BEFORE POSTING A COMMENT, READ THIS Dear brothers/ sisters, Some desperate non-Muslims have been posting comments here which are nothing but lies, fabrications, and links for video whose sole purpose is spreading ignorance and make Muslims think they doubt their deen. And some dear brothers/ sisters asked me why this topic? It might make people suspicious about Islam. And I say: - The sole purpose of this channel is spreading knowledge and truth. It’s not meant to compare religions or criticize atheism/ any other religion. - Thanks to Allah and unlike any other religion or ideology, there is not a single topic in Islam/ Quran which, we Muslims, are afraid to discuss or are ashamed of. - I have not responded to those malicious comments/ video links because they are too insignificant to spend my time refuting them, they simply do not contain any shred of evidence in them not even to be able to refute them. When you see people, who can’t even read Arabic properly, criticize the holy Quran, then I am done. When you see people talking about Quran's different manuscripts or scrolls, I just pity them. - Posting questions is always welcome from anyone, posting an argument provided with evidence is always welcome from anyone, having a scientific discussion is most welcome. But spreading lies just like that will lead to deleting the comment, and if it kept happening it may result in ban. - Know one thing .. it IS an established fact, whether you like it or not: The Holy Quran is the most perfect book that has ever existed, and every single letter or sound in it is verified. Doubting the Quran is truly the most laughable claim I’ve heard .. This video shows (some) of the evidence clearly and concisely: th-cam.com/video/MEtbT_Nrso8/w-d-xo.html Watch it if you have any doubt (don’t forget to turn on the subtitles). Finally .. Keep Learning, Stay motivated and Good Luck. Asslamo alikom, Arabic 101
@Eternity ok simple answer... The Taana Birmingham manuscript in the time of prophet Muhammad... Now, do you have any manuscripts from the 1st century of Jesus?
The Holy Quran is the most perfect book that has ever existed, and every single letter or sound in it is verified. And yet there are 37 different qurons including hafs and wersh which only came about in 1924 egypt. Can you explain that hole in the narrative good brother?
because of the attacker says about Quran variation, youtube recommend this video... thanks to Allah i found this video, and learn a new thing... thanks
Muslim: "Bible is corrupt" Quran (5:116) About not Corrupt Injil: "And as Allah said, "O Isa son of Maryam, (Jesus son of Mary) did you say to mankind, "Take me and my mother to your selves as two gods, apart from Allah '?" Me: bruh hahah where you can find Jesus, Mary and allah worshiped by christian
@@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT at least read the whole verse so you dont make yourself lost by the meaning of it 5:116 Sahih International And [beware the Day] when Allah will say, "O Jesus, Son of Mary, did you say to the people, 'Take me and my mother as deities besides Allah ?'" He will say, "Exalted are You! It was not for me to say that to which I have no right. If I had said it, You would have known it. You know what is within myself, and I do not know what is within Yourself. Indeed, it is You who is Knower of the unseen. 5:117 Sahih International I said not to them except what You commanded me - to worship Allah , my Lord and your Lord. And I was a witness over them as long as I was among them; but when You took me up, You were the Observer over them, and You are, over all things, Witness.
This is a wow explanation....but some missionaries try to use the variations to find as if there are faults....thank you for making this....you settled my case
When the Revelation came in the tounge of Muhammad, to which there were tribes and accent among them. Those who hears cannot understand Muhammad's tounge hence Muhammad asked God to reveal to him in other dialects not native to him.
@@freespeech24 moon god? Quran 41:37 Among His signs are the day and the night, the sun and the moon. Do not prostrate to the sun or the moon, but prostrate to Allah, Who created them ˹all˺, if you ˹truly˺ worship Him ˹alone˺.
I am Arab and I studied a brief about quira'at (in Arabic), but this is the first time for me to understand it clearly. Thank you so much, may God Grant you Jannah!
@@User-4517 still they don’t have 7 Akroof to show akroof 1 to 7 already burnt to ashes and rewritten by uthaman but it was also not available quraisy akroof is authentic
@Tom Staas Lol man...Bible has so many mistakes and your doctors don't have any logical answer for them so they say "it's just a traduction error" Quran is Arabic and has always been, with don't play with 10 languages trying to guess what this word meant in greek and what this word meant in hebrew. Only Arabic, how can hour book be "Superior" if you can't even preserve his original language ? Anyway big boy bring me a single evidence of historical and scientific mistake here and we'll see. Look the Joachim problem in your bible where it's stated 2 same sentence but the age of this king suddenly change, the SAME sentence, your God can't even say the same sentence, without a mistake man ?
@Eternity Indeed, it is We who sent down the message [i.e., the Quran], and indeed, We will be its guardian. (QURAN, CHAPTER 15, VERSE 9) We muslims have memorized the holy Quran for centuries. Word for word. Letter by letter. Everyone reciting same verses. Regarding Bible.. It was originally written in Aramaic and it is a dead language now. Feel free to wonder why this is so.
@@pr7049 they're the same words with different pronunciation, it's called dialects and stop repeating the lies of your hopeless missionaries, Watch this video exposes their lies th-cam.com/video/TZIEwUVQW8Y/w-d-xo.html
I'm a native arabic speaker and when I first read about the 7 ahruf, I couldn't understand it, even with a bit of research, there was always something in the explanation that is ambiguous with no straightforward meaning. I can't thank you enough. May Allah reward you.
@@SheikhAlladeen hey Andy, I'm not a researcher and I have not yet looked deep into ahruf and qira'at, It's -to my shame- a postponed topic on my list, I hope someday soon I'd tackle it. I had to start with this statement to make you understand that I'm not here to fight over something I find hard to my comprehension. as for the first example you gave, I believe you mean Surat Al-baqara verse 10? If that so, I don't see the meaning you're mentioning, perhaps you meant another one? The second one, Surat Al-anbya'a verse 4, yes, the two verbs indicate two deferent subjects, however, the meaning is still the same, to me at least, which is that God is the hearing and the knowing, whether it's a statement of the prophet Muhammad -pbuh- or a command of Allah for the prophet to say, either way, Allah is the one who inspire the prophet with Wahy to say that. So it's not that much of a case to me. As for the third example, Al-anbya'a verse 112, the same applies to me. The Last one and the washing or rinsing the foot during wudu', I had no idea there are two different rules, as for me, a muslim living in an Arabic country, It's been a norm to wash the foot, it's the ordinary thing we do and we learn since we are children making wudu', but I looked it up -thanks to you- and I found that most of the jurisdiction imams, including the famous four, said that washing is how it should be and not just wiping, which goes along with the Hafs qera'a, and also goes along with some hadeeth of the prophet -pbuh- and how he made wudu' himself. My final point, something you mentioned in the beginning of your comment, that ahruf has no existence in the qura'an, we as muslims don't take out rules from the qura'an exclusively, we also have the sunnah of the prophet Muhammad -pbuh- And if we went along with that notion of yours, we wouldn't have had a lot of rules of our rituals, cuz Sunnah sometimes detailed what the qura'an mentioned briefly or generally, and if you're right in what you say, maybe we should stop praying our five prayers with that amount of raqa'at cuz the qura'an didn't mention it, and it was just hadeeth or imitating what the prophet Muhammad -pbuh- used to do. But it's totally up to you to not trust the sunnah, but as for muslims we can't do that.
@@SheikhAlladeen just so you know, in Egypt, we have several official institutes that learn different qira'at, so it's no secret or they're trying to hide it due to the reasons you think might create a debate, the learners even get some sort of a degree called "Igaza" in that qira'a or in ten qira'at, and the most well known qura'a in Egypt have records of different qira'at as well. PS: it's not called "someone's qura'an" cuz that indicates we have "different" versions of the qura'an, like the bible, however, it's called "qura'an with someone's rewaya" or qira'a if you like.
Hi ! I have a question... There are some scholarly opinion that suggests that qiraats are bit confusing but can you tell me what's the majority opinion?
"Abbaas who narrated that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Jibreel taught me one style and I reviewed it until he taught me more, and I kept asking him for more and he gave me more until finally there were seven styles.”
This is the best explanation regarding ahruf and qiraat. Only Islam has the tool to preserve the Quran. That is isnad the golden chain of narration. Only Allah can reward you ustaz.
@Eternity there are person around this world that memorise the whole quraan with sanad, mean their reading is approved by their teacher which if traced back by generation will reach prophet muhammad. the system only to make sure people not confused as for the arab the is no confussion as that is their language. your statement is the perfect statement why that person made a system to determine which is which. don't worry your question been asked 1000years agoo before you think of it.
There is no what called 7 Ahrof .. Quran come with only 1 way in writing ✍ .. only one way in reading 📚 .. this is a big mistake to say that about Quran .. because Quran was written in Muhammad profit life .. please stop saying that .. it is wrong .. Again .. one way in writing ✍ .. one way in reading 📚
@Lion GamingYTz إن علينا جمعه و قرآنه . فإذا قرأناه فإتبع قرآنه هناك طريقة واحدة فقط لرسم القرآن و نطق واحد فقط أما عدا ذلك فكلها أكاذيب تطاولت على كتاب الله مع الزمن و للأسف بفضل جهالة المسلمين اللهم أنر عقولنا و قلوبنا بالعلم
The work done by javed ahmed ghamidi and his student Dr. shahzad saleem regarding the collection & transmission of the Quran are good enough for me. Most of the ahadeeth regarding the collection & transmission of the Quran have serious flaws... These seven qiraat are a bunch of rubbish and the only correct qirat is that which the majority of the muslims hold in their hands today from Arabia to indonesia. The various other qiraat are mostly found in parts of africa. A close look at them will clearly reveal the degraded arabic used in those qiraat and the changes that the people tried to make in the book of Allah. That only Qirat is named after Hafs, but he learnt it from someone else, I cant remember his name, who taught that the variations of Qiraat are wrong. These other Qiraat are a bunch of rubbish and considering them valid, would cast serious doubt regarding the authenticity of the book of Allah. Its time now, to reject them and call the spade a spade. The Quran itself says in surah al qiyamah - اِنَّ عَلَیۡنَا جَمۡعَہٗ وَ قُرۡاٰنَہٗ فَاِذَا قَرَاۡنٰہُ فَاتَّبِعۡ قُرۡاٰنَہٗ After this no other Qirat is valid..
Fascinating! I am a Hafith e Quran myself and had no idea about these consistent variations in Quran. I was only introduced with the first one you recited and memorized that only. Never thought Arabic could be so much diverse
Thank you Sir, I saw your video in my recommended feed and felt very anxious about viewing it, thinking it might throw doubt in my heart, but it did just the opposite as you were clear and concise, subhanallah 7 dialects and still the holy Quran retains it's claim and doesn't contradict itself. I could tell by your dialect that you're an Egyptian, greetings and love from Palestine❤️❤️
What a joke, Quran in seven dialects. Complete blasphemy in the name of "not dividing the ummah" May God help you people, one day you'll understand that the Arabs tampered with the words of God, and that the true way the Quran is preserved is true its literature and mathematical code
allah snackbar not girlfriend Farook Malik Quran 6:101 He is the creator of the heavens and the earth. How could He have a son when He has no consort? He has created everything and is aware of everything
Harf ≠ Dialect Harf ≈ dialect Scholars say they found more than 40 dialects in the Quran. Yet it's consistent and doesn't have mistakes or contradictions
How can differences in words such as singular vs plural or omitted words or changes in meaning “but actually deepening the meaning” be considered as no contradictions? How can the word of god have variations? There is no indication in the quran about these variations as far as i know
I swear nobody can understand how much this video helped me. I was nearly in a depressive state because I didnt understood, but thankfully to allah and you, I'm finally seeing the end of it all. Btw, im still searching clearance on some subjects such as the preservation of the quran, if someone can help me
@@Arabic101 thank you. I have a question regarding quiraat : you said that some ahrofs are in different nouns, such as plural and singular, so the meaning of some verses could change . for exemple : I remember a verse in wich it said that you get good deeds for helping a poor person and the other one said poor men, wich changes the meaning in a sense. if you could clear me up on this matter all my doubts will go away insha Allah . and pls make duaas for me if you can
@@zakariaarezki1661 Asslamo alikom, As indicated, there is no contradcition. the concept of singular and plural in Arabic can be sometimes synonymous, too. We call that اسم الجنس which when mentioning a singular form, but the meaning is all of them with the same trait. So when I say "feed the poor" I mean not talking about ONE person who is poor. BUT I am talking about ALL poor people I know. So in this case 'feed the poor' would give the same meaning as 'feed poor people' In the quran it is in different words of course, but a similar concept. The matter requires more explanation of course, but that is the main idea. Asslamo alikom
@@Arabic101 aleykoum salam, but I dont think that you understand what I said or maybe Im just dumb. its in 2:184, one says miskinin, so one person ( neutral, singular) and the other one says masakina (plurial, masculine). so if the one that says a poor person means to feed the poor in general, the other one says the poor men. is it talking about people in general or only men? but maybe my knowledge in arabic is just just limited
You have no idea how much I was struggling to find an answer for this matter of Quoran variations till now. I wasn't sure to respond to such claims from non Muslims trying to challenge me in my religion but thanks to Allah and then to you, I fully understood the matter now. Thanks a lot akhi and my Allah reward you.
I know your pain brother. I am not a Muslim scholar, and my local school dint really teach about qirat and 7 dialeg of Qur'an. So when non-muslim come to me, and say Qur'an has many version and he give me the proof. I became doubt about the Qur'an, because my local school only tell me 1 Qur'an to read. But I know, Qur'an is the word of God, and if the word of God has many version and different meaning than thats not the word of God. (Alhamdulillah Allah swt guide me, if not I think I will became a atheist, Alhamdulillah ya Rabb.) Aahh... I wanna cry when I think about it, because how many love Allah SWT give me... He dint leave me alone... So I googled about the version of Qur'an, and the internet answer alaways say there only 1 version but has 7 different dialeg. That make my doubt gone, but when I watch this video, Alhamdulillah, and Insyallah, I Will never doubt the Qur'an anymore. Ar-rahman : 13 "Then which of your Lord’s favours will you ˹humans and jinn˺ both deny?"
