did u know the reason he licked his lips was because the prosthetics for the scar on his lip kept peeling off, so he licked it so he wouldn’t have to keep getting it re glued, and then slowly it just became apart of the character
I'd pay Mark Hamill and Kevin Conroy to replicate the interrogation scene from The Dark Knight. Update: Thank you Kevin Conroy for decades of joy and entertainment as the caped crusader.
Hammill's portrayal works because its focused on the eccentric joker in the comics. Ledgers works because all of the eccentric over the top bits were strippes away just leaving charisma and psychosis. Leto's doesn't work because they tried to combine those two things and it made the character weak as it tried to straddle to very different worlds.
Heath made his portrayal of The Joker his own. It was great because it was different. It was more of a "if The Joker were a real person" adaptation of the him. But Hamill's voice captures the personality from the comics the best and that's the one I'll always prefer. I don't see why there has to be a rivalry between the 2. Both are perfect in their own way.
Heath Ledger did it great for making it his own. That's the only thing I loved in the Dark Knight Trilogy. I didn't like Baan Begins or The Dark Knight Rises. just The Dark Knight.
I think there hasn't been a bad Joker, all of them are great, from live action actors to voice actors, all of them have done a great job in their own version of the character.
TPDManiacXC626 I hear Hamil's Joker in those lines. He starts off gleeful as if he's experiencing an epiphany. Then the last line is slow dark and methodical with him showing his trademarked grin at the end
I watched the Superman side to side with Batman every day after school as a kid. It's hard not to smile. Catwoman and Harley Quinn were my role models, not because they are criminals, but because Harley is so free and Catwoman is so self sustaining.
@@Taliesyn42 And that's not what the Joker is supposed to be. He doesn't kill people for fun, he kills people to show the world what a joke it is. Or is that the same thing? Maybe that is what the Joker is supposed to be and that line from the Three Jokers is another shit taken on the Joker's legacy.
The current voice of the joker Troy Baker he still young n sounds almost exactly like Mark but a younger version, look up Troy Baker Joker n watch the video where he reads the killing joke monologue
SuperBabyMario0C I've seen that video, and I own Arkham Origins. And I have to say... he NAILED it as the Joker! Plus I also think he's a really talented voice actor in his other works like Sergeant Matt Baker in Brothers in Arms, Arkham City where he voices Two Face and Tim Drake/Robin and Joel in The Last of Us.
Peter Parker Recycle Bin thank you.. I’m getting so sick of people saying Mark Hamill is the best in the line up with all the other people who’ve played the joker in live action movies. Doesn’t make any sense to me.
With only three words, Mark Hamill demonstrates why he was so effective as The Joker: The aggressive sharpness on the word "why", the aristocratic sound of the vowel in "so", followed by the playful and genuinely curious inflection on "serious?" encapsulate everything that makes his interpretation of The Joker so memorable. He didn't have to think about the delivery, it intuitively sprung from his deep familiarity with the character, and in a couple seconds he embodied a demented genius that takes great joy in his evil, and knows that he's probably smarter than you are. Fucking brilliant. Thank you Mark Hamill.
Now with all the isolation and how fucked up things got after the ewok party you gotta wonder if specs of madness (preferably Brand J) would show up in the new star wars saga version of mark hamill >..
Hamill helped make the Joker great. It's the great actors and storytellers that make the character great. The character alone is garbage. Think about it; a clown that kills. It's super cliche. But the people who poured their lives and careers into Batman and his villains really elevated Joker to cultural icon status.
Mark Hamil is the best Joker, if you only judge them by the voice. Both Niccolosons and Ledger get higher approval from me because they just acted so well, but Hamil and Conroy have, in my mind, the prestigious distinction of being the only 2 voice actors who do their role SO WELL, that they hold up to the live action versions. It amazes me that Hamil, just as an off the cuff joke, does 3 words, and sends fangasms through every person listening. Lets put it like this. Everything a casual fan associates with the Joker is Hamil's. When I asked all my friends to do a Joker laugh, all of theirs resembled the one Hamil did. The Batssss with the extreme emphasis on the s, all of the things that have become integral to the Jokers vocal identity. Also, Hamils Joker in the Arkham games has the additional distinction of a role so effectively portrayed, it is cinema quality. Hamid is and will always be my favorite Joker
Joshua Gill Mark Hamil was the best animated joker but Heath is the best live action joker and its practically impossible to say one is better than the other given that Hamil portrays the comic joker better while Heath was better at portraying the darker version of joker.
Hes a good voice actor but by far the worst person to play the Joker. So far hes the only actor to play the Joker one time before they stopped using him.
Mark: (provides a thoughtful, passionate, and thoroughly well-put answer to a completely botched question) Him: i was just hoping you'd say "why so serious?" Me: (facepalm) WHY DIDNT YOU JUST SAY THAT?!
