Testing & Ranking The BEST Drugstore Liquid Eyeliners
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 พ.ย. 2024
- As soon as I started testing the best drugstore liquid eyeliners, I realized that I had seriously deprived myself from so many great new options by staying "loyal" to my holy grail. I did a 4-day liquid eyeliner wear test of the highest rated at the drugstore. After testing them side by side, I'll rank them from worst to best and crown what I think is currently the best drugstore liquid eyeliner that won't smudge. Enjoy this battle of drugstore liquid eyeliners!
✭ Products Mentioned | I bought all of these products myself. | Affiliate links allow me to earn a small commission from purchases I influence. Thank you! ✭
NYX Matte Liquid Liner [discontinued]
wet n wild Breakup Proof Liquid Liner shop-links.co/...
e.l.f. H2O Proof Eyeliner shop-links.co/...
Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Liner shop-links.co/...
L'Oreal Flash Cat Eyeliner shop-links.co/...
✭ Join our Facebook Group! ✭
/ drugstorebeauty
✭ Let's Be Social ✭
BLOG: www.slashedbeau...
INSTAGRAM: / slashedbeauty
✭ Coupon Codes ✭
These codes give you savings, and I earn commission when you use them!
Get $20 off your first order at SeatGeek with code SLASHEDBEAUTY: seatgeek.com
Get 25% off Kokie Cosmetics with code SLASHEDBEAUTY: www.kokiecosme...
SIGN UP FOR SMILE DIRECT CLUB + Get 50% off your impression kit & $100 off aligners with code SlashedBeauty: bit.ly/sbsdc
*NYX Matte Liquid Liner $7.50* (beginning favorite)
_Pros:_ precision brush tip, smudge-proof, matte finish, water resistant, thin brush tip good for sharp wings, most matte of the bunch, dip brush makes super precise lines, deepest black
_Cons:_ NOT waterproof, broke down and flaked on a humid day, dip brush may not be as beginner friendly
*Wet N Wild Breakup Proof Liquid Eyeliner $4.99*
_Pros:_ [claims: waterproof, fade-proof, flake-proof, lasts up to 16 hours] thin tip good for sharp wings, brush tip stays in good shape longer than felt tips, not super shiney, stayed in tact on a humid day, layers well, pen style easy to use
_Cons:_ tapered applicator means you'll end up with overall thicker lines (unless you do it all with the tip which would be more work), not completely matte, came off a bit when eyes were rubbed, wears around crows feet creases
*E.L.F. H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen $6*
_Pros:_ [claims: waterproof, smooth application, no smudging, feathering, or running] lasts throughout day, pen style easy to use
_Cons:_ applicator makes a thicker line, dries down to feel tighter and hard (would also make touch ups and layering more difficult), shiny finish, looks chunkier when layered, felt tip frays faster than the other brush tips
*Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen $8.99*
_Pros:_ [claims: easy lines, smooth glide, no skipping, waterproof] completely matte, able to get sharp wings, pen style easy to use, brush tip
_Cons:_ not as black, skips at first - needs breaking in, wears around crows feet creases, fades some through the middle
*L'Oréal Flash Cat Eyeliner $10.99*
_Pros:_ [claims: quick and easy, waterproof, all day wear] comes with a stencil, 2nd most matte of the group, brush tip, pen style easy to use
_Cons:_ stencil adds to price, wears around crows feet creases, fades slightly in color throughout day
*FINAL RANKING*:
1. *Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen - $8.99* : smoothest application, brush tip, dries quickly, layers well, precise tip for sharp lines, lasts throughout day, not as matte
2. *Wet N Wild Breakup Proof Liquid Eyeliner* - $4.99 : brush tip, pen is easy, liquid flows well, precise lines, lasts throughout day, leaks if shaken without cap on
3 & 4. (tie) *NYX Matte Liquid Liner - $7.50* AND *L'Oréal Flash Cat Eyeliner $10.99* : NYX liner isn't waterproof, best for precise lines, best matte finish & darkest black. L'Oréal lasts longer, waterproof, pen is easier to use, brush tip, isn't as black, bit dry, 2nd most matte
5. *E.L.F. H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen - $6* : lasted, felt bad, shiny finish, felt tip
some other notes from the comments:
-pen style liquid eyeliners tend to dry out faster, around two weeks
-be sure to shake eyeliners with the lids on
yas noodle boi coming THRU!!! 🥳😌👏🏼 thank you!!
thank YOU! i’m omw to the store in a hurry & thought “wow i really hope i can get a quick answer” & sure enough, you blessed me.
