This edit has way more energy than the released version. No disrespect to the editor on the official video, but yikes, this has a controlled chaos that is absent in the other version.
db4tw I'm pretty sure Trent over-saw the last-minute re-edit that ended up becoming the official video.. Pellington wasn't too pleased about his video being changed up last minute, especially as Trent supposedly never told him about it either.
Though Trent is good at what he does, he's something of a perfectionist when trying to find his specific vision, or so I understand. Not sure what the story is here, but between either wanting his version or a shorter version is up to debate; but I'm going to opt for the idea that it had to be shorter for video play. Though much of it is shot in different ways however, I would almost say it's a bit of column A & B. Just two cents.
I think Trent's edit is tighter. This one's extended intro is nice, but beyond that, I didn't see anything that made it feel more energetic. The scene with Trent's lit face in the tunnel was downright bizarre and almost made me laugh, because it looked like he was barely able to see over the crowd. Also I'm confused by the description because neither of the versions have a woman in a red dress?
Fuck NIN's songs send out powerful, inspirational messages. Taking time to notice the symbolism in their songs is amazing, because it would have taken a genuis to write them. Trent Reznor is a true artist.
fck'n CLASS song!!! not heard this for such a long time and it just came to me today, forgot how great NIN brings back memories of my house as a student, drinking untill you can't stand turning the hall and kitchen into a skate park and ROCKING out to NIN!!!! PTY ON PPL WOOOOTGAAAA!
...ich hab keine Ahnung. Aber irgendwie ist das der cineastische Alptraum für mich, nur für mich, seit ich vor über 10 Jahren für 17 Tage in Auschwitz war. Das wird mich mein Leben lang begleiten und das ist mein Film dazu...Danke Trent, Du erleichterst mir jedesmal wenn ich das sehe meinen Alptraum ein bisschen mehr zu vergessen.
I cannot believe I never came across this video before. I have loveddd this song for ages now. it's one of my all time favorites! and the video... wow... that just blew me away! That was so unbelievable awesome... I don't even know how to feel or think right now. I'm still in awe...
as all of u say 10 years and this video is still amazing also the song!! damn so fucking good!!! and was filmed in my city i had at the moment 8 years!!! i regret that
I love this song but sadly it reminds me of one failed crush and an ex GF. Both were people with serious personal issues, thought I could help them through it....sadly that didn't work out. But I still love this song and I feel that the lyrics is heartening. 😊❤
absolutely. i was even somewhat intimidated by the combo song & vid back in the days, yet felt there had to be something to it. now i think it's awesome.
I feel like this is a superior version of the video. It encapsulates the entire song better, and has some really cool shots that were missing from the edited version. I feel like Trent wanted something they could play on MTV, and a nearly 8min video wasn’t going to work
Dude, there is also a city in Mexico Named Guadalajara! I live in there. It was named after the spanish one, because Nuño Beltran de Guzman, the founder of the city was from that city in spain..
rypb16 think they had to shorten it for tv. So when it got edited things were cut out and changed. this is the directors cut full length video. Like this cut better personally.
@@BiLLz66614I just came from an article stating reznor had a different vision in his head than the director showed him, and they butted heads over it, so reznor wound up editing it himself. He spoke of how he is not good at making videos himself and has to have faith another artist will see his vision right, and it was a reminder he needs to read the manual for his camera (so he can make his own videos).
hey they edited out the hot blonde's face on the train from the original - Trent always said this was not a love song - maybe that was the motivation behind why they did that....odd.
Some times you just gotta listen to it as loud as fuck to drown out all the dumb putrid shit this world puts on blast constantly and let the music notes carry you.
Wow, I have to say: This version is not very good when compared to the one that was actually released. That was one was much more coherent and focused than this one.
the only think i don´t like in this version is how we see the mens are running in such way without advice, miss that finding and how we realice of the scale of that weird circunstance shot by shot.
