***This HOKA CARBON X FULL REVIEW is an OLD video that was never published due to the crazy travel schedule over the past 5 weeks. Thanks for your patience as we begin to roll out more running shoe reviews in the next week. Onward and Upward!***
Overall very happy with the Carbon X. I've just over 120 miles in them, which includes two marathons. I've ran well over 20 marathons, a few ultras, and full ironman, so I have a fair bit of running experience. Post marathon muscle soreness has been dramatically less with the Carbon X compared to all other shoes and the same training load, etc. Yes they felt firm, the first strides felt odd, but those sensations quickly disappear. My only quibble is that I feel the forefoot is a little wide, making my foot slip side to side slightly. On some runs I'm aware of it, on others not. One day I think I've discovered proper lacing tension then the next it seems wrong. It has created a hot spot, but through two marathons it never developed into a full-blown blister.
Seth, I had an issue with rubbing on my Achilles in my first few runs in these, but then I figured out that I could get a good lockdown with much less pressure on the laces than I thought I needed. No more Achilles rubbing + solid lock-down = smooth as butter!
Just ran the LV marathon in these and have used them on some of my long runs. They were great, even for me as a solid mid pack runner. I never had any issues with the heel collar or other hot spots with this shoe, for whatever that’s worth.
I just wore these shoes for my recent Dublin Marathon and got a PB and a BQ for 2021. They felt great, even though I thought they looked kind of ugly. No regrets.
Ok who thought he was going to barbeque the shoe....... I've had my eye on this shoe so glad to see the review and comments. Seems alot have had an issue with the heel but ill still try it out.
I love the Carbon X. No Achilles or feet issues. This shoe helps me to have a faster cadence and less fatigue in my legs. Definitely long run, marathon and HM race shoe.
Had a pair of Carbon X's and liked them, but also felt they were just a bit firm and I could feel it each run. Added a spenco like you did and it's now my favorite shoe ever! Light, reactive, bouncy, and comfortable
Thank you for showing the removable sock liner and how it worked with your inserts. I orthotics and as much as I love trying out new shoes I’m always afraid to buy online because more shoes are coming with glued in sock liners. Great job and thanks for the review
I replaced the carbon x insole with a clifton 5 insole for the Athens Marathon and fortunately it was an experiment that went right,the carbon x insole is too thin in the front, no cushion at all.
I wear the CarbonX on tempo and intervals and I absolutely love this shoe. I am running the Austin Marathon in February and am thinking about wearing the CarbonX during the race. Love, love, love this shoe.
you should. i assume your a nick bare follower? if not look him up..hes got a large following for the Austin marathon. i am interested in the carbon Xs now!!!!!
After My first run in these shoes I was like "What? These are bricks!" I found the midsole very stiff compared to the plush ZoomX in the Nike Turbo and Vaporfly. They felt like the Zoomfly only stiffer with a steeper drop off in the forefoot. I was quite disappointed after reading some great positive reviews and paying over $200CA. Thankfully this dissipated quite a bit over about 25K and it actually feels pretty good now, or maybe just getting used to the feeling. I do like this shoe for speedwork now and have only taken it out for one 20K long run and actually felt pretty good as well. I would rate this as a good shoe and will give it a go on my next long run if you say that is where it shines. I have had no issues with the heel rubbing. I look forward to the Version 2 where they make it lighter.
I never had issues with this shoes I really loved them you can’t even hear them when running so pleased with them and I run mostly on pavement so it works divine.
I would just like to point out one thing. You said you didn't like how firm it felt so you added the spenco insert. The Carbon X is supposed to be a RACING SHOE so it's going to feel firm. It's not meant for 20+ mile long slower distances. There was a group of people that took these shoes when they first came out and started daily training in them and told everyone they're a trainer. This is not the case and not the purpose of this shoe. It's supposed to be firm.
The 40 Something runner if you're running fast for those distances then yes. Jim walmsley was running 5'40 miles when he broke the world record for the 50 mile distance. The shoe is meant to go fast, not slow
The 40 Something runner that would be a great choice! They have the same meta rocker feel but the glideride has a significantly higher cushion and the upper is a lot more plush and premium as well. It's designed to be more efficient for the longer, slower miles
I am fan of these, ran loads of speed work days and even a half marathon in them. They feel solid at faster speeds, not so much at slower paces. I agree, the weight needs to come down and maybe add a new specialized foam for next year? maybe? =)
The HOKA CARBON X is one of the most amazing shoes I've had. And yes, you're right, this shoe gets slippery when it gets wet! This shoe doesn't like anything else than dry, firm concrete :D
The carbon X is exactly something you will expect from hoka just like their other models, plus a carbon fiber plate. Very wide and roomy, rocking feeling and very soft landing. Not sure how ppl find them stiffer than the next %.
