Le Silence de la Mer (2004)(The Silence of the Sea)part.7/10 english subs
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ม.ค. 2012
- Belgian-French TV movie based on the novel by Vercors, shot from 1rst to 28th April of 2004 in Tusson, directed by Pierre Boutron. This film was awarded on the Festival of fiction of Saint-Tropez in 2004.
-----------------------------------------
Téléfilm franco-belge adapté du roman de Vercors, tourné du 1er au 28 avril 2004 à Tusson, réalisé par Pierre Boutron. Ce téléfilm a été récompensé au festival de la fiction de Saint-Tropez en 2004.
Ce film a obtenu 3 récompenses lors du festival de fiction de St-Tropez 2004 :
-Prix du meilleur téléfilm
-Prix de la meilleure interprétation féminine : Julie Delarme
-Prix de la meilleure musique : Angélique et Jean-Claude Nachon
Acteurs:
Julie Delarme (Jeanne Larosière)
Michel Galabru (André Larosière)
Thomas Jouannet (Werner Von Ebrennac)
Marie Bunel (Marie)
Timothée Ferrand (Pierre). - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
Так сыграть Талантище.Немецкий офицер это лучшее что я видела.
Самый волнующий и трогательный фильм,который я видела.Браво всем:актерам,которые прожили свои роли,режиссеру,который продумал каждую деталь.
Thomas Jouannet did an excellent job in the movie as well as Julie Delarme. Sadly, he didn't even nominate for the award. Julie Delarme won the best actress for the Saint-Tropez Fiction TV Festival. I think they both deserved for the awards.
@Elaine Nguyen his expressions and his eyes were spot on. Much better than hers
@@SG-wq4rm He was the film as far as I am concerned, for what it’s worth!
Just speculating here, but there may have been some lingering bias in France in 2004 and other former German occupied countries against sympathetically portraying a German officer in a film about WWII. There may also have been an issue with the criteria for nomination. Julie Delarme was the central character and appeared in every scene, but Thomas Jouannet only appeared in about two-thirds of the film. Other actors nominated that year were the central character in their films, whereas the role of Werner was not the film's central character. His role was too big for a supporting actor nomination, but too small for a best actor nomination, given the stiff competition.
@@kell4674
也不定要靠得獎來肯定,這麼多演納粹軍官,維爾納最溫文儒雅
演表哥那位,也是演技精湛,把小奸小惡演的恰到好處
Thank you Celia for taking the time to add the English sub titles. You made it possible to watch a worthy film that was intense and the unspoken love was impossible. Well acted, unbearable sadness and no hope. Your generosity in putting this film on TH-cam is appreciated Celia.
Thanke you, it's film about beautiful Love!!!👍🥰❤❤❤
The acting is so natural, they don't communicate verbally but actions speaks louder than voice. 😘 🇬🇧
I kniw, SO ROMANTIC and notice they never DID anythng, like I movies in the classic period. Most film is so bad these days, shows shallow people living shallow lives. (Thus was a French propaganda book/ film, of course, so Grandpa HAD to show up to spill evergthjng.. They HAD to send Werner off to the Russian front, where "soldiers do not survive")
I love these types of movies. They don't have to say anything, but we can understand by the way they look at each other with their eyes. No words needed. They don't make movies like these anymore. It is all actions and not enough silence.
best shot when he stood at the pier, so beautiful.
so she cannot avoid his eye contact this time. He wants to find out she has a crush on him or not, but she tried very very hard to hide it. :)
The camera shows his large powerful figure from the back including his black leather boots. This shot demonstrates the power he holds over her if he chooses to use it. As her little brown shoes approach him, he immediately steps aside. He wants her to come to him of her own free will, but he realizes she can’t cross that line. So sad !
Great scene and acting.
@@hearthart673 I think he knew and wanted to see it in her eyes. She did. You can see his eyes looked hopeful and happy that he knew she liked him.
@@user-vn7sj5ig8w it's so hard to find a soul mate in this lonely world; unfortunate, this is a forbidden love !! :(
@@hearthart673 I agree with you! I have always felt we are given that 1 window for a soulmate and it is up to us to catch it. I lost my chance. I didn't know until I lost it.
