Fascinating interview. The moral of the lesson is , support those who are doing good work and be a fortress around them . It doesn't matter if you can not take on the fight yourself. Whenever Shourie speaks his honesty stands out , a rare quality to be found these days.
Barkha . Great interview. Nice that Arun brought out your brave work on Covid. During Covid you had requested people to give our spare smartphones for poor students for online classes. On your advise i distributed 8 smartphones to less privileged families. That is the change one honest journalist came bring in the society. Kudos
Arun shourie investigate journalism i n 1980 s &1992 s. He was m.p. & minister in vajpayee govt. He dominated aganist anti Rajiv campaign. So honoured to see &listen. All the best.
Arun Shouroe has so much to share. Wish Barkha had asked relevant questions rather than looking for self validation from Shourie and play victim of self created political vendetta. He advised her to writing books.
Mr Shourie is institutions himself,super intellectual who present his opinion with strong reasoning. Actually he is the true nationalist and fearless one.
Shourie ji deserves all the respect and kudos 👏 he had been a fantastic son of Mother India , specifically for the sheer genius of his arguments devoid of any inkling to a conviction.....treat him like a debater not a coach or a guru ....respects
Excellent interview. Barkha couldn't muster courage to ask Shourie how he became such a great friend & admirer of Ambanis against whom he ran a campaign in his Indian Express days. Did he compromise? or Did he realise his past mistakes, or what? He has never talked on this. Perhaps that was the reason that Gurumurthy parted ways with Arun.
Same way I felt. UP’s result would have been different. Ravish, Avisar, Barkha,Ashutosh,Akash etc could bring huge change if they are watched by every citizen of India without any prejudice.
Barkha, since morning this was my second interview with Arun Shourie. Earlier was with Karan Thapar. Very interesting conversation. His reference to Mr Goenka and Ex President Gyani Ji is hilarious. I wish sit with him over few issues to which I'm really confused. Another point you raised about past and present politicians, I feel those were well groomed and these are either unschooled or otherwise lack civic sense.
Tolerance or intolerance, not only a word of English dictionary, but it has become multi faced weapon in the hands of persons like Aaron Scourie. I am reading this gentleman for mfore than 40 years. He is articulate and has good literary skills. At the same time he is a man of shifting loyalty. His true face became known to all when he was a co petitioner in the Rafael Fighter case. After all a man with dirty mind and biased view.
I was huge fan of Shourie Sir but sad to see him with Barkha Dutta who is just using him as a cover fire against the people who questioned her role in many debacles
No one can erase gandhiji from the hearts of the people , you can criticize Gandhiji but can't ignore him or forget him if he was not their where is India? the present geography is the result of this man walking north south and east west, creating an awareness about the Indianness in the minds of the common people . If we ever try to forget him we will cease to exist.
This guy is great scholar ..well read ... he has enough knowledge to speak for right or left .. it all about where is standing .... one should know his view about RSS and BJP when he was in Government
Hi Barkha ! have been watching you over decades of your work, and let me add it has been a wonderful journey so far and am sure it shall continue to do so. Congratulations on finding ways to get your views across to us. Wanted to share that at around 25 minutes in the interview you have expressed that it is difficult to get admirers and those critical of the Government , especially of our P.M on the same dining table ( well i have paraphrased), though a rarity it still happening. Please continue to keep going there is a huge majority who still loves a good discussion, minus all the screaming.
If Modi were PM in 1970-80's and Indira in 2020's, this Arun Shourie interview would be full of praises for Modi and about how "things have changed for the worse".
@@niranjankumar7550 Even in that case, Arun Shourie of 2020 would still say that "things today are even worse than 1970's." He is simply romanticizing the past.
What Mr.Shourie said about Gandhiji being the major problem for RSS-BJP is spot on. It seems so obvious after he said it. RSS certainly doesn't have respect for Gandhiji.
Gandhi failed as the leader, to prevent hundreds of thousands of Hindus massacred and sent back in trains loads, in 1947 partition ... millions driven out of their ancestral homes, rendered refugees living on Railway platforms, my family was one of them ... !! ... no wonder he was killed ... !! ... no question of anyone respecting the character ... !!
