THE REASON "DEFFO MAYBE" IS THEIR BEST ALBUM IS BECAUSE OF THE SIMPLE STRAIGHT PUNK LIKE DRUMMING FROM MCCARROLL. AFTERWARDS WAS STILL GREAT BUT OVER PRODUCTION CAME INTO PLAY. BACK IN 94, THIS ALBUM JUST BLEW OFF ALL OUR HEADS. LIVE FOREVER FROM KIRKBY , LIVERPOOL.
Tony was as important as every other member of the original lineup, take 1 of them away and they don't sound like oasis , not proper oasis sound anyway
Tony was a massive part of their sound when I saw them in ‘93 & ‘94. I went originally with the attitude “…impress me.” because Creation had signed them. (Creation released Loveless n Bandwagonesque FFS!). ….and Oasis were incredible. I felt it was like seeing the Who in ‘66 & ‘67. Tony’s playing on both nights was part of it. A massive part of it.
Played on the best album Oasis ever made and played on my favourite Oasis songs. Very unfairly criticised. Noel just didn’t like him I think. I’ve just read his book and I’m sure Noel didn’t like him. Or didn’t like the fact that he stood up to him. Shows what a good bloke he is as well. No bitterness or slagging anyone off.
Tony McCarrol wasn't a useless drummer at all. I've watched plenty of early Oasis gigs with Tony on drums and he was driving force behind the original Oasis sound that got them noticed. Noel took a disliking to him, treated him like shit and constantly dug him out and basically bullied him. Guigsy was too quiet to get involved, Bonehead realised Noels songs were the key to success, Liam was Noels brother so Tony had no support from within to defend him against Noels constant digging at him. Noel was no better a lead guitarist than Tony was a drummer but Noel brought the songs and the rest of them decided they needed Noel more than Tony so allowed Noel to force Tony out. I've got a load of songs written and I'd love Tony to drum on them.
First album was perfect for him, the type of drumming needed. No way could he have done the next album or the subsequent albums after that. He only had two ways of playing, no range and didn’t progress. Bringing in a session drummer to record “Bring it on down” says it all. But, he can’t have many complaint’s really, he was on one of the greatest debut albums of all time and probably still earns a few quid from it.
Excuse to get rid of someone that talked back to Noel. Sad that friends fall out when the stress of success comes. I have spoken to a friend badly when i was stressed out, it's with deep regret.
Guigsy was far from quiet behind the scenes. You really ought to do research on the era, bud. Guigsy was horrible to Tony. Probably more so than anyone in the band. Tony's personality clashed with the rest of the band, it happens. Not everyone gets along. Tony was also insensitive towards Liam & Noel's childhoods, & refused coaching that the band organised to try & help him.
Nar mate I think it was down to the pressure of the follow up second album and by all accounts in the studio Tony didn't cut the mustard, take after take wasn't quite getting it.
I’m a huge Noel fan & would consider myself team Noel but there’s no doubt he’s ruthless with anybody that gets in his way of his MASTERPLAN!!! I mean Tony Gone Guigsy left then came back in 95 then it’s Whitey joins then its Guigsy & Bonehead left then gets Gem & Andy then Whitey leaves they bring in another bassist to replace Guigsy while he’s on a nervous breakdown that bassist is on the wonderwall video & leaves after a tour then Guigsy is back before all leave again. Then Zak Starkey comes he leaves to go back touring with the who they bring in Chris Sharrock then Noel leaves AGAIN for good this time. Beady eye starts with all the oasis members then that goes pair shape then everyone else Chris & Gem join Noel’s HFB there’s a common theme that seems to be very similar. Let’s mention the Real People situation also when Noel promised them writing credits and banned them from all their gigs & didn’t put them on the credits for Columbia & Don’t Go Away & Rocking chair. After promising them they’d get the credit for the work they deserved & he didn’t do anything he promised & banned the rest of the band from talking to them finally he stops all contact with his brothers Liam & Paul He’s no longer friends with any of these guys anymore which tells you a lot about Noel’s character. Tony was great for Oasis but when Noel isn’t happy with you then quite frankly you’re gone. Noel decides & what Noel wanted he got with the record company defending there cash cow & letting Noel do whatever he wanted. ✌️🕊️✌️
He is such a nice guy. I am friends with him on Facebook and he genuinely is a nice guy. He was shafted by the other members and there is videos of him drumming on his Facebook and he is fucking class!
