Yves Saint Laurent Y Eau De Parfum vs. Dior Sauvage Group Reaction
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 มิ.ย. 2024
- Use code BALDASSARRE10 to receive 10% off Mancera Cedrat Boise Intense at Twisted Lily using this link: tidd.ly/3AOf6l8
Enter To Win Our $1,000 Fragrance Shopping Spree on TeddyBaldssarre.com: forms.gle/Pb8ocDiEhC2RRMyw8
Shop Our Complete Fragrance Collection On TeddyBaldassarre.com: teddybaldassarre.com/collecti...
Shop Creed: teddybaldassarre.com/collecti...
Shop Amouage: teddybaldassarre.com/collecti...
Shop Parfums de Marly: teddybaldassarre.com/collecti...
Shop Xerjoff: teddybaldassarre.com/collecti...
In this video, we'll compare two of the most popular men's fragrances on the market, YSL Y and Dior Sauvage. Our guests will react to each fragrance, provide their unbiased opinions, and then share their favorite and least favorite. We hope you enjoy this video! What other types of fragrance videos would you like to see on the channel?
Check Out The Playlists On Our Channel:
Reactions: • Reaction Videos
Reviews: • Reviews
Lists: • List Videos
Educational & How-To: • Educational & How-To
Table of Contents:
0:00 - Intro
1:16 - Yves Saint Laurent Y
3:14 - Dior Sauvage
4:44 - Favorite & Least Favorite
Guests:
Tressa: @tressa_choukalas
Peyton: @peytonburkett
Ashley: @ashleywilkins_
Peachy: @pbethune6
Lexie: @alexxismxx
Jim: @james_ziegan
Chris: @chrisup10x
Baldassare Fragrance Instagram: @baldassarre.fragrance
Courtney's Instagram: @courtneycristineryan
Teddy's Instagram: @teddybaldassarre - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
Guy really said everyone wears YSL Y so dont buy it, but he loved sauvage lmao one of the most popular mens fragrances of all time
Because not everyone wears y edp, and not everyone wear Sauvage. But two are really popular.
I know what nit wit!
Fr
Bro I was thinking the same thing
Same. Thought it’s the other way around
Honestly surprising what the one guy said. I wear YSL Y because it's super versatile and I've never smelled anyone wearing it, but I encounter guys DAILY that wear Sauvage.
Also, I just became your 2000th follower on insta. Keep it up!
I never met someone who wears sauvage but smell Y everyday. So yeah it's not really like you say bro
u dont smell it cuz ur nose blind 😁
Both are horrible synthetics messes. Sauvage smells like a harsh windex and Y EDP smells like a sharp cloying apple mess. Performance isn't everything if you can't wait to shower to get rid of the smell.
I own Sauvage EDT, Sauvage Elixer, and Y EDP. Love them all.
People need to get it out of their minds that EVERYONE is wearing these fragrances. I can assure you that they are not. Billions of People in this World are not wearing those fragrances.
@Sattwik Hazra Australia
In Germany everyone knows Sauvage. Teenagers in 8th grade start wearing it. Many people are wearing it, everyone recognizes it, so it's nothing special anymore.
@Sattwik Hazra You can get a small bottle for 50 Euro. We have a minimum wage of 12 Euro per hour. Many teenagers start a part time job when they're 16 years old. It's not that luxurious here in Europe.
Exactly that’s what I been saying the whole time,,,majority of ppl don’t even wear cologne.. so I don’t get the narrative of dior sauvage being “overly worn”
Exactly. I live in NYC and im out and about everyday I can count on one hand how many times I've smelled Savauge or Y on someone. Is it popular? Yes but that doesnt mean you shouldn't get because you think "everyone is wearing it". If I like the smell i wear it period. It doesnt matter to me who else has it.
