I had to point out to my mother years ago that there was simply no way her idyllic farm in the mountains was not possible without helpers and state backing. 😂
Its possible, as I've had actual family members do it back in China when I used to visit them, but they would definitely not look that good without money. In other words, the farming and skills she displayed are real (as some of my family's friends were subsistence farmers), but the environment she is in, is more or less impossible unless she had a lot of money to make it look nice. They definitely looked much shoddier. But it makes sense, since she's doing it for the show, so obviously, either she has a lot of money or she has some media company bank rolling the investment environment (which explains why she was gone for 3 years). I really like her videos regardless, and I don't really care if they are fake, since 95% of all youtube videos are fake anyways. At least this fake video is nice to look at, and the things she is doing is more or less real (cause I've seen them do it first hand, courtesy of a long lineage of farmers back in the mainland china). IMO, its literally just a homesteading video, and I take it as such, not some explicit form of propaganda, as I also watch people garden in the western countries. And the videos aren't that much different. What she's doing isn't farming, its just gardening and homesteading. Completely different from for profit farming or subsistence farming.
@GizzyDillespee Yes, an advertisement on how beautiful China is. When it comes to propaganda, the Chinese Communist Party is an expert of various ways.
The fact that she uses rural farming lives as her theme in video but when 99.9% of farmers in CCP china are living in deep shxt that's the problem. Who are Disney abusing? Superheroes? Mice? Of course Disney corp is an evil company. But internet comments are taking about how she's using the skills but making people forget about the suffering of farmers.
Honestly, I could care less if her videos are propaganda. They're relaxing and beautiful and do more than "promote country life" they show how to enjoy life and live presently when it's hellish.
One mistake is to assume she was an “independent” content creator before. The fact she can openly go into TH-cam shows she has always had the CCP backing. No other way around in China. It’s like to assume the Chinese who buy real state overseas are “clean” money, it’s impossible
look at those people in the comments always make things political just because she is from china. can't people just enjoy videos without making it political
Yes, but the CCP makes everything, and I mean everything a political act, so Li Ziqi is also their stooge by fabricating reality. It's skilfully made fiction , but sell it as fiction (or historical life), but not a reality.
Oh we know its not real rural China, but we love the fantasy story anyway. She still put in a lot of work to make those videos, regardless how its perceived as propaganda or not, that’s on the viewer.
'We know it is not real rural China'? Why then does she claim that it is exactly that? When people go to Disneyland they do not tell them its real.This is simply nothing more than deceit.
I mean, it's clear there's a large "contingent" of people who make all that land she's on for the agriculture and infrastructure to actually exist for her to then do her "projects". In the real world that sort of property would be a LARGE multi-generational wealthy Chinese family who would be working the property and doing all those projects in order to sell the fruits of it to continue that wealth.
a true chinese patriot..showing what a great life there is in farming, fishing, and living in the countryside...some idiots are angry because they have miserable city...
I didn’t know she owned that many companies. There’s no way, she just sits back on her country home and learns new arts and crafts for months at a time like her videos suggest. Also I do admire her originality before the corporate backing began
She decided to join force with big corporate for big money. So she show the greedy side of her. Since people claim she is so talented, why she wants to work with big corporate..
It probably helps that she is beautiful, but her content is interesting because her story is interesting. It's like she refuses to give up, and she has a lot of interesting manual skills and knowledge that are becoming things people wish that they knew because it's so rare for anyone to have those types of skills anymore.
what's wrong with a little escapism? Sure, you can stage plenty of things with cinematography and filters, but why is it a default attitude to tear her down. Would such a life with such aesthetic be potentially possible, perhaps in the non-industrialised rural parts of China? I mean considering the fact that she has been producing this aesthetic for a while now. Surely, she can't have had CCP backing for her entire career as a content creator. It seems like this video only wants to highlight all the criticism levelled against her rather than entertaining any potential alternatives and it just seems like it's done in bad faith.