Mark Hamill, unsurprisingly, nailed why Heath's Joker was so damn unique but so damn good. The one word he used to describe it in particular, "joyless". I never realized it but that's why he was so good. The Joker, simply by name, makes one expect someone full of joy and humor, but in the Dark Knight, while he had a sense of humor, there was no joy left in him. He was clearly just a man, as opposed to other Jokers, who seem like they aren't really part of the human species.
TPDManiacXC626 Troy Baker does an excellent job and is a damn fine voice actor in general... but I don't like his laugh as much as I do Hamill's. It's what defines the Joker in my opinion, but my opinion is just an opinion.
laz kar Very true. I wonder how sore Hamill's voice must be after talking and laughing like that for almost twenty years of acting. Still, I hope that Baker has a good run as the new Joker, he does a bang-up job that makes the Clown Prince of Crime come to life. His performance in Assault on Arkham was particularly great in my opinion.
Ledger: Why so serious? Hamill: Do we look serious? (Starts laughing) Romero: (laughs with hamill) Nicholson: (laughing at completely other joke he just thought of) Baker: (smiles 'til it hurts) DiMaggio: (silent laugh and red face) Monaghan: (torn between two punchlines) Phoenix: (starts dancing) Leto: (wasn't invited)
You guys are a little harsh on the guy. I mean cmon, I know it's youtube but fuck. have some compassion. The guy was obviously very nervous. Any one of you could of messed up just like he did. Standing in front of 200+ people AND Mark Hamil, a legend in the business, isn't exactly the easiest of feats.
but he really couldn't have done worse. No one's knocking him for being nervous or fucking up, it's how badly he fucked up that people are making fun of and rightfully so. Bitch.
Wow mad props and what a class act Hamill is. He could feel threatened by someone else's Joker but instead takes the time to praise it. That there, ladies and gentlemen, is a class act and a man confident in his work.
Among fans, there tends to be a lot of "competition" or argumentation about why someone is better than someone else. In contrast, I really loved seeing Hamill show such respect for Ledger. I, personally, found both to be tremendous, iconic performances, and I prefer to avoid arguments about who is "better".
The way Mark answered that tasteless question (considering how recent Heath's death was at that point) was SO warm, reverent and full of respect. A decent and professional man, Mr Hamill is. :)
Asking that question was very brave as the room could’ve turned on him, real hard but the minute Mark actually did “why so serious” I lost it! so good! so iconic!
The fact that he thought about it for a second, realized it's what the fans wanted and delivered the line; just to put a smile on everyone's face, is why he's the GOAT.
What a classy guy and great performer?! Just gives the people what they want on the spot, that's true showmanship. Thoughtful stuff about Ledger as well. Mark Hamill just became a little cooler in my mind, which I didn't think was possible.
I wonder ehat kind of roled Mr Hamill would have taken had he not sustained an injury. It's weird that he couldn't even find roles that had few physical specifications or didn't require good looks. He's a very good actor. It's just so sad he's not in more movies.
omg something just hit me, it would be so hilarious and awesome at the same time if we would like get all the jokers that have been done, sitting at a table and then swap stories, in some parallel universe xD
Wow, the best animated Joker saying the lines of the best live-action Joker is something that I never thought was needed but was definitely deserved. RIP Heath Ledger, the GOAT Joker of live-action Batman films, and Kevin Conroy, the GOAT of animated Batman and the entire DCAU
I liked Hamill's and Ledger's interpretations for different reasons. Mark was amazing at producing an insane comical flirty joker, while Heath provided a serious and realistic take on the joker.
Ledger's why so serious: *Creepy and, Terrorizing Hanill's: Comic book style Both are legends until Joaquin Phoenix joins them... And then Jare- you know what never mind...
Seriously.. Heath ledger had the body movements the look, his own personality to his joker cause he could do that ultimately because it was not a video game or cartoon!
youb tijani you have to be kidding me there is more involved in acting as I just pointed out than there is in just making a voice All you need to do is get your voice to the correct pitch and a little more things and then you practice it and keep at it I never said it was easy, there is still talent that gets out into changing your voice but, Acting if you try and act as the joker and he is ment to be a psychopathic killer, who laughs all the time etc and you put the make up on the voice and act as a gangster, it is not going to be pulled off well is it? Well it may be pulled off depending on the person who does it but he is not a gangster he is a murderous psychopathic clown.
***** Nope! voice acting is an art not just everyday talk. I`ve know Mark as the Joker before even Heath rose to fame. We are talking about the early 90`s. Mark brought the Joker to life, when everybody couldn`t thanks to his twisted laugh & attitude.
The guy who requested it was too nervious, if he hadn't being like that we could have saved a couple seconds, but even if someone says "Mark was just being nice flatterying the people working in the Dark knight", I like his opinion on Heath's take on the Joker.