I ran 700km with my first pair. Never had any heel issues, but got five black toe nails during marathon training. I bought my new CarbonX one size bigger. Hopefully that will spare my toe nails. I really like the shoe though.
Just bought these in Canada Black Friday, have been running in Hoka for awhile, love the extra cushioning given PF and Achilles issues. Carbon X hella expensive in Canada but just found my size for $60 off runningfree.com (Black Friday weekend sale). Thank you Seth, very excited to try them. Congrats on 50k subs! Great things ahead. Ps. Would you consider an SJD buff for sale in your collection?
Seth, you ever run in your carbon plate shoes in the winter at all? I just wanted to ask have you found that you have to "warm up" the carbon fibre? Just wanted to check, because i was doing some 1 mile repeats at about 4 Celsius (sorry I live in England hehe) and oh my goodness, that first mile was gnarly on my feet, but after that it was back to "normal" bouncy and springy again. During the summer and autumn months did not notice this , but man the contrast was real obvious. (I was running in these shoes Hoka Carbon X)
QOD: reduce weight, ditch the window view of the carbon - we believe you Hoka, the carbon is there. Mix some graphine into the sole for an über durable shoe.
I managed o grab a pair with a discount from a race bib earlier this year, but with them still selling out all the time, I'm not so sure they'll be getting any kind of major discount anytime soon. Great shoes though, got mine for the Manchester marathon next year 😁 Ps. Never had any rubbing problems.
I also had the same issue on the right shoe as well at the start! I thought it was the socks I was wearing and while no show socks seems to make it worse (no issues in ankle socks) I think it is a fit issue due to the relaxed fit and possible my left and right foot having slight differences in volume - the material also feels kinder rough at the back of the collar. The Issue went away after a few runs but I think it was more my foot adapting.
Im thinking since you give review scores of the shoes you run in. Is there a website with a summary of the shoes and scores from you? It would be so good. 😊 And then links to your youtube vids. 😅
Carbon X is not going down in price because mens sizes are sold out everywhere and they haven't launched new colorways recently. However, some womens sizes might end up in sale. Btw, which one is better in your opinion for long runs, the Carbon X or the Pegasus Turbo? I haven't run in my Carbon X at all because there was something wrong in the sizing. I think they put the wrong label on those shoes. They are smaller than what they should be. So that pair has been sitting in the shoe box for the past 5 months.
Carbon X absolutely tore up my achilles and on the same foot as you Seth. I also got blisters between my toes. I went true to size but I definitely should have gone up a half a size at least.
Cameron McBride I tried it on the treadmill at my local shop and LOVED the feeling underfoot but could immediately tell the heel cup was going to be a problem. I didn’t buy them because of this so I hope they fix it in the next model!
Kacy Manahan I’m glad you were able to identify that before buying! I’m with you on the hope that the next version is improved because I loved the way the shoe felt otherwise
Crikey red alert for me if getting some Achilles rubbing as I have just got over best part of two poor running years due to Achilles issues which I figured where at least partly due to poor fitting shoes. That said if you put an insert (albeit thin) into the shoe is that making it tighter than it might otherwise have been and contributing to the issue?
I've been looking for a lightweight trainer to use for speed workouts and I haven't seen a specific frontrunner so I wanted your opinion on what your favorite lightweight trainer is.
Which shoe do you like better Nike Zoom fly3 or Hoka Carbon x? I have the zoom fly3 and I’m interested in the Carbon X but worried it’s too stiff and will take a beating on my legs.
Forrest W I have the Rincon and Clifton6, I run about a 9 minute mile...am I too slow to get the benefit of the Carbon X? It sounds like I’d need a quicker cadence?
Tom DILLON. Last half I ran 842 in the carbon X and they helped. Cadence remained consistent at 184 over the race. Hard to say if it really helped because my endurance improved for sure but legs weren't as tired and the shoes felt good over the whole race. It's a wider shoe than the Nikes so I feel like it's a more stable ride.
