Wait, what?! I’m a trainee counsellor and have to say we were never told about the no-eating-clients rule. Not one single word! I may need to rethink my future career here....
Amazing Mazey - Autism Assistance Dog Puppy nah, drinking is against my moral code. All I wanna do is eat a client or two every now and then but WITH ALCOHOL?! Oof, you’ve gone too far there bud.
In the book Hannibal Rising, we see that he began as a caring child, protecting his sister and feeling sympathy for the swans on his parents' estate. The cannibalistic soldiers ruined his psyche.
Yes! And he really loved his little sister. Those soldiers were horrific and i really did not shed one tear when i watch Hannibal kill them without mercy. Maybe that makes me a bad person, but.... they are just fictional characters lol so please forgive me. 💘 😻 💜 💛 💚 🧡 🧜♀️ 🧜♀️ 🧜♀️ 🧜♀️ 🧜♀️ 🧜♀️
@@YurinanAcquiline Yes. But he was a kid, starving and was under hostage by the criminals. And they took his sister aside (kid Hannibal tried fighting them off) and cooker her, and fed her to Hannibal. Hannibal did not know it was his sister he was eating, until years he started murdering those criminals and one of them told him thr truth.
Hey man, long-time viewer, don't usually leave comments, but wanted to say your videos are fantastic. Listening to you talk actually relaxes me a lot, love all of your analysis stuff. Thanks for keeping my late nights interested
Oh H.P. Lovecraft, Hitler, Karen Carpenter (singer) General Patten , Gandhi, and as a group Star Trek fans who will watch, read , be things of Star Trek (ever been to a ST convention?)
RoxiRoxi Me This would be interesting (especially Stalin), but actually I don’t think their characters are terribly complex or unusual. They had specific talents (Bonaparte was a gifted general, Mussolini was very good at motivating the masses, etc.), they were highly focused and competent, but more than anything they were lucky to be living at a time of revolutionary change. Without those external factors no one would ever have heard of them.
They were both exceptional in their roles. Anthony Hopkins really ‘digested’ 😆 Lecter’s character from the novel and brought it to life in the film. His mannerisms, the way he moved even his voice seemed to fit perfectly. In the series Mads Mikkelsen presented, dare I say, a far more sinister side (if that’s at all possible for Lecter); the way he meticulously prepped, cooked and presented his meals. He also brought a more physically stronger side to Lecter. I was dubious at first about Hannibal being played by anyone else, but now I don’t think I could choose a favourite. They are different but bring in true aspects of Hannibal to the role they play. Magic.
---Sounds like a nifty tee shirt!😅😂🤣Seriously, I’ve read a number of books on serial killers, particularly Bundy. I think it’s wanting to see the common denominator as to ‘WHY’, they become who they are. Many people get broken up with, have crummy parents or are bullied, which seems to hint at something deeper in their brains that more normies, no matter their tragic backstories, miss.
I’d like to make a suggestion to read Hannibal Rising. It goes into his childhood and what initially triggers him to behave the way he does. In fact, even though it was the final and 4th book of the series if you read it first, it is then in chronological order and will give you more insight into his character before you begin Red Dragon, The Silence of the Lambs and finally Hannibal.
He might as well call himself Dr. Colossus. His feats of intelligence and cunning are more in line with Batman's enemies than they are with any real human being. Seriously, him and Bane are pretty much on par with each other when you consider their movie portrayals. Both have superior intellects, wear the same masks and display super human strength. Both are charismatic, evil geniuses who speak pedantically without flaw. The difference is that people believe someone like Bane can actually exist. And in reality, Lector has more in common with Magneto than he does with a real serial killer.
Doc, please consider doing an analysis of Mads Mikkelsen's portrayal in the tv series Hannibal as a bonus to this one. Much more screen time to consider.
Sheep are born with congenital syphilis. This makes them docile and stupid as a species. I would not eat one for mutton. Would Ewe. "Do not suffer mules gladly, and don't vote for them".
I can't find anything comparable to the show. Bryan Fuller's background in psychology, his literary & artistic styling, and his inclusive and original casting elevate the material. If only there had been the planned 7 seasons... and it took me 2 years to actually look at the screen and not just listen to the dialogue! Once I understood how grounded in empathy the show was, and the use of magical realism, I finally got to enjoy it 💖🙌
i dunno about that, anyone who thinks that would have to be an enormous narcissist who doesn't understand the character at all. he almost murdered clarice who was the only person he loved apart from his sister so anyone who imagines themselves as that important would themselves be a bit mental
I agree, it's like if I could be polite and not offend him he wouldn't want to kill me. Sort of a twisted honor among thieves kind of notion. I've always loved this character, never wanted tio meet him but intrigued by him none the less. Great analysis Dr. G!
@@feeltheillinois No, no mental narcissist here - just enjoying a written character in a playful way. And isn´t the word narcissist a little over used in the last time?
@@fruhbisspattv5259 not referring to you, talking about the people who fantasize about imagining themselves as so superior that they would be immune to his violence, overused or not there would have to be huge ego and self importance to believe that of themselves
Been waiting for this one; Hannibal Lecter and his OCEAN profile. Anthony Hopkins is one of my favorite actors. 'Silence of our doctor'? No way, he's to busy making awesome videos. Thanks, Dr. Grande 😨 🇳🇱
I just finished watching Season 1 of the “Hannibal” TV series, and I would love to see you analyze the character Will Graham, Dr. Grande. I realize he is as unrealistic as Hannibal Lecter, but I found him very compelling and complex. Great video, as always!
You're in for a treat with the entire series. It's extremely well made and the actors do a magnificent job of bringing both Will Graham, Hannibal and other characters to life. I'd also enjoy hearing Dr. Grande analysing the character of Will Graham, especially his apparent ability to empathise with and think like serial killers.
GingerJeanie I agree, I find him fascinating. You might want to read “Red Dragon” - Will Grant is the main character and you learn a lot about him. The two movies based on this book were nowhere near as interesting.
@@spacemonkey4811 What? He’s a psych, not a metaphysicist. We want his psychological opinions of a character, not his opinions on the possible existence of psychic powers.
