No Man's Sky: Grit
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 ก.ค. 2024
- A small and unlikely team was behind one of the most ambitious and anticipated games of 2016. In this 2019 GDC Main Stage session, Hello Games' Sean Murray takes us behind the scenes during the intense and dramatic launch of one the biggest selling new IPs in recent years. He demonstrates how his team found the grit to deal with releasing an innovative and polarizing game into an increasingly vocal gaming landscape, and details how through determination and love in 2019 they have built to record player numbers and positivity amongst their most negative detractors. This candid and open discussion will show the power of focusing on what you do, rather than what you say, in the face of adversity. -- Watch live at / gdc
- เกม
Sean and HG decided to go old school, after being caught up in the new school and letting/having it nearly ruin them. Their strategy after the release catastrophe was simple: We don't listen to what people are saying unless it helps us make the game better. They didn't listen to the press, the hype, the expectations, the noise. They listened to the people who were playing their game who wished it was better. And they made a game that they wanted to play too. And it fucking worked.
You could tell pretty early on that Sean had a passion for this game that was matched by few for any single project in their lives. His descriptions of the potentials before the game I don't think were him lying, I think they were him dreaming. I think he truly intended to try to make the game what he promised from the beginning. Because you don't spend 5 years afterwards as a game studio supporting a game with massive amounts of content for free without loving that game. Sean and the HG team went on a labor of love to fix what they had made into what they had wanted to make. And it fucking shows.
In 2019, the game would have just been released early access on Steam, and they would have spent 3 years building the game to a 1.0 state, and then probably would have kept going even then. This would have saved them SO much, but it wouldn't be the game it is today if that had happened. The absolute beating this guy took in the press after the release was channeled directly into proving that he wanted to fix it. And he fucking did.
Good job guys. I love the game.
I was surprised a little about how much emotion was involved. It is easy to forget that developers are human and do care what people think about their work. It isn't all about the money.
They are a small indie team! They don't have a dedicated PR person!
@Joe Ç he is the founder and Managing Director of Hello Games so i'm not sure who you think he left to deal with the backlash
Ever seen how much a game developer gets paid on average? They're definitely not doing it only for the money.
Watched this after I noticed snippets of this used in "The Engoodening of No Man's Sky". Inspiring, honest, and creative speech - Sean should be proud of what he's done.
That was a powerful statement. "Everything is just data" and how much was able to br drawn from this assumption. Analyzing the data to even find its root and dissociate useless data ( noise ). Man. Much respect
Well they pulled it together, better to do that before launch in most cases, but I give them mad props for getting there and not giving up like so many others.
6:52 “...making games for people who want to play them.”
That’s the dream.
Brutal.
A dream that used to be the norm.
But the amount of work made after release is amazing, very nice job done
I agree, that is indeed amazing. I still find it disturbing though that he talks as if they had become victims of some random natural disaster when what happened was clearly their own fault.
Haekels yes, it was their fault only.
Haekels he still got one big lie behind his back - clouds. Just watch the NEXT trailer and actual NEXT clouds and compare
@@Haekels
I am not sure if it was their fault when literally their studio got flooded from a natural disaster and destroyed their first universe generator...
@@tobiasskorupa1649 Well, did the flood also publish trailers that showed tons of features like massive fleet battles, huge sand worms etc. that were never in the game? Or did the flood give interviews suggesting it is possible to meet other players in the game? (Which is possible now, to their credit)
Thank you Sean! As a software developer/engineer (who doesn't make games) I found this extremely motivational and plan on sharing it wtih my teams.
Hey my art is at 7:04 ! I made the journal entries. Super cool to see it here :D
This is an awesome talk. I think the No Mans Sky story is going to be remembered as something extremely positive. And this talk shows how that was able to happen. Passionate people working passionately. Hard work and love for games.
I'll agree that it had a terrible launch, but No Man's Sky is far better now than it ever has been and I actually like playing it. I'm seriously looking forward to the VR support later this summer. :)
This game is so fucking good now!
