Old spongebob but modern spongebob improves alot more on animation like being more fluid and detailed so if would say which has better animation modern spongebob but I would prefer old spongebob
I do personally prefer older Patrick's more relaxed and chill expressions/look over his more cute modern ones because it just made him feel well older.
He looks cute yes. But most of the time he has some adult stuff that still retains the old aspect of his character. Just like spongebob too they might look younger and cuter but the writers know what makes them relatable to everyone and they returned that in season 9b.
It was mainly because It used Cell Animation and almost everything was drawn frame by frame, so It looked more natural, also the Darker colors and less exaggerated expressions help everything build up
It was my first attempt to re-create the new style, and the last one was so spontaneous, because I had gotten more used to how the drawing should flow, it was more of a practice if you ask me. In any case, I appreciate the feedback :)
“So you were an alien all the time and you didn’t even tell me.” “I didn’t even know.” “Yeah? Well I got you now.” “Oh but it’s not you that’s got me. It’s... me that’s got me.”
Imagine for the 25th anniversary they did a Sonic Generations thing and brought Modern Spongebob back to season 1 and vice verse for a special episode. I'd love to see scenes from both classic and modern Spongebob play in the reverse styles. That be very interesting to watch.
Sorry but modern spongebob is alot better with it being alot more detailed and fluid and just better overall it would be fair to say it's more Nostalgic but it's not better in anyway sorry 🤷♂️
I actually love the modern animation it's more clean and eye candy they should turndown the over the top expression cause when they don't do it the art style just looks perfect
Yeah, although I didn't mind the very bouncier animation. And don't forget that they finally brought back the screwball cartoony style and killed off the Steven Universe-esque style (it's still around but less frequently now). And thanks to the newer animation style, it became a impact for the return of classic cartoon humor, like its spinoff, The Patrick Star Show, Looney Tunes Cartoons, Middlemost Post, Taffy, Tom and Jerry Special Shorts (sadly got cancelled) and the reboot for Animaniacs.
These look awesome, they actually like look their from modern day SpongeBob episodes. I appreciate both of these art styles. And It's really cool to how episodes will look in a different art style.
Not just Oggy and the Cockroaches, but other shows like Doraemon, Pororo the Little Penguin, Garfield, and even Arthur with one episode are doing the same as well. Any other cartoons you guys can think of?
That's the thing I love about the Modern SpongeBob we have now, the colors are more brighter and saturated, and the characters are much more expressive then the older seasons. Edit: I also agree with what you said at the end. I, for one, love SpongeBob no matter the era.
Yeah, my problem with the 1st season was mostly the art style. While not bad, it just didn’t feel lively and expressive as these later seasons. Plus, these newer seasons are bringing back characters we hadn’t seen for years like Bubble Bass
Yin yang gave quite literally gave us yin and yang, the lights of seeing the gross newer episodes being drawn in the good classic style to seeing the dark of the good classics drawn as the gross newer episodes
OH YEAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! This reminds me of another video you made where you talked about another old episode of SpongeBob that got remade in the modern style!😆
The more I see these side-by-side comparisons, the more I want to see a SpongeBob episode/fanfic that swaps between the classic and modern art styles. It's kind of like Sonic Generations if you think about it.
I prefer the older look in large part due to the imperfections of hand drawn animation. Not only does modern SpongeBob look overly bright and exaggerated, the characters look “too” good in a way. The imperfections of hand drawn animation give it character that computers will never be able to replicate
I think that, the old style is the perfect and nostalgic style, since it was the introduction to the series and characters original designs, with that homemade look to it, the ones that we first saw, the new style could be something good if it followed the og style, but with improvments, like better expressions for the characters and more fluid movements. But we all know it wasnt like that. Maybe, just maybe if Stephen didnt quit at the time, this could happend. Note: i also think that the series would have ended long ago, with a good ending, and the episodes would be better than what they are today
Spongebob was a rather clever show for the first 4 seasons or so. Lots of little adult jokes, tongue firmly placed in cheek. Then they started being more on-the-nose and more graphic with their jokes. I finally watched a "newer" Spongebob episode a few years ago, and it blew me away how far the quality dropped.
They should make an episode called “Nostalgia Traveling” where spongebob, patrick, sandy, squidward and mr krabs use a time machine to travel back to different season 1 episodes, with the new animation style and new voice clips for those parts
Unfortunately that might not happen, due to cel animation's death for cartoons after 2004 (when Ed, Edd n Eddy, the final comedy cartoon to remain using this technique, transitioned to digital ink and paint). Yes, it didn't officially die out until 2013, but that was in some other places.
