The Absurd Story Behind Black Clover's Animation
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 31 มี.ค. 2023
- Tl;dw - Yoshihara goat...
Background music used covers by mattyyyM - / mattyyym
Follow my Instagram - / kannas_ricebowl
Follow my Twitter - / kannas_ricebowl
Check out my animation channel - / @tryingsakuga7339
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research.
#blackclover #blackclovermovie #pierrot #astavsdante - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
One thing that I find funny and heartwarming about Black Clover is that if you go to twitter you will see that there's a lot of fans that are aware of BC production issues and because of that a lot of BC fans on twitter end up respecting the fuck out their series staff member(rightfully so), to the point they won't tolerate any type of uneducated slender towards the staff, especially towards the animators
Exactly- people don’t realize how screwed the animators were with what they were given, because the studio straight up didn’t care and invested too much time over Boruto fillers. The black clover anime May have some rough animation edges- but there are a ton of gems within it, and for that, we can only be grateful and continue to support the series
@@Josh-md1bc Yeah it’s all we can do. I think the only way is if BC gets more attention to ANY studio taking the role of Animating BC. It’s sad but The main guy carried the Whole show And ILL RESPECT HIM EVER FOR MAKING THE BEST ANIME EVER FOR MY LIFE. I honestly couldn’t survive if it wasn’t for Black clover
Its fact bro, Thanks to this team regardless of the quality I feel in love with BC, mad respect to them
Most fans of bc I meet in internet are 11-13 yo who think this is the best show bcs they don't know better and will argue with you even if you explain why bc isn't really that good.
It's funny bcs I loved BC at the beggining and had high expectations but it kept getting worse and worse (technical/animation issues) and repeating schemes
@@mariokempes9517 so you don’t like for the Animation?
There are some genuinely amazing animated fights though. That magic captains tournament fight was soo good.
Yoshihara and his little team are the goats🐐
Bruh
@@fanbasek2023p he is right. There were times that an episode had a better schedule. So they can Show off at times for those episodes
I skipped it considering it a filler😂
I know right, even when they were just speaking the animation was amazing
yoshihara loved bc and he pulled so much weight for the show. it’s sad that pierrot left the show to die but regardless of that black clover still has a strong fanbase
I will be coming back likely next year
Oh god,I knew that Black Clover was a production mess,but holy fuck it's beyond that 💀
I never heard a series director doing In- betweening for this many episodes consecutively,it's sad how they were handling the production on scarps leftover by Studio.
What can I conclude after watching this video? Yoshihara is a Goat 🗿
Dude even sacrificed his CSM role just to get some time to work on his favourite child the BC movie💀💀
@@userK894 Fr 💀
Still bro the thing is who tf will work on BC if Yoshihara is absent??
There is no AniP for this show what can we expect,so just let him complete this movie and I don't even know if they're going to continue the show anymore 💀
@@harman4321 yoshihara will always be there with BC franchise unless pierrot didn't want to continue with it ig it will depend how well the movie will do
@@harman4321 there is still no Animation producer for this Show? 💀
@@user-og6pb6dd5p tatsuya yotshihara is my favorite producer frfr
Even if the animation was a mess most of times , the story carried it 🔥
I feel like the tough production gave Black Clover it’s charm while it was airing. Never seen a community more positive and grateful than BC’s.