Ysl Y is a solid safe choice for me. Wear it in the office, wear it for first encounters, stuff like that. When I'm feeling adventurous, I move onto something more niche
What else do you have? I currently have: Dior savage, Bleu de Channel, and Jimmy Choo men
interesting, ever since the new Y EDP intense came out i switched to that one for the buy instead of the EDP. but my all time favorite hands down is Bleu de Chanel EDP. but the other much better sauvage imo Carbon is really good too thatll be my go to on rainy days or just during a cold chilly day.
I love dude's reaction at the end because I imagine that's how the entire fragrance community would react to Sauvage in a blind test. 😂 Just goes to show we love to hate on Sauvage for the sake of hating it hahaha
That's exactly my thought as well.
I hate it because it doesn't smell good on my skin. Dior has much better offerings. Y is a masterpiece however. The salted caramel drydown with the Tonka Bean. So good. On my Savauge is a headache.
Own both and both are great in their own way. Having said that, ln my personal experience I have received more compliments with Y EDP. For some reason women love the combination of freshness and sweetness. Nice vid guys!
It’s so versatile. I love it. It definitely turns heads and last hours.
definitely, i've tried Dior sauvage but is was just too warm and it makes me feel a little bit too "old" for me (i was 17) , and the women of my family agree in that and they didn't like it too much either, but when i've tried Y EDP 2022 all women around me likes it, and me too lmao, now i have Y EDT Intense 2022 and is a 10/10, I just only chose the EDT intense version instead of the EDP one because EDT was more versatile than the EDP
Thrilled to find my wishlist fragrances on your site.
Love to see blind reaction series from you guys. Shows how other people perceive differently. Definitely is subjective.
Can we just aprreciate the quality of the videos. You can see how much work and thought they put in their videos.
seriously underrated for how many subs they have.
I got tired of sauvage edt and kept it at the back for half a year then just recently some one passed me leaving that trail behind and I could believe how good it is.
i love these group reactions!
THIS IS LITERALLY WHAT I WAS LOOKING FORR!!! THANK YOU !!!
I was recently torn between YSL Y EDT or EDP, and went with EDT, due to it being a bit more cleaner & refreshing smell. EDP was a bit more on the sweet side for me, and I already have enough that smell sweet.
I personally loves YSL ETD its clean and can wear it as an every day scent. I wear it often. It's not a head Turner but if your not trying to gain attention it's a good neutral smell.
Its great how you know my man in the nike polo has ran through all the best designers that are worth while. Love it, good stuff.
Got this suggestion from Courtney's Channel and I love these episodes especially Tressa's opinion , She tell it like it is.
Tressa is my fav reviewer on this channel lol
Thank you beyond mere words for having a sound bed that is turned down so as to avoid competing with the spoken word. I need you teach everyone, please!
Love the new faces coming into the videos!
I’ve only smelt Sauvage on two guys and it was really appealing. Granted, neither one had doused themselves in it, but it was noticeable. Of course I knew what it was, but it’s definitely not off putting on someone else. I totally understand why it sells so well.
this goes to show that most people dont like sauvage because it's too popular or because it's a trend to hate on it, most of then think is a good fragrance until they know the name
I own them both, I love them both 😍 I find YSL a little bit more wearable. Thanks
I have both of them currently right now for regular everyday use i am telling you girls love ysl y you can literally see the way they look at you differently
So sad, that the last videos are so long ago. I would love some newer content! Especially Tressa :D I love her ruthless, honest opinions, which are also rooted in a really good understanding of fragrance profiles.
yesss. i was scrolling through their videos but was disappointed they hadn’t posted more recently
I must say that I wear those fragrances which I like and I can afford. I don't care if people is wearing it or not or if it's cheapy or not. The most important to me is that I like it and I have the possibility of having it. Other things are simply secondary...
At the beginning of the video I was expecting Savauge to be the fragrance Chris was talking about lol
Great video. I love Chris’ comment “ Y buy Y”, 🤣🤣
Y not?
Would love to see a le labo centered video! People outside of the fragrance community are mesmerized by the brand, and I would love to see how this group reacts to the scents.