S M "My favorite part is when he says “Hello Clarice” I don't believe he ever actually says those words... People pay less attention to the actual movie than they do the parodies. th-cam.com/video/SSEf2BYQBdQ/w-d-xo.html
Lecter NEVER said "Hello Clarice" in the movie! That's an example of the Mandela Effect. His first words to her were actually "Good morning". It's one of those examples of when enough people quote something, it gets perpetuated and accepted as fact.
Such a great video, Dr. You did a spectacular job with the character analysis. Just my thoughts about a couple of things. I think many people find Lecter fascinating, because he was willing to help Clarice find the serial killer they were looking for, although he wanted something in return for helping her. And Also, I think that Anthony Hopkins' portrayal of him is probably one of the best if not the best acting jobs I've ever seen. In my opinion, if it wasn't him acting in that part, I don't think Lecter would be that fascinating. I've only read the book 'Silence of the Lambs' and seen that movie, and had no idea that Clarice and him lived together, WHOA. You are hilarious I love how you brought up things like "Cons has murdered and eaten clients in the past" and "Jaguars are maintenance nightmares." Hilarious!
@@JesseWright68 that's because it wasnt supposed to be a southern accent but her character was someone trying to loose their accent. Annoying? That's subjective
@@JesseWright68 Lecter, as it was pointed out, was intended to be over the top anyway. I thought that his performance was great, downright creepy. Jodie Foster was good too.
Really look forward to your balanced, educated perspective on such interesting topics (Silence of the Lambs is an old favourite). Feels like I discovered something really special stumbling upon your channel. Lots of respect sir.
Would you consider doing an analysis on MLM or pyramid scheme companies - how these types of "businesses" convince people to join and the tactics behind it, as well as those most likely to follow?
Oh, great choice Dr. Grande! You spoil us with your daily uploads of such great content. I remember when the Silence of the Lambs was released and how riveting the movie was. I was drawn to the intricacies, complexities and how nuanced and contradictory the character of Hanibal was. It was beautiful to see the transformation of his character when he entered into a relationship with Clarice and the tenderness, vulnerability and connection between them that was quite unexpected and touching. As always the humour you sprinkle into your videos delights me! The line about eating clients and the pro/con list was killer🤣🤣. Thank you, Dr. Grande for this very interesting analysis. I was just as riveted as I was watching this movie for the first time. I'm feeling a bit nostalgic so I have to see if it's on Netflix!!
Hannibal Lecter : (Cordell is standing behind Mason's wheelchair on a ledge overlooking the wild boars)”Hey, Cordell! Why don't you push him in? You can always say it was me.”
Well damn! My most favorite analysis of yours yet! I never thought of Dr. Lecter as anything but human, but your theory about Lecter being supernatural ACTUALLY WORKS!
Request seconded! I like the character - he's a good representation of an INTJ who unfortunately hasn't developed much empathy: House probably would say there's no point in empathy for doctors!
I agree that Hannibal Lecter was written to be unrealistic on purpose to make his character more interesting and entertaining. Most serial killers tend to be quite boring, very shallow, and extremely self-centered, which would make for terrible reading, so it makes sense why the author wrote him the way he did. Excellent analysis as always! Love your videos.
Hannibal lecter is one of my all time favorite villains ! My dad took me to see silence of the lambs when I was a kid and I was scared for weeks after ! Great analysis
I've rewatched the film again yesterday. The acting of Hopkins still is phenomenal. I personally have no problem with his character being unrealistic according to typical categorisations. It need not be realistic in order to be impressive.
So fascinating to see a psychological breakdown of Hannibal Lecter like no one else has ever done. I hope someday you can extend further to examining historical personalities and maybe other fictional characters if there is enough appeal for it. Thank you, Dr. Grande!
I check my phone every few hours incase Dr.Grande droppes a video, and today's is 18:37 minutes, i'm like 🙏yassss....great video as always, your dry humor with is alway on point, thank you Doc ,keep them coming!
Neighbor: Yo, Hey what did you do today ?? Me: I learned the 14 characteristics of an organized serial killer, and you ?? Neighbor: oh Me: Hey, you wanna come over for supper tonight? I'll provide the meat and chianti, you can bring the fava beans.
I saw this, clicked so fast! Thank you for this video Dr. Grande. I noticed the new changes in your videos (information boxes while you are explaining), really nice addition!!! 😃
@sasholsuma he killed old lady Kristina (i think this was her name) because he started to believe that there wasnt any God, and that he is the one who should take action, or shortly said - the right to take a live. But still, he had some psychological background. Lets take his childhood for an example. Remember the horse beating scene? Maybe his first contact with violence. I think they Dr.Grande could do a good psychological analysis of the character. Plus, Dostoevsky loved to write deep books with deep psychological background.
You make a great argument for lecter being a vampire... and as I was typing that you said it! Man... many details seem to align with Count Dracula. Fascinating! Thank you for the work you do.
