All-New 2024 Toyota Tacoma vs. 2023 Tacoma | That Much Better? | Interior, Powertrain & More
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 มิ.ย. 2024
- The Toyota Tacoma is by far the most popular midsize truck on the market, so to say there’s a lot riding on the redesigned 2024 model would be an understatement. The current 2023 Tacoma remains as popular as ever thanks to sky high residual values and a legion of loyal fans, but there are still plenty of issues the new truck could fix. In this comparison test, Edmunds’ Brian Wong puts the 2024 Tacoma up against the 2023 Tacoma to find out if the new truck is worth the upgrade.
2024 Toyota Tacoma review: edmu.in/3WONLZ8
00:00 Intro
00:53 Grievances
01:42 Powertrain
03:09 Driving Impressions
03:54 Driver Seat
05:11 Technology
06:40 Back Seat
08:01 Edmunds' Take
Subscribe to Edmunds th-cam.com/users/edmundsv... for the latest car news, car reviews, car comparisons, car shopping and advice.
Visit us! www.edmunds.com - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
With the new Tacoma boasting impressive improvements over the last generation, we are excited to put it up against our new long-term Chevrolet Colorado over the next year. What tests would you like to see us do with both trucks? Let us know in the comments below!
3K + price increase is way too much. Way for Toyota to screw over their customers. 2500 was the most they should have ever increased it by.
Ease of parking in a crowded grocery store parking lot
Get two off road models and compare them in snow or mud.
The third gen will definitely outlive the fourth gen I guarantee you that
So true brother, will save this comment for haters
Based on exactly what? The fact that you're mad you can't get a V6 even though everyone is telling you the new engine is better.
The sales show you that the most important feature for shopper is quality and durability. That is still in question with these new tacomas
For exactly what reason? What has changed to change people's mind about Toyota's reputation. I'm pretty sure it's just a bunch of idiots mad they can't have 6 cylinders or the price increase making excuses.for why they don't like the truck.
The days of the low stressed V6 and 5.7 V8 (Tundra) are gone. Wonder how these high strung, smaller turbo motors will fare when they are 15-20 years old... My 16 year old 5.7 still runs like brand new.
With proper care they will do good but you will always have to spend more to fix on a turbo engine
They’ll be like every other super unreliable turbo engine made.
Turbos don't do well and don't last for very long. Gm tried the same thing when they got rid of their V8 and put in a 4 cylinder with a Turbo. Nothing but problems, and the same thing is going to happen with these vehicles as well.
A good maintenance history when buying used is more important than ever.
Fresh oil and proper warm up/cool down times SAVES turbos
It’s worse. It’s a 4 cylinder turbo/ hybrid with same mpg. I’ll take my trusty v6
Ill take the old Tacoma 100 times over the 4th gen Tacoma.
$3k increase? At this point I might as well pickup a tundra💀
How about the feel and support of the seat it self? Any better cushion or support for long trips?
This is the best '24 Tacoma 11/28 release video by far. Thank you for comparing it with the 3rd gen so directly. As a 3rd gen owner who agrees with *every* gripe you presented, this video answered my questions.
The only other big thing was the 3rd gen ride quality. I assume, when you have the rest of the models, you can give a better take of the SR5/TRD trim coil springs and their road manners.
Glad you liked it!
Eco boost with extra Alrinator or a better tune to move the truck down the road needs 400 hp min
I feel that new display looks like it was added as an afterthought. Not incorporated into the dash.
I can't believe you're 6 feet tall.
Out of 20 different Tacoma reviews, this is the best one so far. Loved the backseat and seating position comparison.
Never understood people complaining about the driver seat position in 3rd gen… has never bothered me
Yep I like the drivers position myself. I'm 5'11. If someone is say 6'5 I'd recommend a bigger truck.
im 6'3 not a problem for me
is it just me or does the 3rd gens looks far better than the 4th one?
New Tacoma looks too much like a 3rd gen tundra. While the 3rd gen Tacoma looks way better than the 2nd gen Tundra. Looks are subjective, but I still think gen 3 Tacoma is still the best looking midsize. Nissan frontier 22+ comes in second for looks for me.
It's just you
Very nice! Too bad about no air vents in the back seats. I'd have to install a sound proof partition, so I can't hear the screams. Would like to see a hybrid option.
