In the name of open minds and the freedom to think and present an argument this video needs to be taught in our schools, then let the free human mind in true democracy decide which argument is closer to logic. Thank you Dr. Behe.
Slowly but surely, they are falling. I think it will take two more generations though before we see a respectable amount of academia subscribing to the design inference. Or before they can freely express it.
Totally agree, let's hope more scientists develop the courage to deny Darwinism, the same way Galileo and other brave scientists stood up against the outdated theories of their day. Dr Stephen Meyer (Darwins doubt/the complexities of the simple cell and proteins), James Tour (impossible abiogenesis) are great resources. Professor Gunter Bechly also has some very scientific videos on here, many of them showing the impossibility of not only the Cambrian explosion, but also the other 9 inexplicable spontaneous explosions of life, where fully formed biologically advanced species 'magically' appear at different levels in the fossil record, without any signs of evolution or intermediary species. Fortunately, advancing technology is on our side, as it is allowing scientists to see how 'advanced' the so called 'simple' cell/individual protein 'machines' really are, and that DNA, without which cells cannot replicate or create any biological substances, is the ultimate chicken and the egg problem. Intelligent design is already staring them in the face, but those such as Dawkins are so bigoted they ignore the obvious and try to over simplify incredibly complex biological processes in an attempt too make abiogenesis and Darwinian evolution possible, which obviously, without a designer and already fully formed creatures, they are not. As our ability to see the complexities of cells and organisms such as mitochondria advances, it will get to a point where even the most stubborn Darwinist, will no longer be able to deny intelligent design.
@@shioq. How silly of you. Surely you have something more substantive to add than “magic.” It shows your lack of intellect to make such a silly statement. As an aside, name a creator who doesn’t care about their creation. The painter, the musician, the beautician, the home builder, etc. each care about, and care for, their creation.
@@goodthoughts9734 i see you're a second language person. One would write, ' why doe bacteria evole?', english is a bit backward from most languages. Being a lowly nurse its incredible how all these functions maintain.
it's not coincidence. it's very small changes every generation over the course of a near infinite amount of generations. like how dogs were bred from wolves into the many, many breeds we have today.
Brilliant, Darwin's theory is dead. And now we've got to figure out how it happened, an almost impossible task I presume, as complicated as the cosmos, as complicated as our brains. It's great that life still has so many mysteries to be discovered. I hope it never ends. Thanks, a great video. ....from Ireland.
Life has come from Eternity. Our temporary existence cannot see that far. We should listen to Philosophy . " where Reason cannot go, ..Faith is not Irrational."
@@paulgarduno9756 What an outstanding expression that was. Those committed to strict materialism err to make the a priori declaration that all things can or must flow, from natural causes. Says who? Says those who can only be 'comfortable' if entertaining that philosophy.
I enjoy this series! It kind of inspires me to become a biochemist, lol. I'm just kidding! Anyways, I've just finished reading your book about Darwin's black box, and it really helps explain what you have been teaching in greater detail. I appreciate your dedication and commitment to the truth Dr. Behe. Keep up the good work 👍. Watching from Mozambique.
Great, exciting amazing creation. When we study science cognisant of the amazing Creator, it's so much more exciting than looking at it from an evolutionary viewpoint. One request: when you've compiled a playlist for season 2, please leave a link for it in the description. Thank you and keep up the excellent work!
And the more we see, the greater the complexity, the more absurd the standard evolutionary theory becomes. How many small positive changes would it take, how many failures would have happened, even the rapid reproduction bacteria have don’t make a billion years look very long. Now compare that to the drastically greater complexity of human beings and the idea of macro evolution is laughable.
Yup.... I was once agnostic, now I'm a theist. I understand that there is always much more to learn, and I used to think science revolved around that idea, but the fact that they refuse to take a second look at darwins theory or refuse to abandon string theory with all of its flaws only shows me that true science is struggling because of the scientific communities inability to push against the status quo.
