Imran Hosein on End Times: Theories vs. Facts
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 ต.ค. 2024
- Dr Shadee Elmasry warns Imran Hosein fans about the pitfalls of getting lost in conspiracy theories and the importance of redirecting focus towards helping those in need around you. Subscribe to our channel for valuable insights on how to avoid distractions and make a positive impact in your community.
Explore more at www.safinasoci...
Learn Islam online at Arkview: www.arkview.org/
Listen to NBF on:
Spotify: open.spotify.c...
SoundCloud: / safina-society
Subscribe and hit the 🔔 icon to receive the latest news & updates from Safina!
Hoist the sails & join the tales by following us on social media!
Instagram: / safinasociety
Facebook: / safinasociety
TikTok: / safina_society
Twitter: x.com/safinaso...
Telegram: t.me/mysafinas...
![[ TEASER ] เงาะป่า - วงL.กฮ. | TMG RECORD](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/M4ObdFfcPww/mqdefault.jpg)
Watch full episode: th-cam.com/video/7VbdGIXJqdA/w-d-xo.html
Study Islam online: www.arkview.org
Sheikh Imran Hosen is my best teacher..
We love sheikh Imran...from Malaysia 🇲🇾🇵🇸☝️
@@azmibahari8016 love him but not misguidance
One eye people can not understand imran hossein.
Leave our great sheikh alone
🙌🙏
I remember the first time I went to an Imran Hosein lecture, it was awesome. He spoke about riba and inflation, and how fiat money is means to suppress the masses. But some of his opinions about the Ottoman Empire and the Bosnian massacre are just wrong, and I believe it is because he takes some of this assumptions as facts. Allah have mercy on him and the Ummah and all our teachers of the past, and guide all of us.
Especially his opinion on Bosnian genocide are really problematic.
@@wajahatgilani when I listen to him I think he has lost the plot, a lot of what he says seem like fantasy and not based totally on Qur'aan or Sunnah though he claims it is . Very baffling indeed.
@@najmaalikhan He's very old now, so we should all just respectfully disagree and do due for him and all our Ulema.
@@wajahatgilani yes well you're right but our scholars being in a position of responsibility should be very careful in what they say and how they it otherwise it then becomes very dangerous when you speak on Islam in such a way which could mislead people about Islam.
May Allah guide us all to right path.
@@najmaalikhan Unfortunately, clarifying the points in the public space is important.
He Is truly what the ummah needs everyone being brainwashed.including us here in malaysia.
"The Caravan Is Moving On Even Though The Dogs Keep On Barking"
You make a strong case regarding what’s theoretical and what’s practical. But I feel you have criticized him as a person rather than criticizing his ideas. If you don’t agree with it, talk about why and tell us what would be the version of truth that Muslims should ascribe to.
They have no courage to face him.
He has some great works on eschatology which i highly praise
In the last days people of knowledge will not want to speak much about the endtimes it say's in hadith. Escatology is sheikh Imran's specialty. I agree on some of sheikh Imrans thoughts and some things I disagree. However, I cannot dismiss or belittle him. He has become older and cannot express himself as well. Remember that we can even learn a thing or two from an enemy. So be patient with him
He’s not wrong about everything. He’s been absolutely on point about interest, fiat currency, lots of issues surrounding eschatology, etc..
That doesn't mean he can deny sahih hadith and the clear prophecies about the conquering of Constantinople, and no one can say they know who yajuj and majuj or dajjal is. We don't have the data. I also heard he also believes the russian orthodox who worship Jesus and believe in the trinity are not Mushrik. They worship Jesus and the holy spirit but are not Mushrik??!?!?
@@vol94 Shaykh Imran Hosein is not denying Sahih Ahadith ,nor Constantinople.
Shaykh Imran Hosein his Islamic Eschatological analysis and explanations are based on the Holy Quran and Sahih Ahadith that are in harmony with the Holy Quran.
Whether you agree or disagree with him that is irrelevant..
@@vol94 You hear ,this one said , bla bla..
You hear, the other one said bla bla..
Shaykh Imran Hosein his book are free to read on the Internet, do some research without prejudice arrogance, ignorance and hatered.
Because that makes you blind, deaf and dump..
I mean there is a lot to unpack. I don’t think these comments will be helpful. Once we realize that there is no monopoly on truth, we can learn to disagree in a constructive way.
It is just very inappropriate to see a learned man , who wants to emulate the prophetic teachings, be so blunt about disrespecting people in the public; an elder at that.
Also, how can a muslim say things like “I heard he believes …(this or that)” brother, you should go and check on what was said before casting judgement.
@@vol94 Then you have not studied all the Hadith about king of Ethiopia ? Where prophet performed his Janaza in Medina while he was still Christian publicly. And Another instance where prophet was a child, A Christian priest recognized him as a prophet. A Christian priest who commits shirk knows he is a prophet ? Go learn your Islam first. And study the books and evidences that is shown. Don’t take anyone at their face value, So & so said it. You are responsible for your actions in your grave for this slander.
