Nah, I think hogtie them near a shallow end of the river watching them cough out water and struggle then slowly walking/pushing them into the water till they drown is worse
@@atithesnail I would like to try a start a chain of comments one-upping each other on the most psycho thing to do so that I can try it in the game lol
@@nicwo not unhealthy just a saying though you probably already know that I think he means that he watched this videos a unnecessary number of times unless you mean that this is good content
Yeah, its a strat for getting higher honour for certain missions, just go to saint denis and run around greeting everybody, in an instant it will go up
I remember once I robbed a guy near the swamps, didn't want to kill him, so I tackled him into the swamp and Arthur decided to drown him by pressing his head down into the swamp without me even pressing anything, pretty messed but I didn't lose honor
@@screwhead7135 i don’t think there is a way to kick on your own, Arthur decides to kick the person he is engaging with if they are slightly lower than him on an incline
Yep, I do the fire one all the time, wondering why defend myself by shooting a civilian who is trying to kill me because I got his new shoes dirty = 👿, But to ensnare someone who calmly asked me for privacy, and drag him over his own bloody bonfire til it incinerates alive = 😇.
@@Kevin-rj5zp Yes, you're right, this moment is thought out, but I mean that the NPC is not trying to get up and is just patiently waiting for his death.
Quick tip* instead of having to ride all the way to a river or body of water; just throw them in a pig or horse trough. If they are tied up and you get their head in the water they will drown. Also you can throw bodies in with the pigs and they will dispose of them for you; if you know what I mean...
Imagine drowning and the last thing you see with your blurry vision is the business end of a shotgun in your face. I know you don't lose honor based on the mechanics of "not being involved" with his death, but this really is way more brutal than most of the ways you can kill somebody in this game lol.
Fun fact: if you do this while unarmed you will get a drowning animation and if you do it with a knife it will have different animation of you slicing the throat after drowning them
It's a shame you lose honour for knocking out people, the amount of people that have been spared because I stopped myself from punching them due to honour is crazy, like when an NPC is just unnecessarily rude
If you do the same thin while unarmed there is a cool animation where Arthur actually holds the persons head underwater and drowns them. Not sure if you lose honor or not for that though.
This is why you will never get anywhere in the game you spent 10 minutes killing him this way when you could have just shot him and got the honor back quicker than that
I’ve got a better one I won’t lie I did it on accident but in west Elizabeth I was hunting for cougars there was two people trying to blow open the safe I didn’t want to lose honour but I did want the money so I tried to lasso and hogtie them I lassoed one and yanked him back on to the detonator switch and blew them both up no honour lost
@@FunnyRedemption you can upset until they start shooting and then kill them You can feed them to animals You can upset them and let the sherriff shoot them
I’m playing this for the first time, currently on chapter 5. I’m playing with high honor. I’m playing the first game next since this is a prequel, but next time I play I’m playing with low honor.
This is exactly what I’m doing I just Finnished rdr2 last week, it was so good I had to buy the first one, I like it but graphics and mechanics of 2010 are horrible
I didnt even know you could hold NPCs at gunpoint on the ground like that. I have hundreds of hours in this game. Easily in the top 3 games of all time by any measure.
I see you're aiming for the 'first' place, but there's no prize for coming in first in the race of being unoriginal. Keep trying, maybe someday you'll come up with something that's actually worth saying.
veterans must have too much patience to bring a man all the way to a body of water and stand there for a good 30 seconds watching them quiver in fear just to eventually go limp
fun fact, if u shoot the gun while half the barrles underwater that part of the barrel wil lstraight up explode and itll be like a flower shape most likely especially with shotguns
This is honestly the coldest way you could kill someone in game. Think about it, “I can either blow your head off and leave nothing of you to find, or I can leave you here, tied up and beaten. Slowly suffocating in a dirty river. Which one do you prefer?”
Real veterans save the game before loosing it and just going on a rampage . Going to the top stairs of the saloon tucking in the short hall way above the entrance and just keep slaying wave after wave of law Men 😊
![[Watch Party] APL 2024 ใครชนะเข้ารอบ Hydra 🆚 Flash Wolves Talon 🆚 GGLive](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/BvuSgyLy4hA/mqdefault.jpg)
Real veterans would just spam “hey mister” in saint denis after killing everybody in valentine
exactly
This right here, is how you do it. Haha
Or pet your horse
🤣🤣🤣💯
100%
You lose no honor, yet this is the most psycho thing you can do.