I've seen a group reaction to Santal 33 and it wasn't good lol. Tressa liked it, though, I remember, but Jim thought it smelled like a stuffed cabbage! 😆
@@DarlingNikki2 yeah that was so funny. I wonder what they might think of Thé Matcha26, Bergamonte 22, Another13, or Thé Noir 29.
I own both, I like the smells for myself, they make me feel good. I could give a shit less if anyone else likes it, it gives me confidence.
If any more people start wearing Sauvage the earth itself is going to start smelling like it.
It be interesting to do the whole Y line VS the whole Sauvage line to see which the girls prefer the most
Girls prefer Y eau fraiche the most, sucks because it's the hardest to find in stores.
@@GrowingDownUnder Interesting, I thought it was an easy find but turns out there’s not much out there in terms of trusted sellers at least is it discontinued?
@@just4interest996 I'm not sure if it's discontinued, but I can't find it anywhere not even on their own website. So i'm gonna say it's discontinued which absolutely would suck because it's the best Y fragrance. It smells like the EDP except more fresh, better balanced and not as cloying sweet. Basically all the issues I had with the EDP, the eau fraiche solved all those problems
@@GrowingDownUnder I agree Y edp does have that cloying sweetness, sounds like it’s a sleeper. Probably because people like me just think it would be like Versace without even checking the note breakdown
@@GrowingDownUnder I got a decant today and you’re right it does smell like a less cloying version of Y I can see this one being more popular if they just named it under the same line.
Chris needs to be a permanent guest on these group reactions. He knows his fragrances.
what?
he says everyone wears y but then calls sauvage amazing and tells us to buy it
its the exact opposite, everyone wears sauvage
@@user-rj3qc2kx1i tbh I smell Montblanc Explorer and YSL a lot more often than I smell Sauvage anymore, pre pandemic I would agree
@@user-rj3qc2kx1i First off, he identified at least one of the two fragrances, and just couldn't remember the name of the other. So his nose is accurate. Second, even if he's wrong about the overall popularity of the fragrances, it doesn't say anything about his ability to describe and identify them.
We need people who don't. Also he couldn't recognize Door SauSage
@@BlazemanGuitarX I don't know where you live but Sauvage is literally the most common fragrance at this point.
This video actually convinces to get Y EDP. I'm actually looking at the demeanor of the individuals that are going for Sauvage and I'd rather not be associated with that type. The individuals for Y seemed more calm and Earthy.
Plus the more hate something seems to get turns out it is actually better ! 😂
I tend to disregard anyone's opinion on any fragrance, whose main take on a scent is "it's good, but too many people wear it." People wear it, because it's good. I guess Pink Floyd and the Beatles sucks, if we use this analogy. Yo, people, don't buy food that's tasty, buy something that makes you hurl, be original! Get a grip... The fragrance community really isn't that big, and only a small fraction of it is concerned about stuff being too popular, so it means 99 people out of a 100 won't have any idea if you're wearing Sauvage, Y, One Million or whatever, nor do they give a damn. All they gonna think is that you smell nice. Don't be a wannabe hipster douche.
Yeah being new to the fragrance community it's a bit mind-blowing how much of a staple this viewpoint is and I will never understand it. Remember, everyone: nobody cares what you're wearing (or at least most don't).
Finally someone with a brain and common sense
Totally agree. Most men don't even wear a fragrence at all. Unless you live in a very densely populated area like New York or LA, it makes almost no difference how popular a fragrence is. 99% of people wouldn't be able to name either of these fragrences if they smelled them. Either one would be a good choice for most men. Just wear what you like.
Tressa is on point, already figured out what’s going on before it’s done
You Should have compared Bleu de Chanel EDP as well and the dry downs of each
Maybe. I have BDC EDP and the hype is overrated imo. Doesn't project and is just a clean scent. Never get any compliments compared to other fragrances. I think it's just a good clean fresh blue scent that's more mature than youthful. Not saying it's bad but people don't go out of their way to compliment or ask about it
Y one of my all time favourites!
