Back in the day, I always thought "Self Destruct" lineup was the quintessential one. "With Teeth" was the first NIN tour I got a chance to see, and I saw them every time they came to NY; Fall, Summer, etc etc. I didn't really appreciate it at the time (isn't that funny?), but now I honestly think this may have been the best fusion of old and new NIN aesthetic via the members. Starting with Jerome, who was an infinitely more precise and 'musical' drummer than Chris, the majority of the lineup is extremely tight, adding just enough little personal flourishes to the material to give it color while staying controlled enough to nail every dynamic rise and fall so well that the record pales in comparison. Then you have the (at the time) controversial Aaron North, who serves as the agent of chaos, turning lead breaks/solos into walls of noise and feedback, occasionally improving, and just generally exhibiting a manic energy that recalled NIN's early days. All of this came together to create a live act that could sync up with elaborate visual displays while at the same time managing to feel unpredictable. Some of these songs from the "Rehearsal" videos, I didn't particularly like on the record at the time, but seeing them this way...well shit, it's hard to deny
@@AlexGordonMusic At the time, a lot of the NIN forums, etc (they had an insanely active online community, still do, but esp then) were abuzz with divided opinions on him. I think BECAUSE he actually dared to change the songs a bit (rather than imitate Trent's sounds), and especially because he did so in a punk-inspired, sometimes 'sloppy' manner, there was a certain segment of the fanbase that just wanted a "professional", a session musician, basically. Also you have to remember, this was the first non-Finck guitarist in over 10 years
They opened with it on those tours, and while on the record I felt it didn't stick out when compared to songs like "Every Day" etc, it was a showstopper in person...and the band was BEHIND A FUCKING SCREEN, SEEN ONLY IN SILHOUETTE
Absolutely fantastic. This has truly inspired me to make music and experiment with noises and musical approaches when I was 17. Thanks to this I have discovered all sorts of industrial music and experimentation. Thanks a lot for being there Trent and ИIN!
@razorbladethorax : With NIN we are witnessing the historical superiority of one artist. The more time passes the more impressive and overwhelming Trent´s file becomes. Perceiving the visual and sonic quality of these documented series of rehearsals -that will surpass what countless bands do when on stage in front of an audience- is clear evidence that those who thought everything had been done and written in music were utterly wrong.
I absolutely love this and I didn't even realize it was on the DVD! I wish I could have seen them during the With Teeth days. But it's all good -- seeing them soon!! :D
Lead vocals were fairly obviously rerecorded in post (best shown during the choruses, when Trent moves away from the mic find the right fret), so possibly a bunch of other elements are not live. Still a fantastic version.
I have to agree, but with Freese instead of Dillon and Aaron North not actually playing guitar but going spastic on the stage it's quite a sight to behold.
The Hand that Feeds was filmed in the Rehearsal room, they pretty much just did the song with a little more action in their movements and distorted the camera (They had a director for that video)
just for a wee bit of nit-picking here =P I dont think its saturated, as much as it is Quantized (or bitcrushed) He seems to be very fond of bitcrushing in The Slip i must say!
@80XY Actually he didn't play on this album at all, Trent plays everything himself on pretty much every album (excluding drums) and then assembles a live band, which is where Jeordie comes into it
@80XY actually Trent Records almost all the instruments himself except drums :) each tour he has a different live band however and this is just a rehearsal :)
Adoro Nine Inch Nails! Son los más grandes.. y me encanta el metal. Pero NiN metal? No.. eso si que no. Ni ahora ni nunca.. en el broken se acercaron, pero seguían siendo Rock Industrial.. de todas formas, eso no es nada malo, no?
I've always wondered what the deal is with these switchboard things that bands likle NIN and Radiohead use, are they actual insturments and what are they hooked up to
Bueno, yo al menos creo que es Metál, mmm yo distingo estos generos en NIN: Rock Industrial, Metal Industrial, Metal Alternativo, Rock Alternativo (Aunque solo es en el albúm With Teetg) e Industrial... pero si son Metal ;)
He toured "With Teeth" until he had heart issues during a live performance, first resulting in the band stopping, and then after an attempted return to the stage, collapsing once more and causing the gig to be cancelled. He was replaced, with the initial 'press-release' essentially being that it was until he got his health sorted out, but Jerome's own statement later on basically claimed he was unceremoniously 'abandoned' and then blackballed from the band. My personal assumption was that Trent (correctly or not I can't say) assumed that his heart palpitations and collapse were drug-related, and because this was the very first "Sober Trent"(tm) tour, he quietly kicked him off for that reason. But I could be totally off base.
