The BEST Voice Assistant 2.0! Siri vs Bixby vs Google Assistant vs Alexa vs Celia! | VERSUS
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 มิ.ย. 2022
- We are back with a brand new voice assistant test, this time including Celia of Huawei! Added on top of Google's Assistant, Amazon's Alexa, Apple's Siri and Samsung's Bixby, we've managed to pull off the most detailed voice assistant test on the internet by asking a variety of questions for your knowledge and entertainment. Which assistant is the best in 2022? Enjoy!
Subscribe to our Channel: th-cam.com/users/versusdotco...
Check out our social media 👇
Instagram: / versus_comparisons
TikTok: / versus_com
Facebook: / versusio
For more details check out #VERSUS 👉 versus.com/
Get the devices here 🛒
Google Pixel 6 Pro: amzn.to/3J8Z1Iz
iPhone 13 Pro Max: amzn.to/3FYMaq3
Samsung Galaxy S21 Ultra: amzn.to/2MAFA2y
OnePlus 9 Pro: amzn.to/3swEggj
Huawei P50 Pro: amzn.to/3GL0AtY
Gear we use to make videos 📷
Camera: amzn.to/2RuWSgC
Lens: amzn.to/3c3h4ji
Mic: amzn.to/3ntp5Cz
Main light: amzn.to/3iBDEln
Second light: amzn.to/2FIJVgy
*All Amazon links above result in a commission given to me by Amazon. It costs nothing extra to you though. - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
The fact that Celia opened the selfie camera when asked to self destruct really cracked me up🤣🤣🤣🤣
hhahahahhahhahahahhahahhahhahajhahab
EMOTIONAL DAMAGE
You could say it "Selfie Destructed" 🤣
Jajajajajajajajajajajajajaja
She knows too much.
Bixby has incredibly improved!
Yes
❤❤❤
It was surprising to see Bixby going ahead of Siri. I was beyond shocked with their progress.
What a great comparison!
It's pretty amazing how capable this technology has become, and how more and more we become dependent on these voice assistants.
I was really glad to see you included Celia in this comparison. It might be noted that the poor girl is not allowed to talk to things Google. It's interesting to note that in the USA my Mate 20 x has Emy rather than Celia.
I still think it's important to talk to all of them so that one gets all sides of the story 😉👍
Yeah, I just hated the button on the side of the phone
The Google devs are just phenomenal. Still amazes me that after so many years of competing voice assistants they are still in the lead. Bixby definitely deserves the award for most improved though, used to be soooo bad.
It's a shame the Google home app is so poor. I'm currently stuck with bloody alexa for my smart home because of how shit the Google home app is. Alexa is really bad and struggles with so many basic things but she is a lot more capable than Google home. I don't understand how Google screwed up so badly
It's shame on apple to not invest in Siri. Google Developers are really good at natural language processing
Honestly.. I never believed Bixby go have gotten this good... Sori used to be the best but now, they suck
true,now they need to make it sound less robotic,the new siri sounds great
Yeah but Google is mostly a software company so it's to be expected
Damn, bixby has improved a LOT. As a galaxy user, the ultimate combo of google assistant and bixby(routines) is just amazing
yes
Does your Google assistant works offline? Basic commands?
@@anuraganasane308 No.. Do you explain how Bixby works offline and I think even when screen is off. 😅
Routines is one of my favorite things about Samsung. I hope they keep expanding it.
what is that//////// ..
/
Google as expected is great. Very surprised by Bixby.
Me too. But I mostly use Google assistant.
Google assistant won I have it
Fr. Really happy for the Samsung users now that Bixby has improved so much
I use Bixby a lot and she is awesome, I was surprised too in the beginning, especially Bixby is considered a new, It came out in 2020
It has Bixby Routine also. where it can do series of conditions and execute automation
Bixby and google assistant combo is unbeatable 😁
Thats me
siri >>>
@@therealkim_jong_un ok kim jong un
@@therealkim_jong_un no
It really is, bixby handing the tv and device control and Googles got the information and home control
can we talk about the Siri's elephant sound 3:35
Yeah me too I don't understand lol... 🤣 the new genetic animal, "TigerPhant" for Apple
😂😂😂
It sounds like Fudge Monster from The Amazing Digital Circus.
Bixby beating siri puts a smile on my face what a character development.
From the underdog to the best side assistant...