I really wish HOKA would design something more aesthetically pleasing. This is purportedly a racing shoe, but it looks slow. Give me something brighter or sleeker or with less "HOKA" stamped on it or anything but a generic white upper/lower.
I can't said a lot about my thoughts how carbon x should looks in 2020 I love hoka this is my favourite brand but I can only dream to buy one of these 180 $ no way I can not afford 😩
i got the shoe as a test shoe and since then i basically only run in those except for races, for me the shoe makes any type of easy to medium pace much easier and more enjoyable than any other shoe - luckily i got them for free from my boss : )
I have a pair of the Carbon X and I find that I get very bad heat spots on the ball of my feet, expressly on the out side of my feet (so bad that my feet have black spots after training for a couple of days). Does anyone else get this?
@Seth James DeMoor, which cheaper alternative for a better running experience would you recommend for long runs? If you had to pick THE ones that you like most for your long runs (excluded Nike Next % :D)
I was in the same situation as you 6 months back, and I avoided the 4% and next% due to cost/principle. But in the end I wasted more money trying different shoes including the Carbon X (it's OK but gives me pain in the ankle joint). The reason the 4%/next% works so well is because of the incredibly soft bouncy cushion, but because of the plate they are not mushy and perform well at pace. There is no shoe like it. Black Friday coming soon so try to find a good deal on the 4% or next%
I am still not decided to spend so much but I am have to admit you started convincing me with the fact that you spent more at the end trying several shoes.. so I am may take a look at them on this Friday 😬 Thanks for your answer! Have a nice day. Cheers
Would this be a good shoe for someone with big toe pain? I think I got carried away running in Fivefingers too much too soon. I think I need a stiff sole and forefoot rocker. Thanks!
Maybe the Topo Athletic Magnifly 2 or 3? They are 0 mm drop (like any minimalist shoe) and have a stiff sole and a nice rocker (similar to Clifton 5). I like my pair :)
@@QronoZ713 Thanks for your suggestion. I will look into that shoe definitely. Looks like a perfect match for what I'm looking for. Out of curiosity did you have any similar pain transitioning to zero drop shoe?
@@adimperial I've had toe pain, that I think was caused from running too hard, too much in 10 mm drop shoes (NB1400v6 and Peg 36). Went back to old Kinvara 9s helped. But also wanted to try a pair of 0 mm drop for more natural running.
I spoke to my local running store owner, who just got back from the World Championships (Marathon). He is not sponsored by a shoe company so can run in anything he likes. He ran in the Next%, rather than the CarbonX for that reason. He said they felt like bricks compared to the Nike. If Hoka want to compete they need to do something about the weight and the foam. I ended up buying the Nikes for my son, even though the Hokas were considerably cheaper.
***This HOKA CARBON X FULL REVIEW is an OLD video that was never published due to the crazy travel schedule over the past 5 weeks. Thanks for your patience as we begin to roll out more running shoe reviews in the next week. Onward and Upward!***
Thank you so much for the review! Very much appreciated. Huge fan btw, get that sub 2:19!!!!!!!
RHYTHM! RHYTHM! RHYTHM!
😆👉🏽☝🏽 Onward and Upward. 😁
Please help me? What i should buy? Hoka Carbon x or Nike zoom fly 3?
@@vlogsbyalejandro 7
Overall very happy with the Carbon X. I've just over 120 miles in them, which includes two marathons. I've ran well over 20 marathons, a few ultras, and full ironman, so I have a fair bit of running experience. Post marathon muscle soreness has been dramatically less with the Carbon X compared to all other shoes and the same training load, etc. Yes they felt firm, the first strides felt odd, but those sensations quickly disappear. My only quibble is that I feel the forefoot is a little wide, making my foot slip side to side slightly. On some runs I'm aware of it, on others not. One day I think I've discovered proper lacing tension then the next it seems wrong. It has created a hot spot, but through two marathons it never developed into a full-blown blister.
I personally liked the firm cushion, it was not at all uncomfortable and really gave me that pop I needed towards the end of my race this morning
Seth, I had an issue with rubbing on my Achilles in my first few runs in these, but then I figured out that I could get a good lockdown with much less pressure on the laces than I thought I needed. No more Achilles rubbing + solid lock-down = smooth as butter!
