It's sad to see such negative comments about Sir James' playing. Sure, he's getting old, and arguably isn't in his flute playing prime, but good on him for keeping with it!! I take my hat off to Sir James and his spirit to keep on playing no matter what! - He broke both arms a few years ago, by the way, and did everything in his power to rehabilitate himself so he could keep playing. Bravo to him! I'd like to see how well all the critics here will be able to play the flute, when they hit their 70's.
Good grief people. I hope all of you can play HALF as good as Mr. Galway. How dare people criticize his performance. Have you never had to play while sick? I know I have. I’m analyzing this composition and found it extremely helpful. There’s only ONE GALWAY. I’m fortunate to have heard him live FOUR times and he’s phenomenal. Get over yourself, or perhaps, practice?
I would still travel many an Irish boreen to hear him, stretched vibrato, short breath and all. What a consummate artist and how lucky we have all been to hear him. And what he has done for classical music and flute appreciation!!! Just lie down and listen, and smile!
I like him so much. When I was a student. it was really hard to learn play flute. I hated playing flute. But since I knew him, I have been getting better to like flute :) Thanks a lot
Sir James, a legend of the flute !! A true master! Despite his years still making music, and he does it very well! Sir James has inspired millions of flute players all over the world, and his sound has not yet been matched, I, who am a luthier, believe he possessed a secret in the opening mouth of his flutes, (He had to reshape the caliber and shape of the Hole) so it had an incomparable sound with the flute.
He is said to have adapted the mouth holes of the head of the flute, made them the same as a flute he made for him, Muramatsu, which achieved an optimal mouthpiece by the shape of the hole, and then all the flutes he bought to make them With an identical orifice, and according to some who could see their flutes had a more square form than normal. But this is impossible to accurately establish the measures because this was his secret.
I love his playing. Sir James Galway makes our audiences heart warm and his own unique sound is so beautiful. Thank you for beautiful music. Your playing is not just music more than that.
I hate to hear(read all these negative comments) musicians are all open to these comments have you heard this or him playing it they play and perform and give of themselves to be shot down by whoever The best musicians never give negative comments and I,ve met a few . Those who feel that they should pass on their knowledge first do it then Talk about it !!!!! D
Not his best performance and there were intonation issues at the beginning but still a lovely piece. I saw him live in March 2013 and he was fantastic and we all have those "not so good days" and perhaps this was one of his. Still think he's fantastic. :)
His tone is still gorgeous and his fingering is impeccable but he misses the embouchure very often and it makes me worried D::: I wonder how he plays now.
I also play the flute so I understand the technical difficulty with that... but it's possible to practice so it doesn't get out of position, and when he was younger he totally owned these types of passages... I'm worried that he's losing his mechanical control with age :( or maybe he was just having a bad day (he still sounds AMAZING though)
At his older age he's lost is "signature" vibrato. He needs, after his millions to step aside for the young new rising stud Denis Bouriakov. Just listen to Denis. As a counterpoint I'm sure that Galway will be recorded as the best flutist of our time.
I stand confident that Galway may well be the best flutist of our time. It's not because I'm jealous as a flutist --- it's because he is a betrayer in that he recorded several of his recordings to accomplish "cross-over" recordings to popular music as "Annie's song", etc so that he could sell his recordings and put more money into his coffers. It's time for him to step aside --- he has been eclipsed by the young flute stars on the horizon: Denis Bouriakov, Jasmine Choi and Emmanuel Puhad. That is, of course, if you wish the late William Kincaid, affectionately known as "the father of flutists" as it is he taught more flutists to become principal flutists of major symphony principal flutists than any other.
It's sad to see such negative comments about Sir James' playing. Sure, he's getting old, and arguably isn't in his flute playing prime, but good on him for keeping with it!! I take my hat off to Sir James and his spirit to keep on playing no matter what! - He broke both arms a few years ago, by the way, and did everything in his power to rehabilitate himself so he could keep playing. Bravo to him! I'd like to see how well all the critics here will be able to play the flute, when they hit their 70's.
WELL SAID!!! 👏🏽👏🏽❤
❤ Grosses Danke!!
Sir James Galwayの演奏は聴いてるとすごく安心して温かい気持ちになるから大好きです♥
Great to hear a wonderful flautist still playing at his age!! He put his WHOLE heart into it!
Good grief people. I hope all of you can play HALF as good as Mr. Galway. How dare people criticize his performance. Have you never had to play while sick? I know I have. I’m analyzing this composition and found it extremely helpful. There’s only ONE GALWAY. I’m fortunate to have heard him live FOUR times and he’s phenomenal. Get over yourself, or perhaps, practice?
Agreed.