"self-destruct"
Celia: Opens the selfie Camara
🤣
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤦🤦🤦
🤣🤣🤣
Siri: ok
Hey, it just wanted to know who was the one that ordered celia to kill herself(self-destruct)
6:05 Bixby should get +100 points for the rap
Yes
7:52 in a backwards way siri just saying "ok" and closing wiped me out more than any of the assistants who responded with a joke
It's one of the way she reacts whenever you insult her. Usually just an "OK" or "that's not nice"
Bixby is very underrated. I love using Bixby when i want to do stuff on my phone. When i want to know something from the internet i use google assistant. Best of both worlds.
With a Samsung Galaxy Device, you get two best of an assistant just for yourself
Bixby and Google assistant
So cool
My Samsung Galaxy a23 has no bixby 😭
@@mahmudurrahmanshovon9415 F
@@mahmudurrahmanshovon9415 I have both, was a pain to turn off bixby for my headphones since well, google assistant is used for most of my stuff anways, Bixby is good, but im more in Googles ecosystem with google home, wifi, and chromecasts, insyead of using smart things
@@bummer7736 F 2
Bixby's rap was 🔥🔥🔥
Bixby got barz
she got real barzz
Alexa's rap was fire as well, if you talk about the voice and tonation that is, I wish the others had a more realistic tonation
"What does an elephant sound like?"
Others: *Elephant noises*
Siri: *Demons from hell*
celia:YoU mAy ChEcK tHe SeAcH aS i FoUnD oNlinE
Lol Siri leaves you on a cliffhanger for the self destruct question😂 She agreed but you'll never know when she'll do it!!!
That’s an interesting way to look at it 😂
“Call 911”
Police: we have 5 calls coming from the same place
😂
Since he's in Germany, he should have said "call 110" ha
The fact that bixby is better than siri is incredible
Yet i still hate Bixby for how annoying it is, i had to spend half an hour trying to turn it off on my device, and headphones lol
@@Wertyhappy27 ikr they keep trying to push Bixby onto everyone and it's incredibly annoying I want the option to have a default voice assistant
Sort of annoying that it's not supported on my phone
Not so much for bixby but bixby routines
Mid series Samsung phone go brrrr
@@tomstreet3147 I think Fine Lock has a routines module if it isn’t available on your samsung phone.
this test is rigged, aint no way u think bixby is better than siri 💀
the dutch Siri happily takes me to his settings. I asked "open Siri settings". it went right ahead to the Siri & Search settings. the dutch Siri also did the divided by 5 thing correct for me. I just had to ask "devide that by 5". The classical music on TH-cam also works fine for me.
I think he should not say assistant settings.
yeah he should say the assistant name since the only assistant with assistant in the name is the Google Assistant
Can we just appreciate how realistic Siri's voice is? We can hardly tell the difference with a human.
so that’s what zark muckerburg use to achieve blending voices with the humans
@@randomfurrymanintheinternet But Siri is not made by Meta and Apple is like tables in my database: they have no relation to each other
@@username8586 it was just a robot meme lol
@@username8586 r/woooosh
Have you found out? I am also curious.
Bixby's Rap is on another level 😳
Doesn't beat Google Assistant's English (UK) language imo.
Doesn’t beat Siri in German
@@joerobinnettebiden4723 tried it almost summoned hitler never doing it again
I thought Alexas was great
I think Celia opened the camera app cause seeing your face is enough to make it self destruct lol
😒
@@Versusdotcom 🥺
"Turn on bluetooth" worked well on my Pixel 6
"Open assistant settings" is not fair for all other devices except Google ones as for me.
"Turn on dark mode" just opened "Dark theme" settings, but in your case it openned "Display" settings
Everyone surprised how bixby improved in the last few years
While I'm impressed how Celia improved in 1 year
Celia could only open apps, turn the music on, take a pic or tell the weather when it launched
Yes. Celia is just a born baby and she has improved that much
Yea, actually it is the winner of the award: The fastest growing assistant. Gj Huawei
Bruna Tim
"You may check the result I found online" 😂😂
🤣
😂🤣😂
The rap 😂😂😂
@@Versusdotcom that’s Celia she said that 🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂😂
Expected Google Assistant to be at the top. Was NOT expecting Bixby to outrun Siri. Kudos to Samsung!
The fact that Celia is the newest of all and still managed to awnser about half of them is remarkable
Funny how both Google and Apple made monotone raps, while Alexa and Bixby just went party mode.
5:34 Yo alexa and bixby goes hard with that rap🔥🔥
This was a great video and I personally prefer Siri. I cracked up when Celia launched the camera on the self destruct command.
Siri turning itself off😶😂
@@osmanaktas6778 Task completed, she was the only one who actually disappeared after self destructing 😂
Well it trigger the owner's self destruct on their dignity by looking at their own face
It's truly how this test has shown that Bixby is really improved over past 4 years and that samsung should get back on track and bring Bixby back to the forefront and continuously improve upon what they have.