Can’t fault Tony and what he did on definitely maybe , legend but I believe that alan white took them morning glory songs to another level that I don’t think Tony’s drumming ability would allowed. Thank you Tony for definitely maybe
Have you noticed that everyone seems to say the same thing ("Daaawww, he's a such a nice guy") about EVERY person in the Oasis story apart from Noel? Why is that?
@@obd9660 Or Liam appeared to be aggressive and confrontational because he wouldn't accept any of Noels controlling, bullying bullshit. Noel is cold, heartless, ruthless, arrogant and the fact that Tony, Bonehead and Liam are still mates, Paul Gallagher is close to Liam and doesn't speak to Noel either and the whole of Oasis stayed with Liam to create Beady Eye tells me that Liam is not the problem, Noel is the problem but Liams reaction to Noel being the problem makes him look like the problem but Liam hasn't fallen out with anyone other than Noel, Noel has fallen out with everyone including both his Brothers with complete disregard to how his aging Mother feels about it. Liam is desperate to make amends with Noel before their Mother passes away and Noel is so selfish, cold and ruthless that he is willing to risk his own Mother passing away without seeing her Sons reunite than to admit any wrongdoing and make amends with his Brothers. He's an unbelievably talented song writer but an absolute heartless, immoral scumbag as a human being.
@@theclown8568 A very straight to the point summing up of how it is. Great post, I`d add that it`s doubtful that Noel could have been accepted into another band, him and his songs, in the way that Liam, Bonehead, Tony and Guigsy did.
sounds a good lad.. not slagging anyone off though has good reason to..definitely maybe by far and away their best albums..their later albums were shit
@@dassteam because noel didnt like him plain and simple. When alan white joined, he tried to impress noel with his drumming knowledge in which Noel said I dont care as long as you look the part. Something youd know if you watched supersonic.
In 1999 McCarroll hired a solicitor Jens Hills - who had won Pete Best £2 million from The Beatles in 1995 - to sue Oasis for £18 million. Arguing McCarroll was owed his part of the band's five-album deal with Creation, the case hoped to set a legal precedent, as McCarroll would have claimed compensation for two LPs on which he had not played. Eventually, he accepted an out-of-court settlement of £550,000 in March 1999 and agreed to give up future royalties, which effectively severed all links to the band, with McCarroll's legal fees reported at £250,000. The settlement provoked considerable reaction (one headline questioned "Is this the most stupid man in showbiz?") and the reporter claimed "what Tony failed to realise was that he effectively held a lottery ticket which would mean he'd carry on winning every year
@@fortnitepros8025 there is no royalties in music now nobody buys cds now music streaming has taken over and a million streams earn s £37 split that between the band members he aint stupid
His drumming definitely maybe reminded me so much of the Sex Pistols. Without Tony on that album, it wouldn’t have done the things it did…especially for me as a drummer. It made me want to play the skins
When I watch " Supersonic" live on MTV in 1994 and "Live Forever" from Letterman 1995, I notice the perfect drumming, for the song, from Tony Mac. He's no Dave Weckl, Buddy Rich, Bonham, Alex VH etc... but his parts and transitions make the songs swing and groove. I love Alan White's playing also. He is a little more precise and had better chops.
2nd time listening to this.... i feel he really needs to dish the dirt and stand up for himself more.... really. Noel still says he was fired because he couldnt play.hes trying to watch his words but...
Not a style of interview I particularly enjoyed... especially the sideswiping questions. He rushed the man too, in order to get his list of questions read out. Pish.