As a musician I can attest to that aspect of the creative process. Writing the song is fun, and everything else that comes after is less fun with occasional spikes of fulfillment. Recording is brutal. Mixing is brutal. Ultimately the song never comes out exactly as you envisioned it, and you consider it done and upload it somewhere only when you're so close to hating it that working on it any further means you might scrap the whole thing and start over. Again.
I'm getting the Valve index and use it for playing No Man's Sky.
"You only get one chance to make the first impression."
I feel bad for him and his team but Sean's resolve is incredible. What a resilient guy and studio and I hope they continue to make games in the future.
Inspiring and honest talk, really great. Thank you
Well done, you've turned it around. Looking forward to what you do next.
and beyond.
I personally believe that no mans sky was garbage when it first came out, however I gave 0 shits about most things, I played it for alittle bit, got bored, not really sure why I got bored, I think other games just had my attention. Anyways the game progressed and got another update, I played for a bit, played about 30 hours but got bored again, there wasnt much that you could do. Then next came out. I enjoy exploring but when there is nothing but bs to explore it gets boring, now however the game is at a point where since next came out I've put 130 hours into no mans sky, just played for 2 hours this morning.
I'm also thinking about buying a vr headset just so I can play the vr part of the game come beyond update. However, I expect that these guys at hello games have more to do. This game better not be done and they really should work on more depth of the game, I expect life to be put into the game, or at least the possiblity of life, I want to fly to a desert planet and encounter giant sand worms, I want to see low medium and high tech civilizations on planets, while rare I want to see colonies on planets, currently if a player is offline I would love to see them at their base, I would also love to see a way to send signals into space from our bases. The point of these signals should be to encourage encounters with other players. I also want to see more done with freighters and frigates, like being able to add more inventory slots to the outside of our freighters, being able to upgrade our ships weapons on the freighters and being able to recruit people from the endless space stations we encounter for a fee to be able to work on our frigates and freighter. I also want to see the option to fly your frigates to other galaxies while you are on the frigate and from there command the frigate to do tasks on certain planets like going and mining certain ore for instance.
I would love 100% to see in the future a different enemy other then the sentinals, actual enemies you can fight against on different kinds of planets. I want the ability to capture creatures and put them into a zoo. In space or on planets, should be planets that they can survive on. Then of course sending out signals for others to come see. The point should also be to populate planets, maybe with clones? Idk anyways just some ideas as this comment gets lost in the comment section. If you do read this and like my ideas by all means please like the comment so others can see.
Well, now in 2021, all of it is here.
Find your metric for success. Hum, wise words. I think this is a moto that most of us can apply to life in general. Find that metric, and optimize for it ! Ever since adopting this moto i've been a lot more productive, and happier in my own personal job. Thanks Sean :)
Very good presentation. Not only for developers, but good teachings for everyday life for everyone.
I wish I had seen this while I was at GDC ✨ Amazing to hear this perspective on his journey
It was indeed an intense release back in the days!
All game companies are full of amazing talents. All they need is good feedbacks from genuine players.
This is a great video as it shows the No Man's Sky launch from the developer's perspective. I admire that they stuck with the game and made it into something better.
Sean I never doubted you, I hope You guys know there are many of us who never doubted you. We understood what happened, and what was happening the entire time. I had sent a job application to Hello games several times, because I really did feel like your studio was more a family than just a team. back then I was too inexpirienced to get into a studio such as yours. But now that I work in the industry and am moving towards making my own game, I find that your formula is my blueprint, you guys have shown what true passion for one's work really means. Unfortunately so many people are backwards, they lack the insight to see what is trully important.
I hope I get to meet you one day, best of luck!
It's one thing for games to change during development but he was still talking about features that ended up missing within days of release. Looking back further even some of that early stuff is pretty questionable, like saying one of the gameplay demos was totally unscripted when people found the files for these presentations in the final games code.