The male lead is a *really* good actor he plays subtly extremely well - you truly believe he is in love, shows, quietly all that is going on inside him. The scene when he looks up after finding the envelope on the floor is very well played - now he knows she has been there. You see subtle surprise mixed with hope as he begins to scan the room... what did she look at while she was here? Which if my things did she want to see....?
SO romantic!
"I need to tell you something...!"... then Grandpa shows up... He needed to tell her the girl in the picture was NOT his girfriend! And notice, she did not turn away when he said that, she was willing to hear him out!
WHAT A SAD STORY!
She won a French prize as Best Actress for her performance, which she should have, but I thought he was as good or better than she. He should have won best male lead .
Absolutely, amazingly pure love, burning inside him, yet such a gentleman 👌very delicate love🦋💟
I think he turns his head towards the bed which was still warm after Jeanne had fallen asleep in it...and certainly the suggestion is that Werner felt the warmth...Anyway, the scene with her lying in his bed immediately after their meeting shows how deeply and desperately she needs to be in his arms where she feels loved and protected...She imagines he's there and holds her in the most tender and pure way♥️ It's my favourite movie!!!!!
@@midnightchannel7759 I agree totally. Thanks for your comment I can only imagine the possible moment of excitement knowing she was in his room. I wished they focused on him for a little bit longer to capture more of his excitement.
Что-то мешало ему заговорить с ней,видимо, её упорное молчание,хотя то,что он обнаружил её следы в своей комнате,сказало ему,что она далеко неравнодушна к нему.И в конце ее слёзы, горькое отчаяние на её лице...Грустная и прекрасная история великолепно сыгранная.
I think she was mixing up her desire for her parents and her desire for him, and the room is a symbolic encounter of the two loves.
Mais c etait a cette epoque impossible de rester magnifique vu la haine tout autour etla lacheté et tout partout.... on reve de vant la violence d une attraction ... malgre tout .. ce qui est humain. Il y a tant de contradictions en nous. Et que dire de l acte de soit disant resistance et le lien flou suggéré avec la rivalité sexuelle de l occuppant et l amoureux econduit et beaucoup moins respectueux de la jeune fille?
I just noticed that you can hear how mad Werner was at what happened to her, from how hard he slammed his door after going upstairs.
Werner is always slamming the door when he gets angry! Who will repair the door if it breaks? Ha,ha.
Seeing the woman he loves attacked was an understandable shock for Werner ! Besides, Werner is everything that Pascal isn't : educated, gentle, patient, handsome... a real gentleman.
Jeanne Should run into his arms and cry her eyes out without saying a word .
Too bad the director did not write this into the script.
@@bobandlucas
不行啦,
法國人怎麼可以投入納粹懷抱,會出人命的
美國電影倒有可能吧
What a beautiful scene! Werner touched Jeanne's hand at the pier!
YES THAT SCENE IS VERY SWEET
No, he doesn’t touch her hand. I wish he did.
@@emmabarr6871 Yes,He did. It's very quick. Other people have said so. The first time I didn't notice. Werner's hand stops moving.
@@silentsea2956 do you mean his hand stopped moving after touching hers? How sweet! 💕💕💕I thought he stopped because picking was nearly finished.
@@emmabarr6871 Yes. It's very quick. Hard to see. His hand stopped moving and he kept gazing at her. I don't know, maybe he thought she would touch his hand too?
I like his eyes!
Yes, nice movie, in fact I looked at it twice ! However, what makes it special bothers me. I was 11 in 1940 and lived through the all four years of occupation, I knew older people, strong anti Germans, who found themselves with one or even two officers living under the same roof. As we can expect each case would be a little different. What bothers me in the fiilm is maybe what gives it its charm but it would have been hard for any host not to, at least, respond politely to his goodnights. The older man does not like his own behavior but finds the willpower to stick to it «almost to the end » which is remarkable and a high point of the fim, I will agree. Many found love in that period and too many were wrongly labeled as collaborators without proper evidence and judgment. Nice film’ Thank you.
Excuse me, do you know if this film was translated into Englih? I would like to see an English version, but can't find it.
Grandpa needs to go on a trip or something. He's in the way!!!!
Grandpa knew what was happening between Werner and Jeanne. He wasn’t so much angry as he was worried about Jeanne and the consequences to her.
@@sharyncarr4279 - that is true and why she asked him what are you staring at me? He made an excuse.
