it’s like this annual groundhog’s day thing, which - I don’t like it - I just want some resolution here. Everytime I watch a needledrop tier list video, it’s like I’m watching it anew and I’m just like “when is this guy gonna troll the person, or the people, watching the video again.”
Even in a joke tier list video Anthony can't bring himself to pretend to feel anything but hatred for Wonderful Christmastime. Drops that shit straight into F.
@@yoitscaptain More listenable than any Hip Hop music tbh. Edit: okay this comment is pretty dumb and i don’t believe it either, countless hip hop songs are better than this song, lay off of me okay?
my very favorite Christmas song is Blue Christmas by Elvis Presley and I don't care if you think it's an Avatar supremacist song Antony, I'm still going to enjoy it.
And the ones that get overplayed overshadow the actual great Christmas songs. I think "Silver bells" for example is fantastic and I would rather hear that song instead of that awful condescending song about Africa not having snow this Christmas
@@brandonayong5823 Very true, and very fair. I was more so referring to songs like All i want for Christmas is you and Last Christmas. In isolation they're both great songs, but with overplay they can definitely become grating.
@@brandonayong5823 Yeah my favorite Christmas song is Marshmallow World. We played it a few times a day when I worked at the Dollar Tree but I otherwise rarely hear it. It’s such a silly fun time. Lil Drummer Boy also slaps. Like, any rendition of it.
That song is so annoying. It is over played asf and tbh I'm sick of hearing it everywhere I go. I wish it would be wiped off the face of the earth so I never have to hear it again
Celebrate Me Home is considered a Christmas song even though there is only one mention of it and it's referred to as "the holidays". That shits in my normal playlist
@@brandonayong5823 That's why I love him though, his dedication to trying something new and the levels of creativity over decades is highly commendable. It just so happened to reach its peak in terms of popularity with this classic christmas banger.
Last Christmas is the undisputed best Christmas song. It’s not even just a good Christmas song, I’d argue it’s one of the greatest songs of all time. Very catchy pop song with lots of layers
Yeah, the best part is he talks exactly the same way about things whether he's being serious or not. Always takes me a minute to realize which way he's going with it.
Frankly he went a bit too far with the whole “wonderful christmastime is F tier” thing, like come on melon we all know it’s your favorite christmas song
The best christmas song is obviously "I want a hippo for Christmas". The lyrics are obviously brillant "No crocodiles or RHINOCEROSESESESSSS I only like HIPPOPOPOTAMUSESSS Mum said the hippo would eat me up but then Teacher said the hippo is a vegetarian" 😂😂😂
This video is a 10. Not only is it immaculate ranking wise, but it has accomplished some absolutely groundbreaking feats such as the experimental repetition of audio near the end and the unfortunate shape of Anthony’s mustache which should be enough to make anyone cry out of embarrassment. Truly one of the videos of all time.
Cbat was robbed! Clearly a interpretation of Tchaikovsky’s Dance Of The Sugar Plum Fairy of the ballet The Nutcracker, I would say it constitutes to a Christmas song!
Idc what anyone says, Wonderful Christmastime is an absolute vibe during the winter, Idk if it’s just nostalgia as a kid or what but that song feels more like Christmas than any other song on this list, I un-ironically enjoy it lol
I never heard the song as a kid, it took until my Beatles-obsessed friend showed it to me but I too now adore it. Completely unironically. I need those synths and bells to know its Christmas, man
I actually don't care, Wonderful Christmastime is so damn good! It always makes me feel like I'm at a wholesome, adult holiday party and everyone is happy to be alive. Love it!
@@ckorp666fuck retail but they play this song all the time at the restaurant I work at and I just bop along while making pizza it’s a good ass song I’m not complaining
yeah, I had no idea it exists and had to go look it up, and honestly it's just as baffling as anything Corey Feldman has ever put out. The man has a gift.