Next spring.
Are they offering a panoramic sunroof yet, or just the traditional sunroof still?
Appreciate the video. Beyond what you stated, can you elaborate more on the driver seat comparison from 23 to 24?? the seating position on the old was terrible. Is the height of the seat better? How about leg support? Very interested in this. For such a terrible seat in the older ones, I can find little on the new seat comfort.
Very good commercial for Tacoma
I absolutely love my 23 SR. Base V6
I have a 22 sr base v6, and I agree with you. The part about the ride quality in our 3rd gen baffles me; my truck handles great and drives at 80 smoothly. It isn't fast, but it's a truck.
I’d like to see how it does towing stuff compared to the v6. Ya it has more power but do you really wanna be revving high to tow? I can always add a turbo or super charger to my v6 but that 4 cylinder is sorta already capped out …so 🤷♂️
I remember back in the early 2000's catching flak for my extra-cab Tacoma, because real trucks don't have extra-cabs. Now double cabs are the norm. It ain't a truck, it is an SUV.
The interior of the 2023 is the only thing keeping me from getting one and waiting for 2024.
And you are ok the 3rd gen shifts, drives? I get it, the v6 is as reliable as it gets. But the current gen Taco is a slug to drive. It is just ancient.
$3k jump in base seems like a lot for year over year, redesign or not.
In comparison with a 2023-24 Chevy Colorado, which do you think is best??
I honestly have no idea what people are talking about when they say how horrible the seating position is. I’ve had a 3rd gen Tacoma for a little over a year now and I’ve always thought that it’s very comfortable.
Tim on Pickup Truck Plus SUV Talk showed that there are air vents under the seat of the new Tacoma.
MPG numbers for most trims on the gas models are almost identical to the V6....
That being said, the hybrid's will probably be at minimum, a 2k premium for a 5/10 MPG increase. Per toyota's website, this would bring the high volume offroad and sport trims to nearly 45k before destination and TTL. I feel like the appeal would be lost on many existing 3rd gen owners to upgrade at this price point. Just my 0.02
$2k premium? Haha! I'm guessing it will be 3x that.
@onehandwashestheother Nissan is discontinuing their v8 this year. GM is not discontinuing their v8 in Silverado and Sierra trucks. Ford is also keeping their v8 motors in their trucks.
@onehandwashestheother I've owned both and personally have never had any major issues with either.
@onehandwashestheother you're delusional dude. I'm not a fanboy of any one company, but Ford didn't become the best selling truck for decades by making crap.
@onehandwashestheother I own Toyota and BMW currently. I’ve owned GMC, Chevrolet, Ford, Jeep, Dodge, RAM, Mitsubishi, and Pontiac over the last 35 years. Where do you see a fanboy for a brand?
If it’s such a great seller, are the problems you identified more personal issues? I love my Tacoma.
The last pickup I had was a Datsun, probably in 71/72. Back then there was NO back seat to worry about, and I don't recall any pickups with a back seat at the time. Back then the claim to fame was carrying a 4' x 8' sheet of plywood or sheetrock... perhaps between the wheelwells. ( NOT in my Datsun, but full sized pick up trucks) By today's standards my Datsun was pretty dinky.
By today's standards, your old Datsun had a HUGE bed. Now the cabs are huge, and the bed is for two trash bags.
@onehandwashestheother You're also pretty damned arrogant , asserting that anyone who enjoys and pursues a career where the ability to haul materials is needed is a "stupid ape." Get over yourself please.
Home building is a skilled and noble career, and I'll bet you enjoy living in one too. I suppose "stupid apes" also built the truck you depend on to get to your self-styled "high society"job? What makes you so cool, brother?
I had a friend in college who majored in manufacturing engineering and was quite talented at it, but siting in a cube on his computer drive him nuts, So he joined his cousin doing line work for PG&E.
Different strokes for different folks, mister. Not all blue collar workers are apes. Clessie Cummins built his first engine at age 12, without college or computers. I'd say he did all right in life. His engines deliver your food.
Have a more humble day, please. Peace to you. All people and all legitimate occupations matter and make the world spin. Even the people who make your toilet paper. Remember, after this fleeting life, the last shall be first.