@@ronaldmorgan7632 The core thought process of the atheistic mind is similar on various levels to a scene from the movie,Tombstone. Wyatt Earp asks Doc Holiday, "what makes a man like Johnny Ringo do the things he does?" Doc answers with the word, "revenge". Wyatt asks, "revenge for what?" Doc answers, "for being born". Atheists refuse to contend with the concept of being created. Answering to the Creator. It is much simpler, and easier (whether they recognize they are doing it or not) to follow the single commandment found in the satanic bible..."do as thou wilt is the whole of the law". Actress Betty White once said that "Growing old isn't for everyone". Extending this observation, we see that living forever isn't either. The hour is late for our wobbly world. As foretold, the signs are here in accurate abundance. See - "Huge media blackout regarding supermoons" on the net See - "Pole shift of Noah's day about to happen again?" on the net Good Journeys All
very well made video. At the end i was stuck by this fact that gradual build up of functionality is not helpful for bacteria. Then why mutation will do that?
The so called "beneficial mutations " had ONLY happened on complete fully operating organisms. Like the mutation that allows us to drink milk, after we have grown older enough, and is not needed for our survival.
As a wastewater biosolids engineer, the “ewww” from the kids resonated a lot with me 🤣🤣🤣 accurate. We indeed generate quite a bit of energy in the form of methane gas thanks to our beautiful methanogens 😊
@@the420god3 No, natural selection is just an instance in which certain variations in gene expressions just happen to be exactly what is required to enable an organism to survive some environment. Natural selection never increases the complexity of an organism, it always results in subtraction of information. Organisms with genomes unsuitable for the environment die out and that information is lost. If you define "evolution" as change over time, then you can call anything evolution and the term becomes redundant. Natural selection is just natural selection. Calling it evolution does nothing. It does not prove macro evolution to be true. Also, your name compels me to advise you not to smoke marijuana. It's not good for your lungs and it causes brain damage.
@@the420god3 continue smoking that Hash while you’re at it. Hope you re read what you wrote “Natural Selection” get it selection? As in selecting for what was already there. Continue dozing off my guy
Yes!!! Michael Behe could be a modern day David Suzuki. Our kids NEED this in the classroom. I'd like to make the following recommendations if I may. Don't mention "Evolution" OR "Intelligent Design". It causes mental walls to go up and brings this down to the level of a debate. This should NOT become a debate. That factory animation is amazing. Just show them how wonderfully made everything is and let it speak for itself. The understanding that "life is wonderfully complex" is all they need to take away.
Great video! Even though I am not in favour of eons of time in Earth's history, the irreducible-complexity and intelligent design argument demonstrated here is excellent and IMHO impossible to scientifically counter.
and it all happened by accident for no reason on a planet that shouldn't exist next to a star that is just perfect to house these creatures...hahahahhahahaahaha, right? yeah.
And who made god ? I am waiting for your nonsensical answer such as he always was or he gave birth to himself or good always existed therefore God always existed. Those are terrible answers.
@@kookamunga2458 No it isn't in the Bible it even says God is eternal. Something or SOMEONE HAD to be enteral to set everything in motion. It's common sense there can't be an infinite regress There had to been a uncaused first cause too try to deny this is saying we don't have a universe and you don't really exist. But you Do... Because something or someone aka God is eternal. And the arguments I have heard points too that someone was enernal not something this is what thesis call God.
So who "programmed" the Magnetotactic Bacterium? "Some things on earth are among the smallest. But they are instinctively wise". (Proverbs 30:24). The author of the Bible is the "intelligent designer" ... it's obvious!
Darwinists after having seen the video: look at all those marvels of evolution! The power of random variation and natural selection in front of our very eyes! 🙈
Please never stop, and please keep not involving religion, or you will be labeled "creationists." This approach without involving religion and only involving science, makes your arguments maintain their undeniablity to the masses.
