Indian Education System 2018 by Dhruv Rathee [No Detention policy]
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 ก.พ. 2018
- In this video, I talk about important aspect of indian education system, which is the No Detention Policy (NDP). I will tell you why the no detention policy implemented in 2009 helped improve india's education system. And how our present government wants to remove this NDP.
Link to petition: www.change.org/p/1-mr-prakash...
----------------------------------------------------
Subscribe: / dhruvrathee
Facebook: / dhruvratheepage
Twitter: / dhruv_rathee
Instagram: / dhruvrathee
Interviews by Dhruv Rathee:
• Exclusive Interviews w...
All episodes of The Dhruv Rathee Show:
Ep 7 Ache Din in UP • Stupidity & Ache Din i...
Ep 6 Lairs Modi, Ivanka: • Modi & Ivanka Lied?! |...
Ep 5 Padmavati: • Padmavati Crorepati Pr...
Ep 4 Rajasthan: • Ache Din are here in R...
Ep 3 Jay Shah growth: • Amit Shah's son, Adani...
Ep 2 Indian economy: • Indian Economy is Cras...
Ep 1 Currency Notes: • New ₹200 Currency Note...
More videos:
PNB Scam: • Reality of PNB Scam & ...
Bitcoin: • Bitcoin in India by Dh...
Aadhaar Card: • Reality of Aadhaar Car...
Best State in India: • Which is the Best Stat...
Petrol Prices reality: • Reality of Petrol Pric...
Budget 2018: • Reality of Budget 2018...
----------------------------------------------------
Please sign this petition and share it :)
Link: www.change.org/p/1-mr-prakash-javadekar-union-cabinet-minister-ministry-of-human-resource-development-goi-save-our-children-from-being-failed-pushed-out-withdraw-scrapping-no-detention-policy
Dhruv Rathee what the hell is demativate😂😂😂
japan dont have exam for students until they are 10 years old....
Dhruv Rathee please add subtitles to this video if possible. Thank you.
Dhruv Rathee bhai ye student suicide itna bada issue nahi hai
Dhruv Rathee in icse board they make u fail
Two missing things in Indian education system
(1) education And
(2) system
I see u everywhere!
True
No education is not missing. Only proper system is missing. Because our school needs to take a proper system to educate the students.
I also
@Rajeev Vij thanks for correcting the mistake.
Dude, the main problem is Government doesn't care about Education, Health & Employment
they're busy in dividing people by caste, gender and *{religion}*. I'm sorry to say but that's the harsh reality
the aim is to end the critical thinking part from people ... if we are not critical they can rule us easily ... that's why education is probably the enemy of politicians
Knight of Ren why will they care about students? They’re not educated themselves. How will a tea vendor know what’s good for children?
Knight of Ren
Isme galti logo ki bhi hai. Sale padte likhte hai nahi inke Maa baap kuch karte Nahi hai. Khaali bacha paida karte jaa rhe hai unko paalne ki koi laayki Nahi hai salo mein. Aur bache ek ladki ko aankh maarta dekhte hai to usko 1 din mein viral Kar dete hai. Aur Jo Indian genius log hai ya humare Shaheed Jawan hai unko koi viral Nahi karta. Shame on Indian Youth !!
Knight of Ren agree
Aruna Meena agree
There should be a public libraries under 1-2 km area . Most of students want to study without distraction 😢
Exactly that's what I want since lockdown has started............studies in home is next to impossible 😷😭
Let me tell you a joke
"Indian education system"
😂😂👏
😂😂
@@Babieskingdom01 bhut sahi
HAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH
Lmao
c'mon man, just copy and paste Finland's education system
there will be OVERWRITING OPTION....
i jusr dont understand why cant we have finland's system
@@therightside7639 our system tell us how to cram
And Finland system of education tell them how to understand.
The major difference
Let’s not look at youth as 20% of the future rather let’s look at them as 100% of the future.
You are doing a fabulous work Dhruv Bhai ❤️
Nice Prince EA reference. Btw it is not 20% of the future it is 20% of the population
सर सीबीएसई से इस देश में सिर्फ 12% बच्चे ही भारत में पड़ते हैँ
बाकी 88% राज्य बोर्ड में पढ़ते हैँ
No डिटेंशन पालिसी का सबसे बुरा असर उन 88% बच्चों पर हुआ हैँ.. ज़मीनी हकीकत हैँ यह.....