@@kootunesscrewy but it’s probably easier to draw how they used to look now. Literally they just take stuff from the first few seasons like color and character. Like Spongebob had a more relaxing vibe to it. Yes it was a cartoon about him being overly eager and always excited however it didn’t necessarily feel like a kids show if that makes sense. Than they just reanimate it. Yes animation takes a long time clearly but something like that isn’t as hard. Hell if you’ve watched girl meets world, they literally had the characters go to an old episode of boy meets world and think about the type of technology they had before and now? So them going to older episodes isn’t impossible! Probably difficult and time consuming but not impossible.
Nostalgia Goggles off ~ og Spongebob series looked 💯 times better than modern, the art style to me was honestly art and the char's just looked more relatable & goofy which i luv bout it. We dont have to argue NoCap
Gotta say, these ''modern-style'' screencap remakes look pretty good. Heck, I'd even dare say that due to how they are more expressive than their original counterparts, I actually kind of prefer the remade shots! Though that doesn't mean I no longer find the season 1 SpongeBob ''style'' charming.
Those who say the old art style was better, while I can see why, I think the newer style kinda looks better animation wise. In the old seasons, the colors were kinda dull and it felt like the models just didn’t have consistency at times
I'm not really sure, I kinda prefer the Old Artstyle because it's all Relax and Mellowed Out. While the New Artstyle is over exaggerated and disgusting.
Idk if this will became a reality, but a remastered version of the 1st season with the modern Spongebob style (maybe for an anniversary gift for some of the fans or something like that) will be good. Either way i respect the effort of the animators during the 1st season, and they did a fantastic work. After all, both Spongebob style's are cool
I remember when I was a kid, and my sister used to dislike the older episodes because she thought the art style was "weird". And I always wondered why they never bothered to remake those older episodes in the newer, cleaner style, until I realised it would be a huge waste of time. (And money, for that matter, but I didn't know that at the time.)
if modern spongebob die down the colors a little bit and made the characters do a little less over the top expressions but still allowed them to do more than the original i think it could be good. i still prefer the original though bc it doesnt destroy my eyes
Nick needs to do some sort of anniversary special where they reanimate a classic episode in the new style and vice versa. If it's well received maybe do more!
I Can't believe this is Nostalgia. I Love the fanart of Spongebob classic. YinyangGio has the most making the best of Fan-art. its a best and better than Spongebob classic episodes
I honestly prefer the more exaggerated modern style (9b-now). I hope we get to see more art like this. Like Vailskibum94, some of these art blends right intl the show and could be mistaken as offical.
Which style do you prefer? 👀
@@Cliffordlonghead What an engaging conversation with yourself.
definitely classic for me
Both are nice.
Old spongebob but modern spongebob improves alot more on animation like being more fluid and detailed so if would say which has better animation modern spongebob but I would prefer old spongebob
Both
I do personally prefer older Patrick's more relaxed and chill expressions/look over his more cute modern ones because it just made him feel well older.
He looks cute yes. But most of the time he has some adult stuff that still retains the old aspect of his character. Just like spongebob too they might look younger and cuter but the writers know what makes them relatable to everyone and they returned that in season 9b.
The animation is cuter in the old version
@@inf.3904 The animation had what can best be described as "personality".
Season 1- Slow minded but good friend
Season 2-3- Loveable idiot
Seasons 4-9A- Idiotic jerk
Seasons 9B-present- Back to season 2
You can kinda say the same about Peter Griffin lol, older looks are really the best looks for old characters
Idk if it’s just nostalgia but I absolutely love the season 1 artwork.
Season 1 is nostalgic because they start in 1999
I like season 1's art not because of nostalgia but because the colors were not so bright and the cartoony expressions weren't always so exaggerated.
It was mainly because It used Cell Animation and almost everything was drawn frame by frame, so It looked more natural, also the Darker colors and less exaggerated expressions help everything build up
I prefer the old animation just the way it is.
No need to improve what’s already perfect.
I wouldn’t call it an improvement….
@@CPL_SHORTfr
This really needs to turn into a Spongebob episode.
@Christofer Pezet zip it
Yeah
@Christofer Pezet get out
NO, PLEASE!!!
@Christofer Pezet NOOOOOO
It was my first attempt to re-create the new style, and the last one was so spontaneous, because I had gotten more used to how the drawing should flow, it was more of a practice if you ask me. In any case, I appreciate the feedback :)
quick question, what art program do you use?
Gj!!
@@diskdem0n Im not yingyangGio but he uses Clip Studio Paint.
@@FireyHDYTPlayz oh thanks
You're pretty underated ngl... Really hope many more people notice ya!