Where is your work on Eschatology? We living in End Times. You using Fihq terminologies to Ilmul Asghiruz Zamaan. You should use Muhkamaat and Mutashaabiyaat Aayaat of Quraan.
Nothing, they live in the past.
@@SilverLine-v1d , he wants to bring back the Khalifa but doing nothing to address the world-wide riba based economy where the banks are the central player
He doesn't need work ? All he has to do is teach the Quran and Hadith.
So... nobody should really be doing anything then.
I don't think I agree with this thinking. I think people should learn to accept critical thinking and uncomfortable truth.
A scholar who starts by saying "if it sounds disrespectful, it is..." and then goes on to tell us about prophetic character? This is quite low.
Well said
Problem is modern so called scholor are not capable of doing any research about the modern world, hencewhy they are jealous of anyone who does it.
The problem in your comment is saying people should accept "uncomfortable truth". Who says what the guy says is "uncomfortable" truth. Its mostly his own beliefs and view. He explains todays Quran and Hadith by some of todays events but most of it without any real basis -- like who /where Jajuj and Majuj are, and many more of these things. He is not a prophet. If he cant provide any real evidence to his claims he should not be attributing the Hadith or Qurans to them. Thats why i stopped listening to him. The man goes too much by his own beliefs and views if political events and wants to say these exact things he says are what the hadith /Quran mean. Thats just wrong
Well have a tradition in this tradition with deriving from guidance. If you teach something that deflects from that you are from the wrong doees.
@@Drew-ox2wnterrible take😊
Humankind: 2 rupees of knowledge
Imran: 3 rupees of knowledge
@@greatcaledonianpenicillin5378 precisely!
On the other hand marginalizing major events like Yajuj and Majuj coming out and the Dajjal and putting that away as tricks from the shaytan is rather peculiar... every prayer we seek refuge in Allah from the fitna of the Dajjal? Yajuj and Majuj is a massive nation on earth and we do not know where their hideout is?? Like of course we should busy ourself with these matters.
The scholars of the subject know where they are.
@@JaefarSABNW how do you know that?
@@drauw The ayat, narrations, and etymology make clear it is the hyperborean, sakas, scythian, or whatever you call Gygys and Maha Gygys.
@@JaefarSABNW how is that an answer to my question?
Such a major point about day to day help as opposed to political and religious theory which is a distraction of shaytaan
Statues of Gog and Magog are in Guildhall, London.
Balfour Declaration.
Labour, Liberal, Conservative Friends of Eskimos in Zimbabwe.
Lots of school boys in the comment section eating biryani and couscous😂
The sheikh is not right about everything but he’s right about a lot.
And who exactly are you?
Stop being smug it's not islamic
This Haram mockery you throw toward other so-called Muslims brothers who disagree says a lot about you
Wow using buzzwords and snark, you are definitely what every Muslim should aspire to be. Sit down with your locker room bully tactics 😂 may Allah SubhanAllahu Wa'taala keep us guided 🤲
From a personal experience pov I can definitely agree with Dr Shadee Elmasry. Alhamdulillah for this channel 💚
Thank you for talking about this, jazakallahu kharian
While I agree about your point on taking care of the immediate surroundings
You are absolutely mistaken if that’s the primary focus of us all
There are people in this ummah who need to step up especially scholars like yourself
Reddit Islam 😂 this is so true and so sad. Shaykh, get ready for an onslaught by the biryani and darul uloom hating crowd.
What the darul uloom has to do with all of this ?
@@muslimuddin3656
This man Imran Hosein regularly disrespects the Ulema of Darul Uloom and his students do the same.
@@sammu
Why ? I mean I am curious
For what he disrespect darul uloom?
I think you meant by darul uloom "deobandi schools"
@@muslimuddin3656
He says it in every video about how he is the only one with the true insight and everyone else is sleeping and/or busy eating biryani. I would rather not watch his garbage again to quote you something verbatim.
The quran thought him
Only salafis, wahabis , deosbandi will go a length of attacking other scholars without ilimul tassawf/ilmul Haqq
Funny because he doesn't use any from what I seen
I remember Sheikh Imran Hossein once said that in order to disprove him, one just needs to use Google Earth and find the iron wall of Gog and Magog. If you do that, you'll also find Gog and Magog. Any takers for this challenge?
It's stupid
The problem with Imran Hossein isn't that he's wrong on some matters. The problem is that he asserts he's the only one who's right and everyone else is wrong. Leaves no room for any interpretation other than his own
Sadly, Imran Hossein isn't the only one doing this. I see a lot of emerging scholars committing this same mistake now
May Allah give us all hidayah. Nothing better than as many people in Jannah as possible. May we be amongst the people of Jannah. Ameen
Please be respectful and call him by Sheikh Imran Hosein
@@SalmaiChicken you're right. Disagreements apart, he's a scholar of Islam. Regardless of whether or not I believe he's misguided in some aspects, he has done more for the ummah than I can ever imagine doing in this life time. I should've been respectful. May Allah forgive my shortcomings. Jazak'Allah khair for pointing it out to me my dear brother
Habibi that's a very fair and mature comment. Very refreshing and full agreement on my end
I wish you understand him deeply! I followed him for the past 11 years and i found 90% of his yeachings are absolutely found true. You better focus on his analysis of The End Time correlations of his teachings vs current world situations!