Omg ily i hope that you hvent the best march ever😋
My personal favorites is hypereasy and 2-in-1 eye booster! Ugh so good. Milani is good too.
This was so damn helpful and time saving. I have a bad habit of looking these things up from inside the ULTA parking lot 😂😂😂 Instant sub just for this comment.
Thank you for actually doing a wear test on your eyes and not just swatching them on your arm and running water on top of it. It’s pretty different having eyeliner worn on the eyes and realistically getting oily after the end of the day verses just running water over the liner and basing your opinion off just that. 😁👍. Great informative video!
Thanks so much for the feedback!!
Shake with top on!! I never shook a eyeliner open but take u for showing us to be aware!!
Thanks so much for watching!
Yeah, My first thought was shake BEFORE you take off the top. 😬
Never have I…shook an eyeliner without the cap on
the amount of times she drew a wing perfectly and i cant even get one right.
over 10 years of it being my go-to makeup look 😅 practice makes perfect!!!
i love her voice and the way she explains its so satisfying
Thanks so much 💕
So good
the research obsessed person in me loooves this video! super informative, good catch with the eyeliner marks too!!
Thanks so much for watching!!
I've never shaken an eyeliner pen without the lid on!
Also thank you for this video. So useful
Glad it was helpful!
It’s like shaking nail polish.
My go to liquid liner is the physicians formula eye booster waterproof ultra fine! Sooooo good! I have really watery eyes and oily skin/lids and it doesn’t budge at all until I take it off at the end of the day!
Everyone keeps mentioning this, so I'm going to have to try it next!! Thanks Krystal!
Is it matte finish?
Love this liner! so thin and so easy to use. Stays on for so long
@@slashedbeauty thanks for this recommendation!
The only Con is it doesn’t dry matte.
Omg I would love a 2024 version of this video!
that's a great idea!
As someone who wants to wear eyeliner but is intimidated as heck, I can't wait to try a few of these!
Oooh you’re gonna love saturday’s video!!! Stick around 🥰🥰🥰 thanks so much for watching and commenting!!
I was so afraid to try winged liner, but I tried the hyper easy one and with the pencil like shape and the brush tip it was so much easier than expected.. I've had a few other ones that I swear couldn't even glide over my eye shadow with tugging and looking awful.. but not that one..
This is the best product comparison video I've seen thus far! Keep em coming girl! You got it down to a science. TY!
Thank you so much, Swin! I appreciate it!! 💖
I REALLY needed this video because I just found out that the Nyx Matte Eyeliner is now discontinued! I had also been using it for years and it was so helpful to see the comparison. I appreciate how in depth you went about application and how matte each of them are. Definitely going to try some of these out
Wait SERIOUSLY!?!?! WHYYYYY I mean I know it didn't end up on top once I did my side by sides but it's still such a solid liner. Wow that's crazy! Well thanks for letting me know and thanks so much for your kind comment.
This was my first video of yours I’d ever seen..... 30 seconds in and I subscribed without hesitation! You are SO eloquent and warm, I don’t feel like I’m being sold anything and I genuinely LOOKED FORWARD to watching the full video whereas with EVERY other beauty youtuber nowadays I just skip ahead to see their picks. Thank you for doing what you do and being yourself!!!!
Best comment of the week! Thank you so much for your kind words. I put a lot of work into my videos and hoping that they're interesting to watch so I'm really glad to hear your feedback! 💕
Watched for all of 10 seconds and instantly subscribed. You’re so easily likable and charming and I love your detailed comparisons here.