Bilkul right
Shi baat hai pure india me ek board hona chahiye
You are right
Bhai ICSE board kha par hai
So who is studying in ICSE board. Some percentage of people is studying in ICSE board school.
I don't know, man. I'm 55 and I'm LUCKY to live as contemporary with youth like you around. Almost all your videos are really informative & educative.Hamara India aagey bhadeyga, JAI HIND!
thanks for these statistics u provided...but we need to work on root cause...infrastructure and quality of education etc I am a teacher ..and after no detention policy also we fail student in our class ... so this policy is not that much effective as it should be..there is many things to be discussed I hope our politicians also join utube and read our comments.. do read my comment
I agree. Root cause is quality of education. NDP or no NDP won't change that
Government should focus on infrastructure and teacher training. It's not easy to get opportunity to study for children of people of rural areas, workers of unorganised sector , girls, SCs, STs. As your data suggests. On that removal of no detention policy further demotivate the parents and children's.
As far as I understood from your analysis that NDP is going to induce more critical and analytical thinking among students which will improve the quality of education and on the other hand now u are saying that it won't change. I am now a bit confused what you really want to say? can you elaborate what do you mean by root causes for quality of education.
Yeah I agree to that, but then don't you think that when we will not fail till 8th standard then we will practice enough to make the things perfect.Let me ask you one thing that y not make NDP to 10th standard then we will reach the magical figure of literacy rate=100% in the coming years?
Pallavi Gaur teacher, do you want to pass your students even when they don't know a few correct answers at least to pass? Don't you believe in quality education?I believe as I have trained 50students only with a government recognized diploma as a beautician. And I have trained them well I'm and have told them to shine wherever they go with my diploma. Don't you expect that from your students?
हमारी सरकार को एजुकेशन सिस्टम बदलने की जरुरत है, जैसे स्कूल में इन्टरनेट youtube, कार्टून एनीमेशन ,रचनात्मक , प्रायोगिक कार्यो ,प्रिशक्षण और खेल को किताबी ज्ञानों से ज्यादा महत्व दे ताकि एक सही सोचने समझने और निर्णय लेने वाला भविष्य तैयार हो सके.... वरना ऐसे लोगो की की भारत में कोई कमी नहीं है जिनका मार्क्सशीट में तो अच्छा नंबर है लेकिन अन्दर से खोखले है
yes i am victim of this...
Sahi bol rahe ho
No Detention policy will be good only if country is much developed😉.
Bhai hamaray mulk aur aap k mulk main bus Number game hai knowledge to bus nam ka hai..
@Aryan Padhy the case in pakistan is worse .. 9th class students ko volcano MATLAB bhi nhi pata
Hi Dhruv can you please add a vlog on guidance for children on distance education v/s regular class
@@rakeshsrivastava4228 achha Kya Mujhe Ye bata Dakte Hai Ki Pakistan me Syllabus Kis Tarah Ka Hota Hai Yani hamre India Jaisa Bahut Pura Hai Ki Samaye Samaye pr major Changes Hote rahate Hai? I Want To Know Plz Reply
Yes
3:21 Ratta marna koi Inse sikhe:-
Indian education system 😂
India has no club system no promotation for sports no student council for school phones & technology not allow in school only ratabazi now they saying no detentation policy to becaming most faltu education in the world
Novaid bhai zadatar nordic country and develop country ma ye system mozud ha kaskarka japan ma
ASAD ALI i agree
Sirf admission ke samey mein ajib ajib quota dekhne ko milte hai.
Bhai apna teachers hii anpad hota hai vo Kya inn cheezon ko samjan ge
Deepraj Gaonkar ha bhi yaha pe deserve logo ke liye koi jagah nhi h
Agar aapke pass 8-10 lac rupees h to aapke job pakki
bhai detention policy ke wajah se aaj kal bahut sare bache ko reading karna tak nhi ata.
Biswajit Mohanty Bhai , unko pehle bhi nahi aati thi.
totally agree with you ,but yeh kyun hua?because padhne ka icha hi khatam hogaya.aur reading is very basic thing every learner must know
Actually isko ground level ke baare mein kuch ni pata bss foreign mein baith k data k base par videos banata rehta hai...
Shai kha yr
Pata nh aisa ku lg rha h..
For your kind information, koi v teacher karab nahi hota, bus unka padhaneka style aalag hota hay. Or aise hawa may baat mat karo, jao school may or dekho halat 9th class wale bacho ka. 9th class wale bacho ko aaj naam likhna v nahi aata only for this no detention policy. To aasa without knowledge wala passes ka kiya fayda.