![NIN: Discipline live at rehearsals, July 2008 [HD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/8Lqsx2Jn4hE/mqdefault.jpg)
Man..... 16 years. Who’s still here listening to this masterpiece
me. everytime. since 2006. one of my favorite albums
16? Really? Math not strong suit eh
The With Teeth rehearsals are so goddamn good
Undoubtedly the best version of this song.
It’s on the only single!
Right. THIS should’ve been on the album
🌝🍿
Back in the day, I always thought "Self Destruct" lineup was the quintessential one. "With Teeth" was the first NIN tour I got a chance to see, and I saw them every time they came to NY; Fall, Summer, etc etc. I didn't really appreciate it at the time (isn't that funny?), but now I honestly think this may have been the best fusion of old and new NIN aesthetic via the members. Starting with Jerome, who was an infinitely more precise and 'musical' drummer than Chris, the majority of the lineup is extremely tight, adding just enough little personal flourishes to the material to give it color while staying controlled enough to nail every dynamic rise and fall so well that the record pales in comparison. Then you have the (at the time) controversial Aaron North, who serves as the agent of chaos, turning lead breaks/solos into walls of noise and feedback, occasionally improving, and just generally exhibiting a manic energy that recalled NIN's early days. All of this came together to create a live act that could sync up with elaborate visual displays while at the same time managing to feel unpredictable. Some of these songs from the "Rehearsal" videos, I didn't particularly like on the record at the time, but seeing them this way...well shit, it's hard to deny
mywhychromosome What was controversial about north?
I always thought he was fantastic
@@AlexGordonMusic At the time, a lot of the NIN forums, etc (they had an insanely active online community, still do, but esp then) were abuzz with divided opinions on him. I think BECAUSE he actually dared to change the songs a bit (rather than imitate Trent's sounds), and especially because he did so in a punk-inspired, sometimes 'sloppy' manner, there was a certain segment of the fanbase that just wanted a "professional", a session musician, basically. Also you have to remember, this was the first non-Finck guitarist in over 10 years
A rehearsal better than studio and live version.
This is one of the heaviest and darkest emotional songs ever....
Still the best song they did on the "With Teeth" Album. Just a fucking amazing, beautiful, yet dark song. Trent Reznor is the Fucking Man!
They opened with it on those tours, and while on the record I felt it didn't stick out when compared to songs like "Every Day" etc, it was a showstopper in person...and the band was BEHIND A FUCKING SCREEN, SEEN ONLY IN SILHOUETTE
And to think this is just a rehearsal.. Holy shit.
They gave it a “Pretty Hate Machine” feel in the beginning of this one. By far my favorite track on With Teeth.
I love how the sound is so crisp with NIN songs - another perfect example.
I miss 2005 trent
Pretty sure he doesn't
@@OkamixOni lol
Absolutely fantastic. This has truly inspired me to make music and experiment with noises and musical approaches when I was 17. Thanks to this I have discovered all sorts of industrial music and experimentation. Thanks a lot for being there Trent and ИIN!
same here
This performance blows my mind
@razorbladethorax : With NIN we are witnessing the historical superiority of one artist. The more time passes the more impressive and overwhelming Trent´s file becomes. Perceiving the visual and sonic quality of these documented series of rehearsals -that will surpass what countless bands do when on stage in front of an audience- is clear evidence that those who thought everything had been done and written in music were utterly wrong.
Best 480p of the TH-cam.
the quality of this is insane!
That first bass drop is out of this world!
does anyone know what sequenced drum vst is being played in the intro? been needing to know!
NIN es la prueba viviente de que el tiempo pasa muy rapido.
I absolutely love this and I didn't even realize it was on the DVD! I wish I could have seen them during the With Teeth days. But it's all good -- seeing them soon!! :D
Lead vocals were fairly obviously rerecorded in post (best shown during the choruses, when Trent moves away from the mic find the right fret), so possibly a bunch of other elements are not live. Still a fantastic version.
that drum man, i love it
love it!
it's like a hundred times better than the album version..
It's a version on steroids. And I was in awe with the album version before I heard this one.
Intense.
That is Jerome Dillon...longtime NIN drummer. Departed during the With_Teeth tour.
I want to travel back to 2005, listen to this and play Doom 3 on a crappy computer at a 800x600 resolution
I never realized how good twiggy sings back up
PADRE, LA CONOSCENZA E' DI TUTTI!! 1+
CD+DVD+LIBRO
Trentastic!!!
@somedaytheendwillcom that's one of the many reasons "with teeth" is my favorite NIN album
cortini's intro makes me shiver
What happened to music ,,,,,we have lost a lot over the years ....Very sad .