This man, such a gold heart, such love for his fans and we love him as much. Not many people become such an iconic figure. He never imposes, always wants to know about how we find his plays, and if people knew how hard he tried to save Star Wars from the pool of shit they were headed. Should have listen to the only one Luke Skywalker, a wise master indeed. Thanks to him, the force is with us forever.
It can be seen as a controversial subject. Hamill and Ledger were acting as namely the same character, which can be seen as a competition. But it would be very distasteful to compare them since Ledger can't respond to it. Of course we separate between the two Jokers as completely different characters. So there is no competition.
The guy: Say "why so serious"
The crowd: *D E W I T*
I shouldn't. It is not the Jedi way
@@DistressedDamsel6 Dew it
It's treason, then...
@@MadnessOpus not yet
Congratulations, 10 months later and you have earned your 1 thousandth like
A man who loves his fans. Mark Hamill is the GOAT
Forgotten comment of Star wars theory :(
star wars theory ur a genius, thank you for all the sacrifices you are making to bring us your amazing fan films, we dont deserve you.
Yes he is and so are you dude. Keep striving to make those awesome sw fan films and videos
SWT what’s up!!
A surprise, to be sure, but a welcome one.
Sometimes, I forget that Mark Hamill was Luke Skywalker, because his Joker is just *that* iconic to me.
I just love him as Mark Hamill
@@julus2722 same.
whether he's luke skywalker, adrian ripburger, or joker, mark hamill is just amazing.
William Reely don’t forget he also played Jake Skywalker! Lol
He also was ozai.. remember him??
If Mark Hamill says he liked Ledger’s performance, nobody panics... but if he says “Why so serious?” Well everyone just loses their minds!
Who else said the last line in Heath Ledgers Joker voice in their heads?....
brilliant 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉😂😂😂😂
@@KM_1983
ME!!! 😂
@@KM_1983 I said the whole thing as Heath
I could only hear this in Heath’s voice
I totally agree that Ledger’s tongue clicks were genius, so creepy.
did u know the reason he licked his lips was because the prosthetics for the scar on his lip kept peeling off, so he licked it so he wouldn’t have to keep getting it re glued, and then slowly it just became apart of the character
treyway 69 lol Are you up watching joker clips too ?
B P no it was the prosthetic I’m pretty sure
It’s not genius, the Joker does not have tongue clicking or any other strange mannerisms other than laughing.
chefmarcos this is like a new take on joker
I'd pay Mark Hamill and Kevin Conroy to replicate the interrogation scene from The Dark Knight.
Update: Thank you Kevin Conroy for decades of joy and entertainment as the caped crusader.
That'd be pretty sick.
How about "how about a magic trick?"
I know Kevin Conroy has a cameo maybe someone could pay him to do that.
*pictures Kevin Conroy beating the absolute shit out of Mark Hamill*
I actually don't want that
Connor Boyle Not necessarily live acting, just the voices at least. 😅😆
what a fan pleaser this guy is
+Jess Bradley He really is; and he replies to fans on his Twitter all the time.
Jess Bradley 777 likes
that is a good thing, in this case
A man who asked him to pose for a photo once described him as "a fuckin' G".
More like "a fucking legend"
Mark Hamill: Well spoken and thought provoking acknowledgement of Heath Ledger's performance.
Every single fucking fan: No. Say the thing.
he didn't even say the one i thought he would xD
"Do the roar." 😐
Say the line, Bart.
@@SpaceMissile I instantly knew that was from Shrek it was ingrained in my head
@@Deathstroke-bs8gx memes are crazy like that 😅
His "Why so serious" gave me goosebumps!!!
***** that girl was me.
+Rafaellm ok l Artiga You are a guy tho.
+mariano Nicolas LOL
+Edward Nigma I squealed when he said it. :D
Edward Nigma Same here?
Marks voice is way scarier he sounds genuinely happy that he's about to kill you like it's a joke.
That Random Artist I can't decide if that's the worst or best pun ever
Hoodini 😂😂😂
THE KILLING JOKE?! ba da ba crash
@Hoodini damn. too late
@Hoodini Ayyyy
If Heath Ledger were still around, Hamill and Nicholson could have a little Joker get together and stage it as a nod to the comics having 3 Jokers.
I would agree on that. But if any of them decides to retire, then invite Cameron Monaghan to the list.
Joaquin Phoenix could make this happen
Were
jared leto the best joker
And now the comics out 😭 would be perfect man
I love how Mark is such a nerd, just a total fanboy
I know you should search a picture of his house. He had a room of comic stuff and it is amazing
I imagine Mark Hamill dressed as Joker appearing at people's birthday parties and saying "Happy Birthday... ya son of a b***h!!"
I wouldn't pay more than fifty dollars
I would pay all my money for that!
