IOANNIS DIMITROULIS I discovered that too, it is Bach anyway; Carl Philipp Emanuel being a classical period musician shows much of a baroque period characteristics in this work but you can tell the emerging classical influence as well.
I agree about the influence, but CPE is NOT a classical period musician. He is from what is called the Mannheim school of Music - the bridge between the baroque and classical periods.
Définitivement fan de mon compatriote Emmanuel Pahud...l'adagio est d'un beauté qui nous étreint tant le flux est à la fois intense et contenu sans vibrato superflu...ma version préférée entre toutes de ce 2ème mouvement - merci ...
Thank you, noygam, for uploading this beautiful composition (or piece, if you will). The sound quality is superb. And the playing by Pahud is sublime, as always.
Hey folks, first of all: A flute and a harpsichord usually don't perform songs - but pieces. Songs have to be sung ;-) And another quite important information: Yeah, Bach was great, especially Johann Sebastian Bach. But he had very talented sons, too (and composing ancestors even), and today musicologists tend to say that this sonata is not from Johann Sebastian, but from Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach. Only in the case of BWV 1030, 1032, 1034 and 1035 the authorship of Johann Sebastian is certain.
SorgenkindDesLebens I believe this one was originally a violin sonata. The other two Sonatas that historians that are from J.S. Bach is the Eb major and the C Major Sonatas
@hardflute the second movement is in this video and it starts several seconds after the first movement end. the second movement starts actually at 04:11
It's kind of a blend really. Could have been JSB pulling off a slightly more gallant piece to live up to the times, or it could have been CPE writing in the format his father taught him. Having said that I'm not sure what case the scholars would make.
You probably know it already, but looks like it's attributed to CPE Bach now (at least according to IMSLP). Haven't researched it really, but I've found information about JSB being questionable.
С чем можно сравнить чистое звучание флейты Эммануэля Паю,звук которой проникает в глубины души...Это ни счем не сравнимо..и каждая из композиций исполнена в высшей степени мастерства ,маэстро в каждую ноту вкладывает душу и можно слушать до бесконечности,словами описать это невозможно,можно слушать и чувствовать душой
I cannot recognized here that this is realy played by Pahud!? His playing here does not looks like to him?! Maybe it is recorded 30 years ago and maybe more when Pahud was much younger as flautist?
@dayret123 heheh, I love Bach's songs too... They're kinda strong and full of energy, but Bach knows how to keep it all in notes!! So his pieces are wonderfull that way! I'm 13,and I play flute too, my teacher didn't tell me to learn this, but I came to idea to play it myself. I'm thankfull. (Bach's great! :DDD)
No... Living water gives eternal life... only 1 person can give it to you and if He does you'll never thirst again... you don't know what you are saying... Tell me... how will you pay for your soul when you die? All those ugly spots on it... sins... Can you pay? You like living water? Seek the One Who can give it...
Although one of my favourite (Bach) and one of my favourite pieces of music (BWV 1020), this is certainly not the way to lead this piece to mastership and full develoment and, for the listener, to enjoy the music. This piece has its special charm by the specific harmony & by its chords - especially in the solo parts of the harpsichord. From this, there is nothing left. Instead one gets the impression of a fully stressed atmosphere with the music sounding as much stressed and automatic ...
K. Främcke, Is there any particular performance that you believe makes justice to the composition? I quite like Jacques Zoon's recording, have you got any thoughts about it?
I play this now on alto recorder and i am pleased that i almost got the speed of the allegro here. My sheet music says also carl phillipe emanuel bach.
It’s attributed to CPE Bach but it’s unknown whether it’s him or J.S. Bach who actually composed it. More modern prints tend to attribute it to CPE Bach whereas J.S. Bach is written on older versions
Dynamics only appeared after 1750, after baroque. In Bach’s era, there is no such thing as dynamics. Some parts were only played “a bit lighter and easier than the others”
As soon as the harpsichord started I knew this track would be fire
it's super damn fire
It’s Bach, of course it’s fire
fax
Especially when it is played by Trevor Pinnock!
