Question Time | 9th May 2024
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ต.ค. 2024
- Fiona Bruce presents an hour of debate, with politicians, commentators and members of the public, in Stoke-on-Trent. On the panel: treasury minister Nigel Huddleston MP; Labour’s shadow secretary for international development Lisa Nandy MP; author and politics and economics commentator Grace Blakeley; and chief executive of the PureGym chain Humphrey Cobbold. Also live on iPlayer at 20:00.
Copyright (C) BBC, BBC News, BBC One, BBC Worldwide, 2024. If you would like me to remove this video, please contact me, not TH-cam.
Hey! It would be greatly appreciated if you could buy me a coffee in lieu of all the videos I have uploaded. Everything here is free, worldwide. It really helps, Thank You.
www.buymeacoff...
Is anyone else really repulsed by the smug smirking and patronising lecturing tone of the tory politician and the gym CEO?
There was Grace Blakely and three tories on that panel.
No. I'm repulsed by Lisping Lisa Nandy.
Which tory?
No not at all he has made lots of jobs for local people, i am repulsed by the lowlife socialist scumbags in the audience who believe they are owed a living.
Yes, and also the way Bruce cut Lisa Nandy short at every opportunity. She and Kuensberg need to be given garden leave.
5 minutes in and Labour already trashing Corbyn and gushing over Conservative MPs... what is the point of them?
Lisping Lisa Nandy is a total horror.
It was Corbyn who gave Johnson his 80 seat majority
@@johnbarrance4926 more the likes of Mandelson, Nandy, Hodges, Phillips, Starmer and Co who actively worked to discredit the leadership for 4 years and during both elections
@@johnbarrance4926 it was the public who did that. Both were very popular with the public which is why there was such a good turnout for a December election.
@@johnbarrance4926 i dont think so. It was the brexit hype that gave him his majority. Corbyn didnt sound serious on the brexit vote.
The British people have been slowly pacified and dumbed down by Murdoch and the powerful = we have the politicians we deserve. Nothing will change. We did it to ourselves.
Yep. Britain is being invaded and all people do is post angry comments. If this was 50s or 60s. People will be out on streets taking matters into their own hands.
That's a very defeatist point-of-view
I would like to see A day when everybody in the country don't vote because what are you voting for
How's the re-join campaign going?
@@colinritchie1398 Change
The Forde report ,Lisa nandy ,,, why has keir starmer ignored its findings
What a brilliant beautiful pleasant and perceptive woman Grace Blakeley is. A real pleasure to have around.
Grace under pressure!!!!
@@BrockSamson-i1i Coals to Newcastle.
Isn't that a bit sexist?
@@alexvince461 I think it probably would be if you had a rod up your arse.
Boycott true gym
Cancel your membership brothers
Do it now
Now online
Why?
Why did the Tory ask about hamas, UK doesnt supply them arms?
Because KKHHHAAAMMAAASSSS 😂
He was desperate. Grace put him in his place.
Is there any sensible way to defend a genocide?
how DO YOU know they dont ?
you sell arms to dealers , who they sell to is academic as long as scammer sunak gets his weapons shares dividends - makes sense to arm both sides in a conflict you arent fighting its common sense & weve dont it since weapons were invented !
Politicians will say ANYTHING to get elected then break their promises when they get in.!! 2 Cheeks of the same Ass.!!
Nick clegg is a prime example ( whos he ? said all the young kids with no university place )
Genocide was the elephant tonight
What genocide?
Pleases 🙏 support Israel 🇮🇱they have every right to defend itself always don't forget october the 7th anything else is IRRELEVANT!
@@georgefrancis8602 do you really think Israel has a green light for everything because of Oct 7th? I feel sorry for you
@@SA77Notts yes thank you!
@@SA77Notts go and fight back instead of waving a flag 3 thousand miles away.
Quite disgraceful remarks from Nandi, Labour are slowly becoming what it was under Bliar. Labour are itching to get their hands in power and are demonstrating they'll be not too dissimilar to the Tories in terms of core policies. Grace Blakely seemed to have really got under Nandi's skin aswell.
Well Blair successfully moved the Labour Party to the centre after the wilderness of Michael Foot and more recently Jeremy Cotbyn.