That’s why you don’t shake the cap off I’ve had that problem
I thought you’re supposed to shake eyeliner with the lid on. 😂
It's a pain to keep putting the lid on to shake it if I'm in the middle of the line! lol
Right! Just put the damn lid on
I never put the lid on 😬
I would never shake with the lid off. 🤦🏾♀️
@Crescent Lunaxy 🤪 never had a problem before this one lol now I've gotten used to putting the cap back on. but literally never was an issue
thank you girl!! ive been looking for a more in - depth video, i love how you explain why you ranked them in those spots :)
Thank you so much, glad you liked it!!
I would never shake eyeliner with the top off!🥰
I'm extremely interested in the Wet and Wild one. Definitely gonna try it some time soon.
Hope you like it!
Just wanted to let you know I actually enjoyed the full review and watched it through. I liked how you did the comparisons and the eod update. I decided to buy the one you liked best and I think I like it more than the higher end I used to have. 🤍
That is amazing, thank you so so much for your comment! What was the high end one you replaced, I'm curious??!
I love how specific your descriptions are! It's so helpful! Thanks for this video!
Thanks so much for your kind words, Carrie! 💜
I subbed right when she started talking. There is something so genuine about her!
You’re so sweet! Thanks so much for watching and commenting! 🥰
I've tried all but the Elf one. NYX was my long term favorite but Maybelline Hyper Easy moved on to my current favorite!
I definitely have to update this vid because now I'm obsessed with the newer NYX Epic Ink pen!
how can y’all even support a brand that harms animals smfh
I'm new to waitressing and was really bummed out
when I realized how I cant possibly wear my favorite eyeliner
to work when I'm so sweaty and oily! (Wet n Wild Megaliner Liquid Eyeliner)
Ive been looking for waterproof/sweat proof makeup
for a few days now and your video has helped me out so much!
Thank you!
That's a great liner but yes, I've experienced transfer to the top of my lid with it on hot days! Hope you find a new fave!!
I appreciate that you review drugstore and budget makeup because as much as I'd want to use makeup, I don't want to pay an arm or leg for it. I also don't use makeup on a daily basis so I can't justify buying high-end brands.
Of course! And there are so many amazing options that don't break the bank now-- drugstore makeup has come a long way!
i loved the maybelline liner but it dried out soooo quickly! i probably got about 2 weeks of use. and i would store it differently and shake every time and nothing helped :(
Oh I experienced that too! I thought that mine was a dud!
Ooooh thank you for letting me know, I'll keep my eye on it!!!
This is also why I typically prefer "dip" liners like the NYX one over the pen style!
YES! even if you flip the tip it drys after one or two uses.
Same!!! I would barely get two swipes & it was dry.. next use it would work for a cpl more swipes. Not good
The meticulousness is so much appreciated!!!
I have "not that insane" hooded eyes and I'm my twenties so my skin is not that smooth. You can imagine how that doesn't help when lining my eyes with liquid eyeliner. I'd have to stretch my skin and that is something that I try to avoid as much as possible.
To summarise- thank you for an amazing and helpful video!
Glad it was helpful, Thanks so much for watching, Dora! :)
Totally subscribing! Please do more comparisons like this! Blush, bronzer, highlighter, mascara, eyeshadow primer etc 😍
Thanks so much!! I've done concealer and liquid lipstick, but will definitely be doing more! 💕
I have a friend who is not really into make-up but she does like her wings. She asked for a recommendation to replace the kvd trooper for something cheaper and I did a bit of research and everything pointed to the Hyper easy. She got it and loves it. Yay me, I guess i didn't stear her wrong! Not into liquid liners myself. 😉
Yay!!! How is she liking it?
OH MY GOD how have I not found you before today. I love your voice!!! You are a breath of fresh air compared to some people on here..
Thank you so much Annette!! I appreciate it 🥰
The Maybelline is my favorite! It is very easy to use with no mistakes, pigmented, smooth, and lasts well.
Definitely the easiest to use with the best results for me!!