I’m happy to see that you’ve finally focused on the sleigh bells and realized “Wonderful Christmastime” is in fact the greatest Christmas song of all time
I love that Fantano hates Wonderful Christmas so much lol it only makes me love the song more. His stories of how the song makes him feel just crack me the fuck up lol Merry merries melons
I'm aware Fantano is joking about White Christmas. The song annoys me anyway despite liking the non lyric aspects. Why would you want it to be a white Christmas as in snow? One, it makes driving dangerous and two yeah it's totally gonna be a happy time when someone wrecks and dies. Also you may not be able to see your loved ones if the snow is bad enough. Stupid ass song. Therefore the song's lyrics are stupid despite Bing Crosby's voice. Yes I know sledding down a hill is fun, but it ain't worth it if you can't go or if someone dies from the bad weather.
This Christmas by Donny Hathaway is the GOAT Christmas song forever. The only one that doesn't make me want to kill myself when it comes on in my retail work environment.
SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME
6:51 Anthony praises Corey Feldman for paying attention to the sad reality of Christmas 10:53 Anthony criticizes John Lennon for paying attention to the sad reality of Christmas
I didn’t realize this was a joke list at first and kinda second guessed my entire life when I heard that White Christmas was actually about **that** then I saw the next entry
as a mexican i want to agree but its so incredibly repetitive and thats not helped by the fact that it gets massive play. Instruments are pretty solid tho. C tier for me
"Merry Christmas. I wrapped it up and sent it, with a note -- saying i love you -- i meant it..." Masterclass of songwriting by George Michael. The lyrics, melody, and production are so warm that they neuter the songs cynical narrative about a guy whose heart was broken. It's a bonafide classic
I mean they’re beautiful lyrics, but not enough important information has been conveyed. Where was the post office he traveled to to send it? What sort of postage stamps did he use? Did he go into the post office or just drop it in the letter box?
I think that we can all agree that the best christmas song is "A Christmas Fucking Miracle" by Run The Jewels, never fails to get me into the holiday spirit!
I have nostalgia for that song because it used to play on tv bumpers before and after Christmas movies. I never heard the other verses until I worked retail, I only heard the hook They’re garbage, and the best part of the song is literally when it ends
hey Anthony Memetano, I’d honestly be interested in a serious video on old artists vs new artists. Obviously music production changes, technology evolves, and skill gets more refined, but what are your thoughts on (not commercially) how artists would’ve sounded/performed in different eras?
Love the cocteau twins version of Frosty the snowman. one of the most unique Christmas song covers but just not many has heard of it. Hope it'd gain more popularity
best Christmas song to me has gotta be “Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)”. There’s just something about it idk, Darlene love’s vocal performance comes off so genuine.
'Danny Says' by The Ramones is another Phil Spector-produced xmas classic. But my personal faves are Fairytale of New York, and (I Wish it could be) Xmas Everday.
There are some S-tier cuts on A Christmas Gift for You from Phil Spector for sure. With that said, I think I'll always prefer the December LP by George Winston.
I’m glad I’m British because if that’s the only choices in the U.S. then you’ve been missing out for donkeys years on some of the best Christmas songs in my opinion ,best era glam rock early 70s/80s Brit releases = slade,wizard,shakey,mud,showaddywaddy, and loads more that never made it to the U.S.
Me, my mom, and my grandmother all LOVE dominick the italian christmas donkey! Listen to it every year. I show it to people all the time and i legitimately don't know why more people don't know about it.
Actually on the 12 days of Christmas you would end up with 184 birds. Each day of the 12 days of Christmas you get the previous gift and a new gift totaling to 364 gifts by the end of the 12 days.
That’s what I was thinking, I always thought it was about snow and everything I could find online supports that, I’m really hoping the internet is right
when "copy and paste" is the best possible joke when "copy and paste" is the best possible joke when "copy and paste" is the best possible joke when "copy and paste" is the best possible joke
Everytime I watch a needledrop tier list, I feel like I'm stuck in this endless feedback loops that I want to get out of.