Leonie Ganivet Yes That Would be great Loved Micheal C. Hall in that Character Dexter Showtime Original Series from 2006- 2013 he was Awesome! Thank you for that Suggestion lovely lady! Excellent Choice for Dr Grande would love to hear The Personality break down of Mr Dexter Morgan!❤👍🏽🙏🏽
Bravo, Dr. Grande!!!!! You know, I find myself using your disclaimer in my day to day activities....."I'm not diagnosing anyone , just speculating.... " and it is widely accepted in society circles!!!!!! I also hear other narrators imitating you.....💖
Actually, it is stated that behavioural specialists at the FBI are the ones who stated that Hannibal had tortured animals, but as you learn through the narrator of 'Hannibal Rising', he actually did no such thing. He protected the swans in the lake when he was an orphan, was particularly fond of horses, and even dogs seemed quite comfortable around him and he seemed quite at ease with them too. In the scene where he made his first kill (the butcher who had insulted his aunt), after he was finished, he went to where the butcher had fish tied under the pier. He released the one that was still alive, and he took the one that was dead. In the novel 'Hannibal', he spotted a poucher at a fair, and tracked him later on where he was cleaning a doe he killed out of season, Hannibal killed him with a crossbow and strung him up right next to the deer and presented gutted like the deer. Just deserts, as Hannibal seemed to think. Hannibal's triggers seemed to be bullies, particularly those bigger than him. The younger ones who would tease him, he would give them his treats (which were rare for them to even get in the orphanage). Those he targeted as an adult were almost always disdainful, arrogant, shallow, and rude. In keeping with his targeting bullies bigger than him, he was totally fine with killing anyone who abused their power and authority to victimize others. Not only did Lecter have the ability to empathize and to even show compassion...it is revealed that just like Will Graham, he was a hyper-empath, with an edict memory. When Lecter tells Will that the reason he was able to catch him is because they are just alike, Lecter was being completely honest (Lecter always told the truth, in his own way). I think what Harris was attempting to do was create the type of 'villain turned antihero' that he personally found particularly alluring as well as frightening---a villian that looks very much like Milton's Lucifer--a figure that is the epitome of evil, but is also an anti-hero...someone who we want to see win because they are persuasive in their plight...someone who is far more human than devil. I think he accomplished that, for the most part...but have to put it out there that Brian Fuller with the TV Series really nailed the Hannibal Lecter that Harris was going for.
Been catching up on your recent videos. Not sure what happened, but dang, your sense of humor has been *unleashed* as of late! Enjoying your perspective and videos, keep up the great work.
I'm always amazed by how seriously people take works of fiction as if the characters are real people. They're so concerned with how realistic a movie or book is that they fail to see the point. Entertainment. Escape from reality. My favorite genre is generally fantasy because there's no false pretense of realism needed. Another great analysis Dr Grande 👏 Edit: realized my comment isn't exactly on topic... but you get the point.
Very fine analysis, Doctor. I just finished reading Hannibal for the second time. It was a pleasure watching your video on the analysis of this character. Thank you for your time. I liked and subscribed. Now onto your analysis or Dexter.
I'm relieved by the overall conclusion. He would be the wild card even to professionals 😨 and i'm glad that insanity doesnt board on geniality in reality haha Very neat as always dr G!!
doesnt a lack of empathy in this context usually refer to affective empathy vs cognitive? And that it is one of the reasons why people on this spectrum are so good at manipulating people around them. They can read facial expressions and body language, understand what the other person is feeling, while staying detached.
Agree, Hannibal would qualify as having cognitive empathy (of course this would have been important for his work as a psychiatrist) but lacking in emotional empathy
I'm pretty sure it was very intentional for Lecter to be so unrealistic and unlike typical/real serial killers. I don't think that was just out of ignorance on Harris' part, it seems to be an important element of the character, part of what makes him so intriguing and interesting as a character is that he is so unlike any other killer.
I recall having to read "Red Dragon" for one of my courses in my doctoral degree program in psychology. It is always interesting to compare the book to the movie. As always, your discussion is highly organized and comprehensive. Thank you so much.
Great vid. He does have some posh tastes: a penchant for Bentleys, a habit of sketching vistas from European cultural sites on his cell walls, a liking for 'fava beans and a nice Chianti'. One would imagine he's fond of a glass of Chateau Neuf du Pape too!
Each criminlal is unique , some are organized and/or intelligent... Hannibal have it all, this make him so interesting. A complete analize; well done, dear Dr. Grande! Thank you! P.S: Without Sir Anthony Hopkins, maybe the famous personage would have died in silence...
Aww Doc, your assessment of Lector has just blown my teenage sentimentality for the creepy character of Lecter right out of the water! But you are dead right... he is not a psychopath, I thought he couldn’t fit factor 2 psychopathy because he was too organised, too calm with no apparent impulsivity, and he didn’t seem to lie - he seemed happy to own what he did, and he didn’t engage in a parasitic lifestyle... I was excited to hear your analysis but as you you went through each point breaking them down I was sitting here thinking “damn, so what IS Hannibal all about then?” And there we have it - human eating super villian it is - mind blown! 🤯🤯 I wonder if Buffalo Bill, the other serial killer in Silence of the Lambs fits the psychopathy profile more clearly...? I read somewhere Harris based the idea for Buffalo Bill on Ed Gein... but who knows... I think I have asked you this before, but it would be interesting to hear your take on the Russian mystic Grigori Rasputin. Thanks for doing this vid.
Thank you so much for one more super analysis, Dr Grande. And congratulations on the 400,000 subscribers! You totally deserve it. May 400,000 more come soon.
His non-lack-of-empathy is what makes him all the more terrifying. A man you truly cannot trust, nor ever truly understand. Defies all your understanding. Scary. Intriguing. Hyper intelligent. We all love it.
True, Dr Grande... Darth Vader is arguably the #1 villain of all time. I mean, Hannibal might have some incredible abilities, but he never (allegedly) used Force choke!
Great video. You mentioned Darth Vader. Was he already antisocial before he became a Jedi? He was taken from his mother when he was nine. He was raised by Kenobi who had very little compassion for him. He later had a narcissistic partner who excused his behaviour which included genocide of a tribe of sand people. The Jedi did know something was wrong with him but let him command armies during the clone wars because he always won. His tactic in battle was to always attack which was not Jedi like and closer to the behaviour of the Sith. He asked for help because the darkness was tempting him and the Jedi were too arrogant to counsel him properly. He found a father figure in the Emperor who told him whatever he wanted to hear but gave him nothing. Could a good therapist have kept Anakin Skywalker from turning to the dark side? (Provided he wanted help of course. Yeah he may have force choked his therapist)
I was so excited when this came up in my notifications today. I'm a huge fan of the trilogy. I say "trilogy" because I just couldn't get on board with "Hannibal Rising" as a film. I enjoyed the book, though, as well as the TV series. Another fun fact about the series (that you probably already know) is that the character of Jack Crawford was based on John Douglas, one of the first criminal profilers and creator of the FBI's Criminal Profiling Program. Douglas's books make for an interesting read. Thank you for another great video!
