Please listen to th-cam.com/video/nG6XkZNUGdU/w-d-xo.html this link... Mauli Mauli ... A marathi song... Pronunciation is maaoolee maaoolee... Means mother.... Here referred to god... Please react it's lovely song
I don't think you got gist of it. I showed that no woman is safe, regardless of her position, religion, social status, age. Even what she wears burqa,saree, western wear,literate,illetate, you see difference between each woman but all are united by the same crime committed against them.
that's kinda what they said. in fact, they went deeper than most other reactions. It was an amazing and honest review. Basically what you've mentioned is what everyone gets from this, but what Korbin noticed is the fact that they used women to represent what men usually use as excuses for assaulting women. It wasn't as detailed a review; but their observation about the little one going to maushi was a good one!
@@aakarshaajitpandey4868 That it was but overall they were not as impacted by it as I thought they would be. Jaby got it fully well. It's in times like this that I wonder if Jaby's half-Asian roots help him with reacting the way we do. Anyway this was one of very few 'sort of fails' for OSR. No problem
No these were spirits. Leaving the room signified being born again as girl child. Having gone through previous life trauma they didn’t want to experience it ever again.
I don't think that's the case. Otherwise her body should be burnt. I think waxing shows that she is just like any other woman. Like others she waxes, makeup etc. It's for breaking stereotype of burka wearing women.
@@rajoberoi2559 Although yours is more logical, I think Sanjana's comment makes more sense because in the film the ladies revealed how they were killed. Some were stabbed, crushed by rock, etc...but none of those injuries were visible, if I'm correct. That's why the woman in the Burkha didn't look burnt as her burn injuries were also not showing
There is a lot of detail all over. Waxing one has probably been described aptly by Raj. The detail of the multiple ages and walks of life and type of clothing etc shows rape happens no matter what you wear or live life like or do in life or how old you are . Rape therefore has nothing to do with a woman's character.
The house is a metaphorical representation of the afterlife. All the members of the house were not only victims of the heinous act of raping but also they were murdered after they were raped. The latest member to have arrived is that little girl, who was also a victim of the same fate. The quotation from Maushi about how Arzu, the woman in Burkha (the one with the wax strip) was burnt alive, how Shruti Haasan was killed with a bottle of beer and thrown in the highway, how Neha Dhupia passed away due to the trauma that she couldn't take any further, how Kajol's throat was cut off and other details by other ladies stand as evidence to the fact that they were not only raped, but also murdered. What kicks the most is that even in the afterlife they are cornered away.
You guys missed the point totally. I beleive the comments down below would clear things out. But it was way too dark and I beleive thar got lost in translation.
It' hell. All of them were raped and killed/died. going outside means re-birth. Which no one of them wants. It's hell and they all have problem with it but they prefers that more than human world.
Why the victims will go to hell?? It is the tyrants and oppressors who will go to hell. Purgatory is the time period where souls will stay till judgement day, according to christians n islamic beliefs. Islam called this state as "Barzakh". In barzakh or purgatory, one soul bear the burden of his bad deeds, or gets the comfort of good deeds. In this video it is something like purgatory, a waiting room because reincarnation is a hindu belief.
they are all dead and their souls living together somewhere. when another one dies, tv goes off. they were all raped and murdered including minor. get it ?
Little details from it-- They all are dead and are assembled at one place after death, what we call afterlife When news repoter says that whole country is filled with rage, neha turns her face and closes her eyes.. As she knows that it is all useless, people forget everything with time, candle marches, etc are just for a time period, after that even justice is not served in brutal cases. The tv goes off and pee sound produced signifying that another victim has died and needs to be occupied in this house .. Kajol said that according to reports ' hr din koi nyi ladki aayegi, kitno ko bahar rkhrnge.. 'That signifies how frequently rapes occur. That medical student signifies nirbhaya, and she is preparing for an exam which she will never give as she is dead(and her dreams too) When kajol says that don't fight after dhupbatti and maushi says there is no God here, why you are worshipping then. Arzu says nobody asked them to to stay here together, ' bhed bakriyo ki trh thuns diya.. They were raped, and killed, no consent nothing. I literally had tears when they told their stories.. That how they were raped.. Even marital rape as maushi was married when she was 12 years old. When neha said she died in trauma of rape, and maushi said you at least got time to cry, then she says that.. If I didn't bleed that doesn't means I was not in pain.. That signifies how traumatic it can be. Kajol in end says that we were adjusting in between those demons, it's easier to stay in this afterlife than that.. When the small girl entered, each one of them was shocked as they were not able to believe that situation is so worse now, that even a little girl was not spared from those demons, they also felt guilty that how they were fighting to send the girl away, without knowing that she is so small. Someone is deaf, someone is wearing shorts, someone is in burqa and saree, some are educated, some are illiterate, all from different religions, Rape is irrespective of these things
I don’t know why the Indians insist on asking these Americans to react to local Indian social issues? It is impossible to understand them because their lives are completely different from the Indians, the life of freedom is not the same as the life of social values, they are doing this because the TH-cam that pays them money and in fact they do not care about anything else
That's harsh , okay really harsh if u want to use such type of words , that they are stupid then let me tell u one thing smart pants , you are stupid . They speak what they get , and u got no right to speak about them like that . If u didn't like their reaction then go dont watch the video hipocrat. 1st u r watching the video and then saying stupid things about them . How stupid u r .