I wast thinking about commiting suicide to this song back in the day it was all powerful and I got to a point where I was too fucked up to care anymore, love this song love NIN
2:06 This shot is amazing
The Fragile Era = the best everrrrrrrr
This edit has way more energy than the released version. No disrespect to the editor on the official video, but yikes, this has a controlled chaos that is absent in the other version.
db4tw I'm pretty sure Trent over-saw the last-minute re-edit that ended up becoming the official video.. Pellington wasn't too pleased about his video being changed up last minute, especially as Trent supposedly never told him about it either.
Though Trent is good at what he does, he's something of a perfectionist when trying to find his specific vision, or so I understand. Not sure what the story is here, but between either wanting his version or a shorter version is up to debate; but I'm going to opt for the idea that it had to be shorter for video play. Though much of it is shot in different ways however, I would almost say it's a bit of column A & B.
Just two cents.
True that. It tickles my ear drums.
I think Trent's edit is tighter. This one's extended intro is nice, but beyond that, I didn't see anything that made it feel more energetic. The scene with Trent's lit face in the tunnel was downright bizarre and almost made me laugh, because it looked like he was barely able to see over the crowd. Also I'm confused by the description because neither of the versions have a woman in a red dress?
passably the best music video ever made.
Perfect song now-a days as it was back then!
I was a young man in 1999 and loved this and the album.
Same here
10 years later it still sounds as incredible as the first time I heard it. He is amazing, a gorgeous musical genius.
*20
@@sebastianb5036 22
Fuck NIN's songs send out powerful, inspirational messages. Taking time to notice the symbolism in their songs is amazing, because it would have taken a genuis to write them. Trent Reznor is a true artist.
fck'n CLASS song!!! not heard this for such a long time and it just came to me today, forgot how great NIN brings back memories of my house as a student, drinking untill you can't stand turning the hall and kitchen into a skate park and ROCKING out to NIN!!!! PTY ON PPL WOOOOTGAAAA!
This video was filmed over at Mexico.
this images, sound, music, lyrics are simply all the sum of our fealings, they mark me..
One of the best music videos ever made
OMFG it's simply perfect. Trent Reznor is a living legend! just a pure talent!
This blew me away. So much more darker and personal, full of win win win.
Oh yeah, I still want to have Reznor's babies.
Both versions are incredible 😩
...ich hab keine Ahnung. Aber irgendwie ist das der cineastische Alptraum für mich, nur für mich, seit ich vor über 10 Jahren für 17 Tage in Auschwitz war. Das wird mich mein Leben lang begleiten und das ist mein Film dazu...Danke Trent, Du erleichterst mir jedesmal wenn ich das sehe meinen Alptraum ein bisschen mehr zu vergessen.
This must be one of my favourite NIN videos!
I cannot believe I never came across this video before. I have loveddd this song for ages now. it's one of my all time favorites! and the video... wow... that just blew me away! That was so unbelievable awesome... I don't even know how to feel or think right now. I'm still in awe...
as all of u say 10 years and this video is still amazing also the song!! damn so fucking good!!! and was filmed in my city i had at the moment 8 years!!! i regret that
I love this song but sadly it reminds me of one failed crush and an ex GF. Both were people with serious personal issues, thought I could help them through it....sadly that didn't work out. But I still love this song and I feel that the lyrics is heartening. 😊❤
This video is the POWER!
never gets old
Still amazing
one of my all-time favourites
Epic extended version of the song as well.
Being the video editor myself, I can see these two versions as ""one for myself"" and "one for a client".
Penis
Penis
what a f*cking amazing video man!
absolutely. i was even somewhat intimidated by the combo song & vid back in the days, yet felt there had to be something to it. now i think it's awesome.
i love this song.... reminds me of my life!!!!
Amazing song, perfect video.
wow, 3 dislikes. what is there to dislike? everything is perfect! perfect song, perfect instruments, perfect lyrics, perfect singer, perfect band!!!
Unbelievable... it's been 10 years...
masterpiece!
I'm here because I don't need fancy trailers to know how awesome NIN is.
I feel like this is a superior version of the video. It encapsulates the entire song better, and has some really cool shots that were missing from the edited version. I feel like Trent wanted something they could play on MTV, and a nearly 8min video wasn’t going to work
ten years after...still amazing...
kocham!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ah, está completo!
this is one of the best videos i ever saw, and this vid is very cool, unique, and badass!!!
