The composition is nifty, but the performance really makes this. I'm astonished that this is just two performers, and their shared sense of timing is incredible.
The composition is what makes the performance lol. Like yeah, they performed it beautifully, but anyone performing the composition correctly would do the same. Not saying it's easy I just think it's funny you value the performance over the composition.
What about the composition ? It's a percussion piece and you can reduce the most important to 5 or 6 : Rebounds, Ionisation, Les Guetteurs de son, …they do a real job, of amazing taste…and the As One title is enough to understand the composition, no ?
In high school I had the amazing and wonderful privilege to play with some of the most talented percussionists I have ever known. This reminds of the many times watching in awe of their artistry. Thanks for the memories. You all know who you are.
Might sounds really cheesy but in a way this is a physical representation of what humanity could be like if everything was ideal. Not realistically, but theoretically. It's beautiful, even as a dream
Marvellous performance by two REAL Drummers. Impeccable timing together, great tempos, and excellent work moving in and out of different time signatures. Wonderful. Thank you.
Every single time I went through this piece I found something new that had been overlooked in the previous run. Every time my brain melts and I have to come back to it and give it yet another listen.
I was having exactly the same thoughts as both of you :) Then the mind naturally strays to what if...Bruford and Bozzio set out to play this piece...and then how would they alter it given electronic percussion &cet...and then...just listen to it again
"I've got and idea," said Gene Koshinski, while drunk from vodka, "How about I have two people splitting one thing on one hand and split a completely different thing on another hand?" Gene twiddled his thumbs and began envisioning his new piece that would be called As One.
My best friend and I in high school bought and practiced this for hours, days and weeks. Never came close. Almost 10 years later and still cannot come close to the incredible performance these two put on and most likely never will. Well, maybe in another 10-20 years give or take 😂
Tries to work out time signature: Brain melts This was one of the most impressive pieces of performance art I have ever experienced!!! Glad I was wearing headphones to get more of the nuances. Well done gentlemen.
a sublime, gorgeous, and perfect illustration of using elements: "home" "tension" and "variation".. .musically. These three ingredients, in my opinion, are the basics for absolutely ALL art forms, of any kind. What makes it special.. is one more ingredient: "surprise"..... xo
This was awesome, great stuff and the other videos of these guys as well. The only issue, is that is was too short and I wanted more lol. Have no fear "loop" is here. For all of you who do not know this, you can right click the play button and then click "loop" for it to replay as soon as it is over. Do this with all your favs that are short so you do not have too go back to your device to click it again. Also, if you never want ads on your YT or web pages, I have been using ad blocker plus for years and its free and awesome. I have seen comments where they say you can scroll the video to the end, then click play and the ads are not there; not sure as I dont have to do that. Love and Peace to all Lifeforms. Love Chris
I see I watched this a year ago and commented that it is amazing. Well, the second time through was even more amazing ! Looking forward to the 3rd viewing....
The composition is nifty, but the performance really makes this. I'm astonished that this is just two performers, and their shared sense of timing is incredible.
John Ladasky it is called “as one”
John Ladasky kinda the point of a percussion duo, specially for a duet titled “as one”
The composition is what makes the performance lol. Like yeah, they performed it beautifully, but anyone performing the composition correctly would do the same. Not saying it's easy I just think it's funny you value the performance over the composition.
What about the composition ? It's a percussion piece and you can reduce the most important to 5 or 6 : Rebounds, Ionisation, Les Guetteurs de son, …they do a real job, of amazing taste…and the As One title is enough to understand the composition, no ?
Really?
this is the soundtrack to the hardest crash bandicoot level ever
LOL So true
kkkkkk
Yooooo I'm high as a kite watching this and was thinking the same thing. Lol
not enough hihat... stewart copeland loves his hihat
@@zacharykoedyker3978 hahaha same
this is the most impressive exhibition of coordination and coupling I have ever seen
Watch the free internet pornography; it has both in abundance.
- So I play the marimba...
- No, I wanna play the marimba.
- ... Ok, hear me out...
underrated comment XD
In high school I had the amazing and wonderful privilege to play with some of the most talented percussionists I have ever known. This reminds of the many times watching in awe of their artistry. Thanks for the memories. You all know who you are.
After only 20 years of practice, these two percussionists finally preformed their piece.
This takes splits to a whole different level
Ethan Lyons those aren't even splits, they're like the same freaking person 😂
The fact that there is no metronome going is just showing how solid their timing really is.
dude they are the metronome.