You should look up the variations with extra words. Of course, it’s easy to be deceived when they convince you not to research for yourself. But remember, your soul is at stake here. Or if you’re right, you’ll be able to give full reason to non believers. It should be God’s will that we be well studied, shouldn’t it.
How can Muslims keep lying to themselves that it's all about dialects when it's so obviously scribal errors? It's so embarrassing. 🤦♂️ In what Arab dialect do you have 'ta'malu' and 'ya'malu' both means the same thing? How about 'qâla' and 'qul'? In what Arabic dialect do they mean the same thing? How about "kabeer" (big) and "katseer" (many)? In what dialects do they mean the same thing? These are obviously the differences in marking (dots and harakat). 🤦♂️
@@zurgmuckerbergwhat does ta’malu and ya’malu mean? And if you think about it, big and many are pretty similar so it would not be surprising to think that the change of words wouldn’t affect the meaning. Example. There were “many” people in the army, there was “a big amount” of people in the army.
Alhamdulilah. Very beautifully explained. Ahruf - dialects. There are 7 dialects that one can use to read the Quran. Qirat- style of reciting the Quran. These 10 styles are based on the 7 ahruf / dialects.
Any explanation for Surah 37:12 Surah 37: 12; Hafs -> But YOU wonder, while they mock. ; Khalaf -> But I wonder, while they mock; Also Surah 2:184; Hafs says to feed a poor person; Warsh says feed poor people. It has legal implications right as we are not sure how many have to be fed as fidya...
@@haveyouconsidered7804 It is A wonder, not I, that is a wrong translation. Second, they don't change anything in the different dialects you said for 2:184. You can literally read the word in Arabic BOTH ways, so there is no "contradication." And what the hell do you mean "not sure", LOL? At least one person is to be fed, use some logic.
@@hexerouseven if agree ,.....' You ' wonder and 'A' wonder is the same??? Seriously...is this what it means perfectly preserved, word to word, dot to dot, vowel to vowel... And second one....what is correct..one person or many people....just tell me what is written in the Quran that is in heaven... it will be helpful.
@@haveyouconsidered7804 We have all of the dialects/pronounciations memorized. We have the same Quran today, just as it was revealed 1400 years ago and anywhere in God's perfect universe and beyond. Harakah was not a thing when the Quran was used (the signs you see above/below the letters), it was only made for Non-Arab Muslims and Non-Muslims to easily read the Quran. The pronounciations you hear in the different dialects (not different versions) can all be pronounced in the Quran that was written down without Harakah, so whatever point you make against this completely falls down and is utterly destroyed. There is ONE Quran. Now you tell me, which Bible is the true one?
@@hexerous Well brother, unfortunately, what you have mentioned is factually incorrect... Quran preservation is a myth. Ibn Abi Dawud, Kitab al-Masahif, p23 - Many of the Quran that was known by those who died on the day of Yamama…they were not known by those who survived them, nor were they written down, nor had Abu Bakr, Umar, or Uthman by that time collected the Quran, nor were they found with even one after them. This is confirmed by son of Umar - As Suyuti , Al-Itqan fii Ulum al-Quran, p524.Son of Umar himself saying, “Let none of you say I have acquired the whole of Quran, How do we know what all has disappeared? On top of that, Uthman burnt a lot of Qurans that did not match the Qureshi dialect. But looks like some survived, that is why we have 37 versions. What you probably have in 1924 Cairo edition Hafs. Ubai had a quran with 116 surahs.. So I can go on, but I desire that you will be sincere in your search for the truth...Unfortunately, there is no one quran with 114 surahs from the mid-7th century....what you have is from a letter time, and they don't agree with each other. I am talking about Topkapi, Samarkhand, Ma il, etc....
Amazing, great job! Now I know about the variations of reciting the Quran. And yes, you made me understand about it too. I'm so excited to learn more about the Quran. Keep on making great videos! Thank you.
@@Arabic101 the Morocco forbid the Hafs reading because it confusing population knowing only Warsh reading check the difference in th-cam.com/video/09u30tqbZmg/w-d-xo.html
Any help with this would be appreciated - In Surah 37: 12; Hafs -> But YOU wonder, while they mock. ; Khalaf -> But I wonder, while they mock; Also Surah 2:184; Hafs says to feed a poor person; Warsh says feed poor people. It has legal implications right as we are not sure how many have to be fed as fidya...
Well, that is because the variations were directly teached by prophet Muhammad, meanwhile Bible has been edited over the years (by people with no authority) edit@@jayski85
@@jayski85 . Because they both different. Variations in Quran is slight, it is about the differet way of reading, and it was known yet in the Prophet's lifetime, because the Prophet know that people have different tongue in the way they pronounciate. Variations in Bible is very extreme: - Catholic Bible has 73 books - Protestant Bible has 66 books - Greek and Russian Orthodox has 79 books - Ethiopian Orthodox has 81 books That's real variations in book versions.
@@amazingislam6997 but Muslim scholars say “ the Quran is unchanged @. If there are different variations in recitation then the Quran HAS been changed over time.
@@jayski85 The variations in recitation already existed in the lifetime of the Prophet. After the death of the Prophet, there is no new variations. So it's true that Quran is unchanged after the death of the Prophet until now.
JazakAllah khair ✨ Many non muslims out of their ignorance are attacking Muslims on this matter, JazakAllah khair for your effort, n I love to listen to different Recitations of Quran ❤️ may Allah SWT grant us deeper understanding Ameen 🤲🏻
Thank you so much for this! May Allah bless your channel for all the effort you're putting in strengthening the love we muslims have for Qur'an. Only Allah (swt) can be so Wise as to reveal those variations without letting any if it effect a single meaning. Subhanallah! Also, it is indeed important that we muslims be aware of this beautiful Quranic concept. Thanks a lot again. Continue the great work! Much dua for Jannah!
Did u live in his time?! If not, stop with this same method of trying to mock our prophet. It's getting old really. First of all, there are varying opinions on her age among scholars, so you don't get choose any one side and keep posting it everywhere, secondly, you do know that it was during 500AD+ right. If there was such a rule against marrying a small aged girl then, he'd be the first one to follow, and he "married" her, not like these days, where people in the name of feminism sexualize even preteen girls like they did in that "Cuties", what do you have to say about that. Oh, next time please read a book written by Aisha (ra) itself, before commenting something like this.
@Tom StaasPornography In the Bible:- 1- A Father In Law Is Paying Sheeps to Sleep with His Step Daughter. 2-Bible Talking About Sex Saying the Guy Looked At the Girls Boobs and It Was Looking Like A Tower 3-A Guy Is Licking Her Partners Vagina and Saying that It Tastes Like Wine And the List Goes On but I Dont Want to Put Dirt In My Mouth By Using Such Words of the Holy Bible One More Thing, Can You Read Those Things In Front of Your Kids, Mother, Daughter and Sister? Talking About Pornography
@@RehanShaikh-pm9ul Lol brother. He has gone quiet. They find it fun to poke at our religion when they can't even defend their own. Also I want to add that just 200 or so years ago it was legal for a girl in UK to get married at 9. You must understand something in the context of its time and culture.
@@baseermirza2947 They cant defend their religion so what they try to do is that they try to make Islam look down and David Wood, Christian Prince, Tash Hatun and Jay Smith are better at this job by misquoting verses, information of Islam, not telling the context and pointing out marriage of Ayesha RA... The Joker David Wood falied to proove Trinity against Muhammed Hijabbadly and made fun of himself and his own religion. And Mister Jay Smith, wh said that he's dream is to destroy Islam and vanish it from planet Earth lost badly against Shabbir Ally on the topic of Is Jesus GOD? And Pro Christian Scholar Christian Prince sits behind the screen and misguide Muslims, makes fun of Islam and abuses Islam and thats what Christian audience wants. Christians have so many issues to solve a few, I ll mention a few. go n study about these things and u will gind out their lies n contradictions of Bible urself 1-Is Bible God's Word?Is It Preserved? 2-Is Jesus God? Dif He Claimed to be GOD or Son of GOD? 3-What About Contradictions of Bible? 4-Scientific Errors of Bible? 5-Who Jesus Is Reffering to In New Testament and Yahwrh Reffering to In Old Testament? 6-Authenticity of Old Testament In thr Bible? 7-Is Yahweh Merciful? Etc
Jazaakallaahu khoiir, i’ve been learning how to read quran properly for at least 2 years, and i just finished my study on tajweed with riwayah Hafsh an Ashim with little comparasion with other riwayah. This video opens my mind to always learn and learn new stuff. Thank you!
I have been looking for this topics for months. Many other explanations make me confused. Alhamdulillah your explanation is clear to me. InshaAllah I can study further on the subject with the basic understanding I have learned from you. Thank you my teacher.
Tbh I couldn't wait u to finish Hafs aspects before u begin teaching us a different Qira'h. So I just jumped to different ppl in the seek of learning. I've mastered 4 so far! I only knew the 7 Ahruf through this channel. Imagine the Thwab u have earned :) Jazak Allahu khairan
Bravo...Ya Usthadh your the best in explaining the complex and advanced Quranic Arabic Grammar or Recitation...I'm lucky to found you in TH-cam. May Allah bless you in any means he wishes. Jazaka Allahu Khairan.
Alhamdulilah , Alhamdulilah .. It's all Allah's guidance and help without which I can do nothing, so Alhamdulilah ... Please share the video and the channel to let more and more people benefit from it and in shaa Allah, you'll share the ajer Ameen and Thank you very much for these amazing words, they motivate me greatly ... Alhamdulilah
@@Arabic101 Definitely Usthadh I'm sharing your videos with my family and friends. Without a doubt ALLAH is all knowledgeable and everything happens from the permission of ALLAH. But indeed you have put your efforts to teach the Holy Qur'an in simple and easy way....🤗👍👌
the Morocco forbid the Hafs reading because it confusing population knowing only Warsh reading check the difference in th-cam.com/video/09u30tqbZmg/w-d-xo.html
@@thetruththewaythelife6796 Hello Genius. I know that you are SOOOOO desperate to disbelieve in Qur-aan. Yasir Qadhi had posted a new video clarifying things and deleted the old video that led to misunderstanding among ignorant and liars like your priest DW & CP
My brother I don't even know what to say may Almighty Allah reward you with a reward that will never end brother with your teachings I have confidence to read the Quran thank you brother as people keep on finding this channel and learned from you may Allah keep on increase your deeds Jaza kumu llahu kayran
and another doubt immediately removed, every time my heart is filled with doubt about any subject in Islam i find a quick answer i wonder why it's not something taught in schools, to know about the ahruf
I relate to you! I think it isn't widely taught, and some discourage openly talking about it since it is a VERY technical subject, and not everyone is blessed with the intelligence to articulate it properly.
@gsem000 salam aleikum brother, please delete your comment as it can create fitnah. Allah bestows knowledge to some as a blessing in order to strengthen their iman and bring His slave close to Him. Why must you write something negative? Instead you should be saying alhamdulilah that Allah grants understanding to his ummah in His infinite mercy.
The best thing about this is kaaffirs thinks they can being us to poIytheism with their baseless lies but infact when they open these topics we research more and increases us in faith 🔸The believers are only those who, when Allah is mentioned, their hearts become fearful, and when His verses are recited to them, it increases them in faith; and upon their Lord they rely - 8:2
@gsem000 Wow. You suck. People can have doubts, you know. We aren't perfect. We aren't angels. We're human. Allah knows that we're weak. There is Shaytan and Fitna all around us. Do you really have to make it harder for a person trying to make any doubt in his heart disappear? You should thank Allah for your strong iman and pray for OP, instead of shaming them. These are not the qualities of a proper muslim. You should worry about yourself, dude.
I am absoulutely jealous with you. You have a capability to make video and explain the right things, it will be your good deeds, the more people watch, the more you earn from Allah SWT. Thanks brother! May Allah reward you jannah.
Christians try use this as an argument Whilst their variations are different stories of the same individuals That’s contradictions And the contradictions of scientific facts and many more This 7 ahruf is but a miracle of the miracles of the Quran for all are preserved
Eternity Just because someone said the standard narrative has holes doesn’t make it right Went back in his word (Remember) we don’t blindly follow ppl 😂 th-cam.com/video/JmjURdYS5K0/w-d-xo.html Check this out for your answer on deference and the “Egyptian Quran” I don’t know why this is like supposed to be against Islam? U Christians don’t want to understand I guess That’s your problem Refer to the channel for more answers th-cam.com/video/K11XfOfTFAU/w-d-xo.html Claim The qiraat are mistakes If u are Christian then OH Man 😂 So I hope u are an atheist trying this hard because then u are trying to debunk something u cannot refute whilst whatever u believe in is not even worthy of this type of criticism Because it’s all over the place ( literally)
@Eternity Actually there’s a difference of opinion on her age. We can easily look at one hadith (saying of the Prophet) and make our own ruling on it but if we do that, it’ll cause corruption due to our limited knowledge. Therefore, we refer to scholars who take all of the related hadiths, Quranic verses, etc. when coming to a fatwa (ruling), conclusion on a historical event, etc. This is the same case with Aisha’s age, may Allah be pleased with her. www.islamweb.net/ehajj/printarticle.php?id=38813&lang=E&id=38813&lang=E We must seek the truth and only then will we be guided. May Allah guide you and your family & guide me & my family and allow us to seek the truth in our hearts.
@Adam A it's funny, this Christian calling himself "Eternity" gets proven wrong twice, then his only response is to give a non-sequitur about the (not unanimous) topic of Aisha's age.
