I like how no one has addressed it takes like 48 hours of prep to make a single batch of icecream. I'm pretty most people can get this within 15 minutes of their home or less with no clean up or prep.
I have several friends with food intolerances so it's tough to find good treats at the grocery store or ice cream shop. That is likely their target audience. Or young parents who want fresh healthy treats for the kids. It's also fun for kids to make their own. Although I agree that the Ninja Creami is a better choice for that.
I agree, this one is a total flop. It's much easier just buying a box of icecream, let it sit on the counter for 30 minutes, and you've got soft ice the easy fast way.
@@joonglegamer9898 It's not a total flop, it was a fine product when it was new. But, technology advances. And no, leaving ice cream sit for 30 minutes is not at all acceptable. You can really only get away with that if you're going to eat all of it in one sitting, if you try to refreeze it, it's going to suck.
I always enjoy these videos, not because I like the products, but because James does a great job reviewing. Some reviewers have unrealistic expectations.
Tip, make the ice cream in your blender and then just chill it in the blender container. This will blend it better as well, especially with the chocolate ice cream, because the cocoa can be hard to dissolve. Honestly this machine doesn't seem the best to me. The problem is it's trying to imitate an ice cream parlor soft serve "experience" but it's failing. The ice cream doesn't come out in a smooth stream, so it's extremely slow and doesn't really fill a cone or bowl in a good way. The freezer bowl is too cold, so it eventually freezes the ice cream hard. The design of the topping dispensers clearly needs some work. Plus this thing is way more expensive than just a standard Cuisinart freezer bowl ice cream maker and it doesn't seem worth it. You're better off just buying the regular ice cream maker and stopping it when the ice cream is as soft as you like and eating it.
@@SmallSpoonBrigade I meant to mix it before you put it in the ice cream maker, not to make and freeze ice cream in your blender? Didn't think I'd have to explain that part.
@@robincochran7369 My Cuisinart ice cream maker is also at least ten years old and is still going strong. The bowl lives in my freezer, tied up in a plastic shopping bag and ready to go wherever I next want to use it.
i have the basic cuisinart icecream maker, with the same frozen bowl technology. it makes really tasty ice cream, however i like. it can be soft if served immediately, or harder if left in the freezer overnight. i really like it, its easy to use, and i just leave the bowl in the freezer all the time so its ready when i want it. the one he reviewed seems to have a lot of bells and whistles that are just unneeded, and its much larger spacewise, with the same size freezer bowl. i bet its much harder to clean with that dispenser too. just stick to the simple model, get your ice cream out with a spoon, and you will be happy
I also have the same basic cuisenart ice cream maker that you have and concur with your experiences. It can make Gelato, sorbet, sherbet, soft and hard ice cream and it way cheaper and easier to use. Makes great ice cream. The soft Ice cream maker seems like a bad idea.
100%. Had the cuisinart for about 15+ years and it is less complicated and less parts than this. And the tub can be kept in freezer and ready to go anytime. For me making ice cream is still a 2-day thing. Make the ice cream mixture on day 1 and then freeze on day 2 to ensure the liquid is super cold because I use eggs and heat up the cream.
I know this was an appliance review, but the design flaws of this thing made for very amusing viewing; I was choking with laughter a couple of times, ha! Thanks for being a good sport and for posting your experience with this ice cream maker!
@@anirudhnavin4568 their first check the ice cream was still liquidy so they waited. Also, UK voltage is different, would that affect the stirring and their freezer may have been set lower. Soft serve isn’t supposed to be brought down to temps below 20deg F (-6 deg C).
Nostalgia sells a compressor based soft serve machine now which is around $600. This is the same machine that was sold as the Ice Cream depot sx1000 , until that company went out of business.
I saw this on Sorted Food and they had constant issues with it freezing up. This really needs a way to defrost it a bit. I'm curious how it would do if you didn't chill the mix before pouring it in.
That's the main issue I had with mine. It's too large to keep in the kitchen and you have to freeze the bowl in order for it to get anything. It did work reasonably well, I just rarely used it because of how much of a hassle it was to setup and clean up.
I laughed my a$$ off watching this!😂 I’m guessing this is headed directly to the bone yard at the end of this video. I can’t think of one redeeming value for this thing other than it being a good landfill object. Thanks for saving so many people from the abject horror of this monstrosity!
steel bowl, plastick pack, ice, saltwater and someting to stir the icecream mix till it gets harder (i used old aa battery milk frother and rubber band to keep it in bowl) then use a fork.... works :)... and no expensive crap taking extra space in kichen
Where does this reputation keep coming from?! Who decided cuisinart was a good brand and when? They weren't good before. They aren't good now. I can only begin to guess that this is literally based on it being the best (read: most expensive) brand sold at walmart and target over the last 10 years. Their products are universally higher in price than the competition, while generally offering worse performance and many of their appliances are downright dangerous with a tendency to overheat, faulty cords that melt because they can't handle the current, and dangerous designs that extremely hot surfaces less than an inch from intended grab points.
@@TheDoc73I’m glad you mentioned this. I had a Cuisinart toaster oven that fried itself because the cord got too hot. I thought it was defective, but it sounds like that’s a common issue.
Good review as always. Personally, you might as well get an ice cream maker with a built in compressor and if you like soft serve, eat it fresh out of the container (instead of curing in the freezer). No need to pre-freeze.
Of course. But those cost a lot more. My local shop has a machine that can go from liquid ice cream premix to actually serving in Iike 10 minutes. Awesome. But the machine was 12 grand.
@@PoeLemic I bought and love the Whynter Ice Cream Maker Machine Automatic 2.1 Qt (Model ICM-200LS). On Amazon right now it's 256USD. But I got it on sale (which happens from time to time) for only $150
I have the Cuisinart ice cream maker which looks like the top half of this device without the spigot and dispensers. It also has a larger "bowl". You freeze the "bowl" overnight then pour in the ingredients and it mixes it into an ice cream. It works really good and by looking into the clear lid, you can decide when your ice cream is the right consistency, AND you can pour your toppings into it and have it mix it as well.