Everytime I watch a needledrop tier list, I feel like I'm stuck in this endless feedback loops that I want to get out of.
Needledrop tier list tier list when
Everytime I watch a needledrop tier list, I feel like I'm stuck in this endless feedback loops that I want to get out of.
it’s like this annual groundhog’s day thing, which - I don’t like it - I just want some resolution here. Everytime I watch a needledrop tier list video, it’s like I’m watching it anew and I’m just like “when is this guy gonna troll the person, or the people, watching the video again.”
Fantano da 🐐 no 🧢
Even in a joke tier list video Anthony can't bring himself to pretend to feel anything but hatred for Wonderful Christmastime. Drops that shit straight into F.
LOL
I got so excited to see him talk about it even though I like it
it deserves to be there, that shit is straight ass
@@yoitscaptain More listenable than any Hip Hop music tbh.
Edit: okay this comment is pretty dumb and i don’t believe it either, countless hip hop songs are better than this song, lay off of me okay?
@@thirdhandlv4231 🤡🤡🤡
I was crying from happiness when fantano said twinkle twinkle little bitch was, in fact, the greatest Christmas song of all time
Personally I prefer sitting around the stereo with the family and listening to ABCDEFU
@@fluorideenjoyer NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
@@fluorideenjoyer also a great choice
every time i see that pfp i think of my old friend pau
I can’t believe this guy put White Christmas in its own S tier? Didn’t know fantano was a Crosby sympathizer, really weird video to say the least.
my very favorite Christmas song is Blue Christmas by Elvis Presley and I don't care if you think it's an Avatar supremacist song Antony, I'm still going to enjoy it.
Smh Elvis is always stealing song credit. That song was originally by the band low!
Snow isnt blue elvis🙄
The issue with a lot of Christmas music is more so the fact that a lot of it gets overplayed, and not so much that the music itself is bad.
And the ones that get overplayed overshadow the actual great Christmas songs. I think "Silver bells" for example is fantastic and I would rather hear that song instead of that awful condescending song about Africa not having snow this Christmas
@@brandonayong5823 Very true, and very fair. I was more so referring to songs like All i want for Christmas is you and Last Christmas. In isolation they're both great songs, but with overplay they can definitely become grating.
@@camsons true. Last Christmas is the better song in my opinion though
@@brandonayong5823 Yeah my favorite Christmas song is Marshmallow World. We played it a few times a day when I worked at the Dollar Tree but I otherwise rarely hear it. It’s such a silly fun time. Lil Drummer Boy also slaps. Like, any rendition of it.
Yeah but they only get overplayed for like a month
Anthony sounded so serious when talking about White Christmas that I went and searched up the lyrics thinking I would find out the song was racist 😭
glad i wasn’t the only one lol😭
White Christmas= the snow falling down
Merrythony Christano
Last Christmas S Tier
Based
Based
Based
That song is so annoying. It is over played asf and tbh I'm sick of hearing it everywhere I go. I wish it would be wiped off the face of the earth so I never have to hear it again
BASED
Last Christmas by Wham is the only christmas song I'd actively listen to outside of the holiday season.
Fairytale Of New York tho
Same with hny from abba
Fairytale of New York and When the Thames Froze as well
Check out reindeer games by froggy fresh 👍
Celebrate Me Home is considered a Christmas song even though there is only one mention of it and it's referred to as "the holidays". That shits in my normal playlist
The annual Wonderful Christmastime cameo.
Glad to see you've finally come around and given it the well deserved S tier after all these years.
It’s the song of all time. When Paul says “simply having a wonderful christmastime”, I felt that
I think that album also had that "TeMpOrArY sEcReTaRy" song which I hate.. Love Paul mccartney but I don't know what he was on on this album
the synths on that song give me so much deep bright saturated VHS purple
@@brandonayong5823 That's why I love him though, his dedication to trying something new and the levels of creativity over decades is highly commendable.
