The Voice Assistant Battle! (2017)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 ส.ค. 2017
- Siri vs Google Assistant vs Bixby Voice vs Amazon Alexa.
Original Siri vs Google: • Google Assistant vs Si...
Video Gear I use: kit.com/MKBHD/video-gear#recom...
~
/ mkbhd
/ mkbhd
google.com/+MarquesBrownlee
/ mkbhd
/ mkbhd - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
![[UNCUT] ย้อนฟัง 2 บิ๊กตำรวจปะทะกัน "บิ๊กโจ๊ก VS รองแต้ม" ฟ้องเรียก 10 ล้าน!! I คนดังนั่งเคลียร์](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vNpTtVjdcBo/mqdefault.jpg)
I asked Cortana to rap for me, she replied with _"I think we both know that would be painful."_
she ain't having any of that shit XD
Ashchu117 Lol 😂😂😂😂
Ashchu117 I asked her too and she said *The thing go skrrrra pa pa pa ka ka skidipi pa pa and a pu pu prrrrrrr dun skiya pu pu tun tun dun dun pun pun*
Ashchu117 lol
comment of the year! xDD
I just tried all of these with Cortana and she got them all right
Bixby needs to drop and album 16:29
el pato agreed
Agreed!
I need that as a ringtone
Yup!
Alexa: im the baddest ai in the cloud today
Bixby: hold my phone
"What is the population there?"
"Its human population" 💀💀
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Kinda right.. 😆😆😆
😂😂
😂🔥
Hey X Æ A-12
Cortana: "Am I a joke to you?"
😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣
Its dead
😂😂😂😂😂
That's what I thought! Lol
Yes it's a joke
Google is for everyday life
Bixby is for internal phone functionality
Siri is for business and work
Alexa is mostly for fun
Probably never owned an echo device
SingSong siri useless
Sychrari i have she can’t even go into settings i’ve asked and she says i can’t do that is line broken or what
Bubble Dumb I can’t understand you either with that grammar. No wonder Siri can’t understand you
@@boomslang4706 Siri cant Understand 99% of the ppl fact.
we want the 2019 edition !!
We also
Yeah where the Toronto Raptors won.
Please yes
That would be interesting in fall, when the next generation Google Assistant will be launching on the Pixel 4 :)
YES PLEASE
Barack Obama = Golden State Warrior's point guard confirmed
limen 😂😂😂
Lol
Amen
obamium powered slam dunk
😂😂😂😂
Question: How far is it to the moon.
BIXBY: Whatever the price I'm sure it's out of my budget.
Moon is outta his budget
Poor guys broke
You: Hey Google, tell me a joke
Google assistant: Bixby.
🤣🤣
Marques: Open Play Store and download Uber
Google: No camera app installed
I'm laughing so hard.
But how come when I asked google to do it she did it????
Even when I asked for the selfie she did it lol
This is rigged
@@elda1337 it's 2 years old lol
Google Assistant - An A+ student who is always on time but also has no sense of humor
Alexa - That kid in school who always fell asleep on the desk but teachers never did anything about it because they knew she'd fight them
Siri - Pampered rich kid who dresses well but is also completely oblivious on how the outside world works
Bixby - The class clown who is really trying her best, but is still a lovable clutz
😄😄😄😆😅😅
True.
Ask google assistant to tell you a jokr
Google assistant is quite sharper and homourous than Siri, Alexa or Bixby....but you just had to write something for comparision. I get it.
AHAHHA true so so true
I’m most impressed about Bixby’s in phone capabilities, I was shocked it actually installed Uber
Having Bixby and Google Assistant both honestly is great once you know which to summon for different tasks. Now, if only they could just help eachother as one...
Dillon M next thing you know they merge into one and set out to defeat their masters
@@mrzoozilla971 which master?
@@dillonm913 really
Bixby is actually the worst
Alexa in round 3 is about as helpful as I am on a Monday morning 😂
*E*
Hiko Plouyr E
Ok Garfield
Monday Monday so good to me
Who's been messing with everything ?