Elders need more execises. Grandpa, go to town centre to have a walk. It is not good for you to stay at home all the time. 😊
Not only the grandpa can see something between them, but even Pascal notices it too.
Yeah. That surprises me as he just spends few seconds to figure out. I think he, as a man, definitly can tell anger in Werner's eyes.
And who wouldn't notice it? Have you seen the way Werner looks at Jeanne? So full of love and passion,too! And Jeanne can't disguise her love! She gets nervous when Werner is next to her!.
@@emmabarr6871 Werner batted his left eyelid upon opening the door, and seeing what Pascal was up to. What a way to show the anger he had at that moment, death glare or stare with left eye blink...
Grandpa....... grandpa always arrives at the wrong time
Werner could have sent him to another place for a few months.
@@silentsea2956 I feel bad for laughing at this hahaha but I agree! Grandpa gets in the way too much!
@@silentsea2956 😂😂😂
😂😂😂@@silentsea2956
Дідусь першим помітив, що вони закохалися один в одного. "Чому ви на мене так дивитеся", - запитує в нього Жанна.
I think it was because he found out that she went into his room the previous night and he hoped that they would for the first time begin a dialogue with each other.
qingshengrusu n
Perhaps he did want to dialogue with her. My concern he tried to open the door to her bedroom which makes me wonder about his true intentions even though he is a perfect gentleman there is still the man inside this German officer. Glad she locked the door but then she might have felt compelled to make love to him.
I think when he approached her room he hears her lock her door and see the light on and maybe thinks she has instead unlocked it for him? That’s why he goes to open the door.
@@serenity4636 so I just picked up on the possibility that he tried her lock. Would love to see more comments on this point. Seems out of character for him
@@ljones1295 No, he did not try to open her door. This would have been a piece of the scene the film director would have shown (too important a move), just like when Jeanne slowly opened Werner's door previously. He just noticed a slight noise - the click of the key when she locked her door - and wondered if she was still awake. He listened... not a sound. Had she moved, he might have knocked at her door because he was just as desperate as her that night. However, when he entered his room, he had the answer to a few of his questions, his hopes.
I really wish the camera stayed on him a little longer when he found the letter on the floor, to take in his reaction when he saw the bed had been disturbed. Or even if he had laid on the bed himself and smelled her perfume.
Let’s hope it was Lavender!
Chanel no5
Janice Kang, that is a good choice too!
Fido, you are so right.
. musk
He did not finished the words I" noticed you come to my room, there I completed . hahaha he knew as well that the bed was messy a bit . oh what a beauty really all in motion NO words but full of LOVE .
can't believe I read almost all the comments on TH-cam about this movie.
I did too 😁
And me
Me too
Same here!
me too
Как красив Жуане.
Also, here, the whole scene screams: TALK TO ME!! I am here- allow me to explain!. I don't know if you noticed, but after the bridge scene, he is following her at home - for the same reason - only that this time was in his way the disgusting cousin. THen a third time he is trying to explain and open himself to her and this time is the grandpa who is in the way and so on and so forth...
@daniela ion
At the pier, What do you think about his stare? Was he trying to seduce her or just froze being so close to her?
Why is he upset right after the asault from freaking Pascal.
I think Werner was seducing her with his eyes. That glance! Even Jeanne couldn't help but to look at him! I think Werner was angry at her assault because of what almost happened to her. Maybe he was trying to control his anger and not beat up Pascal.
@@Skyblue-fw5rm But he still looked upset after Pascal left the house. He gave that angry look at her. He didn't stop, just kept walking but stopped later.
Do you think Werner could have thought that Jeanne was a little to blame?
@@Skyblue-fw5rm he sure didn't show any empathy towards her after the attack.
Because she saw the letter with a picture of a woman in it the night before. He probably wanted to explain to her who that woman was and relationship to him. But at the end, he didn't say anything. Maybe he realized he can't because he was German and she was French.
No! It was because they were interrupted, he was being a Gentleman, the reason is CLEAR.