My respect for Arun Shourie and KIRAN BEDI is Himalayan. The only person who can build bridges between Modiji and Arun Shourie is S.Gurumurthy so that ARUN SHOURIE AND KIRAN BEDI can be appointed as Governor of Maharashtra or Punjab or Maharashtra because the people of this country have noticed that both of them discharge their duties as responsible citizens as laid down in Article 51A of the Constitution. In fact both Arun Shourie and Indian Express are made for each other and also considered as the free voice of the people. Dear citizens if this doesn't work out, please pray to the Almighty that Arun Shourie should be taken back as editor of the Indian Express.
Clearly Shourie is old school. He has to make peace with his past and therefore this memoir now just so that he can cash in from his reputation. There will be few more books on provocative topics of which he is a master. God willing he lives long enough. As for the host this could be a sunshine moment to bask in self glory. Always dubious & deceptive! Jai Hind!
Very true..so old school.. what's the big deal in going and reporting covid using a camera? Dear Sir, the new India try to see what we can do to help our govt in times of COVID which is an unprecedented situation.. please this is not Congress govt, this govt is working with her people to make everybody's life better
Incisive. @ArunShourie. Honour and privilege to listen to him. Such depth. Like #HinduRashtra or irrelevance of Nehru and aim to get rid of Mahatma Gandhi. And aim to bring unitary form of government through one nation one election. Listen to him carefully. Every word is a gem.
If one wonders why NDA-1 Govt of Vajpayee failed/ fell, the answer is here. It's because he trusted people like Shourie who were totally opposed to BJP ideology. This created discrepancy and dissonance.
Barkha dutt is the same journalist who blame the Kashmiri Pandits for their own Genocide...! Hats off to her fabulous Journalism that she can display terrorists as oppressed and oppressed as terrorists...!😇
With all due respect to Mr. Shourie, M Modi did visit Mr. Shourie in Pune, when he was sick. Nehru arrested Sheik Abdullah, Indira arrested Acharya Kripalani to Mani Ben Patel (Daughter of Sardar Patel) to JP and others. Many many including Rajaji, others left Nehru cabinet and party as no one including Nehru cared for their views. (If they listened 1962 would NOT have happened and Indian economy would have been much better). Now, no one calls Chariman Mao father of China or call Bismark as father of Germany or only George Washington as father of America. there is a reason for it. Countries have existed for thousands of years except America (where many are credited as founders of fathers). India too had existed as a even bigger nation under Mauryan Empire. If Gandhiji is the father of nation, then what do we call Mauryan empire ? (it was not Indian nation then ). One gets into all these issues. Besides, as Gandhiji himself said, people call me mahatma, but treat me like a sweeper (he was referring to his fellow congress men). Finally, laws change based on what people want them to be. nothing is written in stone. Mr. Shourie is stretching argument to say India will become another Pakistan while ignoring that it's Indian civilization, that thousands years ago said, 'yekam sat, vipraha bahuda vadanti' when other civilization around the world are saying my way is highway. overall, sad to hear the interview, given the intellectual ability of Mr. Shourie
An admirer of yours though I am Barkha the topic shifted from the book to anti Modi / BJP bashing …..sad to see India’s well known journalists unable to get over they being treated by BJP as persona non grata
How can "compelling idea" emerge, when to run the agenda of Bombay club, leadership has been stymied in Congress, the principle opposition party? BJP is basically Congress on steroids. There's no difference between the two as they both exist to serve few business houses and not the nation.
Gross miss understanding of BJP. BJP is run by RSS ideology good bad ugly you can decide Congress it is just for power.At the top family and at state level many leaders fight among themselves to be CM or state president I can name Punjab, Rajasthan and MP till Jyotiraditya left for BJP.
The problem of two journalists of two camps staying friends is difficult is because Both of them earn their bread from these proximity and closeness to the politicians. Niira radiya files ma'am.
Arun Shourue is a scholar journalist.Given his media experience n having worked with the BJP government,it is a pity that PM under the toxic influence of Late Arun Jaiteley kept him out of the cabinet I feel,even now it is too late if the PM can seek his scholarly guidance on many issues which the present government is caught I its own knots Oh yes,Kudos to Barkha Dutta for getting such a scholarly guest I feel Shri Arun Shourie should be a permanent guest of your panel
Shourie was a BIG admirer of Modi when he was just Guj.CM and aspiring to get back to Center. He was also an avid supporter & proponent of RSS. Just because Modi did not give him any job , ( He expected to be made Finance Minister) because of 2 strong detractors/enemies of his; Jailtley & Subramaniam Swamy who sabotaged his entry into Modi's inner circle. Modi liked Shourie, but a jobless, impatient Shourie lost his mind and started attacking Modi , thus lost his respect. Shourie brought Modi's dislike on himelf.