I remember my first $20 dollar bill
Bet the Joker told you to kill me after we loaded the cash.
I would pay an excessive amount of money if he came to my party
When you get a major thumbs up from the king of joker voice acting himself, you know you've done a damn fine job.
Not really. That Joker is overrated.
Yeah just like your opinion, Mark hammill is the goat
@@ChristianProtossDragoon yeah sure and Leto was underrated
I love Mark Hamill but like dude... Heath Ledger’s joker is so much better
Hammill's portrayal works because its focused on the eccentric joker in the comics. Ledgers works because all of the eccentric over the top bits were strippes away just leaving charisma and psychosis. Leto's doesn't work because they tried to combine those two things and it made the character weak as it tried to straddle to very different worlds.
The guy's brain: _"Say interpret"_
Also his brain: _"No, no, say imitate"_
His mouth: *"Interpretate"*
Mark Hamill was twisting his thoughts with the force
So pleased someone else caught that! Funny slip of the tongue!
My Slovenian partner says "interpretate" 😁
@@silkoth69 somehow I think it’s possible he thinks it’s an actual word, like people who say “conversate”.
Wait interpretate isn’t a word?
“And you didn’t disappoint.”
“You let 5 people die....laughing”
You made 5 people laugh
Then you let Dent take your place
@@JorgeHerrera-sp4lh even to a guy like me thats cold.
When will you learn!? You’re all garbage who comment for likes
Heath made his portrayal of The Joker his own. It was great because it was different. It was more of a "if The Joker were a real person" adaptation of the him. But Hamill's voice captures the personality from the comics the best and that's the one I'll always prefer. I don't see why there has to be a rivalry between the 2. Both are perfect in their own way.
+Austin Pitts That was the point Mark Hamill was trying to make.
Yeah all the Jokers get compared with eachother and lots of trash talk like they are all relevant in their own worlds.
Yeah Heath's was a perfect live action Joker and Hamill is a perfect Animation/game Joker
Heath Ledger did it great for making it his own. That's the only thing I loved in the Dark Knight Trilogy. I didn't like Baan Begins or The Dark Knight Rises. just The Dark Knight.
I think there hasn't been a bad Joker, all of them are great, from live action actors to voice actors, all of them have done a great job in their own version of the character.
I'd love to hear mark hamill recite the interrogation scene
I don't wanna kill you Bats! Not for reals! What would I possibly do without you? Go back to ripping off those idiots?! No, you... complete me.
TPDManiacXC626 I just imagined him saying that, needless to say it was awesome
TPDManiacXC626 I hear Hamil's Joker in those lines. He starts off gleeful as if he's experiencing an epiphany. Then the last line is slow dark and methodical with him showing his trademarked grin at the end
TPDManiacXC626 Holy crap! It's almost impossible NOT to read that in Mark Hamill's voice!
TPDManiacXC626 "Ripping off the mob"
I can't help but smile
Me too! he just puts a smile into your face ;)
Lets put a smiiile on that face!
excactly, that was the Joke...
I watched the Superman side to side with Batman every day after school as a kid. It's hard not to smile. Catwoman and Harley Quinn were my role models, not because they are criminals, but because Harley is so free and Catwoman is so self sustaining.
Fancy seeing you here.
I actually find his Joker to be more scary because he sucks you in with his charisma and you don't expect a psychopath to be so fun.
true, its that british accent mark throws in his joker makes it sound so villainy
Hamill's Joker is a funny guy who kills people. Ledger's joker is a guy who thinks it's funny to kill people.
@@Taliesyn42 Hamill's Joker rolls with the chaos while Heath Ledger's Joker is the chaos
@@Taliesyn42 And that's not what the Joker is supposed to be. He doesn't kill people for fun, he kills people to show the world what a joke it is. Or is that the same thing?
Maybe that is what the Joker is supposed to be and that line from the Three Jokers is another shit taken on the Joker's legacy.
@@bptnmrphy3991 I don't agree with that.
Heath Ledger AND Mark Hamill are both perfect as the Joker.
Now if only we can get an actor that has Leger's physique and serious attitude with Hamill's voice and frivolous craziness!
TPDManiacXC626 Probably won't find someone like that 10-25 years later after Hollywood stops making Batman movies again.
The current voice of the joker Troy Baker he still young n sounds almost exactly like Mark but a younger version, look up Troy Baker Joker n watch the video where he reads the killing joke monologue
SuperBabyMario0C I've seen that video, and I own Arkham Origins. And I have to say... he NAILED it as the Joker! Plus I also think he's a really talented voice actor in his other works like Sergeant Matt Baker in Brothers in Arms, Arkham City where he voices Two Face and Tim Drake/Robin and Joel in The Last of Us.