Yea it's amazing how he never really addresses it. Closest he has ever gotten to addressing it directly, that I'm aware of, is him saying that they are bad at marketing, which is so close to being there, but then he comes to stage talking about toxicity while avoiding the reasons that led to that toxicity.
Not that getting death threats and harassment to extent that they did is not bad toxicity. Props for going through with the vision though.
Those interviews may have been uploaded close to launch, but filmed much earlier. One just doesn't know.
As for the game demo stuff, that is common practice. In fact it's rather stupid to not provide a failsafe stage presentation (especially for such a staggeringly complex game as NMS with so much room for error.)
But if you're right, and they knowingly lied about these features solely to attract more sales - as scummy as that would be, I think they learned their lesson as soon as the backlash and the death threats started coming in.
@@Diesel_Budgie At the very least, Murray was (somehow) on Stephen Colbert's talk show, which are usually filmed the day or week of the show.
@@noobingame9291The toxicity he's referring to is things that go beyond criticism and enter hatred and harassment. This includes death threats the studio got, but not just that
What is the first thing?
Much love Sean and Hello games! ♡
Who else was really fucking confused when the woman in the bottom right just changed all of a sudden.
Was it the intent to release this on April 1st?
Probably none, since it was possible to find this before. I think I saw it 2 days ago. Not necessary to wait for the official gdc channel to upload it xD
They should not give this man a stage. I get his side of the story but in the end lack of integrity should not be supported.
@Cyberian Korniger - In what universe is fixing past mistakes to the extent they not only meet but exceed the expectations at launch, all while releasing content updates for free, not considered "intergrity"?
This issue may have been stated already, but could the sign language PiP be placed in another area NOT blocked by an obtrusive watermark? I can hear, but I noticed the signs are a bit hard to see at times with the watermark in front of them.
Edgar Onukwugha off topic, for some reason I assumed the hearing impaired just used youtube’s automatic subtitles? They’re pretty good
No, they really aren't. They're only good if someone goes in later to edit to fix errors.
What did I say to offend/confuse everyone? I don't understand the hostility here.
@@REXanadu I didn't notice any hostility unless some comments have been removed now. Also I don't see a watermark. Did they remove it now?
All I see is the link to the GDC channel, and that can be hidden by turning off annotations. Is that what you're referring to?
It takes enormous strength of character to keep moving forward and keep improving things instead of just giving up. Respect.
What an unconventional dude. I really like him and I wish him all the best. Also, NMS is awesome.
A gentle and unassuming genius.
Fuck i know the game was shit at launch but imagine working hard on a project and having to get up at gdc and having to defend your art for the first few years or however long it was from launch. Dudes shakin so hard. I think the devs have done an awesome job of fixing the game and that they just fixed the original game instead of making us pay for a massive dlc or new game was awesome.
I traded a 25 dollar gift/game on steam for this game when everyone was jumping overboard on it at the start, knowing and having full faith that they'd fix it- I don't regret it at all. haha
"Better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to speak and to remove all doubt.
"
-Mostly attributed to ABRAHAM LINCOLN.
Proverbs 17:28
Thank you for sharing your insights Sean. Congratulations on your successful recovery with this title. What you guys have done is Amazing.
What kind of "insights" do you get from watching this video?
Im just curious.
Insight #1: Players never have any clue of how hard it is to make the game. Or they don't really care.
Insight #2: Few people will help you do stuff and fix problems, because its harder. Hating is easy.
Insight #3: If you've screwed up, nobody will care about the size of your team, or problems you had, or demands that have placed on you by irrelevant people.
Insight #4: Modern press sucks balls. Always.
Insight #5: Serve the people who support what you're doing, not the people who hate it.
@@EugeneParallax Non of it worth to be called as insight because all of this statements are obvious or falls.
Also about #1
When you buying a car with abs and climate control its fair to expect that they are installed and work properly same as car should be working fine.
