a lot of his albums and the only one I find myself clicking with is Nothing Was The Same, but only an "I mildly enjoy this" type of clicking.
Speculation here, but I feel as though a lot of people who refer to Drake as their GOAT must have connected with his music when they played it during a point in their life which is now really nostalgic to them, for example during their last year of high school
Damn yall ass wrote a whole essay bout the nigga😂😂
I like how you actually give an honest and intelligent answer rather than just saying OVERRATED, UNDERRATED for clicks/views… like, 90% of people in your field woulda said j cole was overrated just to stir up controversy
One day someone said to me “I don’t like Adele. She pushes so hard it doesn’t even sound genuine, it just sounds like she’s trying to be loud and obnoxious” and ever since then I can’t un- hear it.
"cole doesnt get any hate... but hes a mid artist and doesnt compare to any top 50 rappers"
- every other comment in the comment section
yes some of the cole fans are a little over the top but thats how fans get, especially when their favorite artist gets a lot of praise from GOATs but hate from the usually uneducated community.
cole has one album that has to be considered a classic just based on the numbers and effect it had and 2 that depending on your taste in music are easy locks for classics
@@kshurnsb1 4yeo and 2014 fhd are fs classics and maybe born sinner depending on who your asking
@@kshurnsb1 nas said that j cole didnt let him down and cole is one of his favorite artists
@@kshurnsb1 to many people dont listen to the albums and just say what ever they think will make them look cool
Sorry swifties but it's Taylor Swift
Saying “Nirvana is overrated” is such a basic ass opinion
It is tho😂
Saying Nirvana is the greatest band ever means you haven’t listened to Nirvana besides Smells Like Teen Spirit, and saying Nirvana is overrated means you haven’t listened to Nirvana besides Smells Like Teen Spirit
@@kraken_8 trust me lil bro, I’ve listened to PLENTY of Nirvana and I acknowledge that they take way too much light from other BETTER bands such as Alice In Chains or soundgraden
@@sirjeffthethird269dawg, nirvana is underrated, it's only seen as a clothing brand and Teen spirit nowadays,people don't look at the other titles besides come as you are and something in the way maybe.
@@sirjeffthethird269”Alice in Chains or “Soundgarden” interesting…. How would you describe this “BETTER?” I understand the word and equally understand the element of opinion but it appears you are suggesting something more than that here?
woah Fantano being positive is actually watchable
Regarding Nirvana: They singlehandedly killed an entire genre of music.
MTV was playing nothing but Guns n Roses, Bon Jovi, Van Halen, etc. and then “Smells Like Teen Spirit” came out. You never heard from any of those bands again.
That’s how good Nirvana was.
Anybody who gets too much love for anything is gonna be considered “overrated”. No matter the talent level, people don’t like to see artists at the top 🤷🏽♀️ “you’re not really great until u have haters”
Jack Harlow, Lil Baby, Yeat, all of opium. X, (tentacion not DMX), Dare I say Don Toliver.
It’s not even that it’s not my style of music cause I really like Future. I just think all of them are glazed to no end when they really don’t have a lot to offer.
Oh and also Will Wood. I just do NOT fw that guy.
The bald J Cole hater strikes back
The Cole slander is rough
Taylor swift is definitely overrated
calling nirvana overrated is crazy work