Bixby: uh, 5ft 4" tall. Uh, 5ft 11" tall. Uh 6ft 1"
HAHAHAHA😂
lmao 🤣🤣🤣
When!?
Samama vi Britannia 8:33
@@emanuelmolliner5258 ai thx man
That's me in class when teacher asks a question 🙂
Bixby is drunk af
EliteGamerShow lol at least it could rap
Gaurav Kumar I think Bixby is a woman
and also the best even though it's beta
OHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
You know... that explains why it's the only app able to open and download uber and actually take the selfie.
9:30 You asked Siri specifically, " How tall is Barrack Obama ?", while you asked the other voice assistants, " How tall is he ? "
he's a apple fan
That's what I was gonna say, but at least it worked the second time
Siri asked it
@@antoninoguess5389 siri asked what
@Copyrighted Tree Yes yeah but that's because she had no clue what he's talking about, for example google assistant replied without a problem
I watched someone talk to a phone for 20 min.
Yup didn't even realize it's that long until I read your comment.
No It's 18.04 minutes
18:07.
Excuse me its 4 phones
13:45 when you wanna wake at 7:30 am but Bixby understands you more than yourself and decides to wake you at 7:30 pm instead
🤔🤔😂😂😂😂
Hahaha,damn true 😂😂😂
Well, he didn't specify AM, sooooo.
Well he didn't told whether it's a am or pm. And his phone might be in 12 hour format..
@@nahlaaly8466 but it still shouldve known cuz he said "wake me up" and usually that happens in the AM
At 9:20 Siri couldn’t answer it, then you asked her the question directly which ruined the whole point of it.
Same with alexa
yeah. what is this guy doing?
I guess the difference was that Siri asked who you were talking about instead of just spitting out a wrong result?
No joke, like ask the same question again
He's got a little extra love for Siri. Pretty obvious. Shouldn't have cheated to help her.
Q: What's the population?
A: It's human population.
I mean... it's not wrong :D
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂
Good one 😂
Lol😂😂😂 you sound like me in real life😰
Mr. Memeist it’s in Nepal 🤷.. there’s a lot of Sherpas..
These assistants might be cool but nothing scares me more than Duolingo does.
Dude exactly
Ok
Hi Reversal! I didn’t expect you here!
LOL!
Bixby nailed the rap than others 😂
Anurag Shobhan agreed
Anurag Shobhan i
Anurag Shobhan Yeah she's dropping something beats bro
Anurag Shobhan night nu I6i7lk
This is just mess up!!
Bixby - the rap god
Peashooter!! Nice to see you enjoying some youtube vids. Hope the zombies werent too hard on you
Nabin Kalauni Thanks :D I'm still alive :D
Bizby-Autotune king!!
Peashooter CZ The notorious BIX.
Peashooter CZ that’s why Bixby doesn’t work well they put everything into making it a rap god
13:40
Marquez: wake me up tomorrow at 7:30
Bixby: I've set the alarm for *7:30 PM* 🤣🤣
lmao
I don’t get it😞
waffle the waffle ... you don’t get up at 7:30 pm, that’s at night
@@robertetzenhouser but marqees said 7:30 pm
Ananthi Spurgeon he just said 7:30 😂
Imagine Jarvis saying "no camera app installed" when tony asks for IronMan suite
on google assistant, simply saying "take a selfie" or 'install Uber" works, when you oversimplify the sentence, it starts searching for keywords like "camera app" as a name of an app and fails, the simpler the command, the better the result
kanishkvarma I agree
Yes but it should be penalized for not being able to understand what you're saying in a variety of phrasings. Voice assistants are supposed to make using your phone more convenient, so if you have to watch your phrasing carefully in order for it to understand you, that defeats the point a little bit. The ideal voice assistant can understand what you mean no matter how you choose to phrase it, like an actual person.