Thank you SO SO much Dr. Behe & Discovery Institute for this highly intriguing video presented with a lot of relatable examples and shot at very apt locations. Namaskar from India. May God bless you. Hare Krishna
Elon "... it'll be electric so we won't have to use gas and all of the pollution will go away ...... " he said while plugging his car into the electric grid of a coal-fired power plant
The universe is fine tuned. Right down to the smallest constituents of observable reality. We are a fantastic, never ending day dream in the mind of a sleepless God.
This is awesome and remarkable information! I was told and shown a paper by darwin evolutionists that irreducible complexity is possible naturally in generations, what would be your response or was this already answered?
We need to look critically both at Michael Behe's presentation of irreducible complexity (IR) AND at his detractors responses. Can you name which paper you're referring to that responds to IR? I have Michael Behe's book A Mousetrap for Darwin which responds to various papers. I can check out the paper and Behe's response to speak to it more intelligently. Personally, I have only seen one argument against IR that was based on evidence instead of bad reasoning but I haven't seen the papers - just discussed with various proponents of them. And I also heard the response to the evidence based argument.
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 76 | คู่เอก "ผึ้งหลวง vs สมิงดำ"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9SBshmGQOIM/mqdefault.jpg)
In the name of open minds and the freedom to think and present an argument this video needs to be taught in our schools, then let the free human mind in true democracy decide which argument is closer to logic.
Thank you Dr. Behe.
The best scientists at work now are working in the field of Intelligent Design.
Thank you so very much for making these videos available
God bless you u for your hard work and your generous heart
Thank you Dr. Behe and DI, as always very charming and professional presentation!
Interesting stuff. And I was delighted to hear the presenter affirm intelligent design. Yes, indeed!
I can hardly wait to see this one
Discovery Institute -- you are getting the job done! Keep charging ahead, the Darwinian walls are crumbling.
Very much so!
Slowly but surely, they are falling.
I think it will take two more generations though before we see a respectable amount of academia subscribing to the design inference.
Or before they can freely express it.
Totally agree, let's hope more scientists develop the courage to deny Darwinism, the same way Galileo and other brave scientists stood up against the outdated theories of their day. Dr Stephen Meyer (Darwins doubt/the complexities of the simple cell and proteins), James Tour (impossible abiogenesis) are great resources. Professor Gunter Bechly also has some very scientific videos on here, many of them showing the impossibility of not only the Cambrian explosion, but also the other 9 inexplicable spontaneous explosions of life, where fully formed biologically advanced species 'magically' appear at different levels in the fossil record, without any signs of evolution or intermediary species.
Fortunately, advancing technology is on our side, as it is allowing scientists to see how 'advanced' the so called 'simple' cell/individual protein 'machines' really are, and that DNA, without which cells cannot replicate or create any biological substances, is the ultimate chicken and the egg problem.
Intelligent design is already staring them in the face, but those such as Dawkins are so bigoted they ignore the obvious and try to over simplify incredibly complex biological processes in an attempt too make abiogenesis and Darwinian evolution possible, which obviously, without a designer and already fully formed creatures, they are not.
As our ability to see the complexities of cells and organisms such as mitochondria advances, it will get to a point where even the most stubborn Darwinist, will no longer be able to deny intelligent design.
I appreciate the animation so much! I have a biochemistry subject, I wish they taught the topics like this.
Well done guys, concise and straightforward, helps us to be fulfilled ‘theists’. Thanks for the great job.
Well done! A delight to watch and pass on to friends and grandchildren.
I heartily recommend all four of Michael Behe's books
You, sir, are a superb ally of truth and good!! Great video!! Thank you!!
To those who dare say it’s all by chance, I say please stop insulting us-and save yourself from being embarrassed.
you're right. it must be a magical being that deeply cares about you specifically.
@@shioq. How silly of you. Surely you have something more substantive to add than “magic.” It shows your lack of intellect to make such a silly statement.
As an aside, name a creator who doesn’t care about their creation. The painter, the musician, the beautician, the home builder, etc. each care about, and care for, their creation.