Truth based on what ?
Ya Allah. Please fulfill the wishes of all insan all humanity in this world. Syukur alhamdulillah..Salam from Malaysia.
Jazakumullah Khayr Shaykhna,
I have a question:
How do you reconcile that concept of the prophets dealing with the practical instead of the theoretical with the Hadith that the Prophet ﷺ spent a day talking about the signs of the day of judgment?
Imran hossein is the only scholar i know who identified that the arab spring would be a disaster and he was right
No human is perfect but I believe he's onto something
Can you explain onto what ?
Used to listen to sheikh Imran but not anymore. I think way too many of his opinions are honestly way too eccentric for me. I’d like to believe that he’s sincere in his teachings, Allah knows best 🤷🏻♂️
Gog and Magog are mentioned in the Qur'an, in the past and in the future.
Although not core topics, they are still very important. Don't minimise topics the Qur'an talks about. Yes they should not be the main focus, but there is a place out there for people who specialise in these topics.
And taking about priorities. Why do you spend so much time refuting others? That's not a priority. Let the Salafis do that.
Please stop bashing each other, this ummah is One , stop it now!
Should face to face to clear all miss understanding...not through the social media... that's not the way of our prophet Muhammad SAW
His evidence is overwhelming. Why don't you have a respectful discussion with him for the people.
Used to watch the Arrivals series and they used him in one of their content. That's how I discover him first.
I loved his end of times lectures and started listening to him in the 2010s and got his Gog and Magog book printed only to be accused a t*err0rast by my english teacher.
I got a chance to finally see him in 2013, 2014 and maybe the last time was 2018. I got really upset whenever he mentions about the turks and how they are evil so I confronted him about it one day after lecture. I told him why do you say such things about the Ottomans? Then he chastised me by saying to learn a book and not attend his classes anymore. You have to keep in mind I was just wondering, the question wasn't at all offensive. I took that to heart and NEVER listened to his lectures again until people start using his content on random instagram reels and on youtube lol.
Anyway I would still follow his opinions on riba, inflation but I would never take anything about the end of times seriously again.
May Allah bless you and your family in the world and in the hereafter, Aameen.
From the start, you've shown your bias and unscholarly approach. We are not a 'band of believers' but rather truth seekers. We love and respect the Sheikh and his scholarly efforts in explaining the Qur'an.. We don't need your type.
How many books on tafsir have you read?
@@youngomniverse35 That's not your business. You might have read all the Tafsir books on earth but problem is, you're a self-opinionated rabble -rouser so-called scholar smelling of arrogance. Sheikh Imran is never your match and his admirers are never fools. Be careful!
Separate conspiracy theories and Islam
Remember he is also of very old age now, his early lectures were more balanced. Also, he is a scholar of eschatology, not primarily of fiqh/tafseer etc., so that is why his talks are around this subject.
but he blatantly doing his own tafsir on the Quran...
@@wewenang5167 Sure, all scholars have to do some level of tafseer. I'm just saying he should be left alone, and his die hard followers warned of his current state. This doesn't mean he didn't have real contributions in the field.
@@n.a.1397his eschatology thing is not a big deal in my opinion, but he doesn’t consider the conquest of Constantinople by Sultan Mehmet as a good thing and he said when proper Muslims regain power over Istanbul then they will hand back the Hagia Sophia to Christians. Then he also doesn’t consider Orthodox Christians to be Kuffar either, and there’s more the list gets longer on these topics.
Nope. He formulated a faulty methodology for the study of eschatology. It’s not scholarly. It’s hubris.
@@n.a.1397he does not cite from any sources and also say things against hadith
Imran Hossein is trying very hard to make sense of all the prophecies and ayat that hint to us a direction to follow, which is much more than I can say about instituted scholars who ignore some of the very clear evidences he provides. Granted some of his views may be incorrect but that's where he asks you to come up with something better, instead of an all out refutation without a counter explanation. BTW the gog and magog theory is mostly misunderstood to be limited to khazarian Jews because he discusses it in a context that revolves around the Jewish connection but the actual theory simply says the dominant nations at the time will be from the progeny of yapheth among whom was gog and his later generations came to be known as magog. They are not evil only, some of them are Muslims, some of them have established more Islam than other nations. It's their domination and all out control of world affairs that is the sign, be it the khazars, mongols, turks, mughals, British, vikings or whoever Allah chose from among that progeny. You don't seem to understand that this is a matter of opinion and nuanced to its core, something you should debate and counter with equal theory. Imran Hossein is not the origin of these theories either and they've been around for centuries, even Dr Israr Ahmed was of similar views about this subject, but because you think it's an anti Jewish troupe you simply choose to not try understanding it.