Surah As-Saffat (37:12), has two distinct readings in the Hafs and Warsh recitations, which lead to theological implications due to their differing subjects of amazement. The Two Recitations: Hafs vs. Warsh 1. Hafs Recitation (Most Common): • Arabic: “بَلْ عَجِبْتُ وَيَسْخَرُونَ” • Transliteration: “Bal ʿAjibtu wa-yasakhirūn.” • Translation: “But I (Allah) am amazed, and they mock.” • Key Subject: The word ʿAjibtu (عَجِبْتُ, “I am amazed”) refers to Allah. 2. Warsh Recitation: • Arabic: “بَلْ عَجِبْتَ وَيَسْخَرُونَ” • Transliteration: “Bal ʿAjibta wa-yasakhirūn.” • Translation: “But you (O Muhammad) are amazed, and they mock.” • Key Subject: The word ʿAjibta (عَجِبْتَ, “You are amazed”) refers to Muhammad. Differences Between the Recitations 1. Grammatical Subject: • Hafs Recitation: The verb ʿAjibtu (“I am amazed”) uses the first-person singular pronoun -tu, which explicitly refers to Allah. • Warsh Recitation: The verb ʿAjibta (“You are amazed”) uses the second-person singular pronoun -ta, which refers to Muhammad. 2. Theological Implications: • Hafs: • Attributes amazement to Allah, which raises theological concerns: • Amazement implies surprise or encountering the unexpected, qualities inconsistent with Allah’s omniscience. • Anthropomorphism: Describing Allah with human-like emotions (e.g., amazement) contradicts Islamic principles of transcendence. • Warsh: • Attributes amazement to Muhammad, which aligns better with traditional Islamic theology since Muhammad, as a human, can naturally experience surprise or amazement. 3. Contextual Flow: • The Warsh recitation aligns with the surrounding verses, where the disbelievers’ mocking is directed toward Muhammad. In this context, it makes sense for Muhammad to be amazed at their rejection of truth. • The Hafs recitation shifts the focus to Allah, introducing theological tensions regarding divine emotions. Why This Difference Is Problematic 1. Contradictory Theological Implications • The Hafs recitation challenges Allah’s omniscience and immutability: • Amazement implies a reaction to an unforeseen or extraordinary event, which is incompatible with Allah’s knowledge of all things. • Islamic theology rejects attributing human emotions to Allah, as stated in Surah Ash-Shura (42:11): “There is nothing like unto Him.” • The Warsh recitation avoids these issues by attributing amazement to Muhammad, who, as a human, can naturally feel surprise or shock. 2. Linguistic and Doctrinal Ambiguity • If both recitations are considered valid, they create conflicting theological narratives: • Hafs: Allah expresses amazement. • Warsh: Muhammad expresses amazement. • These differences are significant enough to influence interpretations of Allah’s nature and Muhammad’s role, undermining the Quran’s claim to perfect clarity: • Surah Hud (11:1): “This is a Book whose verses are perfected and then explained in detail from [one who is] Wise and Acquainted.” 3. Implications for Quranic Inerrancy • Muslims believe the Quran is preserved and free of contradictions: • Surah An-Nisa (4:82): “Then do they not reflect upon the Quran? If it had been from [any] other than Allah, they would have found within it much contradiction.” • However, the differences between Hafs and Warsh raise questions: • If Allah “praying” is problematic, why does one recitation include it? • If both are valid, how can the Quran avoid contradictory meanings? Reactions by Islamic Scholars 1. Defense of Both Readings: • Scholars argue that both recitations are valid, as they are part of the seven canonical readings (Qira’at). • They claim the Hafs reading refers to Allah’s “condemnation” rather than literal amazement, while the Warsh reading reflects Muhammad’s emotional reaction. 2. Preference for Warsh: • Some scholars and translators lean toward the Warsh recitation to avoid the theological complications of attributing amazement to Allah. 3. Use of Tafwid: • When confronted with theological issues in the Hafs recitation, scholars often invoke tafwid (consigning the meaning to Allah alone), sidestepping the need for explanation. Conclusion The difference between the Hafs and Warsh recitations of Surah As-Saffat (37:12) highlights a significant theological issue: 1. The Hafs recitation, attributing amazement to Allah, challenges core Islamic doctrines of omniscience and transcendence. 2. The Warsh recitation, attributing amazement to Muhammad, avoids these issues and aligns with Islamic theology. 3. The existence of such differences raises questions about Quranic inerrancy and clarity, especially when these variations lead to contradictory understandings of Allah’s nature. Ultimately, the tension reflects broader challenges within the doctrine of Quranic preservation and the coexistence of multiple, differing recitations.
Jazakallah, Thank you this was really helpful. This video really shut down all those non muslims who claim the Quran was changed or has many copies. There is only one Quran with the same meaning & message however different dialects make it easier to read or increase there meaning. The message of the Quran is the same though, this video actually increased my faith. Thanks bro , Keep up the good work.
Blind faith, the word Ahruf is unknown and is a mystery. Their are over 40 different opinions regarding the word Ahruf which means your scholars do not know the meaning of it. It is a mystery and this means that Islam is false.
@@bigfan2452 lol if Islam is false then christianity should be false too and judaism should be false too cause in Islam the holy books of Jews and Christians Bible(injil) torah(old Testament) or talmud tanakh they're mentioned in quran. U "can" say that quran is false but not islam because islam is since the time of adam(AS) and if scholars have diffrent opinions that doesn't make a religion false or corrupt. If I ask a pastor about is Jesus a God or a prophet if he says he's a prophet and I ask another pastor that is Jesus a God or prophet he says Jesus is God does that make christianity false??
@@fahadpasha947 yes, I can say that Islam and Quran is false because both of them came from Arabia in the 7th century. Their is no evidence that Adam was a Muslim at all. Also, to answer your question we do not base our faiths in one pastor but in our early Church Fathers, intellectuals that were taught by the disciples of Jesus Christ. If a pastor contradicts a early Church Father we automatically reject him.
@@bigfan2452 even if there is no evidence the things of his times are evident and adam being Christian or muslim doesn't change the fact. And islam didn't come in 7th cent go check the birth date of Muhammad and tell ur American Michael h. Hart to put Jesus in first place not Muhammad in his the world's most influential persons and there are the muslim that study quranic science and even if it is blind it is blind by heart not eyes and when we read and study every religion it comes to a common term that god is one, there is no idol, coming of final prophet. The vedas call him as "narashansa" Nara(man) shansa( to praise or be praised) and Muhammad means the man who is praised and in old Testament deutronomy 18:18 and in songs of solomon. And I appreciate every religion that it has something in common. And in Bible 1st timothy it says that "the head which is uncovered should be shaved". But in christianity just the nuns cover their head not every woman and in islam it isn't that strict but every women do cover themselves.
@@fahadpasha947 I have already checked it out and it is the 6th century. I never said that Adam was a Christian as we do not believe that either. Also, the quranic science is false and full of errors because it comes 200 years later after Muhammad died. The Old Testament teaches that God is one but has revealed himself in three persons. So, the Bible contradicts the Quran notion of God. Moreover, Muhammed is not in the deutronomy nor song of Solomons because he is a false prophet. The New Testament tells us that False prophets will come and spread falsehood and that's what exactly Muhammed did.
@Arabic 101 the Morocco forbid the Hafs reading because it confusing population knowing only Warsh reading check the difference in th-cam.com/video/09u30tqbZmg/w-d-xo.html
I was just being exposed to this subject to-day. A little bit confused. After listening to this explanation it became clearer. Thanks so much. Grateful to bump to this programme.
Amazimg amazing amazing.. This is the answer to those who claim Qur'an has contradictions.... masha allah.. amazing.. may Allah belss you upon all of ur work and dedication
Jazakkallhu Khair. Dear brother you have explained the topic clearly. I was looking for the answers for a long time. Keep spreading the knowledge. Allah will reward you with the best. Insha Allah.
Alhamdulilahi!!! For ur efforts. A topic that I found complex has been dealt with so elegantly. Subhanallah! May Allah Bless you and the team. A must watch for all our brothers and sisters. 🌸
Jazak Allah Khair. You explained it very well in simple words and it made my belief even stronger than Quran is the Word of Allah (SWT). It will help me during my dawah work.
Thank you ever so much for making it so simple to understand I watch all your videos, it really helps to get rid of confusions, it's so amazing how you explain in short but I get all my questions answered in few minutes, may Allah reward you for your hard work and may Allah make your life happy and easy like you making easy for millions of people who are trying read the noble Quran as it should be read just to please Allah swt. JazakAllahu kheiran.🤗
Assalamualaikum brother, I seriously can't tell you that I'm so shocked 😲 and happy 😊 to know that Allah the almighty has revealed the Qur'an in 7 ahrof and 10 qirat... This is so amazing just for the better understanding for the people and also to challenge the disbelievers... See I'm a 17 year old and I'm a budding hafiza and while reading the Qur'an on my phone as well as mushaf I always wonder why there's a difference as I use indopak script and uthmani also... But now with the help of this video my all doubts are removed and my eman on Qur'an has become more powerful... Seriously I want to thank you for this video... This video means a lot to me
Thank you so much for this clear explanation. It's useful for Muslims and non-Muslims alike, those of us who are still confused and struggle to understand the meaning of different ahruf and qiraat. For those of us who debate with Christians, now we have a resource to share with them. Jazzakallahu khoir
The main points the presenter made was 1. To make it easier to read in one of the seven dialects. An example given was color and colour. If it was to make it easier for the reader then it would be consistent across the whole version of the Quran. If a book had both colour and color in the USA version of the book I would call it a mistake. 2. To deepen the meaning. The presenter gave the example of one aya having a version of having fought or having been killed. His explanation is the difference adds another dimension without contradicting one another. The Quran is supposedly written in clear Arabic and this is an obvious contradiction.
@@heathersoares186 Arabs spoke in different dialects. It was revealed in different dialects to make it easy for them. They had different grammer, different pronounciation, and some tribes didn't have complete letters!
@@SheikhAlladeen first of all, are you an expert in classical arabic? secondly, did any muslim at the time of the prophet and the first 4 caliphs ever argue with one another about a different Quran? NONE! No evidence. Zero! The only evidence we have is one companion arguing about the way a verse is recited and the matter was brought to the Prophet and he said both are correct. No point arguing using the modern context of the language. Case closed.
Jazzakallahu khayr,a bro recently complained to me about a certain Qari the way he recites Fatiha,I told him there are different styles so we were searching for precise answer before we could comment on it since we all reverts.. Alhamdulillah here I got it may Allah bless u for this ilm
Mind blowing and I am shaking. Amazing Quran. May Allah guide us through the holy Quran and give rewards to those who are giving/given their time and effort to teach us the Quran.
he not telling the whole story the Morocco forbid the Hafs reading because it confusing population knowing only Warsh reading check the difference in th-cam.com/video/09u30tqbZmg/w-d-xo.html
InshaAllah please go through all the different ayat like you did with the one with قتل so we can fully appreciate how these words supplement eachother throughout the 7 ahruf, all of them 😍
Masha Allah I am sooo glad I chanced upon your video! thanks a lot for the super duper clear and simple explanation about the differences btw Ahroof and Qiraat! Surely, learning about the Qur'an is a lifelong journey. Baarakallahu feekum!
Assalamu'alaikum, brother. Thank you so much for the video! It's a wonderful explanation for the Ahruf and the Qira'at. In my opinion, if you had added the conditions of an authentic Qira'ah (conformity to the consonantal skeleton of the Uthmanic codex, sound chain of narration to Prophet Muhammad pbuh, and consistency with the linguistic rulings of Arabic), it would've been the cherry on top! I hope Allah will reward you plentifully. Aamiin.
Mash Allah simply n concisely explained.. i ve tried reading about this topic in tajweed books but they make it so complex to understand.. i never got a clear answer or explanation even from teachers! Jazak Allah khair for this much needed video. Much appreciation.
Jazakalah Kheir watched this video long time ago. Watched it again to quickly understand the differences when a friend brought up the qiraat and was somehow confused. Sharing this video with them. May Allah add it to your scale of good deeds untill the final Hour.
Jazakallah Khairan. I found this channel very useful for ummah, especially we Muslims. I was searching article about non Muslims claim on Quran that has many version and how to answer their claim. Alhamdulillah I found this video along with some other videos from our brothers discussing about this matter. But this video is has a very nice and clear presentation to make even a very beginner could understand easily. Once again, jazakallahu khairan, thank you very much for sharing. I subscribed this channel to learn more.
Surah As-Saffat (37:12), has two distinct readings in the Hafs and Warsh recitations, which lead to theological implications due to their differing subjects of amazement. The Two Recitations: Hafs vs. Warsh 1. Hafs Recitation (Most Common): • Arabic: “بَلْ عَجِبْتُ وَيَسْخَرُونَ” • Transliteration: “Bal ʿAjibtu wa-yasakhirūn.” • Translation: “But I (Allah) am amazed, and they mock.” • Key Subject: The word ʿAjibtu (عَجِبْتُ, “I am amazed”) refers to Allah. 2. Warsh Recitation: • Arabic: “بَلْ عَجِبْتَ وَيَسْخَرُونَ” • Transliteration: “Bal ʿAjibta wa-yasakhirūn.” • Translation: “But you (O Muhammad) are amazed, and they mock.” • Key Subject: The word ʿAjibta (عَجِبْتَ, “You are amazed”) refers to Muhammad. Differences Between the Recitations 1. Grammatical Subject: • Hafs Recitation: The verb ʿAjibtu (“I am amazed”) uses the first-person singular pronoun -tu, which explicitly refers to Allah. • Warsh Recitation: The verb ʿAjibta (“You are amazed”) uses the second-person singular pronoun -ta, which refers to Muhammad. 2. Theological Implications: • Hafs: • Attributes amazement to Allah, which raises theological concerns: • Amazement implies surprise or encountering the unexpected, qualities inconsistent with Allah’s omniscience. • Anthropomorphism: Describing Allah with human-like emotions (e.g., amazement) contradicts Islamic principles of transcendence. • Warsh: • Attributes amazement to Muhammad, which aligns better with traditional Islamic theology since Muhammad, as a human, can naturally experience surprise or amazement. 3. Contextual Flow: • The Warsh recitation aligns with the surrounding verses, where the disbelievers’ mocking is directed toward Muhammad. In this context, it makes sense for Muhammad to be amazed at their rejection of truth. • The Hafs recitation shifts the focus to Allah, introducing theological tensions regarding divine emotions. Why This Difference Is Problematic 1. Contradictory Theological Implications • The Hafs recitation challenges Allah’s omniscience and immutability: • Amazement implies a reaction to an unforeseen or extraordinary event, which is incompatible with Allah’s knowledge of all things. • Islamic theology rejects attributing human emotions to Allah, as stated in Surah Ash-Shura (42:11): “There is nothing like unto Him.” • The Warsh recitation avoids these issues by attributing amazement to Muhammad, who, as a human, can naturally feel surprise or shock. 2. Linguistic and Doctrinal Ambiguity • If both recitations are considered valid, they create conflicting theological narratives: • Hafs: Allah expresses amazement. • Warsh: Muhammad expresses amazement. • These differences are significant enough to influence interpretations of Allah’s nature and Muhammad’s role, undermining the Quran’s claim to perfect clarity: • Surah Hud (11:1): “This is a Book whose verses are perfected and then explained in detail from [one who is] Wise and Acquainted.” 3. Implications for Quranic Inerrancy • Muslims believe the Quran is preserved and free of contradictions: • Surah An-Nisa (4:82): “Then do they not reflect upon the Quran? If it had been from [any] other than Allah, they would have found within it much contradiction.” • However, the differences between Hafs and Warsh raise questions: • If Allah “praying” is problematic, why does one recitation include it? • If both are valid, how can the Quran avoid contradictory meanings? Reactions by Islamic Scholars 1. Defense of Both Readings: • Scholars argue that both recitations are valid, as they are part of the seven canonical readings (Qira’at). • They claim the Hafs reading refers to Allah’s “condemnation” rather than literal amazement, while the Warsh reading reflects Muhammad’s emotional reaction. 2. Preference for Warsh: • Some scholars and translators lean toward the Warsh recitation to avoid the theological complications of attributing amazement to Allah. 3. Use of Tafwid: • When confronted with theological issues in the Hafs recitation, scholars often invoke tafwid (consigning the meaning to Allah alone), sidestepping the need for explanation. Conclusion The difference between the Hafs and Warsh recitations of Surah As-Saffat (37:12) highlights a significant theological issue: 1. The Hafs recitation, attributing amazement to Allah, challenges core Islamic doctrines of omniscience and transcendence. 2. The Warsh recitation, attributing amazement to Muhammad, avoids these issues and aligns with Islamic theology. 3. The existence of such differences raises questions about Quranic inerrancy and clarity, especially when these variations lead to contradictory understandings of Allah’s nature. Ultimately, the tension reflects broader challenges within the doctrine of Quranic preservation and the coexistence of multiple, differing recitations.