But when it came to the gamedev we should be felling sorry and cheerful despite the fact that advertised unicorns happen to be a crippled donkey.
I don't think that I should cheer for a scammer or for a person who just doing their job if I wanna buy a cup of coffee and if its not what I expected I don't cheer for barista I just go to another place and its NORMAL.
Player are customers and they shouldn't flirt with you or act like your friends to get their product
@@EugeneParallax #2 If you released a broken product its your god damn job to fix it. You are responsible for that and pushing your responsibilities/expecting someone else to do your job hmm its more than silly but yet somehow ok for game developers O____o.
@@EugeneParallax #4 You don't have to watch this to learn that. If you are elder than 12 I suppose you already knew that media are full of shit damn they even call it post-truth era.
Surprised i enjoyed this
It’s a really interesting point that the top games right now had a rough start
I've noticed this too. It used to be that a final version of the game would only be released once development was complete. Maybe a patch or two would come post-release.
Now devs will release a game at 50% completion, test the reception for it and then decide whether or not to do the other 50% of the original plan and beyond.
I think it's a great business model for studios.
Hats of to hello game team. I hope have many success in the futture
Fantastic talk
beep boop look who it is
I see so many people still holding grudges against this man and NMS. I think thats totally unfair. Yes it disapointed us, yes it was unfinished and that was terrible of them but I mostly blame the hype and the fans. This is a damn good game today and I will always defend it!
don't worry, they got censored. don't they know making money is more important than telling the truth?!
I think Sean was the one that hyped the game the most. In many of his interviews, before the game launched, Sean was promising features that weren’t added until now. But I agree, he did not deserve any of the toxic comments and hate that he received. He doesn’t strike me as someone who is just in it for the money. What I got from the interviews was that he was really excited for people to play his game. Maybe he was just a bit in over his head.
You do realize that you are agreeing with the people who you are saying are being unfair, right?
Death threats aside, the devs completely created the hype and disappointment and even broke marketing laws in the process. They made the bed, now they sleep in it.
@@NathanGatten Sure they fucked up the start and promissed to much what they could not deliver. On the other hand, they didn't run with the money but gone silient and worked on the game and delivered free updates for years now.
So I have mixed feelings about this game and the devs, but most times. For me they could get a second chance because they acted to improve the game depite all the hate. Still they're not off the hock if they promisse something big in the future but I would forgive them for their past.
Given the entire video seems to be dedicated towards his grudge towards his users, it's warranted. This never should have been a video
Exactly what Relic Didn’t do with Dawn of War III! Shame on you Relic! You let the fans down!
Can't agree more. It feels painful and sour just thinking about the effort developeres have put into DoW3, and the game ended up pretty good to say the least, in my opinion, and that it has been just thrown into the dumpster because some infantile morons in so-called "fanbase" made it their mission to *make it fail.*
It could've been such a great game... unfortunately, I still don't know what Relic could've done to make it work. They couldn't control the Steam reviews, and that's what made the game unprofitable in the end.
@@EugeneParallax No developer should ever be able to control the reviews of their product.
@@viesturssilins858 Perhaps, but no players should be able to write a review consisting of false information and without the merit of playing the game for a while. Otherwise you'd get exactly what happened with DoW3 - a good game demolished by thousands of negative reviews full of personal bias and lies and without actual informative content.
I like this man. No matter how bad it was for No Man's Sky, this guy stood by his team and company.
Imagine using 60 dollars on a game that isn't what you thought it was suppose to be. That sucks! I understand the anger and regret.
Now imagine somehow ignoring the fact that the gaming industry is the most anti-consumer/anti-worker industry, and the vast majority of marketing is fake or manipulative, yet there are multiple media outlets that can tell you of the experience, almost immediately, but your fomo has you throwing money left and right, maybe even a season pass too, 'cause God forbid you're not there playing day one, shouting on Twitter about a fucking video game.