What a school boy type of response 😂 no direct refute and no alternate explanations on why Sheikh Imran is a conspiracy theorist. “What can have an opinion on the first place and what can’t” bro just accepts everything that’s handed down by his elders. The world changes, people have different opinions based on world events. This is what you fail to consider in your 6 min analysis video. Sheikh imrans average video is an hour and half long I mean the sheikh is extremely thorough !! Go back to school !!
Like Shaykh Imran Hosein, you too appear to have thrown the sunnah etiquettes of disagreement out of the window. When you include ridicule and belittling in your expression of disagreement with someone, you not only move the away from the way of the Beloved ﷺ, you also lose any potential followers who might otherwise have changed their minds after listening to your opinion.
I think this attitude plays a role in a substantial number of people finding it difficult to accept Shaykh Imran Hosein’s opinions. When even earnest questions, genuine curiosity , or the slightest hint of not agreeing with the Shaykh results in him mocking and belittling them as “school boys” with “less than 2 rupees worth of knowledge”, its no surprise people are going to be pushed away.
Time reveals faleshood and truth is exposed to all who seeks it, pieces of a puzzel can only be put together if you have seen the completed piece.
Guidence is for everyone if you choose it!
I'm glad knowledgeable people come forward with respectable criticism of Sheikh Imran Hosein.
But honestly the internet crowd has lost it and is like a lynch mob.
It is very obvious sheikh Imran Hosein has mostly lost it due to old age.
At one point his theories were really important and he genuinely added to the knowledge-pool of Muslims (despite his mistakes)
If people disagree with him, they should do it in a respectable way and as the shuyukh are seen doing it, they can leave it to the shuyukh criticizing him.
But I constantly see people hound sheikh Imran Hosein as if he were some animal or monster. That is not good and that is not from our adab.
Shadee al Masryvshould have at least called Sheikh Imran Hosein by calling him Sheikh
I agree.. focus on day to day issues, in the present cause what we do today will shape our future. I leave the future to Allah
It doesn't need a phd to spot a an extremist
@@uvaiskomath ?
AND YOU ARE?
Scholars attacking each other via social media is so sad tbh.. if you have something bad to say about someone then put them in front of you and say it to their face and discuss it.
This isn't accurate because how do you know they didn't try speaking in person? Most likely one party doesn't want that and so instead of letting stupidity rampant, he addresses it online. This is valid and you too would do the same if you were put into a situation like this. Imran Hossein ain't a scholar cuz he doesn't even know Arabic
I open the field, myself.
@@DARTH-R3VAN if it wasn’t accurate you would see both of them discussing it. lol what are you talking about. And yes he does know Arabic , please stop speaking out of ignorance.
So why didn't you say it to his face instead of writing it on social media. Hypocrisy. You did exactly what you spoke against
This needed to be said to the public that's why the video was made
It was not just for him it was for the public and for them to know about his errors
Eye opener
Sheikh Imran Hosein is the most brilliant scholar of our time. You're way out of your depth here. You can't refute him with proofs and research that reason with the minds. His interpretation of the end time, dajjal, Gog and Magog reason with the minds. His analysis matches our reality. Ready-made speaker like you is part of the problem. Sheikh Imran is right when he said western Muslims are part of the Judeo-Christian world. And they will be destroyed in the great war. I feel sorry for average Muslims living in the west.
The minds of who? The minds of fools who don't even know arabic? Imran Hosein lives in the west and as a matter of fact obtains most of his profit from it. Not a single scholar considers him an authority in anything, not a singly madrasa uses his books and his books are nothing but stories which are distinctively lacking in scholarship.
Salamun Aleikum, Sheikh Imran, may Allah preserve him, isn't claiming absolute knowledge but defend his position by relying on the holy Quran and calling for any contrary opinion. What galls him and indeed the neutrals are the vile language being used on him.
It is disrespectful. Scholars have had disagreements in the past and still do.
@@worldpeace786 You cant say 1+1= 7 and call it a disagreement. His opinions have no basis in the Islamic sciences. They are poltical analyses which he then forces onto the Quran.
@@youngomniverse35 that is what you called critical thinking. Allah swt blesses Sheikh Imran with critical thinking.
@@alhallaj So if a person says 1+1=7, that's critical thinking ?
That's the equivalent of the west's claim that a gender is malleable. Facult's theory of power which suggests this and also suggests the possible of child marriage is also an aspect of critical thinking. Doesn't change the fact is against the sunnah and delusional.
@@alhallajYou don't use critical thinking to go against the ijma'i aqaid of this ummah. Because the Prophet (SAW) has said that "my ummah will not gather on misguidance". We've almost never done critical thinking to learn aqaid. The sahabah learned them from the Prophet (SAW), who then taught them to thabioon and so on.
imran Hussein is declared a disbeliever because of his claim that Jesus was crucified, his rejection of Authentic Ahadiths and many other blasphemous statements. I used to follow him for many years until I start noticing his love for the disbelievers and yet he insults the Muslims leaders, the muslims and the scholars especially the Sunnis. He is a deviant person.