Nah, I think hogtie them near a shallow end of the river watching them cough out water and struggle then slowly walking/pushing them into the water till they drown is worse
@@joesr31 I wonder what are you trying to prove here.
@@atithesnail I would like to try a start a chain of comments one-upping each other on the most psycho thing to do so that I can try it in the game lol
@@joesr31 i love it!
@@joesr31 i do that too its mad fun just didnt know you could do it in game too
NPC: * held underwater at gunpoint *
Arthur: "You sir, are a fish."
You can teach a man to fish... And then you can teach a man to die.
NPC: *BULP BULP I AM FISH BULP*
@@topbanana.2627 shur
That's what Simon said to Arthur! 🤣
LMFAOOOOOOOOO
NPC: I rather drown slowly than get my head blown off
I guess he was trying to be considerate to his family who might want an open coffin funeral. He thought ahead
If I was in water like tht I would be struggling for air idk how dude just laid still with a gun pointed at his face 😂 he’s him for sure
@@Davidscomix well then instead of having no face you have a really blue face
Wouldn’t u
@@purplebladder no drowning is a very slow and painful process
getting your head blown off takes less than a second
Imagine Rockstar seeing this and deciding to release a patch to fix it. 🤣
Imagine rockstar devoting any resources to red dead anymore
@@swews8157 Hehe.
Only if it affects their gold sales.
It's not gta online I doubt they care
they’ll fix that patch before they ever fix john’s face in the epilogue dude is literally arthur marston 💀
It’s unhealthy how many times I’ve watched your channel more than other RDR2 TH-camrs
How is it unhealthy watching this instead of other TH-camrs
what abou red dead baby i get him more than brother Foller
@@nicwo not unhealthy just a saying though you probably already know that I think he means that he watched this videos a unnecessary number of times unless you mean that this is good content
@@imrealperk_ it do be good content, some of its stolen though.
especially when you consider the fact that the subtitles are in Russian lol
I've seen a table of honor points you gain or lose when doing stuff. It turns out if you say "Hi!" before killing someone it evens out.
Interesting. But not worth it 😄
That's why I greet the whole town before my rampage 🥴
Hi! BOOOMH
Arthur: "Hello sir!"
NPC: " Good mornin' , sir "
Arthur :" So u chose death"
Yeah, its a strat for getting higher honour for certain missions, just go to saint denis and run around greeting everybody, in an instant it will go up
I remember once I robbed a guy near the swamps, didn't want to kill him, so I tackled him into the swamp and Arthur decided to drown him by pressing his head down into the swamp without me even pressing anything, pretty messed but I didn't lose honor
@-'zx alligator
@@screwhead7135 i don’t think there is a way to kick on your own, Arthur decides to kick the person he is engaging with if they are slightly lower than him on an incline
@-'zx I went to get back on to my horse after speaking to someone, and Arthur decided to choke some random woman instead. 🥲 What a silly guy he is.
@-'zx yea
I think Arthur start thinking by himself 😂... Give you an epic kill
If you drag people into water or a fire with a lasso people you don't lose honor. Either that or I've gotten lucky with around 100 npcs
Jesus you're a psycho lol
Yep, I do the fire one all the time, wondering why defend myself by shooting a civilian who is trying to kill me because I got his new shoes dirty = 👿,
But to ensnare someone who calmly asked me for privacy, and drag him over his own bloody bonfire til it incinerates alive = 😇.
👀
Would be interesting to throw people to the gators in the swamp.
@@---ce7gq Rockstar logic for ya
This is the first time I see some not well thought out detail in RDR2, which just reminds how good this games is.
I mean I guess it is thought out because the NPC isn’t staying alive under water
The fact that if you drown an NPC won't cause you to lose honour? Yeah, haha!
@@Kevin-rj5zp Yes, you're right, this moment is thought out, but I mean that the NPC is not trying to get up and is just patiently waiting for his death.
@@VadimID Yeah my reply was me messing around
@@VadimID Why would he? Would YOU want a headless corpse for your open casket?
This better be a scene in a movie. The tension was real.
Hi
Hi
"Sometimes a Great Notion" 1971. watch it.