I will never forget Sandy's Rocket. Loved it as a kid ❤
Same. 😎
I thought it was weird
Man I remember first seeing that episode years ago as a kid hearing that title brings back nostalgia.
“So you were an alien all the time and you didn’t even tell me.”
“I didn’t even know.”
“Yeah? Well I got you now.”
“Oh but it’s not you that’s got me. It’s... me that’s got me.”
Same here
Imagine for the 25th anniversary they did a Sonic Generations thing and brought Modern Spongebob back to season 1 and vice verse for a special episode. I'd love to see scenes from both classic and modern Spongebob play in the reverse styles. That be very interesting to watch.
Someone: og spongebob is better
Others: no modern is better
Intellectuals: spongebob is spongebob
As long as these pants are square, and this sponge is bob, I WILL NOT LET YOU DOWN
Uhhhh Spongebob could you Put me Down???
Better is Spongebob?
I honestly don’t see the difference in the show I love watching the new and old episodes
yes
They should re-animate "Best Day Ever" and "Hooky"
Best day ever isn't hand drawn though
@@cam935n really?
@@JacksonsLegendary Are you being sarcastic or you didn't know that
Those are great episodes! I always sing along with “Best Day Ever”
@@cam935n i actually didn't know that
Old Spongebob: **Has smoother animation**
New Spongebob: **Higher definition**
New spongebob is better
New spongebob is smoother.
@@Gabril962 and funny
@@guillermogazanol1729 Hi, didgeridoo player!
@@TayoEXE Hi Bongo player
The old style will always be the best
Ya
The new style is good too but the old one is better
Take your Nostalgia glasses off...
The original that started it all...
Sorry but modern spongebob is alot better with it being alot more detailed and fluid and just better overall it would be fair to say it's more Nostalgic but it's not better in anyway sorry 🤷♂️
Modern spongebob: I recreated the OG episodes
Modern sonic: well I recreated sonic 1 green hill zone
I prefer old days Spongebob for jokes and animate movement
But i prefer modern Spongebob for the character design and animation quality
Even if your an old Spongebob guy, you have to be real. The new seasons are full of emotion and colour
Yes, I don't hate the modern style besides the overexaggerated expressions but the colors personally hurt my eyes
Too much emotion and color
@@ΑΡΙΣΤΟΤΕΛΗΣΛΑΧΑΝΟΠΟΥΛΟΣ I bet youre a fun guy irl
@@bathroomshy no he probably Boring
@@StevenJones851 yeah I was being sarcastic
They should pull an ATLA and make an episode joking about all the mistakes they made in the past.
Yea you right!
Ah yes, another ATLA fan! Awesome
Now this is an episode I would watch
Like the great divide and that's it :v
they should bring back old spongebob
I actually love the modern animation it's more clean and eye candy they should turndown the over the top expression cause when they don't do it the art style just looks perfect
Yeah, although I didn't mind the very bouncier animation. And don't forget that they finally brought back the screwball cartoony style and killed off the Steven Universe-esque style (it's still around but less frequently now). And thanks to the newer animation style, it became a impact for the return of classic cartoon humor, like its spinoff, The Patrick Star Show, Looney Tunes Cartoons, Middlemost Post, Taffy, Tom and Jerry Special Shorts (sadly got cancelled) and the reboot for Animaniacs.
OH MY GOSH ANOTHER CURRENT NINJAGO FAN!
Idk why, but I just love the quirky screwball animation style, maybe because of the bouncy and fluid movements.
Definitely agreed.
I respect my opinion but I don’t think it looks as organic
There something surreal about seeing these frames side by side, it's almost like it's two different shows
Never before have I been hit with nostalgia so hard
YinYangGio needs to do an official episode for the show, this is amazing!
I wish Yin Yang Yo had a crossover with Wow Wow Wubbzy 😂😁
@@SofiaPreCure
ah yes, my favorite show when i was younger
@@SofiaPreCure those two shows >>>
It would be amazing if these were actual episodes with modern remakes
These look awesome, they actually like look their from modern day SpongeBob episodes. I appreciate both of these art styles. And It's really cool to how episodes will look in a different art style.
The thing I like most about the remakes is I like how the colors are brighter
I fell in love with YinyangGio"s work, I actually seen the posts before this video came out.
Well Oggy and Cockroaches got similar treatment
They’ve been remaking old episodes with new animation style
And I disagree with it
Not just Oggy and the Cockroaches, but other shows like Doraemon, Pororo the Little Penguin, Garfield, and even Arthur with one episode are doing the same as well. Any other cartoons you guys can think of?