Arun Shourie commands his own following Kashmiri Punditji. Aapko mirchi kyun lag rahi hai? Great journalist with a spine. More power to you Barkha for covering.
I have been and still am a great FAN of Arun Shourie. His per5sonal life is a mess because of the illness of his Son & Wife. It hurts. He needed a position in Modi Govt. to take care of the situation, and he richly deserved it. But cruelty of Arun Jaitley & Swamy sabotaged his chances and poisoned Modi's mind.
he did not get the job because he was presumptuous and took modi for granted, modi did not owe him anything, he was , like all persons interviewed by modi at gujrat bhavan on 20/5/14 , specifically told not to discuss the matter with the media before a formal announcement wad made, but he did just the opposite , stood on the footpath outside gujrat bhavan and proclaimed himself to be the next finance minister of India, even had the arrogance to list the priorities before him
Shourie lamenting how journalists in old times when a bunch of elites in lutyens - all daughters & sons of former bureaucrats & top army officers sat together with politicians & designed policies & looted the hell out of a country of a billion where 99.99% had no say at all. You want those times back...no thankyou. No offense to barkha dutt. Her work has always been tremendous & has never sounded cocky.
The problem with lutyen's antiModi and antibjp media is when a former bjp leader now is critical of bjp and modi has become a secular intellectual person. Like most politician Arun shourie was a victim of circumstances to have gone astray in his political ideology today.
I have been watching interviews of Arun Shorie by Srinivasan Jain, Karan Thappar and now you are interviewing Shourie, with the same set of questions. It is so boring. Won't you think it is just a waste or is it the publisher of Shoeie's Latest book wanting promotion. I really respect Shorie and you.
TV news channel destroyed journalism. First time they run advertisement about themshelve, how great they are. Republic to NDTV, all self-boasting journalists.
Arun shourie has gone mad from the time he wasnt offered anything after 2014 winning . Arun used to be a hardcore hindutvawadi leader now just a dhimmi .
After 2009 election, when BJP lost, it was the same Arun Shourie who asked RSS to take over BJP completely, since the leadership of BJP as he described as 'Alice in Blunderland'. He was hardcore RSS supporter during 70's, 80's and even 90's. You can trust Arun Shourie the journalist to an extent but never after he become politician. He was hell-bent on removing Modi as CM after 2002 and pressurized Vajpayee but in vain. And when Modi became PM, he put Shourie in his place. Shourie never forgave that and became even more bitter, when he was denied ministry in Modi's cabinet. The person who once famously demanded that Government must follow a policy of “the jaw for a tooth, two eyes for an eye”, is appalled and outraged that criminals are being neutralized in Uttar Pradesh. From a raving Hindu radical to a liberal toadie, what a journey and an EPIC FALL!
@@saurabhsrivastava522 name calling shows you have zero logic in countering my statement. My bhakti is towards my religion and my nation, so take a long walk on a short cliff.
LOL. Advani and Burkha , scratching each others back. 2 losers. Advani called burkha for Tea and rest is History. He is just a footnote in history now. Panauti struck again.
Intellectual? Who decide that? He has been encouraged to speak about Modi and UP covid cases and Jeep case but, would not talk about West Bengal elections. Disgusting
Burkha Dutt, denier of Kashmir genocide, and provided a narrative for the justification of the genocide. Shourie bitter from not getting a cabinet place in the Modi government.
I used to read Arun Shori’s big and descriptive articles used to publish, I guess, in The Tribune or Punjab Kesari, especially his cohesive article on Babari mosque and Shahbano case, many years back and found him the most learned. But his stint as disinvestment minister, that was marred with disorganised and controversial decisions and ended himself a total failure then his going ballistic against Modi personally while picking so many petty issues coupled with far more trivial assertions here and there, has made him just a laughing stock, just like his sister Nalani Singh, who used to enjoy prime time presentation during congress rules and would hardly make any logical sense of her long verbose over articulation of issues. It’s so easy to speak eloquently or write authoritatively on matters and issues sitting in sumptuous settings but rather impossible to implement them on grounds, aptly justifiable in his case. He needs to be reminded that he used to be castigated brazenly when he was in Vajpayee’s government, by the same media to whose he has become darling of the dialogue only because his speaking against Modi not against BJP.