(.... But I think they both survived the war, he came back from Russia to get her since he could not *help* himself, she was there for him because she could not possibly consider *any* other man, even though she thougut he was sure to uave died in Russia.... He came back for her, found her, and they lived happily ever after..)
midnightchannel There's a 40% chance he died in a gulag in Siberia, a 50% chance he died in combat and a 10% chance that he was freed in the mid-50s a broken man without teeth
@@rowingaway ...not all Eastern Front German POWs were captured by Russians, you know, many were captured by Americans. But, thank you, Rowling, for your uplifting statistics: there IS a chance, then that he survived, returned to her, and began a new life with perfectly good dentures :-)
@@rowingaway Realistic answer
I love how you think!
@@rowingaway Even if it's only 1% chance, I think anything is possible. I mean, this also reminds me of Werner von Haeften, who survived the Eastern Front despite having a severe wound. He went back to Germany to plot against Hitler (20 July plot) though unfortunately the plot failed and he was executed later.
Yep. This shows what we lost nowadays. Men lost their manhood, they dress, talk, behave...like mad sheep - with little understanding of responsabilities, honour, respect, discipline, etc.....Look how nice is this guy who is not tattooed, is shaved, perfectly groomed, highly intelligent, both academically and emotionally and yet, such a man not a pussy... THAT's why this character has such a great success on this site. AS for the kind of love....yeah - no sex, not even a touch and yet the depth of feelings is incomparable - nothing vulgar, disgusting....nothing of the usual crap that the nowadays movies are covering feelings and love with.
daniela ion so true sighhh
And look what we got now
I agree.... Werner saw her as a beautiful sculpture not some piece of meat. He appreciated her silence because he said the ocean needed to be listened to, he was pertaining to her as the ocean. She is brilliant, a gem in his eyes. She felt that about him.
The most annoying MERCEDES car and old grandfather...big obstacles between them
Wondering what would have happened if she hadn't woken up and he had found her asleep in his bed...?
Darn it ! Why did the automobile need to make such a racket of a noise..! Darn it!
Huuuum... He would probably think it's the cutest thing he ever saw and watch her sleeping until she woke up ?
Could you imagine her panic if he found her in his bed! Yikes!
I just said the same thing a few seconds ago. I would love to see his face then! He's very observant and sees much in her face.
I wished he had found her in his bed and what he would react - probably take her in his arms.
Werner is the man I try to be everyday
Lucky, is the one who finds you.
Oh, thank you Miss Bell
You’re welcome Mathias.
Well come Mathias!
You are a dream man, a prince then...🥰
I believe he sees the light from under her room and wonder if she's still up so that's why he tried to open the door.
What do you think would have happened if her door had not been locked? Do you think he would have told her his feelings for her? He seemed desperate to be close to her.
Maybe Werner would have kissed her unexpectedly.
I did double check this scene. Werner doesn't try to open her bedroom door. It is the wooden floor making squeaky sound not the door handle. he is a gentleman 💕
@@emmabarr6871 I am debating this point in my head. Does not seem to fit the character that he would try to open her door so I tend to agree with you. But…..him trying to open her door puts a different spin on this movie for me. Naughty Captain 👩✈️
@@emmabarr6871 I agree. It would have been out of character for Werner to try to open her bedroom door.
At 9:40, she doesn't really say "nothing bad comes from them" but "well, seems like everything coming from them isn't so bad...". It's quite different ;). Anyway, thank you so much for these videos, I just love this movie.
Beautiful scene at the pier in front of the pier! He was seducing her with his eyes. Jeanne made eye contact with Werner. He knew she loved him.
Мне было жаль Вернера и Жанну, они прощались навсегда, он погибнет на восточном фронте, какой взгляд, полный любви!!!
I think he just can't move his eyes away from her when she is so close to him.
@Amy M.....gosh, you described so good about his eyes.
Oh this is a very useful information, thank you!
💕Thank you
I read every single comment. Sigh.....why this movie had to end like this
Want to make a movie re-make? Adjust the ending. This is not based on a real story right?
Why was Werner looking at her parent's picture? Werner wanted to tell Jeanne something very private because he wouldn't speak in front of the grandfather.
You ask a question that many have wondered about. I’m not a psychologist but perhaps he saw himself with Jeanne and the future he longed for with her. Or he has a commitment to someone else but he knows he loves Jeanne. His chance to explain his feelings to her are lost when her grandfather appears. And so we are left to wonder.
@@sharyncarr4279 I felt the same way.
Forse lui voleva fare una dichiarazione d' amore!