Tatsuya Yoshihara is the goat all black clover fans owe him a big one🛐
Literally all BC fans call him as GOAT lol
@@hashshashiinme7656yeah The ones who has at least some Knowledge or know the director or The staff. Some people just hate on the staff which is ridicilous, (lazy animators), (low budget) and all of these bullshits
@@user-og6pb6dd5p yea true but when it comes to yoshihara himself i think all the fans praise him a lot as far as i know
yes the quality of the animation was.... questionable to say the least, but black clover's animation also feels unique and it sets it apart from the rest. its also really nostalgic if u go back to rewatch the series. tbh im glad it turned out this way
I remember people question why tatsuya yotshihara didn't involve more in chainsaw man. Every time people ask that question i just say "black clover"
big respect to the black clover staff that actually wanted to make it good especially the director that called ppl to help
For me, Black Clover was so good that i barely even noticed any of the Unique animated moments, but for the scenes i did notice some "bad" animation, it didn't bother me much, i still thought the episode was pure peak (or almost peak, more leaning on the pure peak side for me), and now figuring out more of the "bad" animation i didn't notice when watching it for the first time, it really made and makes me realize even more of how much i enjoyed and enjoy it, and how much a story or a thing in general could be a master piece for someone, idk what did, but i remember being on crunchy roll, and then looking at Black Clover, and being like "Yeah why not" or something similar, idek if it was a anime I've been meaning to get into for a bit at the time, but the second i started watching it, my whole world changed, and i felt a magnitude i never felt betore, along with how happy i felt when watching something, specifically an anime i think. Almost everyday and night i could, i watched it, even in school for the few minutes i had, when i went camping, and around the night all the way till 4am or higher, god the Elf arc is something else, pure hype each episode, and even the fillers are amazing, i was getting excited a few minutes ago when typing this too! Black Clover is definitely the best anime of 2022 for me, and the 1st or 2nd best for me, when it comes to shonen, definitely the best for me, it has that magnitude that other shonens don't, sure back then, i was pretty interested in JJK or MHA at the time, but Black Clover is built different, Asta is the first character I cosplayed, i got his demon slayer sword, a mask, his wig for the cosplay, a black bulls pajama, and ik more is yet to come. When it comes to the 1st spot, there is an anime that really drawed me in, but when i was younger, so it also has a special place in my heart, but Black Clover might be in the #1 spot for me in general, and i feel like shouldn't even say "might" since it's that great. When finding some "bad" animated moments, it really makes me respect the anime more, and Yuki Tabata.
And once again I am given yet another reason why this is my favorite anime adaptation of all time.
I don't think any adaptation of a manga will ever surpass Black Clover in how symbolically tied into the series its production, reception, and development were. On all fronts, the music, the animators, and the anime itself overcame the FUCKING RIDICULOUS AMOUNT of obstacles in their way. They surpassed their limits.
If you think black clover anime has rhe best adaptation of a manga i highly recommend you watch mob psycho
surpassed shit that is
@@nubzt I don't think it's the best, as the quality is objectively bad and the art style is inaccurate to the manga at times. But I do know that it's my favorite.
@@davizi6146then it is your favourite anime. I would go on to say it's adaptation is actually pretty bad
@@apoorvverma602 How in the name of the Lord is Black Clover's adaptation bad?
Also, Black Clover being my favorite anime adaptation doesn't mean it's my favorite anime. Not every anime is an adaptation and not every anime adaptation is loved for how it adapts.
Ep 63 is definitely memorable you can say that much.
It doesn't look good, but at the same time it's so unique you really feel like insane talents had only an hour to make an episode and that was the result.
We'll probably never see anything like it ever again.
"We'll probably never see anything like it ever again."
Well Jujutsu Kaisen season 2 episode 17 says otherwise
@@Jay-ll2qe Never underestimate how shitty anime productions can be I guess.
black clover deserves more love tbh
Tbh if it had demon slayer animation it wouldget a lot less hate
@@cyberraptor9836 that wouldn't work at all though
Black Clover isn't really a seasonal like Demon Slayer
They even delayed the movie by 3 months 💀
Yes but It looks good
Good honestly. More time hopefully
@@fqeagles21 your sure about that? Just looks like a average anime show production to me, don't even get me started on the CGI. Unless they released a new trailer I haven't seen.
@@gibbsduhem1066 looks better than the series not A level though
@@fqeagles21 alright fare point, can't argue there.
Black clover was just done dirty for no reason at all 💀
Ikr it one of the best I seen
That moment when Studio Pierrot was putting more effort into Boruto filler than it did for actual Black Clover material. You had manga readers pissed off at how the anime was treated, some of which actually learning how to animate just so they can join the team to make it look better in eventual episodes, some of which involved in the Asta & Yami vs Dante fight.