うますぎる 二人で交互に叩いて連打するところとかやばい
すご
わかる。
Huh
The level of coordination, concentration, and timing you would need for this is insane
これはすごい！！！
なんていうか、飽きずに最後まで見れる
息ぴったりだし、叩いた時の音色同じだしとりあえずすごい！！！！
Might sounds really cheesy but in a way this is a physical representation of what humanity could be like if everything was ideal. Not realistically, but theoretically. It's beautiful, even as a dream
Smoking weed?
Yes, it could be the reality.
Marvellous performance by two REAL Drummers. Impeccable timing together, great tempos, and excellent work moving in and out of different time signatures. Wonderful. Thank you.
People, this are individuals who worked their life for such talent. This is pure musicianship.
This was incredible.
Awe inspiring.
Too bad you will never be incredible, noob.
David Jenkins You’re right. You’ll miss me when I’m gone.
This is incredible....or That was incredible...never "
this was"
Please tell me why this does not have over 10 million views? What a composition and performance. Kudos and bravo!!!
I have to watch it again. The only thing i could hear the first time was the sound of my brain melting in astonishment
Every single time I went through this piece I found something new that had been overlooked in the previous run. Every time my brain melts and I have to come back to it and give it yet another listen.
I'm just amazed at the sense of time these people have. This is some extremely hard stuff to pull off without messing up time. Bravo to those lads
Thank you. I'm at a loss for words
”Hey so have you written the second part yet?”
”Ah damn! I forgot... but wait...
*I have an even better idea* ”
Talk about clean
This is the most King Crimson thing I've ever listened to
Zappa too!
I was having exactly the same thoughts as both of you :)
Then the mind naturally strays to what if...Bruford and Bozzio set out to play this piece...and then how would they alter it given electronic percussion &cet...and then...just listen to it again
bidibum I was thinking the exact same thing. Sounds like Drumsons
I was thinking more of Carl Palmer (ELP) but there's some overlap there because of Greg Lake's time with Fripp.
This is true left and right independence
OK that page turn looked so satisfying
Fantastically musical, not just a showpiece. Loved the dynamics and pacing of the whole thing.
Watched this once more this morning, It gets better every time.
Thanks who ever liked my previous comment, needed to here this peace again..
Damn new Donkey Kong OST sounds amazing
That was my first thought too
Splits on splits on splits, then they split different different subdivisions on different hands! Splitception....
good lord. This is insanely good!
"I've got and idea," said Gene Koshinski, while drunk from vodka, "How about I have two people splitting one thing on one hand and split a completely different thing on another hand?" Gene twiddled his thumbs and began envisioning his new piece that would be called As One.
I mean you’re not wrong... XD
He for sure twiddle his thumbs
Him with all his pieces😭
How could anyone actually dislike this? This is beautiful.
My best friend and I in high school bought and practiced this for hours, days and weeks. Never came close. Almost 10 years later and still cannot come close to the incredible performance these two put on and most likely never will. Well, maybe in another 10-20 years give or take 😂
this time signature gives me ANXIETY
Which one?
Time signature has left the chat
would you believe it's 6/8? ... well mostly ;) They also speed up and slow down the main pulse so there are confusing moments
Well, in that case ... you should never listen to Farmer's Market. Try dancing to this: pcGPT3QlRmM
@@kebman The singer sounds like Kermit had an aneurysm
This is one of those gems that you favorite and show friends you know will greatly appreciate it
Awesome! Kept my attention the whole time
This is so complex , clean mind melting, As a percussionist I am still taking it in.
That gave me chills the whole way through.
*tries to figure out time signature*
time signatures? where we are going, we dont neeed, time signatures
seriously what it?
@@bencarter8324 It changes to much to nail down.
4/4, 5/4, 3/4, 2/4, 12/8, 7/8, 6/8, 5/8 -- I checked the score and it has basically everything
@@cykwan8534 Yeah, that's the pointlessly researched version of what I said.
good lord. incredible.
That's an incredibly well performed piece. Really amazing independence and timing. Wow
If only our world’s leaders could work together like this...
FANTASTIC !!! THANK YOU !!!! THE GREAT TERRY BOZZIO WILL BE PROUD !!!!
I think I can see and hear a middle influence of musical theater and repetitive music…quite beautiful ! Bravissimi !!!
That's seriously impressive
As One the perfect title to a flawless performance.
How? How does someone's mind work like that? It was breaking my brain just watching them. I will never be this talented.