Definitely you don’t know the reality on the ground in China. She was a DJ, got a CCP papa to promote her. It works like this in China. She is as fake as Lee Kuan Yew in Singapore
I feel people want to hate her for doing a good job. i do hate the ccp take over her stuff. At least she showed a fantastic china country side. I kinda never felt she was tricking me. This is like saying travel vlog is reality.
ok C/O lighten up on the constant china bashings. next you will be going after wang yan and her TH-cam channel little Chinese everywhere. get a life. Li Ziqi is an artist and the medium is beautiful cinematography and music. we view her projects as witness to the wonderful creative culture of china through the centuries. it is fact presented in a fictional manner that grabs our attention and emotions. I love the young woman's being and fully understand the difference between beauty and the beast. so should you.
I view Li Ziqi's videos as requiring far too much money, effort, time, space, skills, and resources to be anything close to real life. If anything, real videos of rural China become even uglier in comparison.
There is risk with her bucolic videos. If people see the real poverty in rural China, then this backfires against the CCP. If young people are lured to the countryside by the high unemployment in the cites and experienced the realities of a poverty stricken life there, far removed from Li Ziqi's romantic views saturaing her videos, this will also backfire
The quality of her videos has always been too high for it to be realistic. That doesn’t mean it isn’t beautiful. “Cottage core” is similar. A sort of fantasy version of a romanticised past. Only young people and fools would think it achievable IRL.
If that really was her backstory then she deserves all the fame and recognition of the world. A farmer girl from a small background turned into a millionair with hard work, tradition and virtue. Sadly she was used as propaganda machine to me milked. I hope she broke out of it.
I use to think her camera man was a ghost because it should be only her and her grandma right? So who's doing the recording behind the camera, let's call in the ghost hunters for her.
Her videos are wonderful! They capture the simple life we all need. I was really sad when she stopped posting videos; I feared she might have been taken by the government for refusing to comply with their demands.
Damn leave the poor women alone. First i highly doubt the she is pushing any propaganda and secondly even if she does it's ok to toe the party line juat to stay safe and prosper.
I love watching her videos, they relax me. I know she is a hard core communist an realize that her videos are staged. As an American I can enjoy her content without it affecting my politics , which happens to be MAGA all the way. I'm free to enjoy Li Ziqi videos without censorship. I think she is beautiful and the idyllic culture she exhibits is as well. She is providing a service for me to enjoy, isn't that what it's really all about ?
I had to point out to my mother years ago that there was simply no way her idyllic farm in the mountains was not possible without helpers and state backing. 😂
Its possible, as I've had actual family members do it back in China when I used to visit them, but they would definitely not look that good without money. In other words, the farming and skills she displayed are real (as some of my family's friends were subsistence farmers), but the environment she is in, is more or less impossible unless she had a lot of money to make it look nice. They definitely looked much shoddier.
But it makes sense, since she's doing it for the show, so obviously, either she has a lot of money or she has some media company bank rolling the investment environment (which explains why she was gone for 3 years).
I really like her videos regardless, and I don't really care if they are fake, since 95% of all youtube videos are fake anyways.
At least this fake video is nice to look at, and the things she is doing is more or less real (cause I've seen them do it first hand, courtesy of a long lineage of farmers back in the mainland china).
IMO, its literally just a homesteading video, and I take it as such, not some explicit form of propaganda, as I also watch people garden in the western countries. And the videos aren't that much different.
What she's doing isn't farming, its just gardening and homesteading. Completely different from for profit farming or subsistence farming.
Everything looks like an advertisement. No weeds, no branch out of place, nothing dirty, professional camera style and lighting.
@GizzyDillespee Yes, an advertisement on how beautiful China is.
When it comes to propaganda, the Chinese Communist Party is an expert of various ways.
You are a very wise man
@@GizzyDillespee It's obviously all fake. No rural farmer has the time or resources to make anything this professional.
Watch her start promoting the tourism industry for China and its rural side lol
Yes, you nailed it well!
She will have more videos on how beautiful China is.
Yup they already started when China brought every single western TH-camr to China in October and November to record food content ect
Here come the "I think it can't be propaganda, because I like the aesthetics" comments
如果是宣传，为什么停止更新三年？
It makes sense they'd want to bring her back since they're trying to draw young people back to the countryside.
Disneyland is not real either, yet many around the world loves it!!
But Disney doesn’t commit Genocide like the Chinese government… Maybe… 😅
The fact that she uses rural farming lives as her theme in video but when 99.9% of farmers in CCP china are living in deep shxt that's the problem. Who are Disney abusing? Superheroes? Mice? Of course Disney corp is an evil company. But internet comments are taking about how she's using the skills but making people forget about the suffering of farmers.