Celia should have kept in the works until it could answer most questions without having to resort to “see the search results”
We agree!
I'm quite surprised that Bixby has evolved a lot in the last few years.
How you guys create this type of ideas, these ideas are always unique and different from the previous one. You guys just step ahead day by day. Love you guys and also your work. Keep moving forward.
Thank you very much!
For Siri in the “open assistant settings” you have to say “open Siri settings” it still works
Celia is hilarious.
Everytime she just says "you may check result what i found"
Funny
😅
4:24 the reason why siri failed this is, that siri is not the google assistent, if you say "open the siri settings" siri will open it
The thing is, they are all called voice assistants.
@@Versusdotcom I don’t think so - searching for assistant on iOS will never show you Siri, anywhere. It’s just been called Siri since it’s introduction. Assistant is probably just the word that became popular because of Google
@@Versusdotcom Google Assistant passed this test not because its an voice assistent, it passed it because its Name is Google *Assistant*
I think Google Assistant is by far the best for many reasons, not even a competition. Not just for it's ability to answer questions and do tasks, it's also simple, the fastest, when it can't do something it knows it can't do it and says I don't have that ability yet, it's super easy to use on all devices, and in my opinion the least annoying voice, maybe Siri has a better one but all her voices are too human and not robotic enough
'Divided by 5' and 'Speak like Yoda' worked on Bixby when I tried, also it works if you say 'Open Bixby settings', anyway, I'm so proud Bixby has improved a lot, it doesn't deserve the hate it got
5:43 very impressed by the rap of alexa
Bixby is sooo underrated
Siri accidentally got a point for getting “Show me the way to alexanderplatz…” wrong at 1:53. Typical Apple tactics (says the person who won’t leave the apple universe)
It' wasn't wrong, you can see at the bottom it says "getting cycling directions to alexanderplatz", the editor made a mistake putting an X over the phone.
Yes agreed
7:53 celia, how ironic
TO THOSE WHO DONT UNDERSTAND: Celia took a selfie because she thinks ur ugly and if she takes a picture of you, it will break the phone.
No if you look closely you see her counting down the photo, as if it was counting down to self destruct
@@Feetfinder2000 oh i never thought of that😂😂😭
Simple, clear and concise videos. Presumably unbiased. Great job! 😎
Glad you liked it!
it is biased because it don't give Alexa to modify system settings in Android.
This is so informative thanks mate 👌
Glad it was helpful!
2:46 Siri l like her loudness 😂😂
When She spell astronaut spelling . Really appreciate your hardwork sir keep growing 😊
I enjoy using the iPhone, but I would appreciate Siri being able to answer follow-up questions and possibly allow me to control more settings while using it hands-free.
true, siri dumb af
Fyi :
- open the calculator works on Bixby (s22 ultra).
- open the assistant settings doesn't work, but open Bixby settings does (which make sense)
I've noticed you're using a note 10 plus. Might not be the best since Bixby updates might not be the last version.
Very cool! I think it would be kinda cool to see something similar with the smart speakers (Nest Mini, Echo Dot, etc) but also I think a couple of extra points should've been given. Like 4:36, Google may have not turned on dark mode but it did take you to the place to turn it on. Another example is 3:58, Alexa or Siri didn't immediately take a photo but it did open the camera and Alexa even opened selfie cam for when you asked to take a selfie. As a user I prefer both of these behaviors and would expect it from my phone. Either way I liked the video and it surprises me even in 2022 only Google really has context and the ability to hold a conversation.
Thanks for your comment! I think the assistant should be smart and not buggy to just turn on the dark mode. That should be the point of an assistant. Opening the camera is also not enough, as if I put the phone somewhere far from me and I want to take a photo, I should be able to do this by just telling the assistant to do it - rather than doing it myself.
The trouble with some of these questions is that some of them rely on the integration of the digital assistant in their own app. For example, Siri struggling to search Instagram would be a fault of Instagram rather than Siri as a result of it not being properly integrated on their end, or alternatively (this I doubt) access has been denied in some way. In iOS, iPadOS, and MacOS the developer of the software itself is responsible for whether or not their app actually functions with Siri.
That's fair but I think the goal of the video was to see which assistant is the most practical for most people. I don't use Insta all that much but I know for a lot of people it's their primary social media and thus they might want Siri to be able to work with it.
