As Long As You're Mine "Up That I Fell" Comparison
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ก.ย. 2024
- A comparison video with various Fiyeros singing the line, "Somehow I've fallen under your spell, and somehow I'm feeling it's up that I fell" from Wicked. I don't know EVERY Fiyeros so I'm sorry if your Fiyero isn't here.
I don't own anything. All rights go to the respectful owners.
CORRECTION: the picture of liam connor tamne is actually of lee mead's but the audio is still liam's.
Hey, weird request - can you do a video of Wicked comparisons for the bridge of No Good Deed - the lines "One question haunts and hurts..." on to "maybe that's the reason why"?
David Fathom That’s a great request. I second it.
I third it
@@davidfathom3051 I couldn't.... could I?
Yes I thought so... nice correction x
The “up that I fell” line never made sense to me, but then I thought of something:
He’s defying gravity.
i'm the same way with "My wildest dreamings could not foresee lying beside you" (originally the scene was a hotel room so idk why they didn't change the line when the scene changed to the woods.)
I always thought the line was 'odd that I fell'
I thought about this for a long time.
It’s just a really clever play on words. 15 or so years after hearing this for first time this song still sends shovers down my spine.
“Somehow I’ve fallen under your spell”/falling in love: “falling” is usually perceived as a descent, but Fiyero is saying it’s up that he fell because he feels like being in love with Elphaba is an ascension (ie a positive thing)
I always heard "the stuff that I felt"
Hitting the "up" high note should be a must...it doesn't have the same effect with out. Aaron is a god.
Exactly! If they can't hit that note then they shouldn't get the part!
@@BlueYoshi85 it probably was less the ability to hit that note, and more the ability to hit that note 8 times a week and still hit every other note in the song.
I like it without the high note personally
@@wyattcalcote5867 same
@@BlueYoshi85 well there go all the baritones and basses :/
Aaron Tveit and Derek Klena can like...get it...
nikki riniti fucking mood
Hannah Mendillo _Aaron Tveit and Derek Klena can like… get it…_
Aaron for sure
The only valid statement
Yes...yes they definitely can
1. Derek Klena (I just love his voice sm, can't help it)
Books in Neverland
I AGREE AND APPROVE OF THIS ORDER!
These are my top 3 for sure. Fourth would be Kyle Dean Massey
Definitely! They just hit those notes spot on, so easily, its beautiful!!!
Books in Neverland couldn’t agree more for the 1st 2. derek does it with such power and clarity! aaron sounds perfect too but something about derek (probably his everything) makes me think he’s the ideal fiyero. prob the cutest one they’ve had so far too.
Books in Neverland 1. Norbert Leo Butz
2. Aaron Tveit
3. Oliver Thompsett
4. Sebastian Arcelus
5. Derek Klena
"Aaron Tveit *swoons*" Same my friend, same.
same
Wickedly Stemma honestly if a person doesn't swoon are they even human?
Wickedly Stemma Aaron Tveit as Fiyero =Happy girls all around ☺️😁😍
Emily Simski and boys.
Erik W. S. Yes that's true
Sebastian Arcelus is such an under-rated Fiyero!!
YES
Hannah May Especially since he's married to Stephanie J. Block! Their chemistry is off the charts!
Sebastian Aracelus is just underrated in general!
I love how he’s the only one who was giddy (as far as I know at least), which was a nice touch with the “it’s up that I fell” line
Hannah May agreed!!
I really like how Sebastian did it acting wise. Elphaba trying to stop him, but smiling in a very teasing way. It goes miles to show off their chemistry. ^^
Probably because they are married 😂
Team Sebastian
Apparently Sebastian Arcelus bought a ring a week after meeting Stephanie but they didn’t start dating until after the Wicked Tour. I’d like to believe that doing this song every night is how they fell in love.
Norbert Leo Butz just makes it sound so effortless and rich at the same time. He also doesn't camp out on the high note, even though its easy for him.
Yeah I don’t like the new note they put into it. Norbert made it sound so easy without holding onto the note.
Shoutout to the non-English Fiyero's. I don't see them getting enough love, even if we can't understand the word, most of them were insanely good
But especially Jim Bakkum, right?
Norbert because he's OG and his voice is just the epitome of the masculinity of Fiyero. Aaron, Derek, and Jonah because their voices were full and it didn't sound like they were suffering to hit the high notes.
It was anticlimactic to hear that part sung in the key that they weren't supposed to be sung in.