Its a shame on Indian Govt that can spend 40% of its budget on army but just 4% on Education
@@soniajindal7270 this guy whom you are telling is just a movie maker
Mr. Rather, I've passed out my 10th from CBSE board in 2018 and I want to tell something about my experience, upon which you should ponder.
1. The detention policy made students not to study at all. I'm in a govt. school now(in 11th) and the students of my class can't even read simple English textbook.
2. I was also in CCE system until 9th class and suddenly the system changed, which made me study more efficiently (though I couldn't score much but still, I have a broader horizon than my seniors).
3. Though the passing percentage came down last year but those who have passed are not satisfied because their expectations were high as they thought that their marks will also be upgraded as in CCE system.
I think you did not do very well in your english paper.
You "passed out"?
this policy is only until 8th grade and also don't judge anyone
I got Experience, but Not like You. It was really good.
Praveen Thakur exactly you are right💯💯
@@tiwari_9010 Point mate!
I disagree a bit with you.
The data you have shown for 10th class pass percentage from 88% in 2009 to 98% in 2012 is more linked to new grading system introduced in 2010 rather than NDP.
Is NDP responsible for school dropouts? -- YES
Does NDP lead to loss of human resource? -- YES
But the new system of CCE (Continous and Comprehensive Evaluation) is not implemented properly. You talked about CBSE, but quality and knowledge of students with state boards in Government Schools, after NDP, have been degraded to such a low level that students of 8th standard can't even do basic arithmetic. They don't come to school or study properly as they know they will get passed to next class no matter how poor or hard they study. This philosophy in students makes them unproductive in the academic arena. Obviously, such cases aren't seen in private schools where parents and teachers take the education of children seriously but students of public schools are real victims of NDP.
What should be the real solution to this problem?
-- Ensuring good quality of education in schools, especially public schools. The steps taken by Delhi government are plausible.
-- The economic conditions of poor families need to be improved so that there are no dropouts due to the economic condition of families which can also increase child labour. Mid-day meal policy can be extended to secondary education.
-- Scholarships or some other monetary help can be provided to students of poor families.
-- Education should be delivered in vernacular languages for tribal students who often leave school as they can't understand the mode of knowledge delivery.
-- Separate skill centres should be linked with schools to provide them vocational training as all students aren't interested in education after 10th/12th or for higher education.
Agreed 100%
Viral Shot even my family member is a government employee in education sector. He complains about the fact that students don't come to school regularly, still we have to pass them despite low attendance and when the same students get into higher classes, they still are unable to do basic addition. 2009 to 2012 data just tells us about the no detention effect on students which were being detained earlier. There should be no detention but the present CCE system cannot ensure that they will have all round development. What if they get into class 9th and start failing miserably year after year?
A child should be exposed to mind grinding activities in education, not detaining them will make their condition more deplorable. There has to be a better check mechanism.
Viral Shot agree
Viral Shot
Isme galti logo ki bhi hai. Sale padte likhte hai nahi inke Maa baap kuch karte Nahi hai. Khaali bacha paida karte jaa rhe hai unko paalne ki koi laayki Nahi hai salo mein. Aur bache ek ladki ko aankh maarta dekhte hai to usko 1 din mein viral Kar dete hai. Aur Jo Indian genius log hai ya humare Shaheed Jawan hai unko koi viral Nahi karta. Shame on Indian Youth !!
Dhruv will not read this comment, I don't know why these famous youtubers don't reply to criticism, I think they can't stand criticism and they always think they are 100% right every time, look in the comment section dhruv has loved the positive comments only.
Dhruv I've been watching your videos since you analyzed the 3 years of Modi government. I just want to say your quality has improved tremendously and that every Indian should watch your eye opening videos. Thank you !
You're forgetting the fact that everything that's taught in school now is just meant to make every kid discouraged of being creative while the very books we read are carefully put together to turn a group of individuals into a similar thinking crowd. They're taught to conform and as for permission for doing things, every morning the patriotic anthem, how kids become used to being in a crowd and start adjusting themselves to fit into that very crowd. Its creates an atmosphere where being the odd one out is considered bad and discouraged , even though everyone's different.