Jazakallahu ahsanuljaza ya akhi you have explained this very complex and sensitive topic easily and cleared our doubts may allah reward you in this world and here after... Ameen And also very gratefull for sharing those websites this helps alot. ❤❤❤
JazakAllahu khayrun brother extremely beneficial and educational may Allah subhaanahu ta reward you in abundance with all forms of goodness Aameen thumma Aameen 🤲💝🧕 keep up the great work 💝🤲
Information overload! I graduated into reading Quran by 4y/o. I fell off a bit in my teens, but came back to the path by age 20 and started relearning Quran alhamdulillah. But I'm 32 now, I've known that there were Qira'at, and that they sounded somewhat different, but this is the first time I've heard in this detail
You are doing great job, making things easy for us. May Allah grant you highest level of paradise. In the age of ignorance we need more and more clear explanations, not for non-Muslims, mainly for Muslims themselves.
From Chat GPT: Yes, I can affirm that based on what I shared. The Quran is indeed exceptionally well-preserved, with no significant differences across the qira'at that would alter the core beliefs, doctrines, or practices of Islam. The variations that exist in the qira'at are minor and do not impact fundamental meanings or introduce theological contradictions. On the other hand, as demonstrated by the examples in the Bible, there are notable differences in various manuscripts, translations, and interpretations, some of which affect essential theological points such as the divinity of Jesus, the Trinity, and other doctrines. These differences in the Bible highlight its textual variations over time, something that the Quran does not experience due to its unique preservation through memorization and written record. Thus, the Quran's preservation contrasts sharply with the textual challenges present in the Bible.
Surah As-Saffat (37:12), has two distinct readings in the Hafs and Warsh recitations, which lead to theological implications due to their differing subjects of amazement. The Two Recitations: Hafs vs. Warsh 1. Hafs Recitation (Most Common): • Arabic: “بَلْ عَجِبْتُ وَيَسْخَرُونَ” • Transliteration: “Bal ʿAjibtu wa-yasakhirūn.” • Translation: “But I (Allah) am amazed, and they mock.” • Key Subject: The word ʿAjibtu (عَجِبْتُ, “I am amazed”) refers to Allah. 2. Warsh Recitation: • Arabic: “بَلْ عَجِبْتَ وَيَسْخَرُونَ” • Transliteration: “Bal ʿAjibta wa-yasakhirūn.” • Translation: “But you (O Muhammad) are amazed, and they mock.” • Key Subject: The word ʿAjibta (عَجِبْتَ, “You are amazed”) refers to Muhammad. Differences Between the Recitations 1. Grammatical Subject: • Hafs Recitation: The verb ʿAjibtu (“I am amazed”) uses the first-person singular pronoun -tu, which explicitly refers to Allah. • Warsh Recitation: The verb ʿAjibta (“You are amazed”) uses the second-person singular pronoun -ta, which refers to Muhammad. 2. Theological Implications: • Hafs: • Attributes amazement to Allah, which raises theological concerns: • Amazement implies surprise or encountering the unexpected, qualities inconsistent with Allah’s omniscience. • Anthropomorphism: Describing Allah with human-like emotions (e.g., amazement) contradicts Islamic principles of transcendence. • Warsh: • Attributes amazement to Muhammad, which aligns better with traditional Islamic theology since Muhammad, as a human, can naturally experience surprise or amazement. 3. Contextual Flow: • The Warsh recitation aligns with the surrounding verses, where the disbelievers’ mocking is directed toward Muhammad. In this context, it makes sense for Muhammad to be amazed at their rejection of truth. • The Hafs recitation shifts the focus to Allah, introducing theological tensions regarding divine emotions. Why This Difference Is Problematic 1. Contradictory Theological Implications • The Hafs recitation challenges Allah’s omniscience and immutability: • Amazement implies a reaction to an unforeseen or extraordinary event, which is incompatible with Allah’s knowledge of all things. • Islamic theology rejects attributing human emotions to Allah, as stated in Surah Ash-Shura (42:11): “There is nothing like unto Him.” • The Warsh recitation avoids these issues by attributing amazement to Muhammad, who, as a human, can naturally feel surprise or shock. 2. Linguistic and Doctrinal Ambiguity • If both recitations are considered valid, they create conflicting theological narratives: • Hafs: Allah expresses amazement. • Warsh: Muhammad expresses amazement. • These differences are significant enough to influence interpretations of Allah’s nature and Muhammad’s role, undermining the Quran’s claim to perfect clarity: • Surah Hud (11:1): “This is a Book whose verses are perfected and then explained in detail from [one who is] Wise and Acquainted.” 3. Implications for Quranic Inerrancy • Muslims believe the Quran is preserved and free of contradictions: • Surah An-Nisa (4:82): “Then do they not reflect upon the Quran? If it had been from [any] other than Allah, they would have found within it much contradiction.” • However, the differences between Hafs and Warsh raise questions: • If Allah “praying” is problematic, why does one recitation include it? • If both are valid, how can the Quran avoid contradictory meanings? Reactions by Islamic Scholars 1. Defense of Both Readings: • Scholars argue that both recitations are valid, as they are part of the seven canonical readings (Qira’at). • They claim the Hafs reading refers to Allah’s “condemnation” rather than literal amazement, while the Warsh reading reflects Muhammad’s emotional reaction. 2. Preference for Warsh: • Some scholars and translators lean toward the Warsh recitation to avoid the theological complications of attributing amazement to Allah. 3. Use of Tafwid: • When confronted with theological issues in the Hafs recitation, scholars often invoke tafwid (consigning the meaning to Allah alone), sidestepping the need for explanation. Conclusion The difference between the Hafs and Warsh recitations of Surah As-Saffat (37:12) highlights a significant theological issue: 1. The Hafs recitation, attributing amazement to Allah, challenges core Islamic doctrines of omniscience and transcendence. 2. The Warsh recitation, attributing amazement to Muhammad, avoids these issues and aligns with Islamic theology. 3. The existence of such differences raises questions about Quranic inerrancy and clarity, especially when these variations lead to contradictory understandings of Allah’s nature. Ultimately, the tension reflects broader challenges within the doctrine of Quranic preservation and the coexistence of multiple, differing recitations.
It is a true book but have seven ways to receit it Only problems now, was.. How many recitation left? Only the lord of a doomsday, would know & have the answer!
Masha’Allah your videos are simply superb. Crisp and clear explanation. Which software do you use brother? I need it to teach medical students. Jazak’Allah khair
Great video... This is not easy topic to be get on one vodeo. But you make it great video.. Thanks a lot.. Jazakumullah khairal jaza'.. May Allah bless you and your knowledge..
Clearly one of the greatest channel to learn tajweed rules I'm impressed. Jazak Allahou khayran. Just a precision, if I may, for viewers that may think, "well, in fact the masters of qira'at just came and picked up qira'aat randomly by themselves". حاش لله One day, Hafs and Chu'ba who both learned from 'Asim (liked he brilliantly explained in the video) asked him why we are both learning from you but we don't learn the same qira'at? Asim answered by saying (approximately because I heared it in Arabic): "because you Hafs, I teached you the way I learned from Abd al Rahman al Sulami, who learned it from Ali ibn Abu Talib. And you Chu'ba I teached you the way I learned from Zur ibn Habacha who learned it from Abdullah ibn Mas'ud". Just to say it's not like they came with recitation no one knew about before them.
The GREAT explanation ever! I was told wrong thing... but thank u ustadh! U corrected me! And, Could I please have your name? Because calling u without ur name seems awkward.
BEFORE POSTING A COMMENT, READ THIS
Dear brothers/ sisters,
Some desperate non-Muslims have been posting comments here which are nothing but lies, fabrications, and links for video whose sole purpose is spreading ignorance and make Muslims think they doubt their deen.
And some dear brothers/ sisters asked me why this topic? It might make people suspicious about Islam.
And I say:
- The sole purpose of this channel is spreading knowledge and truth. It’s not meant to compare religions or criticize atheism/ any other religion.
- Thanks to Allah and unlike any other religion or ideology, there is not a single topic in Islam/ Quran which, we Muslims, are afraid to discuss or are ashamed of.
- I have not responded to those malicious comments/ video links because they are too insignificant to spend my time refuting them, they simply do not contain any shred of evidence in them not even to be able to refute them. When you see people, who can’t even read Arabic properly, criticize the holy Quran, then I am done. When you see people talking about Quran's different manuscripts or scrolls, I just pity them.
- Posting questions is always welcome from anyone, posting an argument provided with evidence is always welcome from anyone, having a scientific discussion is most welcome. But spreading lies just like that will lead to deleting the comment, and if it kept happening it may result in ban.
- Know one thing .. it IS an established fact, whether you like it or not: The Holy Quran is the most perfect book that has ever existed, and every single letter or sound in it is verified. Doubting the Quran is truly the most laughable claim I’ve heard .. This video shows (some) of the evidence clearly and concisely: th-cam.com/video/MEtbT_Nrso8/w-d-xo.html Watch it if you have any doubt (don’t forget to turn on the subtitles).
Finally .. Keep Learning, Stay motivated and Good Luck.
Asslamo alikom,
Arabic 101
Ma Shaa Allah, jazakallaah ya akhi, keep posting,
Well answered bro! بارك الله فيك
@Eternity ok simple answer... The Taana Birmingham manuscript in the time of prophet Muhammad... Now, do you have any manuscripts from the 1st century of Jesus?
The Holy Quran is the most perfect book that has ever existed, and every single letter or sound in it is verified. And yet there are 37 different qurons including hafs and wersh which only came about in 1924 egypt. Can you explain that hole in the narrative good brother?
@Tauhida Khan All liars and deceivers just like your fake profit and moon god
because of the attacker says about Quran variation, youtube recommend this video... thanks to Allah i found this video, and learn a new thing... thanks
Muslim: "Bible is corrupt"
Quran (5:116) About not Corrupt Injil: "And as Allah said, "O Isa son of Maryam, (Jesus son of Mary) did you say to mankind, "Take me and my mother to your selves as two gods, apart from Allah '?"
Me: bruh hahah where you can find Jesus, Mary and allah worshiped by christian
@@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT at least read the whole verse so you dont make yourself lost by the meaning of it
5:116
Sahih International
And [beware the Day] when Allah will say, "O Jesus, Son of Mary, did you say to the people, 'Take me and my mother as deities besides Allah ?'" He will say, "Exalted are You! It was not for me to say that to which I have no right. If I had said it, You would have known it. You know what is within myself, and I do not know what is within Yourself. Indeed, it is You who is Knower of the unseen.
5:117
Sahih International
I said not to them except what You commanded me - to worship Allah , my Lord and your Lord. And I was a witness over them as long as I was among them; but when You took me up, You were the Observer over them, and You are, over all things, Witness.
@@andheeid i said who worship isa, mary and god 😂
@Ifat H i said abdul who worship isa, mary and god hahah
@Ifat H they don’t know what they are doing
This is a wow explanation....but some missionaries try to use the variations to find as if there are faults....thank you for making this....you settled my case
All of their arguments came be overcome by knowledge of Deen.
The problem is which variant your moon god gave. Isnt he suppose to clear because its god’s language
When the Revelation came in the tounge of Muhammad, to which there were tribes and accent among them. Those who hears cannot understand Muhammad's tounge hence Muhammad asked God to reveal to him in other dialects not native to him.
@@freespeech24 Why are you asking us this question? Ask the moon god worshippers not the Muslims.
@@freespeech24 moon god?
Quran 41:37 Among His signs are the day and the night, the sun and the moon. Do not prostrate to the sun or the moon, but prostrate to Allah, Who created them ˹all˺, if you ˹truly˺ worship Him ˹alone˺.
I am Arab and I studied a brief about quira'at (in Arabic), but this is the first time for me to understand it clearly.
Thank you so much, may God Grant you Jannah!
Ameen!
Aameen, yaa Rabb ❤
La Ilah illallah Mohammad Un Rasul Ullah W Ali un Waliullah 🎉
@@AStory.1abu bakr valiyullah, umar valiyullah, usman valiyullah, muawiya valiyulla, and Ali valiyullah😊
@@limshid3141 Lanat Ho in sab wakiyo par sewaye ali maula ke
Alhamdolillah for native arab speakers getting on youtube and explaining these things. Jzk ustad
Thanks for sharing
The best use for TH-cam, AllhumdliAllah
@@User-4517 still they don’t have 7 Akroof to show akroof 1 to 7 already burnt to ashes and rewritten by uthaman but it was also not available quraisy akroof is authentic
@@rgap3944did you watch the video? I don’t think you did.
