I picked a 4leaf clover my son .Seen a black butterfly floating back and fourth then flew away . After attending Shinedown Carnival Of Madness Toyr with Sevendust . That summer …❤😊
Omg guys, this is NOT lip sync, okay?? This a professional recording, which means they get to edit their videos for a better sound. Live, you will see that he sings only with his voice
Can you naysayers just stop and think about this? If you are in a band and a recording is made that will be published (as in youtube) do you not think that the record company, producer, and even the band would want it "cleaned" up a bit? As max pointed out, at 1:13 there is evidence of this cleaning. it does NOT mean the band lip syncs in concert. If you have seen them live, it does have that live raw-ness as I am sure this show did. And the sound is still magnificent.
Brian Ditmer probably one of the best sounds I have ever heard, true talent is when, LIVE, they sound almost exactly the same as the O. Video, which is very rare,,,and yes, anyone with brains or talent recognition of any sort can pick up immediateLy that this guy sings with his heart, all out,,,every time
@@DcCoO It's not lipsyncing, it's people editing the clips after recording to enhance the sound as well as Brent singing the song phenomenally as he often does.
If you've ever been to one of their shows you would know he does not lip sync. He has an amazing voice but it's definitely better in the studio. He is often slightly off key in the live shows and doesn't even try to hit some of the more difficult notes. That doesn't take anything away from how amazing he is. But when you perform as much as he does, your voice is going to get tired. He has to compensate somewhere. They obviously use recordings for the orchestras when they are performing because who the hell could afford to tour with a live orchestra. But I've seen tham multiple times and there is no way they lip sync. Whoever uploaded this video is likely the one doing the dubbing, similar to what they do for music videos.
Becky Meily the easiest way to tell he doesn't lip sync is to pay attention. When he starts singing this, simple man, save me, or some of the others he gets really into it and gives it all he's got and it sounds amazing. I've seen them live. I know there are times he's off a little but it's worth it to watch him get into the zone. Plus him and Zach are really funny sometimes.
@ShinedownJunkieUK I have no idea I was at that show and saw them live and I can honestly say he did sing live and you did not hear any recordet vocals at this show I was there so I know it I very sad that the WDR fucked it up =(
There's a lot of mobile Phone videos of gigs and even on those recordings you can clearly hear that all the vocals perfectly match the ones on the studio tracks. Only on the acoustic songs, Brent tends to decide to actually sing something himself. Using common sense to discover that Brent really is lip syncing is not being a hater.
Jens van der Ham Hey I'm not trying to start anything, I've seen them live in a small venue and yeah sure he probably does it occasionally but there are also times where he just gets into it and manages to sing his heart out. You can tell the difference cause he'll still fall slightly out of tune. I won't say he never does it I'm sure he does. I know I would if I was doing all those concerts. His voice must get ragged as hell trying to do that. But I digress it's at least good music.
Eric is a hell of singer. He's underrated. He has perfect pitch and his range is similar to Brent, since when they play "sound of madness" live, when it gets to the part in one of the last choruses it goes "when you gonna wake up and FIGGHTT" Eric sings the fight and hits a C5 like every show.
ya lip-sync 3:17 just right before the guitar solo ended going to the chorus, he messed up.. too bad, this is a realy good song but he cant sing it live.. maybe he's losing his voice or something...
It seems that from 4:12 till the song's end his voice changes, like someone at the consolle switched his line from playback to live mic.. He starts to be a little out of tune in that particular moment, while in of the rest of the song he singed in an unexceptinable way
Omg he was lip singing... This is really disappointing. The song sounds exactly like the official one, and after he sings: Century at 1:13, when he moves the mic away, the voice is still the same volume and he stops with his mouth as well.
Thiago Brito tem vários deles assim, é um desgraçado que ando fazendo colocando a musica do CD em cima do vídeo, pois tem esse vídeo com o áudio original na net, dai fica parecendo que o show deles é assim também, mas foi um fdp que mudou o audio apenas.
![SHINEDOWN - If You Only Knew / February 2012 [HD] Rockpalast](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dMR7-sxACAc/mqdefault.jpg)
![SHINEDOWN - If You Only Knew / February 2012 [HD] Rockpalast](/img/tr.png)
![Shinedown - The Crow & the Butterfly (Official Video) [4K Remaster]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1B89Osfj8dg/mqdefault.jpg)
I picked a 4leaf clover my son .Seen a black butterfly floating back and fourth then flew away . After attending Shinedown Carnival Of Madness Toyr with Sevendust . That summer …❤😊
The vocalist is worth its weight in gold period
Magical song with a magical lyrics
Great voice, great concert , great night in the toyoda center
Omg guys, this is NOT lip sync, okay?? This a professional recording, which means they get to edit their videos for a better sound. Live, you will see that he sings only with his voice
Reminds of some I love and miss her everything reminds me of her
this MUST be studio version right?? they can't be this perfect, oh man...
Can you naysayers just stop and think about this? If you are in a band and a recording is made that will be published (as in youtube) do you not think that the record company, producer, and even the band would want it "cleaned" up a bit? As max pointed out, at 1:13 there is evidence of this cleaning. it does NOT mean the band lip syncs in concert. If you have seen them live, it does have that live raw-ness as I am sure this show did. And the sound is still magnificent.