Amazing, love your work Michael
A true Scientist, with proof , reasons and correct deductions ‼️
These videos are getting better and better.
Simply elegant! Well done, easily understood points. I can share this with many people who will be able to grasp the presentation.
This was amazing, I adore your work Dr.Behe
Great job sir
Why does not becteria evolve ??
@@goodthoughts9734 i see you're a second language person. One would write, ' why doe bacteria evole?', english is a bit backward from most languages. Being a lowly nurse its incredible how all these functions maintain.
Thank you Michael for all the work that you and discovery institute do 🙂
It’s so complex design that there must be a creator it just can’t be a coincident
it's not coincidence. it's very small changes every generation over the course of a near infinite amount of generations. like how dogs were bred from wolves into the many, many breeds we have today.
@@shioq.But we don't see any new species came from dogs after breeding dozens of variations
Subhan Allah
Brilliant, Darwin's theory is dead. And now we've got to figure out how it happened, an almost impossible task I presume, as complicated as the cosmos, as complicated as our brains. It's great that life still has so many mysteries to be discovered. I hope it never ends. Thanks, a great video. ....from Ireland.
Life has come from Eternity.
Our temporary existence cannot see that far.
We should listen to Philosophy .
" where Reason cannot go, ..Faith is not Irrational."
@@paulgarduno9756 I'm not religious, but I love the quote. I've often expressed the same idea myself to others.
@@paulgarduno9756
What an outstanding expression that was. Those committed to strict materialism err to make the a priori declaration that all things can or must flow, from natural causes. Says who? Says those who can only be 'comfortable' if entertaining that philosophy.
I enjoy this series! It kind of inspires me to become a biochemist, lol. I'm just kidding! Anyways, I've just finished reading your book about Darwin's black box, and it really helps explain what you have been teaching in greater detail. I appreciate your dedication and commitment to the truth Dr. Behe. Keep up the good work 👍.
Watching from Mozambique.
Great, exciting amazing creation. When we study science cognisant of the amazing Creator, it's so much more exciting than looking at it from an evolutionary viewpoint. One request: when you've compiled a playlist for season 2, please leave a link for it in the description. Thank you and keep up the excellent work!
And the more we see, the greater the complexity, the more absurd the standard evolutionary theory becomes. How many small positive changes would it take, how many failures would have happened, even the rapid reproduction bacteria have don’t make a billion years look very long. Now compare that to the drastically greater complexity of human beings and the idea of macro evolution is laughable.
How could they not consider the possibility that it was not natural?
Agreed.
Yup.... I was once agnostic, now I'm a theist. I understand that there is always much more to learn, and I used to think science revolved around that idea, but the fact that they refuse to take a second look at darwins theory or refuse to abandon string theory with all of its flaws only shows me that true science is struggling because of the scientific communities inability to push against the status quo.
@@ronaldmorgan7632 The core thought process of the atheistic mind is similar on various levels to a scene from the movie,Tombstone. Wyatt Earp asks Doc Holiday, "what makes a man like Johnny Ringo do the things he does?" Doc answers with the word, "revenge". Wyatt asks, "revenge for what?" Doc answers, "for being born".
Atheists refuse to contend with the concept of being created. Answering to the Creator. It is much simpler, and easier (whether they recognize they are doing it or not) to follow the single commandment found in the satanic bible..."do as thou wilt is the whole of the law". Actress Betty White once said that "Growing old isn't for everyone". Extending this observation, we see that living forever isn't either.
The hour is late for our wobbly world. As foretold, the signs are here in accurate abundance.
See - "Huge media blackout regarding supermoons" on the net
See - "Pole shift of Noah's day about to happen again?" on the net
Good Journeys All
1esl
Azá
This is a well made video. Great content to. My compliments
Watching here in Brazil. Yes, there is a project! #TDIBrasil
And once again Behe makes me think about getting an advanced degree in Biology over half a century into my life.
KEEP IT UP DR. BEHE & DISCOVERY INSTITUTE!!