I bought an ice cream maker years ago where you had to freeze the drum for 24 hours. I used it twice and then put it away. I bought a Ninja Creami 5 months ago and have used it almost every day since. I don't see how any other type of machine can be easier than the Creami. If you get a bunch of empty containers you can make multiple flavors and have them ready to go the next day. As soon as I have a few empty containers I fill them back up so it's always ready to go.
idk if you would interested in doing a review for Breville Smart Scoop Ice Cream Compressor. You dont need to chill the bowl cause it has a compressor built into the machine. It's a machine that makes all different textures
Hmmm, I got one of these years ago and don't remember having any of these issues. Yours is obviously an updated model. I haven't used it in a couple of years (it is huge) so now I want to pull it out and try it again!
Same here, I never had any issues with the use of it. The issues I had were mostly having to plan ahead to have the appropriate parts frozen. And the fact that it's a single use appliance that takes up a lot of space. Really, people are making this out to be a horrible product when really it isn't. It's just a product that probably should have been considered obsolete a few years ago and replaced with a version with a built in compressor.
I don't have a Creami, but this is an OK device, I had one, I just didn't really use it very much due to it being a pretty specific tool and needing to think ahead to freeze things ahead of time. I'd probably have gone with the Creami if that had existed when I bought it, just because it does have built in refrigeration.
@@SmallSpoonBrigade The Ninja Creami you have to put your mixture in the freezer until frozen. Then run it through the machine to give you nice creamy ice cream.
I have the KitchenAid Ice cream maker - same type of bowl, dasher and a small piece that snaps on and holds the dasher. I use mine frequently. I store the bowl in the freezer (covered with a silicone lid that attaches snugly) upside down. I always make an egg yolk based custard on the stove. It's super easy to clean up (Just 3 parts that are easily hand washed). The cooked ice cream base makes the difference in the taste.
I'm glad you reviewed this! ;) I think my Ninja Slushie makes amazing soft serve and it's very easy to clean. The Topping Dispenser is goofy lol I think just leave that topping Dispenser out. Then you got to clean all that put your unused toppings back. Eh
This thing is huuuge and still won't chill the bowl and you also have to put the mix into the fridge first!? Instead it's packed with useless features like the topping dispensers, cone holder and the "keep warm station".
Thank you so much for this full review. I am thinking about getting one of these but I hadn't decided. I like to make ice cream because the stuff they sell at the store has too much sugar. This way I can substitute the sugar for stevia.
I saw this reviewed on Sorted Food channel, and they could not get it to work at all as it kept freezing up solid. They also mentioned the issued with it being difficult to clean. So seems like this is a no go for ice cream.
I've got the perfect answer to this get your favorite ice cream at your local store and put in the freezer, then when you want an ice cream go to your fridge no pre freezing and no waiting for things to get cold in your freezer or fridge. May be a few cents dearer but no problem.
I wish I could but the closest grocery store for me is over an hour away and I live in the desert where 3/4 of the year it is over 100f. It was still 100-110 all last week, the first week of October. Ice cream doesn't make it home frozen even in a cooler with ice. It is always soup by the time I get home and then refreezing it makes it taste like freezer burn. That was my main reason for buying a Creami but after tasting the recipes and how amazingly good they are the store bought ice cream just doesn't compare.
Got the same kind of ice cream machine idea, for like 20 bucks 5 years ago. This isn't really any different, just bigger and way too overpriced. It's the same manual work too.
Years ago I bought a cheap Savoureux Pro Line Ice Cream Maker from Walmart. It doesn't have cone holders, topping chutes, or a warming station. And it takes longer than 30 minutes to complete. It does, however, make ice cream at the right consistency every time, and it was far less expensive.
I have an ice cream maker that takes a similar approach. The frozen metal bowl with the spatula turning bit. It doesn't have all the extra fancy stuff, dispenser or the toppings. I don't know that you really need them. It works much like that one. But I just came to the conclusion that I prefer buying as to making it. Idk, I might revisit it. As I've completely shifted my diet away from pre made or restaurant made food. I eat almost all organic/natural food these days and my body thanks me for it. So I could try it again as ice cream isn't really part of my diet these days.
I have a cuisinart ice cream maker with a compressor. It’s amazing. It takes less time to make the ice cream, and no freezing the bowl first. It doesn’t have anything like toppings, but it works.
they tried one out on sorted food and could not get it to make icecream without it blocking the outlet, you managed to do it, they wanted feedback from other owners on what they were doing wrong
Those machines will cost a lot more. But also be quicker. My local place can go from liquid mix in a carton all the way to serving in 10 minutes. But their machine cost more than my car.
I'd have to remove a bunch of food to make room for it. And then I have keep it in there permanently unless I want to wait a day to make ice cream. So this thing would just end up collecting dust on a shelf in the basement.
It looks like there's an attachment for the Kitchenaid stand mixer to make ice cream. Also, any mix you add that isn't a true ice cream custard before it's frozen won't taste like real ice cream. That means cooking it with eggs and the whole shibaz before it goes into the machine. Peace and Love 🌈🌞✌️💕
I have their ice cream maker that, for the cold bowl and churner, looks remarkably similar. We had a difficult time making the ice cream with a consistency harder tan soft serve so this is almost a good remanufacture of the device. Taste-wise the frozen treats were yummy but needed at least double the amount of time for churning with a 'bowl' frozen for days and the mixture also partially frozen. We did find the bowl for the device was not convenient for freezing. It takes up too much room and needs to be in the freezer too long to work at all.