Shoutout to Rachel Tucker cause she probably has one of the best reactions I've watched while that part is being sung. Some Elphabas look like statues.
oooh that smile by Rachel = amazing!
BadgetAgravante: When is the clip of Rachel, can't find it...
@@started_dreaming208 I think I see Rachel at 4:46
@@jalon24 I love her smile
@@suzanner1630 she’s definitely one of the most beautiful in and out of the green!
My Top 3 in Order:
1. Derek Klena - 9:00
2. Aaron Tveit - 3:03
3. Norbert Leo Butz - 0:05
(Honorable Mention) Jonah Platt - 12:02
THANK YOU FOR THE TIME STAMPS THOSE WERE LITERALLY THE ONES I WAS LOOKING FOR
@@intensewhatever SAME GIRL
Makes me want to list them all.
@@intensewhatever same
Sky Bolkin same omg
Adam Lambert being in Wicked is SO the best of both worlds
Okay but why aren’t more people talking about Sebastian!! 😭 HE WAS PERFECT ON EVERY NOTE
sebastian arcelus. i really cant stop watching.
Top 3:
1. Norbert (the OG..obvi)
2. Aaron (swoons)
3. Derek/Jonah (the new age hotties)
Yup I agree with everything you commented
I remember the first full bootl*g of wicked that I saw was with stephanie and sebastian, and every other version I've seen after that paled in comparison because *no one* could match their chemistry. Their performance of this song is honestly the best, 'cause I can actually feel like they are attracted to each other, so they're not stilted like a lot of the others. And sebastian's Fiyero is positively giddy, look at him! Love how he sang this line too
Where do we vote for Aaron Tveit to be te forthcoming movie's Fiyero?
Caroline CP SERIOUSLY THO I NEED THAT
Caroline CP YESSSSSSSS I WILL PAY MILLIONS OF DOLLARS TO SEE HIM AS FIYERO IN THE MOVIE 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻💯💯💯🙌🏻🔥🔥🙌🏻
AND SAMANTHA BARKS AS ELPHIE
YEEEEEEEESSSSSSSS!!!! 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥💯💯💯💯💯🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌
we’re looking too baby...
I find it interesting the most of them really power through "it's up that I fell" and sound great, but far too many of them are either just under pitch or outright flat on the word "fallen". Aaron Tveit's use of his vibrato on the word "fallen" is so smooth and pure - it really works the best for me in this context.
Omg this! He can get it gurl the thirst is real lol
1. I will always have a soft spot for Derek Klena and Aaron Tveit, but good lord Billy Harrigan Tighe is a beautiful man.
2. It's amazing how many of the filmed performances feature Willemijn (although it's not that strange, given how many times she's done the show and how many countries she's done it in).
3. How adorable are Sebastian Arcelus and Stephanie Block? That's chemistry right there.
stormbob Stephanie and Sebastian are married in real life too!
stormbob and Idina is in a lot of them too
stormbob I noticed that Willemijn appeared a lot as well. I lost count how many times she appeared after the first few times.
stormbob they did marry, so...
Jeremy Jordan would be an amazing Fiyero!!
crhiannonelizabeth he’s too old now :(
Will Berger Norbert was 36 when he first played Fiyero and Jeremy is barely 35 🤷🏽♀️
YAAAAAAAAAASSSS
th-cam.com/video/FYKjvSWxkBw/w-d-xo.html 2:54
Jeremy Jordan would be an amazing everything...
I think this “up“ is a great opportunity to go up with your voice you shouldn't miss.
I think Aaron Tveit is the Best Fiyero of all time. Feel sorry for the guys that can't hit it high and have to throw it away.
Zooba57 what about Norbert Leo butz?
Norbert is good. He set the bar as the first. But I think Aaron surpassed it.
Zooba57 they sounded very similar to me
Yes 👏🏻
I'd say a tie for first but they are easily the top two.
My top 5 Fiyeros are Oliver Tompsett, Lee Mead, Aaron Tveit, Adam Lambert and Oliver Savile.
I loved Rachel's laugh when Lee sang "somehow I've fallen under your spell". It's like she thinking "Oh my Oz, I can't believe he just said that".
I still love how many times Willemijn is featured in this video.
Yes I totally agree with your list I’d say the same
Thank you for putting Oliver Tompsett there...he's one of the few that made this entire thing his own. Loved Derek in Anastasia but I think the girls only put him in the top because they're in love with him. I don't think he's a contender in this comparison lol
Oliver Tompsett has been my favourite Fiyero for YEARS! Thank you for putting him at the top of the list, where he deserves to be!