Thanks Michael Behe & discovery institute for an interesting video.
Fabulous production. Fabulous content.
very well made video. At the end i was stuck by this fact that gradual build up of functionality is not helpful for bacteria. Then why mutation will do that?
The so called "beneficial mutations "
had ONLY happened on complete fully operating organisms. Like the mutation that allows us to drink milk, after we have grown older enough, and is not needed for our survival.
Great video, amazing Professor Behe!
Thank you, Dr. Behe!
Brilliant. Absolutely brilliant! Nothing else can compare or explain so well.
Thank you for your excellent presentation Dr. Behe. You are helping to save science!!
well done.. this is a great and very important work. keep on this good job
Waiting
Brilliant, absolutely brilliant
Why its almost like there's a plan or something!
The multiverse is somehow involved. I can sense it!
Hehehe
Going to show this to my 9 year old.
Before they sabotage him with darwin's quackery.
Great revelation about this unknown activity amongst these bacterias.
Excellent job !
thank you for this fantastic video
Way to go Michael... always a genius
If purpose was not only from mind, the machines on Mars would have found evidence of life forms just as quickly as on Earth.
You need to do an episode on the flagellum of the archea. Even more impressive than the bacterial. because it precedes it.
The flagellum cannot precede the bacteria, because its parts must get built by the bacteria.
It is another, Chicken & the egg problem.
Awesome explanation with graphics 👍
As a wastewater biosolids engineer, the “ewww” from the kids resonated a lot with me 🤣🤣🤣 accurate. We indeed generate quite a bit of energy in the form of methane gas thanks to our beautiful methanogens 😊
People who have faith in evolution say no no, it wasn't just by accident! It was natural selection too! As if that would help.
Mutations are errors by definition. Errors don't generate information.
Natural selection IS evolution
Yeah. A whole bunch of needed changes just happened to appear, and all in the right order. Think how many died in the process though. *sniff*
@@the420god3 No, natural selection is just an instance in which certain variations in gene expressions just happen to be exactly what is required to enable an organism to survive some environment. Natural selection never increases the complexity of an organism, it always results in subtraction of information. Organisms with genomes unsuitable for the environment die out and that information is lost. If you define "evolution" as change over time, then you can call anything evolution and the term becomes redundant. Natural selection is just natural selection. Calling it evolution does nothing. It does not prove macro evolution to be true.
Also, your name compels me to advise you not to smoke marijuana. It's not good for your lungs and it causes brain damage.
@@the420god3 continue smoking that Hash while you’re at it. Hope you re read what you wrote “Natural Selection” get it selection? As in selecting for what was already there. Continue dozing off my guy
Wonderful episode!!! One of the best ever, if not THE best!!!
Excellent. Still love Unlocking the Mystery of Life video from 2003.
Yes!!! Michael Behe could be a modern day David Suzuki. Our kids NEED this in the classroom. I'd like to make the following recommendations if I may.
Don't mention "Evolution" OR "Intelligent Design". It causes mental walls to go up and brings this down to the level of a debate. This should NOT become a debate. That factory animation is amazing. Just show them how wonderfully made everything is and let it speak for itself. The understanding that "life is wonderfully complex" is all they need to take away.
Great video! Even though I am not in favour of eons of time in Earth's history, the irreducible-complexity and intelligent design argument demonstrated here is excellent and IMHO impossible to scientifically counter.
Väntar otåligt :)
Eller hur? Visst är det spännande!
and it all happened by accident for no reason on a planet that shouldn't exist next to a star that is just perfect to house these creatures...hahahahhahahaahaha, right? yeah.
And who made god ? I am waiting for your nonsensical answer such as he always was or he gave birth to himself or good always existed therefore God always existed. Those are terrible answers.
@@kookamunga2458 No it isn't in the Bible it even says God is eternal.
Something or SOMEONE HAD to be enteral to set everything in motion. It's common sense there can't be an infinite regress
There had to been a uncaused first cause too try to deny this is saying we don't have a universe and you don't really exist.