3 day in a row with 2 video your killing it
Po 9 love it from my hotel room
Just ran the LV marathon in these and have used them on some of my long runs. They were great, even for me as a solid mid pack runner. I never had any issues with the heel collar or other hot spots with this shoe, for whatever that’s worth.
I have a friend that works for Hoka and he said the only thing they will be updating for the Carbon X is the upper.
Can he get me a pair 😂
And now it's 20 dollars more just for a new upper
borrowed my friend's carbon X yesterday, and run in it for a mile. I think I agree, I expected it to be softer.
I just wore these shoes for my recent Dublin Marathon and got a PB and a BQ for 2021. They felt great, even though I thought they looked kind of ugly. No regrets.
Im new to running. Im about 7 months in. Im up to about 30 to 35 miles a week. Love your channel.
Awesome Rob! That’s a perfect amount of mileage for how long you’ve been running.
@@SethJamesDeMoor Thats great coming from you. Keep up the great work!
The Hoka Carbon x
What a shoe comfort was amazing, took time to break in, lasted 6 months of quality long rounds and tempo run.
thank you for the long term update.
hope to see you in the clifton 6 soon Seth my pair has been sooo nice to my feet
Ok who thought he was going to barbeque the shoe....... I've had my eye on this shoe so glad to see the review and comments. Seems alot have had an issue with the heel but ill still try it out.
Enjoying the extra uploads!
Gabriel Priddy absolutely!! From Philly marathon
QD : my hope regarding the carbon X in 2020 is that it finds its way to my foot. 😁
Yes sir!!
I love the Carbon X. No Achilles or feet issues. This shoe helps me to have a faster cadence and less fatigue in my legs. Definitely long run, marathon and HM race shoe.
Had a pair of Carbon X's and liked them, but also felt they were just a bit firm and I could feel it each run. Added a spenco like you did and it's now my favorite shoe ever! Light, reactive, bouncy, and comfortable
Thank you for showing the removable sock liner and how it worked with your inserts. I orthotics and as much as I love trying out new shoes I’m always afraid to buy online because more shoes are coming with glued in sock liners. Great job and thanks for the review
I replaced the carbon x insole with a clifton 5 insole for the Athens Marathon and fortunately it was an experiment that went right,the carbon x insole is too thin in the front, no cushion at all.
To me, they seem like they would feel very similar to my zoom fly flyknits, stiffer than a vaporfly next% or 4%, and also heavier.
I wear the CarbonX on tempo and intervals and I absolutely love this shoe. I am running the Austin Marathon in February and am thinking about wearing the CarbonX during the race. Love, love, love this shoe.
you should. i assume your a nick bare follower? if not look him up..hes got a large following for the Austin marathon. i am interested in the carbon Xs now!!!!!
After My first run in these shoes I was like "What? These are bricks!" I found the midsole very stiff compared to the plush ZoomX in the Nike Turbo and Vaporfly. They felt like the Zoomfly only stiffer with a steeper drop off in the forefoot. I was quite disappointed after reading some great positive reviews and paying over $200CA. Thankfully this dissipated quite a bit over about 25K and it actually feels pretty good now, or maybe just getting used to the feeling. I do like this shoe for speedwork now and have only taken it out for one 20K long run and actually felt pretty good as well. I would rate this as a good shoe and will give it a go on my next long run if you say that is where it shines. I have had no issues with the heel rubbing. I look forward to the Version 2 where they make it lighter.
I never had issues with this shoes I really loved them you can’t even hear them when running so pleased with them and I run mostly on pavement so it works divine.
I would just like to point out one thing. You said you didn't like how firm it felt so you added the spenco insert. The Carbon X is supposed to be a RACING SHOE so it's going to feel firm. It's not meant for 20+ mile long slower distances. There was a group of people that took these shoes when they first came out and started daily training in them and told everyone they're a trainer. This is not the case and not the purpose of this shoe. It's supposed to be firm.
Hi Jaymes, I am confused now... so the Carbon X's are not good for road Ultra's or even marathons?
The 40 Something runner if you're running fast for those distances then yes. Jim walmsley was running 5'40 miles when he broke the world record for the 50 mile distance. The shoe is meant to go fast, not slow
@@bijohn333 Thanks. Makes sense. Then maybe I would go for the Asics Glideride instead?