Mr.Shourie you have gone down in my esteem long back.Your dislike or opposition to Modi is no problem for me.But in your blind opposition you are negating yourself.I feel ashamed that at one point I was admiring you.Do I have to burn all your all earlier books that I have? Don't they speak the truth? World of Fatwas,Eminent Historians,Secular agenda,Etc... What a fall sir?Feel sorry for you.
That’s the problem when both the interviewer and the interviewee sit on the same side. It is not questions, but provoking to get a certain answers in a systematic way. “Journalism is not important” rightly said by Arun Shourie. Hindu Rashtra is something that is imagination of the journalists only, but for the last 300 years the agenda of Gazwa-e-Hind is conveniently glossed over. I find it strange that we close our eyes ‘selectively’ against such happenings. Yes, majority’s excesses against minority ought to be highlighted, but thing worth considering is why the majority do such things against only one minority, whereas the rest live safely & happily.
.MK Gandhi was neither Mahatma nor Rastra Pita of 1000yrs civilisation..Arun criticism of Modi-a story of sour grapes.And cerainly ,nothing wrong with Hindu Rastra.
Sour grapes 🍇 part of bjp wanted ministry in 2014, was all praise for bjp then. Didnt get the job. Now self appointed moral keeper like barkha. Hypocrites
Kaha yeh india ke top commanders ko dhamki diya karti thi , itna use power tha , government ka backup thaa Or aaj dekhlo Shankarsinh vaghela Arun shauri Jaise non relevant logoko bula ke kam chala rahehai 😏
Arun Shourie tells Barkha, "you personify" independent journalism. Your work is " historic". Congrats.
Fascinating interview. The moral of the lesson is , support those who are doing good work and be a fortress around them . It doesn't matter if you can not take on the fight yourself. Whenever Shourie speaks his honesty stands out , a rare quality to be found these days.
What to support them they'll start wagging as soon as they get sold off their job is done
Thank you Barkha. Love the conversation. Great to see Mr Shourie in public after a long time.
Barkha . Great interview. Nice that Arun brought out your brave work on Covid. During Covid you had requested people to give our spare smartphones for poor students for online classes. On your advise i distributed 8 smartphones to less privileged families. That is the change one honest journalist came bring in the society. Kudos
Arun shourie investigate journalism i n 1980 s &1992 s.
He was m.p. & minister in vajpayee govt.
He dominated aganist anti Rajiv campaign.
So honoured to see &listen.
All the best.
Great interview Shourie saab ..Thanks Barkha! ..love from Jammu.
Arun Shouroe has so much to share. Wish Barkha had asked relevant questions rather than looking for self validation from Shourie and play victim of self created political vendetta. He advised her to writing books.
Mr Shourie is institutions himself,super intellectual who present his opinion with strong reasoning. Actually he is the true nationalist and fearless one.
Shourie ji deserves all the respect and kudos 👏 he had been a fantastic son of Mother India , specifically for the sheer genius of his arguments devoid of any inkling to a conviction.....treat him like a debater not a coach or a guru ....respects
Arun shourie is a wonderful figure . His words are inspering & mind blowing... He bring the whole history in mind and eyes......
Excellent interview. Barkha couldn't muster courage to ask Shourie how he became such a great friend & admirer of Ambanis against whom he ran a campaign in his Indian Express days. Did he compromise? or Did he realise his past mistakes, or what? He has never talked on this. Perhaps that was the reason that Gurumurthy parted ways with Arun.
Same way I felt. UP’s result would have been different. Ravish, Avisar, Barkha,Ashutosh,Akash etc could bring huge change if they are watched by every citizen of India without any prejudice.
bjp 's win should be respected even though u disagree with them.
Out of blue moon how come pranav Roy, Burkha dutt, Shekar Gupta and Karan Thapar remember of Arun 🤔
Barkha, since morning this was my second interview with Arun Shourie. Earlier was with Karan Thapar. Very interesting conversation. His reference to Mr Goenka and Ex President Gyani Ji is hilarious. I wish sit with him over few issues to which I'm really confused. Another point you raised about past and present politicians, I feel those were well groomed and these are either unschooled or otherwise lack civic sense.