The harpsichord goes so damn hard
I’m playing this for my advanced certificate recital on my sax and this is a beautiful recording thank you!
Diossss, por que hoy en dia no hay compositores como Bach!??! Que vuelva el siglo XVI!!!
Bueno sí, pero si quieres a Bach, el XVIII también. Esta sonata me encanta tocarla, es especial.
Bach esta en toda la música de hoy Lily
@@marceloagnusdei, exacto, en varias de sus cantatas hay quintas paralelas, progresiones de jazz, hasta acordes 6-4 !!!
Pahud's playing is sublime !
Can not stop listening !!!, WONDERFUL !!!!!!!, I thank the Lord for JS Bach and for my ability to appreciate His work and also JS Bach's
Jaime Garrido Bergholtz This sonata is no longer attributed to J.S. Bach but to his son C.P.E. Bach.
IOANNIS DIMITROULIS I discovered that too, it is Bach anyway; Carl Philipp Emanuel being a classical period musician shows much of a baroque period characteristics in this work but you can tell the emerging classical influence as well.
I agree about the influence, but CPE is NOT a classical period musician. He is from what is called the Mannheim school of Music - the bridge between the baroque and classical periods.
Great music. And what a fantastic performance! I love it all!
Définitivement fan de mon compatriote Emmanuel Pahud...l'adagio est d'un beauté qui nous étreint tant le flux est à la fois intense et contenu sans vibrato superflu...ma version préférée entre toutes de ce 2ème mouvement - merci ...
Thank you, noygam, for uploading this beautiful composition (or piece, if you will). The sound quality is superb. And the playing by Pahud is sublime, as always.
überirdisch schön🥰
Wow! Bravo!Bravo!Bravo!
La musica barroca es imsuperable....un balsamo y una alegria para el espiritu..no todo esta perdido en el mundo materislista...
Beautiful music, excellent flute player!
Hey folks, first of all: A flute and a harpsichord usually don't perform songs - but pieces. Songs have to be sung ;-) And another quite important information: Yeah, Bach was great, especially Johann Sebastian Bach. But he had very talented sons, too (and composing ancestors even), and today musicologists tend to say that this sonata is not from Johann Sebastian, but from Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach. Only in the case of BWV 1030, 1032, 1034 and 1035 the authorship of Johann Sebastian is certain.
SorgenkindDesLebens I believe this one was originally a violin sonata. The other two Sonatas that historians that are from J.S. Bach is the Eb major and the C Major Sonatas
I've always had my misgivings, because if this really is by CPE, it is the greatest thing he ever wrote.
Beautiful!!...
Très belle!!
Absolutely J.S. BACH, Thank you
Many wonderful 😍❤👍
@hardflute the second movement is in this video and it starts several seconds after the first movement end. the second movement starts actually at 04:11
04:11
Fantastic!
Top! Top! Top! Ik hope to play this superbe piece next year....
Merci !
Playing this for my flute grade 7!
Me tooo got it tomorrow wish me luck :p
It's hard innit
bravo...
0:52 Warms the soul
00:52
3:11
Bach wrote the most beautiful flute music. But he never played the flute and he didn’t know what he was asking of us ha ha ha ha❤❤❤❤❤😊😊😊😊
It's kind of a blend really. Could have been JSB pulling off a slightly more gallant piece to live up to the times, or it could have been CPE writing in the format his father taught him.
Having said that I'm not sure what case the scholars would make.
You probably know it already, but looks like it's attributed to CPE Bach now (at least according to IMSLP). Haven't researched it really, but I've found information about JSB being questionable.
great performance!
Igor Strozzi ,
Bella Sonata ,en sol menor.