You can’t win elections from the extreme left or right - it has to be the centre which is why Blair won three elections with huge majorities
Blair won 3 elections with a huge majority. Corbyn had the worst result for almost 100 years
Blair won 3 elections
Corbyn won none. Embarrassing loss
You mean in a multiple election winning position to keep the Tories out for 10 years? Wow that doesnt sound too bad
Wow! I find myself in strong agreement with Grace Blakeley.A bit disconcerting that she seems to be able to read my mind!
Bit concerned by Lisa Nandy's attack on her. It seemed personal and when she finished you could see she was angry but also pleased that she thought she'd won. That's not a way to do politics.
Freudian slip by Lisa Nandy Labour MP at 15:45: she says Keir Starmer when she means Rishi Sunak. Right Lisa, there may be no difference.
Yes, noticed that as well!
I came here for this! She really didn't do well!
Does anyone know why the pure gym CEO is on the panel?
Because he is a Tory with a breathtaking sense of entitlement.
The most random guest they have had on this show haha
Because the street that should contain another party needs some random Tory supporter instead.
Because his wife is a Zionist and they don't get enough airtime
Seemed to be a Tory/ Israel spokesman
Boycott PureGym!!!
It’s all NONSENSE. The only people defending Israel are doing it for money or for their religion. There is no logical, human, practical reason for not wholly condemning what Israel is doing. Nobody is doing it other than reasons of money or religion
Tonight's episode was brought to you by the word "robust"
Labour and conservative parties are more aligned than not, so it doesn't make a difference to british politics who wins between them. This is evidenced, for example, by how the Israel lobby has pernicious influence/hold over both conservative and labour parties as reported in the following videos by 'declassified UK':
th-cam.com/video/rjuH6_kf3Eo/w-d-xo.htmlsi=E_QycTAC1ndZq90H
th-cam.com/video/FS2PrE5Gruw/w-d-xo.htmlsi=JTRxIpI-ksvR-L6Z
th-cam.com/video/f319YyV8IpY/w-d-xo.htmlsi=ksMc3WQC6JfSodYd
th-cam.com/video/6VzfSrhNI44/w-d-xo.htmlsi=cBjIVLrp57OnRKuy
Nandy is just a loud mouthed bully
All leftists are
have a drink every time a politician / gym owner says 'robust' you'll be on the floor
😂
An utterly disgraceful panel save for one! At least the applause is generally revealing. The tories being vile I can understand, but Nandy indistinguishable from a Tory, puts more effort into trying to trash the only left wing voice on the panel
You won't be happy until the only views on a panel EXACTLY reflect yours. You're a child
Grace is amazing
simp
Can't believe Fiona actually let someone on the left speak. Unheard of
She is terrible.
Are you kidding?? The media is dominated by the left and the woke. You have no idea
@user-fe1gb9uc1t you must be a right wing nut job if you think this show has a left wing bias. Dear God. Every week is like 3 right wingers, one centrist and one person on the left
Question time host is just useless does not suit this show
Boycott PureGym
But what about before October the 7th? Like the past 75 years!
well said.....nobody hardly mentions that just at those times they need to
History started way beyond 75 years ago
@@realityalwaysbulliesopinio1961 There's a much larger land mass the Jews have claim to, not the paltry area they now reside. We can only go by the legal situation now as we can't unravel history eg empty America by repatriating the Africans, Italians, Irish, Polish, Mexicans etc. Or removing the British and Asians from Australia. The line in the ground is now, not 1948 or any other prior date.
Boycott PureGym!
He's an ex Mirror group man and the US government consulting firm Mckinsey and company , its disingenuous for her to introduce him as just the guy who took over Pure Gym.
I'm signing up now. Pure gym all the way.
I doubt you've ever seen the inside of a gym ever. 😂
Literally just cancelled my membership after hearing his gushing of Isreal. Disgusted.
Been with for about 5 Years. Shame on me.
Lies. Lefties don't work out...just complain
Go, Grace Blakely, being on point for the issues! She's speaking 🔊 truth to power
Occupiers do not have the right to self defense.
You mean violent Islamists who took over Gaza by lethal force from Fatah
Not since 2005.