Oliver Tompsett is my personal fav here
@@dignature123 Hahahaha these comments !!
Derek Klena from Anastasia (one of my favorite shows) in Wicked (my _favorite_ show)
Carlos Alejandro Alvarenga Wicked was his Broadway debut. So technically Derek Klena from Wicked
*waits through 9 whole minutes for Derek Klena
Hannah Smith same😂
Came for Derek, stayed for all the other amazing actors
Hannah Smith same😂
Yup same I was also waiting for Kyle Dean Massey and Jonah Platt
mood
And he was like 21 or 22 in this...
SEBASTIAN'S AND STEPHANIE'S CHEMISTRY THO OML
i love my mans aaron tveit and derek klena
I stan Sebastian Arcelus. Such real chemistry between him and Stephanie, that even Taye and Idina cannot capture somehow. Sometimes real life just doesn't translate to the stage.
I'm a HUGE fan of Aaron Tveit, but let's be honest...there will no be another best Fiyero than Norbert.
@mariposita yes, his name is Aaron tveit
@mariposita you’re not wrong
So true
Yes.
Someone had to say it
Sebastian Arcelus, Aaron Tveit, Derek Klena tho... My ears have been blessed
aaron really has something special and norbert is the og. i was impressed with sebastian arcelus (he's so underrated), chris peluso, kyle dean massey and oliver tompsett too!!!!
Norbert just does it beautifully, and so does Aaron!
RACHEL TUCKER’S LAUGH AFTER LEE SAID “UNDER YOUR SPELL” IM CRYING
High-key I just skipped to Aaron and Derek's parts....And omg they're so young and tiny and such previous cinnamon rolls here and Sebastian and Stephanie are so cute and gahhhhh
I LOVE STEPH AND SEB SO MUCH
Fiyero may have fallen under Elphaba’s spell, but I have fallen under the spell cast by these gorgeous men with amazing voices.
my top five(in no particular order)
1. norbert leo butz
2. adam lambert
3. aaron tveit
4. kyle dean massey
5. derek klena
I DIDN’T KNOW DEREK WAS FIYERO UNTIL A FEW DAYS AGO AND I LOVE HIM IN ANASTASIA AND HE’S AMAZING
Same I mean have little crush on Fiyero and Dimitri and know I know he plays both I of them and I almost died
He’s now Christian in Moulin Rouge!, which was a role originated by Aaron Tveit. Highly recommend checking out both performances if you can.
I know everybody likes the "its up that i fell" part but i always swoon when fiyero sings "but you've got me seeing through different eyes"
Totally agree. Also when Fiyero sings “if there’s no future for us as a pair” in falsetto. It’s kind of magical
@@JM-lh8rl I know right! I especially love it because it really shows that although she wasn't able able to change her greeness, he still loves her, and therefore, "you've got me seeing through different eyes."
@@broadwaybrook2319 I found myself replaying that part a few years ago when I found myself seeing someone through different eyes
Top 3
~ Aaron Tveit
~ Derek Klena
~ Oliver Savile
After every single one I was waiting for it to go on to the next part of the song and I was disappointed every time
1: DEREK KLENA
2: Aaron Tveit
3: Adam Lambert
top 5:
1. aaron tveit
2. derek klena
3. nick adams
4. jonah platt
5. michael companyo
SEBASTIAN ARCELUS
sebastian doesn’t get enough credit he is amazing
Everyone needs to youtube Oliver Tompsett As Long as Your Mine with riff - you will thank me - he does an insane riff on this part and if you had included that he would hands down win!
th-cam.com/video/V0Ly_IvtDKI/w-d-xo.html Olly is deffo the best.
I show that riff to everyone I meet
I was shookt to see adam lambert! He is soo good!
We are missing Oliver Tompsett’s opt up where he goes all the way up to D5 on “I”. Can’t believe they let him do that but glad they did! I wonder if this has become an acceptable alternative for the song when they teach it to new Fiyeros.
Oh my Derek Klena’s haircut lmao I died laughing
My favorite Fiyeros, in no particular order:
Norbert Leo Butz, 0:00. Can't beat the OG.
Kyle Dean Massey, 6:01. He's always been one of my favorite Fiyeros. He's got better "up that I fell"s then the one included in this video.
Derek Klena, 9:00. Need I say anything more?