Hadees- muhammad (sal) saw and said aftr that yajuj majuj was released.
hadeesic Conquer of constantinople will occur after armagedon
Quran says in final times chriatians will ve close to muslims as they follow priests(orthodox)
SO debate witg his ideas or explanations with your explanation.
Starting with i have no respect is like flexing 😂😂😂😂
Sheikh Imran always says: "If what I say is wrong, then show me what is right!". I don't see you presenting alternatives
This is similar to a person saying sjsxsdbxjsdx + xsxjsnjsnxj = 2 and if its wrong show me what it right. The notion itself was always nonesenscial. The Prophet(saw) himself used to discourage delving into these issues. If you need someone to tell you that Christians who worship Jesus are kuffar and mushriks, then you need a psychiatrist. Heraculius was an Orthodox Christian, the Prophet(saw) waged war against him. This is apparent to even a child.
This is an awful way of reasoning. First off, we already know he's wrong. He goes around claiming Dajjal is a system. It's not, and it's backed up by Sahih Hadith (narrated by Tameem Ad-Dhari). The entire Hadith is long but you can look it up yourself (Sahih Muslim 2942a). It is not a system.
Furthermore, Muslims have a certain eschatological order that needs to be followed for the end times. They are as follows:
1. The coming of Imam Mahdi (a ruler who will bring justice on this earth)
2. A period of 3 years where rain and produce will decrease by 1/3rd, 2/3rds and all leading to mass starvation.
3. The coming of Dajjal right after this.
4. A period of 40 days of Dajjal's dominion on earth with the first day being like a year, second being as long as a month, and third being as long as a week. The rest will be normal days.
5. The coming of Isa ibn Maryam who will kill Dajjal.
6. Yajuj and Majuj being released. Isa will take the remaining Muslims on top of a mountain to wait out Yajuj and Majuj.
7. A period of peace under Isa ibn Maryam.
"Sheikh" Imran goes against all of these with his crackpot theories. In order to justify his misguided theories, he'd need to bring justification from other sahih Hadith which he will never do, since they don't exist. This makes it by definition wrong. Anything that alters this sequence of events will need to be backed up by other Sahih Hadith, which Imran Hossein has never provided.
It doesnt matter to your belief ti understand what rhey are. So why make big hoo haas about it
😂😂😂😂😂 so "i say whatever I PERSONALLY believe to be truth because I saw it in an interesting vague YT documentary about the freemasons, and I PERSONALY conclude this is what was meant by the hadith/Quran" but yea, if what i say is wrong tell me what is right. 😂 bro get out of here. There a things we dont know and that why we say Allah knows best. We cant just conlude our own personal views/beliefs be the interpretation of the Quran and Hadith.
Dr Elmasry, Salam. I listened your reading of english trasIation of dr abdel haleem to your interview of dr Hatem al hajj. Please elaborate why his interpretation of the release of Yajooz abd Majooz will not be acceptable that would be more beneficial then anecdotal analogy!! i hope you will spend time to understand his arguments before providing intellectual refutations. I am waiting for those arguments so I can rest!! Otherwise you will become another person who did not make efforts rather provided anecdotal refutations.
اللهم أرنا الحق حقا وارزقنا اتباعه وارنا الباطل باطلا وارزقنا اجتنابه
اللهم ردنا إليك ردا جميلا
اللهم ارزقنا توبة نصوحا قبل الموت
May Allah show us the truth and remove arrogance in us and allow us to follow the truth
And show us the wrong path and keep us away from it
With all due respect, it always seems like western scholars want to keep every Muslim at bay.
He is not taken seriously in the Muslim majority world concerning his theories
Imran Hosein isn't taken seriously by anyone.
Sheikh Imran Hosein is a genius who has shed a lot of light on the current and sorry state of affairs in the muslim world. And the best part is that he uses the Quran and the Ahadiths to back up his interpretation of the end times prophecies. the muslim world is stuck in a rut because of scholars like you.
He clearly said it in this video that muslims should mind their own business. Seems like he is in someone’s pocket ? If we mind our own business regarding matters of Dajjal etc who will teach the children ? Our future generations ? They will all go astray!
@@Idkjk971 It is unfortunately this deeply ingrained corruption in the islamic scholarship which is sprouting to the aurgace now. The corruption stemmed off with wahabism which spread its tentacles under the guise of other branches of islam such as salafism to comatose the Ummah so that the rulers can remain in power.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Do ijtihaad on what he says, Do not attack the sheikh, he is the foremost scholar in eschatology, ma sha Allah.
It never seizes to amaze me to see these young polished ready-made scholars on the internet offering opinions about Ulama’s that are clearly waaaaaay out of their calibre!! Akhii, before you dismiss someone like Sheikh Imran as a conspiracy theorist, and call those who share his views are “bandits”, ponder over your deen instead of memorising this kitab and that kitab, recite it from heart like a tape recorder and then issue fatwas!! This deen is for those who think!!! Its sad wallahi that this ummah has lost its capacity to think, not only our lands were colonised but our intellect is also occupied. SubhanaAllah
Agree! If you want to refute then refute it with proper sources and proofs,
,They can’t do it. They have no answers. This is their Scholarship. Cant refute with proper knowledge. He is too busy pronouncing those Arabic words rather than focusing on important points.