yes, but not in that particular test, since the purpose of that test was how easily can the AI understand a simple command in the context of previous commands, so that it's more human and less like having to speak like a robot, but the commands didn't do justice to the purpose of that specific test because saying it the way he did is more robotic than saying "take a selfie". also, for siri he said " open the camera and take a selfie" whereas for google he said " open the camera app and take a selfie" while it might not seem like a big difference, it is.
the purpose wasn't to see if they're perfect or not. it was to see which one is better at a certain task, but at least in my opinion, the phrasing used to test that task was just less than ideal
No one is going to say "ok google, open the camera and take a selfie" in practical use. You'll most like say "ok google, take selfie". So no. You can't penalise it. It's a machine, not human. You can't just spurt a random phrase and expect it to understand. Do you know how many ways you can ask your assistant to take a selfie for you? It would be impractical to get all that kind of training data for the machine. I think it should get a point there, because it's doing like it advertised; which is being able to understand your normal speech and react to it. So no one is going to "normally" say, "open the camera and take a selfie". It's longer to say that than to just do it manually. You'll likely get, "take a selfie".
Damn Alexa is terrible. Also, google absolutely destroyed the others
siri was a decent competitor i guess
Of course it did. Google have all the data they collect every time someone search for something on Google. From the question itself to the page they click as the correct result.
thanks ;( jk
Google obviously won, but I was actually surprised by bixby doing the "open the play store and find this app for me" thing
At the time this video was made, Bixby was pretty new. Bixby can control every setting on the phone, open apps and do functions in them, search for apps and install them. You cant expect the world out of a new concept. Only thing i dont like about bixby is the bixby button.
The next day at 7.30:
Google assistant : ring ring!!
Alexa: ring ring!!
Bixby: ring ring!!
Siri:ring ring!!
Ehem, Bixby wont ring, its dumbass set the alarm to 7 PM, LOL.
13:46
@@dophire I mean... She's not wrong... That's definitely better time to wake up than 7:am😂😅
You Are
bad!😡
What if you wanted to go to heaven, but God said: "No Camera App Installed."
Sooooo....
God = Google Assistant 😂
Luckysquirrel1256 best comment
lol
iOS?Siri
Amazon?Alexa
Rap?Bixby
Google?Assistant
Hotel?Trivago
Samsung made bixby
@@williamsmith6921 woooosh
@@williamsmith6921 r/Whooooooosh
william smith lool
Bendy?and the ink machine
Me: Hey, Bixby what's the weather like today?
Bixby: Hold on (20min later)
Me: Erm... Bixby wh...
Bixby: I said *HOLD THE F*CK ON*
Actually siri takes longer
Balrajda savage no bixby is so stupid
@@reynardrouser7863 siri is fuck as hell
@@aunkn0wndude i'm a samsung user and i have to say that bixby is a piece of garbage tbh.
Why r u Reading dis she’s half decent most of the time
We need a 2019 version
*2020 version
Tedidod 2020 April version
2021 version
2021
2021
Me: siri whats the squareroot of 49?
Siri: Yes
Marques savage didn't even let them finish speaking
Imma like this to get it started
One day, they will have their revenge by skipping Marques video.
I laughed every time he did that. Man was like nope bitch shut up
Especially on Bixby's bit
AfroSamuraiT lol
IMO, Siri should have gotten a half mark on the Barack Obama question since it required a clarifying question
Marko Buha agreed
I know what you mean but then he asked how tall is HE and he answered right
Yea
MrLovaLova no he first said how tall is he and after he said how tall is barack obama
he said "barack obama", not "he"
8:36
me in maths : uh its.. uh.. uh..
you know I'd love to see a 2021 version of this
Okay time for second battle 2k18
7mil18
@Crusader of Useless Exposition 2k19 ?
year two thousand eighteen
portal has joined
Yes
That rap in bixby was better than many😂😂
What time??
Tony: Connect to the cisco, have it reconfigure the shell metals, use gold titanium alloy from the seraphim tactical satellite, that should ensure fuselage integrity while maintaining power to weigh ratio. Got it?