Joe Tufano
Don't forget Frank Archer from Fullmetal Alchemist, Excalibur from Soul Eater, Jin Karia from Bleach, and Yahiko/Tendo Pain from Naruto.
lol the guy that asked that question climaxed when he actually did it
Anybody would
His buddy was recording it. I can't find it, but it was here on TH-cam at one point
@@TomLuTon what a jackass,Mark obviously tried to change the subject because he didn't feel like doing it. Hint not taken I guess.
you didn't?
as did i xD haha
Best Joker actor: Heath Ledger and Joaquin Phoenix
Best Joker voice actor: Mark Hamill
Peter Parker Recycle Bin thank you.. I’m getting so sick of people saying Mark Hamill is the best in the line up with all the other people who’ve played the joker in live action movies. Doesn’t make any sense to me.
No only Heath Ledger
Chase Potter then you’re either a fucking idiot or too young to know the greatness of Mark Hamill’s Joker.
@@VLE-Grimace how do you compare someone who only does the voice with someone who has to act like the character themselves
you acting like there are so many voice actors for joker lol no duh captain dumb ass
Mark is still favourite legendary Joker's voice.
We Have To Go Back well maybe not forever
His voice is what brought that character to life.
1:40 is what you’re looking for
Why skip this wholesome praise?
Vokena Read the title
I o u
Goat
its ok i can wait.
That actually was...pretty funny.
Also, Jared Leto's joker didn't kill me. He just disappointed me really, really, bad.
Ditto.
Geoffrey Sorkin Suicide Squad was fucking horrendous.
Lelouch Britannia They were not whelmed...not whelmed at all
blame David Ayer
Geoffrey Sorkin I understood both of those references
1:40- With that one line, Mark just made Heath Ledger's spirit blush. 👏
The great thing about Mark is that despite being such a influential, legendary actor with tons of talent, he remains humble.
And it's genuine too. Mark is just so down to earth and truly loves us fans.
Indeed
@@cathyskywalker77 here I thought Mark was born at Polis Massa and live a good part of his life on Tatooine… was I wrong ??
I've got another question.
Why does hearing this always plaster a huge smile on my face?
Because he's the Motherfucking Joker.
You got the Goddamned Batman and the Motherfucking Joker.
redtail
Well put.
well, the joker always knows how to put a SMILE on that face.
Jay Nicks And as his plastic surgeon always said,"If you gotta go, go with a smile!"
The Creeper Sad that Harvey Dent's plastic surgeon didn't say that to him.
Ba dum tsss!
Mark Hamill you the man!
Mikeius Official Δεν περίμενα να σε δω εδώ. Fan btw
Mikeius Official Κάνε μπραφ μωρή.
Θέλουμε ερώτηση από Μιχάλη στο comic con του Λονδίνου σε τέτοιους καλή τέχνες
Μιχάλη στο μέλλον θα έχεις ενα σόου που θα λέγεται wtf
Οπ,ο mikeius
I never realized how much I wanted to see/hear Mark Hamill's Joker say "Why So Serious?" until I saw this.
Search TH-cam for "Why so serious Mark Hamill impression animated". It's a pretty spot-on impression.
Couldn’t hear one word because of the hysterical yelling and clapping,
Aarogance Alright, when is the next time?
r juttemeijer
10 months in.
Location of ‘Next Time’: UNKNOWN
I bet if you were there you'd have been one of those hysterically yelling and clapping 😂
With only three words, Mark Hamill demonstrates why he was so effective as The Joker:
The aggressive sharpness on the word "why", the aristocratic sound of the vowel in "so", followed by the playful and genuinely curious inflection on "serious?" encapsulate everything that makes his interpretation of The Joker so memorable. He didn't have to think about the delivery, it intuitively sprung from his deep familiarity with the character, and in a couple seconds he embodied a demented genius that takes great joy in his evil, and knows that he's probably smarter than you are.
Fucking brilliant. Thank you Mark Hamill.
Also Known As Yeah,all his later characters have a bit of joker in each of them
Completely friggin agree with you!
Also Known As savage
Hipster Ninja Indubitably.
Also Known As Right on brotha!!!
"HAPPY BIRTHDAY YA SON OF A BITCH!"
Hello Clown
+The Joker omg so many jokers lol
Are we having a villain reunion?
+The Riddler It must be :P
+The Riddler Riddle me this,riddle me that.Who's afraid of the big black bat?
Mark Hamill is among only a handful of people worthy of playing the role of one the greatest villains in fictional history
+Jungoguy that's because he's one of the greatest heroes too
+Jungoguy After all these years, I never knew it was luke skywalker who did the voice of joker.
+vice2vursa same
Now with all the isolation and how fucked up things got after the ewok party you gotta wonder if specs of madness (preferably Brand J) would show up in the new star wars saga version of mark hamill >..