Gutsy Grace. A breath of fresh air.
MP. Nigel Huddleston look more like a business man than a representative of the people, and it would not surprise me if he doesn't take Israeli Lobby finances, it come off very shady trying to press home "Israel has a right to defend itself".
Yes, Israel has a right to defend itself - proud the UK can contribute to that.
@@ne-ht4zx , nothing wrong with fake illegal State of Israel representing itself, however, not at the expense of other people. They are invading White Supremacist Europeans, this Jew title is religious, not a Nationality or a Bloodline.
You see how he interjected Grace because he stupidly forgot his 'but Hamas' in his opening monologue
Palestine has a right to defend itself
when will people talk about the intense demographic cultural change of the uk , immigration. its more important than isreal gaza conflict to the uk
Lisa Nandy is such a Liar is insane she is given the air time LOL
Bigdaz……big apart from……
Audience member - "...your acting like you would sell your Soul to win a General Election?"
Lisa Nandy - "No i wouldn't, i can't sell something i sold a long time ago to the LFI"
Nandy supported genocide and is now stating that othera are in the wrong, disgusting behaviour and misleading the audience
Nandy doesn’t believe a word she’s saying about that treacherous MP.
Anything to keep their noses in the trough
Spoke a load of nonsense.
Grace makes sense!
Lisa Nandy once had promise.
Not anymore.!!
No she didn't.
@@clivet3252 whatever promise she may have had it’s clear now she is a coward
Never 😂
yeh use to like her ..working class northen girl ....sold out
I’m voting green next, Tories and Labour need to go
Corbyns downfall was trying during an election to nuance the labour position on BREXIT.
It wasnt about the nationalism of rail and water and much of the manifesto was very popular.
You cant nuance a policy like BREXIT when the media insist on portraying it as confusing. The people like simple yes/no during elections which makes elections very blunt instruments.
Mark these words: prior to the next election the pro remainers in labour will be placed in very uncomfortable positions in interviews . Not so much the Tory remainers.
Just enough to produce a hung government, i suspect.
His downfall was he is weak and got bullied by the press and the tories aka labour mps
Corbyns dithering during the 2016 referendum severely damaged the remain vote .The seasoned Eurosceptic used the cloak of neutrality to try and dodge the issue. Any other Labour leader would have campaigned vigorously for remain .
DO NOT VOTE LABOUR! DO NOT VOTE FOR SHIT-FACE SUNAC! VOTE GREEN! OR VOTE WORKERS' PARTY!
You have Dorito crumbs in your caps lock
C'mon Man, Labour have got to have some Standards ffs, if they got rid of their Double Standards they wouldn't have any Standards left whatsoever.
Imagine sitting there with a straight face while doing the maths on how many people were killed on oct 7th compared to the audience. I wonder what his calculation would be for the amount of palestinans killed. Its whatever he said times 35 🤦🏻♀️
Covid costs (PPE, test & trace) were added to the NHS budget so it looks like the gov has spent more money. #ToryLiars
Boycott pure gym
All members you must boycott
Understand what nasty stuff he just saud towards middle and end
Why? Aren't people allowed to have different opinions?
@@alisonstuart2784 Not if they are wrong.
labour being a pathetic left wing party as per
A rather silly comment.
Last time I saw contortionists like this was in a portrayal of Dante's Inferno where many of these panelists will end up!
Boycott puregym
Why?
@@alisonstuart2784 just boycott it, dont ask why!!
@@alisonstuart2784 because the CEO is a prat.
@@orhun2049but he showed sympathy for both sides, do you just want him to show sympathy for your favourite side?
@@StrangeBoyTVdo you really expect me to believe him. You can tell he’s being manipulated by his bosses. He’s pretending to be impartial to the cameras so he wont be lynched, loose stocks/shares
Lisa Nandy is a great supporter of billionaire oligarchs, big business, corporate capitalism, and right-wing murdoch press. She is indistinguishable from a Conservative. So disappointing and despicable. There is no difference between Conservative and Labour. Starmer has dropped all of his pledges!
What a difference between Lisa Nandy in the role as International Development secretary and Clare Short who truly offered hope
Poor Fiona Bruce, she doesn't know which tory to be biased for.