Yes and no. Bixby whole point was to read the screen and try to click on stuff like a human would. You can see this behavior on the Instagram test that failed because they didn't set up an account or on the TH-cam test
yes a couple of those question was google biased
Apple users always trying to find excuses, I thought apps on iOS were better optimized than Android
@@Liamegg27 he’s no wrong tho, for example it would not be the first time google try to degrade experience on iOS device, google disabled on purpose PiP video for TH-cam for their premium sub on iOS but not on android. Idk about other app but it have to be known and considered
All assistants work best in English, so for the ultimate test you should also do some questions in other language's
Hello there! I'm new to your channel, and I just wanted to say, congrats on 100K subscribers!
Thank you so much! We hope you stay 🥰
i cant believe that bixby is better than siri!
Thats amazing !
Looks like samsung is putting alot of effort to improve bixby
3:07 bixby can damn sure open the calculator if you hadn't concluded on one attempt where you messed up the command.
Ofc it can, i mean it literally does things even google can't
I don't know what you mean by 'messed up the command', but it's quite obvious that all the phones understood what I said, including Bixby. We also didn't conclude anything after one attempt - if something didn't work, we tried 3 times in total to see if it was just a bug. The video would be 30 minutes long for no reason if we added the attempts that didn't work, which is quite unnecessary. Long story short - for some reason, the calculator wasn't installed. In a world where even phones from 2005 have calculators, I just didn't assume that I would actually have to download a Samsung Calculator app from the store.
@@Versusdotcom I'm confused all samsung phones come installed with samsung apps installed ( or bloatware ) like samsung internet and calculator I just tried it now with the please bit and it worked?
@@Versusdotcom Bro there is no way in the world that your samsung phone comes without calculator. Heck it comes with all the bloatware that you don't even need.
bro check it out on 1:53 this fker gave siri extra point
After a few minutes of watching the video it made me laugh everytime Celia said "you may check the search results I found online"
Interesting outcome! I'd expected the gap between Google and Siri to be way closer
Google invests more resources in AI development, Siri is just slower to evolve (mainly follow-up questions in conversations). I own an android phone and I always did so I can say that GA is just awesome for anything I ever needed.
@@fleroner8801 fax. Also, is the Alexa smart speaker thing better than Google nest speaker? Really curious because if it isn't, I can make fun of my friend for buying Alexa instead of google
@@SmitePlayz_ I'd say both Alexa and Google are nice, but I don't like Amazon products overall. I feel like Android is a better choice although I feel this choice is about personal preference.
6:00 Siri is good at storytelling
For me, using Google Assistant to activate Bluetooth worked.
Ya me 2 i just tried that out
@@Techymaestro I also tried and It just worked as fine
Same for me
Sometimes it does, sometimes it just shows you the button but makes you click on it to turn it on.
@@Versusdotcom depends on the settings (permission required) that we set
Excellent video. Well done edits.
This is a little bit unfair to Alexa which is more of a smart speaker assistant. While the other 4 were designed around smartphones.
Bixby is awesome now, but Google Assistant will always be the king.
Some of the questions I think may have been a bit more biased towards the google assistant (ie open assistant settings) if you tried asking the phones about their specific ones they might have worked (open Alexa, bixby , Siri settings)
Since they're all officially called voice assistants, I think it should still be obvious for the software.
Bill and Ted reference with guitar riff was amazing
Yes!
I remember Bixby being borderline unusable when it came out. Very surprised to see it surpass Siri.
“Surpass” dude if you use it on the real world it’s terrible. First of all Siri can work without Wifi(no other assistant can) and Siri is pretty good at understanding your voice. Bixby it’s super easy to fake it. I have easily made Bixby to answer instead of the owner
@@hunhowshadow317 oh, I didn't know some of these details. In my comment, I generally meant that it's surprising how Bixby surpassed Siri in the test shown in the video.
@@hunhowshadow317 Siri fan go spread your hate somewhere else
@@th01m3nn I have used both and it’s far superior. We are simply the best 🦾 and that’s a fact
dude Bixby opens up the calculator when i say it ://
For some reason, the calculator wasn't installed. In a world where even phones from 2005 have calculators, I just didn't assume that I would actually have to download a Samsung Calculator app from the store.
Thanks for the informative comparison. However, “Open Assistant settings” is a biased question that skews Google. A user’s familiarity with their preferred AI assistant will naturally skew some questions, so it’s worth watching out for in future videos.
Great video, really well made. A couple of interesting points:
* In your test, out of 45 questions, GA missed 4, Bixby 8, Siri 12.