Disneyland is not backed by the government to promotethe country, so... you're wrong 😂
Isn’t TH-cam banned in China? kind of ironic
Their people are banned from it. Only propaganda is allowed to be shown from China.
Honestly, I could care less if her videos are propaganda. They're relaxing and beautiful and do more than "promote country life" they show how to enjoy life and live presently when it's hellish.
She is great🥰
I love her videos. I know it is way to idealized, but the cinematography is top notch.
One mistake is to assume she was an “independent” content creator before. The fact she can openly go into TH-cam shows she has always had the CCP backing. No other way around in China.
It’s like to assume the Chinese who buy real state overseas are “clean” money, it’s impossible
it's so obvious because her video content is all about promoting tourism 😂 yes i've watched her videos years ago.
I've unsubscribed from her channel years ago after hearing her join the ccp. She does make good videos, yes.
OH MY GOSH, I'D THOUGHT SHE'D NEVER BE ABLE TO COME BACK!!
look at those people in the comments always make things political just because she is from china. can't people just enjoy videos without making it political
Yes, but the CCP makes everything, and I mean everything a political act, so Li Ziqi is also their stooge by fabricating reality. It's skilfully made fiction , but sell it as fiction (or historical life), but not a reality.
you just gave the answer, it's from china, which is illegal to even post on youtube
Oh we know its not real rural China, but we love the fantasy story anyway. She still put in a lot of work to make those videos, regardless how its perceived as propaganda or not, that’s on the viewer.
'We know it is not real rural China'? Why then does she claim that it is exactly that? When people go to Disneyland they do not tell them its real.This is simply nothing more than deceit.
I mean, it's clear there's a large "contingent" of people who make all that land she's on for the agriculture and infrastructure to actually exist for her to then do her "projects".
In the real world that sort of property would be a LARGE multi-generational wealthy Chinese family who would be working the property and doing all those projects in order to sell the fruits of it to continue that wealth.
Winnie milking li zigi
There is 3S policy that is Sex, Screen, and Sports. LI Ziqi play great roll in Screen. ie Cultural Propaganda.
And when she was a DJ, she was good at the other two S 😅
a true chinese patriot..showing what a great life there is in farming, fishing, and living in the countryside...some idiots are angry because they have miserable city...
I didn’t know she owned that many companies. There’s no way, she just sits back on her country home and learns new arts and crafts for months at a time like her videos suggest. Also I do admire her originality before the corporate backing began
She decided to join force with big corporate for big money. So she show the greedy side of her. Since people claim she is so talented, why she wants to work with big corporate..
After this, she's become powerful under CCP control.. it's kinda scary.. even the weinian company quit to disturb her 😮
I dare you to make a beautiful video as good as her😂
It's interesting that Li Ziqi has returned😂😂😂😅😅😅
I still won’t visit ccpland while Xi’s in charge.
Lol, Xi is much of a puppet to the banksters as most all world leaders. If he leaves, the next will be the same.
CCP never change
lol as if a different person will help
@@davidsong4682 exactly
It will be worthy spot to visit once it is turn into a glass parking lot.
She’s the Queen of Fake, her orphaned story is most likely not true as well. Come on, she was a DJ, definitely she has some powerful CCP papa
Even her mom is fake.
It probably helps that she is beautiful, but her content is interesting because her story is interesting. It's like she refuses to give up, and she has a lot of interesting manual skills and knowledge that are becoming things people wish that they knew because it's so rare for anyone to have those types of skills anymore.
what's wrong with a little escapism? Sure, you can stage plenty of things with cinematography and filters, but why is it a default attitude to tear her down. Would such a life with such aesthetic be potentially possible, perhaps in the non-industrialised rural parts of China? I mean considering the fact that she has been producing this aesthetic for a while now. Surely, she can't have had CCP backing for her entire career as a content creator. It seems like this video only wants to highlight all the criticism levelled against her rather than entertaining any potential alternatives and it just seems like it's done in bad faith.