The 40 Something runner that would be a great choice! They have the same meta rocker feel but the glideride has a significantly higher cushion and the upper is a lot more plush and premium as well. It's designed to be more efficient for the longer, slower miles
@@bijohn333 thanks 👍👍
Boy that grilling looks good!!!
You said you’ll do your first run back on the ON cloudflow, please let us know how that shoe felt, really excited 😬
Which shoes would you recomand for fast 5 and 10k?
Got the same shoe a few hours ago with the same colorway in a flea market. Will try them out tomorrow.
I am fan of these, ran loads of speed work days and even a half marathon in them. They feel solid at faster speeds, not so much at slower paces. I agree, the weight needs to come down and maybe add a new specialized foam for next year? maybe? =)
This is my favorite (sub $240) running shoe for all purposes. I'm liking them more and more as the miles and versatility in my runs start adding up.
The HOKA CARBON X is one of the most amazing shoes I've had. And yes, you're right, this shoe gets slippery when it gets wet! This shoe doesn't like anything else than dry, firm concrete :D
Wore this today at Philadelphia. Worked great in rain. Heavier than I wanted. But extra cushioning was nice.
cakej1 what did you think of that wind?
I did the half yesterday. Tough weather for you marathoners today. Great job!!!
Yesterday was beautiful
@@jameschaves5723 Raced in worse. At least it wasn't hot.
The carbon X is exactly something you will expect from hoka just like their other models, plus a carbon fiber plate. Very wide and roomy, rocking feeling and very soft landing. Not sure how ppl find them stiffer than the next %.
I ran 700km with my first pair. Never had any heel issues, but got five black toe nails during marathon training. I bought my new CarbonX one size bigger. Hopefully that will spare my toe nails. I really like the shoe though.
Damn. I'm late. 😣
I love you Seth!!!! Get that sub 19!
LET'S GO HOUSTON!
Got about 350 miles on a oair, and wet roads aren't an issue, but interestingly any residue like a little mud turns them into skates
Really like the Carbon X. I rotate this shoe in on Tempo runs and it performs nicely!
Just bought these in Canada Black Friday, have been running in Hoka for awhile, love the extra cushioning given PF and Achilles issues. Carbon X hella expensive in Canada but just found my size for $60 off runningfree.com (Black Friday weekend sale). Thank you Seth, very excited to try them. Congrats on 50k subs! Great things ahead. Ps. Would you consider an SJD buff for sale in your collection?
Seth, you ever run in your carbon plate shoes in the winter at all? I just wanted to ask have you found that you have to "warm up" the carbon fibre? Just wanted to check, because i was doing some 1 mile repeats at about 4 Celsius (sorry I live in England hehe) and oh my goodness, that first mile was gnarly on my feet, but after that it was back to "normal" bouncy and springy again. During the summer and autumn months did not notice this , but man the contrast was real obvious. (I was running in these shoes Hoka Carbon X)
You didn't compare the bounce to the Nike's Carbon plate. What's different?
QOD: reduce weight, ditch the window view of the carbon - we believe you Hoka, the carbon is there. Mix some graphine into the sole for an über durable shoe.
I have a pair but decided to not go with them. The ride is pretty firm. I would prefer also slightly more drop. 8-10
Awesome great to see this looks great... curious how would you feel this shoe would work for folks with shin splints...
If they get some stock in Europe that would already be a crazy surprise ;)
I managed o grab a pair with a discount from a race bib earlier this year, but with them still selling out all the time, I'm not so sure they'll be getting any kind of major discount anytime soon. Great shoes though, got mine for the Manchester marathon next year 😁
Ps. Never had any rubbing problems.
I also had the same issue on the right shoe as well at the start! I thought it was the socks I was wearing and while no show socks seems to make it worse (no issues in ankle socks) I think it is a fit issue due to the relaxed fit and possible my left and right foot having slight differences in volume - the material also feels kinder rough at the back of the collar. The Issue went away after a few runs but I think it was more my foot adapting.
Do you have a list with all of the shoe scores somewhere?
Im thinking since you give review scores of the shoes you run in. Is there a website with a summary of the shoes and scores from you? It would be so good. 😊 And then links to your youtube vids. 😅
Seth, I was hoping you put the carbon X into the bbq pit. 😉
There true to size but hard to geton i broke the thumb tab like you did to. They do good in deep 💦 splash conditions but on curves i Dont remember. 👍🏻
Good review!