Also, no its not metaphor, they are all dead! they were all victims. This is them telling their story about how the world is cruel, that they didnt even spare a little girl.
Don't expect the reaction you WANT... it's their reaction... people here be like react like this and that...they shared what they got from what they saw...
I think the little girl is the granddaughter of the older woman .. which makes it all the more heart wrenching. That's why she went to the woman she recognized and that's what made the old woman hurt so bad ...
That poor little girl, my heart just shattered. 😢 Few days ago my friend was telling me about his 6 month's old patient, her parents used to leave her with her grandfather and after few days she had a chest conjunction and after the tests they found semen in her . Yeah it was grandfather.
you guys really didnt understand this story .... was disappointed throughout ... may be watch it again guys :/ just to understand the power of this story after reading the comments
@@suvendum.p.7715 hard but not impossible and they are not dumb people they should have got it ...it was at their face the whole time ...but somehow they didnt understand it ....
Korbin and Rick: I live in NorCal (Bay Area) and I came across your channel as I have been home the last couple of weeks with not much to do in my off time. At first I didn't think much of your channel, but slowly I got hooked because I think you delve into details (especially, your movie reviews are very insightful). You guys are also very entertaining (with guessing games/food videos/music videos) and possibly have one of the most important attributes any actor should have: The ability to keep an audience engaged! There are a lot of people who criticise/troll people who have different opinions. But each individual is unique and should have an opinion (whether it differs from others - doesn't matter). I have seen a boat load of your videos and nothing that you said was insulting. I love the cheesiness :-). So please don't worry about trolls and hope you continue to be honest as well as express your real opinions in your reactions/reviews. That's what makes your channel unique and enjoyable! All the best! Hope we continue to get entertained by "OUR STUPID REACTIONS".
As a person sorrounded by mother, aunts, sisters, wife and daughters..... tears flow from eyes each time I watch this short film As a MALE, my head hangs in shame to read the statistics and digest the reality. For once, I found even KORBIN was intense while watching the story unfold and i feel he had no idea about the concluding part.
Korbin understood the plot very well enough. He laughed because the little girl ended the quarrel by just entering the room and everyone was silent and Regretting their thoughts of leaving this kiddo out. Korbin. Understood. The plot.
They were showing women who died after being raped. The last one was just a child. They were not alive but dead. That is why the old woman told the one studying, why are you studying when you can't even go for the exam.
I dont think you guys got to concept of this Short film, I see the guy on the right laughing when that lil girl came in, like what the hell. Dont they get it that she was raped they were all raped, and that girl being so young, it would break one's heart, while he is giggling.
Hey... No need to be so hypercritical. Things can sometimes be lost in translation. Or even in cultural and religious depictions. They did this reaction to educate themselves on something they do not know much about in case of India and we can be supportive of their efforts right? 🙂☺... No need to be so flabbergasted. I'm sure they'll learn it all when they read the comments 😊
Guys (people commenting/watching), Rick and Korbin understood they were dead. That they were in purgatory. They also understood another perspective that we hadn't thought about - a sister hood. It isn't a stupid reaction. This video (DEVI) is multi-faceted. They gained more perspectives than the just the obvious ones. I enjoyed your reaction Rick and Korbin. Thank you. Korbin seemed to get teary eyed there too (but I might be imagining). Respect the women in your lives. It means way more to the future generations and society than you can imagine.
It's not about being smarter. These guys really put in a lot of their time and efforts into educating themselves. And if u had been watching their videos for some time you, sir, would've known that. We can at least appreciate their efforts instead of straight away putting a label on anyone right? Let's spread love and understanding on this platform and not loose judgements😄
plz dont compare its not a good thing. Plus they know bout stuffs bcoz they reseach bout what they r reacting to. What matters is the effort they r putting. Even if they didnt get the meaning doesn't depict that they rnt smart. Every channel has its own charm and way of entertainment
Korbin understood the plot very well enough. He laughed because the little girl ended the quarrel by just entering the room and everyone was silent and Regretting their thoughts of leaving this kiddo out. Korbin. Understood. The plot. Do I understand?