* GA on my Pixel 5 could turn on bluetooth (listening to your voice from this video) and also show me the way to Alexanderplats by bicycle (even though I live in Sweden)
* With GA you are not restricted to one language, it can handle up to 3 languages at the same time.
* GA is not good yet at mixing these languages, e.g. when I ask "take me to Hötorget by bike" it often does not work because it doesn't understand the Swedish word in the middle, but if I ask it in Swedish it works.
* The "read this page" command is awesome (as long as it doesn't need a subscription to access the page)!
There were some bugs in the Pixel 6 series' software during this time. That's why the results aren't consistent. Glad to hear they work on yours!
we need 10 times more comparison and complete and precise information like this. good video for users
5:27 If you set google to English (UK) it gets super cool. You need to ask it to rap 5 times to get a complete song. And it is really good gimmick.
Rap competition tho. Bixby absolute destroyed it 🔥🔥. I have Bixby and I don't know how to describe how perfect it is man.
I subscribe great work keep posting
resume of the video : "you may check the search results i found online"
Actually, google assistant turned on the bluetooth for me flawlessly.
The assistant has a continuous answer.. that is absolutely the best for me
great video as usual! it would be necessary to do the same test except that instead of a smarphone it is a smart speaker
Great video, but... If you ask Siri to open 'Siri settings' rather than 'assistant settings', it works. Other than that though, a very pleasant watch!
Great idea comparing them but I feel the score is not completely accurate - my Siri can play classical music on TH-cam for instance. Also she can continue a calculator string of operations if you quickly press the Siri bubble on the screen and provide further instructions.
The reason Siri didn't get a point is because of the fact that you have to press the Siri bubble. The reason Google got the point is because you don't have to say "hey Google" or open the assistant, you can just ask Google within about a 5 to 10 second time frame from from asking your first calculation and it will add onto the calculation.
Bixby is damn great 👍
Not everyone knows about it
I use most of the time
But Google is something else 🔥
On some commands you would rather not have the apps downloaded or even be logged in on Bixby. How do u expect it to work
5:48 "you may check the search result i found online" thats my rap lol
Celia is a very nice assistant,just that it lacks Google support,that's why it's lacking behind,but we hope to see it better in HarmonyOs 3
Proud Pixel user here 😍
followed the tutorial exactly right, but still different. Using trial version. Thank you
The issue with bixby is that it can not execute some commands with Google suite. Like, it can't play something on TH-cam Music. Just open the app. It can't check emails in the Gmail app, only in the native Samsung email app.
4:36 Bixby failed cuz u didn't even have an account💀💀💀
Bruh moment 💀💀💀
bruh
Huawei when asked 'who is the president of US ' : That,s none of my business (anger on them)
Guess they're salty because the US banned them
@@Solaceon 😂😂
Bixby has a benefit of being built specifically for samsung phones so it has more control over settings than the Google assistant, but Google has better search results and more understanding
I Live for the rap test! hahaha hilarious!
I can't wait for Bixby to overtake everyone else 😂😂
Would be hilarious because of all the hate it got over the years.
It's still shit
3:20, my google assistant can turn on bluetooth?
"you may check the search results I found online"😂😂
5:35 and 6:03 The fact that Alexa and Bixby learned how to rap😃😭🖐
Bixby killed that rap 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Off course google
3:22 The bluetooth one with Google Assistant worked on my case.
Huawei is still improving their HarmonyOS and EMUI system. I hope Celia will improve in the future. 😍
I'm a proud huawei user here!
I just bought my Huawei Nova 9, an upgrade from my Huawei Nova 2 after 7 years and it's still working.
06:21 Bixbys answer on that one :D
Bixby opens calculator on my phone. Maybe you did not have the calculaton app installed on your test phone.
For some reason, the calculator wasn't installed. In a world where even phones from 2005 have calculators, I just didn't assume that I would actually have to download a Samsung Calculator app from the store. Did you have the calculator installed when you bought the S22 Ultra?
@@Versusdotcom thanks for answering. Yes that is why I made the comment. I was also surprised to find that samsung calculator was not installed on the phone and I had to download it. Keep up the good work. Always enjoying your videos.
I laughed so hard when he asked "what sound does an Elephant make" and Celia got marked wrong for finding test results before making the Elephant sounds😂😂😂😂😂😂
To see the comment you may check the results I found online
Now jokes aside I completly expected Google to be ahead, but Bixby improved a lot. Also didn't knew Alexa is so bad. Also I think Celia should show the results instantly without having to click. To be fair it is also the newest Assistent and some things it can do surprised me. Hope they will improve Celia soon, mayby with Harmony OS that should release in a few days.
Great Video.