It just so happened to reach its peak in terms of popularity with this classic christmas banger.
@@brandonayong5823 Temporary Secretary goes hard
Last Christmas is the undisputed best Christmas song. It’s not even just a good Christmas song, I’d argue it’s one of the greatest songs of all time. Very catchy pop song with lots of layers
Nothing like hearing that song when Christmas shopping at a Macy’s
Fairytale of New York and last Christmas are the best Xmas songs
Wrong opinion, Fairytale of New York stands undisputed
to quote trump: wrong @@sirpsychosussy
it wouldn't even be considered a Christmas song if the word Christmas wasn't in it
The back and forth of serious and comedic feedback is giving me whiplash. Good video. Merry Christmas, Melon.
Yeah, the best part is he talks exactly the same way about things whether he's being serious or not. Always takes me a minute to realize which way he's going with it.
I can’t tell wether he’s fucking with us, or if he actually thinks Feliz Navidad is a banger.
Frankly he went a bit too far with the whole “wonderful christmastime is F tier” thing, like come on melon we all know it’s your favorite christmas song
@@duckywinks I mean, Feliz Navidad is absolutely unironically a banger.
America is missing out on some really great Christmas songs by Elton John, The Pogues, Jona Lewie, Slade, Wizzard, The Darkness, Chris Rea, Mud etc…
Brave of you to put Wonderful Christmastime in the S tier, Melon. That is indeed the Christmas song ever.
The best christmas song is obviously "I want a hippo for Christmas". The lyrics are obviously brillant
"No crocodiles or RHINOCEROSESESESSSS
I only like HIPPOPOPOTAMUSESSS
Mum said the hippo would eat me up but then
Teacher said the hippo is a vegetarian"
😂😂😂
Wonderful Christmastime is in fantano's S Tier?
He has to be joking.
@@kenterminateddq5311 you have a problem with wonderful Christmastime in A tier?
Bladee’s Frosty the Snowman is truly a Christmas classic
She a nympho I’m not really sh*t tho
i’m not special i’m not special
you’re just like mee im not special ❄️ ☃️
FROSTY DA SNOWMAN GOIN IM GOIN
CAN'T EVEN PICK UP THE PHONE EVERYTHING IS CANCELED
the whole icedancer is
I unironically like Wonderful Christmastime and I'm tired of pretending I don't.
Growing up I always thought he was saying
"She'll be having a wonderful christmas time"
@@brandonayong5823 I used to hear "Sidney having a wonderful Christmastime"
I kept thinking to myself "Who the heck is Sidney?"
@@my_name_sucks 😂😂😂 Australia is killing it at Christmas time 😂😂😂
I love wonderful Christmastime, 3rd best xmas song behind feliz navidad and marys boychild
Same
This video is a 10. Not only is it immaculate ranking wise, but it has accomplished some absolutely groundbreaking feats such as the experimental repetition of audio near the end and the unfortunate shape of Anthony’s mustache which should be enough to make anyone cry out of embarrassment. Truly one of the videos of all time.
Criminal that the Charlie Brown Christmas album wasn’t mentioned. That is unironically on my top ten albums of all time.
Cbat was robbed!
Clearly a interpretation of Tchaikovsky’s Dance Of The Sugar Plum Fairy of the ballet The Nutcracker, I would say it constitutes to a Christmas song!
Tchaikovsky is crying violently in his grave
Wua wawa wa wawawa-wa
I loved that you kept the "Last Christmas" on an endless loop. Reminds me of a movie that doesn't have an 'S' in the title
This very quickly went off the rails and I love this tierlist for that reason. Couldn’t stop smiling
frosty the snowman by bladee was so good that it took up two tiers
Idc what anyone says, Wonderful Christmastime is an absolute vibe during the winter, Idk if it’s just nostalgia as a kid or what but that song feels more like Christmas than any other song on this list, I un-ironically enjoy it lol
L take Wonderful Christmastime can go take a walk off a cliff
It's definitely just nostalgia
I never heard the song as a kid, it took until my Beatles-obsessed friend showed it to me but I too now adore it. Completely unironically. I need those synths and bells to know its Christmas, man
Drifters version of White Christmas js a certified banger tho
💯💯💯
Both are S tier.