You're really defending Sheikh Imran while talking about how this deen is for people who think!!! The irony here is almost comical.
Also, adding Subhaan'Allah to the end of your rant does not give it more credibility. You're using the name of Allah not to glorify him but to gaslight people. Quite sad. May Allah judge you accordingly.
@@1994mrmysterymanWhat did Imran say and do? I still have no idea
@@LeafSouls Brother, it's best to just type his name into youtube search. Plenty of people have made videos on a lot of the problematic stances he has on various aspects of Aqeedah. One primarily being the discussion about whether the Christians are kaafir or not.
I believe the muslim metaphysician and the muslim skeptic made videos on it. Sheikh assim has a video on him. Dilly Hussain had him on a podcast. There's plenty of material.
He isn’t shiekh at all 😢 spreading conspiracies theories
Time will tell ….there is no point in disrespecting the sheikh
He used to Quran to explain himself,so please do us a favour use the Quran to disapprove him.
We are not blind followers,tell us what knowledge you have on eschatology,we will happily listen to you.
ALLAHU.... sriously, ..... ? Who is this guy?? Who is talking about theory? ... do he realize that he is talking theory , assumption and even fitnah to the Sheikh... ... hopefully this guy will make taubah and apologize to the sheikh..
I haven't heard Shaykh Imran Hossien quote from Hadith or Quran any scholarly opinion . Further more I don't any scholarly or Shaykh who hasn't said what Dr. Shadee said about him. Sorry if it hurts
@@jmurdock8303 thats because in the end times, the worst people beneath the sky would be the scholars of the deen, thats why all of them say what they say about Maulana Sheikh Imran Hosein.
and yet you took time to make this video. fear allah. leave this man alone. just because you don't understand doesn't give you the right....
there's so much things you could've done with your time but you would rather clickbait. good for you. now please do better!!
Facts: sheikh maghili repeatedly told you living in dar al kufr is haram in the maliki school with only dawah being an excuse. With that in mind, how many of your students whom you know for a fact are not daees did you recommend hijrah? Jazak allahu khayr
So, we should not live in Saudi Arabia?
@@JaefarSABNW Is medina dar Al kufr according to you? Do you live in the hejaz or are you a clown living in the US mocking the fiqh?
décoration all around even with Allah words . used as décoration. But the biggest decoration is the one listening to himself .. Well. You looks nice keep going.
Yajuj majuj are the Turks in Turkey, Safavid Turks in Iran, Russian, Chinese, Korean, Mongolians, askhnazi Jews etc.
Wrong clip bro. You meant to post this comment on the channel of the other sheik who has you hooked on conspiracy theories. Next episode is about the illuminati and how they are who jajuj and majuj are, anf saying all this without any real evidence but its sounds cool/amazing/mysterious so it must be truth 😂 Go quick before you miss it.
@@coolGrap199
Yajuj majuj are a race.
@@coolGrap199
Your 'shaikh' is one of the thirty Dajjals at the end of time full of conspiracy theories and nonsense.
@@courierton9217 1. assumption (that this guy is my sheikh ir i even consider one my sheikh). 2. Calling people dajjal. 3. Thinking youre rightious (arrogance). Here you go, just three sins you committed. Dont feel attacked so quickly bro. Perhaps work on not being so insecure. Also since you didnt understand why/what I commented: you say things which there are no concrete evidence for; Youre doing whats sheikh imran does: explaning hadith/Quran by his own beliefs/views (about illuminati etc etc). With that youre comitting another sin: again making people out to be dajjal/ or jajuj and majuj. Youre a fool
orthedoxy is always surprising to hear online, u never hear this stuff from IRL on a online platform
When will we Muslims stop criticising and slandering each other? Let every one be and be followed according to their capacities of understanding! You want to say something perfectly correct then correct yourselves perfectly first.
I have heard criticisms of Sh. Imram H. that I have to accept as legitimate, because I lack the level of knowledge, and I speak no Arabic. But I find it unfortunate that nobody who is critical of him is concerned about the obvious approaching of Djall and the conflicts and circumstances that are clearly happening now... Now of course, our ultimate response to these events is to perfect our iman as always. Its just sad to me that nobody is using what they know to warn Humanity of these events as he is doing, when they know Islam better than him.
There is actually a lot of that being talked about. The problem (for me) with sheikh imran is exactly what has been pointed out in this clip, and am very glad someone finally said: mainly that sheikh imran tries to explain hadith/Quran by his own views/beliefs of todays events. Most of the things he mentiones have no real basis. Yes, we can find them on YT in a cool story about the freemasons. But even on there its all vague and storytelling. Problem is that a sheikh is re-telling those (cobspiracy) theories and claiming it to be the interpertation of Hadith/Quran. Thats just wrong.