@@rgap3944oh my, you people are being lied too. We learn it and even had competition and you thought this knowledge is lost what the hack
i was looking for the clear answer of 7 Asraf and 10 Qirats for long time and found here finally.
@Tom Staas Lol man...Bible has so many mistakes and your doctors don't have any logical answer for them so they say "it's just a traduction error" Quran is Arabic and has always been, with don't play with 10 languages trying to guess what this word meant in greek and what this word meant in hebrew. Only Arabic, how can hour book be "Superior" if you can't even preserve his original language ?
Anyway big boy bring me a single evidence of historical and scientific mistake here and we'll see. Look the Joachim problem in your bible where it's stated 2 same sentence but the age of this king suddenly change, the SAME sentence, your God can't even say the same sentence, without a mistake man ?
@Eternity try and bring a single complete bible from the time of Jesus ? Lol
@Eternity Indeed, it is We who sent down the message [i.e., the Quran], and indeed, We will be its guardian. (QURAN, CHAPTER 15, VERSE 9)
We muslims have memorized the holy Quran for centuries. Word for word. Letter by letter. Everyone reciting same verses.
Regarding Bible.. It was originally written in Aramaic and it is a dead language now. Feel free to wonder why this is so.
The clearest answer is that the written language just didn't have vowels at the time.
@@pr7049 they're the same words with different pronunciation, it's called dialects and stop repeating the lies of your hopeless missionaries, Watch this video exposes their lies th-cam.com/video/TZIEwUVQW8Y/w-d-xo.html
I'm a native arabic speaker and when I first read about the 7 ahruf, I couldn't understand it, even with a bit of research, there was always something in the explanation that is ambiguous with no straightforward meaning.
I can't thank you enough.
May Allah reward you.
@@SheikhAlladeen hey Andy, I'm not a researcher and I have not yet looked deep into ahruf and qira'at, It's -to my shame- a postponed topic on my list, I hope someday soon I'd tackle it. I had to start with this statement to make you understand that I'm not here to fight over something I find hard to my comprehension.
as for the first example you gave, I believe you mean Surat Al-baqara verse 10? If that so, I don't see the meaning you're mentioning, perhaps you meant another one?
The second one, Surat Al-anbya'a verse 4, yes, the two verbs indicate two deferent subjects, however, the meaning is still the same, to me at least, which is that God is the hearing and the knowing, whether it's a statement of the prophet Muhammad -pbuh- or a command of Allah for the prophet to say, either way, Allah is the one who inspire the prophet with Wahy to say that. So it's not that much of a case to me.
As for the third example, Al-anbya'a verse 112, the same applies to me.
The Last one and the washing or rinsing the foot during wudu', I had no idea there are two different rules, as for me, a muslim living in an Arabic country, It's been a norm to wash the foot, it's the ordinary thing we do and we learn since we are children making wudu', but I looked it up -thanks to you- and I found that most of the jurisdiction imams, including the famous four, said that washing is how it should be and not just wiping, which goes along with the Hafs qera'a, and also goes along with some hadeeth of the prophet -pbuh- and how he made wudu' himself.
My final point, something you mentioned in the beginning of your comment, that ahruf has no existence in the qura'an, we as muslims don't take out rules from the qura'an exclusively, we also have the sunnah of the prophet Muhammad -pbuh-
And if we went along with that notion of yours, we wouldn't have had a lot of rules of our rituals, cuz Sunnah sometimes detailed what the qura'an mentioned briefly or generally, and if you're right in what you say, maybe we should stop praying our five prayers with that amount of raqa'at cuz the qura'an didn't mention it, and it was just hadeeth or imitating what the prophet Muhammad -pbuh- used to do.
But it's totally up to you to not trust the sunnah, but as for muslims we can't do that.
@@SheikhAlladeen just so you know, in Egypt, we have several official institutes that learn different qira'at, so it's no secret or they're trying to hide it due to the reasons you think might create a debate, the learners even get some sort of a degree called "Igaza" in that qira'a or in ten qira'at, and the most well known qura'a in Egypt have records of different qira'at as well.
PS: it's not called "someone's qura'an" cuz that indicates we have "different" versions of the qura'an, like the bible, however, it's called "qura'an with someone's rewaya" or qira'a if you like.
Hi ! I have a question... There are some scholarly opinion that suggests that qiraats are bit confusing but can you tell me what's the majority opinion?
"Abbaas who narrated that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Jibreel taught me one style and I reviewed it until he taught me more, and I kept asking him for more and he gave me more until finally there were seven styles.”
But in another story, Muhammad said there r Jibreel n Mikail... lol
It is like a liar will never repear a same story twice
@@artoviva1758 which story?lol.
@@artoviva1758 mate Jibreel and Mikhail are different, theyre different angels, Jibreel is the one that came down with God's word, the Quraan.
@@artoviva1758 wut?
@@artoviva1758 coba tunjukin cerita apa yang kamu maksud 🤪 mana link-nya, jangan ngawur.
This is the best explanation regarding ahruf and qiraat. Only Islam has the tool to preserve the Quran. That is isnad the golden chain of narration. Only Allah can reward you ustaz.
The best explanations that I have come across my research. It’s simple for Muslims and non Muslims to understand.
The best explanation is that the written language just didn't have vowels at the time.
@Eternity there are person around this world that memorise the whole quraan with sanad, mean their reading is approved by their teacher which if traced back by generation will reach prophet muhammad. the system only to make sure people not confused as for the arab the is no confussion as that is their language. your statement is the perfect statement why that person made a system to determine which is which. don't worry your question been asked 1000years agoo before you think of it.
There is no what called 7 Ahrof .. Quran come with only 1 way in writing ✍ .. only one way in reading 📚 .. this is a big mistake to say that about Quran .. because Quran was written in Muhammad profit life .. please stop saying that .. it is wrong ..
Again .. one way in writing ✍ .. one way in reading 📚
@Lion GamingYTz
إن علينا جمعه و قرآنه . فإذا قرأناه فإتبع قرآنه
هناك طريقة واحدة فقط لرسم القرآن و نطق واحد فقط أما عدا ذلك فكلها أكاذيب تطاولت على كتاب الله مع الزمن و للأسف بفضل جهالة المسلمين
اللهم أنر عقولنا و قلوبنا بالعلم
The work done by javed ahmed ghamidi and his student Dr. shahzad saleem regarding the collection & transmission of the Quran are good enough for me.
Most of the ahadeeth regarding the collection & transmission of the Quran have serious flaws...
These seven qiraat are a bunch of rubbish and the only correct qirat is that which the majority of the muslims hold in their hands today from Arabia to indonesia.
The various other qiraat are mostly found in parts of africa. A close look at them will clearly reveal the degraded arabic used in those qiraat and the changes that the people tried to make in the book of Allah.
That only Qirat is named after Hafs, but he learnt it from someone else, I cant remember his name, who taught that the variations of Qiraat are wrong.
These other Qiraat are a bunch of rubbish and considering them valid, would cast serious doubt regarding the authenticity of the book of Allah. Its time now, to reject them and call the spade a spade.
The Quran itself says in surah al qiyamah -
اِنَّ عَلَیۡنَا جَمۡعَہٗ وَ قُرۡاٰنَہٗ فَاِذَا قَرَاۡنٰہُ فَاتَّبِعۡ قُرۡاٰنَہٗ
After this no other Qirat is valid..
Fascinating! I am a Hafith e Quran myself and had no idea about these consistent variations in Quran. I was only introduced with the first one you recited and memorized that only. Never thought Arabic could be so much diverse
Maa sha Allah, may Allah preserve you the same way you preserve his quran
Thank you Sir, I saw your video in my recommended feed and felt very anxious about viewing it, thinking it might throw doubt in my heart, but it did just the opposite as you were clear and concise, subhanallah 7 dialects and still the holy Quran retains it's claim and doesn't contradict itself.
I could tell by your dialect that you're an Egyptian, greetings and love from Palestine❤️❤️
What a joke, Quran in seven dialects. Complete blasphemy in the name of "not dividing the ummah"
May God help you people, one day you'll understand that the Arabs tampered with the words of God, and that the true way the Quran is preserved is true its literature and mathematical code
I guess we should thank the enemies of Islam as they pushed us to educate ourselves about this topic while trying to create confusion about it.
Indeed
So true
Wallah this is so true I was actually so confused at first
allah snackbar not girlfriend
Farook Malik Quran 6:101
He is the creator of the heavens and the earth. How could He have a son when He has no consort? He has created everything and is aware of everything
Alhamdulillah
7 dialects and Subhan Allah no contradictions.
Harf ≠ Dialect
Harf ≈ dialect
Scholars say they found more than 40 dialects in the Quran. Yet it's consistent and doesn't have mistakes or contradictions
@@gamaltabee6889yeah Subhan ALLAH.
How many have you read?
How can differences in words such as singular vs plural or omitted words or changes in meaning “but actually deepening the meaning” be considered as no contradictions? How can the word of god have variations? There is no indication in the quran about these variations as far as i know
@@deadrabbit120 the message.
I swear nobody can understand how much this video helped me. I was nearly in a depressive state because I didnt understood, but thankfully to allah and you, I'm finally seeing the end of it all. Btw, im still searching clearance on some subjects such as the preservation of the quran, if someone can help me
Alhamdulilah, alhamdulilah ..
You can ask whatever questions you have, I might be able to help you in shaa Allah
@@Arabic101 thank you. I have a question regarding quiraat : you said that some ahrofs are in different nouns, such as plural and singular, so the meaning of some verses could change . for exemple : I remember a verse in wich it said that you get good deeds for helping a poor person and the other one said poor men, wich changes the meaning in a sense. if you could clear me up on this matter all my doubts will go away insha Allah . and pls make duaas for me if you can
@@zakariaarezki1661 Asslamo alikom,
As indicated, there is no contradcition.
the concept of singular and plural in Arabic can be sometimes synonymous, too. We call that اسم الجنس which when mentioning a singular form, but the meaning is all of them with the same trait.
So when I say "feed the poor" I mean not talking about ONE person who is poor. BUT I am talking about ALL poor people I know.
So in this case 'feed the poor' would give the same meaning as 'feed poor people'
In the quran it is in different words of course, but a similar concept.
The matter requires more explanation of course, but that is the main idea.
Asslamo alikom
@@Arabic101 aleykoum salam, but I dont think that you understand what I said or maybe Im just dumb. its in 2:184, one says miskinin, so one person ( neutral, singular) and the other one says masakina (plurial, masculine). so if the one that says a poor person means to feed the poor in general, the other one says the poor men. is it talking about people in general or only men? but maybe my knowledge in arabic is just just limited
@@zakariaarezki1661 it’s your knowledge about Arabic akhi, watch more of the videos inshaAllah
You have no idea how much I was struggling to find an answer for this matter of Quoran variations till now. I wasn't sure to respond to such claims from non Muslims trying to challenge me in my religion but thanks to Allah and then to you, I fully understood the matter now. Thanks a lot akhi and my Allah reward you.
I know your pain brother.
I am not a Muslim scholar, and my local school dint really teach about qirat and 7 dialeg of Qur'an.
So when non-muslim come to me, and say Qur'an has many version and he give me the proof. I became doubt about the Qur'an, because my local school only tell me 1 Qur'an to read.
But I know, Qur'an is the word of God, and if the word of God has many version and different meaning than thats not the word of God. (Alhamdulillah Allah swt guide me, if not I think I will became a atheist, Alhamdulillah ya Rabb.)
Aahh... I wanna cry when I think about it, because how many love Allah SWT give me... He dint leave me alone...
So I googled about the version of Qur'an, and the internet answer alaways say there only 1 version but has 7 different dialeg.
That make my doubt gone, but when I watch this video, Alhamdulillah, and Insyallah, I Will never doubt the Qur'an anymore.
Ar-rahman : 13
"Then which of your Lord’s favours will you ˹humans and jinn˺ both deny?"
You should look up the variations with extra words.
Of course, it’s easy to be deceived when they convince you not to research for yourself. But remember, your soul is at stake here. Or if you’re right, you’ll be able to give full reason to non believers. It should be God’s will that we be well studied, shouldn’t it.
@@emmanueloshaddai3259okay
tell me about one with extra words
How can Muslims keep lying to themselves that it's all about dialects when it's so obviously scribal errors? It's so embarrassing. 🤦♂️
In what Arab dialect do you have 'ta'malu' and 'ya'malu' both means the same thing? How about 'qâla' and 'qul'? In what Arabic dialect do they mean the same thing? How about "kabeer" (big) and "katseer" (many)? In what dialects do they mean the same thing?
These are obviously the differences in marking (dots and harakat). 🤦♂️
@@zurgmuckerbergwhat does ta’malu and ya’malu mean? And if you think about it, big and many are pretty similar so it would not be surprising to think that the change of words wouldn’t affect the meaning. Example. There were “many” people in the army, there was “a big amount” of people in the army.
Alhamdulilah. Very beautifully explained.
Ahruf - dialects. There are 7 dialects that one can use to read the Quran.
Qirat- style of reciting the Quran. These 10 styles are based on the 7 ahruf / dialects.
dialects ?
really?
check this out
th-cam.com/video/09u30tqbZmg/w-d-xo.html
Ahruf doesn't mean dialects. They mean "modes." Different dialects doesn't have variant meanings, but Ahrufs do.
Alhamdulillah, I fell on this video by solely the guidance of Allah....
Now I have the answer I've been looking for 🙌🙌❤❤❤🙌🙌
Any explanation for Surah 37:12
Surah 37: 12; Hafs -> But YOU wonder, while they mock. ; Khalaf -> But I wonder, while they mock; Also Surah 2:184; Hafs says to feed a poor person; Warsh says feed poor people. It has legal implications right as we are not sure how many have to be fed as fidya...
@@haveyouconsidered7804 It is A wonder, not I, that is a wrong translation.
Second, they don't change anything in the different dialects you said for 2:184. You can literally read the word in Arabic BOTH ways, so there is no "contradication."