A common theme with ice cream makers that require freezing the bowl ( vs having an internal chiller) is that the bowl and ingredient prep are very important. You need to get the bowl to be solidly frozen in order to have it be cold enough. Your ice cream mix should be nearly frozen as well, so it needs less cooling during the process. I've made good ice cream dozens of times in a tropical environment with this kind of setup. It takes more waiting time than a chiller type machine but it costs a lot less.
Ok I figured it out. It sounds like a lawn mower to trick you into thinking it’s summer and ice cream time. Cuisinart is becoming the Bell and Howell of food brands.
I make my own “soft serve” whenever I want to by taking normal ice cream and stirring it with my spoon until it’s the consistency I want. Much less time consuming and cheaper than investing in this machine, which let’s face it, is a cool novelty the first couple of times, than will most likely end up under your counter never to be used again
My Mom only ever bought vanilla ice scream. Thanks for bringing back the memory of my Granny letting the ice cream soften, then stirring in Hershey's Chocolate Syrup and mixing it up to make Chocolate soft serve ice cream!
Exactly! My mom taught me that trick when I was little. Still do it today whenever I’m in the mood. Not to mention, you can still also opt for hard ice cream by doing nothing at all. This monster of a gadget only makes soft serve, and you either always have to have some pre-mixed in the freezer or wait over a day to have it. Annoying and completely unnecessary.
Thanks for walking through how we would use this. I really want to find a home ice cream maker, so you helped guide me to making a decision on what I will buy.
I find it works best with just straight half and half cream. We keep our bowl in the freezer all the time so it's ready to go at a moment's notice. You don't need 24 hours to freeze the bowl if you have a decent freezer. We have made ice cream after 8 hours in our deep freeze.
Ninja Creami is still number 1 in my book. You still have to plan ahead but I grabbed a few extra pints so we have a couple of base favourites always frozen so if you get an ice cream craving you can just grab a chocolate or vanilla, spin, mix in, and consuuuuuuume! Protein shake masked as chocolate mint ice cream has completely re-invigorated my weekend exercise and food planning routine. The creami will also spin different flavours all day long if you freeze in advance where this has a hard cap on how much you can make due to the bowl and extra bowls take up way too much space in a freezer. Looks like about 6 pints to 1 bowl in physical size. Plus an extra bowl is 40 bucks where extra creami pints are dirt cheap.
Wowww, fancy. My wife and I feel old watching this. In my day we cranked an ice cream bucket to make ice cream or go to a Dairy Queen. Now you can buy a fancy thingy to make it home.🍦😯
Some of my best memories was us kids arguing over who was gonna get to sit on top of the ice cream bucket to hold it down while my parents cranked it. THE best ice cream ever 👍
you can tell the candy dispenser was an after thought. they probably added it to make the device more symmetrical. the chute for the candy could have been set up to drop in the center but it instead launches out the side of the machine.. instead of a button you hold to drop the candy they decided the weird turning thing was a great idea?
Soft serve typically has less milk fat. I worked for Dairy Queen in the 70’s, which called their soft serve ice milk. It seems like Cruisinart uses the same chemicals in the freezing bowl as any other ice cream maker. It just that you’re serving it sooner. If they did a little research, I’m sure they could have found a chemical combination that doesn’t cool to too low temperatures so the ice cream remains softer for longer.
You should review some hand crank ice cream makers. I have one that uses rock salt & ice. It makes great ice cream and best yet, you burn up a few calories when you make it. One thing you should always do is to keep the ice cream mixture in the refrigerator overnight. This is especially true for frozen custard.
So a couple things. I know that in order for viewers to see the process you have to dispense from behind the machine but holding the cone or bowl closer to the dispenser while swirling a bit makes a more uniform ice cream. Second is the dispenser handle is pressure sensitive switching to the down position starts the dispensing but holding down the handle with firm pressure should make it dispense faster. Of course not too hard coz that's going to break it, but enough pressure to make the dispensing faster and holding it closer.
My mom used to work for a place with a commercial soft serve machine. She said it was the bane of her existence. It had to be cleaned thoroughly every night because soft serve doesn't get cold enough to prevent bacteria and mold growth. Later in life, my uncle, who owns a small cafe, was looking to get a soft serve machine. Due to the strict cleaning process, the state I'm in had a license you need to acquire. The fee is astronomical and the requirements are exacting. My uncle said there was less paperwork in getting on the list to receive a liquor license when one is available.
Perhaps trying this with the proper front access might aid in reviewing this product. I've noticed when using soft serve machines in restaurants, you move the bowl around a bit to get the ice cream to make the "cone" shape. This would also help in having the bowl in the best place to get the toppings on the ice cream.
I tried one of these from Cuisinart about 10 years ago. Didn't even last a year. All the gears are plastic and broke. Even the topping dispenser broke due to cheap plastic. Hope they fixed that major flaw with this updated version but I am happy with the Ninja Creami and would never go back.
Super Demo video. Well documented and your comments were great. With all this information, think I will pass on it. But excellent video. Have a great Navy Day!
few years back I bought a hard ice cream maker that doesn't require freezing any containers. Was like $120. Def worth the price. Would love to find an affordable soft serve machine that doesn't require freezing
Thank you so much for doing these! i feel like i can give a review on the product though all i did was watch your operation of it and all! The Cuisinart Soft Serve Ice Cream Maker is trying to do too much! it does not need the the "toppings dispensors" as those can literally just be added yourself and it feels like they were trying to fill out space with such an addition. Would had much preferred the ice cream making drum be larger for larger quantity's to be made. Open hole in the top? i'd return the product immediately if i bought this and there was nothing to cover that hole. i can see that you are getting "watery ice cream" so there's another reason to return it.