Sir , you are intellectually blind! Can’t you see who has destroyed Palestine? If the destroyers of Palestine are not Gog and Magog, then who is?
@@TheNamdar1 they are jews brother, not gog and magog lol gog and magog are sealed until dajjal arrives and they will kill most people on earth. The population today stands at 8 billion, where is dajjal? nowhere. He hasn’t arrived yet and by extension gog and magog are not here either.
Who?
people in this comment section legit got offended and didnt listen to thing this man said. wether this shiekh is correct or not. you can not treat something as fact when there is no basis for it. u can be right about many things but even when ullama were 99 percent sure. they still didnt teach it as fact as they know it could be wrong. how are u defending a shiekh in which says smt is fact when there is no evidence for it
Bros 5rupee worth of common sense is in IMF debt😂😂😂😂
The way you all are treating eschatological events with so much certainty seems as if you did not understand what Dhanni and Qati is. This kind of a belief for the Mehdi, as if like a Saviour and Prophetic Kind of figure is how the Twelver Shias have a belief about their imam Zamana. Being this much apocalyptic is just showing why we have not gained Khilafa back
PS: I don't mean that these topics must not be studied, but getting opinionated on this and connecting it to the present situation of Muslims will just make us Psychologically fixed upon saviour figures.
@@mohammadshabifainan8540 brother, it is unanimous that Hazrat Mahdi and Isa will return and bring upon a new caliphate. This has been discussed obviously by shia, but also our sunni scholars. The return of them is written and recorded in the sahih of bukhari and muslim and other hadith compilations. Hate to break it but a saviour complex is exactly whats going to happen. If Allah swt wanted a caliphate (which is fard upon the ummah) then we would’ve had one. The fact is we are so close to return of Hazrat Isa and Dajjal that the ummah was and is meant to be split according to the minor signs of qiyamah. The last minor sign is the appearance of Imam Mahdi. Then Dajjal will come shortly after. Until then, the ummah is divided, the Prophet sallallhu alahi wassallam said that he fears excess wealth for the ummah more than anything and you can see many muslim countries and its people drowned in wealth but unable to help Palestine. Thats our state. But, we MUST do any good we can and not sit about fantasising, but taking whatever actions we can. That is our duty.
TRUST THE SCHOLARS ABOUT ANYTHING EXCEPT EACH OTHER, FOR THEY ARE MORE JEALOUS THAN GOATS
May Allah forgive us all and Bless us till Jannah. To my opinion, any academic discourse between so claimed "scholar" or "ulama" or "ustaz" or "preacher" should be done behind youtube channel. Arguing in public will only create confusion among Al Awwam. Aren't Muslims confused enough? Divides enough? Motives or intentions or Niyaah is inside a person, only Allah and the person knows. But, our actions may cause others to perceive the opposite our Niyah. May Allah forgive us all and my humble apology.
Your going to ger more follows by insulting otger muslims
imran hussain committed kufr multiple times. What are you talking about? go learn our deen
I respect his work on the Akhiri Zaman but when he says that genocide in Bosnia did not happen he loses all the credibilities . I am from Bosnia and I was in during the times of aggression from Serbia and Croatia. Yesterday was July 11th and 29 years since UN,USA ,NATO gave green light to the Serbian Fascist forces to enter Srebrenica that was protected by the UN forces.They killed over 11000 man but so far only found 8372. They used very well organized system by moving body remains to so many different secret location and many end up in the river Drina that is a border between Serbia and Bosnia.
Why should we care iblees is happy with us or not. Only western scholars talk this way.
💯
What is the Assa in his hand?
Thank you ❤❤ very interesting topic
❤.. much needed . Jazak'Allah Khairan. May Allah subhana wa ta ala preserve you , family and NBF & NBIC .. Ameen.. 💕
Yes ty for making a video on him. Barakallah Hu Feek
So the facts are......?
... not with Sheikh Imran😂
@@coolGrap199 enlighten us
@@NazTheGreat problem with sheikh imran is he interprets Hadith/Quran by his own views/beliefs, and even worse, without actual facts. Which is what I said to your comment. In all kinds of videos he is contributing dajjal to specific peoples, he's saying who we should believe jajuj and majuj are, its always freemasons this, illuminati that. Would all be OK if there was evidence. But to most of what he says there is no proof, there is only mysterious YT documentaries (about the freemasons, illuminati etc) which themselves remain vague. Sheikh imran isnt a prophet. So we should not just accept any sentence he says about who the dajjal is or things of that nature. He should come with facts. somethings have NOT YET shown themselves and thats where we say Allah knows best. But we shouldnt project what we've seen in a YT conspiracy documentary and say THATS what this or that Hadith is talking about. Furthermore, and I can be wrong in this, I would think its haram to make people/muslims have certain (hatred) feelings towards specific peoples because sheikh imran says they are the dajjal. Seems just wrong.