Education system ko Change krne ki jarurat hai..🔄
Education is the country's backbone for success
🔰 *Bhai Engineering ko Expose kardo* 😆
hahahahahahah
😃😂😃😂
Yes
shismohammad mulla ap engineer ho 😂😂😂
He is also an engineer
Exam hatane se nhi blki exam ko face karne ke capable bnao to better hoga
Fail hone pe koi suicide krlega to zimmedari ap uthaoge na
@@nvxhopper4883bilkul but uske liye power bhi to do mujhe
@@stratupgeneralstudies2961 😆 kaha kaha jaoge bhai sb students apko btake thodi suicide krenge power aa bhi gya to ghr pe hi krenge suicide
Apko to abhi apne state ka bhi nhi pta hoga kisne suscide kia aaj
🤡🤡@@stratupgeneralstudies2961
5:25
Yr to wo 9th class m bhe fail ho jyga...
First time i disagree with your thoughts dhruv bhai.
I know teachers who have to give marks to students who left their sheet BLANK. Literally. Ultimately we're raising qualified but dumb people. This is not relevant and should be changed.
shubham ahlawat yes I understand your point of view, but if a student is so dumb then how will he clear 9th std.? Forget about going to 10th or higher education level!
Sahi kaha
True.. I teach mathematics to kids upto 10th.. They all come from a reputed school of my city but some of them are so dumb that they can't even do basic algebra which is taught at class 5 , the reason is this no detention policy. When they don't even deserve to study in class 6 they are in class 8 and struggling with the problems because they don't know the basics by which the problem could be solved , Few days ago I gave them a class 5 book to learn basics first , but now they feel ashamed to ask questions from class 5 book.. It would have been better if they were stopped at class 5 only , first learn then go forward.. No detention policy should be immediately scrapped.
And in 2010 98% students passed from CBSE because of introduction of grading system and not because of this.
teachers mosly pass karne ki hi koshish karte h..kekin paas toh tabhi karega na jabb baccha kuvh theek.likhega
Seriously first time
Done bro 👍👍👍👍
I have signed the petition.
Very nice and knowledgeful video as always.
India needs a youth like u. Love u bro 😊😊😊😊😊
Mohammad Husain bhai ye ravish thode hi hai ye dhruv rathi hai.
Happy Lives so what bro??
They both are doing something good instead of becoming blind bhakt 😀😀😀😀😀
Achha hai.sahi hai .badhiya hai.
Saandar, Jabardast, Jindabad 😂😂😂
I don't think its exams or the marks that matter, what matters is 'what is taught' and 'how it is taught' .
In our country, people are taught 5 questions and for the exams one of them is tested, but in countries with best educational system they are taught to answer the 6th question which may require knowledge of every other questions.
disagree with this ...go at ground level...go to villege...go to govt. schools ..than you know the real face of this policy
This is bcz govt teachers are not teaching well
it is bcoz teachers are not good in those areas and also as children get mature they gonna get serious about studies whether to drop out or continue
Totally right..
Agree with you
Bro, mere jo dost hain (especially in state run schools) they did not study at all and hence at the age of 13 and 16 they ended up in choice of charas alnd ganja .
Thats what I saw during my schooldays.
It might be diff. In ur view
Bhai your research and interpretation level is top notch.Hats off
i never share any youtube videos..... but this one i did....you are awesome
Assasinz Legion america jaise india me bhi ab chutiyon ki baraat tayyar hogi .... mujhe lgta h rathee khud bht bada failure h ...
Assasinz Legion
Isme galti logo ki bhi hai. Sale padte likhte hai nahi inke Maa baap kuch karte Nahi hai. Khaali bacha paida karte jaa rhe hai unko paalne ki koi laayki Nahi hai salo mein. Aur bache ek ladki ko aankh maarta dekhte hai to usko 1 din mein viral Kar dete hai. Aur Jo Indian genius log hai ya humare Shaheed Jawan hai unko koi viral Nahi karta. Shame on Indian Youth !!
Bhai ek petition is ke bhe laga do.. ke ratta based education system se change ker practical based education system le Aaye....
Exam pressure and depression as a result thereof is not only because of our education system. It is mainly because of how parents deal with their children.
Education and Indian teachers aur parents ka mindset jab tak nhi badlega tab tak Indian ka develop hona sambhav hi nhi hai 🥲
Development do not come from good marks.... Kids should first learn etiquette .... In japan until 10 years... kids learn how to respect people and how to keep their surroundings clean..... And they are taught to clean their school by themselves......