My Question is Why Did Studio Pierrot Agree to Make this, EVEN Though they didn’t care, There a lot of series where they generally cared... yet for black clover, the heart is not there. This is one anime where I say THIS Needs A Reboot, Like A Reboot where the Animation is Done in house and The Animation Studio Genuinely Cares.
Trigun Stamepede is in its final arc and the quality of the CGI was breathtaking. You should do an analysis on that
Is it weird that I appreciate those weirdly animated fight scenes from anime? To me as long as the fight scene flow and remain consistent then it’s fine. The pain and Naruto fight to me felt fluid
I'm surprised Black clover animation didn't end up like 7ds s3.
You could say that the Director Surpassed Their Limits 🎉
This was one of the only animes that continued airing during the beginning of covid shut downs and through to the end of a lot of them including japans
The series director deserves at lot of props for trying to manage the anime's production to keep it from completely falling apart.
Thanks for the animation analysis! The moment I watched this episode, I was like, "WTF is this?" and I don't mean it in a good way. I searched in reddit what other people's are saying, and it was like a 50/50 split. The ones saying it was good but with a special style in it and the other ones that said it looked straight up bad. I agree on the CG-Backgrounds and the 3DCG in general. It was not good at all. But I must say that a lot of episodes catched me and were good.
How about you make an animation breakdown of the Fate/stay night Heavens Feel movies? I would love to see this a lot. My most favorite movies ever. Thank you for the video like always. ;)
I think if BC come back in TV series,it depend on how people react to the movie. In Jump magazines The ToC chart is so low and manga book selling is not good too. Is there a possibility that the studio won't continue due to the bad trend? and focus on other anime series?
When neflix Japan release bc anime it's actually top 10 on Japan lmao and let me say this to don't mean much at all BC still gonna sell 200k maximum 2 month bc just suffering from shit schedule and animation plus Early ASTA VA also with neflix actually they got money from it too so we better watch it
Series within jump itself let alone outside of jump that sell far less than BC are being animated. BC is more than safe lol, it’s just a matter of when it will return
@@plumedeneko 2024 or 2025
Could you make an animation breakdown video for vinland saga season 2 once it ends? Doesn't really have too many sakuga-like moments but the overall consistent animation/visuals are phenomenal
I don't know...there really isn't all that much to talk about, let's at wait for it to end first lmao
@@ProbablyPretentious talk about witch from mercury when its s2 comes out
Just like first season but with better consistency and compositing and use of colors as i heard and non of those god awful CGI models
I hope they can have some nice sakuga somewhere
@@tnl-warrior3218 i think it will definitely. But The art work is so damn Strong that it's hard but they have a very good production schedule
best new gen. easily the most fun ive had watching any show.
MY FAVORITE INDIAN DROPPED LFG
😭🙌
I don't get why people so many people seem to shit on this episode, it's wierd, yes, but like you said it is one of the most interesting visuals ever, and god I honestly love this episode, it constantly feels like the characters are on the verge of exploding into a speed blitz of incomprehensible mass and I'm constantly on the edge of my seat while watching, did this episode have flaws? Yes. And even though later on in the yami and asta vs dante fight was more well animated (along with a few other episodes) this episode is just so interesting to watch that it holds a place in my heart as one of the most visually stunning pieces I've ever seen because no, it isn't art, it's animation, in its purest form and it is beautiful, thank you for reading this rant if you read it... to whoever is reading this, you're cool :)
Thanks for the video dude, i never knew black clover anime production was this messed up. Man knowing this makes me appreciate Tatsuya Yoshihara and everyone that involves with the anime production even more
another day another great video
Great video as always, can you make an animation breakdown of Garden of Words.
Great video as always would love to see you talk about One Piece's Wano animation and how it became so good you don't have to listen to me of course if you don't want to that ok keep making these great videos.
Honestly there were so many amazingly animated fights that after finishing watching all the current episodes I don't care about those episodes with awfuly low level of animation. Inconsistancy is very noticable, but It's one of those traits that establishes the show and makes it interesting and more hype because you can see how much things improved
Hell's paradise was released yesterday. It's looks amazing, exept bluring. Can't wait for your review!