You'd actually forget your life without this piece..? 0_o
EXCELENTE BANDA!! ME ENCANTA EL VIDEO!
Outstanding - Rhythm - Passion - Hypnotic - Forever and Ever
Reznor visionary...
Not seen this version since it was original releases on the nin web site back in 1999... it much better then the releases version.
im here because i dont need robert downey to tell me, eh wait, it's because Mark Pellington and Trent Reznor, both are effing genius we knew long ago
such an amazing video. so many amazing visuals. hits hard. love it!!!!!!!
Genius...period
I like the official released version way better but this was still cool to find :)
Guys...Guadalajara is in Spain close to Alcala de Heneres witch is close to Madrid...I was in that place twice...so...excuse me but...it's true!
I love it!!
@crimsonsamuraiftw Agreed, this song (and video) truly describes how I have felt about society for years.
If we cant protect earth, then you can be damn sure we`ll AVENGE IT.
I can't actually pick a favorite among all NIN albums. They're all unique. But I'll pick The Fragile simply because there's more in it.
Hellyeah man!
This song is POWER!
Dude, there is also a city in Mexico Named Guadalajara! I live in there. It was named after the spanish one, because Nuño Beltran de Guzman, the founder of the city was from that city in spain..
4:40 riding the hyperloop
Why do I feel like the song should have been somewhere on the Year Zero album?
Thanx.
This is fucking awesome !!!!
k***king amazing
yes, indeed, this is very powerful song, cause he is screaming and he has got arguments, so it's double intense ;]
4:55 In love xd😳👍🏾
yes, indeed, this is very powerful song, cause he is screaming and he has got arguments, so it's double intense ;]
btw. yep, Reznor is a genius
how did u get such a HIGH quality
Recorded en Guadalajara Jalisco señores!
uuuuuuuuh great 1, i love it.
Fucking amazing stuff
💥💥💥💥💥💯
TRE MEN DO!!!! Y SE VIENE OTRO DISCO !!!
@AFeistyCadaver i remember back n the day Trent had always said his never written a song about drugs.. not even the perfect drug was about drugs,
remix or re-edit of the song, too, right? sounds fantastic.
Why was this version scrapped?
rypb16 think they had to shorten it for tv. So when it got edited things were cut out and changed. this is the directors cut full length video. Like this cut better personally.
Holy shit this comment was in 2013. Lol I was late to the party.
@@BiLLz66614I just came from an article stating reznor had a different vision in his head than the director showed him, and they butted heads over it, so reznor wound up editing it himself. He spoke of how he is not good at making videos himself and has to have faith another artist will see his vision right, and it was a reminder he needs to read the manual for his camera (so he can make his own videos).
I can't seem to find the red dress scene.
hey they edited out the hot blonde's face on the train from the original - Trent always said this was not a love song - maybe that was the motivation behind why they did that....odd.
Damas y caballeros, grabado en el estado de Jalisco y centro de la ciudad de Guadalajara.
FUCKING AWESOME
The original video is better but this one still kicks ass
4:55
Some times you just gotta listen to it as loud as fuck to drown out all the dumb putrid shit this world puts on blast constantly and let the music notes carry you.
This song is totally about drugs, and that makes the lyrics even better.
where is the girl in the red dress?
right I love god .. dudes brillant=)
winds0nlyfrend: same for me!
Fucking LEGEND
Your one of the most beautiful men on the planet. xxx
where exactly is the girl with the red dress?
yeah... the avengers brought me here. Good song! :O
Fuck the Avengers, I'm here because NIN was fucking awesome back in the day.
I'm here 'cause of the Avengers Trailer
I could drive 100mph on bike to this!
Avengers!!!!!
hehe
fuckin a.
Wow, I have to say: This version is not very good when compared to the one that was actually released. That was one was much more coherent and focused than this one.
the only think i don´t like in this version is how we see the mens are running in such way without advice, miss that finding and how we realice of the scale of that weird circunstance shot by shot.
just only for elitè
Total & Utter garbage. What is there to like about this ?
I wast thinking about commiting suicide to this song back in the day it was all powerful and I got to a point where I was too fucked up to care anymore, love this song love NIN