To your surprise, you bought into enthusiastic drivel, and that really sucked, but now, in spite of how dumb your choice obviously was, you don't make it a lesson to learn from, but instead you try and not lose face, ny holding a grudge against one guy.
Imagine all of the above, yet the one guy you hate tries to make up for it, and somehow manages, and here we are, with your sorry ass unable to forgive, because you felt cheated, seeing as you have yet to understand how things work.
Here's a lesson for the slow ones out there: When someone tells you a product is the best ever, but the same person makes a living selling you this product, please, sit down and consider the salesman's logic here... Is he 1) doing you a favour? Or 2) trying to make a living?
Sean Murray has done good.
It's good to see people enjoy No Man's Sky, and I applaud those who were patient and forgiving.
Good day.
I don't agree with all of your points, but I get your main message. A little perspective and emotional control goes a long way with your purchasing choices, among other things.. Consumers will never take any of the blame for their own hype machine.
What an amazing talk.
that was a good talk
How is holding a grudge against him for his trip up at launch, any way mature or rational?
The same way he holding a grudge enough to make this video is?
@@NeoTechni Can you reiterate that in English?
@@mundylunes7755 that was in english. He held a grudge enough to make this video, so complaining about the grudges of those he scammed isn't logical.
Thought this was an April Fools
Even here you only find people critisizing. Guys get over with that negativity... They did a great job. Mistakes can be forgiven. And he knows his mistakes. It wasnt about greed. It was about talking what he wants to do and not what was in the games. And if you look at it like that then he 150% delivered so far. Communication isnt easy. Especially if all media is trying to get every piece of information out of you.
99% of the people raving about the same past things wouldnt have done it better including myself probably
Keep going Sean
They didn't do a great job. And they were dishonest. And then they smoothed it over with corporate marketing speak. Fuck these guys. They're just proof that bad games can be financial successes inspite of poor quality and well-earned dislike for the developers.
@@Yakri
Cheesus Christ mang. Move on!
I rewatched all the gameplay they showed and some of the interviews and in hindsight we got most of it and by now even more and will get way more for free.
And dont try to argue. I will no more respond
@@GianniLeonhart
Point taken 🤣
"Guys get over with that negativity"
Him first.
STILL NO DESERT WORMS SEAN
Appreciate the work and the comeback. XD
A good talk from a good dev. It's scope that caught him off guard. Having a small team and large goals in an industry where triple-A is the console gamer's default under a publisher that intended to support Indies but did not (not really).
Shame about the trailer...You don't recover from that...
No Man Sky will go down as an incredible story of failure, backlash and redemption.
Good job hello games. Love no mans sky
Thought Sean said it wouldn't cost anything to play with others
What makes you think it does?
I mean it only costs the price of the game, that's how every other game does it
This can't have been a coincidence
4:08 why not billions of trillions sean?
1:41 So funny. Buzzwords combo.
He sounds like he's all too aware of how ridiculous it sounds now that the game had been launched.
How would you be describing it when you had to develop it?
He knew how ridiculous it was, back then too. @@maximtsai1856
Is he wrong? It is an ambitious game
@@irecordwithaphone1856 Yes he is. You missed the train by four years and even now you couldn't catch it.
Long time no see
Good talk, I can imagine how it must feel to have all of that pressure on your shoulders. Keep it up!
Alright alright, we get it, Sean Murray is a human too. Thanks for that.
I'm one who did not pile on, said oh well sounded like a cool game, and then bought and played the shit out of it when it was finished.
Same here. Pre-release the game's concept sounded very cool, but at the same time it was being made by a studio I hadn't really heard of before, so I figured I'd wait and see.
NMS was at v1.38 when I finally got it, blew me away, but while keeping those realistic expectations of "this is an indie game" I actually wouldn't have minded getting it at launch.
To be honest NMS has features today that wouldn't be in the game if Sony had bailed out HG and said "yeah you can have two more years."