Carbon X is not going down in price because mens sizes are sold out everywhere and they haven't launched new colorways recently. However, some womens sizes might end up in sale.
Btw, which one is better in your opinion for long runs, the Carbon X or the Pegasus Turbo? I haven't run in my Carbon X at all because there was something wrong in the sizing. I think they put the wrong label on those shoes. They are smaller than what they should be. So that pair has been sitting in the shoe box for the past 5 months.
👋🏽🦊 . . . You're Right! Price dropped to $144.
QD: A little more bounce/less stiff foam in 2020
I ran the nyc marathon with them and had the same problem with bleeding on my achilles but other then that it’s a great shoe!
Glad I’m not the only one, agreed, really my only drawback for the shoe. Did we get to meet in NY?
Yes we did at the group run. Thanks for the feature in the vlog!
Carbon X absolutely tore up my achilles and on the same foot as you Seth. I also got blisters between my toes. I went true to size but I definitely should have gone up a half a size at least.
Cameron McBride I tried it on the treadmill at my local shop and LOVED the feeling underfoot but could immediately tell the heel cup was going to be a problem. I didn’t buy them because of this so I hope they fix it in the next model!
Kacy Manahan I’m glad you were able to identify that before buying! I’m with you on the hope that the next version is improved because I loved the way the shoe felt otherwise
I like the shoe. Just wish the mid foot was a bid wider. I like a wider base. Also the meta rocker seems just too aggressive.
Crikey red alert for me if getting some Achilles rubbing as I have just got over best part of two poor running years due to Achilles issues which I figured where at least partly due to poor fitting shoes. That said if you put an insert (albeit thin) into the shoe is that making it tighter than it might otherwise have been and contributing to the issue?
A dieing breed mate . A TH-cam runner that eats meat ! Kudos 👍👍💪
Im running a marathon this fall. Which shoe should i wear? the Hoka Carbon X or the Nike Zoom Fly 3?
lone peak 4.5 full review
Looks like u had the same problem with the pull tab as me 😂
I've been looking for a lightweight trainer to use for speed workouts and I haven't seen a specific frontrunner so I wanted your opinion on what your favorite lightweight trainer is.
YourMothers LeftBelt Nike streak 7 or the Skechers GoRun Razor 3
Which shoe do you like better Nike Zoom fly3 or Hoka Carbon x? I have the zoom fly3 and I’m interested in the Carbon X but worried it’s too stiff and will take a beating on my legs.
Man that’s a tough one. Very similar shoes, I’d say Carbon X for long runs and Zoom Fly 3 for tempos, hope that helps.
Forget the shoes! What socks were you wearing?
Rincon’s vs carbon x? I love my rincons, haven’t tried the X yet... seems like 115 vs 180 is a no brainer?
JoyRidaz rincon is a trainer, not a racer. And I’ve worn out a pair of each. They are in completely different classes.
i have them both. the rincon is a lite trainer. carbon x helps cadence in the 2nd half when you need it.
Forrest W I have the Rincon and Clifton6, I run about a 9 minute mile...am I too slow to get the benefit of the Carbon X? It sounds like I’d need a quicker cadence?
Stuart Adams will the Carbon X help me if I run about a 9 minute mile or am I too slow? Currently train in Clifton 6 and race in Rincon
Tom DILLON. Last half I ran 842 in the carbon X and they helped. Cadence remained consistent at 184 over the race. Hard to say if it really helped because my endurance improved for sure but legs weren't as tired and the shoes felt good over the whole race. It's a wider shoe than the Nikes so I feel like it's a more stable ride.
Hoka will be releasing the Carbon X-SPE version which is lighter and faster than the X!
Boom, 🎤 drop
After 8 month it turns out that SPE is heavier. Bad mic drop.
Seth J. can you help me? What is better? Hoka one one Carbon x or Nike zoom fly 3?
Is it just me that can’t get away with hokas? Their instep ‘cuts’ into my arch. Really wish I could find a pair to fit 😕
Average Ultrarunner this is the only hoka that doesn’t cut into my arch
Adam Pugsley maybe worth checking out for me then - cheers for the note!
I really wish HOKA would design something more aesthetically pleasing. This is purportedly a racing shoe, but it looks slow. Give me something brighter or sleeker or with less "HOKA" stamped on it or anything but a generic white upper/lower.