Jarvis: hold on... Uh.. Im not sure what u mean
Tony: u what?
Jarvis: sorry sir, just trying to act like the ordinary digital assistants, i just watch it from youtube.
😅😂lol
To my man are GENIUS
What is there population ? « It’s human population » Siri’s got me dead 🤣🤣🤣
Bixby nailed it with the raps, and beats too🙄😂
listen to the beatboxing
Bixby also nails randomly activating and saying hello fo you want to listen to your pirate shantys
Team google assistant
TEAM GOOGLE ASSISTANT
MarkDaNerd TEAM GOOGLE ASSISTANT
Srjan Shetty I have both....
Hell yeah dude
Google assistant sucks
Bixby:"it's human population"
Aliens at area 51:"am I a joke?"
Saoban Reza It was Siri
100%, need to redo this battle in 2019 with Pixel 4(check that sweet sweet build-in), iPhone 11, Galaxy 10 etc!
I was like no way Bixby is that good at rapping and on my s9 I said rap for me and it started dissing APPLE AND BLACKBERRY lol and it had fire music lol
That's impressive...
Siri can't even beatbox!
If only bixby was as good as google assistant
Samec
Balrajda savage dude are you F**cking serious?
Same my dude
At 13:53 Bixby set the alarm for 7:30 PM. If you had to wake up early the next day, you'd be screwed.
Or you can tell her either am or pm
@@user-xn6hq6qh3s He did mention tomorrow though but bixby just set a alarm for today not tomorrow
Alarms never EVER woke me up even once so it wouldn't matter anyway. I always tend to wake myself up at the right time.
That’s some textbook Malicious Compliance right there
Bixby doesn't judge your slacker lifestyle.
Instead of asking " Rap for me ", you can ask " Can you rap " to google assistant and it raps very well
saying "how tall is barak obama" isnt the same as "how tall is he" 9:30
It asked him to clarify so he did
Me: Hey Siri, I want to see a joke.
Siri: Go to your privacy controls and give access to your front camera
Its funny cause thats what the avg consumer of apple products is
LMFAOOOOOOOOO
VicToMKriM ... 😝
LOL!
Detroit: Become Human
Say what you want, Bixby straight fire at the end 🔥
gg ez it don't even lag
Antonio Mendez *doesn't. And of course it lags, its an android
lol enjoy doing nothing on your iphone? but you know if the leaks are true apple are going the s8 way so you'll have one close enough :)
TheFriendlyArab30 Chill, women. Both assistants are good. Bixby is amazing in controlling every aspect of your phone. (Recommended for people with disabilities). While Siri is really fast and is good at answering random questions while having a great personality.
gg ez is just sad cause Apple just copies or is far behind android. Especially after you see what they did today. Watch - samsung copy. Apple TV - Chromecast Ultra. iPhone X - Essential phone.
9:24: How tall is he? Siri: What would you like me to find, Marques?Marques: How tallis barrack Obama. What! That's cheating
10:19
Its *human* population 😂 best way to answer the question 😂
Lol
😂🤣
Siri got to cheat the Obama question!
OttersGonnaOtt yeah :/
Thank you for paying attention.
And on the home Depot one
Truth
He must tell him which Home Depot he wants.
You cheated you asked siri "how tall is Obama " so i dont see the fair part of the vid... ps bixby at the time was beta
Mikayel Jamalyan finally someone noticed !
Charbel Daher I'm surprised more people haven't noticed
Because Siri asked that. If its wrong answer or no answer its no point, if she asked then he replied. It was the "conversation" with assistand as this task was about
pansowa75 the test was about conversation and siri broke the conversation and he gave it the keyword Obama instead of seeing weather it can figure out what the conversation is and continue it. That's and incorrect test on that question .
Charbel Daher Sorry, when I am watching it again it seems that You are right
Bro I'm starting to get hooked on your videos. Loving the in-depth reviews and conversations
can't wait to see this battle again in 2020!