@onehandwashestheothera Prius can fit your gear and mountain bike
I think my 2019 has charger for the back, not sure I don’t ride back there. It does have a naturally aspirated V6!
The way he describes the cars makes me want to buy both of them
"Just under 6-foot"...wow I thought you were like 5'6"
It is not fair to start an argument by saying you don’t like one side of it because anemic engine, bad interior and bad entertainment system. All while forgetting the virtues. The old powertrain is indestructible. You want 300,000 trouble free miles, buy a 2023 Tacoma. You want to go outdoors, any TRD 4x4 gets you there. You want to have an interior that is functional, that means no gimmicks with buttons, knobs, normal Trans lever and hand break get the Tacoma. The new one looks beautiful. I hope it is as good as old.
Why are you just assuming this year's won't be as bulletproof? Plenty of examples of turbos with reliability and it's not like Toyota's reputation has changed
So... Knowing what you know on how Toyota announces new vehicles when do you think will get info -confirmation, and maybe photos of the new 4runner design?
I actually really like my 2023 trd pro Tacoma. I like the simplicity of it and I plan on driving the wheels off it.
People now days will complain if they were hung with a new rope! The 2023 Tacoma I have is everything I ever wanted. Yes there are a few things I would change and some thing I did change but it's still an amazing truck.
I never quite understood why Toyota who completely failed with their full size truck (for many good reasons) did so well with the lackluster Tacoma. For the first time I find the Tacoma to be an acceptable potential option but the optional V6 engine available on the Ranger makes the latter to be on top on my shopping list until I can drive both.
Gen 3 has a v6. Tacoma is reliable and a good alternative to Jeep. That’s why people love them.
I like Brian. He's a good host and what I say next is no way to be taken critically of him or Edmunds other hosts. Please bring back Travis Langness.
He quit, so…
When is it available to the public?
U can pick one up but definitely will have a mark up
$50 grand with additional dealer markup. How long is a turbocharged engine going to last?
Not as long as that 8% interest rate people about to get
I like these new gen , should be good no major changes for the next 10-15 years. 👍🏼
I want to take the new one for a test. How, does it handle the new truck , wit my 17” foot travel trailers . And a 17” fishing boat. If it conq!!! do it beetr I’m in love.!
23 anyday hands down
I’d be worried about the reliability and durability of the new turbo 4
I like the ranger
The 3rd gen looks like the improved version.
Lmaooo.
All we need to do now it's find all of the honest dealerships some are trying to get 5 , 10+ above MSRP. They are taking the excitement away from wanted to buy one.
I want the TRD Sport in manual.
2022 tacoma's do not hunt for gears. I own one. Previous models yes. Great traditional truck that needed refinement. The new tacoma not a huge upgrade unless you get the hybrid imax. And that will be expensive. Rear seat room in the new tacoma is not very good.
Two things resolve the shift hunting. A pedal commander installed or just buying the 6 speed manual
Yep, I have a six speed with the pedal commander on my 2016 and even the six speed, it has much sweeter throttle response with the pedal commander. I also raised the back of the seat using longer seat bolts and washers until it was much more comfortable. I'm in my sixties and I doubt I will ever be willing to pay the kinds of prices we are seeing today on every vehicle . I think this truck might outlast me.
Why oh why would Toyota miss the opportunity to provide lockable storage in the bed? The Honda Ridgeline, Hyundai Santa Cruz, and Chevy Colorado all have that feature although Honda's is the largest.
Why go turbo and no go all the way…it’s a low boost turbo meant to help longevity (which hurts power by not boosting adequately and efficiency by not using a smaller engine), then they’re pairing it with a hybrid system meant to help power (not efficiency). Offer two power trains, one larger higher boosted turbo and a smaller HYBRID with CVT (& 30 mpg), let the buyer decide what’s important to them. (They already have these engines build/tested in other Toyota’s/Lexus) I agree, it doesn’t know what it want me to be when it grows up.
Happy Birthday Chad
I’ll stick to my V6 2021 TRD Sport with only 15k, eventually it will become a collectible just like the (Supra, Celica).
I'll stick with my 2002 TRD. If they had done a real hybrid with 60 mile EV range I wouldn't think twice about selling that and my 2004 V8 4Runner. I really don't want that turbo mess.