Tressa is just so positive😭😭
I tried Versace at first now ready to get my daily scent 🎉
Too me, I really don’t care what these people think, but I have Sauvage edt and YSL Y edp! I like Sauvage and have gotten 1 compliment with it, but Y edp I have had several compliments and of over 60 kinds that I have, it’s my #1.⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I just found out that you has perfume channel, your watch channel really good tho
Just entered the contest! Super stoked at the opportunity to win some fragrances that I cant afford :) Keep up the great work!
i think they should have mentioned in the video title which sauvage they tested, though i'm guessing it was the EDT by the looks of the bottle
How Chris feels about Y is how I feel about Sauvage (which is only one letter different than Sausage).
I sprayed bleu de chanel on my hand and it smelled horribly synthetic, I did’t like it. But I sprayed this one on my hand and I would almost say I love it
i have Dior sauvage EDT And I get so many compliments 💘
some seem to be paid for by Dior, I have the Y edp, and it's amazing. extremely delicious. But keep buying Savage and everyone walking with the same scent... haha I prefer to smell different and very good
the Y edt 2022 better performs than the original. Def a favorite of mine love the initial pop!
Both good fragrances but I couldn’t bear the ambroxan heavy Sauvage hence I went for the Y EDP.
Had them both fragrances...yeah they very popular and that's not without a reason thay just smell great.
Do a blind test video comparing all sauvage concentrations
Sauvage is a compliment beast. I get compliments every time I wear it.
Chris is a good guest to have on
I just got the yves saint laurent and man that smell is freaking awesome plus got some deodorant and man it smells so goooooooooooooood
Just proves peoples opinions and tastes are fleeting.
Please test all the Acqua di gio line next please I would love to see that!
I fell into tris trap when i became a fragrence snob... Had this convo about everyone wearing Blue dnk... i was wrong... Most people are not going out of their way to buy $100 fragrences
Great video ❤️
One thing I like to do is mix/layer fragrances. Especially if I like the fragrances but they're very popular, like Sauvage and Y. These two are ones I wear together and do a 50/50 ratio. They compliment each other very well and you also end up smelling more unique. I get a huge number of compliments wearing these two together. The only problem is when people don't just tell you that you smell great, but ask what you're wearing. Haha. As with any fragrances I mix, I've grown to just tell them it's a mix of a couple fragrances. If they're really curious because they want to buy them for a loved one, they'll then ask for specifics and you can't tell them exactly.
Mixing dior and YSL is understandable but generally you should avoid mixing fragrances as they are already a mix of like 50 scents. You risk ruining the perfume, disturbing the harmony of the carefully selected scents.
@@bauda818 You're entitled to your opinion, my friend. Dior and Y aren't the only two I mix, and I don't always mix everything I wear. I'm wearing Aventus today, solo, and never mix Aventus or any of my Creed fragrances when I wear them. Even with Sauvage and Y, I don't mix them every single time. Mixing in general is just something I do sometimes and have for a long time. I wouldn't say that it will "ruin" the fragrances. Sure, if you like just one or the other by itself, mixing them is going go eliminate you being able to enjoy them for what they are individually. You couldn't think of it like if you enjoy apple juice and cranberry juice, and you mix them you may still enjoy cran-apple, but it's then something different. But as far as ruining them, nothing is ruined. In fact, I've fairly recently found the TH-cam channel of a Perfumer who does videos of various fragrances "reviewed by a Perfumer". He makes fragrances for a living and I've heard him say a couple times that he also layers fragrances and will wear two individual scents.
Who cares if too many people wear a certain scent. People I notice are a bunch of sheep and just go with what everybody is talking about, they care more about what people say rather than their own feelings. If you like sauvage don't be embarrassed, stick with it. I don't go out sniffing people for a living so who cares. I wear what I wear for my family, my wife and four kids. I have a bunch of fragrances and my family gravitates towards two of them bleu de chanel edp and Christian Dior Sauvage edp. I wear it for them and myself. When you try to please the masses you will never please yourself. Like what you like and own it.