Yeah they should do that
I knew I wasn’t the only one who remembered OATC
Both are honestly very welcoming, and nostalgic.
This is what I wanted to see, what would the old season look like the new ones, thank you so much for making this video it was amazing
That's the thing I love about the Modern SpongeBob we have now, the colors are more brighter and saturated, and the characters are much more expressive then the older seasons.
Edit: I also agree with what you said at the end. I, for one, love SpongeBob no matter the era.
Yeah, my problem with the 1st season was mostly the art style. While not bad, it just didn’t feel lively and expressive as these later seasons. Plus, these newer seasons are bringing back characters we hadn’t seen for years like Bubble Bass
I wish SpongeBob was kept in the original animation. But I still love him.
Everyone: That's AMAZING!
Re-animate Graveyard Shift and I Was A Teenage Gary. I would love to see how those would look.
The pizza delivery episode is so classic it’s AMAZING
Therapist: Modern SpongeBob Mega Sponge doesn't exist, it can't hurt you.
Modern SpongeBob Mega Sponge: 0:26
Ayo I actually love the art, the last one is really close to a modern episode
i love the look of classic spongebob episodes i don't know why i just do
This is the definition of Nickelodeon saying to Stephen Hillenburg “Am I really gonna defile this grave for money? Of course I am!”
How?
It was a fan remake. Nickelodeon didn’t do this.
Not a big fan of the pizza delivery episode but the take on modern style looks cool! Kudos to the artist
I've always loved the artwork YingYangGio makes, whatever if it's FNaF edits, FNaF models, or recreations of nistoljic things
This art looks awesome!
the mr. krabs "what" meme got me good xD
Love you bro keep up the great content
Yin yang gave quite literally gave us yin and yang, the lights of seeing the gross newer episodes being drawn in the good classic style to seeing the dark of the good classics drawn as the gross newer episodes
I do appreciate the brightness of the newer style however the classics always going to have a nostalga factor
Yeah, the older style does take me back.
OH YEAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! This reminds me of another video you made where you talked about another old episode of SpongeBob that got remade in the modern style!😆
Seasons 1-8 are the best art styles in my opinion
This just keeps getting better and better
No just no. The old style suits the nature of the old episodes. In my opinion the new art style suits the nature of modern spongebob.
The more I see these side-by-side comparisons, the more I want to see a SpongeBob episode/fanfic that swaps between the classic and modern art styles.
It's kind of like Sonic Generations if you think about it.
I wish modern Spongebob kept the old color scheme. The modern colors hurt my eyes a little bit almost like Teen Titans Go.
I prefer the older look in large part due to the imperfections of hand drawn animation. Not only does modern SpongeBob look overly bright and exaggerated, the characters look “too” good in a way. The imperfections of hand drawn animation give it character that computers will never be able to replicate
These are always amazing ngl 👍
I think that, the old style is the perfect and nostalgic style, since it was the introduction to the series and characters original designs, with that homemade look to it, the ones that we first saw, the new style could be something good if it followed the og style, but with improvments, like better expressions for the characters and more fluid movements. But we all know it wasnt like that. Maybe, just maybe if Stephen didnt quit at the time, this could happend. Note: i also think that the series would have ended long ago, with a good ending, and the episodes would be better than what they are today
Am I the only one who noticed that vail just uploaded a video just like this a couple weeks ago
every video he makes is repetitive with the same ideas tbh
@@bathroomshy yea
Spongebob was a rather clever show for the first 4 seasons or so. Lots of little adult jokes, tongue firmly placed in cheek. Then they started being more on-the-nose and more graphic with their jokes. I finally watched a "newer" Spongebob episode a few years ago, and it blew me away how far the quality dropped.
They should make an episode called “Nostalgia Traveling” where spongebob, patrick, sandy, squidward and mr krabs use a time machine to travel back to different season 1 episodes, with the new animation style and new voice clips for those parts
Unfortunately that might not happen, due to cel animation's death for cartoons after 2004 (when Ed, Edd n Eddy, the final comedy cartoon to remain using this technique, transitioned to digital ink and paint). Yes, it didn't officially die out until 2013, but that was in some other places.
@@kootunesscrewy but it’s probably easier to draw how they used to look now. Literally they just take stuff from the first few seasons like color and character. Like Spongebob had a more relaxing vibe to it. Yes it was a cartoon about him being overly eager and always excited however it didn’t necessarily feel like a kids show if that makes sense. Than they just reanimate it. Yes animation takes a long time clearly but something like that isn’t as hard. Hell if you’ve watched girl meets world, they literally had the characters go to an old episode of boy meets world and think about the type of technology they had before and now? So them going to older episodes isn’t impossible! Probably difficult and time consuming but not impossible.