Fact I will stick with a 2021 and older. They have already came out that all new vehicles made after covid was not made very well.
@@neckbones17made in Mexico. 🇲🇽 vs made in Texas 🇺🇸
Collectible is a stretch. Let’s not kid yourself dude.
hopefully they fixed visibility
I want to see how it does against the Rivian R1T
That's a bit of an apples to oranges type of comparison no???
@@stevebeard7667 Not really. Both midsized truck class.
@@MurseTech64rivian is not a truck. Its a unibody like the maverick. So its comparing a Truck vs a Car with a bed. Plus its electric thats for gays, tacomas are for Guys.
First of all I understand that the EPA regulations and all types of governments are making Toyota and other companies move to new types of vehicles. Second, Toyotas is the best because they know how to deal with customers with quality vehicles. And third, this generation number four will be a serious test because even though the third generation had and continues to have its problems (you already stated) it’s still is the best. That’s why I have one. So this fourth generation with his new modifications better hold up for at least another seven good years.
😁 updated ranger looks the best. But, I would buy a TACO SUPREME! but, wait for 2 yrs for kinks to be fixed.
Has nobody ever heard of a tune for the 3rd gen? Fixes all of the engine woes...
Put it to the grind...let landscapers use it and see how it holds up. It better last because it's very expensive. And it better be coming from Japan...where real craftsmanship happens.
Tacoma's have never been made in Japan.
$3K more expensive at base and no V6 option? No thanks.
Toyota gross profit for the twelve months ending September 30, 2023
was $57,000,000,000 a 24.26% increase year-over-year.
Toyota makes $158,333,333.00 every day.
As a 3rd gen owner this video made me want the 4th gen so much more 👍🏻
Na I'm good... If you're one of those people that wants to have all that technology in my opinion unnecessary stuff in a vehicle by all means but personally I buy a vehicle just to travel get from point A to point b I don't use all that unnecessary stuff I'm 6 ft tall weigh 160 I get in and out just fine seating position is just fine technology is just fine & the way that truck drives is perfectly fine lol
Don’t do it. I have a 2021 6-speed manual. I’ll NEVER have to worry about my turbo going out…. ‘Cause… my… Taco… doesn’t… have… one…
That’s the thing folks fail to recognize - eventually, EVERY turbo goes out. So if you buy one of these, you’d better go ahead and set aside at LEAST $2000 to get that turbo replaced when it goes out.
Again, not a matter of if but WHEN that turbo WILL go out.
Eww. Gen 3 gang 🤘🏻
The 4cl turbo get the same mpg…. Why even bother going to that engine?
Engine…. Engine.. Engine.. some things are best left alone. sorry they should’ve left the 6 cylinder in the Tacoma. like the 8 in the Tundra. as good as Toyota is i just don’t trust those engines over the long haul particularly for The reliable Toyota.
Keep in mind this guys are promoting 2024 and underestimating 3rd gen I own 3rd gen taco I have no problem yet.
To all you 3rd gen owners out there.... pretty much all these complaints are fixable pretty easily and for far less money than buying a whole new truck.
Yep….kdmax, seat jackers, stinger headunit, upgraded suspension and the backseat well that I don’t have an answer
I love my 23 truck the way it is 😊
3rd gen all day baby
@onehandwashestheother yup. these yuppie-mobiles are for dorks who want to look cool and drive around on a trail with their camping gear. is there a company that just makes simple, reliable pickup trucks anymore?
Not getting rid of my 2017 trd pro taco in cement anytime soon. Just getting started on it! Looks better still than most the 2024 models
Just bought a 2023 Tacoma with the V6 engine with only 3k miles on it (practically brand new)
I don’t like the turbo engines of the 2024 models and I especially don’t like the weird techy look they got
They did not fix the "view out the front"... Look at the 5:17 mark. Look how high the dash is relative to this reviewers eye/line of sight out the front. This setup prevents you from seeing what's directly in front of the truck. Like your kid in your driveway.... The hood is waaay to high on this vehicle (or the seat is way too low)... Dangerous...
That's the impression I got after riding in one. The seats are low like a Vette or go cart with legs stretched forward, and dash up high.