Here’s a scary thought. A 32% conviction rate is high among the world’s nations. Pre-#MeeToo, all English speaking countries had a conviction rate that was lower than 10%. France, at that time had a rate of 25% and India 24.3%. It will interesting to see where those rates are now.
It is basically a purgatory. They were all raped AND murdered (they were discussing ways in which they were disposed of after the incident). They didn't wanna go out because going out meant rebirth and they didn't wanna be born again in the fear that they'll go through that again. The message is that the women here were of all ages, cast, status, religion, profession etc, and it showed that no one is safe.
The lady in burkha was burnt alive and she didn't had hair follicle yet she was waxing. Similarly the medical student was studying, kajol was praying. All were dead.
In India, the victim gets the highest backlash as compared to the rapist. People blame women's dress, independent mindset, education, nature. If the clothes were responsible for the rape, then the woman in the burqa would not be a victim. Had independent mindset been responsible for rape, uneducated domestic women would not have become victims. If the nature and way of talking were responsible then the deaf girl would not have become a victim. If going out was responsible, women wouldn't have raped by their own husbands in their own homes. Finally the entry of the little girl into the room is proof that even a small child is not as safe as a woman. We need to understand that nothing is responsible for rape except a rapist mindset.
Damn.. Both of you guys got it wrong for the first time (I guess) ever.. .. it was evident that you didn't get it since the bearded bastard was laughing at a serious and dark scene in the end😭😂😂.. It "is" a purgatory/hell. They are all "dead". Didn't the woman in Barkha say that she was burnt alive?? And everyone was discussing the ways they were killed- with a knife, strangling, hit by a stone etc. And you missed a detail (lost in translation not your fault guys) - when kajol asks them not to turn off their mood(ruin their mood) , the old woman laughs it off saying "everyone is off here". And the woman wasn't making fun when she said that the other one was showing off her thighs . It's symbolic that no woman is safe irrespective of age, class, wealth, religion, dressing sense whether fully covered or not.. etc.
Korbin understood the plot very well enough. He laughed because the little girl ended the quarrel by just entering the room and everyone was silent and Regretting their thoughts of leaving this kiddo out. Korbin. Understood. The plot. Do u understand?
This scene is of the collection of rape cases that are filed in Indian courts everyday. The "room" all these women are sitting in, is basically where all the files are locked away, seemingly for forever. These women watch the news all the time to see if there is any progress in any of their cases. They're all dead, just alive in the form of yet another file locked away in the court.
Korby knailed it when he said, the veiled woman looked down upon the one who wore a skirt. the metaphor was bang on, just that it's very men like idea that the metaphor stood for. Often a girl who mocks societal taboos is mistaken for inviting evil. There was a movie called Mirch Masala, in the mid 80s I guess, where a woman is teased, chased and finally, when she resorts to women for shelter, the women accuse her of being beautiful. To that, Sonbai, the protagonist raises her protest, questioning the women, the problem lies in my beauty, not his brains? Sadly, almost 35 yrs on, and nothing changed, nothing seems to be changing
Guys rick said it is metaphorical they got most of the point they didn't got that they were dead that most of the Indians didn't get that too so please chill
Kudos to you guys to have put the emotions and analysis into perfect words, on a film that put words metaphorically to convey emotions. Rick you are brilliant in your review. And Korbin got the right moment in the film wherevtge small girl his the most horrish woman in the room.
Another very clever short film about 17 mins I think called the school bag very moving powerful omg moment made me cry. Wow bollywood are producing material like this amazing. The relationship of a mother and a son will make your heart melt if your a parent you will feel this.
Two subtle messages were overlooked by most people 1, Bahar kan jayega means literally who is going to take rebirth as a baby girl child because they all were horrified with their past birth/death. No one wants to born again in the cruel world (2) the little girl straight went to the middle-aged lady signifying that they knew each other and perhaps the rapist who raped the middle-aged lady was still roaming free and his more recent victim was that young girl.
To add to the brilliant comments, more than any factual analysis and moral juicing, it is simply meant to strike horror in the hearts of people, to look at the age of the newcomer. I think most of us got by the middle that it's a purgatory, but what kind and how young for this crime in particular should shake one's humanity up. That, to me, was the aesthetic value of this movie more than anything.. And ofcourse, the message that economic status, religion, age, status, education, clothing, etc is no bar, as pointed out brilliantly by others.
Monsters spare no one. Be it someone wearing a Saree, Burkha, suit, or shorts. Be it educated or uneducated. Married or unmarried. Be it someone wrinkly, youthful or... even a child. Monsters spare no one.