He never says Jeanne wait, I want to talk to you. Or Jeanne are you alright?
尊严与热情，责任与欲望。她当义无反顾的选择了前者
Do you know why they often give a shot at his shoes? I cannot tell. As children in Vietnam, we were always given some literature like this: We had to live under the heels of the shoes of the French, the Americans...I wonder here it has the same meaning.
His beautiful leather boots were part of the image of a German officer. They projected strength and status. The scene at the fishing dock was to show his size and power over her, but he never uses the power he has, he moved out of her way immediately. He never wanted to appear threatening to her in anyway.
Lindooooo!!!
Ha! Werner got jealous. I want to know how a jealous Werner would act!!. 🤔
Grandpa did you realise you're the biggest third wheel there...arrrrrh Werner wanted to talk to your granddaughter can't you just leave for 10 minutes and eat the chicken from Pascal or something !
😂
Werner comes home early today? I think he said he usually came back at 10 pm.
Ha,ha. Yes. Maybe they gave him the day off or it was Saturday or Sunday. Or maybe Werner told an excuse to leave early. 😀
@@silentsea2956 i think he makes an excuse to leave work early just for her. 🥰🥰🥰
@@emmabarr6871 He could take a week off for Jeanne! Lol
@@silentsea2956 if that is the case, they should spend this week in their wedding and honeymoon in another country 😉. 😁😁😁 Tell their relatives after war they are married.
@@emmabarr6871 Yes. Have you thought of writing a fanfiction?
❤
Thomas Jouannet est magnifique dans ce film ! J’ai regardé tout ce qu’il a fait et je suis scandalisée de voir qu’il n’a jamais était nominé ou primé ! Cherchez l’erreur ! Trop bien? Trop beau ? Pas dans les critères « woks »?
Je ne regarde plus les films car les acteurs sont « moches » et les films sordides ! On a déformé le goût des gens !!!! Triste monde !
Прочитайте рассказ веркора молчание моря, во первых в рассказе он говорит о девушке, которую просили ему в жены, они так и не поженились, потому что маленький эпизод в лесу испортил некоторое впечатление у Вернера о его невесте, есть рассказ Льва Толстого "после бала", смысл этого рассказа в том, что молодой офицер на балу танцует с девушкой, у которой отец военный, командует, кажется полком, он восхищен, он уже подумывает сделать предложение, но на следующий день, он становится свидетелем неприятной сцены, когда на плацу выстроился этот самый полк, и одного солдата за непослушание этот самый командующий, отец девушки, побил то ли хлыстом, то ли палкой, у молодого человека мгновенно пропало желание делать девушке предложение
Atuação perfeita!!??
Чувствуете некоторое сходство, этот военный и его, молодого офицера при случае накажет, если тот окажется неугодным
Надо было ей уснуть на его кровати, жаль Вернер этого не увидел!
А что толку
why he didn't say a word when he helped her picking up the fishes???!! and then when he was looking at her parents photo why he stopped talking to her??!!!
aleka germanopoulou cuz the girl parents are killed by germans, and the captain just saw his grandpa, so he couldn't finish any sentence.
I think he went to fishing area to talk to her as he knew she went to his room. He lost courage when she froze him out. Then after pascal he wanted to try again but grandpa interrupted. I thought he looked equally cross with her when he ran to help.
He stopped talking because it was deeply personal topic to them both, about them both, , and he was going to acknowledge to her that he knew she had been in his room. But he could not expose this personal thing in front of her grandfather, it would be disrespectful to her. He is a Gentleman... only serial killers are called "Gentlemen" these days, ever notice? The tem is never used which is why men are NOT gentlemen anymore, woe is me! I think we women should insist on it, resurrect the concept, nd act more like "ladies" ourselces, makes for a much more interesting life, imho...
"equally cross with her when he ran to help"? Cross with whom? Werner was NOT cross with her, he's trying to control his anger and not rip the guy who tried to raped her to shreds.
aleka germanopoulou he is so gentleman, and this love so precious to him, he is no assertive ordinary man by any means, very romantic musician, this love is very delicate
Panira nmn ng moment c grandpa ui...
Such a sad love story , he went to the Russian front -40 f
Он же погибнет на русском фронте😒😒😒 но какая красивая форма у немцев!