The updates for nms were incredible. I played the shit out of that game. What a redemption story for hello games. Amazing job.
Doesn't absolve him of false advertising.
Did you play the game?
@@ehallam08 yep, it was false advertising
So early this game is still in early access👀
This is all too common, and its always the publishers fault pushing releases of games that are not yet ready.
i commend the grit, persistence, and comeback, but let's not go blaming the "toxicity" for things you promised and did not deliver, as well as the LONG radio silence.
col. hapablap If you actually watched the video completely before commenting in a video by GDC, not who you actually are referring to, you would see that he actually addressed the topics you mention in his talk.
FlapjaxAttack i watched the full video before commenting. sean never addresses the main problem head-on, which is that the gameplay elements he SAID would be included in multiple interviews, namely meetung/interacting with other players on your journey, were in fact not implemented. instead, he sidesteps the elephant in the riom and mentions sifting thru internet toxicity and marketing-related complaints to get to beneficial feedback from 'real players' for improvements to things like inventory UI. the core issue wasn't streamlining what was already in the game, it was about things that were promised but not delivered.
he had plenty of chances to curb people's hype BEFORE the launch and say, "we will implement these features, but they won't be available at launch. we're a small team and require more time to realize the full vision." he didn't. he could have addressed the complaints AFTER the launch, but he disappeared, which is why the people kept (somewhat unfairly) claiming that he took his money and ran.
i'm one of the people sean mentions in this video, the guy who played 100+ hours in the week after launch. i enjoyed it for what it was, but I'd be lying if i said i wasn't disappointed. i love the fact that they kept working on NMS to make it what it is today, a really solid game. but a little acknowledgement of playing his part in the hype machine and not being forthcoming about non-existent gameplay features would have saved him from the wavr of grief that came post-launch.
that's all people wanted: acknowledgement of his actions and disappearance
@@colhapablap And Valve did the same thing with Half-Life 1 and Half-Life 2. Where's the ire against them? Where's my dynamic moss growth? Where's my self-propogating alien AI? Those were things Gabe Newell himself said would be in the game and they found that it wasn't going to work out in the final build. Same shit, different age.
Just Because Other Companies Did The Same Wrong Thing Doesn't Make It Less Wrong!
And you can bet that if social media and internet discourse were as prominent back then as they are now there would have For Sure been big backlash. Not to mention, the core games themselves were still very good compared to NMS's bare-bone, incomplete release.
You are the problem :/ please stop playing videogames.
Never done before? Wtf, noctis ffs.
He was honest and down to earth and we all should learn from his experience and specially the point he made at the end
it was a god talk ! :> wish him all the best !
Great presentation, ignore the trolls. They don't understand the real world and how to bring a concept to life.
wew
April Fool's, No Man's Sky is Actually Good!
it is good.....now....
Well your not wrong. It was never BAD, just underwhelming
Ah, the dark awful times of making a whole lot of money. That must have been really tough.
Sean I love you man but can you stay still? I'm getting nauseous 😂😂😂
programmers get nervous on stage. Many nervous people, for whatever reason, start dancing.
14:16 space whale confirmed
Shame on everyone that attacked these guys so viciously. Fans of games need to learn the difference between vitriolic dogpiling and meaningful critic. If this industry continues so stay so toxic, we're going to get fewer risk-taking games and more homogenized mush.
You can love NMS. I'm not saying you can't. It may very well be a good game now. They might have fixed the issues it had at launch but those issues should've never existed in the first place and only did because of disingenuous marketing. They've done good to try and fix past mistakes but let's be clear, that's all they've done. It's a little frustrating to see such them getting praise for something they were expected to do from the start. Now he's on stage characterizing the understandable backlash as "toxic" (death threats are never warranted) and framing it as some "adversity" they had to bravely overcome. It feels like another kick in the balls to those of us who still feel wronged. You can love em or hate em but I think both opinions are just as valid as the other.