Oliver Tompsett, 2:20. I didn't expect to like him, but I do.:)
Aaron Tveit, 3:04. Again, need I even explain?
Honorable mentions to:
Curt Hansen, 8:29Samuel.
Samuel Edwards, 10:45.
PS: Not going up in the "up" high note feels almost criminal. I mean, come on. It's in the word. Up! You're *supposed* to go up. Otherwise, it just doesn't feel right listening to it.
I saw Liam doyle (9:44) in 2014 and he was brilliant and made me fall for the character...😂but Aaron and Derek took my breath away😱😍...and Lee was adorable (love him on holby😄)
"Aaron Tveit *swoons*" accurate very accurate!😍😍 🤣
My top 3 in order
1)Aaron Tveit
2) Derek Klena
3)Jonah Platt
1. Aaron Tveit (I literally get chills and SWOON whenever I hear him sing)
2. Kyle Dean Massey (
Derek Klena just gives me chills! ❤️
Norbert, Derek and Aaron are just too close to my heart, I love them so much
My favorites are definitely are Norbert Lee Butz, Aaron Tveit, Derek Klena, and Michael Campayno
i need a full performance with sebastian omg
I can’t wait to hear Ryan McCartan’s rendition of this
riley sunderland it’s AMAZING th-cam.com/video/4aax-wS0V8k/w-d-xo.html
@@aiza2801 Darn! It's unavailable due to copyright claims/
It's the best version I have heard.
@@levifillmlre8687 same
Adam Lambert had me at first note! No one compares!!! You have to see the whole song to really get it! He is sexy as hell to boot! Wish there was a better video of him performing the song!
I love seeing all the understudies! Also we need to normalise changing up a note or riff if you're not feeling up to it one day, it's better as butchering the real note! :)
Would love an updated edition with newer Fiyeros like Ryan McCartan and Alistair Brammer &c.
#1 Hands down was 3:03 - he's the only one who maintained control, pitch, great timbre and intonation throughout.
#2 9:00
#3 10:00
Darn right about Aaron Tveit. 😂 he’s perfect.
My top Fiyero is the og - Norbert Leo Butz followed by Adam Lambert. I’m also partial to Rob Mills (1st Australian Fiyero) ... he was the first Fiyero I ever saw live and seeing how much effort and training he did to pull off this role was awesome to see.
Oliver Thompsett. Kyle Dean Massey. Aaron Tveit. Derek Klena.
(That was in no particular order.)
Derek Klena?! *swoons*
He was great in Anastasia. I had no idea he also played in Wicked XD
It's the hair
There is a video of Darek Klena and Lindsay Mendez singing this at Broadway in Bryant Park. I LOVE HIM, HE IS MY FAVORITE!!!
Oliver Tompsett: WOW, Cliffton Hall: so beautiful, Kyle Dean Massey: So sweet, Adam Lambert: Kills it. Norbert Leo Butz: memories, Derek Klena: surprisingly sexy.
Two years ago I saw Jonah platt and Rachel tucker ( with Carrie St. Louis as Glinda) and it was amazing! It was my first broadway show
Decided to make my list based on some of the guys not really mentioned In he comments that I think so great things here:
-0:50 Derrick Williams (I like the the vowel noises he uses on spell and fell here. Granted the recording isn’t good, but I still love it. He leaves in the e vowel sound and it might sound nasally to some, but I really like it here. It’s different, which always grabs my attention.)
-2:35 Mark Evans (he descends into the section here, starting “somehow” higher. Oliver Thompsett does this too and I love the liberty they both take here)
-7:45 Matt Willis (I love, love, love the way he softens “fallen” here. A lot of guys mix or belt this part but by making it softer, it brings something else to the A4 “up” that I fell.)
- 8:15 Ben Freeman (his placement sits a bit further back than other guys here and I love it. It gives us that kinda mysterious, sensual masculine vibe to Fieyro.)
- 11:46 Matthew Croke (one of the west end guys here that does a great job with the power and technique. When he hits that A4 you can hear there isn’t much strain)
Mark McKelvie yes, I was surprised I didn’t see anyone comment on Croke. I thought he did amazingly.
Yes, I loved Matthew!
I saw Curt Hansen (8:29) as Fiyero and he was amazing! Norbert Leo Butz is my all time fave. Also loved Adam Lambert, Oliver Thompsett, and Derek Klena.