And what the hell do you mean "not sure", LOL? At least one person is to be fed, use some logic.
@@hexerouseven if agree ,.....' You ' wonder and 'A' wonder is the same??? Seriously...is this what it means perfectly preserved, word to word, dot to dot, vowel to vowel... And second one....what is correct..one person or many people....just tell me what is written in the Quran that is in heaven... it will be helpful.
@@haveyouconsidered7804 We have all of the dialects/pronounciations memorized.
We have the same Quran today, just as it was revealed 1400 years ago and anywhere in God's perfect universe and beyond.
Harakah was not a thing when the Quran was used (the signs you see above/below the letters), it was only made for Non-Arab Muslims and Non-Muslims to easily read the Quran. The pronounciations you hear in the different dialects (not different versions) can all be pronounced in the Quran that was written down without Harakah, so whatever point you make against this completely falls down and is utterly destroyed.
There is ONE Quran. Now you tell me, which Bible is the true one?
@@hexerous Well brother, unfortunately, what you have mentioned is factually incorrect... Quran preservation is a myth. Ibn Abi Dawud, Kitab al-Masahif, p23 - Many of the Quran that was known by those who died on the day of Yamama…they were not known by those who survived them, nor were they written down, nor had Abu Bakr, Umar, or Uthman by that time collected the Quran, nor were they found with even one after them. This is confirmed by son of Umar - As Suyuti , Al-Itqan fii Ulum al-Quran, p524.Son of Umar himself saying, “Let none of you say I have acquired the whole of Quran, How do we know what all has disappeared?
On top of that, Uthman burnt a lot of Qurans that did not match the Qureshi dialect. But looks like some survived, that is why we have 37 versions. What you probably have in 1924 Cairo edition Hafs. Ubai had a quran with 116 surahs.. So I can go on, but I desire that you will be sincere in your search for the truth...Unfortunately, there is no one quran with 114 surahs from the mid-7th century....what you have is from a letter time, and they don't agree with each other. I am talking about Topkapi, Samarkhand, Ma il, etc....
Amazing, great job! Now I know about the variations of reciting the Quran. And yes, you made me understand about it too. I'm so excited to learn more about the Quran. Keep on making great videos! Thank you.
Alhamdulilah .. Alhamdulilah .. Please share the video and spread the knowledge to share the ajer in shaa Allah
@@Arabic101
the Morocco forbid the Hafs reading because it confusing population knowing only Warsh reading
check the difference in
th-cam.com/video/09u30tqbZmg/w-d-xo.html
Everything about the Qur'an : th-cam.com/video/ANo6dXc2i-0/w-d-xo.html
Sama saya juga
Any help with this would be appreciated - In Surah 37: 12; Hafs -> But YOU wonder, while they mock. ; Khalaf -> But I wonder, while they mock; Also Surah 2:184; Hafs says to feed a poor person; Warsh says feed poor people. It has legal implications right as we are not sure how many have to be fed as fidya...
Al Quran is a miracle. Knowing that it has 7 variations in recitation and still no contradiction, it is miracle over miracle.
The Bible has variations and Muslims call it corrupted. How can Muslims have many Qirats but Christians get mocked for having different versions?
Well, that is because the variations were directly teached by prophet Muhammad, meanwhile Bible has been edited over the years (by people with no authority) edit@@jayski85
@@jayski85 .
Because they both different.
Variations in Quran is slight, it is about the differet way of reading, and it was known yet in the Prophet's lifetime, because the Prophet know that people have different tongue in the way they pronounciate.
Variations in Bible is very extreme:
- Catholic Bible has 73 books
- Protestant Bible has 66 books
- Greek and Russian Orthodox has 79 books
- Ethiopian Orthodox has 81 books
That's real variations in book versions.
@@amazingislam6997 but Muslim scholars say “ the Quran is unchanged @. If there are different variations in recitation then the Quran HAS been changed over time.
@@jayski85 The variations in recitation already existed in the lifetime of the Prophet. After the death of the Prophet, there is no new variations. So it's true that Quran is unchanged after the death of the Prophet until now.
JazakAllah khair ✨ Many non muslims out of their ignorance are attacking Muslims on this matter, JazakAllah khair for your effort, n I love to listen to different Recitations of Quran ❤️ may Allah SWT grant us deeper understanding Ameen 🤲🏻
Thank you so much for this! May Allah bless your channel for all the effort you're putting in strengthening the love we muslims have for Qur'an. Only Allah (swt) can be so Wise as to reveal those variations without letting any if it effect a single meaning. Subhanallah! Also, it is indeed important that we muslims be aware of this beautiful Quranic concept. Thanks a lot again. Continue the great work! Much dua for Jannah!
Did u live in his time?! If not, stop with this same method of trying to mock our prophet. It's getting old really. First of all, there are varying opinions on her age among scholars, so you don't get choose any one side and keep posting it everywhere, secondly, you do know that it was during 500AD+ right. If there was such a rule against marrying a small aged girl then, he'd be the first one to follow, and he "married" her, not like these days, where people in the name of feminism sexualize even preteen girls like they did in that "Cuties", what do you have to say about that. Oh, next time please read a book written by Aisha (ra) itself, before commenting something like this.
@Tom Staas In bible Mary was 12 years when she was married and there are many examples go search it by urself
@Tom StaasPornography In the Bible:-
1- A Father In Law Is Paying Sheeps to Sleep with His Step Daughter.
2-Bible Talking About Sex Saying the Guy Looked At the Girls Boobs and It Was Looking Like A Tower
3-A Guy Is Licking Her Partners Vagina and Saying that It Tastes Like Wine
And the List Goes On but I Dont Want to Put Dirt In My Mouth By Using Such Words of the Holy Bible
One More Thing, Can You Read Those Things In Front of Your Kids, Mother, Daughter and Sister? Talking About Pornography
@@RehanShaikh-pm9ul
Lol brother. He has gone quiet. They find it fun to poke at our religion when they can't even defend their own. Also I want to add that just 200 or so years ago it was legal for a girl in UK to get married at 9. You must understand something in the context of its time and culture.
@@baseermirza2947 They cant defend their religion so what they try to do is that they try to make Islam look down and David Wood, Christian Prince, Tash Hatun and Jay Smith are better at this job by misquoting verses, information of Islam, not telling the context and pointing out marriage of Ayesha RA...
The Joker David Wood falied to proove Trinity against Muhammed Hijabbadly and made fun of himself and his own religion.
And Mister Jay Smith, wh said that he's dream is to destroy Islam and vanish it from planet Earth lost badly against Shabbir Ally on the topic of Is Jesus GOD?
And Pro Christian Scholar Christian Prince sits behind the screen and misguide Muslims, makes fun of Islam and abuses Islam and thats what Christian audience wants.
Christians have so many issues to solve a few, I ll mention a few. go n study about these things and u will gind out their lies n contradictions of Bible urself
1-Is Bible God's Word?Is It Preserved?
2-Is Jesus God? Dif He Claimed to be GOD or Son of GOD?
3-What About Contradictions of Bible?
4-Scientific Errors of Bible?
5-Who Jesus Is Reffering to In New Testament and Yahwrh Reffering to In Old Testament?
6-Authenticity of Old Testament In thr Bible?
7-Is Yahweh Merciful?
Etc
Masha' Allah, very useful lesson 👍
Jazakum Allahu khairan. 😊
We are waiting your amazing informative lessons every week.
Baraka Allahu fekom.
Everything about the Qur'an : th-cam.com/video/ANo6dXc2i-0/w-d-xo.html
Jazaakallaahu khoiir, i’ve been learning how to read quran properly for at least 2 years, and i just finished my study on tajweed with riwayah Hafsh an Ashim with little comparasion with other riwayah. This video opens my mind to always learn and learn new stuff. Thank you!
I have been looking for this topics for months. Many other explanations make me confused. Alhamdulillah your explanation is clear to me. InshaAllah I can study further on the subject with the basic understanding I have learned from you. Thank you my teacher.
SubhanAllah, this is actually a testament to the preservation of the Qur'an. JazakAllah Khair.
جزاكم الله خيرا
I had confusions regarding these Ahrof & Qira'at, but Alhumdulillaah this vedio helped.
AlhamduliLlah. I pray the blessing of Allah be with the producers of this highly educating programme.
Jazak Allahu Khairan! Very helpful and clear. May Allah reward you with Jannat-ul Firdows for everything you do for His sake. Amiin!
Tbh I couldn't wait u to finish Hafs aspects before u begin teaching us a different Qira'h. So I just jumped to different ppl in the seek of learning. I've mastered 4 so far! I only knew the 7 Ahruf through this channel. Imagine the Thwab u have earned :)
Jazak Allahu khairan
Bravo...Ya Usthadh your the best in explaining the complex and advanced Quranic Arabic Grammar or Recitation...I'm lucky to found you in TH-cam. May Allah bless you in any means he wishes. Jazaka Allahu Khairan.
Alhamdulilah , Alhamdulilah .. It's all Allah's guidance and help without which I can do nothing, so Alhamdulilah ... Please share the video and the channel to let more and more people benefit from it and in shaa Allah, you'll share the ajer Ameen
and Thank you very much for these amazing words, they motivate me greatly ... Alhamdulilah
@@Arabic101 Definitely Usthadh I'm sharing your videos with my family and friends. Without a doubt ALLAH is all knowledgeable and everything happens from the permission of ALLAH. But indeed you have put your efforts to teach the Holy Qur'an in simple and easy way....🤗👍👌
the Morocco forbid the Hafs reading because it confusing population knowing only Warsh reading
check the difference in
th-cam.com/video/09u30tqbZmg/w-d-xo.html
Everything about the Qur'an : th-cam.com/video/ANo6dXc2i-0/w-d-xo.html
@@thetruththewaythelife6796 Hello Genius. I know that you are SOOOOO desperate to disbelieve in Qur-aan. Yasir Qadhi had posted a new video clarifying things and deleted the old video that led to misunderstanding among ignorant and liars like your priest DW & CP
My brother I don't even know what to say may Almighty Allah reward you with a reward that will never end brother with your teachings I have confidence to read the Quran thank you brother as people keep on finding this channel and learned from you may Allah keep on increase your deeds Jaza kumu llahu kayran
and another doubt immediately removed, every time my heart is filled with doubt about any subject in Islam i find a quick answer
i wonder why it's not something taught in schools, to know about the ahruf
I relate to you! I think it isn't widely taught, and some discourage openly talking about it since it is a VERY technical subject, and not everyone is blessed with the intelligence to articulate it properly.
@gsem000 salam aleikum brother, please delete your comment as it can create fitnah. Allah bestows knowledge to some as a blessing in order to strengthen their iman and bring His slave close to Him. Why must you write something negative? Instead you should be saying alhamdulilah that Allah grants understanding to his ummah in His infinite mercy.
The best thing about this is kaaffirs thinks they can being us to poIytheism with their baseless lies but infact when they open these topics we research more and increases us in faith 🔸The believers are only those who, when Allah is mentioned, their hearts become fearful, and when His verses are recited to them, it increases them in faith; and upon their Lord they rely - 8:2
@gsem000
Wow. You suck.
People can have doubts, you know. We aren't perfect. We aren't angels. We're human. Allah knows that we're weak. There is Shaytan and Fitna all around us. Do you really have to make it harder for a person trying to make any doubt in his heart disappear?
You should thank Allah for your strong iman and pray for OP, instead of shaming them.
These are not the qualities of a proper muslim. You should worry about yourself, dude.
Cause it’s a lie
I am absoulutely jealous with you. You have a capability to make video and explain the right things, it will be your good deeds, the more people watch, the more you earn from Allah SWT. Thanks brother! May Allah reward you jannah.
اذا رغبت بالاجر مثل ذلك فعليك بنشر رابط القناة لمن اراد أن يستفيد وينهل من هذا الخير فالدال على الخير كفاعله .
ذلك فضل الله يؤتيه من يشاء، والله ذو الفضل العظيم
Bonek coy
Christians try use this as an argument
Whilst their variations are different stories of the same individuals
That’s contradictions
And the contradictions of scientific facts and many more
This 7 ahruf is but a miracle of the miracles of the Quran
for all are preserved
Eternity
Just because someone said the standard narrative has holes doesn’t make it right
Went back in his word
(Remember) we don’t blindly follow ppl
😂
th-cam.com/video/JmjURdYS5K0/w-d-xo.html
Check this out for your answer on deference and the “Egyptian Quran”
I don’t know why this is like supposed to be against Islam?
U Christians don’t want to understand I guess
That’s your problem
Refer to the channel for more answers
th-cam.com/video/K11XfOfTFAU/w-d-xo.html
Claim The qiraat are mistakes
If u are Christian then OH Man 😂
So I hope u are an atheist trying this hard because then u are trying to debunk something u cannot refute whilst whatever u believe in is not even worthy of this type of criticism
Because it’s all over the place ( literally)
@Eternity the holes are in your brain
@Eternity Actually there’s a difference of opinion on her age. We can easily look at one hadith (saying of the Prophet) and make our own ruling on it but if we do that, it’ll cause corruption due to our limited knowledge. Therefore, we refer to scholars who take all of the related hadiths, Quranic verses, etc. when coming to a fatwa (ruling), conclusion on a historical event, etc. This is the same case with Aisha’s age, may Allah be pleased with her.
www.islamweb.net/ehajj/printarticle.php?id=38813&lang=E&id=38813&lang=E
We must seek the truth and only then will we be guided. May Allah guide you and your family & guide me & my family and allow us to seek the truth in our hearts.
@Eternity you need a job. Real job
@Adam A it's funny, this Christian calling himself "Eternity" gets proven wrong twice, then his only response is to give a non-sequitur about the (not unanimous) topic of Aisha's age.
Surah As-Saffat (37:12), has two distinct readings in the Hafs and Warsh recitations, which lead to theological implications due to their differing subjects of amazement.
The Two Recitations: Hafs vs. Warsh
1. Hafs Recitation (Most Common):
• Arabic: “بَلْ عَجِبْتُ وَيَسْخَرُونَ”
• Transliteration: “Bal ʿAjibtu wa-yasakhirūn.”
• Translation: “But I (Allah) am amazed, and they mock.”
• Key Subject: The word ʿAjibtu (عَجِبْتُ, “I am amazed”) refers to Allah.