Era lo único que tenían...un uniforme muy elegante.De Hugo Boss.Asi de cierto.
Werner era un hombre sensible,un artista,no era un militar.
Respetuoso, educado y enamorado de Jeanne,de Francia y de su cultura.
No les hacía falta hablar para transmitir todo ese amor y ese sentimiento que sentían.
Como decía un poeta español del siglo XlX.Gustavo Adolfo Bécquer:
Por una mirada, un mundo;
por una sonrisa, un cielo;
por un beso... yo no sé
qué te diera por un beso.
Y creo que esos deseos eran justamente lo que los dos; Werner y Jeanne querían,deseaban, cada vez que estaban juntos.
En ese adieu que se dijeron al despedirse...yo,me abría echado en sus brazos y lo habría besado apasionadamente...Ya no lo volvería a ver más...
Algo me habría llevado de él.😞
😁😁😁The German lion saved her
Az esküvői fényképnek fontos szerepe van:D
What do you think he wanted to.say to her at 7:29?
Yeah, I wonder the same thing... Why he went there and waited for her?
Celia M Torres Do you really think that a German official can use his car for private aim ? Even with his driver? I don't think so. Only he wants to lose his job.
He probably want to tell her the letter and messages.
Are you kidding?!? Of COURSE a German office can do ANYTHING he wants in an occupied country, ESPECIALLY when a foreign woman is involved!
The Captain would have access to a personal car and driver. Remember, the driver was the one who picked out his room and remarked about the flowers; he obviously had been his personal driver for some time. Could he have been the one who stole her bicycle???
@@sharyncarr4279 thumbs up for "the driver may steal her bicycle" :)))
Is there anyone can guess and tell me at 7:30 what the captain try to tell the girl? Does he discover something after he carefully look at her parents' picture?
Does he find out they are soul mates first since he has more information?
When does he has discovered? or the Captain just want to making connection to ease the discomfort with the host family, so he is safe while living in this house?
Does soul mates attract each other in a mysterious way, and has strong bond for long time? Please share what you know! Thanks !
I’m guessing he wanted to tell her about the letter he assumes she read from a girl named Greta, if she could read German. It may be that Greta is a girlfriend or fiancée. I don’t think he is married as her last name was not the same as his on the back of the envelope. He may have a commitment to Greta but he finds himself in love with Jeanne. His speech about reading Jeanne’s silence, meeting her at the fishing dock, playing the Bach piece and wanting to explain the letter are his attempts to break down any barriers that keep her from returning the love he wants from her. Unfortunately, everything is against them.
@@sharyncarr4279 -- Thank you for responding to my question! never have a movie I have watched like this one catches my heart for so long, and so touching !
I think, after examine her parent's picture, the captain probably has discovered something they have in common and like to share with her, but grandpa was there, so he stopped!
Actually at the end, Jeanne has returned the Captain's love by playing the piano to save his life, also her tears, her only verbally expression: adieu at the end all have confirmed him that she love him very much! because of the war, this is a forbidden love. Both of them are decent and intelligent people, loyal to their own countries, they know they cannot express their feeling publicly, all the feeling has to be hidden and suppressed; and when he was confirmed with the love, it is also the time to say good-bye FOREVER!! How beautiful ! how sad!
Not just the actors and actress, the director, the playwright, and all the movie staff all did a fantastic job !!
After watching this movie, we know that any long lasting genuine love relationship is not built by verbal expression or physical interaction, it all comes from the heart and soul !
Just love this movie !
Thanks for many of you who have shared good comments and positive reactions after watching this movie! All the sharing make me feel they are so many people who appreciate genuine love !
I see HOPE in today's world with too much lip services!
I believe he wanted to explain the picture to her so she wouldn't be confused.
@deemah hasan - yes there is a connection between "soulmates" that is a strong bond. I met him when I interviewed for a job and asked him has he been to FL? He said "no." He later said, I was the easiest person to speak to and hired me for the job. I stayed until they close the department but the only person he gave two weeks compensation was me only. One can talk from a distance I know I accidentally called out his name and later I saw him drive by my apartment looking for me? Also, another week he called out "hello" and I responded back "hello." We have similar birthdays, both left hand, dedicated to our work and family oriented. However, this is not to be since he is married and I don't want bad "karma" for either of us. I made a vow not to contact him at all. Despite him stopping by my place of employment I wouldn't go up to him. For what? It just wouldn't be an ideal situation. I care too much to form any further connection. It is enough to know someone cares that much about me.