It has a bad schedule looks like. But overall it will look decent. Also the compositing is not bad as some of people (Mappa haters) says. It dosen't Hide the details like in AOT part 1 (for the Most part) and makes the Eye details to look good. But it relies on one color. But it's not bad at all, exept when it's bluring at times
@deeznut4775 you love to say bullshits huh? I'm explaining the production. How tf did i ruin the experience for this dude bruh 💀?
Love your way of explaining ❤
good video, they just need to actually support it when it hopefully comes back next year(spring/autumn) and it can be very very good, the upcoming arc on the anime will be good so the animation needs to be consistent enough , easy as that
Black Clover did have an animation producer, two actually (Maiko Isogai & Naomi Komatsu), they're just not credited as such for some reason but as Producer, they were working on Twin Star Exorcists before and you can notice that some of their connections were on Black Clover (Itsuko Takeda, Mifumi Tomita, Studio Cosmos...)
I guess you got confused with the Production Desk role which was absent for ~20 episodes, although it was a major role too
Also, the animators from TRIGGER (Ikarashi, Kato, Sannomiya...) on episode 63 were brought thanks to Yusuke Kawakami who was working on SSSS.Gridman at this time, not Yoshihara directly or the PAs
Nice video though!
I believe both of them were production assistants who filled in the role of an animation producer (which is why I mentioned the juggling production assistants) as for the role itself, ANN's credits are all over the place, but Kvin mentioned the lack of an animation producer in a sakugablog article, and I'd imagine he knows what he's talking about. And finally yes, Ikarashi came in as a part of that trigger pipeline thanks to Kawakami, but my statement was more general, it wasn't just about him, but rather it was about any big name that showed up throughout the series, as well as the younger webgen guys
@@ProbablyPretentious Maybe not production assistant but yeah, kViN is correct but saying that Black Clover doesn't have an animation producer without elaborating is a bit misleading imo, it kinda sounds like no one is doing the role while we can clearly see that Maiko Isogai and Naomi Komatsu act as such as even the main staff has their connections (Itsuko Takeda, Kosei Takahashi, Yuki Maeda, Hajime Takakuwa...) and almost all the outsourcing studios were from TSE
But it's just nitpicking honestly!
Great video as usual man❤️. Yoshihara is The Goat. Also 3:55 where do you can find these informations?
Anime news network is always a reliable source, that's what I used for the most part
@@ProbablyPretentious thanks man
Well.. awesome video as always
Also, can we expect a video on Vinland saga s2, campfire cooking,slime isekai or your thoughts on spy family as an overall finished product ✨✨
Both VS and tondemo skill (isekai Show) had good to very good production schedules as i heard
@@user-og6pb6dd5p as far as I have heard campfire cooking was like chainsaw man no production committee involved so we can say it is a passion project and if it goes fine then mappa could make a way to completely remove or be the biggest component in production committee and they will earn more profit and will be able to take time they want 🥹
@@gamerboyrax2222yeah i still have my doubts on CSM as (yname) explained some of the things for me. But yeah, it's a Really great thing for any studio to lean away from production committees that ruining the anime industry. They can make a lot more money for themselves and make more sub-studios, and hopefully when they have enough Resources and people, they don't need to make more than they can (although they can handle but with bad schedules at times). And makes their show very profitable (which is The safest and the best direction for every studio). And i hope that's the direction of manabu (Mappa CEO) for mappa (and i think it is) But nowdays they have great schedules too
@@gamerboyrax2222yeah they don't need to have stress to make more shows than they can (although already they are much more stable than a lot of studios). But yeah that's the best path for every studio and manabu (Mappa CEO) seems to go in that direction
I loved the animation for episode 63 idk why but all the flashing and they way the move is so cool to me
I wonder how popular black clover would be if ufotable decided to take over
They don't do long running animes tho. they don't have The staff for that
@@user-og6pb6dd5p who said black clover had to be long running
7:22 and his mother??