Me: whats 20x15-8?
Bixby: (opens calculator)...
Bixby: The answer is 292
Bixby is disqualified for cheating, this was a non-calculator test.
@@maxkho00 😂, Good one 👌!
great!
If you had a doubt with the answer you will going to open the calculator too at the end. So bixby was just presenting her proof
he's a cheater
What is the population? “It’s the human population” lol
Michael Liu Lol!
I guess the lizard people haven't infiltrated yet
When you're called on in class and awaken from your slumber
Marques be waking up at 7:30 PM 13:47
Marques: Set a timer for 2 minutes...
Alexa:
No can dosville babydoll.
I was shook when Bixby searched "Uber"..
Muphyh y
Me too bro
Muphyh you were shook
Now your back to muphyh
When I asked Google Assistant "What is your name?" She said...
The name's Assistant, Google Assistant 😎
dude u need to have the latest version of it preinstalled like those of Pixel XL & Oneplus
@@yaseensiddiquee7502 He said a joke and your reply is random af. LMAO gtfo
To me she said "My name's Google assistant, and I think it's quite fitting"
Badsha.... Maanik.. baadshah😎
6:16 you told Nepal and that's a great moment for us. thanks Marques
Marques: wake me up at 7 30 tomorrow
Alexa: TIMERS AND ALARMS ARE NOT SUPPORTED ON THIS DEVICE
ask bixby to open google assistant
Anthony Kaufmann hahaha savage
Anthony Kaufmann sbe opened in
I test with my note 8 :D
Me too I tested it
J0hnbeeman
5109389035
Bixby: Actually, looks like I couldn’t find the file
**Gets XP**
Simularhero 99 13:30 ☝️😂😂
Failure is the greatest teacher right lmao
Awen Khari Agreed lol
Glad to hear our country name in your video.Thanks for remembering us NEPAL❤
I'm glad that this video comparison has been made
Cortana: hello I'm here too, man * _slaps leg_ * no one notices me :(
nu
LOL
No one notices u as no one notices Windows phone
Cortana has good voice recognition though.
Cortana is too good to be compared to these four.
16:26 *I didn't know Bixby could rap so well*
Well shes gooooooooooooooooooooooood
Same
She can also beatbox and tell jokes
Thanks for all the awesome videos, any chance of an updated comparison for 2020?
11:40
If you say "Let's take a selfie"
It will do so for you
You may try "Its selfie time"
Regarding the "take a selfie" test, I noticed that Google Assistant will fail if you add "open the camera app and...". Simply saying "take a selfie" worked. Probably Google trying to be too smart here...
I feel like siri cheated at 9:25...
Siri is giving specific information maybe. Cause im google lolz.
it kinda did tbh xd
It failed.
Yess it failed already
Yeah! Siri got away there. But overall it doesn't help much. It still lost. RIP
You should also try cortana
We need the 2020 version
ooooo Bixby can spit some bars!🔥🔥🔥
Plexversal Correction: She can spit copyrighted bars*
Luckily you don't have to choose between Google and Bixby, they live happily together on the same device... Google for everything cloud and Bixby for controlling your actual device
Robin Jacobs yep
Ma boi rules
I wish I could like your comment times😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Robin Jacobs I was thinking the same thing. Problem with Bixby is, it is not as good with the accents as Google assistant is. Still though , it is hard to outgoogle Google, right !?
Luckily Google Pixel 2 is coming soon and you won't have to use Bixby at all!
We need a new one of these shootouts for this year (2020)!!!
Marques, hows the voice assistant battle stacking up at the end of 2019?
Still Google
Bix just killed in the rap.
X2
Google assistant and Siri is best
Had music and everything
I tried it on my phone its lit
Billie Joe Armstrong
Cortana does not count i guess
aman gowalkar people use Cortana?
i opened the same questions to Cortana and she did pretty well, except for couple of questions.
aman gowalkar fuck Cortana
Yanal Shoumenn serious man?