Quick tip* instead of having to ride all the way to a river or body of water; just throw them in a pig or horse trough. If they are tied up and you get their head in the water they will drown. Also you can throw bodies in with the pigs and they will dispose of them for you; if you know what I mean...
This tip brought to you by Wu's Pigs and Emporium.
Do they actually do this outside of that random encounter with the killer hooker?
@@ddelarosa96 they sure do.
@@chandlerbraaten847 They put gloves on and load the body on a cart to be incinerated.
Are you the villain from Snatch?
Imagine drowning and the last thing you see with your blurry vision is the business end of a shotgun in your face. I know you don't lose honor based on the mechanics of "not being involved" with his death, but this really is way more brutal than most of the ways you can kill somebody in this game lol.
How gentle and friendly of him to let the other choose between drowning or a slug to the head!
Did you know there is a drowning animation? If you tackle someone into water with no gun when you hold the execute button he’ll drown the guy
thanks can’t believe the game just released yesterday
@@posstaldude some peeps don't know lmao
@@ericbelander2319 yeah, now I gotta try this
There's also a unique animation for stabbing people in the water
@@posstaldude It didnt release yesterday
This game gives me so many ideas for short stories set in the old west.
Seems like a lot of work to save honour you can get back by saying “Hi” to people.
Cause of Death: Natural Causes
Normally (without losing honor) I would pull out the lasso and drag along the floor and hold on tight until they drown in water
Fun fact: if you do this while unarmed you will get a drowning animation and if you do it with a knife it will have different animation of you slicing the throat after drowning them
You can also sometimes get the sheriff to shoot them for you
It's a shame you lose honour for knocking out people, the amount of people that have been spared because I stopped myself from punching them due to honour is crazy, like when an NPC is just unnecessarily rude
@@CavalryCharge This is mostly true
Step 1 : Meeting rude people
Step 2 : Kick their ass
Step 3 : Go to st denis and spam the greeting action for gaining your honor back
If you do the same thin while unarmed there is a cool animation where Arthur actually holds the persons head underwater and drowns them. Not sure if you lose honor or not for that though.
I think if you antagonize someone until they attack you, at least if they shoot at you, you also dont lose any honor if you kill them.
But witnesses will say you murdered them
@@byronboydstun2222 antagonize the witnesses until they shoot you
LOL I feel like this should lose you the MOST honor 😂
I genuinely thought for a while that I was insane because I drowned like 20 people as john
I SAW THAT! I'm getting the law! 🤣
Its nice to see the same visuals for the takedown animation as the old ps2 game Bully
Well technically speaking, you didn’t actually directly kill him even if you caused his death.
Well done sir.
Imma go try this now
When you realize hogtie decreases honor 💀
It shouldn’t?
Just say hi to them to even it out
@@ddelarosa96 idk why but it does
I think antagonizing them in order to agro them cancels it out. Or at least, it's much less honor
“Making someone choose between getting shot and drowning, they still die, but they choose how”
This is why you will never get anywhere in the game you spent 10 minutes killing him this way when you could have just shot him and got the honor back quicker than that
I love how they purposely roll over LOL
Op
Well, that's some good attention to detail.
I’ve got a better one I won’t lie I did it on accident but in west Elizabeth I was hunting for cougars there was two people trying to blow open the safe I didn’t want to lose honour but I did want the money so I tried to lasso and hogtie them I lassoed one and yanked him back on to the detonator switch and blew them both up no honour lost
You can do that?
U can jus kill them without losing honour there criminals to
"hunting for cougars" 😏
@@Scared_Yoda THERE ARENT COUGARS IN MISSIONS - DarkViperAU
@@Davidscomix I didn’t think so at the time but yeah it shows the realism of this game
This is good but there are many easier ways to kill without loosing honor
Like?
@@FunnyRedemption down/burn them with a Lasso
@@silasmerzenich yeah but I was expecting the many easier ways not only one
@@FunnyRedemption you can upset until they start shooting and then kill them
You can feed them to animals
You can upset them and let the sherriff shoot them
@@silasmerzenich you can't antagonize people constantly. After 3 people antagonized your honor will lower.
if you tackle someone with a knife into the water, you get the like punch the knife into their neck animation its pretty dope
The attention to details. 😂
I’m playing this for the first time, currently on chapter 5. I’m playing with high honor. I’m playing the first game next since this is a prequel, but next time I play I’m playing with low honor.
congrats dude, you've been playing one of the greatest games in history
Thanks. 👍. I’m not a dude though. 😆
Nice man 💪 enjoy yourself cause its truly an awesome game
@@SallyCat84 doesn't matter, dude and bro apply to all
This is exactly what I’m doing I just Finnished rdr2 last week, it was so good I had to buy the first one, I like it but graphics and mechanics of 2010 are horrible
I didnt even know you could hold NPCs at gunpoint on the ground like that.