Great analysis doctor! I much prefer those videos than the drama ones. There is just so much more information here that I can learn from. / Also, a suggestion - children who murder (not only psychopaths but all types, if possible)
“Eating clients is usually frowned upon…”😂 I needed that laugh!!!!
Same here! 😂 I just love how he says it with a straight face.
Watch Dr Grandes video on Shane Dawson’s apology video, it is hilarious and I don’t even follow all the Beauty drama.
"Usually" lol
I fell off my chair in laughter over that comment! 🤣✌️
It had me rolling too! I love him!
Wait, what?! I’m a trainee counsellor and have to say we were never told about the no-eating-clients rule. Not one single word! I may need to rethink my future career here....
Could it perhaps be permissible if you select a nice Chianti?
Amazing Mazey - Autism Assistance Dog Puppy nah, drinking is against my moral code. All I wanna do is eat a client or two every now and then but WITH ALCOHOL?! Oof, you’ve gone too far there bud.
What they don't know isn't going to hurt them...
@@rottsandspots lmao...hahaha 😜👍
Cheeky, very cheeky!
In the book Hannibal Rising, we see that he began as a caring child, protecting his sister and feeling sympathy for the swans on his parents' estate. The cannibalistic soldiers ruined his psyche.
Thank you for bringing this up. His psyche was definitely made, not born.
He ate his sister? Right?
Neon Clover yes he did
Yes! And he really loved his little sister. Those soldiers were horrific and i really did not shed one tear when i watch Hannibal kill them without mercy. Maybe that makes me a bad person, but.... they are just fictional characters lol so please forgive me. 💘 😻 💜 💛 💚 🧡 🧜♀️ 🧜♀️ 🧜♀️ 🧜♀️ 🧜♀️ 🧜♀️
@@YurinanAcquiline Yes. But he was a kid, starving and was under hostage by the criminals. And they took his sister aside (kid Hannibal tried fighting them off) and cooker her, and fed her to Hannibal.
Hannibal did not know it was his sister he was eating, until years he started murdering those criminals and one of them told him thr truth.
Hey man, long-time viewer, don't usually leave comments, but wanted to say your videos are fantastic. Listening to you talk actually relaxes me a lot, love all of your analysis stuff. Thanks for keeping my late nights interested
And the clout comes in. Man this guy is gonna be the moderate voice of TH-cam if the platform doesn't implode first
Hi repzion!! Long time fan here!!
Yaaay love you repzion!!😊
Same here!
Same here. When I want to chill I just listen about some fucked up people lol. Dr. Grande makes fantastic content.
Dr. Grande, could you talk about famous historical figures such as Mussolini, N. Bonaparte, Stalin, etc?? 🧐
Send that.
Second that.
Secooooond! More specifically Nietzsche. And Edgar Allan Poe.
Oh H.P. Lovecraft, Hitler, Karen Carpenter (singer) General Patten , Gandhi, and as a group Star Trek fans who will watch, read , be things of Star Trek (ever been to a ST convention?)
RoxiRoxi Me This would be interesting (especially Stalin), but actually I don’t think their characters are terribly complex or unusual. They had specific talents (Bonaparte was a gifted general, Mussolini was very good at motivating the masses, etc.), they were highly focused and competent, but more than anything they were lucky to be living at a time of revolutionary change. Without those external factors no one would ever have heard of them.
Off topic: In “Silence...”, Jodi Foster was amazing in her role, along side Anthony Hopkins!
Both were perfectly chosen for their roles, I agree.
Funny thing is they spent very little time together. Jodi went after that role! I am so glad she did cause she was perfect.
Agreed, Patti!!!!! 🧜♀️ 🧜♀️ 🧜♀️ 🧜♀️ 🧜♀️
Yes probably her best role ever.
They were both exceptional in their roles. Anthony Hopkins really ‘digested’ 😆 Lecter’s character from the novel and brought it to life in the film. His mannerisms, the way he moved even his voice seemed to fit perfectly.
In the series Mads Mikkelsen presented, dare I say, a far more sinister side (if that’s at all possible for Lecter); the way he meticulously prepped, cooked and presented his meals. He also brought a more physically stronger side to Lecter. I was dubious at first about Hannibal being played by anyone else, but now I don’t think I could choose a favourite.
They are different but bring in true aspects of Hannibal to the role they play.
Magic.
"To enhance culinary choices" :-) My chuckle for the day. Thank you.
LOL!!!!!
Seriously, that wine reference made me 😝😝😝
And unironically true. He planned his meals depending on which piece he was feasting on to enjoy with a refined complimentary wine.
Next episode: what cars are most reliable for serial killers, and what personality factors influence your choice of vehicle
Lol I was a bit confused when he was talking about the type of car..
@Giuseppe Bloho oof
Mustang 😆
Scotty will weigh in on that. (Kilmer.)
Bundy had pretty good luck with Volkswagon Beetles. My Mom owned one that lasted very well.
Eating clients is frowned upon - Dr Grande 2020
Ha ha ha that is a great ☝️
---Sounds like a nifty tee shirt!😅😂🤣Seriously, I’ve read a number of books on serial killers, particularly Bundy. I think it’s wanting to see the common denominator as to ‘WHY’, they become who they are. Many people get broken up with, have crummy parents or are bullied, which seems to hint at something deeper in their brains that more normies, no matter their tragic backstories, miss.
It is 'usually' frowned upon, according to Dr. Grande. There might be cases when it is acceptable. 😜
I want that as a pin. Or a badge.
Usually...🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I think he’s actually supposed to just be straight evil and undiagnosable.
Clarice: There's no name for what he is.
I’d like to make a suggestion to read Hannibal Rising. It goes into his childhood and what initially triggers him to behave the way he does. In fact, even though it was the final and 4th book of the series if you read it first, it is then in chronological order and will give you more insight into his character before you begin Red Dragon, The Silence of the Lambs and finally Hannibal.
Kind of like Michael Myers from Halloween.
@@rubyred2874 Myers isnt human at all. He is literally a immortal demon in human flesh.
He might as well call himself Dr. Colossus. His feats of intelligence and cunning are more in line with Batman's enemies than they are with any real human being.