Hamill helped make the Joker great. It's the great actors and storytellers that make the character great. The character alone is garbage.
Think about it; a clown that kills. It's super cliche. But the people who poured their lives and careers into Batman and his villains really elevated Joker to cultural icon status.
I got to admit when I heard Mark’s Joker say “Why so serious?” Sent chills down my spine.
I loved how Mark Hamil said "Why so serious?" That was fantastic to hear such a nostalgic interpretation of Joker saying that classic line.
It's not really a 'classic' line, It's a new one.
XDarkLordXP It was an instant classic. We're going to remember that line for decades.
Happy Birthday to you.
Happy Birthday to you.
Happy Birthday dear Joker fan....
Happy Birthday ya Son of a Bitch!
Everytime when I hear Mark Hammil's Joker voice I feel filled with joy
Now if we could only have Hamil use those lines in a future DC installment...
set in DC Animated Universe. That would be it
I was spazzing out on the floor when he said "Why so serious".
+Gustavo Gonzalez I actually was, I was lying on the floor when I watched this. Don't ask me why.
+Gustavo Gonzalez Oh, it's definitely a weird thing.
Search TH-cam for "Why so serious Mark Hamill impression animated". It's a pretty spot-on impression.
both hamill and ledger are legends. nuff said.
When were you when heat legend die?
I need to update you... Juaquin Phoenix will be joining them... 😝
Mark Hamil could sell joker voice sound bits and make a TON of money. They could say anything and people would want them.
It truly warms my heart that the true clown prince of crime Mark Hamill liked Ledgers take on the joker
Mark Hamil is the best Joker, if you only judge them by the voice. Both Niccolosons and Ledger get higher approval from me because they just acted so well, but Hamil and Conroy have, in my mind, the prestigious distinction of being the only 2 voice actors who do their role SO WELL, that they hold up to the live action versions. It amazes me that Hamil, just as an off the cuff joke, does 3 words, and sends fangasms through every person listening. Lets put it like this. Everything a casual fan associates with the Joker is Hamil's. When I asked all my friends to do a Joker laugh, all of theirs resembled the one Hamil did. The Batssss with the extreme emphasis on the s, all of the things that have become integral to the Jokers vocal identity. Also, Hamils Joker in the Arkham games has the additional distinction of a role so effectively portrayed, it is cinema quality. Hamid is and will always be my favorite Joker
Joshua Gill
Mark Hamil was the best animated joker but Heath is the best live action joker and its practically impossible to say one is better than the other given that Hamil portrays the comic joker better while Heath was better at portraying the darker version of joker.
Glenn A what about John Dimaggio's Joker?
Hes a good voice actor but by far the worst person to play the Joker. So far hes the only actor to play the Joker one time before they stopped using him.
Glenn A I liked his Joker.
Glenn A Lol guys Brett Spiner all the way! shoots myself in the head
Never start with the head....the victim gets all fuzzy!
P0V3RTY09 see
I can literally hear mark’s version saying it and it’s amazing.
how have I not seen this
Apparently it only became popular just recently.
you're late brother lol
Right? I saw this in my recommended and just casually read it out loud like "Mark Hamill's Joker does Heath Ledger's Joooooooh..."
I don't know about you guys but I'm just now watching this and wondering the same
Mark: (provides a thoughtful, passionate, and thoroughly well-put answer to a completely botched question)
Him: i was just hoping you'd say "why so serious?"
Me: (facepalm) WHY DIDNT YOU JUST SAY THAT?!
The actual video starts at 1:39
I thought it started at 0:00 but thanks bro
+John Ramirez Me too😂😂
tnx
U da real mvp
Mark Hamill, unsurprisingly, nailed why Heath's Joker was so damn unique but so damn good. The one word he used to describe it in particular, "joyless". I never realized it but that's why he was so good. The Joker, simply by name, makes one expect someone full of joy and humor, but in the Dark Knight, while he had a sense of humor, there was no joy left in him. He was clearly just a man, as opposed to other Jokers, who seem like they aren't really part of the human species.
I wish they let Mark Hamill say the "Why So Serious" line in the Arkham games
I'd like to hear Troy Baker say that as his Joker.
TPDManiacXC626 Troy Baker does an excellent job and is a damn fine voice actor in general... but I don't like his laugh as much as I do Hamill's. It's what defines the Joker in my opinion, but my opinion is just an opinion.
laz kar Very much so, I just we he could imitate the perfect laugh...
laz kar Very true. I wonder how sore Hamill's voice must be after talking and laughing like that for almost twenty years of acting.
Still, I hope that Baker has a good run as the new Joker, he does a bang-up job that makes the Clown Prince of Crime come to life. His performance in Assault on Arkham was particularly great in my opinion.
laz kar I'll be looking forward to that should it ever come to fruition.