I think the setting is of afterlife and it showcases women of all age, culture and type including autistic, child, own wife or family members etc etc. They also show different classes in different women. I guess they are all robbed of their chastity and then brutally murdered. Reminds me a lot of Yeats’ style I found Rick’s “purgatory” remark quite accurate. The women were quarreling on who was the most unfortunate among them and they are stunned to see what was coming soo after. (That is my understanding)
It's just not men doing to women. As Korbin rightly said it also shows how women were bickering on, judging each other... It happens everywhere and with everyone. What we need to realise is its time we put a stop to this not only with women but with everyone, it has to be stopped by not only men but by everyone. Looking down upon, disregarding someone's choices by belittling, dominating each other and above all being selfish or self centered... All mean the same... assaulting someone mentally. And more horrid is when you physically assault someone knowing they can't punch you back....
They were all murdered and this was the purgatory. And it showed that rape doesn't discriminate between class, religion, caste, age, etc cuz we see all types of women represented.The case from the TV that went bad, was of the little girl. Cuz she was the latest victim, and that's why the TV began working again after they let her in.
All of them were basically raped and murdered and living together in I guess a purgatory. They all tell each other how they were killed and at the end of the movie they see a young girl come in, indicating that she too has been raped and murdered therefore they're shocked and deeply saddened seeing that even a young child wasn't spared.
You need to watch it AGAIN... our STUPID reactors! Funfact- the girl who was drinking alcohol, the" thighs" girl is the legendary actor kamal hasan's daughter.
What other videos should we react to?
Virus malayalam movie
React to "yoon shabnami song" from the movie saawriya directed by Sanjay Leela bhansali.
Hj
Please listen to th-cam.com/video/nG6XkZNUGdU/w-d-xo.html this link... Mauli Mauli ... A marathi song... Pronunciation is maaoolee maaoolee... Means mother.... Here referred to god... Please react it's lovely song
Do react on "go corona go ft ramdas athavale "😅
I don't think you got gist of it. I showed that no woman is safe, regardless of her position, religion, social status, age. Even what she wears burqa,saree, western wear,literate,illetate, you see difference between each woman but all are united by the same crime committed against them.
Yes osr see this!
🙏
that's kinda what they said. in fact, they went deeper than most other reactions. It was an amazing and honest review. Basically what you've mentioned is what everyone gets from this, but what Korbin noticed is the fact that they used women to represent what men usually use as excuses for assaulting women. It wasn't as detailed a review; but their observation about the little one going to maushi was a good one!
@@aakarshaajitpandey4868 That it was but overall they were not as impacted by it as I thought they would be. Jaby got it fully well. It's in times like this that I wonder if Jaby's half-Asian roots help him with reacting the way we do. Anyway this was one of very few 'sort of fails' for OSR. No problem
@Z L you are the biggest hypocrite I have seen.
A really close friend of mine directed this Short Film! Thankyou for your insights guys
You're such a true artist Tushar.
If ur talking about niranjan... This whole premise was stolen from other short film
@@bharathsy which one?
I believe being stuck in that house stands for their case files being stuck in courts waiting for some justice.
No these were spirits. Leaving the room signified being born again as girl child. Having gone through previous life trauma they didn’t want to experience it ever again.
@@banke1a1 yes
When that little girl came my heart broke into almost a billion pieces
Even 2yrs,,,,, is raped😢😢😢😢
And now a days 4 months baby girls are also not safe...
where my eyes just can't hold tears!
Same here
Same here and the guy who was reactiang was laughing
They r not only left, all of them r dead, they were killed.
They got lost in translation, people knowing hindi can understand easyly, hard for people reading sub
@@suvendum.p.7715 exactly
The burkha lady was burnt, hence no hair when she waxed. Has a lot of detail.
I don't think that's the case. Otherwise her body should be burnt. I think waxing shows that she is just like any other woman. Like others she waxes, makeup etc. It's for breaking stereotype of burka wearing women.
@@rajoberoi2559 good insight
@@rajoberoi2559 No that's just symbolic. You don't need to show every thing that happened.
@@rajoberoi2559 Although yours is more logical, I think Sanjana's comment makes more sense because in the film the ladies revealed how they were killed. Some were stabbed, crushed by rock, etc...but none of those injuries were visible, if I'm correct. That's why the woman in the Burkha didn't look burnt as her burn injuries were also not showing
There is a lot of detail all over. Waxing one has probably been described aptly by Raj. The detail of the multiple ages and walks of life and type of clothing etc shows rape happens no matter what you wear or live life like or do in life or how old you are . Rape therefore has nothing to do with a woman's character.
The house is a metaphorical representation of the afterlife. All the members of the house were not only victims of the heinous act of raping but also they were murdered after they were raped. The latest member to have arrived is that little girl, who was also a victim of the same fate. The quotation from Maushi about how Arzu, the woman in Burkha (the one with the wax strip) was burnt alive, how Shruti Haasan was killed with a bottle of beer and thrown in the highway, how Neha Dhupia passed away due to the trauma that she couldn't take any further, how Kajol's throat was cut off and other details by other ladies stand as evidence to the fact that they were not only raped, but also murdered. What kicks the most is that even in the afterlife they are cornered away.