MAYBELLINE for sure! i was so stuck on KVD tattoo liner for yrs, then i finally found another great one.. Makeup by Mario master matter liquid. my local sephoras were out of stock so i looked up your video & found this. first place i checked was target but they were out of the maybelline. went to walmart & it was the last one left. i bought it & was so excited to try it. i did swatches on my hand of the mario liner & the maybelline. they literally both dried the same matte consistency. let it sit for 5 minutes & did a wet finger swipe.. i was WOWWED! the maybelline one DID👏🏽NOT👏🏽SMEAR ONE BIT! the only con about the maybelline one is, maybe it’s just the one i have, but it seemed a little more liquidity during application but no runny consistency. thanks for the review girl! & btw, i never shook my eyeliners w/out the caps on😅 THANK YOU THANK YOU!🥰
Love hearing this!!! Thanks for watching and commenting!!
I didn't try Nyx matte liner but Nyx Epic liner is really epic :)
I've tried the Epic liner in white and it's sort of a thick formula. Is the black the same?
My #1 rn is physicians formula, just because of easy application and precise line. It doesn't look matte but it still looks good. After watching this video though, I'll give wet 'n wild and maybelline a try.
I've got to try that one!! I'll check it out, thanks Janna!
Maybelline hyper easy for the win! Its my drugstore dupe for my favorite brush tip liner, Lorac front of the line pro!
Oooh I haven't tried that one!! Yes, so glad to hear you love it!!
Just found you. I love how you explain things and how clear is your pronouncation so people who can't understand english well can understand.
Stay safe & success!
Thank you so much!! I appreciate it!
Great review video, very thorough but also concise. Appreciate that you showed the detail of how crisp and pointy you could get the line, that's what I struggle with the most when shopping for liners. That's why I prefer the brush tips over felt tips.
100% !! The crisp wing is everything!
LOVEEE the NYX matte liner! Has also been one of my favs for years!
it really is a solid liner, i had just not bothered to really give other ones a fair shot!!
absolutely LOVE your reviews!!! this was my first one- i love how well you explain the wear of the liners with the time test. and straight to the point! you've got yourself a new subscriber 🥰
Thank you so much!! 💕
Thank you for your drugstore eyeliner ranking, most delightful 🤗
Can you also try the K palette real lasting eyeliner? I've heard so many claims and your thoughts are really well spoken when it comes to review so your feedback on this product would mean a lot to me thanks!!!
Loooove this, i have an obsession with finding the right eyeliner, I'm always in the search for the best one! I really love the L'Oréal one but cant seem to find it anymore where i live, so im going to give the Maybelline a try! ❤ Thanks!!!
Hope you like it!!
Very informative and helpful video. Loved how you tested them out against each other! 👏🏽👏🏽
Thanks so much! 💕
Yeah, I messed up a freshly painted wall with eyeliner droplets. My husband was not happy. It was the first (and only) time I used an ELF liner.
Oh noOooOOo. Well I guess at least I had the curtains behind me which were cheap from Big Lots 😂 I think it was more so the wet n wild one though!
I love the wet and Wild and maybelline one.I never done a liquid liner but after watching this i think i could do it😃
Practice makes perfect!!
Thank you for making this video! It was so helpful to me❤️❤️❤️
Yay! So glad I could share. Thanks for watching and commenting!
Thanks for putting a lot of effort and time to make liner analysis ❤❤🙌
Thanks so much for watching and commenting!!
I have been trying to find the best liner i can for a while now, tried out a ton and none worked for me but this helped me out so much!! thank you!! 🙏🙏❤️
Yay! Glad I could help!
Love this video concept/series. Would you do one for concealers? ❤️☺️😘
I have done one! 😜 th-cam.com/video/Nhv6oIF2ORY/w-d-xo.html
@@slashedbeauty thanks!
I’ve had a lot of issues with the elf eyeliner and this definitely helped. Can’t wait to try some of these.
Glad I could help!
I just bought the Went n wild breakup proof eyeliner and it is a felt tip, not a brush!
Thats... bizarre. Are you sure you grabbed the right one?