I've always loved his ability to just switch into the voice at will, it's like he can just flip a switch
now i can rest in peace
Ledger: Why so serious?
Hamill: Do we look serious? (Starts laughing)
Romero: (laughs with hamill)
Nicholson: (laughing at completely other joke he just thought of)
Baker: (smiles 'til it hurts)
DiMaggio: (silent laugh and red face)
Monaghan: (torn between two punchlines)
Phoenix: (starts dancing)
Leto: (wasn't invited)
What about Cameron Monaghan and jack Nicholson?
@@allicide166 When his face went flying and landed in a puddle, I just lost it...talking about losing face....
leto is a good joker just bad writing the snyder cut proved to me leto could have bin a fantastic joker
I was reachering joker actor there alot then I expected
@@loganholm8710 Still hate his laugh, it sounds dull and bored, but I agree Snyder cut made him a little better.
It's crazy to think that he was both Joker and Luke Skywalker. What a legend!
Mark was also others like Skips from Regular Show, Mr Block from Milo Murphy's Law, the Hobgoblin, and of course the Trickster
Now if only I could hear him say it instead of the crowd yelling.
You guys are a little harsh on the guy. I mean cmon, I know it's youtube but fuck. have some compassion. The guy was obviously very nervous. Any one of you could of messed up just like he did. Standing in front of 200+ people AND Mark Hamil, a legend in the business, isn't exactly the easiest of feats.
Besides, he's speaking to the Motherfucking Joker.
but he really couldn't have done worse. No one's knocking him for being nervous or fucking up, it's how badly he fucked up that people are making fun of and rightfully so. Bitch.
Hugo Stiglitz go sit in the corner boy. Your mommy is so dissapointed in you
Wow mad props and what a class act Hamill is. He could feel threatened by someone else's Joker but instead takes the time to praise it. That there, ladies and gentlemen, is a class act and a man confident in his work.
Love how he calls the joker voice old comic book but he invented the joker voice.
He’s been best joker voice and his laugh
Wow this vid hit over 1 million. Merry Batsy Christmas everyone!
It’s summer you goon 😂
happy birthday you son of a bitch..
This shook me..
close your eyes in the end and you can imagine Joker singing that song to you with knife in his hand. Happy Birthday you son of a bitch
I'd love to hear him say "Never rub another Man's rhubarb" in his Joker voice.
Among fans, there tends to be a lot of "competition" or argumentation about why someone is better than someone else.
In contrast, I really loved seeing Hamill show such respect for Ledger. I, personally, found both to be tremendous, iconic performances, and I prefer to avoid arguments about who is "better".
The way Mark answered that tasteless question (considering how recent Heath's death was at that point) was SO warm, reverent and full of respect.
A decent and professional man, Mr Hamill is. :)
...it was 3 years since his death...
That gave me chills. Mark Hamill will always be my original and favorite joker.
hearing joker cussing is honestly as scary as batman laughing
I wanna hear some Jack Nicholson lines. Yes Heath is amazing but we can’t forget about Jack. “THIS TOWN NEEDS AN ENEMA”
Nah, “you ever dance with the devil in a pale moon light.”
Favorite line.
Asking that question was very brave as the room could’ve turned on him, real hard but the minute Mark actually did “why so serious” I lost it! so good! so iconic!
He acted one of the most iconic heroes in fiction, and voiced one of the most iconic villains in history
The fact that he thought about it for a second, realized it's what the fans wanted and delivered the line; just to put a smile on everyone's face, is why he's the GOAT.
I'd like to hear him do the "Wanna know how I got these scars?" lines.
What a classy guy and great performer?! Just gives the people what they want on the spot, that's true showmanship. Thoughtful stuff about Ledger as well. Mark Hamill just became a little cooler in my mind, which I didn't think was possible.
I wonder ehat kind of roled Mr Hamill would have taken had he not sustained an injury. It's weird that he couldn't even find roles that had few physical specifications or didn't require good looks. He's a very good actor. It's just so sad he's not in more movies.
I wanted to hear him say," you wanna know how i got these scars?" But this is great too!
This dude could NOT get his question out
1:47 a great example of a nerdgasm. "YES....YESSS....YESS!!!"
omg something just hit me, it would be so hilarious and awesome at the same time if we would like get all the jokers that have been done, sitting at a table and then swap stories, in some parallel universe xD
+Kristofer Murphy
And people didn't like him being casted before this film and he never saw his glory.
He just lived it ;)
There's already a video demonstrating that, a short animation however. Just search "Joker vs Joker debate".
I love this guy
Wow, the best animated Joker saying the lines of the best live-action Joker is something that I never thought was needed but was definitely deserved.
RIP Heath Ledger, the GOAT Joker of live-action Batman films, and Kevin Conroy, the GOAT of animated Batman and the entire DCAU
I liked Hamill's and Ledger's interpretations for different reasons. Mark was amazing at producing an insane comical flirty joker, while Heath provided a serious and realistic take on the joker.