Sorry, .My English is bad.portuguese o
Is my línguage.
💕
just say it " j t aime " if you did may be i could have ended diffrently
I wanted her to GIVE HIM something at the end, to take with him... So we could hope!! (but, again... this was a french propaganda book-film)
@@midnightchannel7759 That is the key----propaganda. The author/propagandist will not give Werner the pleasure to have a love relationship with Jeanne, so Jeanne never had a chance to cross the line. So all the teasing of their suppressed love is there to keep fans like us marooned in their love story. Look how all of us keep walking in this dark forest of Werner and jeanne, no one seem to be able to or want to find their way out. lol, this movie is too too much...
He tried to open her door like someone said!
It's a true.
@ Amy M I don't think so. She could hear him right outside her room. He was such a gentleman, he wouldn't open her door, ever.
@@SG-wq4rm Well,another person said it was because Werner heard a click on her doorknob because Jeanne locked her door but Werner thought that she was sort of inviting him inside. Probably Werner felt lonely that night. Also even though Werner is a gentleman he is also passionately in love with Jeanne. Remember how he was looking at her legs when she was wrongly seated but looked away immediately because he is a gentleman and a prim and proper man.
@@silentsea2956 I am going to watch again. I thought she heard wood creaking / cracking sound. I hope he was trying to open her door ☺️
@@SG-wq4rm Yes!!! If you notice when Jeanne was standing at her bedroom door ,the door of Jeanne was moving as if someone was trying on her doorknob. It's not very noticeable but Werner moved very close to Jeanne's bedroom door and put his arm/hand close to the doorknob.
Did he try to open the door of her bedroom? What motive would he have for that?
He did, you can hear it on the sound track.
He seemed particularly vulnerable as it was Christmas Eve, he is far away from home and so in love with Jeanne. I think he was going to tell her he loved her.
Love,so love.......
You are right. Werner knew that Jeanne was alone in her bedroom.
@@silentsea2956 Crying river of tears....
@@sharyncarr4279 I don't think he tried to open her door, or the frame of film would have shown it, it is too impulsive and aggressive for his character, notice, Jeanne's room is not a suite, does not have a door plus vestibule plus another door. I don't know what that jiggling noise was, but i think he only listened, and heard nothing and went to his room. He already told her he loved her by playing the Prelude in the living room while she sat alone in front of the fire.
It's actually pretty heartbreaking as in the end they both said "adieu - à dieu" > see you up there, see you on the other side....
They knew that the only chance to reunite and be together was meeting in heaven.
😭😭😭😭😭
So.....who's Greta who wrote to him? Wife, sister, girlfriend?
In the original short story, the German officer talked about a girl he thought he wanted to marry but never asked her. In the 1949 movie version of this story, the Captain had a fiancée. Since Greta’s last name is not the same as his, I assume she is a serious girlfriend or a fiancée. There in is his problem, he may have a fiancée but he loves Jeanne.
Sharyn Carr Thank you.
@@sharyncarr4279 I did not read the book but my interpretation of this is that he wanted her to know who she was, I think his love for Jeanne was more important than this girl, he wanted her to know that he felt stronger for her
why did he seek her out in that fishng hut and only kept gazing at her?
I think he went there to try and speak to her alone. He lost his chance on Christmas Eve but once he knew she was in his room, he was desperate to speak to her. But he lost courage when she kept glaring at him!
He was waiting for an opening, as any Gentleman would... He had to wait until she softened, paused, looked at him for longer than milliseconds... that is why he kept looking at her, willing her to give him an opening... He loves her. But he understands her situation, that he is the invader, so he must allow hr to control the opening completely so she knows she is safe with him, that he respects her...
* sigh *
Remember the scene at the fireplace when he tells her about the silence of the sea, he was taking a big risk to draw her closer to him (grandpa realized what was going on). On Christmas Eve, he was struggling so hard to express his feelings for her without being aggressive. He didn’t want to frighten her which is why he didn’t touch her. Keep in mind who has the power. When he discovers she was in his room and in his bed, he now knows he is not alone in his feelings. He stands at the end of the pier forcing her to walk straight to him, but she doesn’t stop nor will she respond to him. He is crushed which then plays out in the assault scene
I notice when people feel a strong sense of connection they want to see that person no matter what. Just to be around them or feel their presence which what I felt for someone. However, futile it may be.