Tolerance or intolerance, not only a word of English dictionary, but it has become multi faced weapon in the hands of persons like Aaron Scourie. I am reading this gentleman for mfore than 40 years. He is articulate and has good literary skills. At the same time he is a man of shifting loyalty. His true face became known to all when he was a co petitioner in the Rafael Fighter case. After all a man with dirty mind and biased view.
I was huge fan of Shourie Sir but sad to see him with Barkha Dutta who is just using him as a cover fire against the people who questioned her role in many debacles
No one can erase gandhiji from the hearts of the people , you can criticize Gandhiji but can't ignore him or forget him if he was not their where is India? the present geography is the result of this man walking north south and east west, creating an awareness about the Indianness in the minds of the common people . If we ever try to forget him we will cease to exist.
This guy is great scholar ..well read ... he has enough knowledge to speak for right or left .. it all about where is standing .... one should know his view about RSS and BJP when he was in Government
Hi Barkha ! have been watching you over decades of your work, and let me add it has been a wonderful journey so far and am sure it shall continue to do so. Congratulations on finding ways to get your views across to us. Wanted to share that at around 25 minutes in the interview you have expressed that it is difficult to get admirers and those critical of the Government , especially of our P.M on the same dining table ( well i have paraphrased), though a rarity it still happening. Please continue to keep going there is a huge majority who still loves a good discussion, minus all the screaming.
If Modi were PM in 1970-80's and Indira in 2020's, this Arun Shourie interview would be full of praises for Modi and about how "things have changed for the worse".
Had Modi been PM in 1970-80's,we would have been another Pakistan ,full of conspiracy theories and hatred.
@@niranjankumar7550 Even in that case, Arun Shourie of 2020 would still say that "things today are even worse than 1970's." He is simply romanticizing the past.
bad comment
What Mr.Shourie said about Gandhiji being the major problem for RSS-BJP is spot on. It seems so obvious after he said it. RSS certainly doesn't have respect for Gandhiji.
Gandhi failed as the leader, to prevent hundreds of thousands of Hindus massacred and sent back in trains loads, in 1947 partition ... millions driven out of their ancestral homes, rendered refugees living on Railway platforms, my family was one of them ... !! ... no wonder he was killed ... !! ... no question of anyone respecting the character ... !!
Excellent conversation
My respect for Arun Shourie and KIRAN BEDI is Himalayan. The only person who can build bridges between Modiji and Arun Shourie is S.Gurumurthy so that ARUN SHOURIE AND KIRAN BEDI can be appointed as Governor of Maharashtra or Punjab or Maharashtra because the people of this country have noticed that both of them discharge their duties as responsible citizens as laid down in Article 51A of the Constitution. In fact both Arun Shourie and Indian Express are made for each other and also considered as the free voice of the people. Dear citizens if this doesn't work out, please pray to the Almighty that Arun Shourie should be taken back as editor of the Indian Express.
His journalism is marvelous
Every minute of my time spent watching this video was worth it. Lovely content. Tnx barkha and dr. Shourie
Clearly Shourie is old school. He has to make peace with his past and therefore this memoir now just so that he can cash in from his reputation. There will be few more books on provocative topics of which he is a master. God willing he lives long enough.
As for the host this could be a sunshine moment to bask in self glory. Always dubious & deceptive!
Jai Hind!
Very true..so old school.. what's the big deal in going and reporting covid using a camera? Dear Sir, the new India try to see what we can do to help our govt in times of COVID which is an unprecedented situation.. please this is not Congress govt, this govt is working with her people to make everybody's life better
"It's great see you here and thankfull for watching our yellow journalism here"
Incisive. @ArunShourie. Honour and privilege to listen to him. Such depth. Like #HinduRashtra or irrelevance of Nehru and aim to get rid of Mahatma Gandhi. And aim to bring unitary form of government through one nation one election. Listen to him carefully. Every word is a gem.
Barkha Radia discussing journalism ?? What an irony !!!
If one wonders why NDA-1 Govt of Vajpayee failed/ fell, the answer is here. It's because he trusted people like Shourie who were totally opposed to BJP ideology. This created discrepancy and dissonance.