Definitely you don’t know the reality on the ground in China. She was a DJ, got a CCP papa to promote her. It works like this in China. She is as fake as Lee Kuan Yew in Singapore
Li Ziqi, I CCP robot.
li ziqi is the best no1 in the world 🌎
I feel people want to hate her for doing a good job. i do hate the ccp take over her stuff. At least she showed a fantastic china country side. I kinda never felt she was tricking me. This is like saying travel vlog is reality.
ok C/O lighten up on the constant china bashings. next you will be going after wang yan and her TH-cam channel little Chinese everywhere. get a life. Li Ziqi is an artist and the medium is beautiful cinematography and music. we view her projects as witness to the wonderful creative culture of china through the centuries. it is fact presented in a fictional manner that grabs our attention and emotions. I love the young woman's being and fully understand the difference between beauty and the beast. so should you.
She is clearly joined CCP.
I view Li Ziqi's videos as requiring far too much money, effort, time, space, skills, and resources to be anything close to real life. If anything, real videos of rural China become even uglier in comparison.
There is risk with her bucolic videos. If people see the real poverty in rural China, then this backfires against the CCP. If young people are lured to the countryside by the high unemployment in the cites and experienced the realities of a poverty stricken life there, far removed from Li Ziqi's romantic views saturaing her videos, this will also backfire
The quality of her videos has always been too high for it to be realistic. That doesn’t mean it isn’t beautiful. “Cottage core” is similar. A sort of fantasy version of a romanticised past. Only young people and fools would think it achievable IRL.
Who is that?
At the end , she also wants money. Money is the most important thing from her video.
She looks kind of different outside of her videos. Was she using beauty filters the whole time?
Is not that serious smh, just watch entertainment!
Oh, the 304 is back.
She should retire from making video contents, get married and live a quiet life.
Ironic how the C.c.P tried to destroy ancient Chin.nese culture then using her to revive what they almost completely destroyed.😂😂3
oh thats why i dont see her a long months
with 506subscribers only why are telling story.how your channel base on fact? same ziqis chanel not atlest she is doing well.
CCP backing...
If that really was her backstory then she deserves all the fame and recognition of the world. A farmer girl from a small background turned into a millionair with hard work, tradition and virtue. Sadly she was used as propaganda machine to me milked. I hope she broke out of it.
CCP official mistress?
This channel has so much negativity
Her videos are soooo fake!
Winnie the pooh's subordinate.
I use to think her camera man was a ghost because it should be only her and her grandma right? So who's doing the recording behind the camera, let's call in the ghost hunters for her.
Stop using the word influencer
If the 2021 incident didn't happen, then I would still believe Li Ziqi videos. I just watch them now for entertainment.
What a channel full of hate and false info. Just shut it if you don like it.
😏
Meh still fun to watch
Her videos are wonderful! They capture the simple life we all need. I was really sad when she stopped posting videos; I feared she might have been taken by the government for refusing to comply with their demands.
You Mean fake simple life😂😅
@@Ginalopez7877You spot it on!
Did you not listen to the vid are all ?? 😂😂
Weirdo her videos are fake propaganda
@@Ginalopez7877 You could say the exact same thing from any of these "lifestyle" videos.
Damn leave the poor women alone. First i highly doubt the she is pushing any propaganda and secondly even if she does it's ok to toe the party line juat to stay safe and prosper.
Hating because their faulin gong propaganda is less popular 😂
Simping for a Communist propagandist is certainly something Nietzsche's Last Man would say.
Its not reality !! That's the definition of propaganda! 😂😂🤦♀️ talk about hook line and sinkern😂😂😂
She's a millionaire
@anonymousnoticer I wasn't talking about money. Didn't you hear her story?
Leave Li Ziqi alone, you just sound petty and sour grapes
This channel is always sour grapes!
we loved watching her videos but her new videos are much, "choppier" than her old ones. like watching a liam neeson action movie.
GOD BLESS ELON MUSK AND OUR MAGA HEROES
I love watching her videos, they relax me. I know she is a hard core communist an realize that her videos are staged. As an American I can enjoy her content without it affecting my politics , which happens to be MAGA all the way. I'm free to enjoy Li Ziqi videos without censorship. I think she is beautiful and the idyllic culture she exhibits is as well.
She is providing a service for me to enjoy, isn't that what it's really all about ?