All Hoka cushioning feels like a stack of noodles. Does this feel any better?
Just can’t bring myself to like/buy Hoka. However on another note #roadto50k
Woot woot!! Onward and Upward
I can't said a lot about my thoughts how carbon x should looks in 2020 I love hoka this is my favourite brand but I can only dream to buy one of these 180 $ no way I can not afford 😩
Do you always go for a size up when buying running shoes?
i got the shoe as a test shoe and since then i basically only run in those except for races, for me the shoe makes any type of easy to medium pace much easier and more enjoyable than any other shoe - luckily i got them for free from my boss : )
Nice 🙌🏼🙌🏼 glad you are enjoying the miles!
ginger runner says he have it at 6.9 oz, size 11 🤔
If you had to choose between the carbon x and new balance rebel for marathon race shoe which would you pick?
carbon x. rebel doesn't have the cushion for the long haul
I have a pair of the Carbon X and I find that I get very bad heat spots on the ball of my feet, expressly on the out side of my feet (so bad that my feet have black spots after training for a couple of days). Does anyone else get this?
Is the extra 60$ worth it compared to the Rincón?
I’d take the hoka Rincon Over the carbon x any day.
Hoka getting new foam?
@Seth James DeMoor, which cheaper alternative for a better running experience would you recommend for long runs? If you had to pick THE ones that you like most for your long runs (excluded Nike Next % :D)
Try find a pair of zoom fly fk's real cheap. Otherwise epic react fk 2's for mellow long runs
I was in the same situation as you 6 months back, and I avoided the 4% and next% due to cost/principle. But in the end I wasted more money trying different shoes including the Carbon X (it's OK but gives me pain in the ankle joint). The reason the 4%/next% works so well is because of the incredibly soft bouncy cushion, but because of the plate they are not mushy and perform well at pace. There is no shoe like it. Black Friday coming soon so try to find a good deal on the 4% or next%
I am still not decided to spend so much but I am have to admit you started convincing me with the fact that you spent more at the end trying several shoes.. so I am may take a look at them on this Friday 😬 Thanks for your answer! Have a nice day. Cheers
@@mathieupapin8146 4% is on sale at Nike.com 😉
Oh thanks ! And quite a good deal actually. Thanks
Would this be a good shoe for someone with big toe pain? I think I got carried away running in Fivefingers too much too soon. I think I need a stiff sole and forefoot rocker.
Thanks!
Maybe the Topo Athletic Magnifly 2 or 3? They are 0 mm drop (like any minimalist shoe) and have a stiff sole and a nice rocker (similar to Clifton 5). I like my pair :)
@@QronoZ713 Thanks for your suggestion. I will look into that shoe definitely. Looks like a perfect match for what I'm looking for. Out of curiosity did you have any similar pain transitioning to zero drop shoe?
@@adimperial Good luck!
@@adimperial I've had toe pain, that I think was caused from running too hard, too much in 10 mm drop shoes (NB1400v6 and Peg 36). Went back to old Kinvara 9s helped. But also wanted to try a pair of 0 mm drop for more natural running.
What does true to size actually mean?
Yeah this single layer mesh upper always looks cheap. In all shoes
Could you run a marathon in them?
Qd: keep it the same. Ive had no problems with it
6:40 average for 24 miles!
You're a beast!
3 seconds late because of my internet. XD
QOD: A wide version.
Too much rocker = weak toe off
Too much unnecessary locked down :(
Poor mans next %
Bretzky or... wise man choice over the overpriced next %
I hate this shoe. It feels like a brick. Firm, firm, firm. And I've run in everything. Super disappointed. Really beat up after every run in these.
I spoke to my local running store owner, who just got back from the World Championships (Marathon). He is not sponsored by a shoe company so can run in anything he likes. He ran in the Next%, rather than the CarbonX for that reason. He said they felt like bricks compared to the Nike. If Hoka want to compete they need to do something about the weight and the foam. I ended up buying the Nikes for my son, even though the Hokas were considerably cheaper.
Yea. I went with the Next % as well, for this very reason. Uncharacteristically firm for a Hoka.
Looks so bland and boring though... Doesn't say come on let's Race to me. Maybe silly but it does matter to me.
3rd!
Ugliest things I’ve seen in a long time lol maybe for a 75yr trying to play tennis still they would look awesome