@@truecrimescotsman you know why Zak is so good he had two people who showed him how to play, his dad Ringo and Keath Moon. He is the Who's drummer first and foremost as well as Oasis and Noel Gallagher's. That's a good CV in my opinion.
@@Thirdfish Well Tony’s drumming is very simple, Alan’s is quite creative and he only plays what the song requires. Can you imagine what champagne supernova would have sounded like with Tony playing on it? You just wouldn’t play like Mike or Neil in oasis would you, That would sound ridiculous.
@@johnny6476 He wasn't even kicked out for his drumming in capabilities, Noel's ego was high and he needed to take it out someone, he even admits that. All Oasis tracks are easy to play.
@@Thirdfish Fair enough he wasn’t 100% kicked for his drumming, Noel is just a complete wanker. But there isn’t a chance in hell that Tony could have played anywhere near as good as Alan did on morning glory and Noel would have none that. Tony would never have thought to use hot rods for Wonderwall which made the song sound better, He would probably have used the supersonic beat and crashed at the end of every bar like most songs he did.
It all went musically downhill after Tony left I think, it's the same with ANY band, once one member leaves, it's just not the same The first album IS the definitive Oasis sound, and the drums/beats plays a HUGE part in that classic sound for me, the 2nd album and everything else after that just didn't just have that same original vibe, it was all a bit too 'polished' & clean for me
Why is Dave so condescending with his backhanded compliments and comments. He was constantly trying to minimize Tony’s contribution and just wanted to lick Noel’s boots. Tony is highly underrated.
I enjoyed reading Tony's book, but I can't stand how he makes Noel sound like Dr. Cortex or Bowser, or some other super villian. Noels no angel, but he's not evil by any stretch of the imagination. I mean, the man has his own family now. To quote Marge Simpson; "You can't be a bad person if you have a family."
... what..? Are you serious? Grow up in the 70’s in Northern England - you might understand what you have just said is an “ ideal fantasy “ of Family life
Actually, Noel redone a lot of the drum tracks himself to get the album perfect. After the court case, he has been silenced. Don't ever believe a northerner. That means Liam and Noel as well. Their whole story is 50% truth and 50% lies. None of them are honest. What a shame
You can see why Noel and Liam didn’t really like him. He’s like a little Irish man and soft lad scared. Annoying fella kind of fella you dislike and you don’t even know why
Noel, Liam and Bonehead are Irish. Noel doesn't consider consider himself English. Last year he supported Scotland to beat England at Euros. He has said multiple times he doesn't support English soccer team. He has said since 1994 he is Irish. Bonehead recently was asked on twitter what's your Irish background? He responded I am Irish. Both his parents are Irish and so are Tony Mccarrolls parents and both liams and Noels. McGuigans family are also Irish. As Noel said in 1994 when he first appeared on Irish radio he said Oasis are the greatest band to come out of Ireland since the Smiths. The Smiths Johnny Marr also considers himself Irish so do Rourke Joyce all their parents are Irish. So does Morrisey whose both parents are Irish also. John lydon Elvis Costello all have Irish passports and also consider themselves Irish. So do Kate Bush and Dusty Springfield ( Real name Mary O Brien). Steve Coogan said yesterday in a paper he is Irish, both his parents come the same place in Ireland as Noel and liam mother come from. Peter Kay Frankie Boyle Spike Milligan also parents come from this part of Ireland and they also consider themselves Irish. The Beatles arrived in Dublin Airport in 1963. Reporter asked who is the Irish beatle? Reference to Harrisions big Irish family waiting for him at the airport. Lennon turned around and said We are All Irish. Irish immigrants changed the face of British music and entertainment.
What a guy! First time I’ve heard him speak! Very humble, no slagging anybody off! A bigger better man
What else could he do? Get sued or come off as bitter... He's smart enough to know that people wont like it if he was bitter...
He doesn't want to get sued by anybody now does he?
He deserved better.
@@mattiemclean9882 in what way could he get sued? Hes free to tell his side of the story.
Lovely fella. I hope he knows that Oasis fans will always show him love.
Fair play Tony....what an album to be the drummer on!