Lmao.... Cortana is useless... Windows phone is dead
What if he forgot to turn off the alarms, and at 7:30 tomorrow, all hell breaks loose
i need one more this year!
Ayeeee bixbys rap was lowkey lit
Enasio Alston jr The only thing good in Bixby.
Nikko M Bixby can also beatbox.
Absolutely not. When it comes to controlling things that are built into the phone, Bixby is the king.
Richard Hufferson thats what they were going for yhings that bixby cant do google assistant makes up for anc vice versa together they are king, and considering bixby just launched a month ago its pretty dam impressive and if you want to navagate apps none can beat her, or iif you trying to rap or beatbox then none even come close to bixby
Bixby is shit, maybe it'll get better in the future
MKBHD: Open the play store, search for uber, and install the first app
Google assistant: *no camera app installed*
FilthyCasuals hhhhh😂😂
I just tried it now and It worked so... Yeah *REOWNED*
Sometimes during wi fi connections you get spikes of traffic and/or weak connection which can affect the results that are produced from the AI fyi...
FilthyCasuals lol
Still, it beats the crap out of other voice assistants lmao. Only mistake it did was uber thing
I would love an updated version of this with your input man.
huh, i searched up "the voice battle" (as in the show) and this popped up
best one yet
Bixby is the rap master 😅😂
mark menezes
And the cringe master as well
"I'm your prime time, fine wine, Bixby guru" Best verse I ever heard.
If I learnt anything from this phone is that Katmandu is the capital of Nepal
***Kathmandu
Thanks tho XD
Cheers from Nepal.
wasn't expecting bixby to be so prepared for the rap battle.
This has to be done again now. VOICE ASSISTANT BATTLE OF 2020 @MKBHD
My mom is the best Voice Assistant ever!
Ikr
Explained: that's the best comments down here
Yasss, sometimes I even forget what I asked for but she remembers lmao
Explained: hahah.. Thats true 😂
Bixby, struggling the whole time: D:???
Bixby, as soon as it was time to take a selfie or download an app: wait! I got this! :D
me: :'0 you're doing amazing, sweetie...
It's because Bixby uses offline voice recognition, rather than uploading your voice online to help make it more accurate.
@John Grist Bixby and Google should become one thing, sharing the same interface. One Button at the top of the screen (Iphone 4 and Iphone 5 lock phone button location) and they both listen.
If you ask a system/phone offline question: Bixby answers and if you ask an internet question: Google answers
@John Grist If Asking Google to turn on the flashlight (which works just fine on my phone), then say "Okay Google, Lumos"
I got this recommend exactly after I saw mrwhosetheboss aka Arun's video.
Okay at this point of my life, youtube will recommend me anything and i will watch it
You shouldn't have asked Siri a second time
he said his name in the sentence too :/
Yeah!!!! Wtfffff marques
Fastest at not knowing the information.
People like me? I like how you know nothing about me but will make assumptions. I am just telling you facts in this video i did see apple being faster on the voice assistant but it didnt have the information at times. which is ok because no voice assistant is perfect. Literally just use what you like. Everyone has there own personal opinion but it all really comes down to whatever is best and or easiest for you to use.
AHHH. Donn't worry about him salty iPhone fann
bixby with google. The Context understanding of Google is stunning.
Bixby is fucking garbage. Google is easly best and Siri is second, she is very fast and can do more things than Bixb or Alexa.
bixby is trash compared to Siri but Google Assistant wrecks them both imo (Siri is really fast though)
Bixby is about 3-4 months old. And it can compete with the big ones. It can even do some things that Siri and Google Assistant can't. I think this is pretty impressive. Wait 1-2 years and make a test again. I'm sure the results will change.
Black Ursus József probably not
It already changed a lot since it's release date. I say this as an S8 owner who keeps revisiting Bixby weekly. It's constantly improving.
Please make a 2019 edition!
Broo he got so many alarms to turn off tomorrow