Guess it’s not as racist!
Can’t believe I just listened to the old White Christmas looking for racist lyrics lol. There’s nothing, just a song about white snow
Dadoodadoo
I've never quite understood Anthony's hatred for wonderful christmastime, deffo one of the more musically charming contemporary christmas songs imo
The white Christmas take had me dying
Every time I watch this video I feel like I'm stuck in this endless feedback loop that I wanna get out of but fantano is holding me there
Anthony stop, the minimal synths in Wonderful Christmastime goes, and will always go. It’s up there with Plaid and Brothomstates as melodic beauty.
I hold nothing but hate and contempt for Feliz Navidad because I was forced to sing it EVERY YEAR in the christmas program at school.
I was genuinely starting to worry that I was losing my mind during the feedback loop.
John Lennon's "happy Xmas (War Is Over)" deserves an honorable mention I think
for me Last Christmas remains undefeated to this day
"Please sun don't be late" - Truly one of the forgotten classics by the Beatles
Here it comes
Leave it be
unpopular opinion but there's a charm to wonderful christmastime that I can't explain
Thank you! I love it and it’s always considered one of the worst Christmas songs and I don’t get it!
It's the funny synths
The chords are genuinely cool. I think it’s the vocals that are annoying
Yeah I love the song
s+ tier
I actually don't care, Wonderful Christmastime is so damn good! It always makes me feel like I'm at a wholesome, adult holiday party and everyone is happy to be alive. Love it!
A hot take for sure.
@@turnerflorence9658 It literally isn't.
@ckorp666 I remember listening to step into Christmas atleast 20 or so times a day
@@ckorp666fuck retail but they play this song all the time at the restaurant I work at and I just bop along while making pizza it’s a good ass song I’m not complaining
It seems that you do actually care
I'm an unironic wonderful christmastime enjoyer and I'm tired of pretending I'm not
same. it’s my fave
Same! So good!
W
It does feel like the ultimate conclusion to John's "granny music" comments...but I do really like the synth in it to be honest
Your comedic chops are crazy talented, you and ryan are creative beyond belief, merry christmas!!
Who is Ryan?
I was gonna make some joke but the "Italianx" line in the video is more funny than anything I can come up with
Dude, White Christmas is about snow. Like, cocaine.
Chipmunks "Don't Be Late" is an anti-leap year song
Not late per se, but it takes another day to get there
Literally thought Anthony was trolling us with the existence of that Corey Feldman cover but, alas, it is real
yeah, I had no idea it exists and had to go look it up, and honestly it's just as baffling as anything Corey Feldman has ever put out. The man has a gift.
Wonderful Christmas time is so hated that I love it now. Thanks Fantano
I’m happy to see that you’ve finally focused on the sleigh bells and realized “Wonderful Christmastime” is in fact the greatest Christmas song of all time
Yessir
Anthony really out here making it a tradition to shit on Wonderful Christmas Time each year.
It's so funny to me Fantano pretending to be dead serious when he is clearly joking.
I love that Fantano hates Wonderful Christmas so much lol it only makes me love the song more. His stories of how the song makes him feel just crack me the fuck up lol
Merry merries melons
couldn’t stop laughing when the dominick the donkey cover changed
You can't make me hate Wonderful Christmastime Mr Melon Man, I will love it forever
I don’t think I’d classify Angelic 2 the Core as a Christmas song Fantano, but I’m glad to see you put it in S tier regardless
I love that Corey Feldman is actually mentioned here
fantano's woke read of "White Christmas" had my bells jingling with merriment
The worst thing is that he was insinuating it was racist when the title is hinting at snow
@@danielday1459 yeah sure it’s about snow, bigot
read the lyrics and you’ll see how blatantly racist the song is
@@danielday1459 the worst thing is that you believed he was serious
@@danielday1459 fantano was joking. This whole tier list is a joke.