I rather buy a few pints of Haagen Dazs and be done with it. Cleaning all those parts takes the fun out of a dish of ice cream, plus it doesn't come out looking all that great. Here's a fast recipe from Martha Stewart "No Churn Vanilla Ice Cream 1 can (14oz) sweetened condensed milk 2 tsp. pure vanilla extract 2 tbls. bourbon, 2 cups cold heavy cream. Mix condensed milk together with the vanilla extract and bourbon. In a separate bowl, beat heavy cream until stiff peaks form. Fold the heavy cream into the condensed milk, place mix in loaf pan and chill for 6 hrs or more. It's a good recipe, not much clean up and just a few ingredients, without having to store another appliance.
For the people that say it takes too long. Massive you should try an old fashioned ice cream maker where you churn it by hand and add rock salt. My mom had to do that. We have the kitchenaid I've cream maker. Used it once. It takes up too much freezer space in our refrigerator. It worked.
Get a frozen metal bowl, a larger pot with some salty ice water, nest the smaller frozen bowl in there, put your ingredients in and use a little elbow grease. Way easier than trying to mess around with that machine. Not to mention the cleanup. If you want to be extra fancy, put the ice cream in a pipe bag and squeeze it out into cones or whatever you want to serve it in.
36 hours in the freezer💀. Think I'll just buy ice cream from the store.
You just keep that thing stored in your freezer so it's ready to go whenever.
@vinstinct yeah but you would have to eat over 100 servings of the ciusinart servings before you're saving money, and it takes a lot more work
store stuff can have all sorts of chemicals. making it at home allows you to control the ingredients.
But remember it makes ice cream only in 20-40 minutes ;-D
@@vinstinct that's a gigantic thing to have in your freezer at all times
I like how no one has addressed it takes like 48 hours of prep to make a single batch of icecream. I'm pretty most people can get this within 15 minutes of their home or less with no clean up or prep.
The machine is out of order. 😢
I know.. Crazy. Get the Sage Smart Scoop.. Much better, okay it doesn't dispense but no pre-preperation
I have several friends with food intolerances so it's tough to find good treats at the grocery store or ice cream shop. That is likely their target audience. Or young parents who want fresh healthy treats for the kids. It's also fun for kids to make their own. Although I agree that the Ninja Creami is a better choice for that.
I agree, this one is a total flop. It's much easier just buying a box of icecream, let it sit on the counter for 30 minutes, and you've got soft ice the easy fast way.
@@joonglegamer9898 It's not a total flop, it was a fine product when it was new. But, technology advances. And no, leaving ice cream sit for 30 minutes is not at all acceptable. You can really only get away with that if you're going to eat all of it in one sitting, if you try to refreeze it, it's going to suck.
I always enjoy these videos, not because I like the products, but because James does a great job reviewing. Some reviewers have unrealistic expectations.
I typically will look to see if James reviewed it before I buy something now lol
Tip, make the ice cream in your blender and then just chill it in the blender container. This will blend it better as well, especially with the chocolate ice cream, because the cocoa can be hard to dissolve. Honestly this machine doesn't seem the best to me. The problem is it's trying to imitate an ice cream parlor soft serve "experience" but it's failing. The ice cream doesn't come out in a smooth stream, so it's extremely slow and doesn't really fill a cone or bowl in a good way. The freezer bowl is too cold, so it eventually freezes the ice cream hard. The design of the topping dispensers clearly needs some work. Plus this thing is way more expensive than just a standard Cuisinart freezer bowl ice cream maker and it doesn't seem worth it. You're better off just buying the regular ice cream maker and stopping it when the ice cream is as soft as you like and eating it.
You don't get proper soft serve like that. I've tried the whole blender thing and it's a lot more of a pain than you're letting it out to be.
I have the standard Cuisinart that I use a lot. I've had it for about 10 years and I like it much better, it does just what I need it to do.
@@SmallSpoonBrigade I meant to mix it before you put it in the ice cream maker, not to make and freeze ice cream in your blender? Didn't think I'd have to explain that part.
Everything about just getting a regular ice cream maker is exactly what I said as well, lol. You don't need this thing.
@@robincochran7369 My Cuisinart ice cream maker is also at least ten years old and is still going strong. The bowl lives in my freezer, tied up in a plastic shopping bag and ready to go wherever I next want to use it.
i have the basic cuisinart icecream maker, with the same frozen bowl technology. it makes really tasty ice cream, however i like. it can be soft if served immediately, or harder if left in the freezer overnight. i really like it, its easy to use, and i just leave the bowl in the freezer all the time so its ready when i want it. the one he reviewed seems to have a lot of bells and whistles that are just unneeded, and its much larger spacewise, with the same size freezer bowl. i bet its much harder to clean with that dispenser too. just stick to the simple model, get your ice cream out with a spoon, and you will be happy
I have one, too. Easy to clean as well.
I have the same one too. It works so well I haven't even thought of buying this.
I also have the same basic cuisenart ice cream maker that you have and concur with your experiences. It can make Gelato, sorbet, sherbet, soft and hard ice cream and it way cheaper and easier to use. Makes great ice cream. The soft Ice cream maker seems like a bad idea.
100%. Had the cuisinart for about 15+ years and it is less complicated and less parts than this. And the tub can be kept in freezer and ready to go anytime. For me making ice cream is still a 2-day thing. Make the ice cream mixture on day 1 and then freeze on day 2 to ensure the liquid is super cold because I use eggs and heat up the cream.
The way the chocolate ice cream dispensed, along with the streaks it left on the unit, gave off disconcerting "dirty toilet stall" vibes...
9:38
It comes out just like poop too...just a strangely gross experience just watching it lol
8:38 - 8:54
fuuny
@@kennethlasseter9264 Plop
I know this was an appliance review, but the design flaws of this thing made for very amusing viewing; I was choking with laughter a couple of times, ha! Thanks for being a good sport and for posting your experience with this ice cream maker!