Seriously, him and Bane are pretty much on par with each other when you consider their movie portrayals. Both have superior intellects, wear the same masks and display super human strength. Both are charismatic, evil geniuses who speak pedantically without flaw. The difference is that people believe someone like Bane can actually exist. And in reality, Lector has more in common with Magneto than he does with a real serial killer.
Doc, please consider doing an analysis of Mads Mikkelsen's portrayal in the tv series Hannibal as a bonus to this one. Much more screen time to consider.
My favorite Hannibal!
@@alexnorth3393 my favorite, too!!! I have seen everything that Mikkelsen has been in because of his portrayal in Hannibal!
Love the show! I like Mads as Hannibal more. I read that they may do another season in the future 😀
@@jaimereynolds258 fingers crossed
@@alexweiner7861 Shit....I'm crossing my toes too lol
"One does not bother trying to understand sheep. We just eat them." - HL
Sheep are born with congenital syphilis. This makes them docile and stupid as a species. I would not eat one for mutton. Would Ewe. "Do not suffer mules gladly, and don't vote for them".
The tv series was my favourite, we got to see different character's povs and mental illness
I can't find anything comparable to the show. Bryan Fuller's background in psychology, his literary & artistic styling, and his inclusive and original casting elevate the material. If only there had been the planned 7 seasons... and it took me 2 years to actually look at the screen and not just listen to the dialogue! Once I understood how grounded in empathy the show was, and the use of magical realism, I finally got to enjoy it 💖🙌
It's a great series in so many ways.
Dr. Grande is a car enthusiast as well as a firearms aficionado! My kinda guy.
I think, H. is so popular, because he made everyone think °No, he woudn´t eat ME. Only the other people.°
kinda like why girls like “bad guys.” they think they’re only nice to them and not anyone else.
i dunno about that, anyone who thinks that would have to be an enormous narcissist who doesn't understand the character at all. he almost murdered clarice who was the only person he loved apart from his sister so anyone who imagines themselves as that important would themselves be a bit mental
I agree, it's like if I could be polite and not offend him he wouldn't want to kill me. Sort of a twisted honor among thieves kind of notion. I've always loved this character, never wanted tio meet him but intrigued by him none the less. Great analysis Dr. G!
@@feeltheillinois No, no mental narcissist here - just enjoying a written character in a playful way.
And isn´t the word narcissist a little over used in the last time?
@@fruhbisspattv5259 not referring to you, talking about the people who fantasize about imagining themselves as so superior that they would be immune to his violence, overused or not there would have to be huge ego and self importance to believe that of themselves
Been waiting for this one; Hannibal Lecter and his OCEAN profile. Anthony Hopkins is one of my favorite actors. 'Silence of our doctor'? No way, he's to busy making awesome videos. Thanks, Dr. Grande 😨 🇳🇱
"Eating clients is usually frowned upon from an ethical perspective." lmao
I'm still laughing! Good one, Dr Grande!
BWA HA HA HA HA HA
Yes but their therapy was going nowhere!
I loved that one lmfao
BlowItOutYourCunt I’d like to give you a thumbs up but can’t because of ethical reasons.
I just finished watching Season 1 of the “Hannibal” TV series, and I would love to see you analyze the character Will Graham, Dr. Grande. I realize he is as unrealistic as Hannibal Lecter, but I found him very compelling and complex. Great video, as always!
You're in for a treat with the entire series. It's extremely well made and the actors do a magnificent job of bringing both Will Graham, Hannibal and other characters to life. I'd also enjoy hearing Dr. Grande analysing the character of Will Graham, especially his apparent ability to empathise with and think like serial killers.
GingerJeanie I agree, I find him fascinating. You might want to read “Red Dragon” - Will Grant is the main character and you learn a lot about him. The two movies based on this book were nowhere near as interesting.
Mads Mikkelsen has stated that he intentionally played Lecter as if he were the devil on earth or a fallen angel.
Ooo, love him!
A brilliant series. Kudos to all cast members.
Hannibal is Hannibal, he’s in his own category. This was interesting and fun :)
Eating and not murdering? No, you're wrong. That's a 5 star therapist.
That behavior is not normally spelled with a "the"
If you haven't done so already how about an analysis of the fictional serial killer Dexter from the television series.
I was gonna suggest this too!
Yes! Especially Dexter at the series end (spoiler alerts required)
There is a difference in the books to the series, but an analysis would be great!
I was going to suggest this too!
He just uploaded it 7 hours ago! :)
@@karens4033 thanks!
For fictional characters I wondered what your take on the “Carrie” character and also the her religious zealot Mother character would be?
Thats a great idea!
No it's not, once you introduce mumbojumbo like telekinesis, there is no analysis YouCan do.
@@spacemonkey4811 What? He’s a psych, not a metaphysicist. We want his psychological opinions of a character, not his opinions on the possible existence of psychic powers.
Who the hell are you, "Watcher Owl".
My take on all Steven King's characters is that he has basic and horrible politics.
I always hit the like button before i even watch the video lol
We KNOW the content will be awesome!
Me too!
Same here!
Me too! I just know it's going to be great!
My favorite part is when he says _“Hello Clarice”_
...That really brings me back to the days of playing Polybius at the arcade.
"Hello Clarice" reminds me, style-wise, of "They're coming to get you Barbara" (said Bar-buh-rah) from the Original Night of the Living Dead.
S M
"My favorite part is when he says “Hello Clarice”
I don't believe he ever actually says those words... People pay less attention to the actual movie than they do the parodies.
th-cam.com/video/SSEf2BYQBdQ/w-d-xo.html
@@Nope2022HugeTheWarningFan I mean, that's the whole point of the comment. He says "Hello, Clarice" just as Polybius is an actual arcade game 🙄
Lecter NEVER said "Hello Clarice" in the movie! That's an example of the Mandela Effect. His first words to her were actually "Good morning". It's one of those examples of when enough people quote something, it gets perpetuated and accepted as fact.
I've never clicked so fast.
Same!! 👊
Lecter has always seemed to me a modern version of Dracula. Dr, you rock.