Amazing. I want a marimba like that. Love the symmetry on camera.
l'effet "miroir", la musique, ce sens rythmique d'un autre monde, cette improbable chorégraphie : c'est presque surréaliste, voir "dada". Chapeau !
The greatest performance I have ever seen.
Thanks for coming to my school u guys rock
AMAZING, TIMBRE, CLIMAX, THE COMPOSITION, DYNAMICS..... WHEN YOU ARE PLAYING YOU ARE ONE. ¡MUSIC OF SPHERES. CONGRATULATION!!!
Never seen splits like this with a marimba in the setup. Great work!
Fantastic! Perfect! Bravo!!!
That was breathtaking, balanced and melodically outstanding. An amazing piece of work by two very talented guys.
What wonderful music, and the three consecutive passages are very cool even though the two of them are playing together.
I love this kind of music.
Brilliant and gorgeous set-up!
Wow! Unbelievable. Just unbelievable.
Best percussion video I’ve ever seen.
Wow, the performance by the two of you, so in tune with each other, was great.
I think you mean "so in time with each other". In tune wouldn't make sense.
Tries to work out time signature:
Brain melts
This was one of the most impressive pieces of performance art I have ever experienced!!! Glad I was wearing headphones to get more of the nuances. Well done gentlemen.
What did I just watch?!!! I kept getting scared that they would mess up! OMG! Phwew, so good!
great job, fantastic playing, and a very funny tune !!!!!!!!
That was awesome. Well both of you.
Is there ANY room for forgiveness in this piece? How would one recover? Just beautiful! Thank you for this gift!!!
Steve Reich mix brought me here. Wonderful piece. Stunning execution.
Good stuff. Congrats Gene and Tim.
a sublime, gorgeous, and perfect illustration of using elements: "home" "tension" and "variation".. .musically. These three ingredients, in my opinion, are the basics for absolutely ALL art forms, of any kind. What makes it special.. is one more ingredient: "surprise"..... xo
One of the most creative things I’ve ever seen! Great job!
AMAZING piece and AMAZING performance! GREAT!!!
My hat is off to you, gentlemen! Wow!
Absolutely magnificent playing, such syncronicity.
Bring on the rush! This made me tingle!
I don't know what to say. Pure talent and practice.
I love it...so tribal and suspenseful!
Wow! This is very impressive!!! Splendid performance.
AMAZING! great idea, great composition, great talent, fantastic outro!!!
So incredible, it mind boggling. Awesome master musicians.
at 3:53 i was trying to figure out which guy was screaming O MY GOD!! then i realized it was me!!
^ under rated comment
@@MNHSpercussion yup😂
Over rated comment, man has lost all feeling of his jaw and any sense of direction due to this video, the video must be stopped.
Carl Dupre it is absolutely frackin amazing! I can't stop watching it and thinking about it and your comment comes along with it.
Lol! I myself said the same words at the same spot! Great comment and synchronicity!
This really amazing. Woah!
The timing and syncronization😁wow,great!
WOW! This was a great performance.
This was awesome, great stuff and the other videos of these guys as well. The only issue, is that is was too short and I wanted more lol. Have no fear "loop" is here. For all of you who do not know this, you can right click the play button and then click "loop" for it to replay as soon as it is over. Do this with all your favs that are short so you do not have too go back to your device to click it again. Also, if you never want ads on your YT or web pages, I have been using ad blocker plus for years and its free and awesome. I have seen comments where they say you can scroll the video to the end, then click play and the ads are not there; not sure as I dont have to do that. Love and Peace to all Lifeforms. Love Chris
Ein musikalisch und theatralisch überzeugendes Werk.
I see I watched this a year ago and commented that it is amazing. Well, the second time through was even more amazing ! Looking forward to the 3rd viewing....
spectacular !!! I am a Latin percussionist ,, conga and timbale ,, I was mezmerized !!!
I must agree. Absolutely Incredible.
This is what is meant by having your shit together.
Surely they must be twins. That level of shared awareness of timing is amazimg.
Those roffles, so clean!
Unusual music, unexpected and deeply entertaining, great job!
Beautiful and amazing! - C. P. Kaestner
Author, artist and musician
WOW! Incredible!
This is amazing. VERY well done, guys. As a drummer, I know this isn’t easy
Kickass job guys. Super well done
These are some insane polyryhthms, what the heck?!?
Holy S**T that was so good!
Most impressive, I found it very satisfying to watch this performance develop...
Amazing! Great performance!
The independence is real! Great work.
A great composition and an amazing performance!
Amazing