I would still travel many an Irish boreen to hear him, stretched vibrato, short breath and all. What a consummate artist and how lucky we have all been to hear him. And what he has done for classical music and flute appreciation!!! Just lie down and listen, and smile!
I like him so much.
When I was a student. it was really hard to learn play flute.
I hated playing flute.
But since I knew him, I have been getting better to like flute :)
Thanks a lot
Sir James, a legend of the flute !! A true master! Despite his years still making music, and he does it very well! Sir James has inspired millions of flute players all over the world, and his sound has not yet been matched, I, who am a luthier, believe he possessed a secret in the opening mouth of his flutes, (He had to reshape the caliber and shape of the Hole) so it had an incomparable sound with the flute.
juan miguel VALDEZ what secret sis he possess? I need to know. I am a flutist too!!
He is said to have adapted the mouth holes of the head of the flute, made them the same as a flute he made for him, Muramatsu, which achieved an optimal mouthpiece by the shape of the hole, and then all the flutes he bought to make them With an identical orifice, and according to some who could see their flutes had a more square form than normal. But this is impossible to accurately establish the measures because this was his secret.
There is a Gemeinhardt version flute designed by Galway :)
James Galaway -still a phenomenal flutist
I hear so much music in this interpretation...that's all. Great sir James!
I love his playing. Sir James Galway makes our audiences heart warm and his own unique sound is so beautiful. Thank you for beautiful music. Your playing is not just music more than that.
He still sounds phenomenal, even during his "not good days"
Living in the hustle and bustle of Tokyo , I sometimes feel like listening to Galway's performances
From
Tokyo of the Land of the Rising Sun 🇯🇵
He is still the best. Feeling is what counts.
I hate to hear(read all these negative comments) musicians are all open to these comments have you heard this or him playing it they play and perform and give of themselves to be shot down by whoever The best musicians never give negative comments and I,ve met a few . Those who feel that they should pass on their knowledge first do it then Talk about it !!!!! D
WONDERFUL
Ont dirait de l'eau qui coule et lepiaillelent des oiseaux c est beau
ya'll needa chill out. Our favorite flutist is getting pretty old, but he can still make quite a racket. :-D
so much respect for Galway, he is old but still sounds so beautiful, maybe not his best, but beautiful and musical nonetheless.
I can't believe there there are 29" dislikes. What? You play better than he? Unbelievable
HERMOSO
😊❤😊
❤😮😮😊
🥲🥲🥲 James Galway is better than I am on his worst day than I am on my best day. I need to practice. 😐😒😬
Not his best performance and there were intonation issues at the beginning but still a lovely piece. I saw him live in March 2013 and he was fantastic and we all have those "not so good days" and perhaps this was one of his. Still think he's fantastic. :)
Possibly age has caught up with him. The new rising star is Denis Bourikov
@@jimmillen5110 I recall hearing him in the 70s..naturally he is not the player he was...and I think he may have wound up his public performances.
What comes through is that the guy loves playing the flute.
His tone is still gorgeous and his fingering is impeccable but he misses the embouchure very often and it makes me worried D::: I wonder how he plays now.
I also play the flute so I understand the technical difficulty with that... but it's possible to practice so it doesn't get out of position, and when he was younger he totally owned these types of passages... I'm worried that he's losing his mechanical control with age :( or maybe he was just having a bad day (he still sounds AMAZING though)
I agree with Shelly. His tone is too much like an oboe. But I also agree that he is the best.
At his older age he's lost is "signature" vibrato. He needs, after his millions to step aside for the young new rising stud Denis Bouriakov. Just listen to Denis. As a counterpoint I'm sure that Galway will be recorded as the best flutist of our time.
Leave it to TH-cam to screw up the audio. Too much hiss.
If anyone wants to hear this being played exceptionally well, listen to Mauro Scappini. He’s not well-known but he should be.
Nefis
3:54 lol
I stand confident that Galway may well be the best flutist of our time. It's not because I'm jealous as a flutist --- it's because he is a betrayer in that he recorded several of his recordings to accomplish "cross-over" recordings to popular music as "Annie's song", etc so that he could sell his recordings and put more money into his coffers. It's time for him to step aside --- he has been eclipsed by the young flute stars on the horizon: Denis Bouriakov, Jasmine Choi and Emmanuel Puhad. That is, of course, if you wish the late William Kincaid, affectionately known as "the father of flutists" as it is he taught more flutists to become principal flutists of major symphony principal flutists than any other.
Jim Millen b
in order to understand what flute playing is all about you need to listen to Alain Marion playing it...so amateur for his reputation
wow hes losin it vibrato so slow!
I agree
What's happening here? This is not up to his standard...
He is getting pretty old. Thats the only explanation that would make sense to me
Oh my days! I'm not a big Galway fan, but he normally does sound better than this! This was uncomfortable!!
oh god! Galway is out of tune!