Your eyes are beautiful. I like Maybelline for me . What do you recommend for drug store mascara. Enjoyed your video as always ❤️❤️
I have a video dedicated to drugstore mascara here!! th-cam.com/video/Jq0ttJw5cWo/w-d-xo.html
This was a great video !! I agree Madeline hyper stay is the best!!
That NYX eyeliner is discontinued and I LOVVVED IT TOO!! 😔 Thanks for this video!!
Have you tried the new Epic Ink Liner? Very close and maybe even easier to use! It's my updated favorite!
@@slashedbeauty the brush on this feels bigger than the old brush. I liked the skinny tight line with the long brush bristles
With in 15 seconds I subscribe this channel hard working girl
Have you tried the Revlon ColorStay Skinny Liquid Eyeliner? It dries matte and is my favorite! When I was in high school I used the regular chunky tip it came with but then they came out with the skinny tip and it’s been a game changer for me since. I also can’t stand shiny or semi-matte finish on eyeliner!
Ooh I haven't but thank you for the rec!! Same, I always think shiny eyeliners take away from the look and make my eyes look weird!
Good, I'll head out tomorrow to get the Maybelline one 😂
That one convinced me
The wet and wild pencil eyeliner is also amazing.
I love that one for tightlining!
Omg thank you for this video I don't see other videos putting them on the eyes to test them. This really helped me
Thanks so much for watching!
I love this video. However, I have major transfer with the break up proof in like 20 minutes in the humidity.
Oh dang!!! I HATE when that happens though I haven't had it happen with this one. In fact, I wore it on a humid day AND in the pool for a video testing waterproof makeup and it stayed on!
This video was super helpful for me. I almost bought the wet n wild one today but opted for one by annabelle. It's a brush tip , I'm gonna try it tomorrow
thanks so much for watching, Kelly!
this is a really helpful video! and I subscribed from your personality within the first two minutes of the video. you seem awesome and I'm excited to watch more of this channel! :)
Thank you so so much!!! I appreciate it 🥰
I just loved the amount of commitment....
Thank you ☺️
I wish you would have did a line of each on your hand so we could compare the colors and finishes side by side all at once.
🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️ MEGAN lmaoooo I just realized I filmed that and didn’t put it in the video aahhh I’m so sorry lmao. On Monday I have a blog post version of this video going live with swatches tho... dm me and I’ll send you the link 🖤
I've tried all you mentioned, but they didn't last on my eyes :(
NYX Epic is my #1. Great video!!
I've only tried the NYX Epic in white and it was sort of thick-- what do you think?
Even though it was a pain having the eyeliner splatter out, that tells me that the brush would have excellent flow. Just make sure to shake it with the cap on before beginning.
Very true!!!
I use the L oreal cat eye one but I wanna try the first 2 this helped me decide I’m getting both cuz I can’t decide
Hope you like them!!
Thanks to you I found the best mascara for me! So let's get myself a good eyeliner as well!
Yay!!! Which one was it??
I share the preference of brush tip with you. The felt tip always disappoints! Overall great comparisons!
Thank you so much amber!! Yess felt tip just depreciates in quality too quickly
Very informative..loved it!! Please make video on creamy matte and pigmented lipsticks
Check these out!
th-cam.com/video/7-4r7Rk6lMQ/w-d-xo.html
That's crazy, I currently use the Maybelline hyper easy, and it smudges like crazy on me, main reason why I was searching for this type of video
Wow!!! Goes to show not all products will work the same on different faces!
WOW if all of youtuber as dedicated as you omggg it wouldnt be so hard to find the right make up for you🥰 NEW SUBSCRIBER HERE! love ya already💕
Aw thank you so much!!
Would love to see you do this with gel (pot) liners!!
It's been a while since I've used pot liners because they dry out so much, but that was years ago and I'd def be interested in how they've improved! Thanks for the idea!
Yeaaaa!!! I liberally was thinking just this morning about messaging you about the eyeliner! 😉😂 Thank you!!! Now, I watch.....