"Did you play the game?"
Is the first thing everyone defending NMS asks. I did at launch and the first update after. But when someone shits in your cornflakes and hands you the bowl with a smile it tends to make you not want to eat cornflakes anymore. Hello Games shit in my cornflakes. Sure they may have taken out the shit but it should've never been there in the first place. Still ain't eatin those cornflakes.
Whatever.
Oioioi. I'm glad he learned things from this, even if it's only half of what he should have learned..
i've made some mistakes... bUt my TeAM!
A game about shooting rocks was the most ambitious game from 2016, nah lmao
It is sad how most of the gaming community is so closed minded. Once a game is proclaimed bad, it seems like no one wants to change their mind even after the game is completely rebuilt and the studio is working so hard to satisfy the players. The power of memes is just too powerful over mindless brains of spoiled consumers.
Honestly, No Man's Sky haters in 2019 are the definition of the NPC meme: "NO MAN SKY BAD"
The core gameplay loop of shooting rocks to be able to shoot different rocks in a slightly different setting is still there. Everything else was just set dressing or features that were implemented to gain marketing buzz
@@MrMeddyman I'm not talking about the gameplay itself, it sure isn't a game to be enjoying for hundreds of hours, I know that. My point is that many people hate the game blindly without any valid argument. They hate it the same way Pepe culture hates liberals. They simply enjoy the memes which in a longer period escalates to the state that it becomes genuine opinion. That's kinda scary if you ask me.
@@DavidBrocekArt My point is that many people hate the game because he lied. it's the people who are ignoring the lies that are acting "blindly."
@@rumfordc I think the game industry is really way more complicated than just "Oh that guy decided to lie today, because he is a scam."... I'm not saying Murray is a saint person, but I think there is more into creating a huge game like this. The pressure and everything. Imagine being an amateur-ish developer, and one day receiving a contract by freaking Sony. I don't think he lied, he simply was afraid that Sony would kill him in case he would say something negative about the game. And most of all, he is not the only person working on the project, he is just the one representing it in the public, so if there is someone to blame it is most likely the greedy sales managers not the developers.
They're sheep
I'm afraid but, again, this is basically an accumulation of excuses and a huge missed opportunity. This should have been a talk about a man's journey through a spiral of lies, the reasons for his deceptions and what he thinks of it now. Maybe we would understand.
I'm sorry but he is still full of himself. But well, there is some value in here. Some. A little.
Sold incredible well? Wtf? Didn't you remember all the refunds?
Azuwey Ex it still sold well, despite the refunds. Especially for a team so small.
Lol, calling the people that criticized you as "Toxic" after you have been caught lying about your game prelaunch. The whole talk seems manipulative.
You making assumptions, them turning out to be wrong. Is not him lying bud. You are lucky they can't sue you. Valve at least stopped you from refunding.
False. He never once said multiplayer would be a launch feature. Several times he said the opposite. And he fullfilled what he said. Multiplayer came AFTER launch. Just like it was always going to. Idk why the fuck everyone ignored it. I told you all, you all called me a hater. So get fucked i guess you deserve it.
He called the severe threats to his life etc 'toxic'. He related to the dedicated gamers who put decent time into the game. Grow the fuck up.
David Duncan that’s ridiculous! Those angry people who misspent a mere $60 have every right to threaten his life! How dare he call them toxic?
/s
now thats a talented con artist
God you're such a jerk. Please stop playing videogames or stick to the dogshit games like call of duty and anthem.
I get it. April fools, No Mans Sky is a joke.
Blu3W4r10Ck get off of youtube you 10 year old
What's the point of this video? He spend 5/17min on buzzwords and praise to himself. Im not gonna watch any further.
He consistently lied about the content of the game throughout the entirety of its marketing.
The sign language is destracting. Why is it included in the online video?
i wonder if shes just making shit up like the black lady that got caught 😹😹😹
pstuddy she’s not I can tell