I agree! Curt Hansen is quite enchanting. He was also my first Fiyero.
derrick williams, oliver tompsett, aaron tveit (obv), gregor stewart, david nathan perlow, curt hansen, derek klena (
aaron’s vibrato on ”fallen” is DELICIOUS
Nice video! I really love Derek's 😍 Who's your favorite? (Kyle Dean and Aaron Tveit aren't far behind 😁)
In order: Aaron Tveit, Norbert Leo Butz, Kyle Dean Massey, Derek Klena and Adam Garcia!
Special mention to Sebastian Arcelus and Anton Zetterholm because I like their As Long As You're Mine, even though I haven't seen their full performance :)
@@PhantomifyEponine Nice. Nothing but respect for my king, Kyle Dean Massey.
My fav is Norbert and Derek. I love the originals they were just kind of old..
There are 8 that I like but my top three are Kyle Dean Massey Derek Klena and Jonah Platt. I got to meet Kyle oh my god he is such a nice young man. I love all of the musicals he is in. He makes me smile every time I hear him sing.
Same they my favorites too
My favorite Fiyero list
Derek Klena
Jonah Platt
Kyle Dean Massey
Ryan McCartan
Aaron Tveit
This video really made me appreciate this lyric more lol
Adam Lambert played Fiyero AND KILLED IT?! Omg mind blown
I’m always partial to Derek, but I’ve never heard of Liam Connor Tamne, and my jaw genuinely dropped! He’s up there for me for favorites.
Derek Klena will always be my Fiyero
wow oliver tompsett physically made me gasp
WHERE DID THIS DEREK AUDIO COME FROM I need it
Curt Hansen saw Fiyaro when I saw Wicked. He did phenomenal!
3:02 Aaron Tveit
8:59 Derek Klena
Kay_ Carlsin bless you
For me Norbert and Idina are the all time favourites but i saw them first. Anyway, i listened to this song in different langueges and its so great in every. My favourite song from the show with defying gravity. :)
Bettina P I love Derek Klena and Lyndsay Mendez as well as Nobert Leo Butz and Idina Menzel. The originals :).
The only Fiyero I've been aware of up till now is ADAM LAMBERT!! Somehow I've fallen under his spell & no other Fiyero exists for me!! But they are all quite good!! ADAM is Superb!!
Not in order but..
Norbert Leo is just a solid Fiyero right into your ears. Something you will always want to hear :)
Guilty! That was the first time I've hear Aaron Tveit as Fiyero and DAMMMNNNNN. Now I need to see him lol
I've seen Kyle Dean Massey and his Fiyero will always be memorable. And I will always love his chemistry with Donna Vivino on that number. Such a sweet, longing attraction between them that it will make you feel jealous lol.
Derek Klena has this ultimate serenade voice. Just swoon!
I want to see Jonah Platt's Fiyero!
You know who I want to play Fiyero some time? Matpat.
Omg yes
Clarabird like the matpat?😂
I can see it
Clarabird That would be absolutely amazing
Carlos Alejandro Alvarenga
Game theory matpat, yes
I'm kinda disappointed that nobody in the comments is talking about Michael Campayno, I saw him as Fiyero and he's fantastic
Shelby OMG I LOVE HIM
YES OMG
I saw him live with Kara Lindsay and Jennifer Dinioia, they were all amazing and the stage chemistry was so good!
That’s what I thought as well ... he’s really underappreciated
I love the chemistry between the two at 1:50
They’re married☺️ it’s Sebastian Arcelus & Stephanie J Block
Micheal Campanyo!! I met him after Wicked and he is the sweetest person ever!! 13:30
Derek Klena is my all time favorite Fiyero.
I laughed so hard when I saw Taye Diggs....HE NEVER DESERVED HER
Brittney what do you know about their marriage?
Pearl the rebel didn’t he cheat on her or something like that ?
Gobble 1234 I don't think they ever said what happened.
Pearl the rebel oh I thought that because I saw this radio talk show vid where they said that he was seen at a strip club hiring dancers or something
Gobble 1234 possible
1. lee ji hoon
2. adam lambert
3. tie between aaron tveit and norbert leo butz (i cant chose!)
this list will change if park hyo shin is ever cast a fiyero!
Okay, but this is missing Oliver Tompsett's D5 riff choice he does in this very bit. It took me to theatre heaven
Finally a comparison riff for the guys!!!!
Norbie, Derek, and Aaron kill it
I just love how all the german ones are all willemijn
Woah! Adam Lambert did this?!?! Ahhhhh yes!!!!! I’ve completed life!