I don't think you understood it. They are all dead. Killed in various ways.. the point was that age religion class does not matter..
You guys missed the point totally. I beleive the comments down below would clear things out. But it was way too dark and I beleive thar got lost in translation.
How come they are the only ones who get lost in translation always ?
They are all dead. All the women forced to live in a room symbolises that they are waiting for justice. You guys didn’t get it I guess.
One thing I noticed and loved in this film is the mention of mental trauma. That true, its as same as a physical assault.
It' hell. All of them were raped and killed/died. going outside means re-birth. Which no one of them wants. It's hell and they all have problem with it but they prefers that more than human world.
Why the victims will go to hell?? It is the tyrants and oppressors who will go to hell. Purgatory is the time period where souls will stay till judgement day, according to christians n islamic beliefs. Islam called this state as "Barzakh". In barzakh or purgatory, one soul bear the burden of his bad deeds, or gets the comfort of good deeds. In this video it is something like purgatory, a waiting room because reincarnation is a hindu belief.
Why would the victims be in hell, you nimrod ..
@@florad629 You are correct
Hell....??? WTF...????
You were right in saying it was purgatory. These women are here, not wanting to be reborn hence not going back to the "demons" out there.
they are all dead and their souls living together somewhere. when another one dies, tv goes off. they were all raped and murdered including minor. get it ?
Little details from it--
They all are dead and are assembled at one place after death, what we call afterlife
When news repoter says that whole country is filled with rage, neha turns her face and closes her eyes.. As she knows that it is all useless, people forget everything with time, candle marches, etc are just for a time period, after that even justice is not served in brutal cases.
The tv goes off and pee sound produced signifying that another victim has died and needs to be occupied in this house ..
Kajol said that according to reports ' hr din koi nyi ladki aayegi, kitno ko bahar rkhrnge.. 'That signifies how frequently rapes occur.
That medical student signifies nirbhaya, and she is preparing for an exam which she will never give as she is dead(and her dreams too)
When kajol says that don't fight after dhupbatti and maushi says there is no God here, why you are worshipping then.
Arzu says nobody asked them to to stay here together, ' bhed bakriyo ki trh thuns diya.. They were raped, and killed, no consent nothing.
I literally had tears when they told their stories.. That how they were raped.. Even marital rape as maushi was married when she was 12 years old.
When neha said she died in trauma of rape, and maushi said you at least got time to cry, then she says that.. If I didn't bleed that doesn't means I was not in pain.. That signifies how traumatic it can be.
Kajol in end says that we were adjusting in between those demons, it's easier to stay in this afterlife than that..
When the small girl entered, each one of them was shocked as they were not able to believe that situation is so worse now, that even a little girl was not spared from those demons, they also felt guilty that how they were fighting to send the girl away, without knowing that she is so small.
Someone is deaf, someone is wearing shorts, someone is in burqa and saree, some are educated, some are illiterate, all from different religions,
Rape is irrespective of these things
Beautifully explained in easy language for anybody else who got confused with the theme for any reason. Wonderful!..Thanks :)
Rapes are a serious topic in India, but politicians and media are not active currently
Finally, the name is justified.....Our Stupid Reactions
Dumbass reaction
I don’t know why the Indians insist on asking these Americans to react to local Indian social issues? It is impossible to understand them because their lives are completely different from the Indians, the life of freedom is not the same as the life of social values, they are doing this because the TH-cam that pays them money and in fact they do not care about anything else
@@itslove7105 im not indian and i got the message that they all were dead
The concept of rebirth is indian..we can not expect them to get it.
That's harsh , okay really harsh if u want to use such type of words , that they are stupid then let me tell u one thing smart pants , you are stupid . They speak what they get , and u got no right to speak about them like that . If u didn't like their reaction then go dont watch the video hipocrat. 1st u r watching the video and then saying stupid things about them . How stupid u r .
They were telling the ways that how were they first raped and killed
And yes Rick it was a purgatory
😣
Also, no its not metaphor, they are all dead! they were all victims. This is them telling their story about how the world is cruel, that they didnt even spare a little girl.
Don't expect the reaction you WANT... it's their reaction... people here be like react like this and that...they shared what they got from what they saw...
He decided to giggle when the little girl was shown... THAT is what he got from the film until that point!!! WOW...
I think the little girl is the granddaughter of the older woman .. which makes it all the more heart wrenching. That's why she went to the woman she recognized and that's what made the old woman hurt so bad ...