I remember now that I used to watch his lectures at a time i was very interested in conspiracie theories and "the world of the shadows" if you will. Ever since i just want to really know the deen for what it (and what it not) is ive stopped listening.
اللهم صل وسلم على سيدنا محمد وعلى آله وصحبه وسلم
Out of all the sects, teachers, scholars, professors and doctors in islamic theology etc, all disagree with each other and everyone is correct at the same time.
Take your pick.
What scholar credits Imran Hossien
I have a tremendous amount of respect for Sheikh Imran Hossein. But SubhanAllah, lately he has gone to the extreme talking about Prophet Isa (as) in the end of times will return back and he will rule the world according to Christian teaching.
FALSE! I never said such a thing. Allah Most High taught him the Qur'an, the Gospel and the Torah. He will be a just Ruler who will Rule in conformity with Truth in those revealed scriptures. Please stop spreading falsehood!
Cut the sheet and get to the point
I think Shaykh Imran Hosein is mistaken on some issues, nonetheless the future ulema will benefit a lot from his insights and form a more orthodox doctrine regarding the end times according to Islam. Most ulema of the past that we know today were fairly controversial in their times such as Imam Taymiyah or even Imam Ghazali. Still, Imran Hossain just like anyone else is mistaken on some issues and must be respectfully criticized
Are you really comparing ibn Taymiyyah and a-Ghazali with Imran Hosein. Both of these scholars were masters of several fields and had tremendous insight into issues with they supported with quran and hadith. Imran Hosein has no proficiency in any major Islamic science.
A scarf on your shoulders doesn not make you a big schoolar
His primary education is from what i call a "soft-barelvi" institute, barelvi educated are good at creating new cults.
He be hanging out with freasons . I love the guy . He reminds me of Abe Simpson 😅
Way too many videos in this channel are criticisms of other muslim scholars. This channel is becoming like TMZ. All this does is cause more division within the ummah. Just look at the comments section.
you sir are a "schoolboy" i dont care two peanuts for schoolboys 🤣🤣🤣
Where did you graduate from ? Shaykh
He is one of the finest scholar ...whatever he said is almost happened go n watch his lectures 20 years ago.
The problem is you ppl can't digest different opinion...and you cant prove him wrong.
He do not lick the boots of al saud dictators ..😂
@@Elias-eh4gk Shaykh Imran Hosein his Islamic Eschatological analysis and explanations are based on the Holy Quran and Sahih Ahadith that are in harmony with the Holy Quran.
Whether you agree or disagree with him that is irrelevant..
@@Elias-eh4gk there are Millions of Muslims living in China and Russia without any problems.
And those Muslims don't want to be a part of the Bogus Jihad supported by the CIA /Mosad /UK /USA / Saudi Arabia / UAE and their Zionist Judeo-Christian unholy alliances.
Salam my brother Jazackallah I needed to hear this ❤❤❤
What podcast was this?
A proper waste of time don't even bother
Hahahaha i like your style.
I watched him, he mixed a lot of bs with quran and hadists.
Imran Hosein Belives Isa ibn Maryam aleyhi Salam was Crucified and Killed and goes against the Clear Quran And Sahih Hadith🤦
@@HellllooKittttyyyyy he doesn't believe that Nabi Isa was crucified or killed. Your words are pure slander.
@@ayyubwajid7528 i used to be a Fanboy like you but after i heard that from him more then 10 years ago i stopped following him and so should you
Just Follow the Orthodox and Traditional Islam and you will be Successful Quran and Way of the Salaf the first 3 Generations of Muslims upon the Sunnah
@@HellllooKittttyyyyy He never said that Nabi Isa was crucified.
@@ayyubwajid7528 go Ahead continue Blind Following him or anyone else
my Job was only to Convey the Message
Gog & Magog are already released. It’s a matter of Aqeedah now, Because you are denying what Allah has promised to come.
I'm leaning towards that too bro.
Not released yet.
@@Idkjk971 if Gog & Mogog are released or not - is Not matter of Aqeedah ! 😂
This is Aqeedah
1 Belief in the Oneness of God. ...
2 Belief in the Angels of God. ...
3 Belief in the Revelations (Books) of God. ...
4 Belief in the Prophets of God. ...
5 Belief in the Day of Judgment. ...
6 Belief in Premeasurement (Qadar)
@@strategic4124 Gog & Magog are part of the revelation in the Quran, Your point number 3. So denying the existence of Gog & Magog when in fact it is clear as day light is rejecting the versus of the Quran. Allah’s promised has been full filled and they have been released.
@@Idkjk971 I'm not denying ; Gog & Mogog are two corrupt forces that will appear at the end of time !
30 years ago it was the Soviet Union and America
Today it's the ashkenazi Jews and usa NATO
Who they are and how they come about is not a part of Aqeedah !
And you are speculating a theory ! You believe to be correct
This is not Aqeedah !
I see more arrogance and pride in this man than sincere Islamic knowledge. May Allah guide him.
I disagree. Hes wrong on some things, for example the Bosnian genocide, but hes not arrogant.
@@khairt1731 👍