Someone make Hamill read the phonebook from A to Z in his joker voice.
***** His voice would give out while still reading the Aa section..
DEATHBYFLYINGCDS I want him to do a sat nav
Joker: "Owww...Never start with the head. The suspect can get fuzzy and wont feel anything".
Batman: ..[Crush his hand]..
Joker: "See..?"
Ledger's why so serious: *Creepy and, Terrorizing
Hanill's: Comic book style
Both are legends until Joaquin Phoenix joins them... And then Jare- you know what never mind...
*Hamill
Raziq Daniel Oh my bad. I accidentally typed Hanil
Cameron Monaghan also deserves to be on the list too!!!
IMO Heath Ledger's Joker is superior to all the rest as far as on screen performances go but Mark Hamill's Joker voice is the best ever!.
There is no Joker better than Mark Hamill.
Seriously.. Heath ledger had the body movements the look, his own personality to his joker cause he could do that ultimately because it was not a video game or cartoon!
It is easier to Act than to Voice Act, trying to be the joker through only your voice is much harder than being the joker through body and voice.
youb tijani that's kinda bs.
youb tijani you have to be kidding me there is more involved in acting as I just pointed out than there is in just making a voice
All you need to do is get your voice to the correct pitch and a little more things and then you practice it and keep at it I never said it was easy, there is still talent that gets out into changing your voice but,
Acting if you try and act as the joker and he is ment to be a psychopathic killer, who laughs all the time etc and you put the make up on the voice and act as a gangster, it is not going to be pulled off well is it? Well it may be pulled off depending on the person who does it but he is not a gangster he is a murderous psychopathic clown.
***** Nope! voice acting is an art not just everyday talk. I`ve know Mark as the Joker before even Heath rose to fame. We are talking about the early 90`s. Mark brought the Joker to life, when everybody couldn`t thanks to his twisted laugh & attitude.
If you call 411 and ask for Mark Hamill in L A califonia, u will get his ACTUAL phone number
That can't be. You know how many prank calls he would receive if that were the case.
But, I called and asked for him and his maid answered the phone and said call around 6 pm cuz that is when he'd be home
Zeldas Champion Millions... BUAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA HAHAHAHAHAHAH UUGGGGGGGGGGHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!*coughs cough*
Really I want to try this
The Joker how many people did you wreck with this?
2 minutes and seven seconds just to hear mark say “why so serious?”
Completely worth it. 👌🔥
Why so serious?
The guy who requested it was too nervious, if he hadn't being like that we could have saved a couple seconds, but even if someone says "Mark was just being nice flatterying the people working in the Dark knight", I like his opinion on Heath's take on the Joker.
Think of all you could have done with those extra 20 seconds... What a tragedy...
And it was totally worth it
The guy asking the questions...bless his heart!
That guy who asked the question, he had a nerdgasm when mark did the voice. He had to leave the building and buy a new pair of pants. True story.
Dude is the hero and the villain in so many peoples life. Star Wars and Batman have both touched millions of life’s. So has Mark Hamill
Mark Hamill was Luke Skywalker? Holy shit
When did you realise?
dhiresh bharadwa Not soon enough
nuraH S is it bad I saw star wars after I knew hamill was joker?
nuraH S Have you never seen Star Wars?
OMG, I can't believe you posted that
His question wasn’t even acted upon request...
This man, such a gold heart, such love for his fans and we love him as much. Not many people become such an iconic figure. He never imposes, always wants to know about how we find his plays, and if people knew how hard he tried to save Star Wars from the pool of shit they were headed. Should have listen to the only one Luke Skywalker, a wise master indeed. Thanks to him, the force is with us forever.
1:40 at this point a bunch of nerds just started spazzing
Mark Hamill is the man. He's so unpretentious and down to earth
We need more Mark Hamil in our lives please. He is literally a national treasure by this point.
YESSSS!!!! Totally agree!!!
I was hoping for him to say "you wanna know how I got these scars!"
"How would you inTERpreTAte Heath Ledger's lines?"
Wow this guy's nervous
Why did the crowd groan at the question? He didn't insult anybody.
I think they were all going "oooohhh..." as in "This is gonna be interesting..."
Ledger's Joker its kind of untouchable
tigerlover1021
Yeah when I look at it that way I can see that. At first it sounded like he said something bad
Maybe it was more of a sad "ooohh" because Ledger is dead. Dunno.
It can be seen as a controversial subject. Hamill and Ledger were acting as namely the same character, which can be seen as a competition. But it would be very distasteful to compare them since Ledger can't respond to it.
Of course we separate between the two Jokers as completely different characters. So there is no competition.
This dude got 2 GOAT roles being Joker and Skywalker lol