That poor little girl, my heart just shattered. 😢 Few days ago my friend was telling me about his 6 month's old patient, her parents used to leave her with her grandfather and after few days she had a chest conjunction and after the tests they found semen in her . Yeah it was grandfather.
you guys really didnt understand this story .... was disappointed throughout ... may be watch it again guys :/ just to understand the power of this story after reading the comments
They got lost in translation, people knowing hindi can understand easyly, hard for people reading sub
@@suvendum.p.7715 hard but not impossible and they are not dumb people they should have got it ...it was at their face the whole time ...but somehow they didnt understand it ....
@@suvendum.p.7715 i even don't know hindi.. But i understand it in a few minutes by there dialogue.
Well, May be they are distracted by something. These are bad times in USA and all over. I think they will realise their mistake from comments
@@suvendum.p.7715 I disagree... Korbin laughed when the little girl was shown. By then a chair would have known what it meant.
Rick gave the Bugs bunny with the carrot ending that said "Thats all folks".
Nostalgic! Huh!
Yeah its a purgatory......sad stories and sad ending 😔😔
Korbin and Rick: I live in NorCal (Bay Area) and I came across your channel as I have been home the last couple of weeks with not much to do in my off time. At first I didn't think much of your channel, but slowly I got hooked because I think you delve into details (especially, your movie reviews are very insightful). You guys are also very entertaining (with guessing games/food videos/music videos) and possibly have one of the most important attributes any actor should have: The ability to keep an audience engaged!
There are a lot of people who criticise/troll people who have different opinions. But each individual is unique and should have an opinion (whether it differs from others - doesn't matter). I have seen a boat load of your videos and nothing that you said was insulting. I love the cheesiness :-). So please don't worry about trolls and hope you continue to be honest as well as express your real opinions in your reactions/reviews. That's what makes your channel unique and enjoyable! All the best! Hope we continue to get entertained by "OUR STUPID REACTIONS".
My journey of osr is same.....
Welcome to Our Stupid Family!
RS & KM --- ditto --- except that I am from India
As a person sorrounded by mother, aunts, sisters, wife and daughters..... tears flow from eyes each time I watch this short film
As a MALE, my head hangs in shame to read the statistics and digest the reality.
For once, I found even KORBIN was intense while watching the story unfold and i feel he had no idea about the concluding part.
Korbin understood the plot very well enough. He laughed because the little girl ended the quarrel by just entering the room and everyone was silent and Regretting their thoughts of leaving this kiddo out.
Korbin. Understood. The plot.
They were showing women who died after being raped. The last one was just a child. They were not alive but dead. That is why the old woman told the one studying, why are you studying when you can't even go for the exam.
So happy to be getting new reactions , thank you!!!
I was waiting for this reaction. Really emotional ... it makes me cry
Girl child comes in room ......
EVERYONE : Ohhhhwwww....🙁😱
Korbin miles : smiles😁
He smiled because he didn't understand the plot
Dafuq!
Was it only me who understood that Korbin smiled cause he didnt wanna show the surge of pain he was going through inside!
That's when I realised that he didn't understand what's going on
@aishwarya eashwar f
EXACTLY... I was horrified at that... He actually not only smiled... he giggled a little bit... Really living up to the name of the channel.
I cried when the little girl came to the scene.....
Lol looks like karma gets Rick and Korbin @3:58 for yelling at us headphone users xD
Yaasss... Finally you guys reacted on Devi...
To let you know, I cried my eyes out when I watched this and have been waiting to see your reactions..
I was eagerly waiting for this🤞🏻
I dont think you guys got to concept of this Short film, I see the guy on the right laughing when that lil girl came in, like what the hell. Dont they get it that she was raped they were all raped, and that girl being so young, it would break one's heart, while he is giggling.
I think bohot logo ko thandak mil gayi hogi.. kitne time se Devi devi ki rat lagaye hue the..react karne ke liye 😂😂
But they are all dead, didn't they
Was waiting for you to react to this for a long time!! ❤️❤️ Thank you!
Unfortunately they missed the point by a mile.
@@sunbong_rulez yup so true. I was underwhelmed for the 1st time with their reaction ... 😢
Oh my god, you guys just totally missed it, so badly, m still surprised how can you, #disspointing
Hey... No need to be so hypercritical. Things can sometimes be lost in translation. Or even in cultural and religious depictions. They did this reaction to educate themselves on something they do not know much about in case of India and we can be supportive of their efforts right? 🙂☺... No need to be so flabbergasted. I'm sure they'll learn it all when they read the comments 😊
Oh Thank God.. The wait is finally over... ❤️❤️
Guys (people commenting/watching), Rick and Korbin understood they were dead. That they were in purgatory. They also understood another perspective that we hadn't thought about - a sister hood. It isn't a stupid reaction. This video (DEVI) is multi-faceted. They gained more perspectives than the just the obvious ones.
I enjoyed your reaction Rick and Korbin. Thank you. Korbin seemed to get teary eyed there too (but I might be imagining).