I’m watching hannibal right now! I love how you talk about everything! Keep it up Dr. Grande.
Such a great video, Dr. You did a spectacular job with the character analysis. Just my thoughts about a couple of things. I think many people find Lecter fascinating, because he was willing to help Clarice find the serial killer they were looking for, although he wanted something in return for helping her. And Also, I think that Anthony Hopkins' portrayal of him is probably one of the best if not the best acting jobs I've ever seen. In my opinion, if it wasn't him acting in that part, I don't think Lecter would be that fascinating. I've only read the book 'Silence of the Lambs' and seen that movie, and had no idea that Clarice and him lived together, WHOA. You are hilarious I love how you brought up things like "Cons has murdered and eaten clients in the past" and "Jaguars are maintenance nightmares." Hilarious!
Oh, man!!! I jumped on this one faster than Hannibal Lecter would jump on my liver with some fava beans and a nice Chianti.
LOL!!!!!!!
--😅😂🤣
He was a gentleman. He wouldn’t jump on the food.
One does not jump on ones food and Chianti with liver and fava beans.....how uncouth!
This is where Lecter is wrong: it's always Merlot with liver.
;)
The Silence of the Lambs is a favorite movie and book of mine. So happy you covered this one 👍🏻
Oh Hell yeah! Please do Hannibal from the tv show Madd Mickkelson's rendition, I feel like a whole episode could be done on him
I love Mads Mikkelsen!
And bedelia du maurier
“Eating clients is usually frowned upon…”
So you’re saying that in some limited circumstances, it would be permissible then?
I suppose if we're talking a former client, and she's of legal age and fond of cunnilingus, such a practice might not be as undesirable
If you have fava beans and a nice bottle of Chianti available it's permissible.
ahhhh nothing like going to sleep to the sound of Dr Grande's voice analyzing murderers. I just love this channel!
I love this! Thank you for your input on Lecter! Though now I'm dying to hear your thoughts on Dexter! He's my favorite fictional serial killer :D
Oh i loved that show! I met "Dexter" when he was a lowly suit salesman at Men's Wearhouse in Chapel Hill decades ago!
Oh I’d love to hear that as well!
Mermaid Mansion - Really?? How interesting! Dexter is one of my favorite shows...
@@rejaneoliveira5019 yes lol I really did! I'm just an old lady with very few "brushes with fame," and that is one of them. Lol
Mermaid Mansion - Wow, that’s so cool!😃
Omg. He did it. He finally did it. He psychoanalyzed Him.
All the Fannibals watching the dr are rejoicing 👏🏽🙌🏽👏🏽🙌🏽
Hannibal Lecter is a compelling character, but he's ultimately a caricature. And I think that's the point.
Great point.
Hopkins' over-the-top acting was annoying at best. Perhaps the only thing worse was Jodie Foster's awful southern accent.
@@JesseWright68 that's because it wasnt supposed to be a southern accent but her character was someone trying to loose their accent.
Annoying? That's subjective
@@JesseWright68 Lecter, as it was pointed out, was intended to be over the top anyway. I thought that his performance was great, downright creepy. Jodie Foster was good too.
Really look forward to your balanced, educated perspective on such interesting topics (Silence of the Lambs is an old favourite).
Feels like I discovered something really special stumbling upon your channel. Lots of respect sir.
Would you consider doing an analysis on MLM or pyramid scheme companies - how these types of "businesses" convince people to join and the tactics behind it, as well as those most likely to follow?
There is a documentary here on TH-cam about a lularoe consultant where she goes into detail about specific manipulations that might be helpful
that's a really good idea
Thrive today for free. Le. Vel is the best and nutritional information with product.
Oh, great choice Dr. Grande! You spoil us with your daily uploads of such great content. I remember when the Silence of the Lambs was released and how riveting the movie was. I was drawn to the intricacies, complexities and how nuanced and contradictory the character of Hanibal was. It was beautiful to see the transformation of his character when he entered into a relationship with Clarice and the tenderness, vulnerability and connection between them that was quite unexpected and touching. As always the humour you sprinkle into your videos delights me! The line about eating clients and the pro/con list was killer🤣🤣. Thank you, Dr. Grande for this very interesting analysis. I was just as riveted as I was watching this movie for the first time. I'm feeling a bit nostalgic so I have to see if it's on Netflix!!
Hannibal Lecter : (Cordell is standing behind Mason's wheelchair on a ledge overlooking the wild boars)”Hey, Cordell! Why don't you push him in? You can always say it was me.”
"I didn't think Miggs could manage again quite so soon, even though he IS crazy!! GO NOW!!"
LOL!
😂😂😂
It was, "I don't think Miggs..."
@@lylez00 I'd never have had that happen to you, discourtesy is unspeakably ugly for me.
Well damn! My most favorite analysis of yours yet! I never thought of Dr. Lecter as anything but human, but your theory about Lecter being supernatural ACTUALLY WORKS!
The tv series was exquisite
I loved it. My brother in law was grossed out by it.
@@h.borter5367 your brother in law is weak 😏
Dr. Grande, can you please make a video on Dr. House on the "House" TV series.
Request seconded! I like the character - he's a good representation of an INTJ who unfortunately hasn't developed much empathy: House probably would say there's no point in empathy for doctors!
"Whenever feasible, one should always try to eat the rude."
The mind of Hannibal is quite fascinating. We have became spoiled Dr. Grande.
I agree that Hannibal Lecter was written to be unrealistic on purpose to make his character more interesting and entertaining. Most serial killers tend to be quite boring, very shallow, and extremely self-centered, which would make for terrible reading, so it makes sense why the author wrote him the way he did. Excellent analysis as always! Love your videos.
Hannibal lecter is one of my all time favorite villains ! My dad took me to see silence of the lambs when I was a kid and I was scared for weeks after !
Great analysis
I've rewatched the film again yesterday. The acting of Hopkins still is phenomenal. I personally have no problem with his character being unrealistic according to typical categorisations. It need not be realistic in order to be impressive.
While you’re not diagnosing fictional characters, can you do a video on Dr. Chilton who appears to have his own pathology?