Do Not attempt to dispense chocolate ice cream from this machine!
The English channel "Sorted Food" hated this machine, also. Glad to see you both came to the same conclusion.
I don’t think they refrigerated the mix since it took longer for them to get ice cream.
Both of their batches seized. I wonder if they have a commercial freezer and the cylinder was too cold.
@@jpbaley2016it got too cold and they had to wait for it to defrost
At least he got some ice cream, the Sorted boys had no success! I really like the cross-checking of gadgets for their success or failure.
@@anirudhnavin4568 their first check the ice cream was still liquidy so they waited. Also, UK voltage is different, would that affect the stirring and their freezer may have been set lower. Soft serve isn’t supposed to be brought down to temps below 20deg F (-6 deg C).
Nostalgia sells a compressor based soft serve machine now which is around $600. This is the same machine that was sold as the Ice Cream depot sx1000 , until that company went out of business.
I saw this on Sorted Food and they had constant issues with it freezing up. This really needs a way to defrost it a bit. I'm curious how it would do if you didn't chill the mix before pouring it in.
I was wondering who else saw Sorted Food's review of this hot piece of garbage.
Same here 😂
Same. Saw it on Sorted Food. Agreed, it's garbage! 🤣😂🤣
Is the same one?
Lol
LOOKS LIKE A FRIGGIN BEAST...WHERE IN THE HELL WOULD ANBODY PUT THAT SHIT IN THE KITCHEN
That's the main issue I had with mine. It's too large to keep in the kitchen and you have to freeze the bowl in order for it to get anything. It did work reasonably well, I just rarely used it because of how much of a hassle it was to setup and clean up.
Beast? That's a plastic POS... If that thing lasted a single summer, I would be shocked.
Plop
I keep mine on top of the refrigerator...
@@jamesbyrd3740 Oh, it will last an entire summer . . . If you only make 4 batches or less.
I love your reviews. Been watching for years. I have even started using the phrase. “I digress” way to much hah.
Oh, come on now :)
We shall see. 😉
Just throwing this out there, if you are a Costco member, the Ninja Creami is the same price as this.
Sam's Club is also doing good deals on the Ninja products they carry
Ninja creami is the only ice cream maker worth using at home, the others are too cumbersome and end up collecting dust
Ninja Creamin is honestly mediocre
100%! And it’s only half as awful. If it doesn’t have refrigeration, it’s just a blender.
Ok
I laughed my a$$ off watching this!😂 I’m guessing this is headed directly to the bone yard at the end of this video. I can’t think of one redeeming value for this thing other than it being a good landfill object. Thanks for saving so many people from the abject horror of this monstrosity!
Boneyard vote for me too.
Too noisy and the ice cream is too close to freezing.
🤣 it’s an expensive joke on us! BONEYARD!
steel bowl, plastick pack, ice, saltwater and someting to stir the icecream mix till it gets harder (i used old aa battery milk frother and rubber band to keep it in bowl) then use a fork.... works :)... and no expensive crap taking extra space in kichen
What's funny is listening to you saying how slow it is but I have it at 2x speed and it's still like watching paint dry.
Plop
I watch in 2x as well. Makes YT much better.
😂
I do that with politics pods. When they sound normal at 2x speed, how slow are they talking?! 😂
It would have been good to see a comparison between Cuisinart and Ninja Creami by texture, using the same recipes
the choc poo ice cream falling on your hand had my laughing so hard
lol me too. We're such children XD
Cuisinart is supposed to be a good kitchen brand, this looks like a Temu gadget.
It is. It works great if you follow the instructions and don't get dramatic with it.
Right, it seems like Ninja took over.
@@jimmyyarbrough9883 GO! CUISINART DEFENCE FORCE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Where does this reputation keep coming from?! Who decided cuisinart was a good brand and when? They weren't good before. They aren't good now. I can only begin to guess that this is literally based on it being the best (read: most expensive) brand sold at walmart and target over the last 10 years.
Their products are universally higher in price than the competition, while generally offering worse performance and many of their appliances are downright dangerous with a tendency to overheat, faulty cords that melt because they can't handle the current, and dangerous designs that extremely hot surfaces less than an inch from intended grab points.
@@TheDoc73I’m glad you mentioned this. I had a Cuisinart toaster oven that fried itself because the cord got too hot. I thought it was defective, but it sounds like that’s a common issue.
These ice cream makers take forever. I don't remember my grandma's wooden bucket ice cream maker taking this long.
they are about the same. around 30 minutes
@@mccallosone4903 I mean the whole process. This ice cream maker and the ninja creamy both require you to freeze the mixture.
I like my ninja. The trick is to make it when you’re not craving it and make a few ahead of time
@@PandawdyBob this does not. You pre freeze the bowl. Once frozen, mix your recipe and it only takes 20ish minutes.
@lechatbotte
Yes Karen, of course Karen, whatever you say Karen.
James LOVES that temperature probe. Haha
9:38 If you dispense this slowly it may be time to call your doctor. 😂
Oh I saw this reviewed on sorted food - It was terrible.. looking forward to how you get on here :D
I saw that too. Do not know what they did wrong. I have not had a single problem with mine.
Good review as always. Personally, you might as well get an ice cream maker with a built in compressor and if you like soft serve, eat it fresh out of the container (instead of curing in the freezer). No need to pre-freeze.
agree
Of course. But those cost a lot more. My local shop has a machine that can go from liquid ice cream premix to actually serving in Iike 10 minutes. Awesome. But the machine was 12 grand.
@@LatitudeSky I got a machine for less than 300 that has a compressor and is fantastic
@@craigbrockman7893 ... What's the name of it? Didn't know that they were so affordable.