2. Warsh Recitation:
• Arabic: “بَلْ عَجِبْتَ وَيَسْخَرُونَ”
• Transliteration: “Bal ʿAjibta wa-yasakhirūn.”
• Translation: “But you (O Muhammad) are amazed, and they mock.”
• Key Subject: The word ʿAjibta (عَجِبْتَ, “You are amazed”) refers to Muhammad.
Differences Between the Recitations
1. Grammatical Subject:
• Hafs Recitation: The verb ʿAjibtu (“I am amazed”) uses the first-person singular pronoun -tu, which explicitly refers to Allah.
• Warsh Recitation: The verb ʿAjibta (“You are amazed”) uses the second-person singular pronoun -ta, which refers to Muhammad.
2. Theological Implications:
• Hafs:
• Attributes amazement to Allah, which raises theological concerns:
• Amazement implies surprise or encountering the unexpected, qualities inconsistent with Allah’s omniscience.
• Anthropomorphism: Describing Allah with human-like emotions (e.g., amazement) contradicts Islamic principles of transcendence.
• Warsh:
• Attributes amazement to Muhammad, which aligns better with traditional Islamic theology since Muhammad, as a human, can naturally experience surprise or amazement.
3. Contextual Flow:
• The Warsh recitation aligns with the surrounding verses, where the disbelievers’ mocking is directed toward Muhammad. In this context, it makes sense for Muhammad to be amazed at their rejection of truth.
• The Hafs recitation shifts the focus to Allah, introducing theological tensions regarding divine emotions.
Why This Difference Is Problematic
1. Contradictory Theological Implications
• The Hafs recitation challenges Allah’s omniscience and immutability:
• Amazement implies a reaction to an unforeseen or extraordinary event, which is incompatible with Allah’s knowledge of all things.
• Islamic theology rejects attributing human emotions to Allah, as stated in Surah Ash-Shura (42:11): “There is nothing like unto Him.”
• The Warsh recitation avoids these issues by attributing amazement to Muhammad, who, as a human, can naturally feel surprise or shock.
2. Linguistic and Doctrinal Ambiguity
• If both recitations are considered valid, they create conflicting theological narratives:
• Hafs: Allah expresses amazement.
• Warsh: Muhammad expresses amazement.
• These differences are significant enough to influence interpretations of Allah’s nature and Muhammad’s role, undermining the Quran’s claim to perfect clarity:
• Surah Hud (11:1): “This is a Book whose verses are perfected and then explained in detail from [one who is] Wise and Acquainted.”
3. Implications for Quranic Inerrancy
• Muslims believe the Quran is preserved and free of contradictions:
• Surah An-Nisa (4:82): “Then do they not reflect upon the Quran? If it had been from [any] other than Allah, they would have found within it much contradiction.”
• However, the differences between Hafs and Warsh raise questions:
• If Allah “praying” is problematic, why does one recitation include it?
• If both are valid, how can the Quran avoid contradictory meanings?
Reactions by Islamic Scholars
1. Defense of Both Readings:
• Scholars argue that both recitations are valid, as they are part of the seven canonical readings (Qira’at).
• They claim the Hafs reading refers to Allah’s “condemnation” rather than literal amazement, while the Warsh reading reflects Muhammad’s emotional reaction.
2. Preference for Warsh:
• Some scholars and translators lean toward the Warsh recitation to avoid the theological complications of attributing amazement to Allah.
3. Use of Tafwid:
• When confronted with theological issues in the Hafs recitation, scholars often invoke tafwid (consigning the meaning to Allah alone), sidestepping the need for explanation.
Conclusion
The difference between the Hafs and Warsh recitations of Surah As-Saffat (37:12) highlights a significant theological issue:
1. The Hafs recitation, attributing amazement to Allah, challenges core Islamic doctrines of omniscience and transcendence.
2. The Warsh recitation, attributing amazement to Muhammad, avoids these issues and aligns with Islamic theology.
3. The existence of such differences raises questions about Quranic inerrancy and clarity, especially when these variations lead to contradictory understandings of Allah’s nature.
Ultimately, the tension reflects broader challenges within the doctrine of Quranic preservation and the coexistence of multiple, differing recitations.
Jazakallah, Thank you this was really helpful. This video really shut down all those non muslims who claim the Quran was changed or has many copies. There is only one Quran with the same meaning & message however different dialects make it easier to read or increase there meaning. The message of the Quran is the same though, this video actually increased my faith. Thanks bro , Keep up the good work.
Blind faith, the word Ahruf is unknown and is a mystery. Their are over 40 different opinions regarding the word Ahruf which means your scholars do not know the meaning of it. It is a mystery and this means that Islam is false.
@@bigfan2452 lol if Islam is false then christianity should be false too and judaism should be false too cause in Islam the holy books of Jews and Christians Bible(injil) torah(old Testament) or talmud tanakh they're mentioned in quran. U "can" say that quran is false but not islam because islam is since the time of adam(AS) and if scholars have diffrent opinions that doesn't make a religion false or corrupt. If I ask a pastor about is Jesus a God or a prophet if he says he's a prophet and I ask another pastor that is Jesus a God or prophet he says Jesus is God does that make christianity false??
@@fahadpasha947 yes, I can say that Islam and Quran is false because both of them came from Arabia in the 7th century. Their is no evidence that Adam was a Muslim at all. Also, to answer your question we do not base our faiths in one pastor but in our early Church Fathers, intellectuals that were taught by the disciples of Jesus Christ. If a pastor contradicts a early Church Father we automatically reject him.
@@bigfan2452 even if there is no evidence the things of his times are evident and adam being Christian or muslim doesn't change the fact. And islam didn't come in 7th cent go check the birth date of Muhammad and tell ur American Michael h. Hart to put Jesus in first place not Muhammad in his the world's most influential persons and there are the muslim that study quranic science and even if it is blind it is blind by heart not eyes and when we read and study every religion it comes to a common term that god is one, there is no idol, coming of final prophet. The vedas call him as "narashansa" Nara(man) shansa( to praise or be praised) and Muhammad means the man who is praised and in old Testament deutronomy 18:18 and in songs of solomon. And I appreciate every religion that it has something in common. And in Bible 1st timothy it says that "the head which is uncovered should be shaved". But in christianity just the nuns cover their head not every woman and in islam it isn't that strict but every women do cover themselves.
@@fahadpasha947 I have already checked it out and it is the 6th century. I never said that Adam was a Christian as we do not believe that either. Also, the quranic science is false and full of errors because it comes 200 years later after Muhammad died. The Old Testament teaches that God is one but has revealed himself in three persons. So, the Bible contradicts the Quran notion of God. Moreover, Muhammed is not in the deutronomy nor song of Solomons because he is a false prophet. The New Testament tells us that False prophets will come and spread falsehood and that's what exactly Muhammed did.
This was surely a great gem of knowledge .Thank u for making it clear .May Allah bless u
@Arabic 101
the Morocco forbid the Hafs reading because it confusing population knowing only Warsh reading
check the difference in
th-cam.com/video/09u30tqbZmg/w-d-xo.html
Really important video.
Jazakallahu Khairun for this informative video
Great video! It’s awesome that you’re making this information available and easily accessible to the public.
I was just being exposed to this subject to-day. A little bit confused. After listening to this explanation it became clearer. Thanks so much. Grateful to bump to this programme.
Amazimg amazing amazing.. This is the answer to those who claim Qur'an has contradictions.... masha allah.. amazing.. may Allah belss you upon all of ur work and dedication
Jazakkallhu Khair. Dear brother you have explained the topic clearly. I was looking for the answers for a long time. Keep spreading the knowledge. Allah will reward you with the best. Insha Allah.
Alhamdulilahi!!! For ur efforts. A topic that I found complex has been dealt with so elegantly. Subhanallah! May Allah Bless you and the team. A must watch for all our brothers and sisters. 🌸
Jazak Allah Khair. You explained it very well in simple words and it made my belief even stronger than Quran is the Word of Allah (SWT). It will help me during my dawah work.
Thank you ever so much for making it so simple to understand I watch all your videos, it really helps to get rid of confusions, it's so amazing how you explain in short but I get all my questions answered in few minutes, may Allah reward you for your hard work and may Allah make your life happy and easy like you making easy for millions of people who are trying read the noble Quran as it should be read just to please Allah swt. JazakAllahu kheiran.🤗
Wa Iyyakum, brother/ sister,
Jazakum Allahu khairan for these words. They mean a lot to me. Alhamdulilah.
بارك الله فيكم the topic is very clear and well explained.
Everything about the Qur'an : th-cam.com/video/ANo6dXc2i-0/w-d-xo.html
Really needed to watch this video.... I saw a video before this that was trying to confuse me about the authenticity of Quran....May ALLAH reward you.
Assalamualaikum brother,
I seriously can't tell you that I'm so shocked 😲 and happy 😊 to know that Allah the almighty has revealed the Qur'an in 7 ahrof and 10 qirat... This is so amazing just for the better understanding for the people and also to challenge the disbelievers... See I'm a 17 year old and I'm a budding hafiza and while reading the Qur'an on my phone as well as mushaf I always wonder why there's a difference as I use indopak script and uthmani also... But now with the help of this video my all doubts are removed and my eman on Qur'an has become more powerful... Seriously I want to thank you for this video... This video means a lot to me
Thank you so much for this clear explanation. It's useful for Muslims and non-Muslims alike, those of us who are still confused and struggle to understand the meaning of different ahruf and qiraat.
For those of us who debate with Christians, now we have a resource to share with them.
Jazzakallahu khoir
The main points the presenter made was
1. To make it easier to read in one of the seven dialects.
An example given was color and colour. If it was to make it easier for the reader then it would be consistent across the whole version of the Quran. If a book had both colour and color in the USA version of the book I would call it a mistake.
2. To deepen the meaning.
The presenter gave the example of one aya having a version of having fought or having been killed. His explanation is the difference adds another dimension without contradicting one another.
The Quran is supposedly written in clear Arabic and this is an obvious contradiction.
@@heathersoares186 Arabs spoke in different dialects.
It was revealed in different dialects to make it easy for them. They had different grammer, different pronounciation, and some tribes didn't have complete letters!
@@heathersoares186 go first understand what contradiction means and if u want an example then it's bible , the living contradiction
@@SheikhAlladeen first of all, are you an expert in classical arabic? secondly, did any muslim at the time of the prophet and the first 4 caliphs ever argue with one another about a different Quran?
NONE! No evidence. Zero! The only evidence we have is one companion arguing about the way a verse is recited and the matter was brought to the Prophet and he said both are correct.
No point arguing using the modern context of the language. Case closed.
@@heathersoares186 huh? you saying 'color and colour' are both found in the same book? where do you get this idea from?
Jazzakallahu khayr,a bro recently complained to me about a certain Qari the way he recites Fatiha,I told him there are different styles so we were searching for precise answer before we could comment on it since we all reverts.. Alhamdulillah here I got it may Allah bless u for this ilm
Amazing miracle love my Holy Quran. 🥰🥰
Mind blowing and I am shaking. Amazing Quran.
May Allah guide us through the holy Quran and give rewards to those who are giving/given their time and effort to teach us the Quran.
he not telling the whole story
the Morocco forbid the Hafs reading because it confusing population knowing only Warsh reading
check the difference in
th-cam.com/video/09u30tqbZmg/w-d-xo.html
Everything about the Qur'an : th-cam.com/video/ANo6dXc2i-0/w-d-xo.html
This confirms the miracle of the Quran in total - how can a man produce a book like this in various dialects who was illiterate? SubhanAllah!
InshaAllah please go through all the different ayat like you did with the one with قتل so we can fully appreciate how these words supplement eachother throughout the 7 ahruf, all of them 😍
this was a wonderful video ! Straight to the point and well-explained ! Jazakallahu Khairan
MashaAllah!, splendid explanation. May Allah SWT grant you great rewards for this compilation…
Excellent explanation and illustration, especially with examples of the verses, ma sha' Allah! May Allah reward you.
Excellent presentation. Excellent knowledge. May Allah bless you
Masha Allah I am sooo glad I chanced upon your video! thanks a lot for the super duper clear and simple explanation about the differences btw Ahroof and Qiraat! Surely, learning about the Qur'an is a lifelong journey. Baarakallahu feekum!
Assalamu'alaikum, brother. Thank you so much for the video! It's a wonderful explanation for the Ahruf and the Qira'at. In my opinion, if you had added the conditions of an authentic Qira'ah (conformity to the consonantal skeleton of the Uthmanic codex, sound chain of narration to Prophet Muhammad pbuh, and consistency with the linguistic rulings of Arabic), it would've been the cherry on top! I hope Allah will reward you plentifully. Aamiin.
If i was fluent in english I will make this kind of video to answer the Christians.
May allah bless you and thank you for your work
Mash Allah simply n concisely explained.. i ve tried reading about this topic in tajweed books but they make it so complex to understand.. i never got a clear answer or explanation even from teachers! Jazak Allah khair for this much needed video. Much appreciation.
Indeed Allah made it easy for us to recite Quran. ☺
ماشاء اللہ
Beautifully explained. It also refutes allegations on Quran that it is changed.
جزاک اللہ خیرا
Jazakalah Kheir watched this video long time ago. Watched it again to quickly understand the differences when a friend brought up the qiraat and was somehow confused. Sharing this video with them. May Allah add it to your scale of good deeds untill the final Hour.
Jazakallah Khairan. I found this channel very useful for ummah, especially we Muslims. I was searching article about non Muslims claim on Quran that has many version and how to answer their claim. Alhamdulillah I found this video along with some other videos from our brothers discussing about this matter. But this video is has a very nice and clear presentation to make even a very beginner could understand easily. Once again, jazakallahu khairan, thank you very much for sharing. I subscribed this channel to learn more.
Jazakum Allahu khairan for your support.
May Allah accept the work.
@@Arabic101 Aamiin
This work is topnotch. Keep it up akhee. Jazakummullahu khayran kathiran. The Qur'an truly is inimitable
Extremely beneficial.
May Allah bless you and take you from strength to strength.
Bruv, take love ❤️❤️❤️
This was incredible
جزاك الله خيرا ياأخي
Jazaakalaah khoirun from Indonesia
Maa shaa Allaah - A great service towards understanding Quran!