So fascinating to see a psychological breakdown of Hannibal Lecter like no one else has ever done. I hope someday you can extend further to examining historical personalities and maybe other fictional characters if there is enough appeal for it. Thank you, Dr. Grande!
"Eating clients is usually frowned upon from an ethical perspective".. Dr Grande speaking from clinical experience there...
I check my phone every few hours incase Dr.Grande droppes a video, and today's is 18:37 minutes, i'm like 🙏yassss....great video as always, your dry humor with is alway on point, thank you Doc ,keep them coming!
You’re not alone.
Neighbor:
Yo, Hey what did you do today ??
Me: I learned the 14 characteristics of an organized serial killer, and you ??
Neighbor: oh
Me: Hey, you wanna come over for supper tonight? I'll provide the meat and chianti, you can bring the fava beans.
😆😆😆😆
The world is more interesting with you in it, neighbor Clarisse. Love the shoes...
Shouldn't that be "I'll provide the fava beans and chianti, and you can provide the liver"!
I'll pass that test and say no thanks.
I saw this, clicked so fast! Thank you for this video Dr. Grande. I noticed the new changes in your videos (information boxes while you are explaining), really nice addition!!! 😃
Really good analysis Dr. Grande :)
Could you do a next one on Rodion Raskolnikov from Dostoevskys book "Crime and Punishment"?
Aleksandar Pavljasevic oh, that would be fascinating
Great suggestion.
@sasholsuma he killed old lady Kristina (i think this was her name) because he started to believe that there wasnt any God, and that he is the one who should take action, or shortly said - the right to take a live. But still, he had some psychological background. Lets take his childhood for an example. Remember the horse beating scene? Maybe his first contact with violence.
I think they Dr.Grande could do a good psychological analysis of the character. Plus, Dostoevsky loved to write deep books with deep psychological background.
Dr. Todd the absolute Godddd😂 I’ve been waiting for this video for so long now ❤️👌🏻
Silence of the lambs is my absolute favorite movie! I have seen it literally over 100 times. It's also my favorite movie anthology.
OMG ME, TOO, CANDY!!!!!!!!! I have the audio books 📚 too! They are great!
Love the content and look forward to your Dexter analysis down the road sir. : )
eating clients is usually frowned upon. you're killing me doc! 🤣 i'm watching this one twice lol
I'm on my second watch right now lol
You make a great argument for lecter being a vampire... and as I was typing that you said it! Man... many details seem to align with Count Dracula. Fascinating! Thank you for the work you do.
What about the character of "Dexter"? That might be interesting. It was a terrific series.
Leonie Ganivet Yes That Would be great Loved Micheal C. Hall in that Character Dexter Showtime Original Series from 2006- 2013 he was Awesome! Thank you for that Suggestion lovely lady! Excellent Choice for Dr Grande would love to hear The Personality break down of Mr Dexter Morgan!❤👍🏽🙏🏽
Bravo, Dr. Grande!!!!! You know, I find myself using your disclaimer in my day to day activities....."I'm not diagnosing anyone , just speculating.... " and it is widely accepted in society circles!!!!!! I also hear other narrators imitating you.....💖
I think Anthony Hopkins portrayal of Hannibal was so convincing that the character he developed resided with people.
Actually, it is stated that behavioural specialists at the FBI are the ones who stated that Hannibal had tortured animals, but as you learn through the narrator of 'Hannibal Rising', he actually did no such thing. He protected the swans in the lake when he was an orphan, was particularly fond of horses, and even dogs seemed quite comfortable around him and he seemed quite at ease with them too. In the scene where he made his first kill (the butcher who had insulted his aunt), after he was finished, he went to where the butcher had fish tied under the pier. He released the one that was still alive, and he took the one that was dead. In the novel 'Hannibal', he spotted a poucher at a fair, and tracked him later on where he was cleaning a doe he killed out of season, Hannibal killed him with a crossbow and strung him up right next to the deer and presented gutted like the deer. Just deserts, as Hannibal seemed to think.
Hannibal's triggers seemed to be bullies, particularly those bigger than him. The younger ones who would tease him, he would give them his treats (which were rare for them to even get in the orphanage). Those he targeted as an adult were almost always disdainful, arrogant, shallow, and rude. In keeping with his targeting bullies bigger than him, he was totally fine with killing anyone who abused their power and authority to victimize others.
Not only did Lecter have the ability to empathize and to even show compassion...it is revealed that just like Will Graham, he was a hyper-empath, with an edict memory. When Lecter tells Will that the reason he was able to catch him is because they are just alike, Lecter was being completely honest (Lecter always told the truth, in his own way).
I think what Harris was attempting to do was create the type of 'villain turned antihero' that he personally found particularly alluring as well as frightening---a villian that looks very much like Milton's Lucifer--a figure that is the epitome of evil, but is also an anti-hero...someone who we want to see win because they are persuasive in their plight...someone who is far more human than devil. I think he accomplished that, for the most part...but have to put it out there that Brian Fuller with the TV Series really nailed the Hannibal Lecter that Harris was going for.
Would you be able to talk about Hannibal in the TV series?? 😊
Been catching up on your recent videos. Not sure what happened, but dang, your sense of humor has been *unleashed* as of late! Enjoying your perspective and videos, keep up the great work.
I'm always amazed by how seriously people take works of fiction as if the characters are real people. They're so concerned with how realistic a movie or book is that they fail to see the point. Entertainment. Escape from reality. My favorite genre is generally fantasy because there's no false pretense of realism needed.
Another great analysis Dr Grande 👏
Edit: realized my comment isn't exactly on topic... but you get the point.
Suspension of disbelief in the words of Coleridge and Wordsworth.
I was going to request this video!! So happy you made it :)
I’d be extremely interested in an analysis on Patrick Bateman, Dr. Grande 🙏🏼
Yes!
Yes, that would be very interesting. I enjoyed the film but not so much the book.