Yes, he mentioned it in a tweet, his mother helped out with the colouring
@@ProbablyPretentious that's pretty cool ngl
woahh nice video, btw, where do you get these informations ? I also wanna know more about this
Sakugablog I think
Hope views will keep on that level. Wish you and your channel grow
Please make video about
The top production issues in anime industry such as black clover, wonder egg priority, jujutsu kaisen season 2
I love your videos
i literally just watched the latest video right before it got taken down
I was watching it at 1:06 AM and I accidentally clicked off. I immediately clicked back on but then it was claimed. Bruh
I hope the movie does well and we eventually see a 'black clover brotherhood' or 'black clover kai' type redo that gives the series the quality it deserves.
With A Staff that Genuinely Care and Actual Care And Communication Between The Studio.
it definetly did.
@@reverseshinwell the original staff did care about the show.
And yet, I still love it.
Where would you rank studio pierrot as a anime studio and i feel like you could make a 1 hour video just talking about the black clover anime
I can't wait for you to make a video about the absurd story behind Jujutsu Kaisen season 2's animation after the season ends.
You should do a video on Studio Bind and Mushoku Tensei. It has great animation, especially for it being the first anime of the studio. Why was this? Are there certain well known veterans involved or has this talent just popped out of nowhere?
Black clover had insanely good story which stood out from others but the animation became the very reason it didn't reach the fame mha and jjk did. Only if it had a good animation
Episode 100 was something special.
Every department gave their best.
Can you make a video about kingdom animation?
what is texture? I still can't get the hang of this term despite seeing people mention it many times
the fact that even though the animation was definitely a mess loyal fans stayed loyal till the last episode and after episode 150 their patience was paid off
Let's hope when the anime comes back, it's seasonal and it's scheduled far better than before so Yoshihara and Tanemura can have all the breathing room they need so they can get all the best animators they can. And given how good the movie looks via the trailers, it's definitely a sign of what's to come.
i think for videos like this you should add captions on the visuals of the video, you talking about a guy at 5:08 and i cant tell what i see is done by him or not
Luckily we'll all be able to see how Black Clover will look when it's given time to cook in the oven with the movie.
The movie was gorgeous🙏🏽
Never watched BC but i know that production was a disaster and from what u said it's even more bad than i thought lol not even aniP there to help them sheeesh it's rough but in the end yoshihara saved BC from completely collapsing as expected from him
Hey man. Can i Ask you Something? Where exactly do you Learn about Solid information about, interviews of the staff, The production, The staff for every episode (for a Show) etc..? Can you recommend me some reliable leakers? I've been try to find some of them for a while
And also the production of hell's paradise is still a question for me. the first trailer released a long time ago with a 6 months gap for each cour as you said. And it is not a JJK, CSM situation that the production might've started much later because The team is very different. And still the trailer is a bit Limited (of course i don't expect it to be JJK, CSM level because that's not possible) and like some people say that the trailer is pre animated. Again I'm Really confused. But cour 2 will look great right? (even if cour 1 has a bad schedule which is weird because TWIN ENGINE is on the production committee, they always handle the schedules well)
@@userK894no i couldn't. Can you say the name at least?
@@user-og6pb6dd5p yes cour 2 should look better than cour 1 since aot staff will be free by then so atleast inhouse one can help them a bit
@@user-og6pb6dd5p wow so i can't write the account name
Sry but u have to find accounts which r dedicated to prod discussion yourself YT just delete my comment when I mention them
For me animation was perfect specifically black and white moments and cube animation.
Im new to BC and Im currently on the Witches' forest arc. Ladros vs. Asta brought me here. And tbh, I understand now.
Don't forget bc is weekly anime
Thanks Yashihara
I'm waiting for you to make a kny season 3 first episode breakdown when it's aired
Be patient lord akaza
Peak SB
It's clear as day that pierrot is forcing all there efforts on bleach tybw. Even boruto while not as bad as black clover also has some issue and the quality of the code arc is no where near that of the jigen/isshiki arc imo.
Yes but not only reason. Health issues bad planing
@@kishank9580 Yup
@@catlike9444 weekly anime with shitty schedule that's what happens bc need too be seasonal
bleach had nothing to do w black clover's production lmfao. TYBW didn't start production until early 2022.