Respect the women in your lives. It means way more to the future generations and society than you can imagine.
Finally thank you for watching it... ❤️❤️❤️
Hey guys..... Doing great work... Take care guys ❤️
Left me speechless
And that's why Jaby's channel is better !!
I was waiting for you guys to review on this one ... I have no words for this video....
Now I know jaby koay is more smarter TH-cam reactor. Jaby understood and osr didn’t
He is been reacting for 4 to 5 years indian content.
Achara gets everything and Jaby is learning from her.
It's not about being smarter. These guys really put in a lot of their time and efforts into educating themselves.
And if u had been watching their videos for some time you, sir, would've known that. We can at least appreciate their efforts instead of straight away putting a label on anyone right? Let's spread love and understanding on this platform and not loose judgements😄
plz dont compare its not a good thing. Plus they know bout stuffs bcoz they reseach bout what they r reacting to. What matters is the effort they r putting. Even if they didnt get the meaning doesn't depict that they rnt smart. Every channel has its own charm and way of entertainment
You missed the point completely 🤦♀️
Today's reaction was Truly stupid. ..both missed the point totally
They are all dead. That’s why Maushi said nobody else got the time to cry 😢
Also .. none of them charged a penny for this..
Omg you finally did it....😃
What kind of reaction was that at 11:46
Korbin understood the plot very well enough. He laughed because the little girl ended the quarrel by just entering the room and everyone was silent and Regretting their thoughts of leaving this kiddo out.
Korbin. Understood. The plot.
Do I understand?
2:25 COUPLE GOALS 😂😂😂
Finally.........was waiting for u guys to react..... I haven't watched yet
Here’s a scary thought. A 32% conviction rate is high among the world’s nations. Pre-#MeeToo, all English speaking countries had a conviction rate that was lower than 10%. France, at that time had a rate of 25% and India 24.3%. It will interesting to see where those rates are now.
oof this hit right home when the little girl came in
O my god how can you not get it. 😂
Each time I see this video I can't handle my tears 💔💔🥺
India women's are now leading the world we all indians support them because of women's india is independent
It is basically a purgatory. They were all raped AND murdered (they were discussing ways in which they were disposed of after the incident). They didn't wanna go out because going out meant rebirth and they didn't wanna be born again in the fear that they'll go through that again. The message is that the women here were of all ages, cast, status, religion, profession etc, and it showed that no one is safe.
I saw it again with you.. But still made me cry.. It is too powerful..
Wow! Thank you guys I requested it few times. I want you guys come together asap
I don't think the hell and re-birth analogy is correct...
There all are there waiting for the justice like pending files...
Kajol is such a amazing actress.. I mean her eyes emote much more than dialogues .. such a powerful face
They are all dead and in some imaginary space supporting each other
The lady in burkha was burnt alive and she didn't had hair follicle yet she was waxing. Similarly the medical student was studying, kajol was praying. All were dead.
Why were they doing that?
In India, the victim gets the highest backlash as compared to the rapist. People blame women's dress, independent mindset, education, nature.
If the clothes were responsible for the rape, then the woman in the burqa would not be a victim.
Had independent mindset been responsible for rape, uneducated domestic women would not have become victims.
If the nature and way of talking were responsible then the deaf girl would not have become a victim.
If going out was responsible, women wouldn't have raped by their own husbands in their own homes.
Finally the entry of the little girl into the room is proof that even a small child is not as safe as a woman.
We need to understand that nothing is responsible for rape except a rapist mindset.
Yes indeed it is a purgatory
Noooo you got it all wrong !! Didn't expect that from you guys
Damn.. Both of you guys got it wrong for the first time (I guess) ever.. .. it was evident that you didn't get it since the bearded bastard was laughing at a serious and dark scene in the end😭😂😂.. It "is" a purgatory/hell. They are all "dead". Didn't the woman in Barkha say that she was burnt alive?? And everyone was discussing the ways they were killed- with a knife, strangling, hit by a stone etc. And you missed a detail (lost in translation not your fault guys) - when kajol asks them not to turn off their mood(ruin their mood) , the old woman laughs it off saying "everyone is off here". And the woman wasn't making fun when she said that the other one was showing off her thighs . It's symbolic that no woman is safe irrespective of age, class, wealth, religion, dressing sense whether fully covered or not.. etc.
Your name is tatti kota? 😂😂
Korbin understood the plot very well enough. He laughed because the little girl ended the quarrel by just entering the room and everyone was silent and Regretting their thoughts of leaving this kiddo out.
Korbin. Understood. The plot.
Do u understand?
*Finally a meaningful video*
This scene is of the collection of rape cases that are filed in Indian courts everyday. The "room" all these women are sitting in, is basically where all the files are locked away, seemingly for forever. These women watch the news all the time to see if there is any progress in any of their cases. They're all dead, just alive in the form of yet another file locked away in the court.