Great interview,
Big fan of Tony’s drumming
A big inspiration
I think Tony got a raw deal. Glad he is not bitter about how it ended for him. I’ve seen people ruined by clinging on to bitterness. Good for him.
I agree mate.
Go on Tony ❤️
Live forever
THE REASON "DEFFO MAYBE" IS THEIR BEST ALBUM IS BECAUSE OF THE SIMPLE STRAIGHT PUNK LIKE DRUMMING FROM MCCARROLL. AFTERWARDS WAS STILL GREAT BUT OVER PRODUCTION CAME INTO PLAY. BACK IN 94, THIS ALBUM JUST BLEW OFF ALL OUR HEADS. LIVE FOREVER FROM KIRKBY , LIVERPOOL.
Well done Tony McCarroll.. there for the best of Oasis!
Tony was as important as every other member of the original lineup, take 1 of them away and they don't sound like oasis , not proper oasis sound anyway
🍀
Who?
Tony was a massive part of their sound when I saw them in ‘93 & ‘94. I went originally with the attitude “…impress me.” because Creation had signed them. (Creation released Loveless n Bandwagonesque FFS!). ….and Oasis were incredible. I felt it was like seeing the Who in ‘66 & ‘67. Tony’s playing on both nights was part of it. A massive part of it.
Tony's drumming was a lot better than anything Noel has done since 2010.
Behave lol. What a load of bollocks.
Played on the best album Oasis ever made and played on my favourite Oasis songs. Very unfairly criticised. Noel just didn’t like him I think. I’ve just read his book and I’m sure Noel didn’t like him. Or didn’t like the fact that he stood up to him. Shows what a good bloke he is as well. No bitterness or slagging anyone off.
No reason to dislike him, just one of them things.
You don't know the guy personally. The rest of the band did. Neither side were blameless in what happened.
He had a great attack last week. Get well soon Tony Mc!!!
Auto spell is such a pain in the arse!! Get well soon Tony, I think he’s doing better now. 👍👍
Tony McCarrol wasn't a useless drummer at all. I've watched plenty of early Oasis gigs with Tony on drums and he was driving force behind the original Oasis sound that got them noticed. Noel took a disliking to him, treated him like shit and constantly dug him out and basically bullied him.
Guigsy was too quiet to get involved, Bonehead realised Noels songs were the key to success, Liam was Noels brother so Tony had no support from within to defend him against Noels constant digging at him.
Noel was no better a lead guitarist than Tony was a drummer but Noel brought the songs and the rest of them decided they needed Noel more than Tony so allowed Noel to force Tony out.
I've got a load of songs written and I'd love Tony to drum on them.
First album was perfect for him, the type of drumming needed. No way could he have done the next album or the subsequent albums after that. He only had two ways of playing, no range and didn’t progress. Bringing in a session drummer to record “Bring it on down” says it all. But, he can’t have many complaint’s really, he was on one of the greatest debut albums of all time and probably still earns a few quid from it.
Excuse to get rid of someone that talked back to Noel. Sad that friends fall out when the stress of success comes. I have spoken to a friend badly when i was stressed out, it's with deep regret.
@@sionlewis827 he also played on What's the Story album with Some Might say.
@@Thirdfishthere’s interviews with some of the production team and they say he wasn’t cutting it in the recording sessions. But he was bullied
Guigsy was far from quiet behind the scenes. You really ought to do research on the era, bud. Guigsy was horrible to Tony. Probably more so than anyone in the band. Tony's personality clashed with the rest of the band, it happens. Not everyone gets along. Tony was also insensitive towards Liam & Noel's childhoods, & refused coaching that the band organised to try & help him.
Noel wanted his Beatles-Pete Best moment of firing the drummer and so he instigated it.
Nar mate I think it was down to the pressure of the follow up second album and by all accounts in the studio Tony didn't cut the mustard, take after take wasn't quite getting it.