Excellent dhruv
absolutely right mere sath bhi yahi hua 8th standard tak muje exam ka koi tension nhi hota tha aur fir jab mein 9th standard mein aaya to just pass ho kr 10th standard mein gaya aur 2015 ke board exam mein fail ho gaya😔😔😔😔😔😔😔😔
4:52 Girls me dropout rate high kaise hai? Meri class ki sari girls mujhse zyada padhai karti thi and better number laati thi.
Every boy knows the fear of competition from a girl student. 🙄
Ldki jb ek fail hoti thi to use dobara chance nhi diya jata tha aur ghareloo kamkaj me lga diya jata hai ...lgta hai metro city ho bhai
Drop out rate has nothing to do with marks.... It means that more parents prefer the boy child and use resources for providing boys with secondary education..... While girls even when they perform as good as boys if not better are not encouraged to take up secondary education..... This is the harsh truth of India
I don't think you realize how poor India is, and how terrible the condition of women in our country is. You're probably from a tier 1/tier 2 city, where boys and girls are treated equally, also you probably come upper middle-high income family and society. Correct me if I'm wrong.
Bro that was a sarcastic comment. Chill
@@tiwari_9010 LOL. OK. NOW I FEEL STUPID.
Vai!! My name is Tarikul Islam from Bangladesh. You are doing a great job for Indian people.
Thank you 😊🙏
Tarikul islam
You should do for Bangladesh
Dhruv Rathee
Dhruv Bhai Isme galti logo ki bhi hai. Sale padte likhte hai nahi inke Maa baap kuch karte Nahi hai. Khaali bacha paida karte jaa rhe hai unko paalne ki koi laayki Nahi hai salo mein. Aur bache ek ladki ko aankh maarta dekhte hai to usko 1 din mein viral Kar dete hai. Aur Jo Indian genius log hai ya humare Shaheed Jawan hai unko koi viral Nahi karta. Shame on Indian Youth !!
dhruv
You are doing a commendable job on exposing the facts and providing us with news in right direction. But only informing will not bring a change. If you can make a platform in future thats puts pressure on the government to take steps in right direction it will change our country. And you seem to have the capability to do so....
College doesn't give deep knowledge they we don't find jobs😏
50% fee refund of last semester from colleges and some hostel fee refund too We need a strong voice like you to raise the issue in the time of Corona Crisis
Hey Dhruv listen
I always agree with you
But today I disagrees with your thoughts
Sorry but I am facing this
So here in Rajasthan I study in a blind government school
I am blind ok
With rbsc corce
And let me tell you the situation
Here no boddy studys
No teacher teaches properly
Because no one is gonna a fail
Then they enter class 9th and their they feel the pressure
The pressure
And they drop the school
And here the students like me
The hardworkers had to study dubble because
We have to pass the boards any how
I too agree with your thoughts man its very easy for Mr Rathi who got educated from Germany and maybe his primary education must have been good. I also don't agree with the stats that he had put forward. To be really precise he always gives stats according to his school of thoughts, which can not unbiased for sure...
Sumit Sharma I always agrees with Dhruv
But not this time
And I still respect him
Sachin Porwal here the question is not about agreeing or disagreeing to someones thoughts, Its a pity that I have to say this but you have to analyse what others are saying, be critical in your thinking and don't be just a mere follower of someone.I know that you might feel it hard to swallow but my friend this is the harsh of this world and specially our country that we are just followers of someone. I hope you understand this.
Sumit Sharma ya
I fully agree with you... Whatever dhruv is saying is applicable to generally well off private schools, where salaried middle class sends their kids.. no detention has screwed gov primary schools in WB ..teachers don't bother as they know all the kids will pass .. the final aim of the gov should be course revision so that cramming is checked
Our school teachers told that students take studies lightly as they are getting pass till 8th std and in 9th std the scores drop because of this.
this is so informative...i had same thought about cce but now i am clear.
at the same time as per your data you dont think so that the increment % of all the passed student are gone through from those fear earlier so they cleared the exams... therefore i think you should show us recent data for us.
thank you
india needs patriot like u sir. keep rocking as usual 🙏🙏🙏💪💪💪✊✊✊
Education and Indian teachers aur parents ka mindset jab tak nhi badlega tab tak Indian ka develop hona sambhav hi nhi hai 🥲
The RTE has actually brought a major change in education statistics to many states in India. Drop out rates are controlled, admissions have increased, pass percentage and mean has risen. Even the public schools have made to allocate 25% seats for students with limited financial capacities.