I'm still waiting nine the Prada Luna Rossa and Dior homme and Dior home sport reactions
Im 80% nose blind to Sauvage EDT but still bought it. A bit bummed out that i can't really smell it. Funnily i tried La Rive Extreme Story which is a dirt cheap, slightly sweeter, Sauvage clone and i have a bit of a problem smelling that one too. In fact i pick the La Rive scent up more then the original. My nose just doesn't get the DNA it seems.
Stop wearing and smelling it for 1-2 weeks. You'll smell it again.
Those are Smelly Proof bags right? Or are they Lopsak Opsak?
Tressa needs her own channel. She fascinates me.
Yes.
no
maybe
Well.. she’s smokin hot so… 🤷♂️
I already have Y EDP, but I love the blind reactions to Sauvage. Maybe I'll get it now, or at least test it.
Trust me, most of women prefer the Y, I've seen lots of videos comparing Sauvage and the Y, and This is literally the only video where sauvage won against the Y
So I should trust a random TH-cam comment whose experience with Y and Sauvage are ... other youtube videos?
Fortunately, I already tested Sauvage, and still prefer Y EDP.
For those ultimately deciding for themselves between just these two scents, go with Y EDP for a sweeter scent. Go with Sauvage for a fresher scent.
I entered the giveaway. My husband helped me pick. I've never won anything in my life I so need something good to happen. Good luck everyone!!!
I own both and prefer Sauvage EDT. Y EDP has a very strong floor-cleaner note that is hard to ignore and mostly goes unused in my collection. Which is a shame because I loved it at first smell but after a week of wear it started giving me headaches.
You're so right!
I love the way the EDP smells, but it's the only one in the Y line that gives me a slight headache after a few hours. I don't know why. Because of that, I prefer "Y Live" or "Y EDT"
It’s definitely the one of my fav blues ever but it’s hard to wear daily! But that’s also why I like it because it’s so strong
Did they announce the winner of the giveaway?
Try YSL L'homme....this fragrance is known as every girls favourite scent. You gotta test out it's power
I’ve seen girls going crazy for it in a perfume store. My favorite is the bleu electrique version
A lady I work with said I smelled rustic with the YSL.😂
Big fan of Y edp. Just smelled Myslf for the first time and it’s sooo good. Might be better than Y!
I have both. Sausage is smoother, maybe for a date, or church. Y is for sure my head turner, if there's more people around and need to stand out, but its also very sporty, maybe a single spray so when you walk by your gym crush
Stupid auto-correct🤦😂
Sausage great scent
I always go with pepperoni
@@CyberBeep_kenshi lmaooo
@@alfredomacias3208 couldn't resist ;)
Please can you tell me the batch of Y edp? Which year is?
I’ve smelled these on other people and they are nice but bleu de chanel and ASEE are better imo
If like I'm going to buy u now what I love yves saint Laurent😊
Sauvage EDP is the Best Sauvage.
Yeah it splits the difference between the smooth Parfum and sharp EDT perfectly. Everyone complains about its longevity versus the EDT and miss out on an excellent fragrance. 🤷🏻♂️
I want to hear what Jim's ideas of good fragrances are... I bet he wears axe body spray
What one gets the most compliments ?
I see Tressa I hit like 😎 lol on the real though great vid!
Oregon must be only place on earth where Y is more popular then Savage.
Yeah I haven't smelled Y on anyone since I started collecting a year ago.
Funny enough I live in Oregon and a lot of my friends rock YSLY haha
I owe all 3 of thoses colognes. I get the most compliments from women ages 30+ when I wear Creed which i only wear on special Occasions formal dinners Etc. And noticed i get more complaments from women in there 20's more when i wear Savage. I believe younger women enjoy more of a sweeter note kind of clean boy smell. When women 30+ enjoy more of a manly spice, woody smell . But all depends on my mood of the evening .
That's why I always go for the sweeter ones :) Although Dylan Blue seems to be a crowd pleaser. Sweet with a smoky base.