Barkha dutt is the same journalist who blame the Kashmiri Pandits for their own Genocide...! Hats off to her fabulous Journalism that she can display terrorists as oppressed and oppressed as terrorists...!😇
Such a pleasure to see Mr Arun Shourie
Arun Shourie is so interesting but you just can’t be called a legendary journalist once you have had a ride in the gravy train of politics.
Arun Shourie : Master 🙏
Great conversation 👌
Sad that this good person has lost it calling Dutt an institution
Good work of madam barkha continues even after exit from NDTV
With all due respect to Mr. Shourie, M Modi did visit Mr. Shourie in Pune, when he was sick. Nehru arrested Sheik Abdullah, Indira arrested Acharya Kripalani to Mani Ben Patel (Daughter of Sardar Patel) to JP and others. Many many including Rajaji, others left Nehru cabinet and party as no one including Nehru cared for their views. (If they listened 1962 would NOT have happened and Indian economy would have been much better).
Now, no one calls Chariman Mao father of China or call Bismark as father of Germany or only George Washington as father of America. there is a reason for it. Countries have existed for thousands of years except America (where many are credited as founders of fathers). India too had existed as a even bigger nation under Mauryan Empire. If Gandhiji is the father of nation, then what do we call Mauryan empire ? (it was not Indian nation then ). One gets into all these issues. Besides, as Gandhiji himself said, people call me mahatma, but treat me like a sweeper (he was referring to his fellow congress men).
Finally, laws change based on what people want them to be. nothing is written in stone. Mr. Shourie is stretching argument to say India will become another Pakistan while ignoring that it's Indian civilization, that thousands years ago said, 'yekam sat, vipraha bahuda vadanti' when other civilization around the world are saying my way is highway. overall, sad to hear the interview, given the intellectual ability of Mr. Shourie
An admirer of yours though I am Barkha the topic shifted from the book to anti Modi / BJP bashing …..sad to see India’s well known journalists unable to get over they being treated by BJP as persona non grata
Great interview!
Excellent work 👍
How can "compelling idea" emerge, when to run the agenda of Bombay club, leadership has been stymied in Congress, the principle opposition party?
BJP is basically Congress on steroids.
There's no difference between the two as they both exist to serve few business houses and not the nation.
Gross miss understanding of BJP. BJP is run by RSS ideology good bad ugly you can decide Congress it is just for power.At the top family and at state level many leaders fight among themselves to be CM or state president I can name Punjab, Rajasthan and MP till Jyotiraditya left for BJP.
@@vishvapradhan8476 Hindutva Terrorists ideology vs stupid congress power family nautanki
Good interaction barkha
Thnks barkha for connecting us with this great legend 💓🙏
The problem of two journalists of two camps staying friends is difficult is because Both of them earn their bread from these proximity and closeness to the politicians. Niira radiya files ma'am.
But i like wion and palki sharma, the only channel with unbiased and researched journalism.
Sterling interview, to be watched again nd again. Really relished. Barkha may have flaws but she is a journalist of some class.
Arun Shourue is a scholar journalist.Given his media experience n having worked with the BJP government,it is a pity that PM under the toxic influence of Late Arun Jaiteley kept him out of the cabinet
I feel,even now it is too late if the PM can seek his scholarly guidance on many issues which the present government is caught I its own knots
Oh yes,Kudos to Barkha Dutta for getting such a scholarly guest
I feel Shri Arun Shourie should be a permanent guest of your panel
Shourie was a BIG admirer of Modi when he was just Guj.CM and aspiring to get back to Center. He was also an avid supporter & proponent of RSS. Just because Modi did not give him any job , ( He expected to be made Finance Minister) because of 2 strong detractors/enemies of his; Jailtley & Subramaniam Swamy who sabotaged his entry into Modi's inner circle. Modi liked Shourie, but a jobless, impatient Shourie lost his mind and started attacking Modi , thus lost his respect. Shourie brought Modi's dislike on himelf.
Suddenly how come Arun Shourie is being a centre of interest amongst basu, barkha and karan - people strongly opposing BJP
Arun Shourie commands his own following Kashmiri Punditji. Aapko mirchi kyun lag rahi hai?
Great journalist with a spine. More power to you Barkha for covering.