But you Do... Because something or someone aka God is eternal.
And the arguments I have heard points too that someone was enernal not something this is what thesis call God.
So who "programmed" the Magnetotactic Bacterium? "Some things on earth are among the smallest.
But they are instinctively wise". (Proverbs 30:24). The author of the Bible is the "intelligent designer" ... it's obvious!
Incredible, nature's designer was well before and in advance of modern human factories and technologies!
Darwinists after having seen the video: look at all those marvels of evolution! The power of random variation and natural selection in front of our very eyes! 🙈
Perfect world created by God, every micro detail of creation shows how immeasurable is the Lord Jesus, God creator and sustainer of all that is.
Great Dr. Behe!
Ah, thats all just random...lol.
very cool
Evilution is one of Satan’s greatest hits 😈
totally agree with that
Yeah💯
Evolution is obsolete like ever . It's only referred to by people who don't have explanations .
This colorful world has a strong wise designer creator
8:00 - These precious humans God has created.. How can you believe they're "star dusts"? or just product of random chance?
the closer and more truthfully you look at our world, the more you will find God.
"And you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free.”
John 8:32 (NLT)
Our God…the Triune God…He is absolutely amazing!!!
Please never stop, and please keep not involving religion, or you will be labeled "creationists." This approach without involving religion and only involving science, makes your arguments maintain their undeniablity to the masses.
brilliant.
Uh oh, Michaels giving Morgan Freeman a run for his money.
Magnificient microscobic world!
Thank you SO SO much Dr. Behe & Discovery Institute for this highly intriguing video presented with a lot of relatable examples and shot at very apt locations.
Namaskar from India.
May God bless you.
Hare Krishna
Great.
Seeking truth and asking questions is what we humans are designed to do!
👌👌👌👌👌🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️thank you dr behe for this
Thank you....
Brilliant. Praise God. >
Elon "... it'll be electric so we won't have to use gas and all of the pollution will go away ...... " he said while plugging his car into the electric grid of a coal-fired power plant
Science (intelligent design) vs bedtime stories (natural selection)
Excellent! Wonders of nature are God’s “fingerprints”!
Michael , you're wrong. It all happens by mistake for no reason. :) LOL... THANK YOU!
Love it. 👍
amazing video
perfect!
QUESTION: Does the cell DNA actually guide the wonderous morphology of the bacteria or is the DNA limited to protein building block development?
@8:37 Michael your toilet talk maybe didn't win friends but it sure was a great idea.
The universe is fine tuned. Right down to the smallest constituents of observable reality. We are a fantastic, never ending day dream in the mind of a sleepless God.
7:16 ... ok... let's talk about bacteria with guns... I could watch a whole video on this.
Hmm .... I could figure out it now, divine inteligent design revelation to the humans that constructed the Great Pyramids ;)
This is awesome and remarkable information! I was told and shown a paper by darwin evolutionists that irreducible complexity is possible naturally in generations, what would be your response or was this already answered?
I believe that this was addressed @13:40.
We need to look critically both at Michael Behe's presentation of irreducible complexity (IR) AND at his detractors responses.
Can you name which paper you're referring to that responds to IR?
I have Michael Behe's book A Mousetrap for Darwin which responds to various papers. I can check out the paper and Behe's response to speak to it more intelligently.
Personally, I have only seen one argument against IR that was based on evidence instead of bad reasoning but I haven't seen the papers - just discussed with various proponents of them. And I also heard the response to the evidence based argument.
First, where did the ancient bacterium (14:55) come from before I get to dna, rna and other biologicals?
Nano-machineguns 😮
When will MAN acknowledge That there’s a Designer.
Neat!
The question that must be asked is where did the first living cell come from?
[ 3:17 ] Homing pigeons don't use magnetic field for navigation.
Actually, they do. See this article in the science journal NATURE:
www.nature.com/articles/news041122-7
What about horizontal gene transfer that gain new
function