There was a episode where spongebob and Patrick have gone back in time, that episode was a mess.
It's cool to see the difference overtime
Gives me one piece vibes when they remade the first old episodes to better animation
Nostalgia Goggles off ~ og Spongebob series looked 💯 times better than modern, the art style to me was honestly art and the char's just looked more relatable & goofy which i luv bout it. We dont have to argue NoCap
You can’t lie. The best episodes are the old episodes.
Whoever did these is fantastic
They’ve gotta remake Shanghaied and Christmas Who in the modern style! I’ll go freaking insane if they do!
Dang, if it hadn't been for the signature, I would've thought it was official
The new styles look good and feel like they were put more in them, but the old style animation still has charm from the time :)
Stephen Hillenburg must be smiling up in heaven for this artist drawing modern scenes in his classic art style.
Gotta say, these ''modern-style'' screencap remakes look pretty good. Heck, I'd even dare say that due to how they are more expressive than their original counterparts, I actually kind of prefer the remade shots! Though that doesn't mean I no longer find the season 1 SpongeBob ''style'' charming.
These recreations are awesome.
Old style... it's always the old style
Those who say the old art style was better, while I can see why, I think the newer style kinda looks better animation wise. In the old seasons, the colors were kinda dull and it felt like the models just didn’t have consistency at times
I would love to see a remake of the earlier episodes
Cool video dude
I'm not really sure, I kinda prefer the Old Artstyle because it's all Relax and Mellowed Out. While the New Artstyle is over exaggerated and disgusting.
Idk if this will became a reality, but a remastered version of the 1st season with the modern Spongebob style (maybe for an anniversary gift for some of the fans or something like that) will be good.
Either way i respect the effort of the animators during the 1st season, and they did a fantastic work. After all, both Spongebob style's are cool
I disagree with this. Don’t go back an alter this, Nickelodeon
*and
@@macbarrpup2451 *adn
@@Bandug Lol
@Nelo BillsCantrell *dan
@Nelo BillsCantrell Simpsons did it! Simpsons did it!
I now want to see a reanimated collab
I remember when I was a kid, and my sister used to dislike the older episodes because she thought the art style was "weird". And I always wondered why they never bothered to remake those older episodes in the newer, cleaner style, until I realised it would be a huge waste of time. (And money, for that matter, but I didn't know that at the time.)
Patrick went from chill to happy face
I’m literally one of the first people watching this… think about that
if modern spongebob die down the colors a little bit and made the characters do a little less over the top expressions but still allowed them to do more than the original i think it could be good. i still prefer the original though bc it doesnt destroy my eyes
*AmOnG GeUs*
Patrick in early digital and the first seasons: chill
Patrick from 2010: kid
Okay 👍
I like how the fan made it remastered, even though it’s unofficial art, it’s still good.
The SpongeBob crew should remake help wanted, I know you want too as well
The Nature Pants picture was absolutely perfect and accurate
SpongeBob Among Us (Gone Wrong)
tbh, I don't know why Nickelodeon didn't do this already. It looks so neat
This is so cursed…
These old episodes should deserve a remake because of a fan artist. Nickelodeon should hire him.
Epic
the tables have turned
Nick needs to do some sort of anniversary special where they reanimate a classic episode in the new style and vice versa. If it's well received maybe do more!
The backround music almost made me cry🥲
It's just not the same
This is awesome how they recreated the older episodes with modern looks.
I can argue that Pizza Delivery is not the best episode of SpongeBob in just 2 words:
Band Geeks.
more like Krusty Krab Training Video
More like Mimic Madness.
@@themememaster6775
I'd consider Mimic Madness to be in the top 3.
I just want an old spongebob episode to be reanimated in the modern style, like an actual full episode.
First
so?
AND
E
aw man i thought i was gonna be first.
Your first 🎉🎊🍾🥂
Me: Hey I’ve seen this one before
People who don’t watch every video once it drops: What do you mean you’ve seen it? It’s brand new!
I’m pretty sure the title is the same, but you’re thinking of another upload where the drawings were different
@@Azurill_111 ah ok, I thought it was the same video and he just had to reupload it for some reason
I Can't believe this is Nostalgia. I Love the fanart of Spongebob classic. YinyangGio has the most making the best of Fan-art. its a best and better than Spongebob classic episodes
I honestly prefer the more exaggerated modern style (9b-now). I hope we get to see more art like this. Like Vailskibum94, some of these art blends right intl the show and could be mistaken as offical.