Bharka,that is so true,these days if you are not with me you are against.
Don't agree with much of what Barkha says or what her biased guests say, but her passion is admirable
He knows what he’s talking about
And he keeps learning on what he identify earlier
* didn't identify
Indian Media needs journalist like barkha dutt...no cheekho pukaar...no nonsense talk... Respec from Pakistan 💚
I have been and still am a great FAN of Arun Shourie. His per5sonal life is a mess because of the illness of his Son & Wife. It hurts. He needed a position in Modi Govt. to take care of the situation, and he richly deserved it. But cruelty of Arun Jaitley & Swamy sabotaged his chances and poisoned Modi's mind.
he did not get the job because he was presumptuous and took modi for granted, modi did not owe him anything, he was , like all persons interviewed by modi at gujrat bhavan on 20/5/14 , specifically told not to discuss the matter with the media before a formal announcement wad made, but he did just the opposite , stood on the footpath outside gujrat bhavan and proclaimed himself to be the next finance minister of India, even had the arrogance to list the priorities before him
How one wishes that Shourie had remained a journalist and not drifted to other fields.
Hindu Rashtra is the only alternative to the cleansing which is bad.
Shourie lamenting how journalists in old times when a bunch of elites in lutyens - all daughters & sons of former bureaucrats & top army officers sat together with politicians & designed policies & looted the hell out of a country of a billion where 99.99% had no say at all. You want those times back...no thankyou.
No offense to barkha dutt. Her work has always been tremendous & has never sounded cocky.
Love u ARUN SHOURIE SIR
The problem with lutyen's antiModi and antibjp media is when a former bjp leader now is critical of bjp and modi has become a secular intellectual person. Like most politician Arun shourie was a victim of circumstances to have gone astray in his political ideology today.
I have been watching interviews of Arun Shorie by Srinivasan Jain, Karan Thappar and now you are interviewing Shourie, with the same set of questions. It is so boring. Won't you think it is just a waste or is it the publisher of Shoeie's Latest book wanting promotion. I really respect Shorie and you.
Just a case of S(h)our(ie) grapes
Damn good
Plz stop hypocracy n do justice to ur profession
The Angry Crusader.. d Greatest n d most Fearless Journalist
Will you speak on Karauli and law order in Rajasthan.
I have admired Arun Shourie all along.But the way he has referred to the concept of Hindu Rashtra today is intellectually dishonest.
Sad indeed.
Barkha personification of any "journalism"!!! 😆🤣
TV news channel destroyed journalism. First time they run advertisement about themshelve, how great they are. Republic to NDTV, all self-boasting journalists.
He may sound very wise and all but remember he became bitter after modi didn't made him Minister.
Yes media concerned discussion , victim itself have to blamed for his death or reporting that can jeopardize state security
Arun shourie has gone mad from the time he wasnt offered anything after 2014 winning .
Arun used to be a hardcore hindutvawadi leader now just a dhimmi .
After 2009 election, when BJP lost, it was the same Arun Shourie who asked RSS to take over BJP completely, since the leadership of BJP as he described as 'Alice in Blunderland'. He was hardcore RSS supporter during 70's, 80's and even 90's. You can trust Arun Shourie the journalist to an extent but never after he become politician.
He was hell-bent on removing Modi as CM after 2002 and pressurized Vajpayee but in vain. And when Modi became PM, he put Shourie in his place. Shourie never forgave that and became even more bitter, when he was denied ministry in Modi's cabinet.
The person who once famously demanded that Government must follow a policy of “the jaw for a tooth, two eyes for an eye”, is appalled and outraged that criminals are being neutralized in Uttar Pradesh.
From a raving Hindu radical to a liberal toadie, what a journey and an EPIC FALL!
Put Shourie in his place? Speaks volumes about ur intellactual capabilities. Please stick to doing bhakti of chai waalah.
@@saurabhsrivastava522 name calling shows you have zero logic in countering my statement. My bhakti is towards my religion and my nation, so take a long walk on a short cliff.
@@SV2609 Om ka logo laga ke itna gussa!! Take a lamba saans Nafrati chintu.
If hypocrisy had a name it would be Shourie. This man would sell his soul if given a place in Modi's cabinet.