I’m a huge Noel fan & would consider myself team Noel but there’s no doubt he’s ruthless with anybody that gets in his way of his MASTERPLAN!!! I mean Tony Gone Guigsy left then came back in 95 then it’s Whitey joins then its Guigsy & Bonehead left then gets Gem & Andy then Whitey leaves they bring in another bassist to replace Guigsy while he’s on a nervous breakdown that bassist is on the wonderwall video & leaves after a tour then Guigsy is back before all leave again. Then Zak Starkey comes he leaves to go back touring with the who they bring in Chris Sharrock then Noel leaves AGAIN for good this time. Beady eye starts with all the oasis members then that goes pair shape then everyone else Chris & Gem join Noel’s HFB there’s a common theme that seems to be very similar. Let’s mention the Real People situation also when Noel promised them writing credits and banned them from all their gigs & didn’t put them on the credits for Columbia & Don’t Go Away & Rocking chair. After promising them they’d get the credit for the work they deserved & he didn’t do anything he promised & banned the rest of the band from talking to them finally he stops all contact with his brothers Liam & Paul He’s no longer friends with any of these guys anymore which tells you a lot about Noel’s character. Tony was great for Oasis but when Noel isn’t happy with you then quite frankly you’re gone. Noel decides & what Noel wanted he got with the record company defending there cash cow & letting Noel do whatever he wanted. ✌️🕊️✌️
@Gavaldo Aye Noel was ruthless. And he led that band to be the biggest thing in the world for a good 3 years.
Great interview. Tony is a part of Rock and Roll history and very few people can say that!
He is such a nice guy. I am friends with him on Facebook and he genuinely is a nice guy. He was shafted by the other members and there is videos of him drumming on his Facebook and he is fucking class!
Can’t fault Tony and what he did on definitely maybe , legend but I believe that alan white took them morning glory songs to another level that I don’t think Tony’s drumming ability would allowed. Thank you Tony for definitely maybe
What a top guy
1994 they were untouchable live, Tony gave the sound the 'punk ethos', was a top sound.
Legend x
Have you noticed that everyone seems to say the same thing ("Daaawww, he's a such a nice guy") about EVERY person in the Oasis story apart from Noel? Why is that?
Cos Noel's always been big-headed and arrogant, That must be hard to be around.
@@katoness And Liam's violent and hard hitting. THAT must be even harder to be around.
@@obd9660
Or Liam appeared to be aggressive and confrontational because he wouldn't accept any of Noels controlling, bullying bullshit.
Noel is cold, heartless, ruthless, arrogant and the fact that Tony, Bonehead and Liam are still mates, Paul Gallagher is close to Liam and doesn't speak to Noel either and the whole of Oasis stayed with Liam to create Beady Eye tells me that Liam is not the problem, Noel is the problem but Liams reaction to Noel being the problem makes him look like the problem but Liam hasn't fallen out with anyone other than Noel, Noel has fallen out with everyone including both his Brothers with complete disregard to how his aging Mother feels about it.
Liam is desperate to make amends with Noel before their Mother passes away and Noel is so selfish, cold and ruthless that he is willing to risk his own Mother passing away without seeing her Sons reunite than to admit any wrongdoing and make amends with his Brothers.
He's an unbelievably talented song writer but an absolute heartless, immoral scumbag as a human being.
Yeah but without Noel we’d never have heard them
@@theclown8568 A very straight to the point summing up of how it is. Great post, I`d add that it`s doubtful that Noel could have been accepted into another band, him and his songs, in the way that Liam, Bonehead, Tony and Guigsy did.
Read his book. It's a really good read.
Absolutely brilliant read.
Yeah, read it in two nights... class. Top bloke and a top read. Double tops.
@@barrym9610 triple tops
sounds a good lad.. not slagging anyone off though has good reason to..definitely maybe by far and away their best albums..their later albums were shit
Oasis lost the punky edgey sound when tony was sacked , noel had it him for him and was the first casualty of noels ego
I agree so much! most underrated member of oasis ever! Noel just didn't like him plain and simple.
But he is a shit drummer
@@dassteam I'm guessing you know nothing about music or drumming and just taken Noel's word for it.