I thought about getting Sauvage edt but talk of reformulation and its longevity now im not sure.
I picked it up this summer. if it was reformulated it still lasts all day on my skin. 8 hours for sure.
Tressa convinced me to finally try Dior Sauvage after all of this time.
Please do. I like Sauvage so much I wear it to bed. Lol.
@@AidanAidanAAA I did it. I really like it. It's much fresher and cleaner than what I was anticipating, but clearly masculine. I'm pleased.
To me Versace Dylan Blue is better than either of them and you can get it at a fraction of the price on discounters. Can't do that with Dior or YSL fragrances.
i found Dylan to be pretty average.
If only Dylan Blue performed better, I might have to agree with you. For me, Savauge and Y last much longer than Dylan Blue.
@@NevNYC My bottle lasts forever. So strong that I sometimes scrub it off at work lol 3 to 4 sprays
DB is not a good fragrance because of the combination of the incense and ambroxan.
Dylan Blue is definitely a solid choice.
I personally prefer the smell of Y, but most women I've asked prefer Dylan Blue. I think it might be the heavy ambroxan in Dylan Blue that many women are attracted to.
Savauge smells great, but too many people wear it. I forego buying it for this very reason. I prefer Widian London to Savauge.
London is epic
Sauvage always gets a bad reputation but when it’s in a blind reaction, it’s not that bad at all 😂 Maybe it’s overused because it is that good.
I got both, and in all honesty, YSL Y is my most complimented, especially from the ladies. It projects like a BEAST
How many sprays?
@@wd2518 5
It literally smells like heaven
What your y edp batch bro ? My 2022 y edp is weak in performance😢
@@jeaneliseejeanbaptiste2921 2022 as well
Prada Luna Rossa Carbon vs others
I'm probably going to buy Y next. Why? Y not?
As much as people hate it in the frag community, sauvage is a best seller for a reason. This will draw more positive attention than 90% of the niche out there….I know the truth hurts.
Dude's reaction at the end was the entire fragrance community in a nutshell 😂
@@silverstaralchemist 😂
Hell, she literally said the Sauvage is "more unique". Probably more unique than water.
I Like sauvage a lot but interestingly enough my girlfriend gravitates towards the parfum as her favourite of the line.
That being said, I’d be curious to know your thoughts on the different concentrations of the Sauvage line sometime!
the EDP is my favorite has a sweetness to it, and then the EDT is the youngest/manly, Parfum is smooth, Elixir is "older man" type
Elixir is the best of the line. Very sexy smelling and all you need is one spray and you'll be set.
@@darklausal23 Thanks for the summary!
@@winnienguyen4420 I like it a lot but unfortunately my SO dislikes it with a passion…
I have EDT,EDP and Elixir. I just got a big bottle of EDP so have been wearing EDT and EDP side by side a few days. EDP is more oriental spicy and EDT is more citrus. Elixir is way different and maybe the strongest scent I own. I sprayed 5 sprays on me the first time wearing it out and had a bubble on me that was around 15 feet pulsing lol.
Chris is an awesome addition. I would not buy either of them. I have over fifty fragrances and I don’t own them. They are played out. Be different and wear something that stands out in the crowd. Spend your money wisely.
algunos parecen pagados por Dior. Tengo el Y EDP es increíble
Did that one guy complain about Y being popular but not Sauvage which is even more popular? lol
I love how this dude says everyone wears the y but a lot of dudes wear dior everywhere
Sauvage smells good on other people I can't stand it on me. Ysl for me is a fresh bomb I wear just to smell super clean.
My guy really just said that Y is more overused than Sauvage.
Came here to call out the guy who said Dior over YSL Y and saw that everyone in the comments already did that.
2:12 One of my friend says I smell like dawn dish soap in the deep dry down of y edp lol what even or embarrassing was that another friend added the soap the with duck on? Like bruh
Dior Sauvage Elixir vs Ysl y le parfum
dior sausage is great but it just doesnt compare to YSL Y EDP