@@cianlynch6494 the song is literally describing snow
Very bold of you to give Lil Nas X’s Holiday the first ever S+ tier placement
Fairytale of New York, Christmas time (don't let the bells end) driving home for Christmas and killing in the name are all s tier
0:52 Lords of leaping are the best kind of birds
Maids a milking would be my choice
@@jasperfk need some maids to milk me fr
old tracks S tier: White Christmas
new track S tier: Last Christmas
I'm aware Fantano is joking about White Christmas.
The song annoys me anyway despite liking the non lyric aspects. Why would you want it to be a white Christmas as in snow? One, it makes driving dangerous and two yeah it's totally gonna be a happy time when someone wrecks and dies. Also you may not be able to see your loved ones if the snow is bad enough. Stupid ass song. Therefore the song's lyrics are stupid despite Bing Crosby's voice. Yes I know sledding down a hill is fun, but it ain't worth it if you can't go or if someone dies from the bad weather.
This Christmas by Donny Hathaway is the GOAT Christmas song forever. The only one that doesn't make me want to kill myself when it comes on in my retail work environment.
2:30 genuinely surprised melon didn't put a disclaimer after that joke because you KNOW people are going to think he meant that seriously.
It’s weird how the cringe humor of Cal Chusesta is right up my alley, but his joke tier list videos are just annoying lol
Same but I'm starting to think the whole video is satire
Are we just gonna pretend that Wonderful Christmastime isn't a bop that spearheaded bedroom pop into the mainstream?????
SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIMESIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME SIMPLY HAVING A WONDERFUL CHRISTMASTIME
David Bowie’s version of the little Drummer boy is an easy s-tier
6:51 Anthony praises Corey Feldman for paying attention to the sad reality of Christmas
10:53 Anthony criticizes John Lennon for paying attention to the sad reality of Christmas
Last Christmas definitely S tier as is all I want for Christmas is you idc how much it’s overplayed
I didn’t realize this was a joke list at first and kinda second guessed my entire life when I heard that White Christmas was actually about **that**
then I saw the next entry
as someone from hispanic heritage, seeing Feliz navidad in the S tier is goated
as a mexican i want to agree but its so incredibly repetitive and thats not helped by the fact that it gets massive play. Instruments are pretty solid tho. C tier for me
"Merry Christmas. I wrapped it up and sent it, with a note -- saying i love you -- i meant it..." Masterclass of songwriting by George Michael. The lyrics, melody, and production are so warm that they neuter the songs cynical narrative about a guy whose heart was broken. It's a bonafide classic
SMH: "Last Christmas" by Wham!
I mean they’re beautiful lyrics, but not enough important information has been conveyed. Where was the post office he traveled to to send it? What sort of postage stamps did he use? Did he go into the post office or just drop it in the letter box?
*”Happy Christmas…”
I think that we can all agree that the best christmas song is "A Christmas Fucking Miracle" by Run The Jewels, never fails to get me into the holiday spirit!
This and RTJ3 dropping on Christmas in 2016 prove Run the Jewels are the greatest Christmas hip hop duo ever
Everytime I hear this song...
I love wonderful christmastime
I have nostalgia for that song because it used to play on tv bumpers before and after Christmas movies.
I never heard the other verses until I worked retail, I only heard the hook
They’re garbage, and the best part of the song is literally when it ends
hey Anthony Memetano, I’d honestly be interested in a serious video on old artists vs new artists.
Obviously music production changes, technology evolves, and skill gets more refined, but what are your thoughts on (not commercially) how artists would’ve sounded/performed in different eras?