@@TRGoldjkp No I know drums pretty well, he wasn't a good drummer. Also if he was good why did he get kicked out..
@@dassteam because noel didnt like him plain and simple. When alan white joined, he tried to impress noel with his drumming knowledge in which Noel said I dont care as long as you look the part. Something youd know if you watched supersonic.
Humble guy, and what he says about Liam is noted.
Seems very humble and not bitter about being sacked.
I’d love it if during the Manchester Gigs next year Tony came out to play Supersonic
In 1999 McCarroll hired a solicitor Jens Hills - who had won Pete Best £2 million from The Beatles in 1995 - to sue Oasis for £18 million. Arguing McCarroll was owed his part of the band's five-album deal with Creation, the case hoped to set a legal precedent, as McCarroll would have claimed compensation for two LPs on which he had not played. Eventually, he accepted an out-of-court settlement of £550,000 in March 1999 and agreed to give up future royalties, which effectively severed all links to the band, with McCarroll's legal fees reported at £250,000. The settlement provoked considerable reaction (one headline questioned "Is this the most stupid man in showbiz?") and the reporter claimed "what Tony failed to realise was that he effectively held a lottery ticket which would mean he'd carry on winning every year
oaft
I like Tony but he much be stupid as fuck to give up tht royalties
@@fortnitepros8025 there is no royalties in music now nobody buys cds now music streaming has taken over and a million streams earn s £37 split that between the band members he aint stupid
@@theprogrammerrolandmc3039 in 1999 he absolutely did not see the changes in the business coming.
Yes, stupid move, he lost out on all those royalties.
His drumming definitely maybe reminded me so much of the Sex Pistols. Without Tony on that album, it wouldn’t have done the things it did…especially for me as a drummer. It made me want to play the skins
Hopefully hes made some good money from the book.
smart guy and a good drummer
When I watch " Supersonic" live on MTV in 1994 and "Live Forever" from Letterman 1995, I notice the perfect drumming, for the song, from Tony Mac. He's no Dave Weckl, Buddy Rich, Bonham, Alex VH etc... but his parts and transitions make the songs swing and groove. I love Alan White's playing also. He is a little more precise and had better chops.
I wish the interviewer would try and answer his own questions and let Tony speak. Really interesting to hear Tony regardless.
Love you bro....q
2nd time listening to this.... i feel he really needs to dish the dirt and stand up for himself more.... really. Noel still says he was fired because he couldnt play.hes trying to watch his words but...
This interviewer answers his own questions half the time.
Not a style of interview I particularly enjoyed... especially the sideswiping questions. He rushed the man too, in order to get his list of questions read out. Pish.
Oasis sacked their Ringo and replaced him with a series of Jimmy Nicols.
And then in the end got Ringo's son playing drums, the one and only Zakk Starkey
@@b00ts4ndc4ts Zak is a good drummer....so was Jimmy.
@@truecrimescotsman you know why Zak is so good he had two people who showed him how to play, his dad Ringo and Keath Moon.
He is the Who's drummer first and foremost as well as Oasis and Noel Gallagher's. That's a good CV in my opinion.
Yeah Keith gave Zak his first Drumkit, Zak drums more like Keith than his Dad imo, although no one drummed quite like Keith Moon!@@b00ts4ndc4ts
Jimmy Nicol was very good. Unlike Ringo he was a professional & technical session player!
Tony was the fall guy, his drumming was no worse than Alan White.
🤣🤣 No worse? Are you having a laugh.
@@johnny6476 No but I am a drummer and Oasis drum patterns ain't exactly Rush or Dream Theater. Go figure.
@@Thirdfish Well Tony’s drumming is very simple, Alan’s is quite creative and he only plays what the song requires. Can you imagine what champagne supernova would have sounded like with Tony playing on it? You just wouldn’t play like Mike or Neil in oasis would you, That would sound ridiculous.
@@johnny6476 He wasn't even kicked out for his drumming in capabilities, Noel's ego was high and he needed to take it out someone, he even admits that. All Oasis tracks are easy to play.