С чем можно сравнить чистое звучание флейты Эммануэля Паю,звук которой проникает в глубины души...Это ни счем не сравнимо..и каждая из композиций исполнена в высшей степени мастерства ,маэстро в каждую ноту вкладывает душу и можно слушать до бесконечности,словами описать это невозможно,можно слушать и чувствовать душой
соглашусь мне 10 десять лет и я это произвидение играю но он он на мнооооооооооооооооооооооооооооооооооооооооооооооооого лучше играет
si torna sempre dove si è stati bene oh
miau
我的偶像實在厲害，很想有機會聽大師演奏中國樂曲，不知是否可以仙樂飄飄，此曲只應天上有，人間那得幾回聞~
Saviez-vous que la flûte traversière était la meilleure amie du clavecin?
Moi, je viens de l'apprendre.
🌺❣️😊🌷💙
Is this one sometimes also performed on violin and harpsichord, or is that a different G minor sonata?
According to my music, it’s originally written for violin and piano/harpsichord. I know oboists play it lots too.
repeat!
I cannot recognized here that this is realy played by Pahud!? His playing here does not looks like to him?! Maybe it is recorded 30 years ago and maybe more when Pahud was much younger as flautist?
@dayret123 heheh, I love Bach's songs too... They're kinda strong and full of energy, but Bach knows how to keep it all in notes!! So his pieces are wonderfull that way! I'm 13,and I play flute too, my teacher didn't tell me to learn this, but I came to idea to play it myself. I'm thankfull. (Bach's great! :DDD)
just 4:09
04:09
ładne
4 bars with one breath in adagio... oh well
Это настолько чистый звук это,как окунуться в источник живой воды.
No... Living water gives eternal life... only 1 person can give it to you and if He does you'll never thirst again... you don't know what you are saying...
Tell me... how will you pay for your soul when you die? All those ugly spots on it... sins... Can you pay?
You like living water? Seek the One Who can give it...
Donde consigo las partes?
www.flutetunes.com/tunes.php?id=784
www.flutetunes.com/tunes/bach-sonata-for-flute-and-harpsichord-in-g-minor-i-allegro.pdf
0:23
why did he play the eighth notes like sixteenth notes? i mean like staccato?
Baroque music convention I believe
Although one of my favourite (Bach) and one of my favourite pieces of music (BWV 1020), this is certainly not the way to lead this piece to mastership and full develoment and, for the listener, to enjoy the music. This piece has its special charm by the specific harmony & by its chords - especially in the solo parts of the harpsichord. From this, there is nothing left. Instead one gets the impression of a fully stressed atmosphere with the music sounding as much stressed and automatic ...
Finally one person who understands music! So rare to find people like you. Good job, you are absolutely right.
True. A bit too overpowering and prevailing.
K. Främcke, Is there any particular performance that you believe makes justice to the composition? I quite like Jacques Zoon's recording, have you got any thoughts about it?
I play this now on alto recorder and i am pleased that i almost got the speed of the allegro here.
My sheet music says also carl phillipe emanuel bach.
It also has a CPE Bach catalogue designation and has been attributed to both composers, but it's probably not by either one.
+Jeanne Winn not by either one? Who is the actual composer?
It’s attributed to CPE Bach but it’s unknown whether it’s him or J.S. Bach who actually composed it. More modern prints tend to attribute it to CPE Bach whereas J.S. Bach is written on older versions
by C. Ph. E. Bach!
Sounds like CPE. Doesn´t sound like JS.
θαυμασιο
I’m trying to learn this on my flute. Please god help me 😂❤❤❤❤
как на гобое сыграть тоже самое((((((((
They should play little faster i think.
More dynamics
falalalala786 this is a baroque piece. It's not supposed to be romanticized with polarized dynamics and heavy vibrato.
Dynamics only appeared after 1750, after baroque. In Bach’s era, there is no such thing as dynamics. Some parts were only played “a bit lighter and easier than the others”
It‘s not 100% sure that it was written by the same JS Bach. And why so soft the articulation? Is it his own interpreting style?