Korby knailed it when he said, the veiled woman looked down upon the one who wore a skirt. the metaphor was bang on, just that it's very men like idea that the metaphor stood for. Often a girl who mocks societal taboos is mistaken for inviting evil. There was a movie called Mirch Masala, in the mid 80s I guess, where a woman is teased, chased and finally, when she resorts to women for shelter, the women accuse her of being beautiful. To that, Sonbai, the protagonist raises her protest, questioning the women, the problem lies in my beauty, not his brains? Sadly, almost 35 yrs on, and nothing changed, nothing seems to be changing
Guys rick said it is metaphorical they got most of the point they didn't got that they were dead that most of the Indians didn't get that too so please chill
Kudos to you guys to have put the emotions and analysis into perfect words, on a film that put words metaphorically to convey emotions. Rick you are brilliant in your review. And Korbin got the right moment in the film wherevtge small girl his the most horrish woman in the room.
Thanks for reacting to this. I was hoping that you will react to this and you guys did!!❣️❣️💜
It’s a purgatory and they all were raped and killed ... it’s one of the most powerful short story from India
Another very clever short film about 17 mins I think called the school bag very moving powerful omg moment made me cry. Wow bollywood are producing material like this amazing. The relationship of a mother and a son will make your heart melt if your a parent you will feel this.
They all are discussing this in their afterlife. They are not alive anymore.
Two subtle messages were overlooked by most people 1, Bahar kan jayega
means literally who is going to take rebirth as a baby girl child
because they all were horrified with their past birth/death. No one
wants to born again in the cruel world (2) the little girl straight went
to the middle-aged lady signifying that they knew each other and
perhaps the rapist who raped the middle-aged lady was still roaming free
and his more recent victim was that young girl.
I think u guys should react to Kajol’s songs nd her acting. She’s better than ur fav heroines.. 😂😀
First time Korbin didn't look away during a video. I think his eyes were a bit teary I thought, at the moment the little girl showed up. 11:43
Umm no he actually giggled when the little girl entered... the guy was completely clueless
To add to the brilliant comments, more than any factual analysis and moral juicing, it is simply meant to strike horror in the hearts of people, to look at the age of the newcomer. I think most of us got by the middle that it's a purgatory, but what kind and how young for this crime in particular should shake one's humanity up. That, to me, was the aesthetic value of this movie more than anything.. And ofcourse, the message that economic status, religion, age, status, education, clothing, etc is no bar, as pointed out brilliantly by others.
It's PURGATORY guys.
Mukta barve..the lady in burqua and neena kulkarni the elderly angry lady..are the natural actresses of Marathi film industry
Monsters spare no one. Be it someone wearing a Saree, Burkha, suit, or shorts. Be it educated or uneducated. Married or unmarried. Be it someone wrinkly, youthful or... even a child. Monsters spare no one.
I think the setting is of afterlife and it showcases women of all age, culture and type including autistic, child, own wife or family members etc etc. They also show different classes in different women. I guess they are all robbed of their chastity and then brutally murdered. Reminds me a lot of Yeats’ style I found Rick’s “purgatory” remark quite accurate. The women were quarreling on who was the most unfortunate among them and they are stunned to see what was coming soo after. (That is my understanding)
Welcome to the other side of India !! 🙁🙁
Finally they reacted
It's just not men doing to women. As Korbin rightly said it also shows how women were bickering on, judging each other... It happens everywhere and with everyone. What we need to realise is its time we put a stop to this not only with women but with everyone, it has to be stopped by not only men but by everyone. Looking down upon, disregarding someone's choices by belittling, dominating each other and above all being selfish or self centered... All mean the same... assaulting someone mentally. And more horrid is when you physically assault someone knowing they can't punch you back....
They were all murdered and this was the purgatory. And it showed that rape doesn't discriminate between class, religion, caste, age, etc cuz we see all types of women represented.The case from the TV that went bad, was of the little girl. Cuz she was the latest victim, and that's why the TV began working again after they let her in.
Korbin... DID you actually GIGGLE when the little girl was shown in the end? Were you drunk while doing this reaction?
It's about a cell in the purgatory.
All of them were basically raped and murdered and living together in I guess a purgatory. They all tell each other how they were killed and at the end of the movie they see a young girl come in, indicating that she too has been raped and murdered therefore they're shocked and deeply saddened seeing that even a young child wasn't spared.
Everybody: You missed the point completely.
Me: Oh god. Everybody. They clearly did.
Was hoping in the end you guys would read the synopsis to get the story of this short film, maybe a rewatch would make more sense!
You need to watch it AGAIN... our STUPID reactors! Funfact- the girl who was drinking alcohol, the" thighs" girl is the legendary actor kamal hasan's daughter.