I'm afraid if detention would be applied, the students from weaker sections of the society would have the biggest impact.
इस पॉलिसी का दूसरा पहलू बेहद ही चिन्तनीय है !सुधार अति आवश्यक है भाई !!
I appreciate your valuation about dropout from school.
I really appreciate your work...👍👍
Sandar jabardast zindabad.dhruv Bhai aap Dhruv tare ki tarah Amar aur adig rahen.sat sat Naman
I am a student and being a student I request you to make a video on reservation to eradicate this system
Thu general category Wala hai na 😂
Also , there are many other ways to reduce exam pressue . Things such as counselling and guidance will not just help them to curb the exam pressure but also enable them to handle life problem in future . Removing exams is not a way out as ultimately students will have to face so many other problems in their lives after their school . thus they must be prepared to fight the problems rather than creating an unreal environment for them by removimg exams .
Respectfully, I don't agree with you totally. I agrre that this policy have drastically helped the children in decreasing the dropout rates. But the data suggested by you of the CBSE for 10th class can not be used to determine that the students have rightly done in there first exam that is 10th as there were no exams before that. This data can not be used because with this policy CBSC also started a policy of home Board examination for 10th class. When i was in 12th, my computer teacher used give the 10th students grade arbitrarily on all the CCE like sports and other things, So even if a student was failed in theory there was no way he could fail in 10th. Even once our administrator told us that in a cbse board meeting at panchkula, they were having a meeting because few students jumped of from top of there house because of result so no student will be failed in exam of physics. He mentioned that these were exact words that students should not be failed.... Now some people will argue that why the some of them were failed than. So, to answer that, CBSE said that students can opt for board exams if they want of they can stay in home board examination, therefore the excess failure happened in those board exams. And some few who were not at all good were failed in home boards too.
What i think is that NDP is not a solution to this problem, Yes it have done great in slowing down dropout rate. But it creates the problem of kids not being serious or at all interested in things that should be done at schools. I am not against playing and other extra carriculum activities that they promoted with CCE but these all things were on paper.
To my knowledge best thing to stop dropouts is counselling. One counsellor, who is well equipped with knowledge of counselling and have a degree for it should be appointed at every school. That is the right solution.
Rankit Godara ....exactely in my comment also i supported this thing
This is the first video I disagree with Druv. I am a teacher and give home tuitions to children from class 6 - 10, and I have been giving tuitions since 2002. Ever since this policy has been implemented, I have seen a drastic decline in children's performance. They are not taking studies as seriously as we used to do in the 90's. They know they will pass even if they dont study. Taking the overall percentage into consideration and not just final exam marks is a good thing but not detaining stupid and naughty kids is unfair on the ones who are really taking the time to study and working hard for getting good marks. If all the data in the world was so accurate, then the whole world would rely on data and not look at the reality.
THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT IS WROTE
Rankit Godara I think students should be in school rather than passing exams....
this line is god to listen and speech but life doesn't work that way, exams are not there to just fail you, they make you strong and give you a sense of responsibility towards what you have learnt. I too feel i should be collecting my pay check rather than proving myself to company that i deserve it.
भाई तू चुनाव लड़ कहीं से,
मेरा वोट पहला होगा!!! 🙂☺️🙏👍
VH Original bhai ise sonia gandhi ne MP ticket k liye select kar liya hai 2019 me ye politics me aa raha hai
VH Original 1 aour Kejriwal aa jayegq
पूरा देश डूब रहा है साल इस नेतागिरी के चक्कर मे
Rajeev Batra 😂😂
Dudh ko chash me mat dalo 😂😂
Your arguments are correct brother but in NDP, a student don't really want to study as there is no chance to fail, they pass every year like this and suddenly in class 9th when they feel the need to study they feel the extreme stress of studies
yr i love ur voice and jo aapke bina kisi se dare sch bolne ka andaz h just amazing 😍😊
Sach nahii jhut
@@yogeshaithani7244 sach
Bro Dhruva Rathee u always good work
sir, i am a great follwer of your vedios and i completely agree to what you say... but here, i think we have a different opinion...I am myself a teacher and my mother was also a punjab govt lecturer... The ground reality is something very different... this system has deteriorated the quality of education since its applications... The teachers are bound to pass a child in his primary classes and in villages, the children of 9th are even unable to write ABCD.. this becomes a nightmare for the teachers as the standard of 9th is much higher in comparison to 8th... So if you say that the children drop off, its just the incompetent ones sustain longer,, hence the same child drops in 9th.. So no advantage... also he/she who availed all government facilities adds nothing other than burden.. The quality of city school education also reduced as now the students think that its ok to not study... Hence... on number, we generate high number of litrate people,, but the quality of literacy is very poor... Lets be more analytical, this is a possibility that a huge section of students drop out from 9th because of their incapacity and thus only the compitant students are able to reach 10th... Thus more % students pass in boards... Another point is that because the primary teachers know that students are bound to get promoted, they also dont teach.. Hence THE GROUND REALITY IS THAT A MOJOR SECTION OF PRIMARY GOVT SCHOOL TEACHERS TAKE SALARY EVERY MONTH AND TEACH NOTHING THROUGH THE YEAR... Darwin once said- "survival of the fittest" so why are we generating infit dependent students using this mechanism??? I expect you read this comment and react to it...