I have super watery eyes so in my outer corner and inner corner i always have to touch up.... that said waterproof is required. Ive found nyx liners always leak and splatter whn u shake them ive tried all of them that they have. My fav liner is actually not in this video. My favorite liner is the ulta brand liner its a felt tip but it is a very flexible felt tip so when u use it it feels like a brush tip ive found the felt tip does not like break apart and ive found it doesnt leak or splatter you can shake it till your hearts content and no mess
I love the Ulta Beauty Brand and haven't tried their liner... thanks for the recommendation!!
@@slashedbeauty youre welcome anytime :)
Do you have a video where you test the best ones to see how long you can use them before they dry out/ run out of product? I LOVE your testing process but I think that the usage cost would make a difference for me when considering the eyeliner I'll be using more.
That's a really interesting idea!! Thanks!!
Thank you so much Miranda, omg the master precise liner from Mabeline is pretty good but now I know what liner to pick for next time ❤️
Thanks Michelle!!! I almost tested that one but I think the hyper easy had better reviews!
Slashed Beauty omg I’ll definitely check it out, can you get it at Ulta
I don’t know what you’re doing to keep your eyeliner intact throughout the day but when I use it, by the end of the day my eyeliner smudges and fades away. And I’m not even rubbing my eyes! I used the maybelline New York eye liner and for some reason, it doesn’t want to stay on my face.
I’m not doing anything particular. Perhaps you are more oily in that area than I am. Are you priming the eyes?
@@slashedbeauty I know absolutely nothing about makeup. I bought the eyeliner cause I wanted to try something new. I don’t know what priming is. I clicked on your video cause I was hoping it could explain why I’m having so much trouble with it. I thought maybe I bought a bad brand. It says water proof so I assumed it was good. *shrug*
@@Dnightshade100 Gotcha! Well the oils around our eyes can definitely break down makeup, everyone just has a different skin type and some people's eyes are more oily than others. Do you notice at the end of the day your eyelids are a bit slick/shiny? Using an eye primer (often used before eyeshadow) can help mattify the lids, control oil and keep makeup on them. Even if you're not using eyeshadow, it can still help with the liner! One of my favorites is the Milani Shadow Primer, and a new go-to of mine is the e.l.f. Lock It Down primer - amzlink.to/az0yc7XJFdtBV (affiliate link)
@@slashedbeauty thanks, I’ll give that a try 👍🙂
@@slashedbeauty wanted to let you know how it turned out. I went and bought the primer you recommended along with trying the wet and wild brand of eyeliner you used. I even washed my face before putting on the makeup and I gotta say your suggestion made a big difference! I wore it all day at my local church festival and at the end of the day my makeup didn’t once smudge or fade! Woohoo! 😄 thank you so much! I feel much more confident wearing eyeliner now. Thanks so much! 😁 👍👍✌️
Thank you SO MUCH for this video! I have been on an eyeliner hunt for days now. Buying the maybelline one right away. EEK!
Since filming this I’ve also discovered the nyx epic ink liner which I loooove!!!
@@slashedbeauty Omg its like you read my mind. I loved your review so much that I literally searched 'slashed beauty nyx epic ink liner' last night to see if you had reviewed that one cuz I was trying to decide between the maybelline and nyx one. whichever one is more matte and doesn't bleed would be the winner for me.
@@haleemasadia3857 I don't have the maybelline one on hand anymore but they both have just the SLIGHTEST bit of sheen, mostly matte. As far as bleeding goes MAYBE maybelline would work best-- the nyx formula doesn't bleed necessarily but sometimes I notice a lot comes out at once if I've shaken it too much or it was stored at a weird angle and then obviously youll have a lot come out and spread around if you're not careful.
@@slashedbeauty thanks a lotttt. My maybelline liner is on the way anyway 😄 Do you know of any marker liner that's 100% matte tho? I don't like sheen at all
@@haleemasadia3857 The Physicians Formula Matte Butter Eyeliner is 100% matte-- it's decent and is a brush tip but for some reason the brush is kind of blunt so it can be difficult to get a sharp point. But it does have a beautiful flat matte finish!
Omg thank you for this video!!!! Very detailed.
Thanks so much for watching, I'm glad you enjoyed it!