Very fine analysis, Doctor. I just finished reading Hannibal for the second time. It was a pleasure watching your video on the analysis of this character. Thank you for your time. I liked and subscribed. Now onto your analysis or Dexter.
great job as always!! ahh, if you ever decide to do another movie, Fight Club would be super interesting!
Oh wow. That would be interesting. I've never thought about that one on a clinical level.
OMG YESSSSSS! The book is really good, too!!!
@@cindyrhodes yes! my favorite book
@@grayhatjen5924 im a psych student now so its like a playground for me haha it helps that its my favorite book/movie too.
@@anyt7183 awesome!!!!!!!!!! His book SURVIVOR is really interesting, too.
I'm loving your channel, Doc. Thank you for doing this.
I'm relieved by the overall conclusion. He would be the wild card even to professionals 😨 and i'm glad that insanity doesnt board on geniality in reality haha
Very neat as always dr G!!
Great video, Dr Grande. Hannibal is my favorite fictional character. I would love to see an analysis of doctor Lecter from the TV show.
doesnt a lack of empathy in this context usually refer to affective empathy vs cognitive? And that it is one of the reasons why people on this spectrum are so good at manipulating people around them. They can read facial expressions and body language, understand what the other person is feeling, while staying detached.
Agree, Hannibal would qualify as having cognitive empathy (of course this would have been important for his work as a psychiatrist) but lacking in emotional empathy
so&so on the couch' book series by dr grande. can't wait!
When you are watching one Dr. Grande video and get a notification for a new Dr. Grande video lol
IKR!!!!!
Grande holding a strait face through this: priceless.
Way to keep control of your emotions. Hehehe
I highly recommend anyone to read the books. They are classics.
Agreed!!!!!!
I'm pretty sure it was very intentional for Lecter to be so unrealistic and unlike typical/real serial killers. I don't think that was just out of ignorance on Harris' part, it seems to be an important element of the character, part of what makes him so intriguing and interesting as a character is that he is so unlike any other killer.
You are awsome Dr G
Love from new Zealand
💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
I recall having to read "Red Dragon" for one of my courses in my doctoral degree program in psychology. It is always interesting to compare the book to the movie. As always, your discussion is highly organized and comprehensive. Thank you so much.
You have do to an analysis of Dexter Morgan from the Show "Dexter".
Great vid. He does have some posh tastes: a penchant for Bentleys, a habit of sketching vistas from European cultural sites on his cell walls, a liking for 'fava beans and a nice Chianti'. One would imagine he's fond of a glass of Chateau Neuf du Pape too!
I've always wondered if there have been people out there who don't fit into anything. Who are anomalies in real life like a Hannibal type person.
Each criminlal is unique , some are organized and/or intelligent... Hannibal have it all, this make him so interesting. A complete analize; well done, dear Dr. Grande! Thank you! P.S: Without Sir Anthony Hopkins, maybe the famous personage would have died in silence...
Fun analysis of a fictional character.
I'm behind on this one. One of the best. Humor point on, Dr. Grande!
Aww Doc, your assessment of Lector has just blown my teenage sentimentality for the creepy character of Lecter right out of the water! But you are dead right... he is not a psychopath, I thought he couldn’t fit factor 2 psychopathy because he was too organised, too calm with no apparent impulsivity, and he didn’t seem to lie - he seemed happy to own what he did, and he didn’t engage in a parasitic lifestyle...
I was excited to hear your analysis but as you you went through each point breaking them down I was sitting here thinking “damn, so what IS Hannibal all about then?” And there we have it - human eating super villian it is - mind blown! 🤯🤯
I wonder if Buffalo Bill, the other serial killer in Silence of the Lambs fits the psychopathy profile more clearly...? I read somewhere Harris based the idea for Buffalo Bill on Ed Gein... but who knows...
I think I have asked you this before, but it would be interesting to hear your take on the Russian mystic Grigori Rasputin.
Thanks for doing this vid.
Thank you so much for one more super analysis, Dr Grande. And congratulations on the 400,000 subscribers! You totally deserve it. May 400,000 more come soon.
His non-lack-of-empathy is what makes him all the more terrifying. A man you truly cannot trust, nor ever truly understand. Defies all your understanding. Scary. Intriguing. Hyper intelligent. We all love it.
I have been waiting a long time for you to give your opinion on ol' Hannibal.
True, Dr Grande... Darth Vader is arguably the #1 villain of all time. I mean, Hannibal might have some incredible abilities, but he never (allegedly) used Force choke!
Great video. You mentioned Darth Vader. Was he already antisocial before he became a Jedi? He was taken from his mother when he was nine. He was raised by Kenobi who had very little compassion for him. He later had a narcissistic partner who excused his behaviour which included genocide of a tribe of sand people. The Jedi did know something was wrong with him but let him command armies during the clone wars because he always won. His tactic in battle was to always attack which was not Jedi like and closer to the behaviour of the Sith. He asked for help because the darkness was tempting him and the Jedi were too arrogant to counsel him properly. He found a father figure in the Emperor who told him whatever he wanted to hear but gave him nothing. Could a good therapist have kept Anakin Skywalker from turning to the dark side? (Provided he wanted help of course. Yeah he may have force choked his therapist)
Oh fabulous! Dissecting the "inscrutable", this should be very interesting! Great job! Cheers Doc!
I was so excited when this came up in my notifications today. I'm a huge fan of the trilogy. I say "trilogy" because I just couldn't get on board with "Hannibal Rising" as a film. I enjoyed the book, though, as well as the TV series.
Another fun fact about the series (that you probably already know) is that the character of Jack Crawford was based on John Douglas, one of the first criminal profilers and creator of the FBI's Criminal Profiling Program. Douglas's books make for an interesting read.
Thank you for another great video!
*No killing and eating clients*. Okay, noted. I'll remember that in my future career endeavors
Great analysis doctor! I much prefer those videos than the drama ones. There is just so much more information here that I can learn from. / Also, a suggestion - children who murder (not only psychopaths but all types, if possible)
Can you please do a video on Prince or Amy Winehouse? Their both so interesting! Thank you very much for your videos!
Oh yes, I would love to see this!
Today is my BD and this is my favorite villain, thanks Dr. Grande.