I CAN´T REMEMBER WHAT IT IS I TRY TO FORGET NEITHER
I have to agree, but with Freese instead of Dillon and Aaron North not actually playing guitar but going spastic on the stage it's quite a sight to behold.
kocham !
Legend
The Hand that Feeds was filmed in the Rehearsal room, they pretty much just did the song with a little more action in their movements and distorted the camera (They had a director for that video)
so good
You are also right on that. Hurt is very heavy as well
just for a wee bit of nit-picking here =P
I dont think its saturated, as much as it is Quantized (or bitcrushed)
He seems to be very fond of bitcrushing in The Slip i must say!
wow
lol wow had no idea the synth percussion sounded like that in the song. maybe it's a variation to the studio recording
@80XY Actually he didn't play on this album at all, Trent plays everything himself on pretty much every album (excluding drums) and then assembles a live band, which is where Jeordie comes into it
that's right, the same saturated Kick.
we still use it on a lot of songs.
Bring Aaron north back to the nails, also geordie white, best incantation of the band!
@80XY
actually Trent Records almost all the instruments himself except drums :)
each tour he has a different live band however and this is just a rehearsal :)
@o0derkish0o yeah, 2005-2009 was pretty active for NIN, they even came to my country :D the newspapers wrote: the best concert of the decade
\m/ .... Long Live to NIN! =P ...I love this song, the guitar is aggressive ...NIN ARE METAL MOTHERFUCKERS!
2024 🔥💎
Better than the studio version
industrial METAL.....listen to the riffs, totally metal
heeeeeeeeeeey!
Im about 90% sure its reaktor.
Could be MaxMSP, as he said he does a lot of work on it, but it really does sound like reaktor more than anything else.
Jerome!!!
i agree.. dillon was the right man for nin
Why do every one of them have that same straight black hairstyle?
fascinating, I'm guessing this is when the Hand that Feeds was shot?>
Adoro Nine Inch Nails! Son los más grandes.. y me encanta el metal. Pero NiN metal? No.. eso si que no. Ni ahora ni nunca.. en el broken se acercaron, pero seguían siendo Rock Industrial.. de todas formas, eso no es nada malo, no?
love and sex is not enough
Can someone tell me what type of drumset that is?
Remember me on the sweetest girl
I've always wondered what the deal is with these switchboard things that bands likle NIN and Radiohead use, are they actual insturments and what are they hooked up to
150/10
did they end up using some of this for the final cut of the album? It sounds familiar. Man this is really really good
with teeth a great fucking album?
you know dave ghrol played like 7 of the studio recorded songs on this album right?
Was not aware! Very cool…
@80XY
Forgot his name???
@badbenij360 Sounds similar to that deployed in Survivalism.
Bueno, yo al menos creo que es Metál, mmm yo distingo estos generos en NIN: Rock Industrial, Metal Industrial, Metal Alternativo, Rock Alternativo (Aunque solo es en el albúm With Teetg) e Industrial... pero si son Metal ;)
Trent was always the best. Aaron was a try hard
Check the 'smoochers' at 3:39. Yum!
@80XY Twiggy is THE BEST,hand picked by the G.O.D......lol
I was the 666 like, rooooock
th-cam.com/video/fXcC9MXE7bA/w-d-xo.html
lets just say its industrial
Can someone please tell me who the drummer is? It's not Jerome Dillon, is it?
It is Jerome Dillon. He worked with NIN for some of the With Teeth tour gigs.
He toured "With Teeth" until he had heart issues during a live performance, first resulting in the band stopping, and then after an attempted return to the stage, collapsing once more and causing the gig to be cancelled. He was replaced, with the initial 'press-release' essentially being that it was until he got his health sorted out, but Jerome's own statement later on basically claimed he was unceremoniously 'abandoned' and then blackballed from the band. My personal assumption was that Trent (correctly or not I can't say) assumed that his heart palpitations and collapse were drug-related, and because this was the very first "Sober Trent"(tm) tour, he quietly kicked him off for that reason. But I could be totally off base.
@@mywhychromosome That is exactly right
@@robhoyt188 You mean why wasn't welcome back, or the first part?? Haha.
Industrial Folk.
ok so did jerome. but with teeth, besides these guys, is all trent.
is that nick zinner on guitar?
Aaron North
25,001
No it's not.
Snape on those lead vocals..
They think they're really cool
wtf?! why is this recording so compressed to hell? it hurts to listen ;(
ZIM ZUM ES UN MAL BAJISTA HACIENDO DE GUITARRISTA...
weakest line up...he's ever had.