-regards
Good perspective :)
I think if a 9th class child cannot even understand ABCD, we should focus on imroving quality of education and teachers. NDP or no NDP won't change that anyways
WOW ! its a really knowledgeable video. Bro please make many more videos about education policies
Very good 👍 😲
I liked some of your videos, but this one is crap. Facts that lead to wrong conclusion, like that of passing students of class 10th of CBSE. That was because of home board and CGPA system. And how can we forget the rule passed by UPA govt. to make 40% contribution of 12th board percentage in IIT-JEE MAINS exams.
I agree with you. This video is crap.
Exactly
He's a crap.
Most of the video shows just one side of picture
Still remember the public out cry against Kapil Sibal for implementing the unfair "normalization" system for JEE ranking back in 2012.
there was no pressure on the children to learn and on the teachers to teach. Therefore, there was a need for policy change so as to improve the learn
perfect,well said!good going dhruv
Dont misguide ppl, you are telling them half truth, just to make everyone believe what you believe... Your points may be right that you mentioned in this vedio, but let me tell you QUALITY of education system has been dropped significantly, since the implementation of this "no detention policy" and thats why government is thinking to change it.
Nope it's good now youth are looking other good career option like sports , Acting , mass communication , tourisem not only science and engineering .
dhruv, I would like it if you would make a video on how India could improve its health system and manage the costly bills of private hospitals
One million congratulations
he deserve more sub's... I recommended everyone to watch his videos
Dhruv, I really respect your contribution towards our society and you chose the best medium to convey your messages. I wish you long, healthy and successful life brother.
Good
Nice and informative video. Good that you shared the link to the petition. Can we know the status of the bill now? Was it tabled this March?
This video should be in Trending.
I don't agree on this issue....Fear is not always bad ..... Sometimes it's good too....It stops you from doing bad things!
love and freedom are better way too..
First video where I don't agree with him.
real serious issue
Please make video on parallel Coaching center education system in India..
Hi Dhruv, request you to make a video on *SSCScam* as your coverage is valuable.
Dhruv can u plz make a video about NOAH who is saying I'm time traveler. Whenever i open youtube everywhere i see his videos claiming that he is time traveler plz make one video about him .
Bhai jo ek baar march me fail hoga, vo may me dubara exam de skta h
ISHAN KHANDELWAL it is inability of the school
U give me goosebumps brother... I love ur videos soo much
Dear Dhruv thanks for giving me Important knowledge.
FOR EVERYONE WHO IS WATCHING THIS VIDEO 📹.
Druv Rathee, you always show one side of a coin. Watch the javedkar sir's full video on RSTv. No detention policy is only making our students and teachers unaccountable. India is the only country in the world having highest number of enrollment but our class 5th students can't read class 3rd book 📙 and class 6th student can't do class 4th maths problems. This is the result of No Detention policy. Are you still happy with this. 😕 Dont become a roadblock by signing petitions against No DETENTION POLICY.
👉 Most of the people who watch your videos and support you blindly are fools.
👉 NCERT will half its syllabus by next session. Then it will be easy for students to pass their exams in 5th and 8th.
👉 With no detention policy we are producing only unemployable youth.
U r right
I was waiting for you to speak on this topic. Thanks buddy.
Thanks for your Sir
बहुत ही गंभीर मुद्दे पर बात कर रहे हैं ध्रुव भाई
कक्षा 1 से लेकर 8 तक पास फेल प्रथा है सरकार को पुनः लागू करना चाहिए
Namaskar dhruv...