I have hundreds of hours in this game.
Easily in the top 3 games of all time by any measure.
Batman: I don’t kill
Also Batman:
Beautiful horse
Другой вариант - Можно с лассо схватить NPC при этом не завязывая его руки - тащить по реке.
i aint doin allat but we up
I didn’t realize you were attempting to kill Aqua Man lol
Rdr2 is so beautiful
Holy crap that's the most down right evil way to not lose honor.. I can't wait to play tonight..
Arthur was like:You get up,you are dead 😈
Thought you were gonna feed him to some alligators
The second guy's face didn't even look like it was underwater.
First
I see you're aiming for the 'first' place, but there's no prize for coming in first in the race of being unoriginal. Keep trying, maybe someday you'll come up with something that's actually worth saying.
"If you want to beg for your life, you have to die first."
- Ust Nus
the choise the life give to us
He landed on his back but decided to flip over onto his face so he was in the water...
this is amazing... super dark scene but its lovely that ithappens
Alternative, hold the draw feature until they fire on you, then let the law kill them
the amount of shots i've taken to the chest and not drawn my gun is insane, but with modern-ish medicine and a local lawman, no more aggressor!
look at that detail. you can actually see the man lay underwater and drown without him flailing around gasping for breath.
Im actually genuinely impressed that Rockstar had the thought that someone might try this and programmed the game to work how it should
That's the coldest shit ever.
somehow this is way more disturbing that just killing somebody normally.
Folder is dressed as a legend the wild bill
bro had a cardiac arrest
He was resisting hard for his intrusive thoughts to win.
Damn, the river got him.
veterans must have too much patience to bring a man all the way to a body of water and stand there for a good 30 seconds watching them quiver in fear just to eventually go limp
'Oops, what a shame.'
Diabolical. I love it.
Def historically accurate
fun fact, if u shoot the gun while half the barrles underwater that part of the barrel wil lstraight up explode and itll be like a flower shape most likely especially with shotguns
This is honestly the coldest way you could kill someone in game. Think about it, “I can either blow your head off and leave nothing of you to find, or I can leave you here, tied up and beaten. Slowly suffocating in a dirty river. Which one do you prefer?”
Yeah man you really showed him, riding to the border of town
wow rockstar thought about every details
This games wild
No Air No Problems
Bruh this is awfully great lmao
Be me, antagonizing the dude to attack then forcing the sheriff to end his life like how a law-abiding citizen should act. Completely moral and legal.
Well, some Veterans would just keep shouting "Lennaaaaay" till the person dies 😆
Pinkerton: Well, it looks like this man drowned to death.
Arthur: you just might be onto something there *mischievous smile*
Haha I thought you just got them out of town😂 I'm gonna go swimming soon👍🏼
Another good way to do it is to find a campfire and drag them through it with the lasso
"Damn, the river gottem"
Nooo that second guy died of intimidation 😂
Every once in a while I'll see Red Dead Redemption 2 abbreviated and think it says R2D2
Ole Arthur? Yeah hes a chill guy.... sometimes throws innocent people into rivers... but hes a chill guy
Bruh by then I ain’t even mad anymore
Real veterans save the game before loosing it and just going on a rampage . Going to the top stairs of the saloon tucking in the short hall way above the entrance and just keep slaying wave after wave of law Men 😊
Damn that's messed up dude.
I do it too since the beginning
"attach to ground"
they only drown to death after you let them, what kind gentlemen.
feeding 'em aligators with some FRESH MEAT
Ain't nobody have time for this, mister.
But what about the familiarity of the guns!?!? -Jack and Slade And The Gunslinger
Also works with lasso
You’re colder than the river you drowned him in
well played
you never lose honor if you kill O'Driscoll
This is absolutely psychotic
The second one got traumatized to death bruuuhhh 😢
This is so gruesome lmao