@@PoeLemic I bought and love the Whynter Ice Cream Maker Machine Automatic 2.1 Qt (Model ICM-200LS). On Amazon right now it's 256USD. But I got it on sale (which happens from time to time) for only $150
I couldn’t stop laughing. Thanks for what you do.
Spotted the electric light orchestra lp on the left of the shot. Good stuff!
Where?
I have the Cuisinart ice cream maker which looks like the top half of this device without the spigot and dispensers. It also has a larger "bowl". You freeze the "bowl" overnight then pour in the ingredients and it mixes it into an ice cream. It works really good and by looking into the clear lid, you can decide when your ice cream is the right consistency, AND you can pour your toppings into it and have it mix it as well.
7:52 It's good that you said it what we all were thinking already with the white stuff :-D
I bought an ice cream maker years ago where you had to freeze the drum for 24 hours. I used it twice and then put it away. I bought a Ninja Creami 5 months ago and have used it almost every day since. I don't see how any other type of machine can be easier than the Creami. If you get a bunch of empty containers you can make multiple flavors and have them ready to go the next day. As soon as I have a few empty containers I fill them back up so it's always ready to go.
idk if you would interested in doing a review for Breville Smart Scoop Ice Cream Compressor. You dont need to chill the bowl cause it has a compressor built into the machine. It's a machine that makes all different textures
Breville makes excellent products % I have one of their Smart Ovens and it’s perfect since our stove die 2 year ago!!!
Take a shot 🥃 every time James says "look how slow it is". 🥴🥴
who in their right mind would want to listen to that thing for 30 minutes just for some ice cream
Its not loud.
@@jordanmc9015 NOT LOUD? Alright pal. Clean your ears.
@@NatPat-yj2or its like mircowave loud
Close your eyes and listen to the (( oh the nuts are working. The nuts are working. Ahh sprinkles )) part 😂
@8:35 the chaos had me dying 😂❤
Hmmm, I got one of these years ago and don't remember having any of these issues. Yours is obviously an updated model. I haven't used it in a couple of years (it is huge) so now I want to pull it out and try it again!
Same here, I never had any issues with the use of it. The issues I had were mostly having to plan ahead to have the appropriate parts frozen. And the fact that it's a single use appliance that takes up a lot of space. Really, people are making this out to be a horrible product when really it isn't. It's just a product that probably should have been considered obsolete a few years ago and replaced with a version with a built in compressor.
@@SmallSpoonBrigade I ended up getting a second freezer bowl bc it stressed me out that it needed to be in the freezer so long.
Recently found this channel and this video has me cracking up. Needed the laugh. The chocolate ice cream part 😂 the nuts went everywhere.
Best reviews available! Amazing as always.
Not going to replace my Ninja Creami with that.
I don't have a Creami, but this is an OK device, I had one, I just didn't really use it very much due to it being a pretty specific tool and needing to think ahead to freeze things ahead of time.
I'd probably have gone with the Creami if that had existed when I bought it, just because it does have built in refrigeration.
@@SmallSpoonBrigade The Ninja Creami you have to put your mixture in the freezer until frozen. Then run it through the machine to give you nice creamy ice cream.
Soft serve is my favorite! Add some chocolate chips and it is heaven
I think an old fashioned 1800s ice cream churn may be faster.
I have the KitchenAid Ice cream maker - same type of bowl, dasher and a small piece that snaps on and holds the dasher. I use mine frequently. I store the bowl in the freezer (covered with a silicone lid that attaches snugly) upside down. I always make an egg yolk based custard on the stove. It's super easy to clean up (Just 3 parts that are easily hand washed). The cooked ice cream base makes the difference in the taste.
I'm glad you reviewed this! ;) I think my Ninja Slushie makes amazing soft serve and it's very easy to clean. The Topping Dispenser is goofy lol I think just leave that topping Dispenser out. Then you got to clean all that put your unused toppings back. Eh
I have had a shit day at work. My day just got a whole lot better… yay 😊 a Freakin’ review vid and some soul food
This thing is huuuge and still won't chill the bowl and you also have to put the mix into the fridge first!? Instead it's packed with useless features like the topping dispensers, cone holder and the "keep warm station".
Thank you so much for this full review. I am thinking about getting one of these but I hadn't decided. I like to make ice cream because the stuff they sell at the store has too much sugar. This way I can substitute the sugar for stevia.
I saw this reviewed on Sorted Food channel, and they could not get it to work at all as it kept freezing up solid. They also mentioned the issued with it being difficult to clean. So seems like this is a no go for ice cream.
I've got the perfect answer to this get your favorite ice cream at your local store and put in the freezer, then when you want an ice cream go to your fridge no pre freezing and no waiting for things to get cold in your freezer or fridge. May be a few cents dearer but no problem.
I wish I could but the closest grocery store for me is over an hour away and I live in the desert where 3/4 of the year it is over 100f. It was still 100-110 all last week, the first week of October. Ice cream doesn't make it home frozen even in a cooler with ice. It is always soup by the time I get home and then refreezing it makes it taste like freezer burn. That was my main reason for buying a Creami but after tasting the recipes and how amazingly good they are the store bought ice cream just doesn't compare.
I agree completely! When I want ice cream I don’t want to wait 24 hours!
@@ace25805I would move.
Got the same kind of ice cream machine idea, for like 20 bucks 5 years ago. This isn't really any different, just bigger and way too overpriced. It's the same manual work too.
Years ago I bought a cheap Savoureux Pro Line Ice Cream Maker from Walmart. It doesn't have cone holders, topping chutes, or a warming station. And it takes longer than 30 minutes to complete. It does, however, make ice cream at the right consistency every time, and it was far less expensive.
We have an ice cream maker attachment for our Kitchenaid mixer. It’s pretty similar to the Cuisinart but with fewer parts and easier to clean
LOL! The Keep Warm Station!
I have an ice cream maker that takes a similar approach. The frozen metal bowl with the spatula turning bit.