Love the cocteau twins version of Frosty the snowman. one of the most unique Christmas song covers but just not many has heard of it. Hope it'd gain more popularity
I want to know where Bing Crosby was on Jan. 6
thank you anthony for ranking last christmas 7 times 🙏
0:50 "Why so many Birds?" *Brennan Lee Mulligan enters the chat*
I thought white christmas was about the snow or cocaine. Thank you Melon for helping correct my mistake
it's about snow lol. fantano just wants everyting to be racist and problematic
@@FeedRevo Yeah he was definitely just meming
@@FeedRevo so funny how u missed the joke lol. he literally said italianx in this video do u honestly think he was being serious💀💀
The end of this video is proof to me that melon is still a master shitposter
I love this shit-post/tier list hybrid format.
How do you spell the word at 12:10 ? when he says "I feel almost ... at this point"
best Christmas song to me has gotta be “Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)”. There’s just something about it idk, Darlene love’s vocal performance comes off so genuine.
'Danny Says' by The Ramones is another Phil Spector-produced xmas classic. But my personal faves are Fairytale of New York, and (I Wish it could be) Xmas Everday.
Unanimously agree
There are some S-tier cuts on A Christmas Gift for You from Phil Spector for sure. With that said, I think I'll always prefer the December LP by George Winston.
The only good cover of that song is the mariah one tbh
Lies and deciet. After 12 days of Christmas, you will have acquired 184 birds.
Christmas Wrapping by The Waitresses is an S Tier for sure.
John Lennon’s “This is Christmas” is one of my favourite Christmas songs
How could you forget the Christmas classic, “Grandma got run over by a Reindeer”?
I’m glad I’m British because if that’s the only choices in the U.S. then you’ve been missing out for donkeys years on some of the best Christmas songs in my opinion ,best era glam rock early 70s/80s Brit releases = slade,wizard,shakey,mud,showaddywaddy, and loads more that never made it to the U.S.
No Fairytale of New York 😢 that’s the best Christmas song of all time
Fantano has messed with my head so much and some of these songs are so ridiculous I had to check if they were real
"Wonderful Christmastime" really isn't that bad.
Me, my mom, and my grandmother all LOVE dominick the italian christmas donkey! Listen to it every year. I show it to people all the time and i legitimately don't know why more people don't know about it.
I don't know about you people, but Don't Be A Jerk (It's Christmas) is unironically one of my favorite Christmas songs.
Bro that song is a *BANGER*
Spongebob bangin fr fr
@@doctortedums607 SpongeBob always drop nothing but bangers. Not just episodes, but also music.
@@themaddestvillain-g4q I know, Goofy Goober Rock man.
@@themaddestvillain-g4q Ripped Pants is an unrecognized masterpiece
Can’t believe he didn’t tier last Christmas
So glad someone finally realized the Robin Pecknold meant White Winter Hymnal to be a Christmas classic
The five gold rings in the twelve days of Christmas are apparently actually gold-ringed pheasants, so that’s 7 consecutive days of birds.
Thanks for the existential crisis at the end of the video, Anthony. Really fit the Christmas spirit!
Actually on the 12 days of Christmas you would end up with 184 birds.
Each day of the 12 days of Christmas you get the previous gift and a new gift totaling to 364 gifts by the end of the 12 days.
Yessir! We Italians need more artistic representation. Make Dominic mainstream again!
Any version of Carol of the Bells is S tier
whole lotta red is a christmas album
Attempting to name all the reindeer for 20 minutes isnt a tier list Mr. Fantano
I think Wonderful Christmastime may have just beaten Revival's record for Melon's fastest and most heartfelt F Tier placement
The ending made me feel like I was losing my mind
Wait were you memeing about White Christmas? I can’t find anything suggesting that the true meaning was about race for the song
That’s what I was thinking, I always thought it was about snow and everything I could find online supports that, I’m really hoping the internet is right
He was joking!; i was super shocked at first too, then realize he was totally trolling the whole video!🫣🤠
when "copy and paste" is the best possible joke
when "copy and paste" is the best possible joke
when "copy and paste" is the best possible joke
when "copy and paste" is the best possible joke