Brian Ditmer probably one of the best sounds I have ever heard, true talent is when, LIVE, they sound almost exactly the same as the O. Video, which is very rare,,,and yes, anyone with brains or talent recognition of any sort can pick up immediateLy that this guy sings with his heart, all out,,,every time
there's a least 10 times when it can be seen he lipsyncs
@@DcCoO It's not lipsyncing, it's people editing the clips after recording to enhance the sound as well as Brent singing the song phenomenally as he often does.
not lip syncing. This video just has the studio version dubbed over the video.
Yeah I remember writing that song....good job
If you've ever been to one of their shows you would know he does not lip sync. He has an amazing voice but it's definitely better in the studio. He is often slightly off key in the live shows and doesn't even try to hit some of the more difficult notes. That doesn't take anything away from how amazing he is. But when you perform as much as he does, your voice is going to get tired. He has to compensate somewhere. They obviously use recordings for the orchestras when they are performing because who the hell could afford to tour with a live orchestra. But I've seen tham multiple times and there is no way they lip sync. Whoever uploaded this video is likely the one doing the dubbing, similar to what they do for music videos.
Becky Meily the easiest way to tell he doesn't lip sync is to pay attention. When he starts singing this, simple man, save me, or some of the others he gets really into it and gives it all he's got and it sounds amazing. I've seen them live. I know there are times he's off a little but it's worth it to watch him get into the zone. Plus him and Zach are really funny sometimes.
Lime sorry. He didn’t miss one beat or one. Don’t know what blip you think you heard but IT WASNT THERE
what a voice! live is even better!
In this particular show, Brent does sing! YAY BRENT! There have been shows he hasnt. His voice goes great with the acoustic settup.
Shit!! You are a music genius brent smith. So unique and breath taking..
Canta muito. Perfeito
shinedown are awesome
visit greece!! :)
The fall is never ending.
I love song
CROW
This song is true to me I had a four leaf clover my son summer sky a black butterfly my first time . ❤
i thing this is from live in cologne 2012 ! and yes PLZ COME TO GREECE !!!!
I wanna see them soo bad x.x
when u and i were getting high as outer space..................................................
in which there was one acoustic HERP. stand by everything.
A version without playback, please!
3:18 Playback...it's sad because Brent is a great vocalist :(
This is for a TV show, in the actual concert it's not lip synced. There's videos of this concert on TH-cam where they aren't lip synced.
❤😂😊😊
Awesome song! The girl at 2:40 looks like Sharon Den Adel's sister.
Zack is so disoriented in that one! xD At least Barry's having a laugh... As usual! :D
The voice as the regular song
Fcking WDR. Brent sounds amazing live, and even on the crappy cell phone recordings. I don't understand why they would want to do this.
nice
!!!♡♥♡!!!
@ShinedownJunkieUK I have no idea I was at that show and saw them live and I can honestly say he did sing live and you did not hear any recordet vocals at this show
I was there so I know it
I very sad that the WDR fucked it up =(
haters gonna hate
this is from 2012
There's a lot of mobile Phone videos of gigs and even on those recordings you can clearly hear that all the vocals perfectly match the ones on the studio tracks. Only on the acoustic songs, Brent tends to decide to actually sing something himself. Using common sense to discover that Brent really is lip syncing is not being a hater.
Jens van der Ham Hey I'm not trying to start anything, I've seen them live in a small venue and yeah sure he probably does it occasionally but there are also times where he just gets into it and manages to sing his heart out. You can tell the difference cause he'll still fall slightly out of tune. I won't say he never does it I'm sure he does. I know I would if I was doing all those concerts. His voice must get ragged as hell trying to do that. But I digress it's at least good music.
3:15 who is singing there? the ooouuhh there like... no microphone lol
no, TV dubbed over
Um...what happened at 3:19?
You know Eric can sing too...
Eric is a hell of singer. He's underrated. He has perfect pitch and his range is similar to Brent, since when they play "sound of madness" live, when it gets to the part in one of the last choruses it goes "when you gonna wake up and FIGGHTT" Eric sings the fight and hits a C5 like every show.
δυσκολο το βλεπω
visit greeeeeeeeeeeeeeceeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
ya lip-sync 3:17 just right before the guitar solo ended going to the chorus, he messed up.. too bad, this is a realy good song but he cant sing it live.. maybe he's losing his voice or something...
It seems that from 4:12 till the song's end his voice changes, like someone at the consolle switched his line from playback to live mic..
He starts to be a little out of tune in that particular moment, while in of the rest of the song he singed in an unexceptinable way
Voice in playback. No dubt!!!
No,He can just sing exactly the same with the official canned song
Omg he was lip singing... This is really disappointing. The song sounds exactly like the official one, and after he sings: Century at 1:13, when he moves the mic away, the voice is still the same volume and he stops with his mouth as well.
Playback que vergonha!
Thiago Brito eles fizeram sem payback é que alguma entidade fez um overdub com a versão do estudio.
Thiago Brito tem vários deles assim, é um desgraçado que ando fazendo colocando a musica do CD em cima do vídeo, pois tem esse vídeo com o áudio original na net, dai fica parecendo que o show deles é assim também, mas foi um fdp que mudou o audio apenas.
Why is he pretending to sing....
Lipsinging...
All i see is women..