Finally, I have all my questions been answered, alhamdulillah. Very well explained 👍👍 JazakAllahu khairan.
Surah As-Saffat (37:12), has two distinct readings in the Hafs and Warsh recitations, which lead to theological implications due to their differing subjects of amazement.
The Two Recitations: Hafs vs. Warsh
1. Hafs Recitation (Most Common):
• Arabic: “بَلْ عَجِبْتُ وَيَسْخَرُونَ”
• Transliteration: “Bal ʿAjibtu wa-yasakhirūn.”
• Translation: “But I (Allah) am amazed, and they mock.”
• Key Subject: The word ʿAjibtu (عَجِبْتُ, “I am amazed”) refers to Allah.
2. Warsh Recitation:
• Arabic: “بَلْ عَجِبْتَ وَيَسْخَرُونَ”
• Transliteration: “Bal ʿAjibta wa-yasakhirūn.”
• Translation: “But you (O Muhammad) are amazed, and they mock.”
• Key Subject: The word ʿAjibta (عَجِبْتَ, “You are amazed”) refers to Muhammad.
Differences Between the Recitations
1. Grammatical Subject:
• Hafs Recitation: The verb ʿAjibtu (“I am amazed”) uses the first-person singular pronoun -tu, which explicitly refers to Allah.
• Warsh Recitation: The verb ʿAjibta (“You are amazed”) uses the second-person singular pronoun -ta, which refers to Muhammad.
2. Theological Implications:
• Hafs:
• Attributes amazement to Allah, which raises theological concerns:
• Amazement implies surprise or encountering the unexpected, qualities inconsistent with Allah’s omniscience.
• Anthropomorphism: Describing Allah with human-like emotions (e.g., amazement) contradicts Islamic principles of transcendence.
• Warsh:
• Attributes amazement to Muhammad, which aligns better with traditional Islamic theology since Muhammad, as a human, can naturally experience surprise or amazement.
3. Contextual Flow:
• The Warsh recitation aligns with the surrounding verses, where the disbelievers’ mocking is directed toward Muhammad. In this context, it makes sense for Muhammad to be amazed at their rejection of truth.
• The Hafs recitation shifts the focus to Allah, introducing theological tensions regarding divine emotions.
Why This Difference Is Problematic
1. Contradictory Theological Implications
• The Hafs recitation challenges Allah’s omniscience and immutability:
• Amazement implies a reaction to an unforeseen or extraordinary event, which is incompatible with Allah’s knowledge of all things.
• Islamic theology rejects attributing human emotions to Allah, as stated in Surah Ash-Shura (42:11): “There is nothing like unto Him.”
• The Warsh recitation avoids these issues by attributing amazement to Muhammad, who, as a human, can naturally feel surprise or shock.
2. Linguistic and Doctrinal Ambiguity
• If both recitations are considered valid, they create conflicting theological narratives:
• Hafs: Allah expresses amazement.
• Warsh: Muhammad expresses amazement.
• These differences are significant enough to influence interpretations of Allah’s nature and Muhammad’s role, undermining the Quran’s claim to perfect clarity:
• Surah Hud (11:1): “This is a Book whose verses are perfected and then explained in detail from [one who is] Wise and Acquainted.”
3. Implications for Quranic Inerrancy
• Muslims believe the Quran is preserved and free of contradictions:
• Surah An-Nisa (4:82): “Then do they not reflect upon the Quran? If it had been from [any] other than Allah, they would have found within it much contradiction.”
• However, the differences between Hafs and Warsh raise questions:
• If Allah “praying” is problematic, why does one recitation include it?
• If both are valid, how can the Quran avoid contradictory meanings?
Reactions by Islamic Scholars
1. Defense of Both Readings:
• Scholars argue that both recitations are valid, as they are part of the seven canonical readings (Qira’at).
• They claim the Hafs reading refers to Allah’s “condemnation” rather than literal amazement, while the Warsh reading reflects Muhammad’s emotional reaction.
2. Preference for Warsh:
• Some scholars and translators lean toward the Warsh recitation to avoid the theological complications of attributing amazement to Allah.
3. Use of Tafwid:
• When confronted with theological issues in the Hafs recitation, scholars often invoke tafwid (consigning the meaning to Allah alone), sidestepping the need for explanation.
Conclusion
The difference between the Hafs and Warsh recitations of Surah As-Saffat (37:12) highlights a significant theological issue:
1. The Hafs recitation, attributing amazement to Allah, challenges core Islamic doctrines of omniscience and transcendence.
2. The Warsh recitation, attributing amazement to Muhammad, avoids these issues and aligns with Islamic theology.
3. The existence of such differences raises questions about Quranic inerrancy and clarity, especially when these variations lead to contradictory understandings of Allah’s nature.
Ultimately, the tension reflects broader challenges within the doctrine of Quranic preservation and the coexistence of multiple, differing recitations.
So well simplified and explained 😍.. Baarakallaah brother ❤️
Jazakallahu ahsanuljaza ya akhi you have explained this very complex and sensitive topic easily and cleared our doubts may allah reward you in this world and here after... Ameen
And also very gratefull for sharing those websites this helps alot. ❤❤❤
JazakAllahu khayrun brother extremely beneficial and educational may Allah subhaanahu ta reward you in abundance with all forms of goodness Aameen thumma Aameen 🤲💝🧕 keep up the great work 💝🤲
This is the best answer I've seen thus far regarding ahruf and qiraat on TH-cam.
apa kabar cik
The best explanation of Ahrufs ma sha Allah. I was looking for a video like this. May Allah (swt) bless you all. Ameen
may allah bless you my dear brother !!!! this was presented so well and explained so well !!thank you again
Thank you men
May Allah bless you
Information overload! I graduated into reading Quran by 4y/o. I fell off a bit in my teens, but came back to the path by age 20 and started relearning Quran alhamdulillah. But I'm 32 now, I've known that there were Qira'at, and that they sounded somewhat different, but this is the first time I've heard in this detail
Learned so much my Allah bless you thanks akhi❤
Love your videos... Jazakallah khair
My number 1 teacher
May Allah Erich with Iman,wealth and good health and shower his rahmah and barakah on you and your loved ones.
Wow. Jazakallahu Khairan. Why didn't I find this video sooner.
You are doing great job, making things easy for us. May Allah grant you highest level of paradise. In the age of ignorance we need more and more clear explanations, not for non-Muslims, mainly for Muslims themselves.
Everything about the Qur'an : th-cam.com/video/ANo6dXc2i-0/w-d-xo.html
Fascinating and super informative! I feel soooo happy to have found this channel! Allahumma barik lak, jazakAllahu khairan jazeelan♥️
From Chat GPT:
Yes, I can affirm that based on what I shared. The Quran is indeed exceptionally well-preserved, with no significant differences across the qira'at that would alter the core beliefs, doctrines, or practices of Islam. The variations that exist in the qira'at are minor and do not impact fundamental meanings or introduce theological contradictions.
On the other hand, as demonstrated by the examples in the Bible, there are notable differences in various manuscripts, translations, and interpretations, some of which affect essential theological points such as the divinity of Jesus, the Trinity, and other doctrines. These differences in the Bible highlight its textual variations over time, something that the Quran does not experience due to its unique preservation through memorization and written record.
Thus, the Quran's preservation contrasts sharply with the textual challenges present in the Bible.
ChatGPT can be influenced if you don’t present it with unbiased questions
Surah As-Saffat (37:12), has two distinct readings in the Hafs and Warsh recitations, which lead to theological implications due to their differing subjects of amazement.
The Two Recitations: Hafs vs. Warsh
1. Hafs Recitation (Most Common):
• Arabic: “بَلْ عَجِبْتُ وَيَسْخَرُونَ”
• Transliteration: “Bal ʿAjibtu wa-yasakhirūn.”
• Translation: “But I (Allah) am amazed, and they mock.”
• Key Subject: The word ʿAjibtu (عَجِبْتُ, “I am amazed”) refers to Allah.
2. Warsh Recitation:
• Arabic: “بَلْ عَجِبْتَ وَيَسْخَرُونَ”
• Transliteration: “Bal ʿAjibta wa-yasakhirūn.”
• Translation: “But you (O Muhammad) are amazed, and they mock.”
• Key Subject: The word ʿAjibta (عَجِبْتَ, “You are amazed”) refers to Muhammad.
Differences Between the Recitations
1. Grammatical Subject:
• Hafs Recitation: The verb ʿAjibtu (“I am amazed”) uses the first-person singular pronoun -tu, which explicitly refers to Allah.
• Warsh Recitation: The verb ʿAjibta (“You are amazed”) uses the second-person singular pronoun -ta, which refers to Muhammad.
2. Theological Implications:
• Hafs:
• Attributes amazement to Allah, which raises theological concerns:
• Amazement implies surprise or encountering the unexpected, qualities inconsistent with Allah’s omniscience.
• Anthropomorphism: Describing Allah with human-like emotions (e.g., amazement) contradicts Islamic principles of transcendence.
• Warsh:
• Attributes amazement to Muhammad, which aligns better with traditional Islamic theology since Muhammad, as a human, can naturally experience surprise or amazement.
3. Contextual Flow:
• The Warsh recitation aligns with the surrounding verses, where the disbelievers’ mocking is directed toward Muhammad. In this context, it makes sense for Muhammad to be amazed at their rejection of truth.
• The Hafs recitation shifts the focus to Allah, introducing theological tensions regarding divine emotions.
Why This Difference Is Problematic
1. Contradictory Theological Implications
• The Hafs recitation challenges Allah’s omniscience and immutability:
• Amazement implies a reaction to an unforeseen or extraordinary event, which is incompatible with Allah’s knowledge of all things.
• Islamic theology rejects attributing human emotions to Allah, as stated in Surah Ash-Shura (42:11): “There is nothing like unto Him.”
• The Warsh recitation avoids these issues by attributing amazement to Muhammad, who, as a human, can naturally feel surprise or shock.
2. Linguistic and Doctrinal Ambiguity
• If both recitations are considered valid, they create conflicting theological narratives:
• Hafs: Allah expresses amazement.
• Warsh: Muhammad expresses amazement.
• These differences are significant enough to influence interpretations of Allah’s nature and Muhammad’s role, undermining the Quran’s claim to perfect clarity:
• Surah Hud (11:1): “This is a Book whose verses are perfected and then explained in detail from [one who is] Wise and Acquainted.”
3. Implications for Quranic Inerrancy
• Muslims believe the Quran is preserved and free of contradictions:
• Surah An-Nisa (4:82): “Then do they not reflect upon the Quran? If it had been from [any] other than Allah, they would have found within it much contradiction.”
• However, the differences between Hafs and Warsh raise questions:
• If Allah “praying” is problematic, why does one recitation include it?
• If both are valid, how can the Quran avoid contradictory meanings?
Reactions by Islamic Scholars
1. Defense of Both Readings:
• Scholars argue that both recitations are valid, as they are part of the seven canonical readings (Qira’at).
• They claim the Hafs reading refers to Allah’s “condemnation” rather than literal amazement, while the Warsh reading reflects Muhammad’s emotional reaction.
2. Preference for Warsh:
• Some scholars and translators lean toward the Warsh recitation to avoid the theological complications of attributing amazement to Allah.
3. Use of Tafwid:
• When confronted with theological issues in the Hafs recitation, scholars often invoke tafwid (consigning the meaning to Allah alone), sidestepping the need for explanation.
Conclusion
The difference between the Hafs and Warsh recitations of Surah As-Saffat (37:12) highlights a significant theological issue:
1. The Hafs recitation, attributing amazement to Allah, challenges core Islamic doctrines of omniscience and transcendence.
2. The Warsh recitation, attributing amazement to Muhammad, avoids these issues and aligns with Islamic theology.
3. The existence of such differences raises questions about Quranic inerrancy and clarity, especially when these variations lead to contradictory understandings of Allah’s nature.
Ultimately, the tension reflects broader challenges within the doctrine of Quranic preservation and the coexistence of multiple, differing recitations.
Very well explained thank you so much, may ALLAH Bless you for your efforts
Everything about the Qur'an : th-cam.com/video/ANo6dXc2i-0/w-d-xo.html
Very clear and concise! May Allah bless you of your effort in presenting this vdo.
MashaaAllah very educative. JazakAllahu khair
Quran really, perfect, true, book.
Alhamdulilah.
It is a true book but have seven ways to receit it
Only problems now, was.. How many recitation left?
Only the lord of a doomsday, would know & have the answer!
Thanks for sharing your knowledge based on the different qar'at.
It is important to know for the recitation of the holy Qur'aan.
MasyaAllah. May Allah rewards you and your team jannah for the good deeds you have done for this ummah 🤲🏻
Masha’Allah your videos are simply superb. Crisp and clear explanation. Which software do you use brother? I need it to teach medical students. Jazak’Allah khair
Great video... This is not easy topic to be get on one vodeo. But you make it great video..
Thanks a lot.. Jazakumullah khairal jaza'..
May Allah bless you and your knowledge..
I have subscribed just by watching the first video impressive jazak Allah khairan .
Let’s see what you have more :)
Thank you very much 😭😭 My faith was not firm not long ago after watching Dr Jay video.. Jazakallahu Khairan 👍👍
He was still right☠ Theres variants
@@ZEN_180different dialects all from the prophet
Clearly one of the greatest channel to learn tajweed rules I'm impressed. Jazak Allahou khayran.
Just a precision, if I may, for viewers that may think, "well, in fact the masters of qira'at just came and picked up qira'aat randomly by themselves".
حاش لله
One day, Hafs and Chu'ba who both learned from 'Asim (liked he brilliantly explained in the video) asked him why we are both learning from you but we don't learn the same qira'at? Asim answered by saying (approximately because I heared it in Arabic): "because you Hafs, I teached you the way I learned from Abd al Rahman al Sulami, who learned it from Ali ibn Abu Talib. And you Chu'ba I teached you the way I learned from Zur ibn Habacha who learned it from Abdullah ibn Mas'ud".
Just to say it's not like they came with recitation no one knew about before them.
The GREAT explanation ever! I was told wrong thing... but thank u ustadh! U corrected me! And, Could I please have your name? Because calling u without ur name seems awkward.