LOL. Advani and Burkha , scratching each others back. 2 losers. Advani called burkha for Tea and rest is History. He is just a footnote in history now. Panauti struck again.
Hindu-Muslim devide isn't NDA origin.
Shourie misses the JINNAH narrative. It began with him.
Burka..your proudest moment should be..neera radia tapes
Intellectual? Who decide that? He has been encouraged to speak about Modi and UP covid cases and Jeep case but, would not talk about West Bengal elections. Disgusting
JUST ANTI BJP
poor fellow , did not get any job even after being interviewed on 20/5/2014
Full support to Arnab Goswami.I feel proud to watch his channel.
सत्ता के लोभ में शौरी जी ने अपनी विचारधारा को त्याग दिया। तब भी मैं उनका अनादर नहीं करूंगा।
sad to see him blabber like this... congress has no agenda! kya ho gaya inko..
This old bad man is not recognising our civilization .he is pairside of our nation
Burkha Dutt, denier of Kashmir genocide, and provided a narrative for the justification of the genocide. Shourie bitter from not getting a cabinet place in the Modi government.
Barkha's questions are more irrelevant, better questions could have asked. After all the woman is biased.
I used to read Arun Shori’s big and descriptive articles used to publish, I guess, in The Tribune or Punjab Kesari, especially his cohesive article on Babari mosque and Shahbano case, many years back and found him the most learned. But his stint as disinvestment minister, that was marred with disorganised and controversial decisions and ended himself a total failure then his going ballistic against Modi personally while picking so many petty issues coupled with far more trivial assertions here and there, has made him just a laughing stock, just like his sister Nalani Singh, who used to enjoy prime time presentation during congress rules and would hardly make any logical sense of her long verbose over articulation of issues. It’s so easy to speak eloquently or write authoritatively on matters and issues sitting in sumptuous settings but rather impossible to implement them on grounds, aptly justifiable in his case. He needs to be reminded that he used to be castigated brazenly when he was in Vajpayee’s government, by the same media to whose he has become darling of the dialogue only because his speaking against Modi not against BJP.
Yeh unmarried widow hai jism dhal Gaya hai
Spell check - pamphleteering
Mr.Shourie you have gone down in my esteem long back.Your dislike or opposition to Modi is no problem for me.But in your blind opposition you are negating yourself.I feel ashamed that at one point I was admiring you.Do I have to burn all your all earlier books that I have?
Don't they speak the truth?
World of Fatwas,Eminent Historians,Secular agenda,Etc...
What a fall sir?Feel sorry for you.
That’s the problem when both the interviewer and the interviewee sit on the same side. It is not questions, but provoking to get a certain answers in a systematic way. “Journalism is not important” rightly said by Arun Shourie. Hindu Rashtra is something that is imagination of the journalists only, but for the last 300 years the agenda of Gazwa-e-Hind is conveniently glossed over. I find it strange that we close our eyes ‘selectively’ against such happenings. Yes, majority’s excesses against minority ought to be highlighted, but thing worth considering is why the majority do such things against only one minority, whereas the rest live safely & happily.
hegde, devi lal...kya bekar leaders hain?
.MK Gandhi was neither Mahatma nor Rastra Pita of 1000yrs civilisation..Arun criticism of Modi-a story of sour grapes.And cerainly ,nothing wrong with Hindu Rastra.
Sour grapes 🍇 part of bjp wanted ministry in 2014, was all praise for bjp then. Didnt get the job. Now self appointed moral keeper like barkha. Hypocrites
VERY DISGRUNTLED MAN
WAS PRAISING MODI UPTILL 2014
AND NOT ADJUSTING WITH HIS DESTINY
He is irrelevant . He used be different man then. Now self centric
Barkha dutta should also write her memoirs. She is as irrelevant as Arun shourie.
Stop journalism Barkha Dutt. Stop acting
"Today's Media is not worth watching!?" And so are you Arun Shourie!
Anti India channel needs to do a coverage on your friend and accomplice Rana Ayuub on swindling money and her anti national activities.
"Anti India" used by BJP and its blind followers to cover up their failures,incompetence and short comings.
Kaha yeh india ke top commanders ko dhamki diya karti thi , itna use power tha , government ka backup thaa
Or aaj dekhlo
Shankarsinh vaghela
Arun shauri
Jaise non relevant logoko bula ke kam chala rahehai 😏