@@Thirdfish Fair enough he wasn’t 100% kicked for his drumming, Noel is just a complete wanker. But there isn’t a chance in hell that Tony could have played anywhere near as good as Alan did on morning glory and Noel would have none that. Tony would never have thought to use hot rods for Wonderwall which made the song sound better, He would probably have used the supersonic beat and crashed at the end of every bar like most songs he did.
@ Conor Ryan
Oasis fan?
Lo ve hisdrumming!
It all went musically downhill after Tony left I think, it's the same with ANY band, once one member leaves, it's just not the same
The first album IS the definitive Oasis sound, and the drums/beats plays a HUGE part in that classic sound for me, the 2nd album and everything else after that just didn't just have that same original vibe, it was all a bit too 'polished' & clean for me
Lol they didn’t go down hill. They got huge when Tony left.
Fanning comes off biased as fuK unprofessionally so.... did Tayter cut u a check to do this?
Fanning is a tosser.
How hard would it be to be fired from a band that is just on the cusp of huge success? That must have been gut wrenching.
Seems like a nice bloke.
Why is Dave so condescending with his backhanded compliments and comments. He was constantly trying to minimize Tony’s contribution and just wanted to lick Noel’s boots. Tony is highly underrated.
Who's Matt?
@@sratus lol typo
Guigsy not giggsy
The interviewer clearly has done very limited research
Fanning ffs
I enjoyed reading Tony's book, but I can't stand how he makes Noel sound like Dr. Cortex or Bowser, or some other super villian. Noels no angel, but he's not evil by any stretch of the imagination. I mean, the man has his own family now. To quote Marge Simpson;
"You can't be a bad person if you have a family."
... what..? Are you serious? Grow up in the 70’s in Northern England - you might understand what you have just said is an “ ideal fantasy “ of Family life
Fred West had a family!!
@@katoness ..you’ve nailed it!👍
To Quote Marge Simson? When I read that I could no longer take your comment seriously.
How is it possible to 'quote' a person who doesn't exist?
Giggsy in oasis instead of united 😂
Great bloke but others drummers were better.
Actually, Noel redone a lot of the drum tracks himself to get the album perfect. After the court case, he has been silenced. Don't ever believe a northerner. That means Liam and Noel as well. Their whole story is 50% truth and 50% lies. None of them are honest. What a shame
You can see why Noel and Liam didn’t really like him. He’s like a little Irish man and soft lad scared. Annoying fella kind of fella you dislike and you don’t even know why
Liam liked Tony when he was in the band, ditto Bonehead. Noel got on with Tony until they got the record deal.
Racist.
Noel, Liam and Bonehead are Irish. Noel doesn't consider consider himself English. Last year he supported Scotland to beat England at Euros. He has said multiple times he doesn't support English soccer team. He has said since 1994 he is Irish. Bonehead recently was asked on twitter what's your Irish background? He responded I am Irish. Both his parents are Irish and so are Tony Mccarrolls parents and both liams and Noels. McGuigans family are also Irish. As Noel said in 1994 when he first appeared on Irish radio he said Oasis are the greatest band to come out of Ireland since the Smiths. The Smiths Johnny Marr also considers himself Irish so do Rourke Joyce all their parents are Irish. So does Morrisey whose both parents are Irish also. John lydon Elvis Costello all have Irish passports and also consider themselves Irish. So do Kate Bush and Dusty Springfield ( Real name Mary O Brien). Steve Coogan said yesterday in a paper he is Irish, both his parents come the same place in Ireland as Noel and liam mother come from. Peter Kay Frankie Boyle Spike Milligan also parents come from this part of Ireland and they also consider themselves Irish. The Beatles arrived in Dublin Airport in 1963. Reporter asked who is the Irish beatle? Reference to Harrisions big Irish family waiting for him at the airport. Lennon turned around and said We are All Irish. Irish immigrants changed the face of British music and entertainment.
@@billyflynn6432Are you Irish may I ask?