Nandy is such a waste of space...........invariably defaults to 'when I was in a school/hospital/ pub/market' in my constituency' yet remains ineffective and vacuous
Thank you south africa thank you CELTİC we humans are not animals we humans are all palastine ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤1948
Although countries have a right to defend themselves, somehow it feels like that right doesn’t apply to Palestine.
It's not a country. It was established by colonial Britain
@@MrHungryeyez I never said it was a country, I said Palestine
@@MrHungryeyez You're right they are not a country they are an apartheid occupation. So actually that means they do have a right to defend themselves against the occupiers.
@@BrockSamson-i1i My point was about the people of Palestine should also have the right to defending themselves.
Good to see the bias standards are alive and well with the continued support for the genocidal Zionist regime and Tory grassroots as always acting like children and the usual childish hate thrown at labour isn't surprising it's the only thing grassroots Tory's are capable of FYI palastiane is a state/ country while Israel is recognised as a genocidal Zionist Terror camp Zionists moaning about Oct 7 yeah a tragedy caused by 75 years of Zionist occupation and ethnic cleansing freedom for Palestine from the river to the sea
ROLL ON THE GENERAL ELECTION, ENOUGH OF THIS BLAH BLAH BLAH BS, JUST GET THE BALL ROLLING INSTEAD OF DRAGGING ON THE INEVITABLE.........
You have Dorito crumbs in your caps lock
Anyone else tired of bigbrother rolling out the same people. Lisa nandy, yvette cooper, lammy, thornberry n streeting. Again n again n again its sad
Trust and Politicians are two words that do not go together.
Freedom of speech for who we humans are all palastine ❤❤❤❤❤❤Thank you humans ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Anybody but Lisa Nandy!! PLEASE.
Black lives matter we are all palastine ❤❤❤❤❤❤
And GPS surgery's are getting WORSE !!
"It takes a lot to cross the floor" she's taken a long, long look at what went on last week at the local and London elections and has decided to change ship. Obviously she expects something in return such as continuing to be the MP for the Dover constituency.
I'm gonna start putting half a savoy cabbage on my head too
The elephant in the room are unelected consultants with policy power.
Why were the tories unable?
Blocked by non tories at every turn.
Little Britain Central
That's Stoke-on-Trent 😆
The politicians play their roles well don't they.?..
Anti-Semitic can also mean Anti - Arab. Arab is a synonym for Semite. Arabia - home of the JM267 P58 West Asia/Semitic DNA, which also includes Jews. P58 - Cohen
7 plus decades of Israeli apartheid was the elephant in this room
Bottom line. There is no party worthy of our vote. There is no party with strong common-sense leadership who act as a collective to deliver what the people ask. Bringing Labour in, a party that seems all over the place, will lead to a bad situation getting worse. Emergencies are abounded; ailing NHS, immigration (legal & illegal), another religion invading our culture, lack of opportunities for our kids, housing and that's all before the terrible state of our roads, dirty city centres, heating costs and lack of social care. We seem to put more focus and importance on things out with our own navels; wars in Ukraine & Gaza, the climate non-emergency, transgenderism, the Kardashians and the Eurovision Song Contest ! We need a person or party of common sense and obedience or UK will morph into an Eastern European state.
Can we really trust Ms Nandy with our country’s financial future? She is sincere, I’m sure, but though I’m a Labour supporter they need more able people in charge. I fear things will soon go from bad to worse. Of course Labour are acting as opportunists and they won’t deliver on their promises - no one ever does once they get into power. And over Diane Abbott - for goodness sake, who in their right mind would won’t that divisive and incompetent person back in the party. How shambolic things have become.
If only Grace understood economics and history
Obnoxious little Head Prefect isn't she
When is a general election not a big deal lol
such a robust debate
I want a new host to this show almost at much as i want the UK to have a new prime minister. Looking just at the last question, Fiona gets the station and gives it to the two right wing men without much dressing. Then when it comes to give it to the more left leaning women, she adds facts and quotes to preemptively weaken their arguments. It's disgusting. She's incredibly clearly right leaning. She doesn't even try to hide her bias.
Scotland needs to continue voting SNP and eventual independence. Labour and the Conservatives are two cheeks of the same ....