@M M do you understand the video. One of the reasons why black clover suffer was because pierrot didn't care about black clover and instead focus their efforts on naruto and bleach. He even said in the video "studio pierrot doesn't care" it's one of the reasons of black clover problems.
If pierrot didn't care about Black Clover why not just cancel it earlier? 170 episode is really much while most of the animes are 12 or 25 episodes long. It just sounds really weird make an anime this long while didn't care how the episodes looks like.
It isn't cancelled, it's on hiatus.
@@tick1180 probably the producer and tv demands
I loved the animation.
I think the animations are great
What did you think about jigo episode 1?
I wish ep 63 would be reanimated by some studio like demon slayer jjk or solo leveling studios
I have to admit that Black Clover is a good Anime even though the animation can be pretty bad at times.
Do a animation breakdown on hells paradise forest episode. It’s amazing first episode
Thank you for the education :^)
Tbh black cover would be better as a seasonal anime
Make another black clover video BUT THIS TIME MAKE IT ON THE RECENT MOVIES TRAILER IF YOU CAN DO JJK YOU CAN DO BLACK CLOVER
He isn't entitled to give you a video wtf?
@@TH3FU113ZT true but he could make it for his own views
Even if the animation is sub par some times I still will say black clover is a 9 outa 10
nice info
Japanese animation studio have a vision for they own project but the most of them is out sourcing but in America they do have plenty off studioand have so much source but didn't have any vision what a world
Fico muito triste de saber que Black clover não teve a atenção que merecia e se depender tirando o filme que foi incrível quando o anime voltar ele talvez não tenha uma animação descente 😞😟
This is why I am reading the manga
Ngl I kinda like the style of episode 63
Cool video. Good thing I read the manga I guess. But it is sad what happened to the anime adaptation. Hopefully, it improves later on.
Also I would love for you to talk about Bleach like this. OG one I mean. There are some great episodes in that I remember. Even better than the new one(even tho overall the adaptation was mid for various reasons). Like episode 341, 219 comes to mind. Thanks
Forget everything.
The problem with Pierrot is they view everything as next Naruto.
So instead of having a proper seasonal production they want to make it a long running continuous show.
God knows what do they get from this.
Long running shows are more risky than seasonal shows.
I love BC, if only they have a proper seasonal production we would have gotten a decent animation all throughout with in between movies.
But nah. Well it's still a successful show, atleast after 30 episodes it started to pick up fame.
If they had enough time (not in a hellish schedule) and even not. If they had an actual Animation producer and staff. Black clover would look much more consistent. Like bro, tatsuya yoshihara is on black clover. He is a big freaking name. He himself carried BC
No the problem is that every time an anime gets a break is another chance for it to get cancelled Caribou-kun made a video on Naruto fillers and speculated that if Naruto was seasonal, there’s a possibility it wouldn’t have even got a complete adaptation.
Things like the format are decided by the top of the committee and those credited for the Planning phase, it's Shueisha and TV Tokyo's decision to air Black Clover as a long running (and obviously they're also the ones behind Naruto, Boruto or Bleach)
We a need different studio for black clover. I mean, they even gave up on Boruto.
Black Clover Brotherhood anyone?
"the only episode i'll talk about in detail is episode 63""
"for obvious reasons" 💀
yoshihara come back
I think he definitely will
A video on one piece should really be expected
The story was interesting to me so I never care about the animation of the show and it's in my top 10 . Interesting video
Still waiting for that kannada video
Bhai , apne country me anime jaisa kuch kabhi banega kya ?
Wait did you actually take me suggestion
“But shut up” 😭😂😭
Really love your animation analysis videos. You are a really underrated youtuber. Considering you are a danmachi fan, I would love an analysis video of the series animation as a whole. Many consider that S1 is the best animated of them all. I wonder if you also share the same opinion.
Man, I was there when Black clover first csme out, insta fan, then there was so much fucking padding and slowass weird fucking pacing I just couldn't, I've wanted to got back into it but I think One Piece was enough *longass anime* for me
Do one about the new bleach
another example of a studio not careing anymore is My Hero Academia on Season 4 they just said fuck it we give mob psycho all our budget
That’s a very horrible example
Ok