_Bro you are always on the right side so am I_ 👍
I am 15 yearsold. and my honest opinion i can feel these all points so thank you dhruv sir-
I m seeing this Vedio when 2020 m New education policy aa Chuki h....
Ab dekhte hn Kya hota h
Same here😄
@@MdSaif-jp5rc 👍👍👍🤓
What are your views on Home Schooling?
Harsh Patel I never thought about it deeply or researched about it enough to have an opinion 😄
nice episode
Please make a video on full scholarship programs in europe and America, the difference between education system here and there
This is one of the few videos where I do not agree with your views, though I do appreciate your efforts. However I thought it was imperative to put forward my thoughts so that it compells you to reconsider your stand on this issue. It is a well known fact that quality of education system in India has been downgrading year by year. Just to give you an example, my Grandfather was born during British rule and he completed his education for 11 years. Despite this, he could very well converse in English, he was good at Mathematics and his overall acumen was way above average. As compared to him, my Dad who was born in mid 60s is a Graduate, doesn’t converse in English (he understands it). Coming to me, I have completed my Post graduation and I had to take extra efforts to excel in certain areas. To be fair, speaking English is not a thumb rule to gauge education, but it can give a clear picture regarding quality of the same.
Also to point out, in your videos like Best state in India and India being No.1 in crime against women, you have stated that data is not always accurate. In a similar fashion, data regarding education cannot be considered reliable. If you actually visit a school, you will understand the ground reality. Students from 8th or 9th class do not understand basic mathematical rules, are poor in languages and communication skills and only few students are ambitious about their future.
सर आप CBSE का आंकड़ा बता रहे है।।। एक बार सरकारी विद्यालय का भी बता दीजिये।।।
कुछ निजी विद्यालय तो आपने छात्र और छात्राओ को परीक्षा के लिए तैयार करते रहते है।।। परन्तु सरकारी विद्यालय का क्या होगा।।
वहा तो एक प्रकार की उदासीनता अ गयी है।।
Bhai Ek college ki 75% attendance Ek against bhi Ek video Bana do
And college ki phudu halAt par bhi
kuch nahin hoga .... jab tak modi government hai...
modi government ke pehle colleges pe 75% attendance nahi tha kya????
Brother please make video on ssc exam scams ,i too have have seen all this ,how ssc is playing
Thank you sir
I think 2012 board exam of CBSE must have been very easy. Facts and data are not always great to judge something, I also have given 10th exam in 2012 but from ICSE board and trust me NDP doesn't even matters to students, what matter to them is their class topper, family topper, elder cousin pursuing MBA or Btech from IIT and parents expectations resulting into pressure. NDP might reduce the pressure a little but then students will be more dumb than now.
I've done my graduation in Pakora. Where's my job?
Your way of describing things is supbbbb.......
Sir My mom has been teaching in government school since last 5 years and what they told me that students are not taking studies seriously due to no pressure of getting failed and when students got failed in 10th class exam ,at that time My mom have to have answer to higher authorities for students bad result.I am not doubting on your research but this is the reality which I have observed regarding this policy.
Hi sir I was your fan but in this topic I think you are illusioned . The no detention policy has a very bad effect on our students. As they know they won't fail so they don't study . students get very reluctant and don't give a shit about studies. They somehow pass till eighth grade but when they have to appear for the board exams they fail. They don't even know the alphabets properly. Even if the teacher wants to detain a student he can't because of this no detention policy. I've seen many of my cousin failing ninth exams because they passed till eighth without any exams or study.And about the statistics I don't know about the statistics but students suffer ,they leave schools after failing ninth. A teacher can't teach counting to a ninth grade student.Thats the truth. If the student anyhow passes the boards with his memory power but won't make a good citizen in the future.
p.s: my respect for you grew lesser.
Totally agree with you. This video is disappointing.
Stats he showed were just of CBSE and in 2010 pass percentage increased because of CCE pattern . He calls it because of no detention .. Sometimes I feel his other stats are biased too but because of lack of knowledge , we firmly believe whatever he has to say.
I just began watching videos of Dhruv Rathee, been a week or so.. I came across one and was impressed, watched few more of my interest. But among all those, this one is the worst. An average educated adult who has been in touch with school/students in any way, be it his work, his own children or otherwise can throw more light on the pros and cons of today's education practices including the no detention policy than this video does.
Highly disappointing and skewed.
You are right