@@slashedbeauty OMG YOU RESPONDED!!!!!! AAHHHHHH!!!!!!! Thank youuuuuuuuuuu again!!!!! I’m so happy to find you here!
THIS VIDEO IS SO GOOD PLS THANK U
thanks for watching!!!
First video I've watched, and I love it
You're so welcome!
New to your channel . I wanted to get my tattoo eyeliner( waterproof (not drug store) , but it is not in stock at Sephora. Therefore , I have to get one for drugstore for temporary. I weren’t sure to pick maybel or L’Oreal. Thank you , and I know what to order tomorrow.
Yay! Glad I could help!
subscribed after watching!! eyeliner is my favorite part of makeup, thank you for this video
Glad you enjoyed it, thanks so much for subscribing, Serena!
Super detailed review! Love it! What eyeliner are you using in the waterline? I need to find one that doesn’t budge! Lol
Essence! I have a whole video about waterproof eyeliners here: th-cam.com/video/hVdB1jBS6Z8/w-d-xo.html&lc=Ugy6KcX-WhjXiOYGio94AaABAg
New subscriber.. love how you get right to the point, loving your content 😍☺️
Thank you so much!!
I loved Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Liner so much'; however, the brush tip frayed long before the eye liner dried out. Moving on to your No. 3 choice now.
Really? i didn't have that issue-- I used it up before noticing fraying especially since it's a brush tip, it really shouldn't fray at all actually.
@@slashedbeauty Maybe I accidentally caught some of the brush fibers in the cap? Three or four of them were at odd angles.
@@missivonne Yes, that's happened to me before for sure!!
Omg you look like Manny from Degrassi! So pretty
This is my FAVORITE compliment EVER! 😍😝 Thank you!
Thank you for all your tips. I love all drugstore brands. Especially LOREAL. 🥰🥰🥰
Very detailed comparing video . Excellent 👌
Thanks a lot 😊
You should be a news broadcaster, you do a great job captivating the audience with your explanations!
I have a feeling being a youtuber may be more fun for me 😋 thank you!!!
Guess what's on my hunt list for today!! Super excited and thank you! 🙏🏼 I have been needing a new liner for soooo long! 🥰😍🤩
You'll have to update me and let me know how it works for you!
I'd never shake my liner with the cap off, so..not a deal breaker for me.
I'm here because I just got the Maybelline liquid liner (not the one you have) and it's HORRIBLE. I tried it years ago and thought it sucked, but I figured I got a dud and just tried it again and it's just as bad. I HATE it. So hopefully I find a new recommendation here. 🤞🏻
ooh I haven't tried that one! I hope I can help you find your new fave!
I was wondering which liner she used at the end cause it looks good and she came in clutch and told us
🙌🏼💕
Hey doll id never shake withour cap on!😱 Lol 😉 Always try tip out before applying for first time....years of use taught me this (old doll). Thanks for your very detailed reviews.
Thanks so much for watching, Betsy!!
Hi Miranda! Thank you for this eye liner face off!! Of course, I have lipstick questions. What lipstick/gloss are you wearing at 1:51 and another one at 12:59? Have a great weekend!!
Hi Val!! At 1:51 I layered the Milani ludicrous lip crayon in So Obsessed and the wet n wild jungle rock gloss in fearless. At 12:59 I don't remember at all but I will try to!!
Nyx has been my favorite for years but recently I’m unable to find it even at Ulta. The maybeline stiletto liner is a close second for me! I have extra skin on my eyelids so felt tip is usually a disaster.
Apparently through the grape vine I've heard they're discontinuing it and pushing their Epic Ink liner, I'll have to try that one next.
i can say from experience that the l'oreal flash cat is great BUT also has some pen malfunctions that keeps it from reaching full use for longer than a month or 2.
thanks for pointing that out!
Thank you for your honest reviews!
Thanks so much for watching and commenting!
Just subbed. I love the packaging of the maybelline one to it looks expensive i think. Im going to try that one 😁
Definitely! Thanks so much, Kyra!
This video is so helpful!!!
Glad you think so!