It doesn't have all the extra fancy stuff, dispenser or the toppings. I don't know that you really need them. It works much like that one. But I just came to the conclusion that I prefer buying as to making it.
Idk, I might revisit it. As I've completely shifted my diet away from pre made or restaurant made food. I eat almost all organic/natural food these days and my body thanks me for it. So I could try it again as ice cream isn't really part of my diet these days.
Home-made ice cream with real fruit is a delight!
So you almost have to make ice cream manually, to make ice cream......
It looks like It
I have a cuisinart ice cream maker with a compressor. It’s amazing. It takes less time to make the ice cream, and no freezing the bowl first. It doesn’t have anything like toppings, but it works.
they tried one out on sorted food and could not get it to make icecream without it blocking the outlet, you managed to do it, they wanted feedback from other owners on what they were doing wrong
James LOVES that temperature probe. Haha.
That little cone in the holder was the cherry on top for me. 😄😄
Just saw this on Sorted Food as well. Curious to see if you have similar results.
Same
If you have to put any part in the freezer it's not for me. The machine should be able to make ice cream directly.
Those machines will cost a lot more. But also be quicker. My local place can go from liquid mix in a carton all the way to serving in 10 minutes. But their machine cost more than my car.
You can get counter top ice cream makers with a compressor in the 200 dollar range that this thong almost hits.
I'd have to remove a bunch of food to make room for it. And then I have keep it in there permanently unless I want to wait a day to make ice cream.
So this thing would just end up collecting dust on a shelf in the basement.
It looks like there's an attachment for the Kitchenaid stand mixer to make ice cream. Also, any mix you add that isn't a true ice cream custard before it's frozen won't taste like real ice cream. That means cooking it with eggs and the whole shibaz before it goes into the machine. Peace and Love
🌈🌞✌️💕
I have their ice cream maker that, for the cold bowl and churner, looks remarkably similar. We had a difficult time making the ice cream with a consistency harder tan soft serve so this is almost a good remanufacture of the device. Taste-wise the frozen treats were yummy but needed at least double the amount of time for churning with a 'bowl' frozen for days and the mixture also partially frozen. We did find the bowl for the device was not convenient for freezing. It takes up too much room and needs to be in the freezer too long to work at all.
A common theme with ice cream makers that require freezing the bowl ( vs having an internal chiller) is that the bowl and ingredient prep are very important. You need to get the bowl to be solidly frozen in order to have it be cold enough. Your ice cream mix should be nearly frozen as well, so it needs less cooling during the process. I've made good ice cream dozens of times in a tropical environment with this kind of setup. It takes more waiting time than a chiller type machine but it costs a lot less.
Ok I figured it out. It sounds like a lawn mower to trick you into thinking it’s summer and ice cream time.
Cuisinart is becoming the Bell and Howell of food brands.
I make my own “soft serve” whenever I want to by taking normal ice cream and stirring it with my spoon until it’s the consistency I want. Much less time consuming and cheaper than investing in this machine, which let’s face it, is a cool novelty the first couple of times, than will most likely end up under your counter never to be used again
My Mom only ever bought vanilla ice scream. Thanks for bringing back the memory of my Granny letting the ice cream soften, then stirring in Hershey's Chocolate Syrup and mixing it up to make Chocolate soft serve ice cream!
Exactly! My mom taught me that trick when I was little. Still do it today whenever I’m in the mood. Not to mention, you can still also opt for hard ice cream by doing nothing at all. This monster of a gadget only makes soft serve, and you either always have to have some pre-mixed in the freezer or wait over a day to have it. Annoying and completely unnecessary.
Plus, those freezer bowls die after a couple of years, and they are expensive to replace.
Thanks for walking through how we would use this. I really want to find a home ice cream maker, so you helped guide me to making a decision on what I will buy.
I find it works best with just straight half and half cream. We keep our bowl in the freezer all the time so it's ready to go at a moment's notice. You don't need 24 hours to freeze the bowl if you have a decent freezer. We have made ice cream after 8 hours in our deep freeze.
Ninja Creami is still number 1 in my book. You still have to plan ahead but I grabbed a few extra pints so we have a couple of base favourites always frozen so if you get an ice cream craving you can just grab a chocolate or vanilla, spin, mix in, and consuuuuuuume!
Protein shake masked as chocolate mint ice cream has completely re-invigorated my weekend exercise and food planning routine.
The creami will also spin different flavours all day long if you freeze in advance where this has a hard cap on how much you can make due to the bowl and extra bowls take up way too much space in a freezer. Looks like about 6 pints to 1 bowl in physical size. Plus an extra bowl is 40 bucks where extra creami pints are dirt cheap.
Wowww, fancy. My wife and I feel old watching this. In my day we cranked an ice cream bucket to make ice cream or go to a Dairy Queen. Now you can buy a fancy thingy to make it home.🍦😯
Some of my best memories was us kids arguing over who was gonna get to sit on top of the ice cream bucket to hold it down while my parents cranked it.
THE best ice cream ever 👍
looks like the baby food scene from robocop.
you can tell the candy dispenser was an after thought. they probably added it to make the device more symmetrical. the chute for the candy could have been set up to drop in the center but it instead launches out the side of the machine.. instead of a button you hold to drop the candy they decided the weird turning thing was a great idea?
Soft serve typically has less milk fat. I worked for Dairy Queen in the 70’s, which called their soft serve ice milk. It seems like Cruisinart uses the same chemicals in the freezing bowl as any other ice cream maker. It just that you’re serving it sooner. If they did a little research, I’m sure they could have found a chemical combination that doesn’t cool to too low temperatures so the ice cream remains softer for longer.
You should review some hand crank ice cream makers. I have one that uses rock salt & ice. It makes great ice cream and best yet, you burn up a few calories when you make it.