Whats the difference between the '7th October' and a cow? You can only milk a cow once a day... 😂
Bring them home
How can you have peace in an apartheid country?
Did she really say that she has values and they don't (audience)!!!!?
I'd say we are well past needing more indicators.....
Get back on to uk stuff. We got british jewish people who are scared to walk our street in the uk that what should be concentrated whats happening in Britain not other countrys
Gullis is fucked. Brilliant
Gullis is a great man who has done great things for the Stoke people we love him.
Labor??? That's a joke isn't it? British dark humor, it must be!
This is supposed to be about the uk not other countrys stop bring other countrys in to this plus theres a right for uk to defend its self
Rats deserting the sinking ship starmer is no better labour will not stand with the people and put them first
People of colour don't vote lammey don't vote labour we humans stand with palastine Mandela Marcus malcom King we humans are all palastine ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤Thank you humans
Vote Reform
Lisa Nandy makes it obvious Elphicke is a good fit for Starmer's Labour party
Labour will bring this country to its knees. If the tories weren’t racist and picked rodhi before liz truss, this country would be would be in a better position internationally
One thing that is better in the UK today than 2010?
When you realise you can not give an answer to that…you should recognise you’ve been blagged beyond belief.
53:02 the sense of entitlement is breathtaking.
Leftists hate success. Cry harder. Someone has to pay for your benefits
@@MrHungryeyez The new breed of poorly educated, badly trained, incompetent British doctors are among the highest paid in Europe but provide one of the worst services in Europe. British taxpayers are getting poor value for money.
My job went to stoke leaving me with out a job and many others
We humans are not animals we humans are all palastine freedom for one is freedom for all humanity stand with palastine Mandela Marcus malcom King ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Stand with plasticine
20 min on 1 question. Boring
People can change their minds...i seem to remember the former immigration minister was touting the Rwanda plan until he decided it wasnt going to work and resigned...
Humanity stand with palastine Boycott labour Boycott lammey Boycott labour don't vote labour Humanity stand with palastine ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I stand with Israel bring them home
United States of Israel
I can’t complain about our Australian Medicare. It’s not perfect. By any means my mum is 93 and received a pacemaker on Medicare with no waiting time at all.We still have long waits for hip replacement and non urgent surgeries etc. Also our Private system is very expensive with out of pocket expenses. So a lot are coming out of private healthcare.
Having lived in Melbourne for a while I agree the healthcare is generally good, but its not a fair comparison to the UK. We have a population of around 67million where Aus is 22million. We need sizeable hospital in pretty much every town, and multiple GP surgeries and dentists etc in pretty much every village for it to work efficiently. We are not mostly gathered population wise in places like Melb, Syndey, Brisbane, Perth, Adelaide etc. The NHS was rated the best regarded and most efficient service in the world in 2010. The population has not got that much sicker and older in that time its purely down to austerity, funding not keeping in line with inflation and Tory mismanagement.
Costs me $90 to see the GP these days in Melbourne.
Big King Crimson shirt!
Spotted this guy too. Smiling as the puppets dance.
Keir Starmer doesn’t want an election..?
Humanity stand with palastine ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Pure gym man wants to privatise rhe NHS
Pure gym man wants the new breed of poorly educated, badly trained, incompetent British doctors to be paid footballers wages.
I think Lisa has done more defacing Labour than their defector.
Interesting isnt it, where Corbin got IDF and Hamas round a table, way back. Not like anyone asked or he wanted to score political points... and Lisa is regurgitating that like the 'what do you mean' about the Iraq /MD invasion.
Interesting, Grace earned more respect than an entrepreneur, and two MPs.
One of the reasons I left Britain and am living abroad is the hypocrisy of the people who vote for the conservative party elections after elections and then come onto programs such as this to moan and whine about things they did vote for. The conservative party has been in government since Cameron which means the last Labour government was the Gordon Browne administration so all the chaos and incompetence with the dilapidation of the hospitals and schools are under the Conservatives they also presided over Brexit which has devastated the economy. Cameron visited Trump, Boris visited Trump since Trump was voted out of government by the Americans, be aware and vote them out!
Yeah what their words...march forward (with money we fought with money we will be buried)