@@phillipgrandison2384 Yeah, I was in the market for a new truck in 2022. I WANTED a new toyota. Primarliy because I wanted a manual transmission, and toyota is the only option (jeeps don't count, crap quality). But I sat in a brand new 22' toyota, and dam, the seating position was brutal. The view out was terrible. Ended up going with a Ridgeline. 20k miles later, I could not be happier with my choice.
Yep. I bought a new tacoma in '21. Lasted 2 years & sold it. Seats & seating position suck
how much better is the 2024 over the 2023? it's not. at all.
Did they move the seats up from off the floor pan ? Sitting in a Tacoma reminds me of sitting in a go cart, with legs stretched forward. No thanks.
Ridgeline for the win...
That’s a cool crossovers 😂😂😂
Ohh I might buy this truck 🛻 I don’t have kids and only two cats .
Blind spot monitoring is NOT standard. Gate keeping BSM to higher trims and packages is not acceptable Toyota.
So Tacoma wanna be American now, specially when that look.
OTT tune solve all the problems with the 3rd gen Tacoma... Automatic transmission no more ⚙️ hunting 18+ horsepower 24+ foot pounds of torque does not void the warranty and only $450...
The chassis alone on the 2024 is a clear winner for me.
Honestly, I think the Colorado looks better.
Give me back the v6
A 2.4 cyl will not hold up over the long haul..
Turbo crap to high an rpm
If he was taller than 5ft he could reach the steering wheel.
I rather go with the Tundra SR5 At $56k
You know that the tiny turbo won’t have the same longevity as the V6 , and Toyota parts are $$$expensive. It’s too bad that all of the other improvements don’t matter when considering that puny power plant. I’m haven’t drunk the Toyota Kool Aid. I’ll stick with my 7.3 F250 for at least another 400,000 miles.
4th gen is already proving to be not very reliable
All trucks are starting to look alike. If it was just one, it would look good. Now, it's just getting boring. I'll keep my old truck.
I absolutely love the new Tacoma! I think Toyota did an awesome job. The design inside and out looks so much better!
New engine and 8sp transmission = zero improvement in fuel efficiency lol. Come on Toyota.
Now imagine how the truck would do with the old v6 tuned to 300hp and that new 8 speed. I bet it would out perform this new turbo engine pile of shit.
Ahh yes, the "this old one is a piece of shit and the new one is so much better" immediately upon a new model coming out of anything.
Duh, That’s typically the result of progress fool🥴
why do they always get short people to review vehicles? To make them look bigger? lol
A 4 cylinders ok with a couple cans of paint, but not viable for towing or any kind of payload TBH
A full size Chevy Silverado comes with a 4 Cylinder too.
Maybe an unpopular opinion… I think the 24 tacoma is ugly.
Looks like Toyota funded this video. If the old Tacoma was so underpowered, how did it achieve such a great status in resale, and such as the retailers like to always point out? They would’ve never sold so many of them if it was truly an issue. But now the Toyota has come out with a screeching four-cylinder with the turbo wanted to probably won’t endure nearly as long as the old engine. All of a sudden this is the better engine …all marketing.
My 23 does constant 7 second 0 to 60 times. Absolutely no hunting or gear issues. And, they fixed the cry baby driving position with electrical drivers seat.
The 24 has morphed into a sissy boy Ridgeline.
Same short seat bottom as before, I don't see a more comfortable seating position at all.
Have you sat in it yet?
😆
Why do I hate the new tacoma? And I mean EVERYTHING about it.
My 3rd gen better last forever because this is a major downgrade.
So long, longevity🙄.
Honestly dont know why everyone is hating on the turbo 4. The 3.5 v6 was shit. Id rather get the turbo 4.
Bro are you like 5'0? Haha short Asian. Can't relate. I'm 6'0 and Asian. My 3rd gen Tacoma will take out any 2024 taco.
5’7 Asian here, easy dude. 😊. Let’s be honest here, besides the V6, your 2023 Taco can take out anything, let alone the 2024.
If the Taco’s future is destined to be like the Tundra’s then I’d stay away from the Taco! Built in Mexico, way overpriced, and a 4cylinder turbo. No thanks.
Overpriced
Toyota screwed up for 2024