Wanted to see if she would give a hint to her true feelings for him. She hides them well like the sea he said about her.
What did he wanted to tell her?
I don't know..... Sad.
@@ivabaptista7069 I think explain the girl in the picture
Why was he waiting for her down at the dock?
He realized she had been in his room by the letter out of place and the pillow on his bed had been disturbed. He was hoping that she would respond to him if he got her alone away from the house. He is sure that she is hiding her feelings for him. She has no choice but to walk toward him. His tall dark figure including his heavy boots is meant to show the power he holds over her but he never uses it. He immediately steps out of her way, as he wants her to come to him of her own free will. She can only glance at him, but not speak to him. The disappointment is on his face as she rides away from him.
To see further proof in her eyes that there was more to her feelings than anger.
也许这不能实现的爱情成就了这最为永恒的爱情
Michelle Currier 可憐無界河邊骨 猶是春閨夢裡人
Michelle Currier 二戰時期德國東線戰場傷亡太大 Werner 估計是掛了😭抱歉人不在美國
@@mswonwongo , 第二次世界大戰很可怕! 聯軍打仗勝! 我公公是美國軍, 說投降的德國軍在雪地上鞋子都沒有穿! 公公脫下來給他們穿, 軍人跪下來抱著公公的腿............. 公公說見到幾千猶太人的屍體將柴一樣疊在一起
Michelle Currier 唉 聯軍是西線戰場 比東線蘇俄好多了 東線幾乎是有去無回 屍骨無存了
Michelle Currier 晚安謝謝 我找來看看
many thanks for the explaination.i believe that the movie was different from the book.i have not read the book.but why couldnt he tell her?he could speak french. was he in love?.was he tongue tied?but she was in love with him .how coulld she hide from him.she looked at him quite coldly
Sometimes love doesn't come to mind in the beginning after a while she started to realized she was when she saw him pick up Pierre when he was injured that endeared him to her.
maybe he was overwhelmed in his love for her.but strange that he,a german officer,a man of education ,sence of loyalty to his country,(they all were brainwashed),someone used to the harshness of war, should be stricken dumb in front of a slip of a girl
No.. nonono. He is a Gentleman, he is protecting her privacy, a Gentleman would NEVER speak of intimate things like this in mixed company! The reason is clear!
I believe they were soul mates due to the music connection they both felt. After all, there are more ways to connect or communicate and that's through music too.
She was more than a slip of a girl because she maintained the household and took care of her grandfather. There was something so mature or her age and dedicated to her life teaching lessons to earn a living in this town. He was stunned by her strength of character.
I believe he wasn't accustomed to the war and was still naive how things were until his friends came to visit and explained in their language this is how it is- face facts! It was depressing to see his world fall apart at that time.
she looks like Adele
They're both beautiful women.
She does and has such a pretty face.
He is jealous
Why?
@@user-rf9gs1by3kc why didn't he make the confession? What did he think of this scene with Pascoal?
Tell me, please
@@user-rf9gs1by3kc Sorry,I am from Brazil,and my lánguage is Portuguese.my English is bad.
the first version he had a fiancee. I think he was shocked by this scene, not knowing what to do.
@@user-rf9gs1by3kc me too.God bless you and your family all.
Хз
It seemes like Werner was married?) Wasn't it a pucture of the boy in that letter?
In the book it's his (ex) fiancee , whom he doesn't want to marry. Werner has some particular dislike to German girl in general, and foolishly believe French could cure it.
4:25 he wants her so bad
Hera678 omg I know! I've watched it before and never noticed that he actually touched her hand.
Mary Thao when? She never uttered a word to him until the end - "farewell"
rmb yen it's really hard to see but it happened when she dropped the fishes and he took off his glove to help her pick it up. It's really quick and have to pay attention to the angle. I watched it so many times cause it happens so quickly.
@@marythoj205 I watch this part at 0.25x speed. He doesn’t touch her hand. Sadly
@@emmabarr6871 aww wishful thinking lol