One thing you should always do is to keep the ice cream mixture in the refrigerator overnight. This is especially true for frozen custard.
So a couple things. I know that in order for viewers to see the process you have to dispense from behind the machine but holding the cone or bowl closer to the dispenser while swirling a bit makes a more uniform ice cream. Second is the dispenser handle is pressure sensitive switching to the down position starts the dispensing but holding down the handle with firm pressure should make it dispense faster. Of course not too hard coz that's going to break it, but enough pressure to make the dispensing faster and holding it closer.
Alright just in time for winter
I eat ice cream in winter 😅
@@Nenezilla in the cold outside it doesn't count when you indoors warm in the winter
It ain't winter for the whole world at once, just sayin
@@zarzee8925 yeah but most of us will be mostly from the US and yes it going to be winter
@@ricoviii1 How have you determined "most of us" is from the USA? Such a close minded American thing to say 😂
My mom used to work for a place with a commercial soft serve machine. She said it was the bane of her existence. It had to be cleaned thoroughly every night because soft serve doesn't get cold enough to prevent bacteria and mold growth.
Later in life, my uncle, who owns a small cafe, was looking to get a soft serve machine. Due to the strict cleaning process, the state I'm in had a license you need to acquire. The fee is astronomical and the requirements are exacting. My uncle said there was less paperwork in getting on the list to receive a liquor license when one is available.
Perhaps trying this with the proper front access might aid in reviewing this product. I've noticed when using soft serve machines in restaurants, you move the bowl around a bit to get the ice cream to make the "cone" shape. This would also help in having the bowl in the best place to get the toppings on the ice cream.
I note that you also didnt mention how much waste there is considering the ingredients going in to what you got out.
Watched this on sorted food and they tried to get this to work but didn’t have any luck.
His commentary during the toppings took me out 😂
"I got one nut! The nuts aren't working..." I died...thanks for the laugh haha
Oh my you crack me up. I worked at a fast food restaurant in high school and they teach you how to make soft serve look better.
I'll refrain from describing what that chocolate ice cream looked like coming out of the dispenser.
💩
Oh yeah. We all saw it.
Do a search for the hilariously cringe "Brown 25" scene from the 1970's movie called "The Groove Tube". 😂
The way the chocolate one kept cutting itself into slow plopping logs 😂💀💀
I would love to see a review on different electric ice cream machines!👍🤩🙏🏼
Buy a ninja creami.
I tried one of these from Cuisinart about 10 years ago. Didn't even last a year. All the gears are plastic and broke. Even the topping dispenser broke due to cheap plastic. Hope they fixed that major flaw with this updated version but I am happy with the Ninja Creami and would never go back.
I laughed incessantly at the chocolate ice cream part. Looks like dog doo. 😂
Good to know that I wasn't the only one who thought that.
@@KaneshaAndrews so not appealing but very funny 🤣
Super Demo video. Well documented and your comments were great. With all this information, think I will pass on it. But excellent video. Have a great Navy Day!
Dude your face gave up the real review - love the honest reactions, sure helps make up a mind on a gizmo - Ta!
I had one years ago and it worked so much better! You could make beautiful cones and bowls of ice cream. It wasn't slow like that.
I use the silicon covers to cover my ice cream base too. However, I don’t use that ice cream maker. It would take up about half my kitchen.
Always wanted 2 ask you where you normally buy your t-shirts from? I can tell they are good quality👌🏾
few years back I bought a hard ice cream maker that doesn't require freezing any containers. Was like $120. Def worth the price.
Would love to find an affordable soft serve machine that doesn't require freezing
Great review, as always, and I love when you digress 😊
I will always digress!
@Freakinreviews Happy Thanksgiving!
Thank you so much for doing these! i feel like i can give a review on the product though all i did was watch your operation of it and all!
The Cuisinart Soft Serve Ice Cream Maker is trying to do too much! it does not need the the "toppings dispensors" as those can literally just be added yourself and it feels like they were trying to fill out space with such an addition. Would had much preferred the ice cream making drum be larger for larger quantity's to be made. Open hole in the top? i'd return the product immediately if i bought this and there was nothing to cover that hole. i can see that you are getting "watery ice cream" so there's another reason to return it.
What’s the ELO stand on your table? (Love their Out Of The Blue tour)
I WAS GOING TO ASK YOU TO REVIEW ONE OF THESE!! THIS IS SUCH A GOOD DAY!
Okay, never mind. Thanks!
I rather buy a few pints of Haagen Dazs and be done with it. Cleaning all those parts takes the fun out of a dish of ice cream, plus it doesn't come out looking all that great. Here's a fast recipe from Martha Stewart "No Churn Vanilla Ice Cream 1 can (14oz) sweetened condensed milk 2 tsp. pure vanilla extract
2 tbls. bourbon, 2 cups cold heavy cream. Mix condensed milk together with the vanilla extract and bourbon. In a separate bowl, beat heavy cream until stiff peaks form. Fold the heavy cream into the condensed milk, place mix in loaf pan and chill for 6 hrs or more. It's a good recipe, not much clean up and just a few ingredients, without having to store another appliance.
It's chaos in here! You make me laugh. That's why I like your videos. I am informed and amused. ✌️✌️✌️
For the people that say it takes too long. Massive you should try an old fashioned ice cream maker where you churn it by hand and add rock salt. My mom had to do that.
We have the kitchenaid I've cream maker. Used it once. It takes up too much freezer space in our refrigerator. It worked.
Get a frozen metal bowl, a larger pot with some salty ice water, nest the smaller frozen bowl in there, put your ingredients in and use a little elbow grease. Way easier than trying to mess around with that machine. Not to mention the cleanup. If you want to be extra fancy, put the ice cream in a pipe bag and squeeze it out into cones or whatever you want to serve it in.